Skip to content
Retro Warriors 320 - Mini Motorways and Infrastructure Games episode artwork

Sep 6, 2021 1 hr 7 min

Retro Warriors 320 - Mini Motorways and Infrastructure Games

from Retro Warriors

Topic starts at: 29:45. This week wer're discussing Mini Motorways and the evolution of infrastructure games! Don't forget to support the show at https://patreon.com/retrowarriors and come chat with us in Discord at https://discord.gg/WxyjUcJpEx. You can also buy some RW stickers at https://www.redbubble.com/people/rwshow/ and listen to Cinema Rogue at cinemarogues.podbean.com

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Retro Warriors 320 - Mini Motorways and Infrastructure Games

0:00 1:07:41
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Ladies and gentlemen, welcome to Rachael Warriors. That's 320. As I can host Jess and maker, and as always, I'm joined by R of note. So, maybe we have website, Rachael Warriors.net, where you can get our magazine that we published five years ago.

You can look back in time with retro was like five years ago. People have been talking about the magazine the other day and they're like, you know, I really want to do another issue. I just kind of sit down and make the time for it because it's time. Also my problem was I made the whole thing in a word document, which is the worst way to make a 32 page magazine.

Let me tell you. I've got publisher. Because I have publisher too and I had it at the time. And I opened it and I went, this seems complicated.

I'll just do it in a word doc. Actually, it wasn't even word. It was pages, which is the- Oh, right. You're selling a Mac, right?

Yeah, the Mac version of Office. Well, not the actual Mac version of Office, but like Apple's version that they wish you would buy instead of Office. And I did it in pages. Oh, boy.

And then just exported to PDF. Gross. And it sucked. You'd like add something on page two and every page would bump down and be like, oh my God.

Yeah. Anyway. I use a publishing software and it's a word process. I published it.

So technically it makes pages of publishing software. Okay. Thank you. I played Left 4 Dead too.

I love the only one over that series I played. I never played a Left 4 Dead. And my friend who I've been playing on Counter Strike with was like, you got to play Left 4 Dead. And I was like, I do.

And he goes, yeah, I bought it for me. And that's how I played it too. Oh, for some real quick. Somebody said, you got to play this.

And I was like, I don't want to buy that. And then the next thing I know, I had a gift in my Steam library. Yeah. And they were like, you should play this now.

And I guess I'm playing this now. And I played it one time ever. He was a little nervous because he was like, I don't really do scary stuff. So maybe you want to watch a trailer or something.

I like, I don't know why I never played him because I like online multiplayer games. But what I really like is being me and my friends versus the computer. I don't want to compete with other humans because then I lose. And so I've always liked like PvE style online games.

And I never even occurred to me play any of the Left 4 Dead games. And I played this one. It was a good time. I enjoyed it.

Maybe next time you guys play it, I should install it and play it a second time. Yeah. You should install it and we'll play. It's a good time.

One of you'll have to tell me how to play it. Well, you point at the zombies and shoot the zombies. My Steam library says it was last played in 2016. That's probably the exact same.

That's probably the same. That's probably the same. I bought Cruelty Squad. Why?

People that don't know Cruelty Squad is a mean joke the gaming press is playing on Steam users right now. Yeah. So I had gone into our Discord to say, why are people reviewing this? Is this just like, am I just seeing this everywhere because I read it once and now I see it everywhere?

Or is it really that everyone is reviewing it for some fucking reason? What it looks like is one of those weird, unity asset swap games but on acid. And as soon as you see it, you know what kind of game it is. You know those games that are kind of intentionally shitty garbage.

They have some kind of dumb gimmick or visual gag that is going to make streamers buy them and play them. Yes. And everyone is insisting major outlets are reviewing Cruelty Squad and going, oh, it's really good. It's yeah, it's this weird goofy, ugly, intentionally bad looking barf game.

But oh, it's real good. Yeah. That's what I can see. It's like once you get past the shitty first layer, if you discover there's a really deep game beneath.

And maybe there is. But it's like, it's like, it's like if someone cooked a steak and then they put it in the bottom of a toilet. Yeah. It's like a steak.

But I don't know that I want to dunk my face in there to take a bite. It's right there. It's right there. It's fine.

And I'm sure it's still a delicious steak. And what sold me is because you know I were going back and forth and I was like, I think I have to buy it. I can't say don't do that. And I read a review and I just pulled it up because I sent it to you and the review is this is from Steam.

Soundtrack is made entirely of brown notes, nauseating graphics, destroyed myself with a toilet. This is the cyberpunk we deserve. And I played it, and I'll tell you what it is, because afterward I went and played the game that it is wanting to be. It's wanting to be like a joke version of Deus Ex because a lot of the game is like, oh, you get these different augments and you add them to yourself and they give you different abilities.

And then you're going through these large labyrinthine levels in different ways, taking different paths using different strategies based on your weapon and ability to load out. And that's a sound idea, which is an idea that played out in Deus Ex. That was a game that was very well known for. But what if your health meter was a giant slab of liver or something and took up a third of the screen?

My problem was I like shooting games. And as a shooting game, it controls dog shit. And I played like an hour and a half of it and returned it. And I feel like I don't know if I gave it its due or not.

It just wasn't the moment to moment gameplay wasn't fun. I didn't care to upgrade my abilities because just controlling my character was not enjoyable. And in a video game, you spend a lot of time controlling your character. And I just...

That's true. I've learned that in playing video games in the past. I can say this confidently. If you're a huge fan of like the first Deus Ex game or games like it and you've played the shit out of all of them just to death into the ground and you have a kind of weird sense of humor, then I could see you really liking Cruelty Squad.

If you're like me and you haven't played those games in the ground, maybe just go play those games instead because they're cheaper and easier to play. And also better. And polished. So yeah, and I think that's why you're seeing outlets like PC Gaming, Rock Paper Shotgun and stuff, giving you a good review because these are guys that are those people.

They've played these games to death. And this game is specifically not a par... There's got to be a word for it, but not a parody, but like a deconstruction. Yeah.

That's exactly the term. It is a deconstruction of those games. And if you're into that, that deconstruction of that type of game, then yeah, I totally see what they're going for. Yeah.

So it's weird. I will watch or read game reviews from time to time. I've learned that most outlets don't even touch the games that I care about. Like the genres that I play and that I enjoy, they just skip right past it.

If they do look at it, their review is typically if you want this game, you already know you want it. Yeah, which I do. It's true. I don't like that as a review method.

So I do use it for Dwarf Fortress. That's the only game that I'm like, if you want to play Dwarf Fortress, you already feel it in your heart. Right. And if you don't, then please don't.

But despite that, I still keep watching or reading game reviews about things that I know I'll never play, just because I kind of want to still see what the market is like and what people are playing. And maybe there's something new or interesting or creative that'll make me play a game. And then I just suddenly saw everyone reviewing cruelty's flood. And I was like, what?

Is this a joke? Is there a meme that I'm missing here? And I just couldn't get it. Because all of them were like, this game is stupid and it looks like shit.

You know it looks like shit. Everybody gets it. But if you give it a chance, I feel like I said, if you're, if you're, if you're someone out there is like, man, the original Deus Ex is my favorite game of all time. And I have that kind of weird, Tim and Eric sort of sense of humor, then I could see that person being into that.

I could see me like, yeah, I could see that. I'm neither of those things. Yeah, that's awesome. So, so that's why it didn't work out was the game I played on stream today, which is a game called Prodius, not Parodius.

Because Parodius is the game with the penguin and stuff. It's Prodius, P-R-O-D-U-S. Can you add a penguin to this one? I mean, it's innarly access, so this guy's the limit.

I'm going to play more games if I have penguins. I bought this game because there was a recommendation on Steam where a person said it's like Doom, but the way I remember it being the first time I played it as a kid. And playing it, I agree with that. It feels very much like a mashup of like 1993 Doom and Doom 2016.

It's just a really fun kind of throwback style shooter. But what I notice a lot with these throwback shooters is some of them are too much of a throwback. They keep too many old designs that don't really work as well. I've been really enjoying the level design.

They have some really cool ideas. It's not just that Doom thing of I don't know, it's a big maze. Like I played a level on stream where it was kind of that maze and you're circling around this complex, but in the middle of it are two snipers. So anytime you're out in the open, they're firing on you.

Just interesting ideas like that. And it was fun. Some levels are like, this level is just a big giant arena. It's just a whole bunch of bad guys.

And then there's the standard old school Doom style levels. And then there's levels that have lots of moving parts and different gimmicks. It's just really cool. It's interesting.

It's fun. It scratches that same itch for me that Doom 2016 did and that Doom Eternal does not. Because for all its merits and Doom Eternal has mini-marits, it feels like a pivot from Doom 2016, not a refinement. I'll never not hear Doom Eternal.

Well, you know. Every time. So, yeah, if you're like me and you're like, yeah, I played Doom Eternal and I liked it all right, but I really wanted more Doom 2016 than Proteus is great and you should play it. Also, Proteus is great.

Also unrelated. Both of them. Yeah. Also, OdeMedius.

If while we're here. You can skip OdeMedius. It's fun. It's not a CNA.

But otherwise you can do it. So it's interlaxes on Steam and I think it's $25. And I've played a little over two hours of it and I'm just really enjoying it. It's just really fun.

The gunplay is really fun. The gore is, I mean, through the roof. There was one part. It was in my stream where I just unloaded on a pile of creatures with the chain gun.

And when it was done, the whole room was red and there was blood dripping off the ceiling. Like just fun. It's a normal day in Silent Hill. It was like the shining.

It was ridiculous. And I do like, they have real 3D models but you can toggle on and off like a 2D. Sprite mode. And some of the enemy models are legitimately kind of creepy to me.

So it really does like that reviewer said on Steam. It's that Doom 1993 feel where it feels really like brutal and dark and awful and kind of creepy and like a little bit scary sometimes. It's that same. Now, obviously it's doing that by being 10 times more of all of that than it was because Doom doesn't feel that way to us because now it's been 30 years.

But yeah, yeah. So highly, highly recommend Prodeius on Steam. Had a good time with that. Where did the name come from?

I have no idea. Okay. Just curious. Like a third act band at a metal concert.

I think maybe it's supposed to be pronounced Prodeius because it's a product that you may buy. Figure it out. Prodeius. I was bouncing through a few games this week trying to find some stuff to play.

I was looking through just trying to find a recommendation. I looked through the Game Pass Quest and I was like, get some extra points if you play one of these games and get an achievement. And one of the games listed was this game Haven. So I decided to give Haven a try.

So Gameplay wise, it's a neat gameplay loop. It seems to be like a mix of over the shoulder exploration with quasi rail elements and also possibly survival mixed with. You're just saying words now. I know mixed with like a heavy handed adventure game maybe.

And the main characters in it really need to cool down with the PDA. That's the first thing I'm going to say. Okay. They feel the need to stop and make out and baby talk each other all the time.

Baby talk each other. Yeah, they'll just be like stop and be like, who's the most beautiful? That's looking in your eyes. That's incredible.

You just need to stop now because I'm watching you. And it just feels like the game constantly feels like you're interrupting someone's private moment. Yeah. And you're like, I should leave.

I should let you two do what this is whatever's going to happen. And just tell me when you're done and I'll come back and you're still going. Okay. All right.

I'll just come back. Oh, you're still doing it. Fine. Just like half an hour and there was like a crisis and a mild conflict.

And it looked like they were going to get angry at each other. And then moments later they were like, I can never I can never be mad at you. I know when you say baby talking, you probably mean much more attractive than this, but in my hand, I imagine just be like do, do, do, do, do, do, do, do, do, do, do in the making out. It's just all that, and you're just being like, man, this is weird.

I don't know. Do, do, do, do, do, do. It's just. It's, it's, it's kind of awkward.

Like I get that they're trying to go for like a somewhat genuine romance story. I get that, but it comes off as just like I walked into somebody's bedroom and, And bedroom and maybe kind of maybe kind of too intimate right off the bus. It's awkward. Yeah.

And then the opposite of that, I played some Hades. I'm dying to know what you think of Hades. I'm digging it. I think it's a I think it's really fun.

It's got a set and I'll have you know, it is a road light. What? In case you were on the way. I was played a bit more just because everyone was talking about him.

Right. Yeah, because it did come out in Game Pass. So yeah, why do I switch version? I played Game Pass version for a minute and I went I lost I've lost all my progression and I went to the switch version.

Yeah. So I was playing around with it a little bit. I probably I think I went through like seven loops give or take. Yeah.

Um, I got a little ways into the second area where I learned that I could just walk into lava and die. Mm hmm. That was good. That was not as a very dash focused player.

I spend most of my time in the lava actually. See, I got I got past the first boss with like four health left. Yeah. So I just died of media.

I did. I went to the second area and when I was trying to walk into the next room, I just walked into lava. Yeah, died. So that the second area didn't last long.

Um, but I don't like it. I like that even though you are constantly restarting, which is normal for a road light game. Um, you do get to carry over something. And I appreciate that.

That makes me feel like I am at least making progress. And on top of that, there is still a ongoing narrative that incorporates in your constant failure. Right. So it doesn't feel like I'm just having to restart.

And I know you don't play a lot of the genre, but this is really where most road lights are these days. Almost all of them have this. Yeah. There is.

Yes. The core gameplay loop is repeated, but there's this static progression on top of it. Now that was what attracted me to a rogue legacy a few years ago. Yeah, which is a great game.

Um, and it's it is a great game, but then I got maybe five or so hours into a regular one that and I just kind of felt like I stopped making any progress. Like I run into a brick wall and couldn't get me further. And that's upside to the design of the story progression in Hades, which is that you will eventually hit that brick wall, but then new story stuff still keeps popping up. Yeah.

And I appreciate that there is some incentive to keep going rather than just maybe someday you'll get past that right instead of just grinding away at building structures or whatever to maintain your static progression. Yeah. So, but I am I'm enjoying what I've played so far. I'm probably going to keep chipping away at it.

I don't know that it'll be something that I, you know, get super, super into, but it'll be something that I maybe throw a few runs out of here and there. Yeah. I like Hades. I like rogue lights.

I want to try a more traditional rogue like Tangle Deep is still my go to recommendation is it just what a stellar game. Yeah. I haven't tried the easy motor God mode or whatever it is yet. And Hades.

So I don't know what I've never played with that. I'll tell you what it is. Is every time you die, it reduces the damage you take by 2% pernally. Huh.

So if you've been playing with out it, then you're basically dying and not getting anything for like a shop. I'm still getting stuff. I'm getting those little purple dots and I got gems. I dumped all I turned God mode on immediately when I started playing and I've dumped all of my resources into extra lives and health.

So when I play, I think I have like two or three lives. Yeah. I just I just I think the extra life was the first thing I unlocked. Yeah.

And then I got the the color from Cerberus, which lets me have some extra health now. Yeah. I know it. Skelly's tooth, I think is the one the other extra life thing because there's the depth of finds that you get in the mirror, but then skelly's tooth is the item that you can level up.

Can you wear more than one item? Because I can tell I can only wear one at a time. That's correct. But you can do I don't remember how you unlock it, but you can unlock the ability to change items.

Between areas. Nice. So you can be like, I want this item in the first area, but then when I go into the second area, I want this item. Yeah.

I think I may have already paid for that at the little construction dude. I think that's where it's done. Yeah. I think I built a relic gallery or relic rack or whatever in another place.

And I was like, where is it? I don't see it anywhere. And I didn't catch it all where it said it was going to be. So it's probably waiting for me after the boss again.

Yeah. Yeah. But it's fun game. Yeah.

It's really neat. I'm digging on it more than I thought it would. It's it's a very it's one of those games. It's viscerally fun to play.

Yeah. Every every motion and every movement just feels nice. Yeah. And I got to give them credit for that.

And then I also have been playing Quake a little bit. Yes. As have I, which just spoiler for our first news item. Quake was leaked in the quick cons schedule as a revitalized edition and then just announced and launched immediately.

I I I I cannot play Quake with a controller. Oh, yeah. I wasn't going to try. I tried it on my PC.

Holy crap. I was like, what is happening? What about the N64 version? What about it?

Yeah. No, I it took me many attempts to get it to install on my computer. It didn't want to install on either of my computers. I just kept getting air messages.

And then finally, I waited a full day from when everyone else was able to download it. And I was like, oh, you want to Quake? Here you go. Yeah.

And it's it's running fine now. It was weird because not only does it immediately play in 4k without me having to do anything weird to get it to run. But then I play through a level and it popped an achievement at me. And I was like, I'm playing Quake and it just popped in a cheat.

What is going on? Yeah. No, let's fire through some news real quick. First up, yeah, Quake revitalized edition came out.

It's on Game Pass right now. You can go play it. It is a real genuine. I don't want to call it a remaster, but they have remastered a lot of it.

And it also, it's an nail soundtrack and includes new lighting, shadow engine, online multiplayer works fine over Xbox Live and then crossplays with PC. It's good. Does it crossplay with other consoles? That I don't know.

I know that L.R.G. is going to be publishing physical releases for Switch PS4 and PC. Are we not on Xbox despite the fact that it's a first party Xbox game? Yeah, that'd be nice.

I know well. More SNES concept art released by Nintendo design and Brand Director Lance Barr. It looks so neat. I'm not saying I saw the previous one.

Oh, yeah. It's basically just more sketches. A lot like the ones that were in the playing was super power book that came out around the time the Super Classic came out. It's just more of his sketches from that era.

And it's just really neat stuff. I love seeing that those early design sketches and some were just but ugly, but he did show some more where you can see that he is moving into the purple and away from from the. Bad colors from the bad colors. No, no, not the not the not even addressing the Japanese model.

It's just because originally it was going to be just like a big NES with a top loading port, but still the NES color scheme of like gray with the black drive and the red stripe and then slowly it migrates from that into the purple. I'm not going to play it. Please stop asking. I'm not going to play it.

Atari reports losses despite the release of the VCS. What? Wow. It's so nice.

It's the VCS. If our voices get higher pitched, it's more disbelief, right? It's going to be a sine wave. New Shining Force mobile game announced as part of an IP deal between mobile developer Hive and Sega.

Does this look like shit? I didn't look at it. It looks like a gotcha game. All right, then.

Sega renews some trademarks on Crusader of Sinti, Ranger X and a linko liver story, which are mostly beloved games. Yes. I imagine it's probably just for legal purposes. I doubt anything new is happening.

Maybe it'll be included in some bundle or something. But I guess. Yes, RB rating hints at rerelease of previous Disney classic game collection this time with the Jungle Book. I guess so it's Lion King Aladdin and now also Jungle Book.

Is the Jungle Book a beloved Disney classic? It's a beloved Disney classic movie. Well, yeah, I'm aware of the movie Saturn. The game existed.

I feel like if a review from the time didn't lambaster for not having the features by way of saying it was the bare necessities, then they lost their chance in the sun. Solgeboy owns Atari and is the CEO according to Solgeboy and not Atari. I like that. What?

Exactly. This is just straight up him getting free PR and it fucking worked because the story I read was like Solgeboy, whose most recent project is blank. I was like, why are you fucking selling me on him? Right.

Stop. Fishing at a Skyrim. Yeah. Can't wait.

We mentioned in the last episode all the more reason to play Skyrim. Now you can fish Saturn. I already was not interested in Skyrim. Now I'm less interested in Skyrim.

If they make the game uninteresting enough, at some point don't you have to play it? No. Just because, okay. See, I'm not the one who bought Cruelty Squad.

Leave me alive. I got a refund. The rest of the Master Games for Lost Judgment are revealed. The Master Games.

The Master System game saved us. The Master Games. The Master Games sounds like one of those multi-game cartridges you got on the NES that was like 50 games for like $100. I thought it sounded like the shitty direct-to-VHS parody of the Hunger Games.

The Master Games. Alex Kidd and Miracle World Fantasy Zone Penguin Land, Quartet and Duro Racer, Woody Pop and Maze Hunter 3D and Secret Command are all going to be included in Lost Judgment. And if you aren't already a Master System fan, those all sound like games we just made up. They're not.

Those are Master System games. And you should definitely play Fantasy Zone, so. Yes. Put it out there.

I feel like I like Quartet, but I can't remember. A brewery in Maryland is making a series of unauthorized Final Fantasy 7 IPAs. So if you like IPAs, I don't, then you can drink them, and they are beer. And they have Final Fantasy 7 art on them.

Or you're willing to go to Maryland to buy them. Or you can go on Redbubble and order as many Final Fantasy 7 stickers as you want to pick them on your beer. Yeah, that way you can have your own Coors Light, but Final Fantasy 7 edition. It's an option.

If you want your Schlitz to have yuppy on it. Schlitz. What do you have to drink? Just Schlitz and Mad Dog.

That's it. So you are as aware of anyone as anyone as of my crippling Coke Zero addiction. So sometimes I'll be on a meeting at work, and I don't turn on my webcam because I'm not a monster. And if I open up a Coke Zero while I'm on my meeting, apparently my microphone on my work headset will pay for it.

And my microphone on my work headset will pick that up. And my boss always says, already timed up another Schlitz, huh? Five o'clock somewhere. Let's get it on the topic of hand.

This week we're talking Mini Motorways and the evolution of infrastructure-based city building games. That was, we couldn't have, there's no way. That was as brief as we could get it. Now I'm tempted to make the actual title when I publish it.

It's like 40 words long. It's not, this is the evolution and current state of think-em-ups. Is that what we want? With a focus on Mini Motorways.

Basically we wanted to talk about Mini Motorways, but we wanted it through some type of lens that related to vector retro gaming. So here we are. And yeah, I found a review of some city builder game that called them think-em-ups. Weird.

And I liked that. So now they are think-em-ups. Nice. So we will talk about Mini Motorways shortly.

But first we kind of want to talk about sort of the evolution of city builder games. And then we're going to explain why we're talking about Mini Motorways at all in relation to city builders. So just for context, let's talk about major city building franchises from the past and kind of where city builder games were before we get into why Mini Motorways is here at all. And obviously we have to start with the SimCity games, which are kind of the true simulation style infrastructure building game.

When people talk about city builder games, they're always including SimCity. And then it's a question of whether or not they include these other ones. Right. You've also got the Cities XL and XXL games, which came out.

These were later ones. These were 2009, 2010, 2011 era. It was basically after SimCity had died and the fan base was hungry for more and they wanted to try to capture that audience while they were still desperate. And then Max has tried to watch it.

And then after that era, it kind of details us straight into the Cities Skylines era under city builders are now. And as far as like pure city builders where you are building a modern metropolitan city, those are kind of the big beats of the city builder. You have SimCity and then SimCity 2000, 3000, SimCity 4, and then kind of the declined of telling it to cities, telling it to cities Skylines. And I feel like you can draw a direct lineage from the original SimCity to city Skylines pretty easily.

Oh yeah, absolutely. And there have been other offshoots from that people who have tried to make other games. There's one that I've gotten in my Steam library now that's still in early access at this point, but it's starting to get somewhere called NewCity. And it feels like somebody played so much SimCity 2000 and just wanted to remake it, but without having any of the tools or infrastructure that SimCity 2000 had.

So they're basically making it from scratch and in doing so they're giving it some modern quality of life improvements. So it's neat. It's definitely still early access, but it's already showing some promise as far as that classical style of city builder goes. Yeah.

I do want to make a distinction here between traditional city builder games and city builder games that include warfare. Yeah. Because you see a lot of other games lumped in with city builders in varying degrees of things like the anno games, things like Caesar 1 through 4, the Tropico games. You see these lumped in and in my head they're always different because they include some facet of warfare.

Yeah, it feels like the bridge between simulation and strategy at that point. Right, exactly. And maybe they're not necessarily full strategy games. I play a bunch of anno 1400 and most of the game is you building a city and supply lines and infrastructure and stuff like that.

Then it turns into a strategy game, which is fine if you want that. Very often I do, but I don't know that I would consider them pure city builders. Right. And other stuff that was kind of in between the two, like a city realm, which is a game that 2k would rather we all forgot existing.

You also get stuff like I see, like if you go to city building video games on Wikipedia, just the genre, the dwarf fortress is included. Oh. And it's one of those things where it is a city building game. You are building a city of dwarves.

You do fight some things, but there's not like that strategy warfare. It's like you'll get invaded by an angry elk that showed up, but it's not like, all right, now it's turned into my army versus your army. So there's, you know, there's some weird gray area. But really, SimCity, dovetailing in two city skylines is the big stuff.

And I did just kind of want to, before we start talking about many motorways, discuss sort of the core gameplay loop we expect from city builders. Right. And for me, it's this, this, this increasing of tension, right? Where, where things start really low stakes and you have a large amount of resources.

You usually start with a lump sum in these things and usually the difficulty is determined by how much money you start with. Usually, yeah. And then you're sort of building this house of cards, but for me, I feel like city builders, they need to have this thing where you're building this house of cards, but the house can never totally collapse. If that makes sense.

Unless you keep releasing Bowser. Right. Yeah. Unless you're intentionally mucking things up.

But like what I loved about SimCity growing up is that you never really lost SimCity, which was nice. You know, on the other hand, you would sometimes reach these sort of soft fail states where it was like, you're so screwed that you just have to start over. See, my, my soft fail state that I always hit was, my goal was always to hit that 500,000 population to hit the final milestone. And I would constantly be able to make cities that would hit about 315.

And then just for no reason I could ascertain the population would just start tanking. And I dropped down to about 220 and lived there forever. And I could not ever figure out how to make it grow again. Yeah.

I also feel like there's the discussion of complexity, which is important. And really it boils down to how does an increase in game complexity diverge from the classic city builder gameplay loop? Because what we've seen in this evolution of SimCity over the years is the original SimCity was a relatively simplistic game. Yes.

Most of its ports were pretty simplistic. SimCity 2000 added a whole layer of complication on it. Yes. But it was mostly like fiddly stuff, infrastructure related complication.

And then as time grew all the way into city skylines, we've reached this level of like this, this abstraction versus granularity thing, right? Where I like the abstraction of the original SimCity. Yes. And I am constantly overwhelmed by city skylines to the point where I barely know what's going on.

And in the original SimCity, like you said, it's an abstraction. You've got these perfectly square units and you just get to place roads or rails between them. And everything fits perfectly in a grid. And it's completely unrealistic.

That's not how an actual city would generally be able to survive. But in the SimCity world, it's so abstracted that it does work that way. And as SimCity itself evolved, you started to see diversions from that. Even SimCity 2000 already added variable sized zoning.

So you could have as large of a plot of residential as you wanted and then just place roads throughout it however you want. So you already started to see slowly SimCity ramp up to where it was more of a quasi-realistic simulation. But it always became a question of what exactly are you simulating? And I feel like city's tries to go more for that actual city management and population management simulation.

Right. It's this level of high granularity where you're concerned about how many sick people are in this one office building. Right. Whereas even the later SimCity games, not counting that last one, were still a little more abstract.

But what I was thinking about was, well, you can look at your traffic. You can look at your crime statistics. You can look at your education. But these are all at the macro level.

You're just seeing what the entire city is like or you can look at a graph of where there are hot spots of things. But that's about as detailed as it's going to give you. You still kind of have to abstract the rest of it. I feel like it's been this sort of divergence away from city building and infrastructure management games being pretty casual.

To becoming increasingly hardcore over the years. I'm like, I'm going to play city skylines. And I play it and it's fun in the beginning. And the thing that I noticed kind of across the board that city builders struggle with, including SimCity, is the late game.

There is no late game. You just eventually get bored or decide you failed and you move on. Or you've decided you've succeeded. You decided this is as much as you want to.

And you're like, now I'm done. And so it turns into this thing where there's no structure to the play experience, which is a draw. But at the same time, it means that you always just kind of meander away from them. My other thing is there's been this divergence from the earliest games, especially when you look at the oldest SimCity games.

It felt very, like you said, they felt casual. I don't even know if casual is the right word for it. It was very self-explanatory kind of. It was something that you could easily explain to someone without having to study microeconomics.

So elegant without being necessarily simplistic. You know, there is much worse thing that, yes, earlier games were more simplistic. They weren't, I don't know that I would say they were simple games. I did earlier, but I was wrong.

But it feels like we went from where it was a game based on a simulation to now where it feels more like a simulation masquerading as a game. And it feels like it has lost some of its gaminess as the genre has evolved. Yeah. I do feel like for something to feel like a city builder to me, there cannot be direct warfare.

Yeah, which is why things like Caesar and Anno and stronghold, all kind of Tropico, all kind of fall out of it for me. Yeah, they feel more like light strategy games to me. You know, it needs to be more like Simtown. Yeah, right.

Because that's the good. That's the good. Actually, where you are now, you need to move over to Simphon. Oh, is that it?

I do feel like there was this kind of drive toward granularity that I felt around the time the Sims came out. And I remember when the Sims came out, all my friends who liked Sims in Light Sim City were all wanting a Sim City game where you could zoom into the individual person level. Right. But you kind of can in Sim City 4.

Yeah, this sort of led you. I mean, you can't, it's not like the Sims once you get down there. But I feel like there is this sort of, I don't want to call it a push because I don't know that there was a concerted effort in the development community to do so. But just among fans, you know, at the time that I knew, myself included, we were all like, oh man, what if the next Sim City, it's the Sims in Sim City?

Oh, Smush didn't want because people live in a city and people are Sims. Well, they pitched that Simsville game that was supposed to come out that would be kind of the in-between step where you had Sims but living in a little community and they couldn't make it work. And really, I think the closest they ever got to that game that had the major scale all the way down to the minor scale was Spore, which is not even close to a city builder. It's not, but it does kind of feel like that.

Yeah. I do feel like specifically the Sim City DS games did a good job of kind of getting back to what made city builders great to me, which is, is this kind of decreased complexity, decreased granularity and more kind of macro management type stuff. Yeah. I was talking many motorways and why the hell we're talking about it is far as release information information that was developed and published by Dinosaur Polo Club.

They're the people that brought us Mini Metro, which is also a very fine abstract puzzle game, released on iOS September 19th, 2019 released on Steam July 2021 and on switch it is currently planned for early 2022. It is an abstract traffic game. It's a traffic game. Traffic simulation.

I'm going to go. You called it a puzzle game and not once have I considered that it could be a puzzle game, but now that you say it out loud, I think it absolutely is a puzzle game. So to break down what many motorways is basically you are presented with a very abstract, very soothing, colorful palette. You are given a large building and you're giving a house that matches its color and that house wants to go to that building.

Yes. And so you need to connect it with a road and then the game grows itself. The city builds itself while you gain more houses and more different locations of different colors in the houses. One go to their corresponding colors.

So you're selling, creating this labyrinth of traffic. Yeah. And trying to make it as efficient as possible. That's your core gameplay loop.

Right. And what's interesting to me is it came out, you bought it and then I bought it and then Pablo bought it and then we were all playing it and you said to me, it really scratches that sort of city builder Sim City itch for me. And my first thought was that's the dumbest thing I've ever heard. It's not even remotely one of those games.

And then my next thought was, I mean, yeah, it does kind of feel the same. Yeah. And what it is, is I think it's this level of abstract macro management that it does very well, that it lifts directly from this, this sort of older lineage of city builder games. But it takes out the entire aspect of you building the city.

That has nothing to do with you optimizing your city. Right. And in fact, the way that they build their city is often completely dumb. And I think it's why do you build that house on the other side of the river when you know the factory you want to go to, is way the fuck on the other side of the map.

Why did you do that? I do think a lot of why it kind of has that same sort of old school Sim City vibe is very much the presentation, like Mini Metro, or like Mini Metro. It's very soothing, very calm color palette. Everything's very like soft edges, very muted tones.

Super stylized. Not very realistic at all. Very, very stylized. And I think some of what kind of makes it have that same sort of feel for me also is that in city builders, I don't care about my citizens.

That's true. I'm not here to listen to citizens bitch to me on a fake version of Twitter, like in cities, Skylines. I don't care. I'm here because the character in this story that I care about is the city.

Right. Not the citizens. The citizens are just the gameplay structure for me interacting with my city. Right.

And I feel like many motorways in many ways, many motorways, you might say, the game makes it feel like your city is a character. Your city is this constantly growing pet that you're trying to tend to. Right. And it makes it feel like the city is front and center.

Not the citizens. You never care about these dumb little jerks that need to get to the red building and the blue building and the light blue building. Why don't you go to the regular blue building? Why doesn't the light blue building have the same stuff as the regular blue building?

They're both blue. But it gives you the sense of you care about the city, but you don't care about the individual granular level of everything. Right. Of every person in it.

And even seeing little cars driving back and forth, you gain no affection for them. If anything, you gain hatred for them because they seem to intentionally get themselves stuck in the stupidest fucking ways. Now, I do also feel like there's this act of this motion in the city building games that a lot of times when I'm playing them, a lot of what I'm doing is just sitting there and watching. That's true.

Just watching this city that I've created operate and I feel like newer city building games, they want to get away from that. They don't want you sitting there watching. They want you always having something to do. This building has a problem.

This building has a problem. It's just keep working on things. Oh, you're sure it just backed up. Oh, this is on fire.

It's such a... And it's a thing that we kind of saw even as early as since 2000 where suddenly buildings would be abandoned and you had to destroy them so they could rebuild there. It's the first time you get that. Yeah.

Yeah. And it's this thing where they're trying to put in this thing of, well, we want you to interact with it. And in earlier games, it was there, but it wasn't really a major deal. In newer city building games and even some of the newer city's and city's kind of lines were sure.

It's this thing where it's always got you doing these different sort of menial tasks that aren't necessarily affecting things. And I feel like in many motorways, there are chunks of time where the city's always slowly growing, but you're just kind of sitting there enjoying it and getting to take in this thing that you've put together. But simultaneously, there's a minimal level of stress on top of it. You're like, yeah, when's that next house going to pop up?

Yeah, I know the factory's going to pop up and it's going to be the worst place. But there's that there's this gap where every time something new pops up, you've got a few seconds to... Yeah. And we haven't said this.

You can speed up and pause the game. So the way I play it anyway, and this is I think why I get that city builder feel is when something new pops up, I pause and I build for it. Right. And so there I am building my city.

I get that kind of city builder, city building motion. And then I unpause and I just watch it. I just watch it exist. I judge whatever structure I've built.

Maybe I delete it real quick and build it up a different way because I'm like, oh, that was stupid. But it's this motion of I build a thing and then I just kind of sit there and I just watch it. I just watch it. I just watch it exist.

And I feel like that's something that's the portion of this gameplay loop that feels like a city builder, even though again, you're not building a city. The city builds itself. You're building roads. Yeah, at best you're building the infrastructure of the city.

And you're still given limited options as far as what you get to build because they're already building the origins and destinations for you. You just have to build the go between. Let's talk tools that you're given in the game. Yeah.

It has bridges and tunnels, which are pretty self-explanatory. Right. It has traffic lights that you can put in. It has roundabouts and it has motorways, which are basically highways that go over all of your other roads.

Yeah. The game, like Mini Metro before it, randomly gives you a choice of one of these two of these things and you can pick one. Yeah. And generally the better choice will give you less road tiles to work with.

Yeah. I know motorways always give you less road tiles. I think the rest of them give you the same, don't they? They may.

But then sometimes you get an option for no upgrade, but just more road tiles. Right. And I struggle with some of these bridges and tunnels I use a bunch. Roundabouts to me are the most useful with the way I build.

Yeah. Same here. Motorways, I go back and forth. Sometimes I'll put in a motorway and I'm like, man, that was a genius idea.

What a genius place for a motorway. Other times I put it in, I'm like, no one's using it. You can move them. I know.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Retro Warriors?

This episode is 1 hour and 7 minutes long.

When was this Retro Warriors episode published?

This episode was published on September 6, 2021.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Retro Warriors episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.