Skip to content
Retro Warriors 450 - Everquest (Project1999) episode artwork

Mar 4, 2024 1 hr 32 min

Retro Warriors 450 - Everquest (Project1999)

from Retro Warriors

Topic starts at: 26:50. This week we discuss Everquest! You can find our Discord, Patreon, social media, and more at https://linktr.ee/retrowarriors

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Retro Warriors 450 - Everquest (Project1999)

0:00 1:32:35
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

You do my luck in our tour, he's up to 450. As my host, Jess Maker, and not as always, I'm joined by our producer Guy. You did it right this time. Woo, I modified my behavior just in time.

As far as I was keeping, Saturn is still not here because he wasn't here two hours ago when we recorded the last episode because we recorded in blocks. So when you ask two hours from now, he's still not here. He's still not here. He'll be here in episode 451.

Also, this episode 450, it's not so notable, I think. You know, it's notable. Yeah, we don't celebrate the 50s apparently. No, I think the first time we did 50, we did, but then after that, it's just the hundreds.

Right, well, 50 happy happens every year, right? Right, wait, it's the same, it's like how comic books do it, right? The up to 100, you celebrate 25, 50, 75, but after 100, nobody cares about Spider-Man as you won 50, but issue 200 is a thing, you know. That's right, now they're saying to me two Spider-Man's a month, they're getting greedy.

It's Spider-Man. It's a little, no, no, it's two individual Spider-Man's. It's better than Batman, there's like 12 Batman comics every month. If you wanna read all the Batman, it's like Batman and his shitty friends and there's like 50 of them.

No, I tried that at one point. I just tried getting like the, the TVBs at the end of the year, whatever, right? No, there's too many, there's like Batman, there's Detective Comics, I thought those were the same thing, no. Well, it's okay, so when I was reading it, I was totally off on a chance.

Second episode of the night, in case no, Batman was like about Batman fighting Batman criminals, but Detective Comics was him being more detective-y and solving crimes and shit. That was my assessment time. I mean, that makes sense, I guess. Yeah, anyways, the Saturn's still not here, he'll be back for episode 451, and he'll be better than ever, I'm making that claim now.

And if he doesn't live up to it, then you all have had your expectations set and then shattered and it's his fault. Well, you know, certainly better than now. Yeah, he'll be better than he would be if he was here right now. Last night he got on, I was like, okay, let's do the show, oh.

My face are so bad. I'm in pain. I think I can make it through the show and sleep in the night. Poor guy.

My way. I picked up a few games to play on my new laptop. I picked up Deep Rock Galactic Survivor, which is- I read that as Surveyor, and I was like- Surveyor would be more on brand for Deep Rock Galactic. Deep Rock Galactic was a, it still is a, four-person online co-op PvE kind of looter shooter with crafty bits in it is what I'm going to say it is, and I think it's pretty accurate.

I have no information to contradict that. Basically, you play space dwarves going to space mines and shooting bugs and mining stuff, and then going back to the ship, and it's just like a fun online co-op PvE game. And they released this game called Survivor, which is a Vampire Survivors clone. Oh, okay.

And it's really good. Like it, it's really good. You said that, yeah. It is more structured than Vampire Survivors.

It maintains the mining. So in addition to running around, killing enemies, picking up the XP from them and upgrading your weapons and stuff, you are mining materials as you go. So there's this kind of like, mental balancing act that you're doing of like, Hey, I want to kill these bug monsters and get my XP, but also I need to mine things to get materials to upgrade myself, you know, in between levels. And after the, I get a game over or complete the level.

So it's a job. And just that, I mean, yeah, right, as much as Minecraft is a job. And it adds, adding that second layer really diversifies the gameplay. But also because the level is covered in mindable materials and it's like top down, you know, isometric view, you can kind of craft like tunnels and strategic areas into the level.

So you're like, oh, there's too many enemies coming at me. Let me mine a tunnel and funnel them all down into it. So they're easier to kill. So in addition to having this bouncing act of like, I want to be mining, but I also want to be killing things and getting their experience.

You're also changing the level as you play. And on top of that, each level they have a special goal. So it'll be like, Hey, mine 20 of this mineral or pick up six of these little, you know, mushrooms, little dungeon mushrooms off the ground or whatever. So you've got this quest going on, the mining going on and the usual like Vampire Survivors get all the dudes going on.

Fill this eight by 10 hole that you've done with blood. I fucking wish I was a quest. Here's your murder pool. It's it's really good.

It's very complex. It's very deep. It's very fun. The difficulty curve is so vampires, there's a moment in the game where you kind of tilt in every game of the S you hit a moment where you're like, all right, I've now accelerated my upgrades to a point that the enemies cannot keep up and I'm going to win.

Yeah, yeah. Or you don't reach that point and they overwhelm you and you die. The deep rock lactic survivor is really good about keeping you right on that razor's edge where you're not quite tilted enough that you don't have to worry, but you never quite feel so far behind because sometimes in vampires, if I was you'll do a run where you're like, this ain't fucking happening, you know, like you just, you just kind of get bad upgrades or you made some bad choices and you're getting overwhelmed quickly and you're like, yeah, you can struggle along for a minute or two, but you're like, I make it to the end. I don't know if it's just how I've been playing it or how it's designed.

I feel like it's a design thing, but they're really, really good about keeping you right on that razor's edge where, you know, it's not easy, but it also doesn't feel overwhelming. Well, I mean, it's good. I feel like a lot of times when I play vampires, survivors, you know, I'm trying to like do do achievements still like an unlock characters, et cetera, et cetera. And so you get to a point where you're like, you know, 10 minutes in, it's like, oh, I can just stand here and then, you know, walk away.

Yeah. Yeah. It's it's really and maybe that happens later. Maybe eventually you get upgraded to the point that it's, you know, a non issue, but at least in the hours I put into it so far, which is according to my steam play time six hours, it's really good.

There's four classes. They're all very different. It's got multiple levels. It really trickles out the unlocks kind of slow, which I like because I think it's them identifying that, you know, something that vampires, I think maybe identified a little bit too late where sort of the point of the game is to unlock stuff.

And so vampire survivors has built it so that there's just so much fucking shit to unlock that there's always something to unlock. Survivor here is more the realm of there doesn't seem to be a shitload of unlocks yet, but they trickle them out kind of slow. You're not getting them crazy fast. And then they add my stolen early access game.

So it's it's but it's like nine bucks. And man, it's it's really good. If you've been looking for the next good vampire survivors, this one, I think not only is a good one, but also adds enough different strategic elements that it really does feel like a different game. Because some of my players are just like, yeah, this is just vampire survivors, but she made it look like Diablo graphics or yeah, this is vampires fibers, but it's pixelated in your own graveyard.

You're like, it's fun. I like it, but it's not really like fundamentally different or improved on that formula, right? Yeah, that's you're right. Survivor definitely feels like they are bringing something new to the table, like just the mining part alone would be enough if it was just the same game, but then look, here's mining on top of it.

That would be enough. But they do add enough to really feel like the I would say the first that I've played the first real standout in this new genre that has been created by vampire survivors, obviously not accounting for vampires fibers. But since VS, nothing has quite felt super stand out. This one really does.

So super duper absolutely picks up if you like to VS at all. It's fun. It's real fun. You can't tell me how to live my life.

I can recommend to you how to live your life. I also picked up the Etrion Odyssey, like HD remaster bundle on steam because the collection came out for all three of them and it was like $80. So I put it on my wishlist. It was on sale for like 40 bucks for all three of them.

That's when we take your horse on a journey. What? No, I was seeing. God damn it.

No, it's not bad. It's an quantity. I'll see. Um, it's it's it's Etrion.

It's it's really good. It adds just enough. It's a it's a very gentle remaster, right? It adds just enough to make them feel very playable because people that haven't played the very very first Etrion game, it's missing kind of some of the features that later ones had.

Like I don't believe the original game had auto mapping at all to my recollection and they they add pretty expansive auto mapping. Some of the later ones in maybe also the first one had auto mapping, but it would only map the floors, not the walls. So you can turn on like full auto mapping, you can increase combat speed. It makes it feel nice and snappy.

And it's it's real good. I was a little concerned about the map controls because people haven't played Etrion. It's the first person kind of anime aesthetic dungeon crawler. And that's the whole game is to go to town, gear up and then go into the dungeon.

It's like how many levels of the dungeon, but you had to draw your own map on the touchscreen with the pin. So that was the big that was what made it cool. Cool. I was worried for it.

It was cool. All right. God fuck off. Oh, okay.

I don't I was a little worried how that would translate to a controller interface, but I think they did it pretty intelligently and it's a little fun for a couple of minutes, but then you kind of get get get the swing of things. And I've only played a chunk of the first entry and so far because I want to do them in order, but they're still really good. I would definitely be a little annoyed if I paid I looked at up $80 for the collection, but they seem to be going on sale for half off pretty regularly. And I think I think it's 40 bucks worth of for the trio of games is fair.

I also I also started playing a drink by builders too. No, no reason really. It just has been in my steam library. I got on super sale for like $5 or whatever, you know, doing like the last winter sale or whatever.

And I was just I had been playing a lot of SPS games from, you know, I talked about last week. So it's very much like the terrors of war. I'm like, I need something to sort of cleanse my palate. That's not just like literal war crimes playing out in front of me and people being like, Oh, raw American military save the world.

I was like, I need to kind of, you know, cleanse that palate. So I went to a drink with builders. I'm not far past the extremely long tutorial segment. It felt like ours, but it's cute.

It's fun. I enjoy it. It says my play time is 16 hours. There's no way it's that high.

I think I must have left the game running or something. But it's. Or you were just having so much fun. You lost track of time, Justin.

If it really is 16 hours, that means the tutorial boat took me 16 hours and I'm not willing to admit that I'm that bad at games yet. I think there's still some amount of hope for me. So I'm just going to say maybe I left it on overnight. I guess.

What are you going to play? Okay. Why went to your house and played some magic? My house.

Yeah, we did play some magic. We drafted some wilds of L. Drain. Yeah, we discovered that entry is just innately good at magic.

Andrew, you hit the nail on the head. Andrew is a really good deck builder. Just inherently. It doesn't matter what game he's playing.

And I think what it is is he has hardcore into the DC deck builder game, which is for people who haven't played deck builder games as the name implies, you start out with a small static deck and you add cards to your deck as you play. And he's played an insane amount of that. And I think it's just taught him really good kind of card evaluation because he is annoyingly good at building decks. I'll show up to his house.

A card game he's never played. I'm like, hey, let's build some decks and play. And he comes out of the gate with like a relatively competitive deck. And I'm over here like, oh, I can't actually play a third of my cards.

That's the wrong type. I fucking read them wrong. So I don't work like that's that's me. So yeah, he is very good at putting together decks.

Yeah, as impressed like we played we played two games, I guess, of our draft and decks, like three player games and Andrew one, both of them. Oh, yeah, he did. Didn't he? Yeah.

Huh. I didn't even occur to me. It was a really good time. I had a blast with y'all.

It was really fun. Yeah. Yeah. Playing arena because the new set just came out beginning of the month.

So that's a lot of fun. Hi, enjoy learning a new set. And again, it's kind of like last week we talked about men where I'm in a journey to learn how to play limited or draft limited arena, right? Fair magic, excuse me.

And like the people that I listen to like podcasts or watch their content or whatnot, you know, they're all like, yeah, you know, I play arena, you know, sporadically, I know how to do all of these things because I've been playing magic for like 50 years. Right. Like, oh, okay. That's just why you're good at this.

Yeah. So, you know, I'm on year two, I think, and starting to feel like I'm kind of okay. Like, like as much as you're like, oh, there's an expert magic player that's coming over or whatever. Like I play and like get past gold.

Like Gold League, you're still you're getting like the way the ring system works. Like each league is in divisions and each division has like little pips or whatever they get to fill up. Yeah. And you get two pips if you win and lose a pip if you lose through gold, right?

So as long as you're winning at like a 50% clip or like 45%, you're still going to get out of gold eventually. So I'm still in the I'm stuck in platinum because once I actually have to like maintain a winning percentage greater than 50, no, it doesn't happen. You know, so I feel like maybe, maybe eventually I'll get out of platinum and then feel like I'm kind of good at the game. I've always been bad at and disliked all limited formats in card games.

And I've learned what I really like, what I really get a kick out of is, and it's been true of every card game is finding one deck I like and just getting really, really, really obscenely good at that one specific stack of cards. And that's it. Yeah. Like that's, and I learn all of the nuance.

I learn all of the matchups with that one deck. I learn how to do weird edge cases and all the weird stuff that is so in like flesh and blood was the most competitive I think I ever got in a card game. And I played Reinar was my main deck and I doubt anybody knows flesh and blood listening, but if you do, you know that Reinar is like a trash tier deck sucks. He's been trash tier since he came out.

He's just bad, right? And I got because it's because he's a luck based deck, right? And so competitive players hate luck based stuff. They want to be as consistent as possible.

And I got so good at manipulating the variables in that deck that by the end of it was not a luck based deck anymore because I got really good. Like that's where the joy is for me, right? But just like slapping together a pile of cards I've just pulled. I'm like, I don't know.

My, what I say is that I'm dumb. And so it seems to take me a long time to learn and understand the interactions that these cards have seems taking longer than most other people. Like other people I feel can look at some cards and be like, I can kind of see this little engine that they have going between one another. I'll look at the same cards and just see nothing.

I'll be like, we talk about, and you'll have to sit down and explain it to me like I'm a little kid and I'll be like, oh, and I still won't get it until I've done it a dozen times. So that's just kind of where I am on it. But I'm not so play limited, but you know, I've always been so bad at it. It's fucking terrible.

And then another night I've gotten back into Destiny 2 a little bit. Yeah, I fired that up. I spent last night playing with you and Andrew and then this afternoon I was kind of like getting back up to, you know, not competitive because it's kind of a PDE game, but like playable. Right.

You're like 160 armor levels below me or whatever. Yeah. I'm like fixing my gear up trying to understand like, you know, where are we playing at? Like what's the stuff to search for this season?

Like what's going on with it? Yeah. Yeah. I'm kind of kind of excited to get I deleted fours of five off my Xbox.

We got rid of that 120 gigs and then downloaded 140 gigs of Destiny 2. So there you go. Nice. It's great.

Enjoy Destiny. Having gone through a bunch of FPS games lately, it feels like the only major game that's really focusing on PVE, first-person shooter content. Yeah. And I like, you know, it has a weird party size.

Yeah. That's always been a problem for us. But now we're down to three friends that play. So great.

Yeah. So it's like, I know that it's in demand because Destiny 2 does pretty good for itself. So like, why aren't more companies doing like really meaningful online PVE, first-person shooter content, please? I would like that if there was some competition in this space.

Right. It would be nice. Which brings us to the news. First up, Breath of Fire 2 is now playable via the Capcom Town website, which is a weird website that you can go play games on if you want.

But it's Breath of Fire 2, so you can also play Super Nintendo ROM. But it's on the website if you want it there as well. I've never even heard of Capcom Town. I think I went to it once and I was like, that's neat.

I'll just play the ROMs like I wasn't going to. Yeah, I'm at it now and it's just loading. The website includes sound. We recommend turning it on for the full experience.

Not right now, Captain. Is it still all like neon yellow? Yeah. Nice.

You say neon I say piss. FDC has accused Microsoft of misrepresenting its plans during the Activision Blizzard King merger after recent layoffs. What? Why can't believe a Big Maker corporation doing giant acquisitions would lie about their plans?

Not to the government. This is impossible. Yeah. Persona 3 Reload and Like a Dragon Infinite Wealth have become the fastest-selling games in the history of either franchise at 1 million units within one week.

Yeah, it's alright. Which, first of all, let me say, that's great. Second of all, it's frustrating because the launch monetization and pricing of both of these games is what has prevented me from purchasing either. So I don't like that I feel that some market, you know, monetization practices are being reinforced by the data.

But also I like both of these franchises, so I'm conflicted. Also Sega announced lower than expected earnings due to slow sales, which we're starting to see every game company do because now that they've laid it for everybody off, they want to come out and be really sad about their low sales. And so I think we're just going to be seeing this for a couple of years of game companies coming out and boo-hooing about their low sales. Celeste developer Maddie makes games has released a free 3D interpretation of the game called Celeste 64, which I haven't played yet, but looks really cool.

And Celeste is a cool game and you should play it because it's basically free on like a bunch of stuff. It keeps coming in and out of game paths, which is annoying. Yeah, I'm pretty sure like the original Celeste is just free. You just go download it.

I don't think it, you know, but in any case, it's a fun game. The original PC-8801 version of ease has released on Switch internationally, but the game still plays only in Japanese. So if you don't speak Japanese, maybe you don't play it because you won't know what they're saying. Although the first ease game, you could probably get by.

I think you probably get through it without knowing what any of the words are. It's pretty light game. I booted it up for all of 30 seconds. The first one?

Yeah, I like the first one. It's kind of arcadey. Yeah, well, I enjoyed it. Apparently it played like three hours of it.

It's basically the whole game. It's not very long. Yeah. So I don't remember it at all, but I saw the news and was like, oh, yeah, I meant to go through that.

I got like the ease one in two chronicles. Yeah. And so I booted it off and it went, no, not right now. Yeah.

After week of rumors, Microsoft held a future of Xbox conference where they said that Xbox will continue to make consoles, though some games will be going multi-platform, shocking nobody. I don't think anyone's shocked by any of this. I think it's nice to hear them recommitting to the idea of dedicated hardware, because I think that's a thing a lot of us like. But I'm also not upset at more multi-platform now that I primarily game on PC.

So yeah, both good things to hear them doubling down on. Yeah, I'll be interested. Like, it sounds like both Sony and Microsoft want to be more multi-platform going forward. Interested to see what the exclusive landscape looks like.

And how that affects hardware sales. Like, I haven't bought a PS5 at this point, and I don't know if I will or not. Yeah. Yeah, I still have no intentions purchasing one.

I just I can just play all those Sony exclusives on a year delay, except for Demon's Souls. Fans have recreated the Satellaview F0 courses from a VHS recording using AI interpretation, which is the weirdest fucking sentence you know, I've sent a long time. I'm okay with this use of AI. Me too.

Like, it's cool. I didn't read enough about it to understand how they did it with AI, but neat, you know, right? Yeah, like I have problems with like AI art and really with AI voices, obviously. But this seems like a cool application.

Yoshi Takah Murayama, Suikoden, series creator, and scenario writer for Audin Chronicle has passed away at age 55 tragically again, just like last week, extremely young. Yeah. So that's very tragic to hear a lot of those communities are still in mourning. And it was I don't I don't I mean as far as I know, it wasn't an unexpected thing.

So that's very tragic to hear. It's getting to the point is like, oh, when that guy was born, I was all I'll bear or excuse me, when I was born, that guy was barely a teenager. It's getting there, right? You're replaying.

Oh, no. Sony says PS5 sales missed goals and will adopt more aggressive PC release plan, which is what I want to fucking hear because I don't have a PS5. So thanks, Sony. Right.

Yeah. Let's go down to like a three month delay, you know, like like movies. And finally, Tekah Knight seems like it's going to be adding an in-game cash shop after the game's release to skirt reviews, dinging it for having a cash shop, which is something I think should be illegal. I think it should be legitimately illegal to take a game that someone just paid $70 for and add a cash shop to it.

Period. Full stop. That's my thoughts on it. I'm very annoyed by this.

I can see why, you know, like if you want to have a cash shop, sure have your cash shop, but to add it, the game came out what two weeks ago, like you're obviously just trying to dodge reviews being upset about your monetization. Like what other reason would you possibly have? They're adding value, Justin. You know what's really valuable?

Buying a thing and then getting the whole thing. Oh, I thought you were going to say EverQuest. I thought it was just me one of your bad tricks. Hey, you know what else is really valuable?

EverQuest, which is our topic at hand this week. This is for synopsis. Do you have too much free time? Our modern MMO is too enjoyable.

Come try EverQuest. I really like what I'm doing and it's efficient. As far as a note on scope, this is very long note on scope. So please bear with me.

This is kind of a weird episode because EverQuest is basically multiple games at this point and I don't just mean EverQuest 2. All of the various fan servers for the game, which we talked about last episode, kind of exist at different points in the game's 25-year history. So this fan server is playing a power era and this fan server is Koonarck era and this fan server is a different era. There's one EverQuest fan who's two into this episode and they're like, I didn't listen to the last one.

So without going into too much detail on all the options, for the purposes of this episode and the research I have done, it is important to know about two versions of EverQuest. Retail EverQuest, sometimes also called Live. This is the version of the game that originally launched and is still going and still being run by the successor company that launched it. It has had 25 years of active development.

It's on its 30th expansion and is so different from the game that it that from the game that launched in 1999 that it is effectively a different game entirely. That is in the gameplay section of our episode, not the game we're talking about, but in the development section of the episode is the game we're talking about. Okay, that makes sense. Project 1999 is a fan run officially sanctioned server that tries to emulate the experience of playing EverQuest in 1999 after the first two expansions came out, but before any later content releases.

And while not a perfect representation of the time, because again, it's an emulated fan server, they don't have the original server files, it's not perfect, it is the closest to a time capsule that we have in the EverQuest space to see what the game looked like in 1999. This is the version of the game that the gameplay section is about, because this is the one I played, but the development section is not about. It is about the actual original retail game that this game is emulating, but is not, is everyone with me? Sure.

Does this make sense? I think your issue is wanting people to understand you. It's worth noting that there are many other classic fan servers in similar and other eras of the game, with the notable recent one being Project Quarm, which is a little bit later than Project 99 and is post the graphical overhaul that the game receives, so it looks very different. P99 is the version of the game that I played, the game version of the game I still play, and for this episode, it is the version of the gameplay we will be discussing.

So this is why it gets weird, because if I go play retail EverQuest, it's not the same as EverQuest that came out in 1999, which is the game we're talking about in the development section, the actual original release. I feel like your plan is to just say it so many times. Fine. Okay.

Getting into the actual topic, release info, game came out in North America March 16, 1999, came out in Europe April 28, 2000, and was ported to the Mac in North America June 24, 2003, which is real late. And the Mac client also has its own emulator, the Alkabore Project, which is what Project Quarm is based off of. It's a very weird, I'm just going to keep talking. As far as first encounters, the first time I ever heard about EQ was an early OTS Teenage Comedy movie called The New Guy starring DJ Qualls in Eliza Dushku, and in it, a few of the characters were obsessed with the game.

And at some point, like long post-World of Warcraft, I tried to figure the game out, and I was playing the then current retail version and just found it totally indecipherable and just kind of quit because it seemed like an absolute fucking mess. Where are we talking about that movie like the other week? I think we were. I think I brought it up because I was like, yeah, that's how I heard about EverQuest, was the new guy.

No, you brought it up because in the movie, the oh sorry, so, Tangerin. In the movie, the new guy DJ Qualls plays this like nerdy guy at his school, and he has like an erection, and the lunch lady grabs it, and like this is the embarrassing moment that forces him to move schools in the whole gist of the movie is that at the new school, he's going to be a cool guy. He's not going to be that dorky old guy, but the reason he had to move schools is because after the lunch lady grabbed his dick, she like twisted it and it broke. And so everyone called him Broke Dick.

We were talking, we were saying, you brought up the Broke Dick thing, and we were joking about that. Oh, it was just answering us, or was punching people in the junk in the game we were playing. Oh, yeah, and you're like, we'll call him Broke Dick like in the new guy. Now, I want to be clear, I've not watched this movie since it came out, like 2003 or whatever.

So I do not vouch for how well it holds up for anyone that pursues it because of what we've said here. Oh, yeah, no, I imagine it does not hold up well at all. I do remember enjoying it at the time, but I was also like 12, so, you know. Yeah, no, I was in college and enjoyed it at the time.

Yeah. What about you as far as first encounters with EverQuest? We kind of talked about it last week a little bit, but I played it in college because I worked for Speed Zone. And my boss was like, I played this game, you should play it too.

He was super nerdy. And I tried and it was an experience. It is an experience. You would have been in the, we established last episode, you would have been in the Plains of Power era, which is a very divisive era of a game.

Let's talk development. So this game was originally conceived by John Smedley in 1996. The actual design and development was done by Brad McQuaid, who not very long ago passed away, unfortunately. Steve Clover and Bill Trost.

Smedley had already worked in the games industry and was the head of Sony Interactive Studios, originally known as Sony Interactive Studios America, when he was put in charge. It did undergo a few name changes over the years before finally morphing and kind of splitting off from Sony into the daybreak game company, which is what it's known as today, which is the company that currently still runs EverQuest, EverQuest 2, Planet Side 2, I think DC Universe Online. Don't think do Magic Online too? They do Magic Online, yeah, that as well.

Not Arena, but specifically into GEO. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Smedley was very into tabletop RPGs and Dungeons and Dragons at the time. He went to his boss in 95 with the pitch before getting completely shut down.

And this was late 95, and that boss quit the company like right after he pitched it. So he immediately went and re-pitched it to his new boss, Kelly Flock. And he said, do it, give him the green light. What kind of dirt do you think he had on his boss?

I don't know, man. I don't fucking know. So no, you can't play that game. All right, well, you're out of here.

Brad McQuaid and Steve Clover had put out a game called War Wizard that Smedley was aware of and impressed by. So he sought them out to work on this new project. Bill Trost and a few others also worked on the War Wizard team, and they were brought in and it grew to about 10 members. All of them were kind of enamored with mudds at the time.

They were excited about the idea of this online game. And before long, that 10-person team grew into a 25-person team with different departments, and they were just kind of off to the races developing the game. Sony Interactive licensed the engine from a game called Tanneris and slapped on some network code and then basically built the rest from scratch. McQuaid and Clover were the primary designers, and they eventually ended up with an 80-page design Bible that would be worked into the game.

And what's really interesting is it was relatively complete, like most of the content in that document made it into the final game. McQuaid would later comment that they really got to make the game that they wanted to make, which I think is important to keep in mind. Bill Trost was largely in charge of the art and history and kind of visual direction of the game, as well as the very robust and detailed faction system that the game has that we'll talk more about later. And then after making use of some of the kind of then burgeoning 3D improvements at the time, the game was worked into a playable enough state to be shown at E3 and GDC.

The Kino's area of the game was shown at E3, and it was received well, but at GDC, the response was so positive that they struggled with players refusing to give up their seats. Like they were literally trying to chase people and be like, hey, your time's out of this next person's and they would be like, no, I will not stop playing a request. And then they caught people that would leave the seat and go to other seats, they would log that character out, go to a different seat, log in and keep fucking playing. Like this is how addictive the game was out of the gate, whether chasing people around a fucking GDC booth.

At launch, the game gained over 10,000 subscribers on the first day and enjoyed very high sales. Within six months, it had 225,000 units sold in over 150,000 players, which at the time is enormous. This is before MMOs pulled in millions of people. That's gigantic numbers.

And being an MMO development just never stopped. And in the early days, it was a struggle to secure adequate bandwidth to keep the game up and running, because when they estimated their server space, the only metrics they had to go off of was like web browsing data, right? So they're like, hey, how much service space would we need for this much web browsing? And they bought servers based on that.

Come to find out, EverQuest uses way more data and is much more time and packet sensitive. And so in the first three months, they had people in the data center at all times, literally 24 seven around the clock, people sitting in the data center, having to bait these servers before they were able to really fix all of their bandwidth issues, because it was so unprecedented. They just were not properly prepared for it. The history doesn't stop and continues to today because the game is still made, daybreak, still runs it.

The game has never really changed hands. The company owning it has just slowly kind of morphed over the years. And it's interesting to hear a lot of the people on the current retailer request team talk about the game, because a lot of them have been there since either the beginning or near the beginning. But they're bringing in new people because the game is 25 years old in 2024.

And I was listening to like one of a high reps talk on a podcast and she was talking about like, it's really weird having people working on the game that weren't alive when it came out. And there are a lot of lessons that we've learned over the years running this game for a quarter of a century that these, you know, I don't want to call kids, but these young people don't know. And it's lessons that we have to say, no, no, no, this doesn't work that way. And they're like, well, it should.

And they're like, yeah, we know it should, but we learned that in 2003 or whatever. And it's just a code. Good luck. It's just fucking fascinating.

Like just it's fine. Like, I don't know what the longest developed game is. I don't know if there's a world record for like game with the longest development, but I mean, this has to be up there, right? Like 25 years of active development.

Now, granted, it's a shadow of its former self. It's very much free to play. There's microtransactions. And you know, it's it is what it is.

But it is still getting new content. There's still new stuff being made for it. Like that's insane. Just the amount of shit in the game.

And so this is where I put in a big hard break. Oh, I say, I say now, we're going to talk about the closest to what EverQuest was when it launched that I could play, which is not retail EverQuest, because retail EverQuest is an accumulation of those 25 years of development. And I wanted the classic experience. I played Project 1999.

And that's the year it came out. That is the year it came out. Okay. So the the P99 server is meant to be as close to classic original EverQuest, as is reasonable.

They fix they don't have like the launch UI because the launch UI is like ridiculous. Things like scrolling your mouse in and out, zooms in and out of your character. There's little bits in here. Very minor conveniences added.

But they're very, very, the P99 team is extremely concerned with like how authentic how classic is this is the phrase they use? They're like, well, that is classic and that isn't classic. They're very zeroed in on what is and isn't classic, right? And I was trying to I think the server's been running since at least 2011.

So even this fan server of original EverQuest is older than most MMOs ever made it to officially, right? Because this is that's 13 years ago. And I think it started before that, which is fucking insane. This is insane stuff.

I mean, you know, there's there's audience for it, right? Like, I know, like you share it. And and the servers, P99 has three servers. There's the blue server, which is the original, the green server, which launched like three years ago, and the red server, which is the PVP server.

The blue and green servers usually clock between like 300 and 1000 players, depending on when you're logging in, which is pretty good for a fan server, right? Yeah. The red server clocks. Sometimes it hits triple digits.

Okay, so just, you know, it's not nearly as popular. It's kind of dead. But we're talking anywhere between like 600 to upwards of, you know, 1800 people playing this fan server at any given time depending on the time of day, which is a lot of people for a server that's been around for a long time. So presentation, uh, every quest, as I mentioned, did go through quite a graphical overhaul in the retail version to make it a little more palatable.

But but the classic version, I honestly find very charming. The entire game, the aesthetic of the game is very classic fantasy. It's very classic token-esque fantasy. There's elves and dwarves and halflings and the lot of big raid bosses are like dragons and giants and trolls and stuff.

Oh my. But I'm, I'm like, I'm a pretty big fan of like vanilla fantasy to begin with. You know, I'm a noted enjoyer of vanilla token-esque fantasy. And I know that like it's not, you know, you certainly don't spend time crafting fantasy worlds in various tabletop systems.

It's not like you. Yeah. So let's say this, you have played in my D&D campaigns. I forget Saturn's not here.

You have played in my D&D campaigns quite extensively at this point. Yeah. And while I do like a weird escapade here and there, I think you know that I'm very much a traditional fantasy fan. Where's our who talks like this?

That is clearly. I'm happy enough with dwarves that live under a mountain, elves that live in a forest and halflings that are going to steal all your shit when you're not looking like I'm, I'm happy with that, that version of fantasy. And again, I know it's not the trendiest version, but I like it. You know, dungeons are flagstone corridors with torches and they're kind of wet and there's cobalt in them like that's I'm, I'm okay with that.

I like that. And as a big vanilla fantasy fan, I really like the, the presentation and aesthetic of EverQuest because I find that very token-esque fantasy to be really timeless, right? There are other versions of fantasy that I find a little less timeless and they end up feeling a little dated as winter as they get older. But I really do like what classic EverQuest has to the point that when I went to retail EverQuest to play and compare, I was taken aback because the graphical overhaul looks very not classic fantasy.

They made everything look kind of weird. Like my dwarf, because I play a dwarf in Project 1999, I'm a dwarven player. My dwarf has like a big beard and he's kind of bald on top. He's got a scar over his eye.

He's a very dwarf-y looking dwarf. So he's chonky, stocky, short dwarf, right? And I made the same thing, I made the same thing in retail EverQuest. And my dwarf was very like slender and athletic looking.

His, his beard was, you know, cropped very close to his face. And he just, he didn't look as rugged, you know? And the thing is in classic EverQuest, dwarves have a special jump animation and it is one of their class features. It has no functional use in the game.

Like, functionally, it has no gameplay purpose. But one of the perks of playing a dwarf is that when you jump, you do this kind of like tumble, like you roll. Okay. And it's very dwarf-y, you know, because you're short, very low to grand, very kind of rotunda.

So you do this sort of jumpy roll thing instead of a regular straight up jump, because you're short. And in the graphical, you know, the graphical overhaul, the retail version of EverQuest, they changed it. So it's like a ninja flip into the air. Wow.

That seems like, yeah, I was like, yeah, like I was playing one night and I was teamed up with another dwarf in some high level character came by and was like, helping us out with stuff. And we're like, okay, cool. Thanks. And he's like, you guys are so cool.

Do the jump. And we had to like do the tumble for him for his enjoyment. So he would give us buffs. And he's like, that's awesome.

See you later. Like, that's what he wanted. So I was really sad that I turned into this very weird way too high, like straight up ninja somersault jump in the overhaul. I love the soundtrack in this game.

It is legitimately good fantasy music. And the actual sound font is pretty simplistic. Like, I think it's MIDI music. And I've said on the show before, I have very dumb ears.

And the sound font makes it simple enough that the music is more accessible to me, if that makes sense. And so I legitimately find myself like humming some of the tunes, like the theme for Colodine, the D'Orbin City, as I'm like doing dishes and just kind of around my house. I wish. Let's talk gameplay.

Again, specifically about P99. No, I got it. Don't do it. Gameplay wise, I think it's best to describe classic EQ by what it's not.

Okay, because I think most of us are probably pretty aware of like basic fantasy MMO structure by now. You like grind progressively more difficult monsters, complete quests, do dungeons, eventually transition to end game raids and get your epic gear. Like that's that's that's fantasy MMO shit, right? Yeah.

And that's present in this game. It's present in a different way. But that's all here. Classic EQ still has all this.

It's just kind of a different version. So the way I want to talk about this is I'm going to give you kind of the basics. So we know fantasy MMO, it's your standard stuff. So I'm going to go over some basic details and then I'm just going to have a big list of like hardcore MMO shit that Project 1999 does.

All right. And here first up, classes, you got your four class categories. You have your casters, which include Enchantor, Magician, Necromancer, Wizard. You have your priests, your healers, which are cleric, druid and shaman.

Your melee classes are barbed, monk, ranger, rogue, and your tanks. Your big tanky dudes are Paladin, Shadow Knight, and Warrior. The game does it here to kind of the standard tank healer DPS triangle for parties, right? Yeah.

But it's really loose with it. All of the classes are so different ability-wise that like I was playing in a group the other day that there was six of us. It was five priests and one tank. And it got weird, but it was doable, right?

The game doesn't enforce it, you know, as long as you're smart and you play smart, you can get by with it. I sometimes you'll get into a party and you'll be like, all right, we're kind of a weird makeup. We're like, you know, two clerics and three enchanters. Like what do we do?

And you start to learn the good combos. Like Enchantor combo is really good with cleric. And I play a cleric. So I know when I see an Enchantor, like, hey, just me and that Enchantor can go a long ways longer than like me and another cleric, right?

The levels go from one to 60. And then it's full stop. You're just done. There are quests for epic gear and there are trade skills.

If you so choose, you can take up like brewing or blacksmithing or whatever. It's not quite as robust as kind of modern trade skills systems, but they do exist, right? They're in the game. I had to take up cooking for a story I told on the show a couple of episodes ago where I had to make a rat sandwich for a guy to fucking complete my quest.

So that's all pretty basic fantasy MMO stuff. And a lot of games have cribbed this kind of stuff, the one to 60 levels, the the 10k on DPS thing that you know, right? This is all very familiar. Yeah, yeah, for sure.

So let's go over what makes it unfamiliar. So this is just some hard school or hard old school MMO stuff to be aware of. And this list is either going to make whoever's listening to it go, oh, I'm never going to play this game or go, oh, this sounds really interesting to me, right? These are the wrinkles.

First up, you lose XP when you die and you can de-level from it. Yeah, that sounds awful. Didn't find me to do that. I'm also did that.

Yes. No, thank you. Yeah. When you disconnect abruptly, your character stays logged in for one minute.

So if you're, you know, you're trying to like unplug to get out of combat and can happen, you're just going to log in dead. Nothing is instanced. Nothing anywhere. And this means you are always in the same pool with the same people and you can and will build a reputation in your server and you should work to make it a good one.

If you're an asshole to people, people will be like, oh, yeah, I recognize that fucking guy. That guy was an asshole to me three months ago because there's no instances. You can't escape these people. There's no cross server playing nothing.

It's the same people the whole time. There is no dungeon finder, party finder, raid finder, none of that. There's no game wide chat except for private messages. So finding a party means using the slash who command and being social talking to people and private messaging them.

Hey, I see you're in the same area as me and the same level. Would you like to come party up with me? Etcetera, etcetera, etcetera. Are you totally turned off yet?

Travel is slow as molasses. There are no mounts, boats take forever. I think a round trip on a boat ride to get to a different continent is half an hour in real life. Good God.

Okay. Most people there are a couple classes that can teleport you, but they expect a tip. Getting places just in general takes effort in time. It's a thing.

It feels like you are going on an actual adventure. There's no auction house. There's no market board. If you want to sell something, you stand in the East Commons tunnel and you shout about it.

You scream WTS this, this, this, and this. Here's my price. Want to shit. Yeah.

Want to shit. Anyone can loot anything on the ground. Including other people, right? Not other people.

No. You cannot loot other people's corpses at all, which is nice. And PVP servers, I believe you can, but I've never played PVP in classic air request. Kill stealing is possible.

If you start attacking a thing and I attack it and I do more damage than you, that's my kill. I take the experience from you. When you die, your loot and your equipment stays on your corpse. You must recover it.

Or it's just there and you don't have it. So corpse runs our thing. And this is my final thing. You cannot see Monster HP, party MP, Buff Timers, yours or others, and a litany of other standard information that we've come to expect to be able to see at all times.

When someone's buff runs out, they have to message you and ask for a refresh on that buff. When their MP is low, they have to tell you, they're like, Hey, I'm out of an MP. I got to meditate or other people won't know. It is just a slow game.

It is a tough game. Progress is slow and methodical and the game will absolutely have no issues with smacking you down if you get too fast or ambitious. You're not really selling this game, man. So let me talk about the playing nice.

Because all of this stuff, theoretically, in my head would make for the most toxic, hateful, garbage filled place full of assholes fucking each other nonstop. Right? When we think about what a game with these restrictions would feel like in the modern era, it's that this just sounds like a recipe for a toxic shit fest, right? Yeah.

But the game has play nice policies. And what this means is you cannot be an asshole to people in the game. And this is in my eyes, what sets the EQ experience apart from modern MMOs and why I find it so engaging. If you are caught kill stealing, if you're caught training, which means dragging a train of monsters onto someone else to escape them, if you're caught just being rude to people or harassing people or following them or looting somebody else's corpse that from a creature that they killed, you can and will get banned for it.

Because the game is is compared to modern MMOs, very heavily GM, there are GMs in the game, you can petition them, they will come in and they will redistribute gear, they will administer temporary permanent bans. So the game creates the structure of ultimate freedom, right? You can loot anything, you can kill anything. Let me tell you about my first death in the game.

I spawned into the game in front of like this dwarven dude, and I immediately tried to strafe left to get a better look at him. Yeah. With the Q button, Q in classic EverQuest is bound to auto attack. So I immediately punched him in the face and he fucking killed me.

I died. That was my first death, three seconds into the game. You know, and other examples, you can target anyone with any spells. I can target enemies with my healing spells, I can target friends with my damaging spells.

Well, I mean, not friends, NPCs, because there's no PVP, I play in a non-PVP server, I can target the shopkeeper with my, you know, a smite spell or whatever. And this, so the game provides this extremely open, flexible framework, and then enforces being nice to each other. Like if you're just in the game calling people names or whatever, they'll come like get on to you for it. It's a thing.

And there's, there's something so intangibly exciting about it. Because for the most part, in like modern MMOs and stuff, if you're just kind of being annoying, but you're doing shit that the game allows, for the most part, nothing happens to you, right? Yeah. And the argument is usually the argument you see made outside of classic MMOs is, well, the game lets me, if the game lets me do it, I should be able to do it.

And this is kind of the opposite way to handle that, right? The modern way to handle that is all right, let's design around these shitty things people are doing. This game just says, hey, just don't do that. We're not going to keep you from doing it.

You can go steal everyone's kill. We're not going to stop you from doing it. We're going to ask you not to. And it creates what it creates is, and it's something we see in tabletop role playing games, it creates a social contract.

We aren't just people sitting behind our computers playing a game together. We are people engaged in a social contract, the terms of which we've all agreed to, and we all understand that one another are going to abide by. And that social contract creates some amount of like social responsibility to one another in the game world that is lacking a lot of the time in my experience in modern MMOs. Because modern games don't really super, like if the game lets you do it, they'll let you do it.

They'll let you fucking do it. They're like, well, yeah, I mean, the game lets him. So, you know, it's not his fault for being an asshole. P9 is like, no, yeah, it is.

You were being an asshole. Like like, uh, spawn camping level like two when you're like 50. I love that you brought up camping because I want to talk about the gameplay loop. Okay.

So, um, general gameplay loop of the game is log into the game. You first, when you get in, you already know what you're going to go, what you're doing because you have a camp somewhere, you've camped out somewhere. You check your friends list, your guild roster, your whatever for people to party with, check the zone you're camping in for people to party with. See if there's already a party there that you can join.

You start sending some messages. Like every time I log in, I send a couple of tells, I have a couple chats, usually I receive a couple of messages from people and I end up in a party somewhere and you just kind of gain XP in the zone you're parked in and then when you get full up on loot, you go bank and sell stuff and then you go repeat. And when you reach too high a level for that to be meaningful, you move on to the next camp and camps are broken down. Um, they're understood in a social way within the game.

Nothing is identified. Um, so for example, I just got done spending a lot of levels in a little dungeon area called unrest and keep in mind nothing is incensed. So, dungeons aren't run. People don't run into end through a dungeon.

We started the painting and we're going to do all the content through to the end because there's other people there and you're just going to run into each other and fuck at each other's stuff that you're doing, right? Yeah. You're going to end up training monsters on one another. It's going to be a disaster.

So what happens is socially players break the zone down. So when unrest when you show up and you're like, Hey, uh, you know, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, LFG, there's a LFG flag to just like a fancy 11 you type LFG on and it puts next to your names. And when people see you, they're like, Hey, that, that player is looking for a party and you shop and you're like, Hey, I'm new to the zone. Where do I go?

And they go yard. All right. So the yard is the yard because unrest is like this old haunted mansion. Okay.

It's the yard in front of the mansion where all the low-level monsters are. So that's your camp. You go there, you either make a party or join a party. If there's a party they're already camping and they're full, you respect them and you do not take their, their monsters from the yard.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Retro Warriors?

This episode is 1 hour and 32 minutes long.

When was this Retro Warriors episode published?

This episode was published on March 4, 2024.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Retro Warriors episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.