Skip to content
Robert J Rosenthal talks Trump and Journalism episode artwork

Sep 6, 2018 37 min

Robert J Rosenthal talks Trump and Journalism

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

We're joined by one of the very big names in the world of investigative journalism, Robert J Rosenthal, from the Centre for Investigate Reporting, in the US. Robert’s long distinguished journalism career includes being a correspondent in Africa, reporting from Lebanon and Israel, a slew of award-winning investigations and, as well as the editor of the Philadelphia Inquirer and managing editor of the San Francisco Chronicle.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Robert J Rosenthal talks Trump and Journalism

0:00 37:36
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome. You're listening to Fourth Estate, the show where journalists talk journalism, coming to you from 2SCR in Sydney on Galigal Lands of the Eora Nation, right across Australia on the community radio network and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. My name is Peter Frey and I am, among other things, the co-director of the Centre for Media Transition at the University of Technology Sydney and my esteemed producer today is Anthony Dockrell. Tonight's show is not so much about news and newsmakers in our own country.

You might recall last week we did the Media and the Leadership Challenge in Canberra with journals from the New York Times, the Sydney Morning Herald, the Financial Times and the head of the UTS Journalism Monika at Art. That day on podcast and all I can say is go listen. This week we are going to take a look at the state of investigative journalism in the United States, a little bit here and elsewhere. Innovation in journalism and one of our favourite subjects Donald Trump and the news media.

And on the Trump front we might be in danger of running out of shock and awe but we are certainly not short of material. Veteran investigative journalist Bob Woodward, he of Watergate fame has penned a book about Trump's White House and which senior administration officials call the president among other things a liar and idiot. They say that Trump is so ill suited to the job that officials are hiding key documents from him or declining to act on his impulsive suggestions such as killing Syrian President Bashar al-Assad or as the book says Trump telling the general methods let's fucking kill him let's kill the fucking lot of them. To help us understand all this and much much more I am joined by one very big name in the world of investigative journalism Robert Rosenthal from the Centre for Investigative Reporting in the United States.

Robert's long and distinguished career includes being a correspondent Africa reporting from Lebanon in Israel a slew of award-winning investigations and for his sins time as the editor of the Philadelphia Inquirer and managing editor of the San Francisco Chronicle. There is much much more but Robert Rosenthal welcome to the fourth state. Thank you Peter. Glad to be here.

It's great to have you. Let's start with your president and the Woodward book which the whole show isn't about that but I think we have to start with that. So Trump has called it a con and a few people quoted in the book such as Defense Secretary Jim Mathes and White House Chief of Staff John Kelly claimed that they have been grossly misquoted. So I guess the question also comes to mind is will the book have an impact and if so why?

I'm not sure it will have an impact immediately that there was also today as you know an anonymous editorial op-ed in the New York Times by what's described as a senior White House official which mirrored much of the comments but basically said you know we're aware of what's going on and we're going to protect the United States and we realize it. I think the book will just be more a lot of confusion. I think in the United States right now there's a huge political divide and it's dangerous and if you're one of Donald Trump's base it'll just book in this op-ed or another example of the deep state and the conspiracy against Donald Trump. If you can't stand Donald Trump it's more the same it's not going to change your mind.

I think that the question is a big middle where they're going to go and we have a midterm election in two months which you know will really I think push the direction of the United States one way or the other. If the Republicans control the House and Senate who the hell knows what will happen? If the Democrats take the House or the Senate it could lead to even more chaos but really boxing Donald Trump in and could lead to impeachment politically. So I think that but I do think the momentum now in the United States you know the this huge energy for Donald Trump but there's bigger energy he's activated a lot of people politically and I think that's really where the midterm elections are going.

Yeah well we're all very much glued to US politics we're very much glued to the midterms. Yes it's true it's interesting I mean I guess the other thing is from where we sit a lot of us are kind of a bit scared that there's someone who's so seemingly ill-suited to this job in the White House. How does it feel in the US? Embarrassing.

Dangerous. Humiliating and also you know we're always all the fixation and his ability to get inside everybody's head literally every two minutes or 30 seconds depending on the tweet barrage and the response in the news but it also says a lot about the United States. I think you know this is he was elected the way our system works you know if you get in the Electoral College. We did get more votes but what does it say about America and the forces and the feelings that have been unleashed in terms of racism and divided politics it's a very dangerous moment and it's and it's people are really concerned and it's amazing how disruptive it is and I'm was around during Watergate and grew up in the 60s when we had you know Jack Kennedy assassinated in the 63 if you think of that period we had our civil rights movement which was incredibly dangerous violent ugly this Vietnam War happening at the same time and then five years later you know Martin Luther King and Bobby Kennedy, Mega Revers other people assassinated and the nation it was teetering and was that akin to that sort of it's I think it's justice I think the difference now is yes I think it was actually more disruptive than and if you and violent we haven't had the violence yet but the big difference now is the internet and the ability of Donald Trump to be the biggest and most influential and disruptive publisher in the world simply by tweeting so the constant barrage of information is really disruptive.

And that goes to what the show is really about is that in a sense on one level Trump seems to be playing the news media at its own game insofar as it as you say constant barrage of outrage which is very hard not to report right? Yeah I mean he's the president of the United States and you know he had a Twitter feed that was quite active before he went into politics and remember the birther movement he created a following around that but it is you know it's instantaneously and it is obviously unprecedented but again if you look at the authoritarian and the model of the authoritarians forever they've always controlled the information and whatever technology existed whether it was pamphlets or the town crier or the radio and Germany in the 1930s and now we have social media so the control of information and from what we're talking about tonight journalism also with the whipping boys. Well do you think this Trump you know the rhetoric the fake news rhetoric the enemy of the people rhetoric is that working or is that just working to the base? I think it works to the base and I think it also sets up when if whatever negative information comes out the base won't you know it's not true it's not true it's not true they're liars they're which is a tactic or strategy also in terms of the vast conspiracy you know the dark state whatever you want to call it and the Democrats in the Mueller probe so it's done with not only maybe belief on his part but also to undermine the credibility of any critical reporting and that's really fake news is really critical reporting in his eyes.

And just to stick with this because I mean really quite a lot about your Kyle Pope for instance at Columbia Journalism Review and the Reuters people actually out of Oxford they both made these sorts of points that faced with this by Raja Trump that sort of the the journal it's got two problems one is that this is so much of it so the normal chance to look at you know to a whole weekend to investigate all those things are kind of you know having sped up so there's a lot that might be slipping by here and the second point is faced with this you know being called the enemy of the people journalists have a choice or possibly have a choice where they pull their punches or end up looking like their partisan which is possibly you know a bad look for journalism. Well it's only goes away from objectivity. Yes and also we have business models I think similarly what you have here in Australia where you have news major news organizations Fox MSNBC and the left Fox on the right others who clearly are catering to a political point of view that supports their business model in their audience so the audiences you know are going to what they want to hear rather than different points of view which also leads to another important things to things that just completely ignored or not covered by depending on your political point of view. But the disruption you know is real and the question of what journalists do I think you're seeing headlines in the New York Times for example that say this lie or here's what he said and here's the facts.

So it's it's it's really interesting dilemma when you're it's the president and he says this is an extent and say this is not true. What you're seeing that happen right now? I mean you wouldn't know me do that. Well normally the president doesn't bald face lie or not tell the truth and I think in the past you have skepticism or you have investigative reporting that does it but now it's constant and so we're in we are in somewhat uncharted territory here.

Yeah I think so. Well think about it today in Washington in the last 48 hours you had Woodward's book you know leaks around it coming out and then within 24 hours you have someone's who said to be a high level White House official basically saying there's been a don't worry we understand what's going on. He is a liar he doesn't tell truth but there's a quiet sort of coup d'etat going on that we're going to take care of you and if and if that was done it's totally the times obviously I think someone wrote it times obviously he knows who it is. Can you imagine being in the Trump White House and I mean this is like you want to it's better than fiction.

Talk about you know the court of the Medicis or whoever. Yeah. Well just just finishing on Trump for the set for the time being I was in China about six months ago and the Chinese a lot of people China said to me and obviously a few people it's not the old Chinese not China's view but a few people China said to me basically Trump is a genius because he can't be this nuts. Well this kind of this contrary.

I think he said brilliant at his own marketing and ability to understand what motivates and thralls activates his base and whatever you want to call the base the people who support him and it's clear that in the United States right now it's not only a political divide it's really really complicated and hard to talk to people who don't agree with you politically and there's also a racial divide and what he's also activated you know we talked earlier about the midterms or a lot of people I think right now there are more women for example candidates for the congressional offices than ever for many of the of some on the Republican side but many are Democrats and many of these women actually are graduates of the US military academy so have served in Iraq and Afghanistan it's fascinating and the old order on the left if you want to call it the left is really being disrupted and I would it's going to be interesting to see what turnouts going to be because again this isn't a national election these are you know five hundred thirty five seats in our Congress which are hyper local and it's not about the national candidates this is about the local candidates and US Senate's a little different there you know this there are thirty three seats up out of a hundred but there's tremendous amount of energy. He's unlikely to win the Senate. Well Democrats it's only two seats. It's two seats I mean they're not saying so but it's I think it's this chaotic moment right now and if you can believe polls which you know take with a ton of salt you know the unfavorable against Trump is going up the polls are saying the Republicans Democrats will control the House maybe the Senate it's a toss up it's going to be and it could be unforeseen events I think when he said yesterday or two days ago warning Assad about something I think military action when US gets into more wars than we're in already that always leads to things it's it's it's a totally unpredictable unforeseen new moment we're in yes okay it affects the whole world.

I mean we're all let's just say we're glued to our sixth system as almost as much as you guys are. And you know he's getting cornered right now and it's dangerous it's a potentially dangerous moment. It is it is indeed. Hey let's talk more broadly about the best case journalism seems slightly happier subject all of a sudden but anyway you don't have an amazing job at expanding the Senate for investing reporting.

Thank you. You've done so into both the terms of funding in reach in innovation in terms of content and content form and channels including even the use of plays based on investment journalism and coloring books even I was a new one to me today when I was listening to you talk. So how did you do that I mean what's what's the secret here. Failure.

That's right. Well for your audience I mean in the States obviously maybe not obviously we have different tax laws so that people can give money for nonprofit journalism and use this tax deduction. So we have a history not of deep funding in the United States but of American foundations who would support investigative reporting in the center for investigative was the first and oldest nonprofit founded and created in 1977 so 41 years ago. But what really you know I was as you said or mentioned thank you for that wonderful introduction.

I was an editor I started as a copy boy at the New York Times but I was also the editor of Big Papers so I'm and been a reporter but my passion for it was really to try and create a new model at a time when the American newspaper industry had been sort of eviscerated by the financial collapse and the onset of the internet and how did I do it I think that just was really open number one to really important stories that made a difference number one and then really embracing while not being a technologist the skills of people who were able to create content on platforms that reach people in brand new ways across the internet whether it was video or audio or an animation you name it and how data was used or interactive data sets mapping and understanding that these are new ways of telling stories that you know I grew up in a newspaper which was pretty straightforward and pretty remarkable every day that came out when you think about existing technology then but understanding that there were people with skill sets that I certainly didn't have who could take information and tell stories in new ways. Do you think that the industry and this again being very broad but there was a reluctance in parts of the industry to embrace technologists because part of this what you talked about is the need to embrace people who aren't necessarily journalists who aren't necessarily even story tellers. Yes I think that here's for me the problem the way I see it was that in a for profit model in corporate news organizations the number one priority is profit and making money which is fine no one was making money but it totally was hate to say this trumps the journalism needs you know what was going on so when the American newspapers revenue and you've seen it here in Australia began declining and profit margins dropped the one way to keep a profit margin up obviously was to cut costs so they cut out journalists they cut out delivery of papers you name it and so circulation dropped intentionally it was less coverage you know and if you I don't know the data points here but from my own knowledge you know a paper I was the editor of the Philadelphia Inc where I was a very good newspaper when I was the editor I had over 600 people in the newsroom today it's a couple of hundred so think about any of your listeners will understand and that's comparable to here how many things are not being covered that were how many things don't you know about it might be your kid's sports team but it could be the city council or you know who's giving out the judiciary of criminal justice issues that really had oversight and I don't want to sound too cynical but it's my experience that corruption is not unique to any one country or culture no it's actually unique to human nature right tell me about how do you feel about citizens journalists and one of the if you like the big narratives the promises of the web and and the likes of you know the likes of Jay Rose and the K-Shirkin Ursula's people in your country was like right okay here come the audience they're gonna be telling the story you're gonna be working with journalists at best possibly don't even need journalists at worst what do you think I think we need journalists I think journalists know how to glean facts and most importantly the best journalists know how to tell a story because you know if you have a bunch of data and who's gonna pay attention but if you can find the characters to tell a story I think it's really important today to hear and be listening to and have access to on a two-way street to communities and people to get information and even use them potentially as sources of news but I don't think especially for investigative reporting to have credible investigative reporting that's accurate you can rely on the citizen average person because depending on their point of view who they're trying to take advantage of or screw or they're mad at god knows what they'll put out there and we've seen that happen clearly on social media so I do think there's a really important role but I think that what the technology has opened up is the ability to have communications there was always in a sense citizen journalism because the best reporters you went out to the community you covered and you talked to people and you came back and reported on it and they were your sources and if they trusted you were what the story wrote was accurate they called you up or sent you a letter or whatever it was in the old days so that to me was also a form of citizen journalism but I think the openness but to rely on them no I mean is it's a journal is somebody who's at the scene of a car accident takes the picture that goes viral as a journalist is I don't know I don't think I mean they were witness they're witnesses to go further if they can but they're giving it the context they tell in the story so I'm someone who didn't always embrace citizen journalism I embraced a citizen and the openness of dialogue but I do think there are things journalists do that the average person doesn't do and can't do and doesn't understand tell me about the center because one of the I mean you have done remarkable things in this time and one of them has been this kind of sense of measuring impact is that it tell me how you measure success because it's a very you know that and the reason we do that is because if you're funding CIR and people have asked me this question if you're a philanthropist or foundation you want for example of support building wells in a community that's dirty water you can see it or put you know fun schools being built somewhere but how do you measure you know if you're funding journalists and what does that mean you're not going to see something being built but what you do can measure or in terms of impact is how if you're doing a story an investigative story this elite deposit of change this elite the legislation changing this mean to a community dialogue around an issue it's a huge range of things is it helps someone's life does it take get someone out of jail or is in jail or create a positive for someone's life who was in a deeply negative situation and I could get into great detail so it's many things you do a story that becomes curriculum for university or a high school there's a story that lead people to take action or create solutions so I mean those are all forms of measurement loss changing etc exposure of a problem that people didn't know existed so those are all you know in a big market a laundry basket of impacts there's so many ways to do it and one of the things we learned that there were so many unintended consequences as well that we saw as success but it was creating a culture where those things were captured it was most important and one of the things you did was create this this impact tracker tracker which I look at this afternoon as historical yeah it's a content management system that we share with other news organizations and it really is also that a culture you create in your news organization where people are sensitive to and aware of a huge range of results from their stories and again the people who support CI are not looking for money or some kind of return they're looking for what we call in the states sort of social justice journalism yeah any public service and you would have heard this already in your time in Australia of course we don't have anything like the level philanthropy that you do in the States but then we have much more impact and much more inputs from the government sector then which causes problematic for you know so I know you know hey you're the newbie here but I'm interested in your take on this in terms of how do we get people in the private sector to put their hand in their pocket and support journalism well I think that's tough and I do think you know the tax laws and the states mean as you said that somebody supports us or the foundation that's a job to give away money individuals it's a tax break I think it's you really it's an education process and I think you know depending on your point of view politically in the States right now is to press the enemy of the people or is the press the saviour of the republic because for an authoritarian historically you know they take over or coerce you know the judiciary the legislative law enforcement and the press and in the United States right now one could argue that the depending again on your political point of view the biggest opposition the thing that may be slowing down Donald Trump more than anything is the press so when you can articulate that and also explain to people historically the control of information in any society is one of the most crucial things in terms of the good for a democracy you explain it that way and I think the other thing that's really important is to talk about the risks that journalists take you know we saw this we you know the imprisonment of two journalists in minimar yeah we're just journalists journalists are killed around the world doesn't happen much in the United States but it's a profession where people really believe they're serving the public and also like the military law enforcement in different ways they're actually targeted and eliminated in prison because of the job they're doing so I think those are all part of the message that I try and tell people in whites worth it and for many people that cuts across political lines sure absolutely I guess it's an interesting conundrum because I'm not sure if we want to elect a Donald Trump to reinvigorate the news media in this country I wouldn't advise it but nonetheless your point is well and I think the point you make that to to reinvigorate the news media we have to tell the stories that the news stories would not exist without journalists basically yeah and administrations you know prior to the internet always try to control the message it's just you know but the acceleration and the ability through these social feeds and other tools really have created a whole other dynamic and I think you alluded to earlier sort of I think the rules have changed you know I this is a maybe an analogy that will annoy or make some of your listeners unhappy or they may agree with it I frequently think about and it's not that extreme in the states but it's getting there or it's dangerous you know if I was a journalist in let's say Nazi Germany in the 1930s or 20s what would you have done and in that case what the Nazis did is they basically killed or imprisoned people stood up to him we're not at that point but you sort of alluded to that earlier what what do we do and I'm not saying we're there in the states but when you have a leader who plays loose with the facts and is so volatile and stirring up people it's really potentially setting the stage for violence and I think that's really the great danger here that in the US is highly divided right now and what happens in the next few months is anybody's bet absolutely I'm just gonna stick we're gonna come back to that in a couple seconds but I did want you know like me I probably have a lot of you know experience under your belt what do you tell younger journalists when they what do you say younger people when they say they want to be a journalist well there's two things one of you know we have I really love working with the younger generation because for me personally it's like giving giving back because I had great opportunities when I was in my 20s getting into journalism today is completely different than when we started but at the same time there's a lot more opportunities because of the nature of distribution you know even three or four people getting together or a couple of people are one person being able to write a story tell a story well you can get distribution you can potentially get audience I'm not sure how you make money but there are different models now being created in the states you know this is very vigorous but small nonprofit sector where there are hundreds of journalists employed who may be new to the game or came out of corporate media but that's something that is a positive doesn't offset the loss of you know corporate media but their new models being created and I think one of the key things right now is how you work together with others who have skills collaboration both internally and externally to reach an audience and I do think the role and I differentiate between media and journalists because there is a role for the journalists globally and I mean as you do a lot of people from around the world who are journalists and it's a journalist are people who are generally passionate creative people who really believe in making a difference in trying to serve their society so I think it's a very important role and we have to figure out to keep it going absolutely and just yeah that difference that you make between media and journalists is actually very a valid one for everyone really you make a difference between in essence people comment on making opinion the Fox News NBC as well versus reporters that basically where you draw the line is blurred and the other thing right now and there's always been even in the states you know actually when the United States started the newspapers were basically created by the political leaders and they were pure propaganda and we had something called the Alien and Sedition Act to stop that and really what it was is that President Adams you know didn't like the people who were criticizing him he tried to put him in jail sounds dissimilar but yeah I think the media to me has been blurred a lot by opinion talking heads and you know I'm sure you have it here I know you have it here in Australia the same thing where you it's basically point of view point of view opinion opinion opinion and their speculation and it almost doesn't mean anything it's the Philly airtime and I think from many people in the public everything is blurred and they're hearing people say things and they take it as fact and it really undermines the best journalism because people just confused and but I also want to say one thing that you know I don't want to sound elitist but there are always people there's always been the case it's not something new it's not bad and when I mentioned earlier the extremes are going to believe whatever their point of view they're going to believe it no matter what they're entrenched so where how big is the middle you know and what is that group of people actually going to do sure absolutely always about that tell me about your views about the Google Facebook we've never seen a lot of unprecedented attention to Facebook and Google they're back in the having Senate hearings again or Facebook and Twitter or not Google you know the debate in this country very similar to what's happened in your country and there's a lot of resentment in the news media the publisher level and journalists level that they took the money basically and then they kind of weaponized crap and fake news and that sort of stuff and yet at the same time as you know we're both in that meeting today you know Google's in that meeting Google's has a lot of supporting news journalism Facebook likewise Twitter is the amplification arm of not only the present lots of good people use Twitter so where do we draw what do we show should we think about this well I think you know we're in this moment if you go back 20 years none of this existed which is you think about this tiny window of time that this disruption has happened as well as you know the devices that were all in a sense instant publishers and receivers and the distraction so I think it'll be fun to come back in 50 or 100 years and sort of sweet how this sorts out I think you know these models it's not simply Facebook and Google and Twitter that have you know eviscerated the newspaper industry you know it was the fixed cost you know I I'm sort of not sure where it's all going I do think that those companies need to figure out how to if they really care about society to get more money into the quote journalism they're also from my own experience in talking to them they do not understand journalism and they're a little afraid of it especially investigative reporting but I think they're trying to really figure this out and and do you think they want to understand journalism I think they would like to but again from my own experience this this just they don't get it and and talking to the people there they come from a whole different background engineering they're not necessarily the thing about how do I say this they come from a culture in a world where the goal was revenue make it scale and make as much friggin money as possible and be as monopolistic as you can. And that is a dangerous recipe as far as I'm concerned in one that I saw which led to help lead to the collapse in a lot of ways of quality journalism because it was never about the work for the people who controlled the purse rings it was about you know as I said earlier profit so those values I think have to shift and the ability to turn to do public service let's call it public service journalism that's what I call it in a non-partisan way is something they really have to understand and I think this is an education process I mean I think that the genie came out of the bottle and the people who created those companies had really no idea where we go in terms of the evil or the abuses that we've seen it was all like wow this is great and I think there's a huge learning curve and you know candidly they were created by some really really brilliant people who were young and I frequently said this they were brilliant people who had no wisdom.

Smart but not wise. Yeah. And very little life experience and I think that's what we're seeing going on here. We're watching them grow up live now.

Yeah. We'll catch all our lives indeed. Let's just return to the Woodward book as a final moment. I was very interested in the Washington Post released the transcript of a phone call between Woodward and the audio you can hear.

And the audio between Woodward and Trump in which the president says he didn't know they'd been asked for the interview from Woodward and seems sort of resigned to another bad book about himself coming out and at the end of that transcript Woodward ends the call by saying something which I found a little jarring although well intrinsically American he says to Trump I quote I believe in our country and because you are our president I wish you good luck. So I guess my question is is there no limit to US patriotism? I think there is a limit. I think it's just it's such a hot button subject politically.

Do you think Trump is the limit? Well I think yes I think right now as I said earlier you know there are millions and millions of Americans who are angry embarrassed and that's always been the case. I mean it's not like me. I mentioned when we started talking you know when I was young guy I mean the Vietnam War and there are millions and millions of people in the streets and the divide around that and the violence.

I mean we had a group called the Weather Underground and mainly white they were blowing people up and trying to and the Black Panthers I mean again this volatile stew and we've had this in the past and I think that but the cudgel of you're not patriotic or protecting the flag this whole episode we're having you know we've got football players American football players taking a knee it's just again it's about the political divide and so tell me if you were on the phone to Trump would you say I believe in our country because you're our president I wish you good luck. I would say I believe in the best American values and I wish you would respect them. And on that note well Rose and L I thank you so much for being on the fourth state with me Peter Frey and my British earthly doctoral tonight. I'm going to put in a big plug for Reveal it's a fantastic resource a great fantastic news site and fantastic podcast every week yeah.

Yeah it's called Reveal News.org if you want to hear it. Yeah I strongly recommend it on anyone in journalism and in best journalism in particular. Yes have a great rest of stay and we'll see you in the US and all I can say is keep up the great work. Thank you for being on the fourth state.

Thank you for inviting me. Thank you Australia. A safer Ontario means more police and prosecutors making sure my car doesn't get stolen. It means building new jails to keep criminals behind bars.

And it means there's no need to wear me when I play at the park. We're making every corner of Ontario safer to make all of Ontario safer. That's how we protect Ontario. For all of us.

Learn how at Ontario.ca.ca. Pay for by the government of Ontario.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 37 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on September 6, 2018.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.