Skip to content
Rod Sims on the Digital Platforms Inquiry episode artwork

Jul 29, 2019 40 min

Rod Sims on the Digital Platforms Inquiry

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

ACCC has just released 619-page report on the power and impact of digital platforms on Australian media. To help us make sense of the report but to also see what it could mean for our media we have a special in-depth discussion with the chairman of the ACCC, Rod Sims.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Rod Sims on the Digital Platforms Inquiry

0:00 40:57
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome. You're listening to Fourth Estate, the show where journalists talk journalism, coming to you from TSCR in Sydney on Gadigal Lands of the Aura Nation, right across Australia on the community radio network and directly to your device across the globe via Comcast. My name is Peter Frey and I am the co-director of the Centre for Media Transition at the University of Technology Sydney and my producer today is the Ever-One for Anthony Dokrull. As I just said, normally on the show we talk to journalists about journalism.

But today we are making an deception and talking to someone who has spent considerable time recently talking and listening to journalists and media executives and it's been no idle chat. He's enquiries going on for over a year and a half and resulted in a hefty, rich and perhaps even glorious 619 page reports on the power and impact of digital platforms, namely Google and Facebook, on the news business, the conduct of journalism and the media market. I guess today is Rod Sims, the Chairman of the National Competition Regulator at the ACCC and that's the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission. Hello Rod.

Thanks Peter. Hello and thanks a lot. Like a description of the report. Thank you.

Well it is all that and a lot more. I should say quickly that you haven't only been talking to journalists and their bosses. You've had numerous industry consultations and received about 180 submissions. So no one could ever accuse you and your team of skimping on the task.

So sincerely congratulations on the report which is a big meaty read especially as you suggested the other day in one sitting with alcohol which I try to do that sadly failed. Anyway. You could have had more alcohol. So by way of disclosure, disclosure I should say that the centre which I co-directed some consulting work for the ACCC for this report and that it has also received research funding from Facebook and Google.

So I guess that shows where highly entirely compromised or entirely balanced. I'll go balanced. Thank you. Before we get to the recommendations Rod, can I ask three broader questions?

So you spent considerable time in the belly of the beast that is news media this last year and a half. So what did you take from that? What's the view from in there? Just how challenged is Australian journalism?

I think very challenged but it does depend where and who you are. So there's a geographic dimension and there's a mode dimension. So the geographic dimension is local media being in the regions or metropolitan areas has traditionally particularly printed completely dependent on advertising and that's what's of course most unchallenged and whereas the city papers, the big city papers can move to subscription or in the case of the Guardian get donations which are doing quite well. In the local areas they just don't have either of those options.

Just to get to that point because it's one of the recommendations but just on that point. Do you not think that there's a subscription model in local and regional? I don't think I've got the expertise to say that I hope that is possible. Right at the moment we're seeing a number of closures of local print media and we've got the numbers in the report where a lot of local media no longer exists.

So that's the threat. In terms of mode. If I could just say so. So print is under the most pressure and there's been a significant reduction in journalism but the TV at the moment is not doing too bad but the threat is not far away.

The more that shows that are produced on TV, start to appear on social media perhaps via YouTube or other means then that content can be seen in other ways and the TV companies are less able to control the advertising and less able to monetize it. So that threat I think is coming and of course at the moment radio seems to be relatively okay but things could change quickly. And that's the gist of your report really. In essence this is a treatise on market power and market control.

One of the things that you stop short of recommending was some form of content tax on Google and Facebook to fund journalism. Of course that would have been very popular in media circles and journalism circles. Why did you stop at that? Well we didn't actually.

We and look at the terminology here does get confusing but we've recommended a code of conduct which sounds pretty weak because there's a range of codes of conduct which are not enforceable. There's no penalties if you breach them and completely voluntary. The code of conduct we've recommended here is compulsory, enforceable and large penalties would apply. So what we have in mind is that the digital platforms would be required, the major ones, to provide codes to ACMA, the Australian Communications and Media Authority that addresses their relationships with the media.

And if ACMA is not happy with what it's getting it can impose a standard. So at the end of the day, ACMA can actually impose something on the platforms. And those codes have got to cover data sharing, algorithm ranking changes, fair value sharing and not impede media monetization. So in mentioning fair value sharing in our view that allows the media companies to negotiate with Facebook and Google about that content levy or content fee you just talked about.

And if ACMA is not happy with where that ends up it can impose something. The reason for doing it that way is I don't think we as regulators whether it's the actual CRACMA would know how to, at certainly what level to impose that fee and exactly how to do it. So it's much, this is one of those things which is much better if it's negotiated and then ACMA can come in and arbitrate. Agma needs to have a, just on that point though, Agma does need to have an idea what the fair value is because I mean we're presupposing that the platforms are going to negotiate in good face and we're going to presuppose also that there's a level of taking give on the side of the media companies neither of which we've really seen in the debate so far.

So in the end of the day Agma needs to need a real chief and b a real idea of what is a fair outcome. Yeah. Look that's fair enough but I guess the point I was reacting to is the statement that we didn't recommend a fee for content which I think news limited was seeking amongst others. And as I say we believe we've done the same thing through a different mechanism.

It's there to be heard basically. That's right. I mean I take your point that the party might not be able to agree but I think in listening to what the parties have got to say in getting into the detail of a regulator can then come to a view as distinct from us thinking to impose that upfront. Before we get back to the recommendations I did want to put out there this the first chapter which deals with the rise of the digital platforms and I'd recommend anyone listen to that show.

I don't read the recommendations but also that first chapter because it's quite extraordinary the power reach of Facebook and Google and a population of 25 million the number of the over 19.2 million Australians use Google search a month 17.3 million use Facebook 17.6 watch YouTube that's owned by Google and then point two million access Instagram and by Facebook and that's without checking in WhatsApp which is owned by Facebook. So that's a considerable power in front of us. But can I ask you this aren't these companies creating products which frankly millions of Australians love right is that such a bad thing. I don't think we ever said it was a bad thing.

No we we were pains in the report and of course these sort of things never get reported to point out that there's been enormous benefits from both Google and Facebook they do provide services people value they have been innovative so we're not questioning any of that we are simply saying that their reach is considerable as you just mentioned they're in a very dominant position they clearly have substantial market power and when you have substantial market power that brings other things into play that would not be there if you did not have substantial market power so it brings in the incentive and ability to preference their own businesses preference their own advertising business it also means that they become essential gateways for the media companies but none of the media companies individually are essential for Facebook or Google so there's a very unequal bargaining position so what we're trying to do is remedy all the problems that have emerged because yes they've brought fantastic innovation and many benefits but with that massive power and reach has come a range of problems which need to be addressed. Do you think we've been a little bit asleep at the wheel as they've grown and grown and grown? Well it's not clear what could have been done to do things differently up to this point what we're trying to do is come up with recommendations that deal with the problems and some of this is so difficult to see and complex that it really did take an 18 month study to get to the bottom of it and of course we can only do these sort of studies when government's directors so should government have directed us a couple of years early well you know maybe but I think the key point is the studies out there now are we going to deal with the problem. Fair enough.

Just a slight different angle on Facebook and Google we are a mid-sized country on the other side of the planet from where they are headquartered why are they going to pay any attention to what we have to say? Two things. Facebook and Google are unambiguously doing business in Australia and that test means that they're caught by our act and the act of the privacy commissioner and the act of an actma so they're absolutely caught by Australian regulators and governments can of course legislate to impose things on them. Their only alternative really would be to stop doing business in Australia which I think is a fairly extreme step and the reason I don't think they'll do that and the reason I think the recommendations we've come up with will have further effect is of course where we are liaising very closely with our overseas counterparts and we're right in the middle of all that and our overseas counterparts are going through our report as we speak so there's a range of things happening overseas so I don't think Facebook and Google can ignore what Australia says last time I looked I think we were the 13th biggest economy in the world.

I agree that doesn't make us one or two but it doesn't make us 50th either and the fact that we have a very close linkages with the US, the US, the UK and many countries in Asia for that matter. I think this has got to be worked through and it will be part of what's happening not only in Australia but elsewhere. This is a slightly premature question I suspect but you would be very aware of what's happened vis-a-vis Trump and Macron recently where the French of Sault to Impose restrictions attacks on the platforms and Trump has said how do you attack a US company? Are we running, is that the politics of this that's going to play out?

Look I think issues of transfer pricing have been around for as long as I can remember and where the value is created and where the tax should accrue is one thing and I guess the debate is it's a tax in France or is it a tax in the US and I can understand countries having different views on that but the Department of Justice and the Federal Trade Commission have now moved to set up inquiries into Google and Facebook. I think they asked empathetic to the spread of disinformation to copyright issues. There's definitely a push on in the United States in relation to the effect of digital platforms having on the media. Indeed I've heard reports that suggest the impact on the media in the US is stronger than the impact in Australia.

I don't know that's right but it's certainly happening but certainly an open debate there. So I think all the species in our report put aside the tax issues are ones that are going to be looked at all around the world and I would imagine we're going to get a fair degree of world agreement on these things rather than the sort of difference of opinion you'll inevitably get over tax. Yeah well just as an aside I was in Google land in Palazzo about three weeks ago and all they really want to talk about was what's this Rod Sims guy up to. So I think you have been noticed.

I think you've very much have been noticed. I just want to talk about... I don't know how you answered that one for you anyway. Well I said he's been up to some good work and I'm sure the Google people in this country have been following what you're doing very very closely I'm pretty sure of that.

As I said earlier this is show about journalism so I'm going to talk about the recommendations that really impact on journalism because I would excuse me because there are some really also some really important suggestions in this report about data protection, about previously reforms and improving digital literacy which we might not get to. And there is a potential here and the government says it will respond to the report by the end of the year after a 12 week consultation process though as we would have heard on Friday and through the weekend that these initial responses are very favourable. You're an optimist and realist Rod and I know you can't pre-empt what will happen but how confident are you that this report will bring about lasting change from a government level. Yeah look fairly confident.

The turntable of the government said itself is a fairly ambitious one. I mean yes as you said at the start of this chat we've done a lot of consultation ourselves we've had many many public forums and got many many submissions but I think now that the final recommendations are out there it's quite appropriate for government to consult on them but saying they'll provide a response to the report by the end of the year that's great I really hope they can stick to that turntable. I'm extremely confident that significant change will flow from that report. Whether it all gets picked up or not I don't know but I'm extremely confident that there will be significant change.

Well the time is right isn't it? I mean both on a regulatory sense but also in a political sense. Early in the political cycle the government has made a lot of statements for these things like Christchurch and what have you and of course we have this parallel thing which is obviously not related but parallel thing about media freedom so I imagine the government is very much aware of news media issues at the moment. I think they're very aware of news media issues I think they're also aware of people's concerns over over privacy and that this issue both on media and on privacy is only going to get worse so I think they are aware that now is the time to take some steps.

I should emphasise that the steps we've set up in our report and perhaps this is the lead into where you're going. We believe answers to problems we can see and touch and feel at the moment but they also set up a continuing flow of information so that governments can stay ahead of these issues so this is very much a hugely important beginning of the game but it will play out over a while so I don't want to downplay the recommendations that we're recommending coming to play right now they're very significant when you think of copyright this information on Benjamin on addition in addition to all the things you mentioned and they will go a long way but we will be we and other regulators will be providing government with a continuing flow of information so the government can stay ahead so I think we're in a pretty good place with what we've put together. Well yeah on those points and you did read my mind a recommendation for for instance suggest that there should be a new digital branch within the HPC which is going to monitor and investigate anti-competitive behaviour by the platforms and that that branch is going to hold an inquiry into the supply of advertising technology services. Our attack is a very very whole issue in the news media industry it's not particularly well understood but it really does go to the heart of that sort of question about transparency and by extension into the revenue models.

What's your rationale behind that? What do you want to get out of that inquiry? We want to get more transparency so in the report we've got a very detailed explanation of how ADTIC works and how amazing it is so that when you go on a site that could immediately trigger an online auction that would be done in nanoseconds to sell the ability to advertise to you when you go on a website so it's quite amazing quite impressive but what we don't know which we need to know more about is how much of a cut all the intermediaries are taking so if you as an advertiser say to Google or Facebook here's a hundred dollars please buy me some ads exactly how much of that money gets taken by intermediaries versus results in ads we also don't know whether there's any self-preferencing going on we know this Google dominates a lot of the ADTIC and is a very big presence there so we just want people to know what's going on and the importance of that is that advertisers will get a better sense of where they should be advertising at the moment there's so much they don't know. The other thing with that branch is aside from the ADTIC study it will also be providing regular reports to government and the community on what's going on with the digital platform so that's so there'll just be a continuing flow of information and recommendations if we see new issues that need to be addressed.

Will there have teeth such that the platforms are compelled to actually tell the truth and be driven? That's what we've recommended to government that in a sense they issue us a new direction standing direction so that we've got those proactive information gathering powers that will help us both out enforcement work because we believe there are issues under competition and particularly consumer law with the consumers in this lead which is being provided with unfair contractors but also to get the information for that public reporting. Okay we touched on this earlier but recommendation seven which is the this idea that there's going to be this code of conduct about the platforms treating the content providers or the content makers fairly you've given the platforms and the news media industry nine months to work at this deal. Is there any rationale for that?

Is that there's a random figure I was just a bit curious about that. I think we wrestled with six and twelve right now we added the two and divided by two. On the one hand we don't want this to drag on for too long. On the other hand we want to get engagement so that there's some clarity about what can be done and what can't be done and keep in mind as I said earlier this is more than just a fee for providing or a royalty for providing information.

There can be a range of things that the media companies can negotiate on and they may judge that something's more important. I'll clearly judge that something's more important than others. I'm like trade off and say we want enough time to allow that to occur but as I say we don't want it to last too long. There is a sort of when you talk to media executives and senior journalists there's sort of this sense of anger in a sense.

I think when we look at what's happened to the industry you go back to really when the classifies disappeared from print and that was a massive blow where people would possibly underestimate that. You certainly don't do that in the report I might add. Then we have the platforms. Is there any, I guess what I'm trying to get at is there a sort of golden sum of money in anyone's head about what will it take to make the news media happy about its relationship with Facebook and Google in the order of some of money?

No, look I don't think so. I think I'll be misleading if I made up a number. We have got a range of recommendations which I suspect you're going to get onto which tackle this issue for various dimensions. And should I say a distinction we've made here is this isn't like digital cameras putting Kodak's old film out of business.

This is about journalism which is very much an essential part of our democracy. So Google and Facebook are causing issues for journalism not by replacing it with their own journalism but by operating in such a way that it makes proper journalism difficult to do and that's what we've got to address. Of course Google and Facebook will tell you as I'm sure they've told you. They've told me many times that they're doing a lot to enhance public interest journalism.

They're doing a lot to help publishers. They're doing a lot to fake news, et cetera, et cetera. So what do you make of their solicitations that they're doing good work for journalism? Well, they are doing some things but that's not going to solve the problem.

Clearly not going to solve the problem. One aspect of Facebook and Google is of course they want people on their site. They want to be who you go to to get information so the more they can anonymize news the better because then you can get it from Google and you can get it from Facebook. The media business model of course is all about brands.

News limited, Fairfax or now 9, the real press that they want to be known as places to go. They want to be able to be trusted sources of journalism. And so you've just got a conflict in the business operating model. So I don't think providing a bit of seed funding to help some small new journalism startups is going to do it.

And might I mention that some of the journalism startups that are pure digital natives, they didn't exist until we had the internet. They're struggling big time as well. Which is both sweet and what have you. Exactly.

So whatever Facebook and Google say they're doing they're not that both of these are certainly in a difficult position. And both of these relied very heavily on Facebook. Yeah. Moving on to other bits of the report.

There has been this regional and small publishers innovation package. That's a grant scheme to help innovation in local and regional areas. You're suggesting that this money which is about $20 million should be rolled into a bigger pot and that there should be about $50 million a year there to support reporting on things like local government, local courts, those sorts of things. Can't argue with that of course.

But do you have any thoughts about what needs to happen to make sure that that money is well spent? You need an arm's length body allocation and that's I think entirely possible. This has obviously got to be kept very separate from government. I might add of course the biggest way we support public interest journalism in Australia is the funding of the ABC and the SBS.

And now different people have different views on the ABC and SBS but that is government funding for broadcasting. Now the ABC particularly does great work out in the regions but you need a plurality of views. You need others out there. So the problem with the current package which really came out in our future journalism forum is he talked about innovation.

This isn't about innovation. We just want local news reporting to continue to exist and that's why we've redirected that programme into our programme. We've beefed it up, how much money's enough. Look we don't know but I think let's get on and give this a try and make sure that we've got local court reporting, local council reporting, all sorts of other things that make for a well-informed democracy.

In a similar vein you make suggestions or recommendations to make it easier for journalism to get tax deductible status. Have you asked finance and treasury about that? Has anyone got an idea how big such deductions could end up being? Not that big is the answer.

I don't have the number up on top of my head but we're not talking a very large amount. And keep in mind this is people who need to be donating to effectively, I mean the idea is that journalism would get charity status and that charity is a word in the eye of the beholder. But if you think of the Judith Nielsen $100 million fund, that's one example. Obviously the Guardian seeks donations, that's another but this would mean the tax office would have to check that the people donating don't have any editorial control and that's fundamental.

I mean what we're really saying is journalism needs a new business model or commercial journalism as distinct from public sector broadcasting, commercial journalism needs a new business model. If they can get more support from philanthropy, why don't we encourage that? It's really as simple as that. Well but where this gets a bit tricky of course is there's usually a constraint which are the words public interest journalism.

So now I think we can all agree that reporting on local courts and local councils is a very much public interest function. But what about reporting on the Kardashians or some cat stack of a tree in the Daily Mail or some such? Is that public interest journalism? It is a fine line.

I think it is entirely possible to put a group of sensible people together who can form opinions on those matters and distribute the money in a fair way that's publicly available so everybody can see that it's fair or comment if it's not. I don't think public interest journalism is that hard. I accept there are grey areas out there but I think anybody that would be set up to do this can quickly formulate well this is in this is out and give some clarity and I think it'll learn by doing. I mean it's not hard.

I agree with you. I think we're at get Stricky and I'm picking on the Daily Mail. I don't really want to pick on the Daily Mail because like the Daily Mail all of the publishers have a mixture of content and some of that content obviously clearly is public interest journalism. Obviously, the investigative journalism is the prime example but there's a sliding scale that takes you all the way down to reporting on food and fashion and lifestyle and all those sorts of things which are all part of the mix of those companies.

So that's where it gets tricky now. That is right and that's a judgement that will have to be made. The interest here is to make sure that we continue to have regional and out of inner city metropolitan journalism continuing to function and we judge that $50 million will go a long way to help that happen. As I say we draw that line will be up to that independent body who would be charged with allocating that money and they may well have to make tough judgments in the way you say but I think it's just eminently, eminently doable but we do accept that you know you need to have a fairly full-time definition certainly it's way beyond investigative journalism but it's reporting on facts that are important to the community.

Now again the eyes of a holder but I think it's very doable. Yeah I mean that's a good distinction though isn't it the report. Reporting on facts that wouldn't otherwise come to light and that could be you know the traffic report perhaps. Oh I think the traffic report would definitely if I could say come in there I think you know the cat up the tree might might well as well if it was an important local item of information that people needed to know.

I guess it depends on who cat it is. If it's the mayor's cat it might be important. I think that's right but it's an event going on that if it captures you know people wonder why the fibergates got four trucks at number four smith street again. I don't think it'll slow people down much if we take an appropriate one of the things problem with the innovation fund is it got caught up in the definition of what innovation.

This is I think an easier discussion what's important for the public to know. If you put it that way then I think this is a reasonably stowable problem. I have to confess that I was on the panel of the innovation fund so you have a lot of sympathy from me. I know we could talk all day about this I'm sure you could but you've got another job to do or continuation of your job.

I did want to touch on the recommendations around disinformation so again we're back to industry codes and another key role for Aqma and we are talking about what some people call fake news. In the report there's quite a great discussion about it but do you have a handle on the size of the problem of disinformation or fake news misinformation or whatever you want to call it really it's quite a big agenda there. Do you have a handle on the size of this problem? I think it's huge but we haven't found a way to quantify it but certainly the impact can be enormous as I think we've seen particularly in the UK and the US and it's the more you can get information to target individuals if you can pick off 5% of the population and hit them with wrong information but wrong information they might be susceptible to believing then you've got a serious problem and I think this is where going back to your earlier point of course Google and Facebook are doing some wonderful things but they are effectively data gatherers their whole business model the whole way they make money the whole reason they exist is to get data on you and sell that to advertising but that information is so targeted about you because they want to know everything about you so they add get more bang for the bucks so they can sell the ads for more that's name information can be used if they can work out whether you're amenable to fly to Greece tomorrow they can work out a lot of other things about you and that's where that disinformation becomes so powerful so I think it's a huge problem I can't quantify it but the impact can be profound when that information which is now ubiquitous gets into the wrong hand so we need to control not only what information these platforms can gather but then what can be done with it and how we can have processes to make sure that information is taken down at the moment that's all in the hands of Facebook and Google try contacting Google and Facebook to talk about this when something's running you haven't got a hope so it's got to be better processes to deal with it they would argue that they're not publishers I mean this is an age-old argument now that they're not publishers and they shouldn't be held liable for this spread of disinformation and Google would also say on Facebook you know that there's a kind of a right to know first amendment type style of you know we are here to enhance a debate rather than restrict it where do you draw the line on that one because they have a point I think to a point I don't think they have much of a point really they have created these platforms they they have algorithms that they constantly amend that determines what information you see you can't then wash your hands of misuse of that platform and I think governments all around the world have acted when there's been certain information out there that they don't want so there's all sorts of government laws that that deal with inappropriate things being said now each country can make its own decision on where you draw that line the US might draw a different leader Europe for example in the cases what some people might describe as hate speech what some people may regard as classifications that you put on television programs that cannot be seen at certain times so that's what governments do and if Facebook and Google who have created these platforms who curate these platforms who else is responsible it's not them I mean this is just absurd who else you don't have a track with their arguments on this no I don't I think we've almost run out of time is there anything I've missed I mean there's a lot of miss but is anything else you want to kind of emphasize in this and I've got one more question no I think that covers the main things I was aiming to get across so over you for that last well the last one is the you know crystal ball question so let's fast forward say 18 months maybe two years but 18 months the government has responded positively to your report the platforms of blood in line the journals are getting better funding especially in the regions the tax deductible status just how much rosier will it be to be a journalist in any month's time in this country I hope considerably I have no doubt it will be better how much better is very much a crystal ball but we need journalism it's essential for the proper functioning of our society and of our democracy and you know what I was just talking about in terms of having some control over what is said is in a sense the mirror image it really is important that you have a profession of journalism that is interested in seeking out truth and getting information out there there's no doubt that journalists like the rest of us in society inevitably have their own biases I'm one who reads the Australian and the age every day so I get a balance of opinions because they come at issues in very different ways but I find each of them informative and we need that out there so I think that journalism will be a lot better placed in 18 months I hope a lot better place well that's wonderful note optimistic number of the things thank you so much for your time thank you so much for your report and wish you all the best what's the next step for the report it sits with the government for a while are you kind of done now and you just wait to see what Josh right and working on things I know how the Treasurer mentioned that two things firstly the government has it up for 12 weeks consultation and then I'll make decisions by the end of the year our team that did this work stays in existence and it will help government form views on the report it will be a valuable source of information to everybody in government trying to form that form their views so no we remain extremely active this is not like for example the Productivity Commission which puts out a report and then says okay over you we're out of here we're not going anywhere the ACC is locked and loaded you bet right what seems the chair of the ACC will see the head of the digital platform inquiry thank you so much for your time and for being on Fourth Estate thanks for your just a good thanks and thank you all for listening to the Fourth Estate this edition was recorded at the studios of 2SER and I heard across the country on the community radio network make sure you subscribe to the Fourth Estate on your favorite podcast app so you can hear us talk media politics and a few things in between including talking to people like Rod Sims we'll be back very soon with our next episode but in the meantime you can stay in touch with us on Twitter where our handle is Fourth Estate AU thank you so much to my producer Anthony Bockwell my name is Peter Vary thank you very much for listening.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 40 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on July 29, 2019.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.