Skip to content
Rootless: The Best of 2024 episode artwork

Dec 19, 2024 23 min

Rootless: The Best of 2024

from Tablet Studios Hosted by Tablet Magazine

It’s been a whopper of a year: Israel at war with Hamas and Hezbollah, a decisive Trump victory, anti-Semitism on the rise, and formerly great American institution on the decline. Yet as this look back at 2024 in Rootless reveals, we’ve many reasons to be hopeful, at home and abroad. Why? Join us in looking back at the year and find out.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Rootless: The Best of 2024

0:00 23:49
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hey there, it's me, Liel. It's already the month of Kislev, or if you're going by that other calendar, it's December. Which means that the year is almost over and everyone is scurrying away someplace warm to light the menorah or roast chestnuts on an open fire or do whatever it is that we do in this merriest of seasons. So we figured it would only be right to take a little break and give you all a little gift. A fun-sized, best-of-the-rootless podcast for the year.

If you've been with us for a while, you know what to expect. Observations and conversations that are rarely cuddly, often insightful, always essential. Why? Because the times, as a clever Jew once put it, they are a-changing. And because there's nothing sadder than a dumb Jew, and because if you want to figure out what's going on, you better be ready for some real tough talk. What we give you on this show isn't a viewpoint. It's not some partisan hack attempt to convince you that this side is always right or that side is always wrong. No one has the time for that. We are Jews, and Jews from Moses to Joey Ramon have always been outsiders.

The purpose of this show is to ask crucial and disturbing questions like, should we still be sending our kids to college? Or should Israel actually annex parts of Lebanon? Or are we thinking about abortions all wrong? Or how do we go about and unravel a justice system that is now actively thwarting justice on behalf of lunatic radical ideologies? These are difficult questions and to grapple with them, we call on some of the smartest people around, people you will not necessarily hear on any other podcast on earth. So today, we would love to bring you a sample of these voices and we kick things off with Amiyad Cohen, one of Israel's most creative thinkers about why Israel absolutely must seize land unless it wants to fight pointless wars with Lebanon again and again and again. When you want to win a war, you first of all want to prevent the next one.

So winning this one or getting to a ceasefire at the end of this war doesn't help you a lot unless you're the underdog and ready for the next war. If you really want to win a war, you need to prevent the next one. So in 56, we're the underdog and we went with Egypt. We took over the entire Sinai Peninsula and withdrew because of the Americans kicked us out of it. 67, everyone knows we took over plenty of territory. 73, we took over territory until the 101st kilometer from Cairo and 40 kilometers near Damascus. And we negotiated that territory and succeeded us to prevent both ends to the future war, which from Egypt, we didn't have till today. And even with Syria, we don't have till today. Lebanon is different.

In 76, we tried to take to the Litani River, we withdrew back, and then we took to Be'ot in 82, and we withdrew back and kept the perimeter. Now, that's the core of the problem, because they did not lose the war in a way that forced them to surrender and give up in Israel. We didn't build a border like we have the Jordan River, like we had the Suez Canal, or after the deal with the Egyptians. So we had a normal border that's equivalent, and the Syrian border in the Golan Heights, which is a geographical border. So the endgame of the war did not deter, in 82, the Lebanese from soon to the Shiites to deter them to prevent attacking Israel again.

And the second Lebanon war, again, we did not take over land. So we still stuck with the Lebanese Shiites now wanting to attack us again. This war, to prevent the fourth Lebanese war, we have to verify that this victory is the final victory against them. And that will be represented on one hand, surrender. And the second part of it needs to be with a real clear border at the end of the war that will prevent them from attacking us. That border geographically needs to be the Italian river and the occupation of territory to verify that their surrender and loss will be very clear to them. Speaking of the Middle East, we also talked to Tony Badran, Tablet's news editor, about why so many of us have been getting the Middle East so wrong for so long.

So we started this episode by talking about sort of the geographic nature of the Levant and how that has been a determinative or structural factor throughout its history. And I think we have to revive some of the concepts and constructs from the historical geography of the Levant. And that includes, as you noted also in your introduction, you know, the idea of territories and buffer states. So, I mean, we deal with this. We just don't call them that. Like, for instance, Jordan, right? Jordan is a buffer state.

OK, Jordan's function is to stand between Israel and the Shia Iranian realm in southern Iraq and so on against any incursion or from, you know, in the past used to be like Syria, for instance. So basically, Jordan is a buffer state. That's it. It has its values, has its usefulness. But let's not go, you know, it's a buffer state. Well, let's spend another second of this, because, you know, I think a lot of people, if you were raised in, say, Michigan or Illinois or anywhere in the good old U.S. of A, you think, well, what do you mean, sir?

A state is this real thing with a proud people and a heritage and a tradition. You're saying, and I fully agree, no man, this is a complete fictitious creation there to serve one practical purpose and one alone has no other right to exist except for this very limited strategic use it has always had. Right. And the funny thing is that its leadership understands this. Exactly. I mean, that's the hustle. That's the nature of the hustle, right? If you don't pay us, the Iranians will come. You're just kind of stating the obvious. That's your job, your territory that stands between us and something else, right? And Syria.

Same thing. I mean, so, I mean, for the longest time, the Alawite family of the Assad, you know, managed to convince the world or the world convinced itself that somehow Syria is actually not only a real country, it's the beating heart of the region, right? It's like, what are you smoking? What you've been seeing in Syria since 2013 is the real historical manifestation of Syria. which is you know the turks have their own little buffer zone up in the north uh some other power you know i mean for a while there used to be something else but you know the russians have their own base there the americans have their own base there the iranians are kind of everywhere you know for a while israel was trying to do the same in the golan heights jordan maybe also tried to you know in the south east as well on its border that's it it's territory and the states that are affected by this territory or have interest in this territory will take action as necessary to protect their security in this ungoverned territory now americans have the historical capacity to understand this because the american continent at one point was this right when the european powers when spain england france and so on were all battling

on the American continent, and they were using proxies, the Indian tribes, for instance, and other stuff like that. And then we had things until recently in the 19th century called territories, which had a different, you know, relationship to the federal government than other actual states and so on. So this concept is not alien to us. We understand this, right? And in the Levant, it goes back forever, literally to written history, first written history. I mean, you can find documents to that effect. I mean, I studied as far back as the late Bronze Age, so I didn't go much further back, but you can go further back, right? And it's the same pattern. It's the same thing.

Closer to home, we asked Sebastian Gorka, who is joining the incoming administration as senior director for counterterrorism, why so many Americans from so many walks of life went MAGA in November. Whether it's Brexit or whether it's Donald Trump, MAGA and November the 5th, all of this, all of this can be explained in one thing. You don't have to talk about the border or no tax on tips or, you know, the response to October the 7th in the Middle East. One thing, people are fed up with being told they have to be ashamed for loving their country. That's the bottom line. Whether it's working class Brits in the UK, whether it's Americans here, black Americans, Hispanic, I mean, Star County, 93% Hispanic voted for President Trump. That hasn't happened in Star County in Texas since 1783 or something. I mean, 93% Hispanic. And my friend was telling me he's watching interviews from Star County because the mainstream media didn't understand how Hispanic County voted for the white supremacist. And in every interview outside these people's homes, Hispanic voters, there's a stars and stripes flying from the porch. And in fact, there's no connection. The interviewer doesn't understand how, why would a Hispanic voter

have a stars and stripes because they're fed up of being told America is bad. Maybe their granddad came here with nothing, worked himself to the bone. Now they have a house, a small business. And just look, we live in perverse times and you know better than anyone else. We live in the perversest of times where we have an elite, including the vast majority of the bureaucracy who detest the nation of which they are a citizen from the 1619 project on to allowing 12 million illegals into the country. You can't do that unless you truly.

truly detest the nation of which you are a citizen. And this wasn't Kamala or Biden. Remember what he said three days before the inauguration. Obama said, I will fundamentally change this nation. We are days away from a fundamental transformation. You do not transform fundamentally that which you love. You only do it to that which you hate. And when a New York jury acquitted Daniel Penning, a former Marine, of all charges in the death of Jordan Neely, a mentally ill man who was menacing bystanders on a crowded subway car, we caught up with the Manhattan Institute's Nicole Galinas to talk about what is so broken with our legal system and how we could fix it.

They can be reformed and we've done it before. This is just a matter of political will. And also the public just genuinely maybe not understanding a few years ago what these progressive changes would mean. I mean, they were sold as we put too many people, we give too many people a criminal record for possessing a small amount of marijuana. We shouldn't give them a criminal record for that. We put people in jail for jumping to turnstile. We weren't actually doing that. But this was the argument that, you know, you don't want to saddle people that just did an unfortunate thing with the criminal record and keep them getting a job. People say, oh, you know, that's probably true. Most people, I think they didn't think this meant.

You could shoplift, you know, dozens and dozens of times from the same store and just face no repercussions. Or if you hold someone up with a gun and you don't shoot them, you know, we're not going to prosecute that crime as aggressively. I mean, it's kind of a bait and switch. And I think people are realizing the bait and switch. Now, with the Penny case, I kept a very open mind. I've written a lot about the rise in subway crime over the past four years. You know, we've had the subway homicide level has risen fivefold.

in the past four years relative to the level between 1997 and 2019. We used to have one or two murders a year on the subway. We've had more than 30 homicides on the subway since the spring of 2020, so a massive increase. But I never took a position on was Penny guilty or not guilty. I wrote a lot of things about it that the city should have prevented this by keeping Neely in secure mental health care because the city knew of Neely's. He had been hospitalized a thousand times. He had 42 arrests.

People in the hospital said he should be in restraints because he had potential for violence. So the city clearly failed here. But I figured, you know, OK, the city failed, but we don't know if Penny also failed. So let's see what came out during the trial. But I think it's fair to say that the jury made the right decision. I think we're beginning to see the change, you know, some signs, including multiple cities and states across the country pulling back on this leniency when there are referendums saying we don't want to decriminalize drugs anymore. We see the result of that, including on the people who are addicted to drugs.

It just takes a very long time in New York because our political system is, it is not optimal. I mean, you have low turnout races. Most people tend to blame the mayor for everything when much of this comes from the state legislature. Most people don't know who their state lawmaker is. They're not sure how the lawmaker voted on these particular issues. These are low turnout races. You have a governor who's very, she's not very good at controlling the legislature. So it's just taking a long time, much longer than it should. But I think you see the frustration in Trump.

increasing his share of the city vote. I mean, to go from 9% to 18% of the Manhattan vote, and that's pretty significant. And I think you see some of it in the jury results today. I think the jury did its job. It didn't do this based on political considerations, but they live in the real world. I mean, if you're taking the subway every day, you see, you use your own common sense. I mean, you're asking Penny to behave perfectly in a situation that the city should have avoided.

We also asked legendary publisher and editor Adam Bellow to explain to us why American publishing, once the beating heart of American culture, the cultural industry that put out giants like Adam's father, Nobel laureate Saul Bellow, had gone, had become a hotbed of not just mediocrity, but raging anti-Semitism. All right, let's get under the hood because we're talking about sociological phenomena. So one thing that I would say is that because I have worked at all these places, 35 years, and they've changed dramatically. They changed from the top down and from the bottom up. Now, one of the things that changed, so I indicated earlier that there's a great deal of merger and acquisition activity. And one of the things that happened was that in the course of the, let's say the 60s, 70s and 80s, publishing went from being an agglomeration of independently owned, small, basically family owned companies to being.

communications conglomerates, corporate entities, usually owned by foreign corporations, by the Germans. But the German ownership really wasn't onerous. The problem was the corporatization. In other words, the type of people who led these companies. Because I think that ultimately the problem is a problem of leadership.

The people who led the companies, the large companies, when I was a young editor coming up, were real book people. They were really committed. They were principled. They were committed to freedom of speech. You had people like Bob Bernstein at Random House who published Sakharov and the Russian Refuseniks. He sponsored many important black writers. He was a leader in the industry. Other great figures, Roger Strauss, for example, and other people who I looked up to and admired who would not have put up for one minute with a revolt from the woke junior staff.

those people would have been fired. When I was a young person in publishing, you sat and listened to your elders talk about what we were going to publish. The decisions that were made at that time were based on lengthy experience and understanding what people actually want to read. And you have to have that kind of feel for things. How wonderfully undemocratic. Yeah, it was aristocratic. Publishing, of course, originally was aristocratic. When publishing in America started in Boston in the 19th century, it was a purely Brahmin enterprise. The people who ran those publishing houses decided what the rest of us should read. That was their role and their function. Well, one thing that happens when there's a change from family ownership to corporate management is that the sense of legacy and identity tends to disappear. And this is just a natural process. I was part of a company that was...

absorbed by Simon and Schuster. And then later we absorbed Random House. And what happens is that the incentive structure changes for editors. You're part of a bureaucratic system and you're no longer in an artisanal. you know, role. It's a very different thing. It's metrics-based. It's metrics-based, and you are rewarded for, you know, the terms of success change. And so very, almost imperceptibly, like iron filings lining up with a magnet, you change the way you think about what you're going to publish because you think more in terms of unit sales than you do in terms of the kind of books that you want to be identified, your taste in books. The management, also the change in management means that the people who run these big companies are judged on a quarter-to-quarter basis. They cannot afford to have more than one bad quarter.

If they have two bad quarters with too much red ink, they're fired, right? So that conditions their thinking. Whereas, you know, Roger Strauss, one of the founders of Farrar Strauss, didn't think that way. He was willing to invest in long-term value. He signed up people who he thought would win the Nobel Prize and did. That's what a publisher used to be. Now they just throw money at people who have a platform.

But the show isn't always ripped from the headline. Sometimes we dive deeper into timeless conversations that are still very timely, like the one we had with Erica Pellman, who runs the Jewish Unplanned Pregnancy Support Network, Shifra, about how we can better think about and respond to abortion. And if you look at the numbers right now, if you say that Jewish women have the abortion rate of just sort of white women, non-Hispanic white women in general, that's 6,000 abortions per year. And if you assume Jewish women have... the basic birth rate of American women, which is 54 for a thousand a year. That means that more than 10% of the babies that are being born, there's babies that are being born. And of those, we always, people think about, you know, the really extreme and tragic circumstances of rape or incest, but 96% of the time abortion is not because of that. Abortion is because of emotional pressure, social pressure and financial pressure. These are things that are not fixed. You know, when you look at a situation, you look at a crisis is, you know, I can't afford a baby right now. I can't handle a baby right now. What part of it is fixed and what part of it is fluid?

If you view I can't afford a baby right now is fixed, then the only answer, since most people unfortunately are not open to adoption, is abortion. If you view I can't handle a baby right now is fixed, then the problem becomes the baby and therefore the solution becomes abortion. But if you look at the same situation, you said I can't afford a baby right now. What's fluid is I can't afford it. That's something that with health, with services, that can change. So I can't afford a baby and I can manage it, but I can't handle a baby right now. That's something that can change. I can get parenting skills. I can get the counseling I need. I can build the social network that I need. It's not fixed.

We had many more amazing conversations and we look forward to many more conversations to come and to having you join us. We will be back early in January. Until then, happy Hanukkah, Merry Christmas, and we'll see you again in 2025. We hope you enjoyed this episode of Rootless. We will be back next week with more much-needed real talk. Rootless is a production of Tablet Studios. The show is hosted by me, Leah Leibowitz. Our executive producer is Courtney Hazlitt. The show is produced and edited by Josh Cross, Quinn Waller, and Leah Dunn. If you want to let us know what you think about this show or have ideas for future guest episode topics we should cover, drop us a line at podcasts at tabletmag.com.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Tablet Studios?

This episode is 23 minutes long.

When was this Tablet Studios episode published?

This episode was published on December 19, 2024.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Tablet Studios episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.