Welcome to PivotPoint. Success is a journey. PivotPoint is a podcast of Taylor for Success, a nonprofit organization that seeks to empower job seekers to achieve economic self-sufficient. My name is Liz Hart, and I'm the founder and executive director of Taylor for Success.
If this is your first time listening to the podcast, thank you. Make sure to like this podcast and hit subscribe so you don't miss a new episode. If you've been listening for a while, thank you for coming back, and welcome again to PivotPoint. Success is a journey.
According to Indeed's career guide, the top interview question is, can you tell me about yourself? Not surprising. But think about why do they ask this? Interview was asked this to learn more about you as a candidate and to assess how you're different from other candidates.
There are different ways to ask this question. Tell me about yourself. For instance, an interviewer could say, I have your resume in front of me, but can you tell me more about yourself? Or, I'd love to learn more about your journey.
They could also ask you, tell me a little bit more about your background. They could ask, can you describe yourself? And lastly, they could say, tell me something that's not on your resume. Now, for many years, I have advised job seekers to answer this in a way that brings it back on the interviewer to get more specifics as to what they're looking for.
Saying something like, I'd love to. Could you be a little bit more specific? What specifically do you want to know? And so forth.
Recently, I had a conversation that changed my view of how to answer this question. Welcome back to PivotPoint. My name is Liz Hart and I'm the founder and executive director of Taylor for Success. And I haven't done one of these in a while, but this is sort of like a coffee break.
And I want to give a little background to this one and how it came about. So today I have an HR professional with me. So I'm talking with David, who is an employment and staffing operations manager. He has many years of HR experience.
He is certified by the Society of Human Resources Management. He has certifications in veterans at work and employing abilities. And he is going to share his expertise on interviewing and answering interview questions. We were having a conversation about a typical interview question that I answer in a certain way and have for many years and recently discovered that I could actually be wrong in my answer.
So the question was, when you're in an interview and the interviewer asks you, tell me about yourself. Now, for several years, I have been given the advice of that's too broad a question. You need to get the interviewer to focus on a particular area. And it was also one of the ways that I would advise people to shift the conversation back on the interviewer.
Okay. And I would say, well, that's a very, so when the question is asked, tell me about yourself, I would say, I'd love to. It's a pretty broad question. What specifically would you like to know?
And that is built on the premise that they have your resume in front of them. And so they're not really asking about your background. However, I heard recently in a meeting that I was on that people, interviewers don't like that question. And there's a lot of pitfalls.
So I asked David, um, is my response a good one? And you we got into this long conversation about why saying that could potentially be a pitfall for an interviewer because you don't want to ask personal questions, right? So David, am I summing that up? Correct.
Yeah. By the way, thank you for having me. Um, so you bring up, you bring up several great points. So historically, the interview was used to ask just as kind of an icebreaker question, tell me about yourself.
And we are living in a much more litigious society these days, especially now when it comes to hiring and things along those lines. And so the couple of problems with tell me about yourself is that oftentimes the candidate doesn't fully understand what type of answer you're looking for. And your response is about when you do get the tell me about yourself question, directing it back to the interview to ask, well, I'd love to tell you about myself. What areas would you like to know about type of idea?
And I think that's pretty pretty much the summary of what you said. The problem is, is that candidates will respond to the tell me about your self question and they will go into their life stories. And the problem with that is is that more often than not, the professional life is rarely touched upon in that tell me about your self question. And as that moves forward and the answer and more and more come out from the candidate's answer, they will start telling you personal issues.
They will start telling you things about, you know, sometimes you may hear things about their family or whatever it might be. And whether this candidate is a good candidate for the role or not a good candidate for the role, it kind of handcuffs the interviewer and the interview team that if you decide not to move forward with this candidate is the select candidate, conceivably that candidate can come back to you and say, you decided not to hire me because I mentioned to you that I am X, whatever it is, whatever their interest might be, whatever their answer might have been on a personal side of things. So what I do is I always recommend to my hiring managers. Let me go back to this for a quick second.
So what is an interview? I think we need to understand a little bit. And this is where most interviewers do not understand this. And most candidates don't understand this is, first of all, an interview is the opportunity for the candidate to tell the prospective employer about themselves and about their work history, their knowledge, skills, abilities, and how they would fit into that position that they've applied for.
So basically it's a conversation between it's a conversation, exactly, but it's also an opportunity for the employer to sell the company or sell the position. So a good interview should be a two-way conversation. So it's both the employer and the candidate selling themselves and letting people know about letting the interview team know about themselves, the company, whatever it might be. And the other piece of information that most people don't understand is the majority of interviewers who interview really don't know how to interview.
And one of the earliest tells that you can tell when an interviewer is not well schooled an interview, it is when they do ask that question, tell me about yourself. So a strong candidate like yourself would come back and say, I'd love to tell you about myself. What would you like to know about? And that opens up that opportunity for a more professional response.
We recommend to our hiring managers and I recommend to our hiring managers is to be very specific about the question. So basically, we've crafted a question that says, tell us what interests you in this position and what unique qualities and skills you will bring to the role. And that is a great, I believe that's a great icebreaker question. And in probably 90% of the interviews that I do and I'm involved in a lot of them, that's a question I use.
It doesn't matter what the role is. If it's an integral level role to a CFO role, CEO role, whatever it might be, it's a type of question that sort of gets a little bit of information from the candidate so that they can start to highlight some of their professional knowledge skills and abilities and when they come from a little bit of their background from a professional side effects. Okay. But the candidate would need to give more of an answer than just to elevate a speech pitch, right?
Absolutely. Yes, it's an opportunity for a candidate to really kind of give maybe a three or four minutes synopsis on their professional career and how they basically how they ended up where they are sitting across from you or your interview panel at this particular opportunity. Thank you. That was a great answer.
And I want to go back a little bit about what an interview is. And I always like to describe it as a dating situation. You know, you're trying to get to know each other a little bit. And as a person who manages many hiring managers, two questions.
Do you give your hiring managers training on how to interview someone? And do you talk about how they can sell the company to the candidate? Yeah. So that both of those questions are great questions.
And the answer to both of those questions is yes. So in human resources, it really is our responsibility to train our hiring managers as best as we can on the interview process. The hiring process overall. And you know, really the first part of the very early part of the hiring process is being able to review candidates and determine which candidates may or may not be potentially right for the position.
So that builds your interview pool. And so once you're able to once you're able to gather an interview pool that you think you've got you've got qualified candidates to bring in for interviews. And obviously the next step would be setting up those interviews and then also creating an interview, a series of interview questions. And one thing that hiring managers in many cases make a mistake on is they will try to ask too many questions in an interview.
And which depending upon the role will depend upon the number of questions that you're going to ask. We best practice that we tell our hiring managers for entry level to maybe medium level positions, usually somewhere between 10 to 12 questions. And interviews generally should run anywhere from say 30 to 45 minutes. Again, once again, depending upon the role.
The other thing is as the role is higher in the organization, then you would you know, you would ask more questions, you might ask more knowledge, skills, and ability questions. You know, it depends. But one thing that we try to tell our hiring managers that for a fair number of roles that they're trying to hire for, again, once again, depending upon the level of the role, generally wanted to be was enough. And you should be able to determine the appropriate candidate within 10 or 12 questions after you've interviewed the individuals that you want to bring in.
We also try to tell our managers we try to help craft questions for them. And we also and the method that we use the method of questioning that we're using right now. And it's very popular. And it's it seems to be getting the best answers are behavioral behavioral based questions.
So it's basically tell me about a situation when you dealt with a upset customer or again, they all have to be crafted around the role that you're doing, but they should all be behaviorally based so that the interview we have a candidate can say, well, there was a particular situation when I encountered a client that was not happy that we were late on getting a project in or whatever it might be and how would and how that and how that client and I'm sorry, how that candidate answered and took care of that particular situation. So that is that that's really a way of getting some in-depth understanding of how they may respond to situations at your organization when they come when they come across. And the other thing that we teach our managers is, and this is always the big one and you would be shocked at some of the questions to get asked about what questions not to ask. Right.
Good point. Right. I mean, the obvious ones are, you know, are you planning to have a family? Yeah, we have how old are you?
I mean, and today's day and age, it just it boggles the imagination, honestly, that people are still asking these questions. I mean, different questions that we've said, are you married? Do you have a plan on having children? We'll take care of your children while you're at work.
Is English your first language? Really? Are you a U.S. citizen?
What country are you from? All of these questions are, they're just outright illegal questions to ask. And this is how companies and organizations and interviewers get themselves into trouble. What is your religion?
What church do you go to? Do you have any disabilities? All of these types of things will get an organization into pot water, if the candidate is offended and they want to pursue something along those lines. But it also gives your organization a bad reputation because with social media and all of these social media platforms and blogs and everything else, it doesn't take long for a negative reputation for your organization to get out there.
And it gets picked up so, so quickly. Yeah. So that brings me back to my question about selling the company. You know, when you're interviewing someone, you talk about the benefits of working for your company and so forth.
Is that difficult to do? Or I guess the question is, what questions do the candidate ask? To show that they've done their research, but not just surface level research? Exactly.
So as you know, from career coach and you and I have met, you and I have worked with hundreds of clients that have come in through tailored for success or from other organizations that I've been a part of, one of the things that we always tell our clients, which generally are going to be candidates for a role somewhere, whatever organization or company or what have you, is that prior to an interview, you the candidate need to do your homework. So I mean, everything is available today on the web. So you can go out, you can, there's, I don't think there's a company out there today that doesn't have a website or a Facebook page or a, or a, some type of, some type of social media or presence one way or the other. So you need to spend some time as a candidate, you need to look that stuff up, you need to find out what does the company do?
You need to really read go in depth on the job description, because if job descriptions are written properly, they will, they will give you almost all the information that you need to know, certainly about that role, but also will give you some insights into the organization. Many job descriptions today will also list or have links to comprehensive benefits, so that you can go in and you, and you know, you can go in and check out what the benefits are. But what we also do with our hiring managers and with our, and I'm lucky because I have a talent acquisition team that also works in our organization, they can prepare hiring managers and hiring teams. What are points that you want to make sure that you touch upon when it's your turn to sell the company and sell the organization to the candidate, because the simple fact of the matter is, is that any candidate that you're interviewing, more than likely is hopefully they're currently employed, because as you know, it's always easy to find a job when you have a job, and that, and, and, and we've been doing this long enough list, and you know this, you can tell when somebody's unemployed, and because it's just that air of desperation.
Right, during the headlines. Exactly. And good interviewers will pick up on that in a minute. So then naturally, especially in today's economy, why aren't you currently employed?
What happened? Where have you been? What's been going on? And the other thing is, is that even when you get down to the point of selecting a candidate and offer, you have to also understand that more than likely you're not the only offer that candidate has on the table.
Yeah. So the, so that, that really enhances the reason why you need to be able to sell the key points of your company. It might be your benefits, it could be retirement plan, it could be, it could be tuition reimbursement, it could be, you know, a robust out of office opportunities between time and time and holidays, or all of the above for them. And organizations, their benefits need to be competitive with everybody else's in order to attract good, in order to crack it down.
Yeah. We'll help the hiring manager prep a sheet. And we've even done, we've even done that when you're leaving on the interview, I'd like to leave you with, these are some of the benefits that we offer here's a link that you could go to to get more, more, more information about our benefits. All of our job postings will have a link to what we call our comprehensive benefits so that they can go in so the candidates can go in and they can see what types of medical insurance that we provide, what types of dental vision, all of that type of stuff that we provide and other additional, additional benefits to joining our organization.
That's really great because I remember back in the day, you'd have to search that information out yourself or wait to get an offer to find out that information. So I think that that saves a lot of time. So my last question for you is, what type of questions do you like candidates to ask you as an interviewer? So I really, so there's always the, I call this the one candidate, candidate interview, traditional question.
And it's in some form or another, and I haven't had to do one in a while. So I have a little choppy on it, but basically, is there anything more that you need to know about me or go back to the interview team and say, did I, is there any additional information you want to know, depending upon what that answer is or regardless of what that answer is, what are the next steps in this process? So those two types of questions really will, if it's a good interview, that increases that dialogue a little bit more. So the interviewer, I've also asked, depending upon how the interview goes, I've also asked, based on my responses to your questions, do you see any, what do you think of my strong points?
What do you think might be my weak points? And how do you think I would fit in to your team in this particular role? Very few interviews will answer that question, because they're afraid to answer that question. Sometimes they're just not sure, but that is a really great question.
But you can't ask questions about like, so what does your company do? If you don't know by now, and you have done your research, that's just showing that you're not, you're not well versed in what's going on. You never ask questions about, so how much vacation time you offer, you never ask salary questions. Those are the simple questions.
How many breaks do I get during the day or something along those lines? And those are all, you know, you don't see those in all level roles, but we still see them occasionally come up. Yeah, I mean, it sounds simplistic, but it happens all the time that people ask these questions. And again, it depends on the level.
And I think if I'm hearing you correctly, basically, what you're saying, the two questions that you like, is that for the interviewee to ask, is you're basically asking the interviewer, is there anything in my background, what we talked about, et cetera, et cetera, that would prevent you from offering me this position, right? Exactly. You would mention to me at one point about another question. This is a bold question for a candidate.
But sometimes, depending upon how that interview is going and how that dialogue is going, you can flip it back to the interviewer or the interview panel and say, how did, so tell me a little bit about how you got to where you are today. Because who doesn't like to talk about themselves? Yeah, the great one. And the other thing that we always want to remind our candidates, and I know you do it, I know I do it all the time.
And even for my interview teams, I always tell candidates, it's okay to take notes. Yeah. Okay. And I've also told candidates that there's nothing wrong with having some predetermined questions written down, because let's face it, everybody is on high anxiety and an interview.
Yeah. And so if there are two or three questions that you have, that you just want to ensure that you don't forget, there's nothing wrong with having those written down in your portfolio or whatever you happen to bring. And, you know, today we see so many virtual interviews. So all you're seeing right now is just our shoulders up.
I've got notes right here that I'm looking at. Yeah. Yeah. So just to remind myself to bring things up.
So there's nothing wrong with that. Right. Right. Yeah.
That's a good point. I thank you for your wisdom and your insight from a interviewer's perspective. I wonder, would you come back and talk about because I know we've had many conversations over resumes and when you look at resumes and things like that, you may or may not do that as much as you used to, but just some things that people should be aware of in their resumes. Absolutely.
I would love to do something on resumes and more so now today, because resumes need really need to be tailored to the position. I call it resume living document. Okay. And what I mean by that is that for every role that you apply to, your resume should focus on that role.
It should just not be one general resume. That's a whole lot of discussion. That's a whole lot of discussion. All right.
Well, David, thank you for your time and thank you for your insight. I'm sure the listeners are going to enjoy it and we will definitely talk soon. Thank you for listening to Pivot College, a podcast of Taylor for Success. Taylor for Success is a nonprofit organization that empowers job seekers to become economically self-sufficient by providing resources, skills, training, and supportive reinforcement.
Since 2000, we have been empowering job seekers to secure employment and advance within their careers. To learn more, I encourage you to visit our website at www.taylorforsuccess.org, where you can sign up for our newsletter, receive services, or volunteer to support our mission. You can also get daily updates by joining our Facebook or LinkedIn group and by following us on Instagram and Twitter. Thank you for listening to Pivot Point.