Skip to content
S4 Ep9: Don’t Be a Jerk, Murderers! episode artwork

Aug 29, 2019

S4 Ep9: Don’t Be a Jerk, Murderers!

from Perhaps It's You Hosted by perhapsitsyou

This week, we've got some advice for all the murderers out there: don't be a jerk! *** >Support the show, get bonus content! www.patreon.com/perhapsitsyou > Special Outro music by Olivia Hinthong >Follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter @PerhapsItsYou, or email us at [email protected]. Perhaps It's You is made with Jetpack Podcast. Full show notes and every episode at https://perhapsitsyou.wordpress.com/

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

S4 Ep9: Don’t Be a Jerk, Murderers!

of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Before we get to our show, here is a podcast we think you're going to love. We were able to capture some fingerprints, but again, same as the DNA. We haven't been able to match that to anybody. He's probably one of the biggest open-hearted people that I knew. But, you know, honestly, he had an addiction too, right? We can talk. There's a possibility here that there were childhood traumas. We're trying to turn every stone to find evidence. This is Genevieve Germain, host of True Crime Real Time. Join me on a bi-weekly dive into the lives of the missing and murdered, available wherever you listen to your podcasts. You'll never know who else you'll meet along the way.

Hello, Mystery Solvers. It's Perhaps It's You. An unofficial Unsolved Mysteries rewatch podcast. I'm Liz. I'm Samantha. And I'm in a mood. I'm a lot less sick than I was in our last episode. You might be. We'd still have Samantha's voice, but maybe you miss her sexy, deep, sick voice. Maybe. I probably will still cough a few times in this episode. The cough is lingering as it does. Ugh. But I'm on the mend. Goddamn, I know. I'm a curse. It is. Do we have any updates? I got jack shit. I got big zero for updates. I don't think I have anything. I mean, I'm just in a state. Surprise, surprise. Like, everything annoys me.

I have no patience today. We all have those days. It seems like they're more frequent recently. Not sure why. Might be something astrological. I don't know. Yeah, maybe. I had a day at work the other day where everyone that came in was so rude and pushy, which this is Minnesota, so that doesn't usually happen. And I was just like, what is going on? Yeah, we always have one or two of those. Today at work, I asked my boss's son, who's about to enter the fourth grade, do you believe in ghosts? Which is just me making small talk, right? And this kid super seriously goes, well, yes, because Einstein proved that energy cannot be destroyed.

Wow. I know. And I was kind of like, that's a solid theory. Holy shit. Yeah. Did this fourth grader just prove the ghosts are real? I think so. Wow. So there's something to think about that that kid is smarter than you.

I feel like every fourth grader is smarter than me. It's an interesting age. It's like some of the time, yeah, because also they're learning all this stuff in school. Their brain is working so fast. And they're watching all the YouTube videos. They just like know fucking everything. But then also, so sometimes it's like, you're like, oh, that was very profound child. And then sometimes you're like, oh, right. You're just a little child. I have a second cousin, I guess. It's my cousin's kid that is around that age. And he, I was leaving a family event saying goodbye to everybody. And he declares very loudly that I need to make sure that I give my dogs flea and tick prevention because fleas carry the bubonic plague.

So I was like, you're right. Good point. That's very important. I don't want the play. I don't want the play. And here's my dogs. So. Wise wisdom from children everywhere. Wow.

All right, we're here to talk about season four, what is it, episode nine? Episode nine, season four. This one's pretty decent. Let me pull out my information. Sorry I just made so much noise. My first one. I want to say before I even get started, I'm not responsible for this mystery. You might be watching this going, Liz, did you send these pipe bombs? But no, I was a small child at the time, and I was not so smart that I was proving ghosts exist, so it wasn't me. Okay, so this mystery is unwanted? That's literally my first. No, I am not responsible for this bombing, because you might think I was.

This is the mystery of the televangelist bomber. Yeah. So, as you might guess, this is someone who sent bombs to televangelists. Not a televangelist who was bombing people. No. I've never heard of this before. I never knew this was a thing. As we said, we are not responsible for this. I don't want anyone to get blown up by a bomb.

I have opinions about televangelists, but I don't want them to be bombed. I think they've established that making bombs is hard, and also, I don't know how to do it. Yeah, I can never figure. I'm sure there's math involved, especially to get one to go off at the right time. That seems extremely difficult. I'm very sure I would blow myself up. Yeah, exactly. I would blow up my whole house, probably my whole neighborhood. This was not me. There's no way. Okay, so, televangelist Pat Robertson, his daily broadcast over CBN, the Christian Broadcasting Network, are seen in nearly a million households nationwide. I'm not wishing him bombed, but it is a bummer that he's still alive.

I wouldn't wish him to be bombed, but like, what if he got bedbugs? Yeah, yeah. Like that and like a really horrible like foot fungus. Yeah. And something that prevented him from talking. His toenails fell off and then he could just never speak again. He's a really terrible person. Yeah. So I do sort of understand what motivated this bomber. Sure. I understand disliking Pat Robertson. Absolutely. So Robert Stack, he's calling his opinions controversial.

In the mystery, we see him standing in front of a whiteboard with, I don't know, divorce equals bad written on it or something. I'm not really sure. He got that from the Bible, everyone. Yeah, he actually tells us in the recording that God hates divorce, which I never read that in the Bible, but maybe. I'm sure God has other things to worry about, just like the whole universe. No, your divorce. He's very concerned about it. He hates it. Self-centered in a way.

To think God gives a shit about your divorce or someone's divorce. But in the whole, like, workings of the cosmos, he was like, I don't know, you entered a legal contract. Like, no. Must stay together. Robertson's broadcasts originate from his headquarters in Virginia Beach, Virginia. Each day, thousands of letters and packages arrive at the CBN mailroom. Most of them are donations from viewers, but on April 27, 1990, Scott Sheepers, a CBN security guard, was called to the mailroom to check a package addressed to Pat Robertson.

He's quoted as saying, when I looked at the package on the monitor of the x-ray machine, I didn't see anything that led me to believe there was a problem or it was very suspicious. So apparently they get so much hate mail that every piece of mail needs to be screened before it arrives. They have an x-ray machine at their headquarters. And this poor man, sheeples. It was his job to. It was his job to. Suspicious packages. Yeah, look at it. Do you think we need to start x-raying all of our mail? No, we've gotten a few strange things, but they've all been in good. You know, we've never gotten any hate mail. No, we haven't. Or anything like that. You know, the worst thing we've received is that.

one-star review or whatever when you declared you wouldn't salute the flag. But you know what? I've kept up not saluting it. But that was digital. You know, you can't screen for that. So, I don't know. Yeah. I think we're... I would use to, like, I don't put people off from sending us gummy snakes. I was going to say, we're such suckers. If you send us food, we just eat it. That's true. That's true. If I got a package of gummy snakes, I would open it and shovel them into my mouth right now. Even if the bag was, like, a little bit opened, we would be like, this is fine. Obviously got jostled in the mail. Yeah, these cookies are still good. Are we telling people how to murder us right now? Maybe. They already know. That's true.

That was not a secret. It's food, everyone. That's how you murder us. Done. So Sheepers remained on guard and decided to check the contents of the package. He was baffled by several strips of newspaper sticking out of the box. He says, I was still somewhat skeptical about it, so I stepped away from the box as far as I could and took my left hand and extended it out, grabbing the lid of the box. I feel bad for this dude. He...

Clearly had a bad feeling about it, but he didn't want to, like, make it a thing if there was nothing actually wrong. Right, if it was just some, like, cookies. Yeah, if they want to, like, call the bomb squad or whatever the hell you're supposed to do. So he's standing as far away as he can and, like, very carefully opening the lid. Yeah, if we open this up and it's just, you know, some Bibles, I'm going to look like an idiot. So as Scott carefully opened the box, he was suddenly thrown to the floor by an explosion. The reason I know this is quality. It is quality. Very well done.

Although I think Scott plays himself in the reenactment and he's not the best actor. Okay, that part is not great. The like explosion part and then the ATF coming in, I thought looked really good. Yes. So he says, I had a severe pain in the upper part of my left leg and abdomen over to my right leg. I made the determination that this is it. You know, I either lay here and possibly die or I get up and go find help. So that's when I made the determination to help myself and pick myself up off the floor and try to get to the front of the building.

When I say he's not a good actor, him reenacting this is, like, he has this baffled look on his face, and he's just, like, confused about what's going on, and he's covered in blood. Yeah, it's probably not the face you'd be making. It kind of reminds me how Mark Wahlberg only has two expressions. Like, he can look surprised, or he can look determined, and that's it. Those are the only two he has. This guy, I think, has, like, blank, and, like, yeah, confused. Those are his only two. Scott Sheepers was rushed to a nearby hospital where he underwent emergency surgery to remove shrapnel embedded in his leg.

Authorities determined that the package contained a homemade pipe bomb. They quickly linked the bomb to an earlier attack aimed at another televangelist, Pastor John Osteen, who I think is the father of Joel Osteen. Oh, yeah, yeah, that makes sense. In 1960, Pastor Osteen founded the Lakewood Church in Houston, Texas. The church was one of the largest in America and seated more than 8,000 worshipers. Like Robertson, Pastor Osteen used television to spread the gospel, and he was also the target of a similar mail bomb. On January 30th, 1990, three months before the CBN bombing, John Osteen's daughter, Lisa Kynes?

Sure. Arrived at her office to open the day's mail. See, they didn't actually directly ask for donations on the air, so they got a lot less mail than Pat Robertson, and they did not have this, like, security set up. Yeah, it was just his kids going, yeah, it was their job to get the mail. They were not getting thousands of letters every day. Right. So she says, I felt like it was safe to open the package because I opened a lot of packages. We've never had any problems, and this looked like an ordinary package. It had a label addressed to my dad, typewritten to my dad, and then it had a return address.

She says, you're not really suspicious of things like that. It was just a cardboard box. It had one piece of tape on it. I opened the box when I was sitting down, and the next thing I remember was standing about five feet away from the chair, and I was very shaken, as if I had had an electric shock. So yeah, so she's sitting down. The notable thing about the box, the only notable thing was it had the word burgundy, like, written in Sharpie on the side. It's like a box used for shipping candles. Yeah, so that's the only thing that they could really determine from it. Lisa had been the victim of a pipe bomb wrapped in newspaper. She suffered third-degree burns and cuts on her right leg and abdomen, but she recovered quickly and just four weeks later returned to the pulpit. When she's in the... I realize this was...

What, a couple years later when they actually make the episode? She looks fine. Yeah. I would not. There's no indication that she was wounded by a bomb. Yeah, she recovered totally. She seems to recover. And she has this gigantic, like, televangelist-type crimped hair. Oh, yeah. It's huge. Humongous. And then the reenactment of her opening the package as she has these, like, long press-on nails. So that's pretty great, too. Yeah. That's obviously what I took important notes on. The nails. The perms. The perms. Yeah. The fact that...

That possibly this box belonged to someone in a multi-level marketing candle scheme. Interesting. There used to be one called Candle Light. I don't know if that still exists. Well, now it's all Scentsy. Yeah. So maybe be suspicious of those Scentsy dealers. I don't know. According to Kenneth Weaver, chief postal inspector of the Eastern Region, the box used in both bombings was the type used by candle distributors.

A composite sketch depicted the man who was seen mailing the bombs. He's described as a neatly dressed white male with brown hair. He has average billed and weighs between 160 and 175 pounds. Both bombs were mailed from within 25 miles of Fayetteville, North Carolina. The U.S. Postal Inspection Service is offering a reward of up to $50,000 in the case. And this was never solved. There's a little bit more information on Unsolved Wiki.

So, at the time of the bombings, investigators speculated that the case might be linked to the murders of Judge Robert Smith Vance and civil rights attorney Robert Robinson, who were both killed with similar bombs. Walter Moody was later arrested and convicted for the murders of Vance and Robinson. However, he was never conclusively linked to the televangelist bombings. More recently, some have suggested that Olympic Park bomber Eric Rudolph may have been responsible for the bombings. I don't know about that. Interestingly, he matches the description of the bomber and lived in North Carolina around the time the bombs were sent. The bombs he used in the 1996 attacks were similar in design to the televangelist bombs. Also, he was apparently against materialism and born against...

Christians. However, he has never been officially connected to these bombings either. And if you Google this case, all you really find is the unsolved mystery stuff. Like, this is not something that people have talked about. And this is the first time I've ever even heard of the televangelist bombings. People were like, someone wants to bomb Pat Robertson? Okay. Fine. I thought it was interesting that both of the people who were actually hurt by the bombings, which are not the televangelists, and if you think about it, obviously wouldn't be. They're not opening their own mail. Bombers. Think about it. But both of those people were very sympathetic. And they were like, I hope the bomber gets help. Yeah, it was very interesting. Because eventually he's going to kill someone. Uh-huh. Yeah. They both were, like, very level-headed about it.

They were not like demanding an eye for an eye or something. They were just like, I hope this person gets caught before someone else gets hurt. And they clearly need help. And sending things through the mail to hurt people is sort of baffling because most of the time it's postal workers that are injured. It's whoever's opening. Yeah, famous people, people, important people, powerful people aren't opening their own mail. It's going to be an intern in the mail room somewhere. Yeah. That gets the anthrax, right? Like it's not. Think about your crimes, people. Think it through. Think it through. Yeah, Roberts didn't have time to open his own mail. Obviously not. He's too busy. Not that I'm trying to give people advice on how to commit. No, I am. How to hurt people. That makes sense. That makes sense. That's really the point. That's it.

It's only going to hurt innocent people. Just bystanders. And this security guy just worked there. I don't know that he really had anything to do with the operation. It was his job to stand at an arm's length away from a suspicious package and carefully open it. Which if he hadn't been at an arm's length... They said that he could have easily died. Yeah, if his wound was in his chest instead of in his leg, he would be dead. The doctor said he probably wouldn't be invaded out of the room. I don't even know what else to say. It's interesting that they were never caught. I'm sure this was taken very seriously. I feel like federal crimes that do involve the mail are usually taken pretty seriously. So it's weird that there's not a lot of...

information about this. It's weird that this isn't talked about more. If you Google the case, you'll get the Unsolved Mysteries. You get one Reddit thread, and then you get recent news stories about people being mad to televangelists or buying private jets. Yeah. So I couldn't really find any more information, except for people speculating on Reddit. So who knows who it was? Maybe it was Eric Rudolph practicing, or I don't know. Look, it wasn't me, and- Wasn't me either, despite- Perhaps it's you, it's going to come out with a bold stance. We are against mail bombings and letter bombings. It's very bold. We're against Nazis. We've said it before. I know. I know that's shocking, but we're willing to say it. And we're also saying, try not to kill people by sending bombs to the mail, which-

Since it's very complicated, it should be easy to not do. It should be. Yeah. Try not to. Try not to. Control yourself. As tempting as that is. Put your pipe bomb supplies away and go do something else. Please. Yeah. Join a book club. Take up knitting. Yeah. There's got to be something else you can. There's other hobbies for you. Repair old radios. I don't know. Collect model trains. Yeah. Put those skills to use. Something a little more productive and a little less going to get someone hurt in a mailroom. Those people want their fingers. Yeah. They need their fingers to do their jobs. Yeah. Don't be a jerk. Don't be a jerk, murderers. Don't be a jerk. Maybe that's the title of this episode. Don't be a jerk, murderers.

Okay, we have a lost love now. Trigger warning in this last love. Strong trigger warning in this one. It's not as wholesome as you want a lost love to be. It does have a happy ending, but it's got a brutal beginning. It does. However, this is one of my favorite lost loves, I think. I really like this one. Okay, so picture yourself. It's the 1960s. You're on Chicago's south side. Chicago continues to be a very segregated city. This is the black part of the city. This is the part of the city that the city ignores, all right? So this is the story of...

Kathy Williams. And before we get to her, Robert Stack says, we've all met people who've made a lasting impression on us. Sometimes they are total strangers that pass through our lives without ever knowing they've made a difference. A lasting impression is, seems like a, it's kind of underscored. This person basically saved her life, but still.

It's nice to think about that maybe you've made a huge difference in someone's life and you don't even know it. Which I like that. Maybe you're just doing your job and then you don't even realize that. Maybe you're just not an asshole when someone really needs that and it turns everything around. So this is a pretty cool story. Okay, so Kathy at this time is 14 and is being sexually abused by her stepfather. And the scene that we get is like he forces her to drink alcohol to get drunk. At like a party. No one else stepped in or did anything. I wasn't clear like how many people were there or what had happened. Based on the number of beer bottles like laying around all over this apartment. And then Robert's like saying it was a party.

It's very disturbing. There's definitely a few people there, a few adults. But she wakes up, she is naked, and her stepfather is basically naked on top of her, and she doesn't really remember what happened. It's extremely disturbing. So she tries to run away and, like, leaves a note to her family. She also had two younger sisters. We don't really hear where her mom is in this. I'm not sure she's still around. So, unfortunately, her stepfather found her almost immediately. He beat her, and he locked her in a small room for a week at the house of a relative.

Yeah. Because the problem is that her stepfather is a respected detective in the ever-corrupt Chicago Police Department. Huh. So it's hard for her to get help. And Robert St. refers to this as a horrible but all-too-familiar tragedy. How familiar? I hope not, but maybe it just makes me want to cry my eyes out. 14-year-olds being abused and locked in rooms. All-too-familiar. All-too-familiar to Robert Sack. I hope not.

So she couldn't exactly just go to the police and report what was happening. Which she knows, even as a 14-year-old. She's like, my father's a bigwig. He's super respected. This isn't going to work. So she comes up with a plan, which I think is smart. She's going to pretend she has amnesia. She's been watching on some of this? She's got to figure it out. She knows it's a plague on our society. Tons of people have amnesia. She goes to the police station and she's like, oh, I don't know who I am. I don't know where I live. Because she's hoping to place her literally anywhere else. She does not care where she ends up, so long as it's not at home with her stepfather. But in talking to the police, they're saying things like, if there's something going on at home, if you have any siblings.

You don't want to leave your siblings in that situation, too. And she had two younger sisters, and it hadn't occurred to her that she needed to get them out of harm's way as well. So at that point, she cracks. She admits that she knows her name. She admits that her stepfather's abusing her and that she's just trying to get out of the house. And at first, the cops are very sympathetic. They already say they're going to help her, blah, blah, blah. But by the time they find out who her father is, and her father comes down to the police department to get her, when they inform her stepfather, like, oh, she doesn't want to go with you, he has her, like, considered a delinquent. Yeah, incorrigible is apparently a legal term that teenagers can be...

Charged with a crime, essentially? So it's basically not listening to your parents. It's punishable by getting thrown in juvenile detention. Right. So instead of being listed as a Jane Doe and being placed in a foster care, which is what she was hoping, she's locked up in the county jail with just the general population for a night because she's quote-unquote incorrigible.

and then is going to be set to a home for like delinquent minors she has to go to a trial there's a family court trial and she a lot of people from the community her friends and like other community members show up and want to testify on her behalf they know what's been going on or at least they believe her and they want to testify like no this kid is not a bad kid whatever the hell that means It's the stepfather. However, because the stepfather has so much clout, they're not allowed in the courtroom. And also her file, which had affidavits testifying to the abuse and validating her story, that file is conveniently lost. Yeah. So the only side the judge gets is from the stepfather who says she's out all night, she's doing drugs, she barely comes home, she's doing underage sex work. From what we can tell. He's completely lost control over her. I don't even see her getting an opportunity to talk to speak. I don't even think she gets to speak or even say anything. She doesn't have a social worker.

I don't think anyone is representing her at that trial, and I don't think the judge asks her any questions. I think literally, at least the way they show it in the reenactment, this stepfather and his lawyer go up to the bench, tell the judge, like, yeah, my daughter is out of control. You gotta lock her up. And the judge's like, okay. Yep. Gavel. Done. That's it. Send her away. Send her away. So she's sent to the Illinois State Training School for girls, which apparently was a thing. Sounds horrific. And the sentence was until she turned 18. And she says, I didn't know I could feel that kind of pain. So horrible. That, like...

Basically, her life had gotten so low that she kept thinking, well, at least it can't get any worse. And then it would fucking get worse. And then she'd be like, oh, I had no idea I could hurt this much. Because this is like a new basement on the pain I had already experienced. Okay. Because when things start to turn around, glad you held in. Thanks for sticking with us. On a ride to reform school, at least in the reenactment, she's in the back of a car with two other girls. Kathy is sobbing because she realizes that she's not going to get to see her friends and sisters. She had a community that was extremely supportive, but their hands were tied by a corrupt system. Yeah. So they're like...

pleading like where are you taking her she realizes that she doesn't know where she's going they don't know where she's going in order to contact her and she's being like ripped away from the only people who care about her so she's sobbing in the back of this car the other two girls who i guess i don't know are delinquents whatever the fuck that means skip school too many times they're saying does this girl look like a troublemaker to you yep and she's like just sobbing and sobbing and eventually as the deputy is driving them to the reform school tells her whole story like no you know i didn't do anything wrong blah blah fortunately This deputy actually listens to her, and when he drops her off, says, look, I don't know what it is, but I believe you, and I'm going to help you. Which is kind of at the risk of his own job. Oh, for sure. I'm sure that's not what he's supposed to do. I'm sure he's not supposed to care. Yeah, it is not his job to look into whether... These people, they've been quote-unquote sentenced. I'm not really sure what the fuck this even is, but she went through some sort of court. A judge decided she's guilty, and she was sentenced to a reform school. It's not this guy who's just driving them there. It's not his job to question judges. But he's like, it sounds like you got railroaded. I'm going to look into this for you. Hang in there.

And so he gets her an interview with a social worker a few weeks later. It sounds like he actually also got in touch with her friends and the people in her community because they're trying to figure out what to do. Because I don't even think they knew where she was. No. So he gets a number from Kathy. Like, who should I call? And it's who knows, right? Someone she trusts. And so by talking to her friends and loved ones, is able to set up with this appointment with a social worker.

like gets them the right people to talk to so that they can actually like do something because i'm sure they were like what the fuck are we supposed to do they don't know where she's gone they don't know what options are available to them a judge has declared this like what are you supposed to do now so she gets an interview with a social worker he actually gets her full file he talks to the people that wanted to testify at the trial but weren't allowed to and he's like yeah it looks like you got a really bad deal this is not justice you know i'm gonna see what i can do and two weeks later she is released and emancipated she's emancipated as a minor and she is allowed to go live with friends in her old neighborhood. Which she considers her true parents. Yeah, right. Like, obviously, she doesn't want to go back to living with her stepfather. It sounds like, we don't know exactly, but it sounds like her family, at least some members of her family were somewhat complicit. Someone has the place where she was locked up for a week. Yeah. So I don't know that she could go live with someone who's actually related to her, but she had people in her neighborhood that she could go live with, and she goes and lives with them. And she refers to this deputy, she doesn't know his name, but she refers to him as her knight in a paddy wagon. I love her. Yeah, she's really cool. And she...

It's right. And thinking that her life would have gone in a very different direction if he hadn't believed her. And nobody even was interested in listening to her or her side of the story. She was 14 at this time and was going to stay in that reform school until she was 18. Yeah. And so she feels like she owes this person her life and the way that her life turned out. And she goes on to have a son. And they show a picture of her son. And her son's really hot. Extremely. So that's important, too. Gotta mention that. Gotta mention that. And then, so the update is, he was watching the broadcast. Yes! His name was Fred, I think. You know, I didn't write that down. He was, yeah, he was. I was just so happy that.

You don't get to see the reunion. Which, that's the only thing I would change about this, this segment, was if we could see the reunion. Maybe they wanted it to, you know, be a private matter. But she did get to reunite with him and thank him. Yes, because...

How cool for that guy. Amazing. Who, you know, really put himself out there to help this girl and could have gotten fired and was really at a risk that to do what was right and it worked out. And so... This is really a heartwarming story. He got the, you know, the thanks, the pat on the back that he deserved and he got to know that he made a big difference and we got to know that her son is freaking hot. Extremely. Was his fan of herself? It was a good story. It's rough and it's horrible and I hope it's not as common as Robert Stack says, but it's nice to know that when the system completely fucking fails, this one guy was willing to do the right thing. I love these last lives. I mean, her story is...

and it would be better if that just never happened. But what a fucking happy ending. But that guy's a hero. He's a hero and... I salute him. Yes, as do I. I salute her hot son as well. Well, yeah. Okay. We have another mystery in this episode. This is an unexplained death. This is wild. This one, yeah, this is a wild story. So this is the murder of Beverly McGowan. In early July 1990, 34-year-old bank clerk Beverly McGowan began advertising for a roommate to live with her in her Pompano Beach condo.

I definitely pronounced that wrong. She soon found a potential candidate, a British woman named Alice. Alice drove a nice car and appeared to be a successful career woman. They also shared an interest in the New Age movement, particularly numerology. Every time Robert Stack talks about something New Age, he calls it the New Age movement. Is that really like a movement? I'm not sure that's the right way to describe it. They both were interested in numerology, something that Alice immediately took advantage of. Alice agreed to do a chart for Beverly using numbers from her personal life. She asked for her passport number and birth certificate information, which was...

Is that something you typically give at your birth certificate and your passport number? I don't even know where my birth certificate is. Do you throw it on your social security number? Yeah. That tells you a lot about your life. It reminds me of that joke on the Wild Wild Country parody where the cult leader's like, you have to leave your family members behind. If you could put their...

They're banking information into this basket. So apparently she did a chart with her using her birthday and whatever, and it came back and was like, I need more information. I need more numbers. I need your passport number. I need your passport number, your social security number, your banking route number. After the chart was completed, Alice told her that she would find true romance and accumulate great wealth. However, she also claimed that a man and woman that were close to her would deceive and hurt her. Which, was that supposed to be her brother and sister?

On July 17th, a few days after Alice moved in, Beverly vanished. On July 19th, several of her family and friends received letters from her claiming that she had sold her condo and was planning to start a new life. Her loved ones, however, were suspicious. I just want to say on the record right now that I'm never going to send a letter like this. So if you get a letter from me that's like, hello, dearest brother, I've decided to sell my home and all of my belongings and walk into the woods. No. It's not happening. I want my shit. It's not being sold until there's a great estate sale after my death. I could never leave my dogs. This is just flat out not happening. No. No.

Her siblings, Steve and Jane, went to her condo to investigate. Her car was gone, her phone was disconnected, and she had not been seen at work for two days. Her nightgown was on her bed, which had also not been made. They said it looked like she just walked out. To Beverly's siblings, it appeared that she had just left and had planned to come back. Other than her car, the only things missing were her two cats, a dress book, birth certificate, and passport. They later learned that she had sent a telegram to her mortgage company, authorizing them to foreclose on her condo and dispose of her personal belongings. Okay. Which is very strange. We're in the back to be like, what? Please foreclose on my house.

Please throw all of my crap in a dumpster. No one will want any of it. Thank you. Farewell. Thank you, bank. On the same day that Beverly's family and friends received letters from her, her mutilated body was found. I'm still just imagining his letter. Dear bank. I have no need of worldly possessions. I'm moving to a higher plane. Please rent two dumpsters.

And they're just like, what the fuck? We don't do any of these things. It's handwritten. It's just like, please throw all my stuff in a dumpster. Yeah. Very, very bizarre. Oh, Alice. So, Beverly had been dumped in a remote canal in St. Lucie County, Florida, 100 miles from her home. Her killer had slit her throat, removed a portion of her head and hands, and cut...

a tattoo off her abdomen to delay identification. However, they didn't realize that she had another tattoo. This was a yellow rose and it was on her ankle. Along with the tattoo, dental records positively identified the body as that of Beverly McGowan. This is disgusting and terrible, but also a reason to get secret tattoos that very few people know about. That's true. Hmm. Something to consider. Consider getting a secret tattoo. Police were confused by the letters that Beverly had sent to her family and friends. Yes, they're fucking bullshit. That's why. They were written in her handwriting and there appeared to be no evidence that she was forced to write them, but how would they possibly know that? Police immediately...

I don't know. Sometimes, yeah, do I feel like I would recognize my brother's handwriting? I do. But would I necessarily recognize someone faking my brother's handwriting? No. Probably not. So, I don't know that that's really evidence. Police immediately became suspicious of Alice, who had been seen- Really? The mysterious stranger that had moved in only a couple days earlier? And had been seen using Beverly's credit card after her murder. Like, the ugliest shot you've ever seen in your life. It was bad. Ugh.

It was pretty bad. Also, Alice in the reenactment has this Dolly Parton hair. Yeah, it's a really bad wig. This is like the episode of big hair. It's true. Everyone has big hair. So she also apparently used Beverly's identity to escape to England. After Beverly's murder, a man posing as her also used her credit card to reserve a rental car at London's Heathrow Airport. He later picked it up there using her name. I like that they kept pointing out that it was a guy just wearing a cheap Cleopatra wig from the Halloween store. It was extremely obvious. They kept emphasizing the cheapness of the wig.

Yeah, it was extremely obvious. This was clearly a person in disguise because that wig was not even combed. The two suspects have yet to be identified and the case remains unsolved. So the woman known as Alice is the prime suspect. She was believed to be... So she was staying in the United States working for IBM in South Florida. She had told Beverly that she was working at their Fort Lauderdale office. However, IBM stated that they did not have one there or had anyone from England working for them. Why would IBM have a Fort Lauderdale office? I feel like she just was like, oh, American company, American company. IBM. They're huge. Yeah. It's probably them. And I'm going to Fort Lauderdale.

I couldn't even be bothered to figure out where they would actually have a company. All right. Some people are not met for a life of crime. So this has not been solved. In December 1996, after rechecking the British Airways Flight 292 passenger list, authorities discovered that, quote, Alice had used the name Sylvia Ann Hodgkinson to purchase her tickets. Through this name, authorities were able to identify her as con artist Elaine Parent. She had previously been acquainted with Hodgkinson and had stolen her identity. In May 1991, she was arrested while holding identification for both Hodgkinson and another woman. However, she was released without charge. Forensic evidence in Beverly's car and handwriting on a tablet in her condo.

was also linked to elaine over the years she became known as the chameleon killer as she had stolen more than 20 identities however because of this she was able to elude capture for over a decade in april 2002 police finally caught up with elaine with the help of an anonymous tip from america's most wanted or an american an american's most oh i can't speak an anonymous tip from an america's most wanted viewer at the time she was living under the name darlene thompson in an apartment in panama city after detectives arrived they allowed her to change clothes during this time however she took her own life with a um by shooting herself in the head uh Although Elaine's death might bring a sense of closure to Beverly's family, it left much of the secrets of her bizarre lifestyle and criminal career unanswered. Also, some suspect that she may be responsible for other murders that she had yet to be connected to. Right. As for Sam, who was the person in the wig, he was never identified. However, some believe that he may have actually been Elaine. One source states that Elaine, wearing a black wig, picked up the car at Heathrow Airport. The black wig was previously believed to have been worn by this person named, quote, Sam. So, yeah. She was apparently a con woman who may have killed other people.

Yeah, and Beverly had so much going for her, it's really a shame that... The segment ends with a lot of people being like, I don't understand this crime, it's extremely complicated, and they only got $1,000. Yeah. And Robert Stack literally at one point just goes, why? And it's a really good question, because they could have just robbed her. They did not need to murder her and leave her in a canal and do all this... Cut her up. It's so bizarre. It's extremely strange. It's really over the top. Yeah, she didn't need to answer her roommate ad and move into her house and do the whole chart thing.

I don't know. I guess they just wanted her passport information, but... I guess that's what they used to probably flee the country, but... But for $1,000? For $1,000. That's so much work. At that point, just get a job. Channel that energy into something more productive. Yeah. Ugh.

Really? That's an awful one. I can't believe I haven't heard of that before. Pretty bad. I did draw a mustache from it, but... Oh, is that the very small, like, mustache? I called it the dullard. Yeah. It's just kind of boring. So, I have one more. He needed to let that mustache extend a little bit farther to the sides. It looked very awkward. There's really no spectacular mustaches in this episode, so you can pick between that one and one in this last one, which one is your favorite, but both of them are pretty generic. So, this is a wanted, this is our last mystery for this episode, and it's from 1985 in San Francisco. It's the case of Sally Garrity, who was unlucky in love.

Yeah. Very unlucky. Yeah. So her and her sister Sherry were raised by their aunt Lydia. And Sally was a bookkeeper and also made money selling Native American crafts. She was a member of her tribe. And that's a little bit plays into this mystery. In February of 1985, she met a young man named Sal Guardado at a neighborhood bar. And they show the reenactment is like they bump into each other playing pool. And he's like, oh, my name's Sal. And she's like.

Oh, my name's Sally. That's so great. What I remember most from this segment is Robert Stack saying, as many people do, she found love in a local dive bar or something like that. And I was like, really? Yeah, storybook romance, Robert Stack. Yeah, I wrote down that she thought she had met, quote, Mr. Right, which was a phrase we used a lot in the 90s that I don't really hear anymore. Maybe because men are trash. Send them to the moon. People are no longer holding out for a, quote, unquote, Mr. Right. She was really impressed that he had a car and a part-time job at a pizzeria.

There's nothing wrong with having a part-time job at a pizzeria, but I don't know that that should be so impressive. It sounds like her standards were a little too low. Yeah, the bar is on the ground. We've talked about this before. So within a week, he had proposed and taken out a loan for a ring. I don't want to tell you what to do, but if you've known someone for a week, I get it. Life is short. You're in love. You want to get married. But you could just not be married. You could also not be married. You could also, I don't know, if you're going to get married that quickly, for sure have an exit plan. That's going to be my advice. Yeah. If you want to...

Yeah, I don't know. Have this whirlwind romance. Just make sure you can, like, walk away if you need to. That's great advice. Because yikes. Because yikes. He quickly lost his car and his job, and they had to move in with her Aunt Lydia. At which point, he quickly showed his true colors. He just wanted to sit on the couch and watch TV and yell at her and her aunt all day and then go bowling. He had got her, right? Now she's trapped in a marriage. So he no longer needs to try and keep a job. He no longer needs to try and pay for his car. He's not trying to charm her. So he immediately stopped all this shit.

By the way, it's been like three weeks. I know. It's gone from this like whirlwind romance of the perfect man to this guy just like barking orders at her while he's guzzling beer on the couch. Lovely. Such a short period of time. So at some point he goes with her and her sister to a Native American festival that was 30 miles away.

From San Francisco. And at that point, her sister is like, well, this is a huge change from when we saw him at the pizza parlor. And she was like, all starry eyed and was like, isn't he amazing? And now she's just like, oh, I'm so sick. It's been like a couple of weeks. And she's already like, oh, this guy, he's the worst. And then at the end of the festival, he like weirdly demands that he gets to borrow the van that Sherry has.

And she's like, yeah, I'm borrowing this from someone. Yeah, it was like her works van or something. It was not hers to blend out. I was like, you can't borrow it. He's like, I want to take the train back to San Francisco. And he like threw this big fit about how he should get to take the van and was like, no, I'm taking it. Like, what is she going to drive? And eventually Sally is like, no, we're leaving. You're ridiculous. But at this point, I think it's like, just, it's clear it's over. Yeah. It's just, how is it going to end? And the answer is very, very badly. Yeah, unfortunately. So they're fighting at home because Sally gets a ride home from someone and Sal becomes convinced she's having an affair.

Which, like, she should, because this guy's terrible. But also, what was happening? Yeah, he's just a control freak. So he's, like, screaming at her for probably, like, not wanting to walk home from her job, which, understandable. And at this point, Aunt Lydia comes home, and it's, like, super awkward, because they're clearly fighting. And then Sal goes, hey, uh, I need you to go to the store. I think Lydia's the nicest person on the planet. Yeah. He was like, I need cigarettes, and I need them now. And I would have been like, get your fucking own damn cigarettes, and I was like, get out of my house. But she was like, okay, because she's...

She's trying to keep a peace, you know? She's trying to be a good aunt. So she goes to the store. She gets the cigarettes. She comes back. She's like, I have your cigarettes. But no one says anything. So she was like, all right, well, it's time for the news. I'm just going to sit down and watch the news. So she's sitting on the couch. She's kind of dozing. She hears the door squeak open and realizes, oh, someone might be home, but whatever. I'm just going to keep watching the news. And then Sal comes up, tries to strangle her. Yeah. Uncalled for Sal. And then it's hitting her in the head with a bowling ball. This is horrible. Because he's the worst man in the world. He hits her in the face with a bowling ball. The sweet old woman.

Yeah. So he's the worst. He's the absolute worst. So when she wakes up because she's knocked out by her head injury and calls the police, it turns out that Sally is already dead and that she was strangled with either a leash or a telephone line. She was probably murdered while Lydia was out getting cigarettes because Sal was like purposely getting her out of the house in order to kill her niece. That's so sad. Yeah, it's terrible. And unfortunately, this is not solved. Yeah. This guy got away with it. Everything's awful. And at one point, her sister uses the phrase put to justice that she hopes he can be found and put to justice, which...

I think she was going to say put to death, but then like... Thought better of it. Yeah. But I like the idea of saying that someone should be put to justice. Look, we don't know what happened to this guy. Robert Stacks speculates he could be in Miami, Mexico, Hawaii, or Puerto Rico. And I was just like, so anywhere. Literally anywhere. You know, this period in 92. His birthday is 51. He could still be alive.

All right, so let's try to find this guy. He's 5'10". You're worried. We had 210 pounds. He had brown hair, black eyes, and a tattoo of a heart with an arrow on the name of Rachel on his upper right arm. So if you see this guy, if you see this guy, please turn him in because he's trash garbage and I hate him. He hit an old lady with a bowling ball. He strangled and killed his wife. Yeah, Sally seemed incredibly sweet and optimistic and like a lovely person. He didn't need this shit. She didn't deserve any of this. Sally's garbage. If you are, for some reason, know a murderer and are listening to this podcast, today's the day. You're turning him in. He needs to be put to justice. He needs to be put to justice. That is the end of that. So that, ugh.

Bummer. A bummer note for the end of this episode. Okay, let's read this episode. All right, mysteriousness. I mean, I guess we have two things. No one knows who that person was. No one knows what happens to Sal. And the chameleon story is actually still pretty mysterious, even though we know who did it. They found her, but they didn't get to talk to her. There's no answer to her. She killed herself before they could even get her to the police station, so there's a lot of mystery there. The only one that's not mysterious is the lost love. I mean, I hope her stepfather went missing and was never found, but other than that... Not a lot of mystery. I would say thumbs up, though. High on the mystery factor. I think so, too. Reenactments.

pretty good i thought all the bomb the explosions were pretty good the attention to detail was great the paper the yeah um i don't know that any other ones stood out to me but i would still say they were good yeah thumbs up thumbs up ah fashion i mean if you like big hair this is the one for you that televangelist daughter perm that whole family had the biggest hair i've ever seen and then alice had a weird bouffant wig yep so cleopatra wig you get a terrible wig you get to see press on nails i mean solid yeah you get to see actually a lot bev had a lot of great outfits She had some flamingo earrings we saw in the picture. I knew you'd like the flamingo earrings. Yeah, I think that's a thumbs up for sure. Yes. And Robert Stack? I mean, he was fine. He was fine. He was wondering why. I think he's questioned why. Why do this, chameleon killer? It was a good question. Valid. Valid. The question we should be asking is why? Why on earth do this? Do anything else. Yeah, so thumbs up for Robert Stack. Alice, can't you just sell drugs like a normal person? Jesus Christ. I'm sure you could get it that way. That's probably a more steady income. Yeah, and you don't have to kill anyone and take off part of their jaw and their tattoo and leave them in a canal.

Ugh, Alice. Awful. All right, how do you rate this episode? I really like The Lost Love. I love a heartwarming story. Lost Love's my favorite. You get some. I hate having to talk about a televangelist, so there's that. But it was interesting because I'd never heard of the case before. Yeah, I think this is good variety. I think these are interesting cases that could actually use some more attention. I would love it if we get an update in a few weeks that Sal was caught somehow. That would be amazing. So I'd say 3.5. I'm right there with you. Three and a half stars? Three and a half stars. Yeah.

Three and a smidge stars. It was solid. It was solid. I was happy we got a good lost love in this one. Yeah, the killings are kind of brutal. No, they were. We could use like a ghost or something. Yeah, maybe next time we'll get a ghost. Yeah. I'd like that. Fingers crossed for a ghost. Cross your fingers. All right, what do you have to recommend? Oh, I'm excited about my recommendation. I have a TV recommendation. You're going to need Hulu for this one. This is a Hulu exclusive. But if you have that service or you can borrow someone's password, I would highly recommend watching the show.

pen 15 which i've been watching someone recommended it to me a while ago and was like you're gonna love this and i don't know why but i just didn't get around to watching it until now it's so good i love it and it's not really like anything else we've recommended previously on the show it's about like being a middle schooler in the year 2000 okay and interestingly the two main characters are like playing themselves as kids even though they're in their 30s It sounds dumb, but it somehow works. It's actually amazing. And so it's just about them and their friendship and the awkward experience of being in the seventh grade, which is really the most awkward, traumatic time. The most awkward time. This show's attention to detail of this era of transitioning from an analog to a digital world is so... It's such a fucking time capsule. It's unbelievable to me. It captures that so well. It captures the awkwardness of this age and having no idea what you're doing and trying to seem...

cool but not being cool and yeah i relate to it so hard it's sometimes hard to watch because it really does stir up these things from like my youth yeah where it's like oh fuck like i totally forgot what that was like and that's it wow i love it is a blue original yes cool um i can see how this is like kind of niche so i'm guessing they like you know i couldn't see this being on like a big network i can't really think of another show to compare it to i guess if you liked freaks and geeks maybe you would like this but it's a little more fanciful and also you get um one of the main characters maya is asian-american so you get that experience too which i think is really cool and how that's like adding to the awkwardness like not being accepted at her school and um I'm not done with it yet. I've watched maybe like eight episodes and I love it and I know I'm going to be, if that's all that there is, I'm going to be so sad when it's done. It's so good. That's a solid recommendation. I don't watch Hulu as much as I should, I have to say. Only, like, if we need to watch something for the podcast that's on Hulu, I'll turn to it, but I very rarely, like, peruse their offerings. No, several times I have said to Mac, like, we should just cancel this. I never watch it. And then Mac's been like, oh, I watched whatever on it. I'll be like, okay. Yeah, I think we only keep Hulu for, because I need it for the podcast from time to time. Yeah, but...

I don't know. Maybe there's more on there than I should be paying attention to. That's a great recommendation. I'm also recommending something that is on TV. And this is a documentary that's on Netflix that I meant to recommend a long time ago but forgot. Sure. This is a documentary that my husband and I stumbled upon. It's called The Last Breath. And I think it's a British documentary. Yes, I think it is. So this is the real life story of a saturation diver, which is something I wasn't super familiar with. I have no idea what that is. Before I watched this. My husband likes to watch Nova documentaries, educational documentaries about things like this from time to time.

So he had watched some different documentaries about saturation diving, and that's why he chose this. It's weird. I'll probably get some of this wrong, so thank God he doesn't listen. These underwater oil rigs have to be, like, maintained and partially operated by people who are on, like, the seafloor. They have to go down there and dive and do various tasks.

But if you just pluck someone from the surface and put them down there, they die from the pressure or whatever. So they put them in these little capsule things, I'm not sure what they're called, where they slowly over time acclimate them to that pressure, I think. And then you can go down there and live down there. And then they bring them back up and you slowly acclimate to the surface. I don't know. That's wild. It's also crazy. I'm not sure if it's cost, but they breathe helium instead of oxygen. And so they talk with the helium voice while they're down there. I'm not sure why. It might be cost. It might be helium is better down there. I don't know what the deal is. I don't know a lot about this. We went into this blind. We had no idea what it was even about.

Turns out it's about this incident that happened. I don't want to give too much away because you shouldn't be spoiled on this at all. It's a wild story. But something happens while this team is underwater and some wild shit happens that we were stunned when we watched it. So I can't really give you more information. No, I don't think you should. I don't want to spoil anything, but some calamity happens, there's a rescue, and that's it. Huh. I am intrigued. Yeah. I think that's a good teaser. And it's one of those things, very rarely I feel like you just randomly stumble onto something that's really good. I've heard no one talk about this documentary before. What's it called again? It's called Last Breath. Okay.

You will be amazed. And also, it's just something that I didn't really know was a thing. Yeah, I never really thought about that. They live in this tiny little bubble. It's very small on the ocean floor. Apparently, they make so much money because no one wants to do this. Yeah, why would you? There's only like a handful of people on Earth that are willing and trained to do that. So they make a ton of money in a very short period of time because they can only stay down there for I don't even know how long. Sure. A couple months, maybe a couple weeks. I'm not sure. So in that short period of time, they make a bunch of money because they're like one of...

12 people or something. I don't know. I'm making that up. Should we become saturation diaries? Absolutely not. You definitely cannot have claustrophobia to do this. No, thanks. And then their shifts are like 12 hours, like diving, right? Like on the seafloor, fixing shit. I don't even know what you're doing out there, but you're swimming around. You know, doing this with a wrench. And then you go back into this tiny little bubble and you live with like four other dudes. Yeah, kill me now. No, thank you.

Also, you're constantly watched the entire time because there's people in the rig on the surface or there's a boat, a ship, a ship, definitely a ship, not a boat, on the surface that have to constantly monitor your vital signs. So you have to take a shit because I'm pretty sure someone's watching you. Oh, they're like, God, Joe's masturbating again. There must be some unwritten rules that there's no masturbation. Look at his vitals go. I know what that means.

He covered up the camera again. I'm sure that's not allowed. Oh my goodness. Yeah, that sounds terrible. It was interesting. It was one of those things where sometimes my husband picks these things to watch and it's like, okay, I don't want to watch another thing about a tunnel being built. Yeah, I know he watches a lot of things about bridges. Yeah, yeah. He likes to watch things about big engineering projects. I was like, ugh, one of these again. But it was actually really interesting. And the story is wild. All right. So, you know, if you're looking for something to watch.

Huh. I think that's a wrap. I think so. Should we plug our shit? Yeah. Follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter at Perhaps It's You. Oh, yeah. If you want to email us a paranormal tale, something that's happened to you that's spooky or mysterious or otherwise unexplained, Perhaps It's You podcast at gmail.com. There's also a form on our website, Perhaps It's You.com. Yeah. Patreon. Give us money if you want. You should. I mean, we're pretty cool. We're not going to ask for your passport number in exchange for a chart. And if you give us $1, you get a ton of shit. So it's a pretty good deal. You get a bonus episode every month for one, and we'll send you a postcard. Yeah.

So, it's a great bargain. And this month's special episode is going to be about the Exiles. We're about to record it right now. Which I think everybody's been waiting for this whole time, so. Liz has, for sure. Samantha's like, not me. And I was like, I didn't mean you. I meant the mystery solvers, Samantha. It's the mystery solvers. Yeah, I think that's it. Yeah, I think that's it. I feel like we're supposed to say something more thing, but give us a five-star review. Oh, yeah. And iTunes have a podcast. We need it. They're our life force. We're trying to get to 1,000. I saw we're trying to get to 1,000 followers on Twitter. No, I want 999 followers by October. Because it's like 666, but better. It's what Satan wants.

So, follow us on Twitter, perhaps. If you're not on Twitter, go make a Twitter account and follow us. Yeah, I don't care. I don't care. It can be a stock account, whatever. It can be the one account you follow. That's fine. Yeah. We'd be honored. Yeah. 999. Let's do it. Follow us and I pet that dog. Yeah, there you go. That's all you really need. We've already improved your life significantly. Yeah, you're welcome. So, bye.

Frequently asked questions

When was this Perhaps It's You episode published?

This episode was published on August 29, 2019.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Perhaps It's You episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.