Skip to content
S5 Ep3: Assassin Talk and Baby X episode artwork

Mar 26, 2020

S5 Ep3: Assassin Talk and Baby X

from Perhaps It's You Hosted by perhapsitsyou

This week, we are joined by everyone's favorite voice crush, Mac! We talk assassin babies, the next big conspiracy, and more! *** >Support the show, get bonus content! www.patreon.com/perhapsitsyou > Special Outro music by Olivia Hinthong >Follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter @PerhapsItsYou, or email us at [email protected]. Perhaps It's You is made with Jetpack Podcast. Full show notes and every episode at https://perhapsitsyou.wordpress.com/

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

S5 Ep3: Assassin Talk and Baby X

of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello, five enemies. Hello. Our enemies? Yeah. Hello, friends and enemies. Hello, five listeners. Hello, BD Wong. Hi. It's time for Perhaps It's You, your favorite unofficial Unsolved Mysteries rewatch podcast. I'm Samantha. I'm Liz. And we have a special guest today, your voice crush. It's Mac. Hi, everyone. I think we had a request to have Mac on this episode. What is it? Episode three of season five? Two of season five. We're on episode three. Oh, my God. I don't even know what day it is. No one does. It's okay. Are we making a podcast right now? For some reason, yes.

We're going to keep those five enemies happy if it's the last thing we do. Absolutely. Does anyone know how BD Wong is doing? I asked on Twitter, and I got no answers, and I just hope he's okay. Oh, no. BD Wong, if you're listening. He's not on Twitter, so I can't ask him directly. I bet he's got a fake. He's got, like, an anonymous account. Or, like, a PR person runs an account for him, right? I mean, he doesn't have a, like, checkmark account. So maybe he's like, you know, I don't know what. He's drilled. There was that BD Wong bot on Twitter? Yes.

Where anytime anyone on Twitter mentioned BD Wong, they would just tweet back, BD Wong! I don't think it's up anymore because I didn't get that. What was the point of that? I don't know. BD Wong bot is sick. Oh, no. Not the bot. BD Wong bot. Yeah, how are you hanging in there, Samantha? You know, taking it one day at a time. That's good. I don't think I'm doing that, and that's a bad idea. Don't be like me. Well, I mean, you know where you are, right? I mean, we all do it in our own way. I guess.

I'm just hanging out with the dogs every day. This is the greatest time of their lives. Yeah. Dogs love this. They get lots of attention. People are home all the time. Perhaps they get extra walks. It's like the last thing that ever happened to them. Definitely. How are you guys holding up over there? I mean, we're live. So that's good. That's really all you can have. Very, very low. Mac, how are you holding up? You know.

It's weird. Yeah, you were eating that just before we started. You really gotta ration the quarantine snacks. It's very tempting to just eat them all. I'm just lying in bed, staring into the abyss, not doing anything. That's not how it takes up a lot of my time. Very long naps, like ridiculously long naps. Yeah, I mean, whatever. I do have a couple updates. Update number one. A huge thank you to listener Patrick that sent us a month of the Criterion.

channel that is amazing because the super nice gift i had mentioned on the last episode that filmstruck was gone and patrick was like oh they basically just rebranded it as the criterion channel here's a month of it how amazing is that amazing thank you so much so really i know that i know that patrick had no intention of giving that to me but i will be watching it and i appreciate it mac is like an added bonus to that i it's no that's super sweet and super considerate i should probably since i'm really like literally doing nothing start like watching a movie a day or something You could do it. Perhaps it's you letterboxed where you write little reviews of all the movies you watch. Oh, see, there you go. I mean, I probably won't, but I could. I've got lots of homework assignments if you're interested. Maybe that's really what we need right now. Some friends of ours, their kids have been making a kid's news every day, and it's literally the most adorable thing I've ever seen in my life. It's just them giving an update on what is happening in the house, where they are on Lego projects.

Oh my goodness. What's like a breaking news story that they've covered? Like the hamster got loose or something? Yeah, they've shown their pets. They talked to their uncle in Buenos Aires. They did an interview? They had a foreign correspondent. They update on what the toilet paper situation is. It's literally the cutest thing I've ever seen in my life. It's freaking adorable. So shout out to kids. This episode of Perhaps It's actually brought to you by Kids News. It's actually the only news source I've been consuming. It's a lot less depressing than other news sources.

People seem really freaked out in general, but I'm not sure why, because all I've known is that Rex is doing well in his Legos, and it's a nice day out. Yeah, they do the weather. There's, like, dancing. Everything seems fine. I know what people are doing. Freaking adorable. The other update that I had was a couple episodes ago, we talked about beauty queen Tammy Lynn, who vanished off the face of the earth. And you had asked if she was actually in the movie Scarface, and I said that I didn't think she was. I was wrong. So if you watch Scarface, you will see Tammy Lynn. This is coming from Wikipedia.

She is the girl who is a distraction to the lookout car during the bloody chainsaw shower scene. I honestly wondered if it was near the chainsaw scene, and I don't know why I thought that. I've never seen Scarface, so that is quite a sentence. I've never seen it either, so that sounds wild. I mean, that's kind of cool that she's in such a beloved, remembered movie. It's her legacy. Google her. That movie comes up, so I was wondering if she was in it. She lives on. Justice for Tammy Lynn.

I know. We have a new episode to talk about today. We are on episode three. This episode is pretty good. I actually really liked it. Am I at the right part of my notebook? No. But, okay. You're first, right, Liz? I am first. And I'm talking... Oh, first of all, though, when Robert Stack is, like, just introducing the episode, is he at the DMV? Where the hell is he? He's standing. It didn't look like some kind of government. Yeah, they just, like, dimmed the lights on, and I was like, is that the DMV? Not sure. Robert, we really need to shoot today. Well, too bad. I'm getting my license.

all right all right i mean make the best of it okay so my um case is a wanted they called it a wanted it's really not though it's um if you look this up on unsolved mysteries wiki it's referred to as the seattle arsonist this is a case from 1989 it is um so there was an arsonist in the area but this segment is mostly talking about the floor alarm fire that was the black stock lumber warehouse fire um so it starts with some footage of that that includes like the roof exploding and you know a warehouse burning down um And they thought it was connected to an unidentified arsonist that had been connected to over 20 fires in and around Seattle. So the Blackstock Lumber Fire happens at 10 p.m. 20 fire trucks respond. At first, they thought that the fire was controllable, but then it very quickly spread to other parts. And like I said, the roof exploded.

So we hear a little bit about Matt Johnson, who was a firefighter who died in the fire. His partner is interviewed from Unsolved Mysteries, and he talks about just how the intense heat was so overwhelming that it felt like he was being x-rayed by heat. So it felt like he was being x-rayed by heat, and so it was impossible for him to get his partner out of the blaze because he was so, like, weak and disoriented. And the lack of oxygen in the intense heat left Matt unable to move. So he ended up dying in fire, but his partner, who we hear from...

bill meredith was able to escape so matt's body is found in rubble uh the next day he left behind a wife and a 15 year old month old son so originally they were thinking that maybe the fire had started by accident like someone was trying to keep warm and it got out of control but then we hear from investigator dennis flower who thinks he discovered a pattern in the ruins that matched the signature of a serial arsonist that he had been tracking for years and it seems like this guy has created this like mythological nemesis in his mind that it's like him versus this arsonist. And he's like determined to track him down. And he says that he first encountered this arsonist in 1984 when Seattle's Carpet Exchange warehouse burned down in less than 20 minutes. And that the fire was so intense it melted concrete and warped steel beams. Which I'm not going to say anything about 9-11 right now.

So after the Blackstock Lumberyard fire, the Seattle Police Department began investigating on a national scale. They were like looking for other warehouse fires that fit that pattern. And they decided that there was 20 fires in the United States and Canada that seemed to be started by the same individual who they were calling the king of arsonists, which is super ridiculous. OK, so the fires started by this arsonist were considered especially dangerous because, OK, this sentence from Unsolved Mysteries Wiki makes no sense to me. The fires by this arsonist were especially dangerous because the oxygen in their water only made the fire burn faster and hotter.

They said that in the episode, and I'm sorry, but I don't think, I don't know. Look, I'm not a scientist. I'm not a fire investigator. I know very little about water, but I don't think the oxygen in water makes fires burn better. Is that a thing?

Well, I guess like a grease fire, if you throw water on it, it just spreads it around, right? It doesn't put it out. So maybe they did say that there was some special accelerant being used that they had a hard time identifying. Yeah. I don't know. I don't know a lot about it either. They were like, the chemicals they used meant it burned really hot and the oxygen in our water only made the fire work. I've never heard this before and it sounds super not real. Yeah, that is a weird one. They claimed he was the most sophisticated arsonist in the history of the United States and a part of what made him...

So dangerous was that he designed his fires to be death traps. And like Mac was saying, he was said to use an accelerant that was unknown and left no residue. Okay. They were calling it a high temperature accelerant or HTA. And then it generated temperatures between 5,000 and 7,000 degrees, which is three times hotter than normal fire.

so yeah so maybe maybe at that heat yeah you boil the water almost immediately and then it ends up feeding the the flames uh somehow i i don't know well good thing we have mac here because that just sounded like gibberish to me that that sounds more legit than what they were saying in the episode so maybe that's at this point i drew a mustache and i think it was this guy trying to track the arsonist but honestly i don't remember i just remember he had a really sophisticated looking mustache it actually looked really good on him and i called it the alfred and it's one of the few cases where i was like yes that white guy should have a mustache looks great so We now get to the part where the Seattle Fire Department does a test fire with an empty shopping mall, which is wild to me. So there was, I guess, this mall that no one was using anymore. So they just decided to burn it the fuck down.

And then they decided they like did different accelerants or like different mixtures and fuel of different parts of them all to try to figure out what this arsonist was using. And they wouldn't tell us on the show what it was because they don't want us all to become the king of arsonists. But they said that it was. Well, the prince at this point, right? The king is maybe the prince or princess. The Duke and Duchess of arsonists. The fuel was said to be a mixture of several common ingredients. And they felt that the arsonist might not be an engineer, but he definitely knew a lot about building construction because.

He's read a book. He's read a book. He's very dangerous. He has a library card. He knows how to use it. He knew enough about building construction to, like, make sure the fires were death traps. Though I sort of feel like really hot fires, they're going to be death traps. Like, I don't understand. They also speculated that he might be mixing this, like, special accelerant and getting other people to light it. But that's based on, like, nothing. I don't see any evidence of that. Yet another unsolved mystery. Yeah, that's another unsolved mystery. So that test was done on March 25th, 1990. They burned down that shopping mall, which, God, that must have been so fun.

It looked fun. I wish I could have been there for that. I don't think there was a lot of scientific value, but they got a light shit on fire, which is probably just what they wanted to do. Yeah. So according to their test, only one fire produced the same type of fire that was at the Black Dock lumberyard.

And that was based on an eyewitness who read about the fire in the paper and realized he had been in the area 15 minutes prior to when the alarm was called in. Oh, this is the person that sees this car. So someone saw a like 1970s or 1980s Mercedes driving out of the parking lot of the lumberyard shortly before the fire. And it just seemed weird. Like it was a super nice car coming from a warehouse. So they kind of remembered that from a different fire. There's a woman that saw a quote suspicious man after the fire with that. And literally the only thing suspicious about him was that he wasn't looking at the fire. There was like a crowd gathering. And then this one man was like, whatever, I've seen fires. I don't care. So he's like.

walking away and she thought that that was suspicious so they show sketches the cool guys don't yeah yeah he was like too cool she was like i don't know there's something suspicious about how cool that guy is so they had under hypnosis of course because this is unsolved mysteries they had both eyewitnesses describe the two men that they saw and then had sketches made they don't look a thing alike um but they are wanted for questioning even if they're not arsonists the guy driving the mercedes was between 35 and 40 in 1992 he had great hair and a mustache and a beard and a receding hairline and the guy that was like too cool for school was six foot well dressed and is mid to early 30s in 1992 and was said to have an athletic build dark complexion and dark hair so um two firefighters died in these arson fires we hear only about matt johnson but also robert earhart died in 1988 apartment fire so um the authorities at the end of the segment are like looking into suspicious insurance claims so this aired in 1992 the thing is the lumber yard fire probably is not an arson because guess what it's a warehouse full of lumber

Very burnable stuff. This whole episode, they present almost no actual hard evidence. They just keep talking about how hot the fire was burning, how they didn't know what the accelerant was. Could the accelerant have been wood? Yeah. Yeah. The fact that they're like, we can't find any evidence of accelerant. It somehow has left no residue. There's like literally no evidence of it. They're just like, but it was really hot.

So this is what Unsolved Mysteries Wiki says. Unresolved. In September of 92, Paul Keller was arrested for several arson fires in Seattle. Originally, he was thought to be the arsonist. However, in February of 1995, a new investigation by the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, and Firearms into the Blackstock Lumberyard case determined that it was an accident. Investigators concluded that the high temperature accelerant was not the cause and that a power line most likely caused the sparks. Another possibility was that there were transients had accidentally started the fire. Either way, lumber stored at the facility caused the fire to reach such high temperatures.

It's like, yes, it's just a thing of fire fuel. I can't believe this magic warehouse exploded. Yeah. Many of the fires that were believed to be caused by this special accelerant were actually determined to be accidents. However, authorities have yet to close all cases linked to the, quote, king of arsonists. So there probably were some arson cases in Seattle, except that the one that they talk about on Unsolved Mysteries is just a tragic fire at a lumber warehouse.

Well, it's something they mentioned because they referenced fires across the country that they thought were attributed to this king of arson. But then they mentioned just like offhandedly, sorry if you just heard my dog sneeze. They mentioned just like offhandedly that they were looking into insurance claims related to some of the fires, which is like, hmm. I mean, yeah, it's arson, but they're making it sound like this diabolical person who's going around setting fires to kill firefighters specifically. And when it's like some of these that were probably arson, maybe were more for insurance money. But this one specifically was just like a wood factory burned down. But if you're going to burn down your facility for the insurance money,

Why would you go with anyone but the king? Well, I guess that could be one theory is that people were hiring him for their insurance thing. But I don't think that's true. You've tried the rest. Now try the best. I think that they felt, for whatever reason, like very attached. Like they seem to take this very personally. And I'm sure they were quite upset that this firefighter died. But I don't think someone like masterminded this to make this like perfect death trap. It's more just fires are dangerous.

And wood burns pretty good. I'm not a fire expert, but I do know that. I've seen many forensic files, and I'm sure if forensic files were updated, this would be even more common, but an arson investigator will point to things and say, oh, this proves the burn pattern started in this room, and this accelerant was used, blah, blah, blah. And then a few years later, someone comes in and is like, yeah, that's actually none of that is true. It was an electrical fire. This person's in jail for no reason. Like things that people were pointing to as like irrefutable evidence turned out to be like way more open to interpretation and that people that were arson investigators had received actually very little training. They received like just enough training to be dangerous and think they knew what they were talking about, but they would be interpreting things wrong. And the fact that these people just assumed there must be this like miracle accelerant that they couldn't like test for or see any evidence of.

Like, what are you basing that on? Absolutely nothing. Yeah. Arson investigation is like a lot of forensic science that has come under increased scrutiny in recent years. Like we often talk about how hair analysis is just completely bunk. I don't know that it's completely bunk, but it's more like to use it properly would have it guide your investigation, but you would have other evidence. Right. Not just going off of, because burn patterns, what, yeah, like Liz said, if you watch old forensic files, what are referred to as burn patterns, like people know now that normal accidental fires can create things that look like.

accelerant pooling or whatever so i'm suspicious of this specifically because there's no other evidence the witnesses that means nothing there's just people around a fire like a huge fire yeah no and all the you know the only thing they had was that it was really hot like a giant fire in a wood factory of course it's hot like what i don't yeah they i think they were mostly excited that they had footage of like things burning down and that makes for okay television but there's not really a lot of a case here Okay. Now it's time for Mac. We brought Mac on the show because we have a more political case. So he's going to take us down memory lane. Yeah, I'm the assassination guy, I guess. So the second segment of this episode deals with Huey Long, the kingfish, which I discovered was a self-declared name. Oh, you can't do that. You can't do that. He started answering the phone as this is the kingfish and stuff like that. Yeah, what a loser. Yeah.

so the segment is I mean it's more about who Huey Long was and that and that's probably what's most interesting about it the mystery itself is just sort of like well here's the story of his assassination and maybe it didn't happen that way so as far as a mystery goes I don't know that it's mysterious but I do think Huey Long is an interesting figure and certainly worth talking about. Are you telling us you're a Huey Long truther? Well, I mean, we'll talk about that later, I guess, just because there are a lot of reasons to think that maybe that's not, maybe the story they tell is not exact. And that was something that I found kind of interesting. So like a few years ago, the Dollop, the Dave Anthony and Gareth Reynolds podcast, they did an episode on Huey Long. And so that's where a lot of my information, that and our good friends at Wikipedia are informing me a lot about Huey Long. But I mean, he's always been an interesting figure.

If you saw the movie or, you know, if you're a literate person and you like the book, All the King's Men, the Robert Penn Warren book, that's supposedly about Huey Long. Oh, okay. The sort of... Sinclair Lewis wrote a book in the 30s called It Can't Happen Here about a sort of fascist leader coming to power in the United States. And that is also a sort of Huey Long parable. And that's something that the episode didn't really go into. They painted him as a populist figure and one who was sort of out there for the working person and for the poor. And he was. And it's hard to talk about Huey Long because he's...

He's like equally good and evil in a lot of ways. He built a ton of hospitals. He taught 100,000 people in Louisiana how to read. I mean, Louisiana in the 20s and 30s was a very poor and a very... I guess, backward to use a kind of loaded term place. And Huey Long was out there honestly fighting for poor people and for and against like big business interests and oil companies and things. So like you hear some of his speeches and you're like, yeah, all right. And then you kind of look further and you wonder, OK, what am I getting on board with? So just a background about him. He was you know, he was born in 1893, grew up in Louisiana and got going really early. Like he was a he.

dropped out of law school at like 19, but still managed to argue before the Supreme Court. Yeah, that's really impressive. And I mean, this is also like long enough, long enough ago that America wasn't really a very serious place yet. You know, like you could have kind of goofballs come to enormous power in ways like, you know, we, it's hard to remember. Well, I certainly don't, I'm not old enough, but like prior to World War II.

America was kind of a joke, right? Like it wasn't, it was a smaller country. I mean, not in terms of area, but it just wasn't like a world power in the way that we think of it now. It was getting there, but it wasn't yet. So in 1924, he's elected governor on an extremely powerful, extremely populous plan. He's talking about building roads. He's talking about building hospitals. He's adding night school so that people can learn to read. He's talking about doing all kinds of social programs. He added a medical school to the Louisiana State University.

but at the same time he's doing all this good stuff uh he is also like the archetype of that sort of southern politician who is in control is like dictator for life in whatever sort of fiefdom he has right so like when he leaves office his wife takes over right and then after the assassination his son is senator from Louisiana for like 40 years you know it's um it's it's these uh you know political machines happen all over the place there's there's New York there's Chicago there's all the the sort of expected things but like Huey Long is kind of the archetypal Southern, like, I am the state kind of person. And that's where it gets kind of scary, where all of the populist rhetoric kind of turns into stop sounding like, I don't know, Frederick or Franklin Roosevelt and start sounding like Benito Mussolini, right? And so in a way, it's interesting to talk about Huey Long now because...

Well, we live in a country that has a Huey Long sort of-esque figure at the top who's just not nearly as skilled and powerful in the way that Huey was. Did he really wear white suits all the time? He not only wore white suits, he would wear like purple and pink suits and things. He was a very flashy dresser. I wish they had highlighted that more in the segment. Yeah, they had a white suit, but I should have played a pink one. Yeah, yeah. I mean, I think he was wearing a white suit when he died. But so Huey Long.

Part of his, so we should say, this is a fun little part of his, where he, so he keeps getting elected to political office and then getting impeached because people, you know, he is genuinely opposed to business interests and they come for him. And he upset all of the, like, this is the 30s when the Democratic Party is the only party in the South, right? And it's sort of turning the tide between, you know, the parties have sort of switched alignments in terms of ideology. throughout the century so this is kind of in a flux so this is you know he's uh he's coming in as a populist democrat which is new and um And so when he's elected to the Senate, and I believe that is in 1930, he's worried that his power in the state itself is not going to be consolidated properly. So he actually takes nine months to get to the Senate. He's elected and then delays swearing into the Senate for nine months so that he can stay governor and make sure that the people he wants to be in charge are going to be in charge when he leaves.

So as a senator, he's still basically running Louisiana, though he's not supposed to be, you know. And he's just kind of a loud mouth. He's for the poor. He's Mr. Tough Guy. And there's a lot of reasons I think people liked him because he did genuinely support them. But at the same time, and they do mention this in the episode, that he's sort of insanely vindictive if you are his opponent. I wrote that down and I was like, well, that's admirable. Say what you will about the man, but you knew how to hold a grudge. He absolutely did. And that is kind of comes into the deal with his assassination.

I mean, one of the things that the episode doesn't go into and is probably pretty related to his death is that in 1935, a paramilitary organization was formed in the state called the Square Deal Association explicitly to fight Kiwi Long. Like, these are guys with guns getting ready to go to war. Yeah! Footage is amazing. And I mean, yeah. So like they did have a shootout at the airport in Baton Rouge. And so they're kind of acting in the episode like, who could have seen this coming? This is, you know, why would this simple doctor shoot the senator and things like that? And it's like, well.

There's a lot more to that story, especially around violence and Huey Long as a person, than they're really giving it credit for. So the story of the assassination is that, you know, for whatever reason, the United States senator is in the state capitol building. Not a normal thing, at least today. You know, he isn't a state legislator, right? He is a national legislator and has no legitimate power in the state at that point.

but he he's there he's fighting with people walking around and um this this uh dr weiss um what is his first carl weiss is uh is waiting there supposedly to speak with him but it's at this at some point he's coming out of a guy's office and uh carl weiss allegedly pulls a gun and shoots him and then he would he's bodyguards take out all of their guns and And also that he didn't come back as a zombie. Yeah, no, they just turned him into pulp on the ground. And Huey doesn't die in this incident. He's like, he's like running down the hall. Yeah. And he kind of staggers off and is taken to a hospital. And and this is also not covered. They do cover it a bit in the in the show that.

There's some controversy as to whether a bullet was removed from Long's body, from him. He was still alive at the time. According to some witnesses, it says the episode that they pulled out a slug and by vague descriptions from non-professionals of the bullet, they think it's too big to offend the size of the gun that Carl Weiss had. Other people say there wasn't a bullet that was ever removed from him. One thing we do know is that in Baton Rouge, he went to the hospital and they...

tried to get, this was not in the show, but they tried to get some of the doctors from New Orleans who were, you know, the bigger city, they're more specialists to come up to work on him. But they were in a car crash on the way there. So the chief person in charge at the hospital at the time was kind of like a country doctor. He didn't really know. surgery but he was like i'll give it a shot and tried to do the surgery um and and yeah long ended up dying a few days later three they were like in this segment they claimed that the bullet went into his intestine they like patched up his intestine but then just like don't notice that his kidney is also punctured is that is that line up does that seem accurate i mean that so i i did a little looking and nobody's the thing is like this isn't really a big conspiracy theory. I think you have to be pretty deep into Huey Long lore to be concerned about this. I don't think most people accept that there is any real question to what happened here. I think it's kind of like there are some historians who are very interested in Huey Long as a figure who do want to think that maybe it was an accident or maybe it was...

You know, there are people, though, who think, like, at this time, Long was having a feud with Franklin Roosevelt. So there are people out there who think that this was, like, done by the government. And, you know, it's too early for any of the, like, CIA or FBI stuff. I mean, the FBI existed, but not in the way that we kind of would think of it 30 years later. But, yeah, it's not, you know, the world of conspiracy hadn't really been constructed yet. Literally, people said they were going to kill him, and then he was shot.

I mean, that's the thing. Somebody made a death threat that we're going to shoot you tonight, and then he got shot. And people are like, how could this have happened? Well, and the other thing is that, so they said, oh, his only connection was that his father-in-law was a judge who was being gerrymandered out of being a judge by what Long was doing. And that's true. But Weiss's sister was also fired for being a teacher because of Huey Long. And his sister-in-law, he had a bunch of family. I mean, I think to be sort of prominent in the state.

you were either with or against Huey Long. And if you were against him, you were very against him. So it's, yeah, so it's hard to say. And I don't know, I don't know that there's any evidence that Carl Weiss was part of the Square Deal Association, the sort of paramilitary organization forum, but those were just business owners. You know, they weren't like gorillas in the forest or something. They were just people who hated. You know, they didn't set up a, yeah, it's not like, it's not, yeah, a group living in the swamps, like doing terrorist attacks. They were just, they were business owners. They were, they were,

middle-class people who felt like his sort of strain of, uh, populism was, was detrimental to all the guys getting off of those trucks with guns is wild. It's worth watching the segment just for that. Yeah. I mean, it, yeah. And it's, it's an interesting, I think that, I mean, I know we talk about this later, but I think the reenactment is decent and, um, and it's actually kind of an interesting thing to learn about a guy that is sort of an obscure figure in, in American history.

You know, what he would have done if he hadn't been killed is an interesting question. There's a lot of theories that he was going to run against Franklin. He had originally supported Roosevelt in 1932, but there were theories that he was going to run against him in 36 from even from a more populist standpoint. And then there are theories that he wasn't going to do that. He was going to do some other electioneering. But he would say things like, you know, if I he would always say that Franklin Roosevelt was a fraud because he was from a rich family and that if I can promise way more than he can.

And if I get in there, they'll have trouble getting me out after four terms and things like that. Like he was ready to become, you know, this would become the United States of Huey Long's America and things like that. So I don't know. I mean, he's an interesting figure. They showed his footage from his funeral of all of these people lined up to pay their respects, just like regular people that felt impacted by his policy. So he clearly he was incredibly popular to the people who liked him. 200,000 people went to his funeral.

Yeah, so he's, it's really difficult. It's hard to say. I mean, one of the things a lot of historians point out, so, you know, you think Southern politician in the 30s, and you kind of wonder, one of the interesting things about it, he was opposed to the Ku Klux Klan, and he was opposed to a lot of types of bigotry. He didn't use a lot of race baiting in his speeches or anything. But other historians have said, well, Jim Crow South.

He didn't have to, exactly. That almost went without saying in Louisiana in the 30s. And he also did a thing where he would say what he knew his audience wanted to hear. I guess there's stories of him campaigning in northern Louisiana, which is much more sort of... you know, they were very opposed to alcohol and things like that. And he would, he would be Mr. Teetotaler up in the North. But then when he was down near New Orleans, he was talking about whiskey and others. So he just, he never really, the most important thing to Huey Long was that Huey Long be powerful. And whatever he had to do to get that, it seemed like he was willing to do. But yeah, whether, whether Carl Weiss actually shot him or not, I almost hope not just because that guy seems really sad on the episode.

I mean, but at the same time, I don't think it's such a I don't know that it's like out of the realm of possibility that a doctor whose family is considers themselves being ruined by Huey Long would. snap and take matters into his own hands or would secretly be part of a paramilitary organization set up to violently oppose the Senate. The evidence that they presented was more like, these are not the actions of a man who was planning to kill Huey Long. And I was like, well, what if he wasn't planning to? What if he just did? Like, what if he did go there to talk to him and then Huey wouldn't talk to him and he just snapped and shot him? What do you think of the theory put forth in the episode that there's no way he could have walked into the Capitol building with so many security guards there with a gun without getting frisked or someone noticing the gun and taking it away?

i mean it's that we think of that now like going to an airport or something but they didn't have metal detectors they didn't have you know it would have been this doctor with glasses What I thought was less likely was there was a theory put forward that Carl Weiss punches Huey Long, and then one of the bodyguards accidentally shoots Huey Long, and then they all shoot Carl Weiss to cover it up. But part of that theory was that they went to Carl Weiss's car and got his gun and dropped it. And I was like, how would they fucking know he had a gun? Or what car was his? Or what are you talking about? That doesn't make any sense to me. It seems like the simplest scenario is that Carl Weiss shot him. None of there was an elaborate conspiracy with all this.

all 60 of his security guards to all cover up their accidental murder. I don't know how they would know that he owned a gun or that it was in the glove compartment of his car and that they could go get it and leave it there. That doesn't make any sense to me. Right. I mean, it's hard to say. In a way, I mean, I can't say it doesn't matter, but it isn't really a question that a lot of people have unless you're pretty specifically involved. I do feel bad for his son. He was just a little baby at the time and it would have to be weird growing up and it's like, oh, your dad's an assassin. That's just a strange life. Right.

Yeah, and it doesn't have that same, like, last time I was on, we talked about Sirhan Sirhan, and that is a weird story, right? There's weird stuff in that story. And the Kennedy assassination, there's a lot of weird stuff in that story. And so it's easier to kind of pull strings on that and have stuff fall apart. Here, there's just not that much to pull. And I don't know, I don't like being the guy who comes on and is like, yeah, the official story is always true. But at the same time, I feel like there's just not that much.

Half of Louisiana, you know, maybe 45% of Louisiana hated Huey Long. 55% of Louisiana loved Huey Long. And the people who hated him had like... Who wanted him dead? And then he died. Yeah. Exactly. Yeah.

I would tend to agree. The gun that Carl Weiss used to shoot Huey Long is on display at the Old State Capitol in Baton Rouge if you are looking to go see it. Well, they found it in someone's safety deposit box. Oh, right. Yeah. It was in the police chief for the gear. It was missing for a while and it ended up being in his safety deposit box for some reason. And that is a weird thing. I'll give you that. That's a string. I don't know. I don't think there used to be this really tight chain of custody on stuff.

i think he was kind of like well this is cool and just like hold on to it because it's like a piece of history and that's a big yeah and that's a big part of like why the story is harder to talk about because it is so old and life like the way crimes are handled in the way like yeah you could probably walk into the capitol building with a gun and no one would really notice you know you're not going through a metal detector you're not necessarily being there's not some guard sitting on a stool asking you to open your purse or your backpack or whatever there's it's just not life was different back then you know so it's it's hard to say um i do find it interesting If he grounds more evidence. Yeah, it's an interesting figure. Do you think you're not going to devote your life to this conspiracy? Like the flat earther we watched that documentary about? I'm probably not going to. Not a lot of people talking about this one. So this could be the next big thing. Maybe you should start a podcast all about this. Mac's wearing a t-shirt that says, I am Mac McCormick. And people just come up like, is it really you? The Huey Long conspiracy theorist? I wonder what the merch possibilities of this could be.

I think Matt would have to start wearing a purple suit all the time. Okay. No, you're good. I could dress. I could, I could, yeah. Like those people who like study Mark Twain too much and then start impersonating him and stuff. I could be, uh, the more you, you know, Oh, the more you read about Mark Twain, the more you're like, no, a white three piece suit is a good idea. I like the idea that you're going to start dressing kind of like this Louis, Louisiana dandy, like, but in Minnesota where you're wearing like a purple linen suit and like fanning yourself. Yeah.

If we ever get to go outside ever again. Swelter in in this house. Someone do something. Yeah. Darling, would you get me a glass of frosted lemonade? Perfect. Quench my thirst. Yeah. Wow. My only thought about this case is that they call it a mysterious legend, which is what they call like Bigfoot and the blackness monster. They've done that with other like historical cases too. And I don't know why they just didn't make a like history mystery or something. Mysterious legend.

they do throw the I think last time that was on it was Mysterious Legend and it's yeah like Bigfoot Loch Ness Monster guy who got shot okay one of these things is not like the other yeah unless unless Bigfoot killed him yeah I mean hmm all right Do they have a special name for the Sasquatch in Louisiana? Do we know if there's a swamp version? Maybe there's a swamp ape. Right, yeah. I mean, I think it's... It is weird that they call it a legend, but I don't know. What are you going to do? They didn't have a good category. I don't know that they knew they were going to be doing a lot of assassination talk when they started the show. This segment was called Assassination Talk! I do think the sort of summary of...

But I do think the summary they gave of who he was was a little simplified. I think maybe it... It definitely focused on the better parts of Huey's... Well, I think they wanted it to be more sympathetic, but then it does kind of leave out some of the motivations for killing him. Yeah, which I don't think were noble. I will say that. I think that whoever shot him, if it wasn't an accident as alleged in the show, then was doing it because their liquor store was having a hard time. It wasn't like, we need to stop this man from...

from helping too many people. Yeah, this was probably a pretty sort of personal and business-related grudge. So I'm not like... This actor, like, he loves this role. He got really into it. And I have to say, the actor they got from Dr. Weiss looked just like him. Exactly like him. They had a 40-year-old play a teenager. This guy looked just like him. No, this one was uncanny. Maybe he is somehow a Dr. Weiss impersonator. That's very niche.

He just appears at like historic homes in Louisiana. It is I, Carl Weiss. He's one of the least popular accounts on Fiverr. He has a cameo, it's only $1. Carl Weiss impersonator. Yeah. It's me, Carl Weiss, assassin of Huey Long. Just want to say happy birthday to Jenna. Obviously Samantha and I should start doing cameo. We should do it for like 50 cents.

We should try to have the cheapest cameo. Yeah. We should try to have the cheap. I'm pretty sure you have to be invited to do it. What would be our cut of 50 cent cameos? I don't know. I think they were kind of like hitting up celebrities. They were being a little shady with the quarantine with like, hey, you're going to be stuck inside. All I know about that is that Trixie Mattel keeps turning them down. If you wanted that Trixie Mattel cameo, it's apparently not happening. But ours for 50 cent shows up. I'll record some cameos for a quarter.

We'll spend it on beef jerky. We do a lot of cameos to get beef jerky. It's expensive. Goddamn, you're right. You're so right. Oh, I have another update for everyone, and it's so sad, and that's that I no longer work at a salon, and I no longer have access to hair, so Mac's not going to get a surprise rat tail. Mac, do you really, really want a rat tail? Yeah, I dodged a bullet. Is that a really weird prank? No. You know, yeah. I think maybe when I was in, like, third grade, that would have been exciting, but I don't know that...

Back when the new kids on the block all had rat tails. Listener Gary, who photoshopped me and Robert Stagg with rat tails. Those are pretty good. If you want to see Robert Stagg with a rat tail. Who could you not? We've been waiting for this all our lives. Okay, there's one more. Do you feel like you've done justice to your segment? I feel like you have. Yeah, I think so. I mean, I don't know. Yeah, this isn't the biggest mystery ever, but it is interesting to learn about Huey Long, and he's worth looking into. I know nothing about him, so I thought it was pretty interesting.

Samantha, you have our last message. Save just for you. It worked out perfect. You always get lost love and you always get treasure. So we are looking for the siblings of Mary Jane. And this is how the story goes. On a summer day in 1947, a housewife in Weed, California was walking through an overgrown field, which is appropriate. As you do. In Weed, California. She's walking through a field. Strange name. From like getting groceries or something. When she finds a young girl beaten and abandoned, just like sitting in the tall grass. This is so sad.

She was taken to a hospital and placed in intensive care. Due to shock, she was unable to speak to anyone or tell them who she was. She was nicknamed Baby X by the nurses at the hospital. They couldn't come up with, like, a cuter nickname for her. That sounds like some sort of cyber robot. Baby X. I don't want to see the movie where Baby X turns into, like, an assassin or something. Oh, my God. Do you know who it is? It's Baby X. Baby X. This is the Muppet Baby version of Wolverine. The thing is, even though the makeup is so bad, just being with, like, very...

bruised, beaten child in a field, even though it's, like, not realistic. It's still so sad. She was kept in the hospital because the authorities did not know what to do with her. Her photograph was... That's the solution! The photograph was distributed to several newspapers across various states, and then two weeks later, a witness came forward identifying the girl as Mary Jane Medlin, the daughter of Lucille Medlin of Selma, Oregon. Lucille was staying in a log cabin in Selma with her boyfriend, young son, and older daughter. A police officer got out of his car. This reenactment police officer is ridiculous.

and he approaches the couple showing a photograph of mary jane beaten and bruised to the boyfriend who did not first denies that he even knows who the girl is but then when because he's garbage seal admits that the girl in the photograph is her daughter and the boyfriend confesses to abandoning the child but claims that he did not beat her uh apparently he's he's like all i did is abandon her and it's fine beat her like Who else? Okay, this guy is really trash. The couple had apparently decided to abandon the child because they thought they were unable to raise three children. Lucille and her boyfriend were arrested and charged with child abandonment and assault. Lucille was allowed one visit with Mary Jane in the hospital where Mary Jane met her younger brother, James, for the first time. A few weeks later, Lucille and her boyfriend pleaded guilty to the charges against them and were sentenced to 20 years in prison. Mary Jane, her three-year-old sister, Leoma, and her four-week-old brother, James, became wardens of the state and were separated.

Mary Jane initially went to live with her biological father, but later spent time in several foster homes. She married at the age of 16. She and her husband now own a successful restaurant in Placerville, California. They have four children and 10 grandchildren. in 1988 mary jane began searching for her siblings and in 1991 she found her sister leo mccrane um they were reunited uh it was really cute because in the episode mary jane describes how scared she was that her sister was going to reject her and she's great and then you see them like together they're friends it was really cute they're like walking down the street and she's like i think i'd like to buy that teapot and the other one's like why don't we go see how much it is Mary Jane and Leoma are now searching for their long lost brother, James Gilreath. James was born on June 14th, 1947 in either Selma or Grants Pass, Oregon. He may have been adopted by an Oregon family and they believe that his name may have been changed to Donald. So an interesting note on this case that I found when I was looking it up on Unsolved Mysteries Wiki is that before Mary Jane was identified, some investigators speculated that she was a missing Oklahoma child named Joan Gay Croft, who was also featured on Unsolved Mysteries. Although I don't know when, I assume we'll come to it eventually. She was a girl that went missing from an Oklahoma city in the aftermath of a horrible tornado.

apparently the tornado hit the town and she and her sister were hiding in the basement and her mom her mom found them in the basement and she was fine but then her mom had to go to the hospital and in the aftermath her sister said that two men came into the basement and abducted her um and so a lot of people thought that this wow if you look at the photo of joan they do kind of look similar her and mary jane now it wasn't it wasn't her because mary jane was identified um but i just thought that was interesting So this case is solved. James' adopted sister was watching the broadcast and contacted her mother, who contacted James. His name is now Donald. He goes by Donald Barrow, and he lives in Fresno, California. Two weeks after the broadcast, Donald and his family drove to Placerville, California, where they were reunited with Mary Jane and Leoma. The siblings had not seen each other in over 45 years. Sadly, Leoma Crane passed away in 2008, but they did get together, so that was nice.

It's a very sweet reunion. Donald is like, I'm a dude that doesn't know how to show emotions, but I have a lot of emotions right now. He seems so happy. He brought them presents and balloons that say congratulations. i just i just couldn't stop from thinking of him at the balloon store at the like counter just like no that doesn't work get some balloons what are they gonna say uh yeah happy birthday thank you no that doesn't make sense uh i guess congratulations it's so cute it's really interesting for me to see these people that feel such a like deep connection with their siblings that they essentially have never known and yet And yet they still, I mean, she literally saw him one time for a few minutes. They thought that she was two years old when she was found. So I don't remember anything from being a two-year-old, but she remembers seeing her brother once, and she carried that with her for her entire life. And wanted to find him, and he's clearly so happy to be a part of their lives, and it's just really sweet. So, yep, that's the story of, oh, Donald does have a mustache. Oh, that's true. I would look better without it. It's a little bit creepy, but you know what? I called it the happy family.

It's a very big mustache. It's very triangle in shape. Yeah. Yeah. But I was just so happy for Donald. You know what? Yeah. Yeah. All right. Should we rate this episode? Yeah, that's the whole episode. We only get three mysteries in this one. So let's go ahead and rate it. That's really not that mysterious. A fire. Not mysterious. A guy getting assassinated who a bunch of people wanted to kill. Not that mysterious. Lost love. Not that mysterious. Thumbs down.

I say so. Reenactments with our next category. They were really good. I think they were good. Yeah, that was good. Do you guys know if, like, I kind of wonder sometimes if Unsolved Mysteries is like buying footage from documentaries that don't end up working out or something? Because, like, because sometimes they have these reenactments that are really good. And, I mean, obviously sometimes they have, like, the actual family members of missing people or whatever sort of walk down and go like, oh, no, what happened? You know, and so that explains some of it. But sometimes...

the quality is sharply different from when it isn't and it makes me wonder if they like thought something here you know because they don't get any of this real people they just end up getting much better actors because like you're right sometimes we have that makes sense yeah clearly put a lot of work into finding actors that actually like know how to act and look like the people and then in our last episode we have like that weird lake monster It was almost confusing. Yeah, yeah. They're playing college-age students and teenagers and don't look anything like them. And you're like, what is happening right now? But I think that probably something like this, they could feature in the commercials and they just poured more money into it. And some of the more typical segments are kind of just like, eh, we can stretch our dollar. Right. Our next category is fashion. Okay, I have to say thumbs up because...

Mac's now going to be wearing three-piece linen suits all the time. I thought the fashion was pretty good, actually. And Robert Stack, he's got a few different locations. At one point, for no reason, but he's got the trip. Yeah. No reason at all. None of these have anything to do with the woods. This is definitely, he just refused to show up one day, so they sent the camera. This is actually Robert Stack's backyard. Are those all the categories? Well, we didn't rate Robert Stack.

Yeah, I think this episode's pretty good. Even though it's only three mysteries, they did a good job of covering them. I thought it was pretty solid. I liked it. I feel like 3.5, maybe? I'm there with you. Yep, 3.5. It's not quite a 4, but it is really good. Matt, what do you think? Yeah, I think that's right. It's a nice ending, yeah. So you get one.

Fire was interesting, but not, like, I don't know. I mean, it's like, oh, that sucks. Huey Long was interesting, though. Contemporary arson, you get a historical assassination, and then you get, like, a nice, like, current lost love. Just sort of ended up on a high note. Yeah. I agree if a ghost had been in there that would have really kicked it out over the line. I agree. Do we have recommendations this week? Okay. I have the simplest, almost, like, goody-two-shoes recommendation for this week, which is that in these trying times, I feel like people should try journaling. I think...

It's very overwhelming. It's very stressful. We're all feeling a lot of emotions. Maybe you don't want to, you know, burden other people who are also stressed out feeling all these things. It really helps to write stuff down. I personally, I kind of hate doing it, but I always feel better after I do it. You don't really need like a special anything. You have a notebook. When I had an office job, I used to journal at work and put that in Dropbox. You don't really need a like special whatever, I think.

just to like process those emotions and get them down will be helpful that is my recommendation super simple it just occurs to me now that all the people who are like really into bullet journaling yeah that's not what i'm recommending i'm recommending more just like sit down write whatever you're thinking just spill it out don't worry about it being like very profound or like eloquent or anything like that just like be like hey today i was worried about this but i have plenty of pasta the dogs what you know whatever write it out and i also just think this is going to be like a very important time in your life and it will be interesting to look back and remember what this is like because it's so fucking weird that's my recommendation a weird recommendation but it's something that I've been enjoying as I've been stuck at home and that is live animal cameras so oh yes yes yes great idea I recommend eagle cams because it just so happens Minnesota has one you can find it it's a really good camera it even has sound if you want to hear the eagles it's the Minnesota DNR's non-game eagle cam you can google it and you can find it's on YouTube

um and the eagles just hatched three chicks like just last week the third one hatched and i've watched this eagle cam for a few years they had a transitional period where they have like lost the camera one season so like whatever but it's a nest that's actually kind of close to my work so i drive by it when i'm actually going to work and um first of all seeing the little baby chicks you can it's fun to see them be fed like the parents will like bring fish and stuff to the nest and then feed little babies and you can watch them grow up um but also like people get so into these eagle cameras this year for the first time i joined the facebook group for the eagle camera and there is I cannot think of something more wholesome than just all of these old people on Facebook that are just like so invested in the lives of these eagles. They have names. They're going to have a naming contest for the chicks pretty soon, which is like, that's so fun. Screenshots and like post updates in the group. It'll be like feeding at 4 55 PM. It looks like all three babies got something to eat. It's like so adorable. They'll like narrate the like lives of these. Cause they're like, they're also like a new pair of eagles, I guess. And so like, they have this whole like thing about how they're new parents and like, I don't know, maybe other people aren't as into this as I am, but it's really fun to watch. And it's like very low stakes and low stress. And it's something that you can.

Back around the 2016 election for a while, I was watching this walrus cam a lot. I forget exactly what, but somewhere on the coast of California, they had set up a camera where this place where all these walruses hung out. And for some reason, it was so relaxing to watch. And they eventually turned off that camera. So I should find a new one. But something about also because you had like the ocean noise, like lapping. And then, you know, the walrus, you know, having a grand old time.

I was like, this is the stuff. Hook it to my veins. Because people are stuck at home and need something to do. So you could probably just look around on the internet to see if there's a different animal that might interest you. I really like the eagles just because it's fun to watch the babies grow up. I will say that, yeah. I need a capybara cam, though.

I'm looking for that. It's the Southwest Florida one. And that one has had like some drama this year, actually, because there was. Oh, what? Actually, that one has had drama for a few years. The only reason I watch it is because I think a year ago or two years ago, one of the babies got attacked by an owl and fell out of the nest before it was ready to fly. And they like collected it and like rehabilitated it. So I still follow that camera on Facebook. And I noticed I saw this year that one of their baby that they had hatched one baby and it had died. And there was a huge like conspiracy about whether or not there was a fish hook in one. And that's why I like the baby died. And like.

Because I guess the people that run those organizations, like the local DNR, don't intervene if it's, like, a natural, if something is happening naturally. Like, with the three babies, one of them might die. That's just kind of how it goes. Not often do you get all three. So, like, they won't intervene if it's natural. But if it was, like, a man-made calamity or, like, something unusual, like the owl attack, they will. But they didn't, and then it died. And so everyone was upset because they thought that they saw, like, a fishhook. But it turns out it probably died because the parents brought something to the nest that had been killed with rat poison. But then the parents...

the adult eagles laid another egg and I guess it just hatched. So they have like another baby in the Southwest one. So if you want to watch that go down. Mac, is this going to be your new conspiracy? Eagles conspiracy? They killed him. They killed him. They was assassinated. In frame 44391, you can clearly see a fish hook. This is murder. Don't believe what they're telling you. Like cruises or conventions. Do you think people from the eagle conspiracy will like start going to that? They've got a little, they've got a little cardboard thing that, yeah.

The eagle conspiracy. They're like in the corner with, you know, it's like, oh, we can never compete with like flat earth. Yeah, that's a good philosophy, I think. Matt, did you have a recommendation for us? Yeah, I do want to recommend the, I mentioned it, the episode of the dollop about Huey Long, because I don't know that I did a great job explaining sort of his trajectory. It's episode number 215. It's from like three years ago. It's very good. And they go into it a lot more in depth. And that podcast in general is fun to listen to. They talk about a lot of weird.

history moments that you might not have heard of. There's a really good one about Australia losing a war against emus. There's an emu war in Australia and the emus won. It has been a hard year for Australia. I hope our Australian listeners are okay. They had all those fires. Then they had floods. Now they have this. The floods put out the fires. Plus emu wars. Take care of Tom Hanks.

So you say. That was a while ago. I think they would probably win today, but at the time it was closer. But that's a good podcast. I recommend. And the episode about Huey Long, if you're interested in... Well, I think that pretty much wraps it up for another week in quarantine. I mean, I guess, if anyone cares about anything anymore, we are on social media, Twitter, Instagram. We have a Facebook group. If you just want to talk to people, you can go to our Facebook group. You can really talk about whatever. We don't care. We have Patreon. If you're in need of some...

Yes. If you're in need of some bonus extra content, you can go get our whole back Patreon thing for a dollar. I know. So you can Google, you can find us. There's also links on various places, including our website.

If you want to give us a five-star review, we could use a pick-me-up. We'd appreciate it. Is there anything else that we're supposed to plug? We're going to keep doing this as long as we can. Figure you could use something to listen to and we could use something to do. Hang tight. Stay inside. Stay safe. Five listeners. I think that's pretty much it. Don't worry about solving any mysteries. You're on break right now. That's fine. Yeah, don't worry about it. Thank you, Mac. Thanks for doing some research.

Bye, everyone. Bye, B1.

Frequently asked questions

When was this Perhaps It's You episode published?

This episode was published on March 26, 2020.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Perhaps It's You episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.