Skip to content
Saving Baseball’s Soul: Fans First, Chaos Allowed episode artwork

Sep 18, 2025 26 min

Saving Baseball’s Soul: Fans First, Chaos Allowed

from The Baseball Insiders Hosted by FanSided

Author Jane Leavy joins Adam Weinrib to unpack Make Me Commissioner: a fan-first blueprint to restore baseball’s soul. From Cape Cod’s Eldridge Park to today’s metrics-first MLB, we cover wood bats, shifts still legal on the Cape, NIL/draft churn, and two competing arm-health fixes—shrink to 11 pitchers (force real starting pitching) vs expand to 15–16 with honest, fluid usage to reduce TJs. Plus: Roger Angell’s critique, Dave Roberts’ tough calls, why the challenge system (not full robo-umps) is coming, and what MLB can learn from the Savannah Bananas: “Fans first, entertainment always.” — Why Cape Cod = Baseball’s Soul — The Illusion of “Nothing Changes” (MLB $$, nets, safer parks) — Wood Bats Return: New Sound, Old Game — Shifts on the Cape: Still Legal, Still Used — NIL & Draft Timing → Showcase League (Cotuit’s 40-player churn) — 2023 Firebirds: A Real Team (feat. Labradoodle “Betty”) — Air Bud vs. MLB Rules: Dogs Taking Infield? — Roger Angell’s Lament: “They Took Away Half the Game” — From $18 Beers to Fading Primacy — “Throw Till You Break”: The Rays Model — Fix Idea #1: 11-Man Staffs—Make Starters Pitch — We Lost the ‘Third-Time-Through’ Chess Match — No-No Drought, Yamamoto Close & Letting Him Finish — Pulling Kershaw/Hill: Are We Precluding Greatness? — Fix Idea #2: 15–16 Arms, Fluid Usage, Fewer TJs — First Act as Commish: Kids 10 & Under Free (Math Checks Out) — Next Up: Challenge System... Full Robo-Umps — Savannah Bananas Lesson: “Fans First, Entertainment Always” — Clutch Defined (Sue Bird) & Measuring the Immeasurable SUBSCRIBE to The Moonshot, our weekly baseball email newsletter, where the FanSided MLB team, including Robert Murray, break down all the biggest stories in the big leagues with humor, insight and behind-the-scenes info: https://fansided.us5.list-manage.com/subscribe?u=b9bb472d0aa5e8abf01e2ced7&id=fa28ec1e24 Join our Discord channel! Become a member HERE to get started: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC7_dK0B3mwchuelVrj_M-ng/join --- SUBSCRIBE: https://www.youtube.com/c/TheBaseballInsiders Follow Robert: https://twitter.com/ByRobertMurray Follow Adam: https://twitter.com/AdamWeinrib --- #MLB #Baseball #MakeMeCommissioner #CapeCodLeague #OrleansFirebirds #RogerAngell #PitchingInjuries #RoboUmp #SavannahBananas #FanExperience

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Saving Baseball’s Soul: Fans First, Chaos Allowed

0:00 26:02

No transcript yet.

Requests help us decide what to transcribe next.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of The Baseball Insiders?

This episode is 26 minutes long.

When was this The Baseball Insiders episode published?

This episode was published on September 18, 2025.

Can I download this The Baseball Insiders episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.