Saving History: Gutelius House & Ragamuffin Hall

Frank Stroik, Board President of Preservation Mifflinburg, shares the remarkable rescue story of the Gutelius House Museum. When the historic 1803 log home faced demolition in a 1997 auction, a small group of community members came together in an unforgettable moment of urgency and purpose. With help from nearby neighbors and a local Justice of the Peace—honoring Frederick Gutelius himself, Union County’s first Justice—they secured the property and sparked a preservation movement.Conrad Fisher shares the story behind Ragamuffin Hall—its deep roots, remarkable transformation, and growing cultural impact. Once the historic McCoysville Presbyterian Church, founded in 1777 by circuit preacher William Logan, the building has witnessed centuries of change, from open-air sermons to its 19th-century brick structure completed in 1871. After serving its congregation for over 150 years, the church closed its doors in November 2022—only to begin a new chapter the very next day when Conrad took ownership and reimagined the space as Ragamuffin Hall.