Skip to content
Season Three | Episode Five: "New Voices" episode artwork

Jan 20, 2023 40 min

Season Three | Episode Five: "New Voices"

from Down the Path Hosted by Will Rice

In Episode Five, in 2022 host Will Rice was able to interview the two people who were hired by Stanley Bain to manage the Cargill Creek and Grassy Cay Lodge for the 1995/1996 fishing Season. Just one of their responsibilities – was managing and maintaining all of the boats. Music: Theme music for Down the Path was written and recorded by Alex Flock: www.alexflock.com. Season Three of Down the Path is being supported by The Flyfish Journal. Visit www.theflyfishjournal.com/downthepath for a special offer available to Down the Path listeners.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Season Three | Episode Five: "New Voices"

0:00 40:30
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hey listeners, this is Will Rice. Welcome to season three of Down the Path, which is being supported once again by the Fly Fish Journal. The Fly Fish Journal is a quarterly print magazine and digital platform that showcases the highest quality imagery and fly fishing's greatest stories. FFJ supports independent projects like Down the Path and other freelance journalists, photographers, and storytellers in each one of their issues. They'd also like to offer Down the Path listeners a special subscription offer. To learn more and subscribe, visit theflyfishjournal.com backslash down the path.

And they said, well, Stanley's looking for someone. We can't promise anything. But if you come down with us, he'll pay your airfare. And at the very least, you'll have a couple weeks down there, which sounded good to me. I was interested in the job and wanted a little adventure. And that's how I ended up going to Cargill for the first time. As we begin Episode 5 of Down the Path, Season 3, I'm sure as listeners, you have quite a few questions about the disappearance of Stanley Bain, his crew of four, and three fishing boats. I'm pretty sure they are some of the same questions that I had as I was researching this story.

I'm going to continue to try to unpack and contemplate some of the remaining scenarios that you heard about in earlier episodes. My name is Will Rice, and you're listening to Down the Path Season 3. This is Episode 5. In Episode 5 and 6, I'm going to pose these questions to people who knew, worked for, and fished with Stanley Bain. Before we get into those questions and those scenarios, I need to explain how I came to interview Jeff Shainer and Sandy McMaster in the late summer of 2022. Jeff is who you heard from at the top of this episode, and you've heard clips from my interview with him in previous episodes as well.

When my story about Stanley Bain was first published in 2007, I really didn't hear too much about it. I'd run into fishing buddies or people at fly fishing trade shows and they might say something like, hey, great story about that guy who went missing in the Bahamas. What do you think really happened? My answer was always the same. I honestly have no idea. It wasn't until 2008 the print story made its way to the digital world. I remember there being a few online comments, but there wasn't a whole lot of feedback, at least that I was aware of. That all changed in March of 2010 when I received an email from someone named Jeff with no last name.

who didn't seem to think that I got the story exactly right. Or at least I didn't include all of the right details and backstory. As it turns out, Jeff was Jeff Shainer, who worked at Cargill Creek and Grassy Key Lodge in the 1994-1995 season prior to the disappearance, as well as the early portion of the 95 season after the disappearance. It took me a little while to connect the dots and realize that Jeff was the other half of the quote-unquote brother and sister team that has been brought in to manage the lodge. Again, that's detail from the Angling Report story you heard from back in episode one.

Jeff confirmed that his sister was in fact the same Sandra McMaster who I tried to track down and interview five years earlier. In those early email conversations back and forth, I felt Jeff was a bit cagey. He would share some details or anecdotes if he felt them to be absolutely factual, but he was a bit vague when it came to what he thought might have happened or what he heard from others when he was there. Here's an example from March of 2010 when I asked him what he had heard from others or what he thought might have happened from an email exchange. I still say it was an accident, bad weather and bad seamanship.

Only one person I knew had enough motive, self-professed hate for Stanley and the Lodge, and enough criminality and connections to make me wonder. But if there's any proof of anything, I don't have it. When I asked who that person might be, no definitive answer. But fair enough, I get it. But here's the thing. Knowing that there is someone possibly out there who had motive, hate for Stanley and the Lodge, and connections to criminals that perhaps had something to do with the incident is interesting. But it didn't help me from a research perspective. There was nothing really for me to go on. There was no one new I could reach out to or try to interview.

Jeff and I communicated via email again in 2014 after I returned from another trip to South Andros that you'll hear about on a later episode. Long story short, though our conversations were interesting and what Jeff shared about working at the lodge was really compelling, I never felt I had enough to move the story forward. That all changed in 2021 when I received an email via downthepathpodcast.com from Jeff. We hadn't been in contact for over seven years. I'll read you Jeff's original email from August 3rd, 2021.

I've shown it to a few people and the reviews were somewhat encouraging. Anyway, if you'd like some excerpts, I'd be thrilled to share them with you. If this is of any interest, we could talk more. Thank you, Jeff. P.S. I've been enjoying the podcast.

And yes, as a side note, listeners and fans, I read and respond to every single email listeners send me about down the path. I always appreciate your comments and the feedback. Thank you. So Jeff sent me his manuscript that documented his days spent at the Cargill Creek Lodge, traveling back and forth between Nassau, Andros Island, and down to Grassy Key. The diary entries are expansive and fascinating and filled with incredible detail.

The stories about life at Cargill Creek and Grassy Key and the other anecdotes were enough that I wanted to share them with Down the Path listeners, as I do believe this type of detail about the day-to-day workings of the lodge from 1994 into 1995 really brings additional context to the story, details that I didn't have back when I originally was doing my research. So here are excerpts from my interview with Jeff Shainer and his sister, Sandy McMaster, who both had intimate knowledge of the Cargill Creek and Grassy Key Lodges, Stanley Bain himself, his crew, and what happened before and after August 5th, 1995. Where appropriate, I'm going to include additional commentary from Brian O'Keefe on certain topics as well. Some of the questions I'm going to dig into include, where did the boats and crew go missing? And what were they doing? I wanted to talk about the boats. What kind of condition were they in?

How about the weather and storms? During that time of the year, was a summer storm the possible culprit? Had anything like this ever happened before? What about the possibility of hijackings or pirates? And why did they have so much money on the boat? What about Cuba? And there will be more questions asked and answered in episode six as well. For now, here's Jeff Shainer. My name's Jeff Shainer, and I live in upstate New York. I live on one of the Finger Lakes. Grew up here and have lived here for most of my life, except for various years when I was off living in other places. But this has been my home.

for most of my life, and I used to do quite a lot of fishing, and it got to be a profession for a while. These days I fish for fun, and not very much professional fishing in my life anymore. Kind of semi-retired, I was an archaeologist for about 15 years, and now I do various things, including carving trophy fish and painting and things such as that. Tell me a little bit about how you ended up saltwater fishing and how you ended up down in the Bahamas in the 1990s.

Yeah, well, I've always been saltwater fishing. I was lucky. I had a father who was in the Navy, and he had a love of the ocean, and I had uncles who lived on the East Coast from the Mid-Atlantic and also down in Florida. So at a very early age, I was exposed to saltwater fishing, and it's just what I've always loved. And not just the fishing, also just the environment, the creatures, the marine biology. When you get exposed to that when you're a little kid, you never quite get it out of your system.

And so I was fishing the mid-Atlantic in Jersey and Maryland when I was very young, the Florida Keys when I was very young. So I never really started fishing. It's just something I've always done. And when I couldn't be at the ocean, I lived in a place that has some very good fishing. And so I've always been a fisherman of every type. I've always loved boats. I've always had, you know, I grew up with sailboats and rowing skiffs. And when I was in my teens, my dad bought a small center console and we were taking that.

way out in the ocean, further than we should have when I was 16 or 17 years old. I was driving that boat 100 miles offshore and scared the whole time, but we'd go right back out there and do it again. And that was before GPS and all the fancy electronics. It was just chart navigation, a stopwatch, and a course protractor. But I love that kind of fishing. I love fishing offshore. And then when we'd get down to the Keys, it was just like paradise because you only had to go four or five miles off the shore to get to where the big pelagic fish live.

And so I've always been a boat person. Our story kind of picks up right around 1994. And so could you walk listeners through, you know, kind of what was going on in your life, what you were doing in 1994, and how you first were introduced to Stanley Bain and Cargill Creek Lodge? And, you know, if you have to back that up a little bit, you know, feel free to do that. But if you could kind of let us know where your life intersected with Stanley Bain and South Andros Island. The first time I...

got to Cargill Creek Lodge and met Stanley Bay, was in 1992 on one of the trips that my brother, who managed a fly shop in Syracuse, had set up. And I would stay behind while the others were off doing guided fishing, and I did talk to Stanley. We talked about my captain's license. We talked about offshore fishing, which were subjects that interested him quite a bit. And I went again in 1993, and pretty much the same thing happened. You could tell that the lodge was...

It was a little shaky in those years. There were some issues with supplies and accommodating the guests and food. But the way I came to work at CART was in 1994, my brother... mentioned to me that some acquaintances of him, some people I've met, Joe and Millie Elgway had taken a job to manage Cargill Creek for the 1994-1995 season. That was in the spring of 1994. And my brother said they're looking for someone to manage the new grassy key camp and that I should go talk to Joe and Millie, which I did. I might have gone over to their house for lunch, I think.

And they said, well, Stanley's looking for someone. We can't promise anything. But if you come down with us, he'll pay your airfare. And at the very least, you'll have a couple weeks down there, which sounded good to me. I was interested in the job and wanted a little adventure. And that's how I ended up going to Cargill for the first time.

I was very interested to hear what Jeff thought about Stanley and his first impressions. Did he strike you more as a businessman? Did he strike you more as a lodge owner, an angler, all of the above? What were your initial impressions of him as a person? My initial impression to Stanley is that he loved fishing, and that's what we would have talked about. He was just really enthusiastic about our talk of offshore fishing. That was something that really stand out to me.

In addition to Jeff's first impressions of Stanley, I wanted to know about what it was like on Andros Island and the Cargill Creek Lodge. We'd catch a charter flight from Fort Lauderdale, right over Bimini, fill out our immigration forms, land at Andros Town, and then catch a taxi the 30 minutes or so it took to get down to Cargill Creek, which is the southern extreme of the northern part of Andros Island. South of Cargill Creek is North Bight and the other Bights, and then you get down to South Andros. And during 92...

And 1993, when I first went there, the Grassy Key Camp, which is at the southern tip of the island, about a 70-mile boat run, Cargill Creek, that new lodge was under construction. And it was an awesome undertaking to build a lodge that could accommodate 20 people in the middle of nowhere, virtually inaccessible. And that was under construction in 92 and 93. And both times, I did go down there and stay overnight. Cargill Creek Lodge.

was, I think, suffering by then, partially because of the money and the work and the personal energy that it was taking to build the new venture down at Grassy Key. The main lodge at Carville Creek was in need of some repair and some better. Prior to my interview with Jeff, I had interviewed a retired Coast Guard captain. You heard from him at the end of episode four. After his input, I was very eager to hear what Jeff's job was at the lodge and his thoughts on the boats, including the larger boat named the Why Me, as well as the Skiffs.

And rather than being the manager of the Brassy Key Camp, which is what I had gone down there to do, I ended up being a kind of a co-manager with Joe and Millie at the Carville Creek Lodge because there was so much work to do. The place had fallen into such disrepair, and there was just so much labor that had to be done. I was disappointed at the time to not be the manager of Grassy Key Camp at that moment, but it made sense because there was so much to do at Cargill Creek. And the way we would, we started taking trips or taking groups of guests to Grassy Key. We always just called it the key. We started taking groups to the key.

probably in mid-September of 1994. And at first we had a 22-foot center console, which it was made by Answer Marine in Miami. We just called it The Answer. So we had The Answer, which is a 22-foot center console with a 225 horsepower outboard. And we use that primarily to get fuel, food, laundry, you know, everything that was needed to accommodate guests. And the guests themselves, we use that boat to get people and supplies and materials from the main lodge to the quay, which was a good 70 or 75 miles south through a very, very treacherous passage of shallow water. And, you know, it was all coral reefs on the east side of the island and shallow shoals on the west side. So it was a significant bit of navigation, incredible logistics.

The amount of fuel, really, really unsustainable in many ways. And quite dangerous, too. And we were also taking skiffs back and forth from the main lodge to the Grassy Key Camp. And the whole time, Grassy Key Camp was still being constructed. We were, I think, by that winter of 94, 95, we could accommodate up to 15 people at a time at Grassy Key Camp. But that would have, when it was finished, it would have been up to about 20 or 25 people at a time.

which is significant, which is a significant number of people to take care of. Just the amount of fuel that it took to run the boats and to supply that place is really something. Just like if you're going to launch a space shuttle into space, it takes an awful lot of fuel just to get to the first stage, just to transport the fuel that you need for the second stage, to transport the fuel that you need for the third stage. So it was really something. We also had the Wymane, which is, I don't know, a 34, 36-foot horse sport fisherman. It was pretty decrepit. At that time, it was a good 20 or 30 years old. And it had engine problems, and it leaked quite a bit. And on several occasions, when that boat wasn't broken, we loaded up with tons of supplies. And Stanley would take that boat down to resupply the key. You did quite a bit of boat and engine maintenance. Am I correct in that?

Oh, yeah. When I first got down there, there were virtually none of the skiffs were in running condition. They had broken transoms. They had holes in the bottom. The paint were peeling. The seats were broken off. The motors were in just a state of disrepair. Virtually none of the, I think there were 10 outboards in the boat building at Cargill Creek when I first got there. And none of them were in working condition. And I mean, I can take an outboard apart and put it back together, but I'm no mechanic. And there were no spare parts.

There were no tools. There were not even any manuals. So it was doing what you could do with what you had. For the first several months, I was doing constant boat maintenance. Just boat repair, I should almost say. Rebuilding motors, or at least lower units and power packs and everything that can go wrong with a motor except for power head issues, which I couldn't fix. But just rebuilding transoms, painting boats, just getting those boats working again. And in addition to all the other maintenance, toilets, sinks.

air conditioners, windows, everything that had fallen into disrepair. There was a lot of work to do every day. After reading Jeff's diary and manuscript and talking to him over the phone, it was clear that as an employee of Stanley Bain's, he wore a lot of hats. In addition to the lodge itself, fixing and maintaining boats, logistics involved with the Grassy Key camp, the lodge guests needed to eat. And this, as simple as it sounds, appears to be the root cause of what happened to Stanley Bain and his crew.

I'll let Jeff explain. Now, one of your other jobs there, based on our earlier conversations, you did quite a bit of fishing to feed not only other staff at the lodge, and I guess lodges, but as well as some of the guests. Can you talk a little bit about that work you did? Yeah. I mean, I'm someone who loves to fish. I found myself, whenever I had any spare time, sort of having to be the commercial fisherman for the lodge.

We would have bought what we could, but the local fishermen weren't really supplying us with enough. And there was a lot to make up for. We needed to catch a lot of fish and a lot of conk and a lot of crawfish. The first few months, I'd always been a diver and a snorkeler, and I'd been catching crawfish. I was a kid in spearfishing and fishing offshore, so none of that was new to me, but it was a new area to learn. And the local folks weren't real big on showing an outsider around. You kind of had to figure things out for yourself. So there was a definite learning curve, and there was a lot of commercial fishing. It was a lot. So I was reef fishing. I was collecting conch. I was spearing. And then a little later in the season, I was fishing offshore.

In all of that, you know, with the different boats, you know, your trips out to the Blue Water, you know, to do some fishing, runs down to Grassy Key to the south, runs up north to Nassau. Did you have during that, you know, kind of 94, 95 season, were there, you know, were there boat issues? Did you have kind of near miss situations that concerned you? Yeah, absolutely. Every day was basically a life or death gamble. This was not safe.

Stanley and the other Bahamians of Andros, they were watermen. And they weren't into redundancy and float plans. And they would basically go by the skin of their teeth and trust in God. That was the Androsian waterman way. I had come from a different culture where you tell people where you're going, you're there at a certain time. If not, then someone's going to come looking for you. Boat maintenance. I came from a different culture of seamanship.

I found, while I was there, adopting the Bahamian way. And like I say, I was young, or younger anyway. Being a little reckless suited me. I wouldn't have been reckless with a guest, never. But reckless with myself, yeah. I found myself enjoying my adventures with the Bahamians. I enjoyed it very much. I asked Jeff if he could remember or describe situations that were of particular concern. We had some very, very close calls. One time, Stanley was bringing the whiny over from Nassau, the tongue of the ocean between Andros and Nassau.

It is a very significant piece of water. It gets rough. The seas get mountains. And we had deadlines. We, Stanley, had to get parts or materials to the Quay in order to accommodate the guests who were booked. We had to get these materials and this fuel to the island, to Cargill, and then down to Grassy Quay. And we had to do it on time, or a whole lot of people would be really mad at us. So the deadlines were really making us take risks. And one time, Stanley was coming across from NASA.

The Wyoming, the sport fisherman, it had, oh, I can't remember how many tons of bags of cement and cans of it. Just the boat was overloaded to begin with, just packing. Imagining packing as much stuff as a 36-foot boat will hold without sinking. I mean, it was just really, really packed. And as he was coming across from Nassau, he developed transmission problems, and he couldn't make way, had no steerage, and the boat began to go sideways in the swells.

And this is all in the dark. Miraculously, he drifted across the reef crest and missed some reef crest islands. Just a miracle if he hit those or if the boat had sunk. That would have been the end of him. So I got a call. It must have been 5 in the morning. Stanley called on his cell phone, and he said he needed a tow. And Stanley's brother, William, who was one of the guys who worked at the lodge, he came along with me, and he pointed the way through the coral heads in the dark.

And by the time it was getting light, we were beginning to approach where Stanley was. We miraculously found him and spent the rest of the morning towing him in the overloaded boat back to Cargill. But that was a close call. And there were quite a lot of those. Wow. Yeah, that does sound like a close call. But I mean, it seems interesting that there's a duality there because I have heard that kind of navigation through those keys and close to South Andros, all those different bites. I've heard stories that Stanley could really navigate that well, but then there's this also kind of recklessness that you hear about. Does that sound right? Yeah, absolutely.

As a boater, as a mariner, as a captain, you know, I just was really interested in that stuff. I love the waterman lifestyle and the way these guys knew that area. They could navigate through those shallows in the Bight. We're talking huge, you know, at least stretches of many, many miles, you know, just really, really expansive areas and just shoals everywhere. And they could do it at night in a storm. And they would do it without any electronics. There was no GPS. Very often there wasn't even a compass.

And to this day, I don't know how they were able to do that, and I'm in awe of it. I started to get better at that kind of thing after being there a year. But navigating those bites at night in a storm, no. Even after a year, I couldn't do that. But Stanley could. And there was this duality that you mentioned. There was a true recklessness when they were offshore.

And I think it's because the culture didn't have a lot of offshore fishing. They basically stayed inside the reef. They stayed inside the lagoon. They stayed inside the bites. And that 6,000-foot deep tongue of the ocean, that was kind of new for a lot of those men. Even though it was just a quarter mile off the beach, they didn't spend a lot of time out there. Some did, but those were the sailboat days, and the sailboat days were ending. And the powerboat days were really starting in the 90s. And I think that was new to them. It was still kind of new.

And so I think that's part of the reason there was this way those men would take powerboats on the open sea in ways that I wouldn't unless I was following their lead, which I often did. A lot of what you just heard from Jeff is exactly what captivated me when I first read his diary entries about his time at Cargo Creek Lodge. I wanted to jump forward from the day-to-day experience at the lodge to the disappearance itself. What was Stanley doing? Where was he going? And how did Jeff find out about the incident? My final moment in the 1994-95 season, I was running the whole place myself.

The other managers had gone, and for a month, I was chef. I was boat person. I was charter flight coordinator. I was taxi coordinator. I was doing inventory, buying fuel, everything. Everything it took to run a couple of grassy-key trips while having people at the lodge. It was a lot. And so I did that for a month on my own before I headed home towards the end of June, I believe it was, the end of June in 1995. But before I left, I had some conversations with Stanley, and I remember one specifically.

I was just outside the kitchen, and Stanley was talking about rebuilding the kitchen. He always talked about rebuilding things. He was a builder at heart, and you would just have to know the man. We were talking about the upcoming season, and by this time, I think Stanley and I were pretty close. He was pretty pleased with me. He knew how hard I worked, and the success of the lodge meant a lot to me. We were fairly close by the end of that first year. I said, I know that next season is going to be hard. We're going to have even more bookings.

There's just no way I said that I can keep doing commercial fishing at the level that I've been doing it. The first few months I was there, it was almost fun for me, but just impossible for me to be a manager at that level and also try to catch the crawfish that we needed. And so as I was talking to Stanley, he said, yeah, your time's too valuable for that. He said, what I can do to relieve you of that work, you shouldn't be doing that kind of work. He said, I could bring a, you know, bring a freezer onto the Wyoming. We'll get a generator and put a freezer on the Wyoming, on the sport fishermen. And he says, I'll get some divers. And, you know, during the summer when the crawfish season opens, we'll, you know, I'll get some divers. We'll go down to the, to the water keys and we'll, we'll, you know, fish until we, we get a thousand crawfish tails. You know, we'll, he said, they could, you know, what they don't catch, they could buy from other fishermen who will be working the area. And my first thought, I was jealous. I, because I thought, oh boy, I couldn't think of anything more fun.

than going with Stanley and the local watermen and spending a few days on the quay, spending a few days on the whiny, catching crawfish. It just sounded like something I really would like to do. So my thought was like, oh, damn, I wish I could go on that trip. Maybe that's why I remember it so clearly. So not long after that, probably within a week or so, I was back home. I was home for the summer. Virtually no guests want to be down there in the summer. And there was materials to collect, and we had to prepare for the next season.

And it had to be about six weeks later that my sister and I learned that Stanley had disappeared. We probably didn't know he had disappeared until 10 days or perhaps two weeks after the others had realized there was a problem. We were probably the last to know. My sister, who was going to be the manager with me the next season, was making calls to the NASA office, to Stanley's wife, and to whoever we could get a hold of. And she was only given the runaround. She couldn't get a hold of Stanley. And finally, they admitted to us that he had disappeared. In the next episode of Down the Path, we're going to dig in even further and explore what was being discussed on Andros Island very shortly after the disappearance of Stanley Bain.

He's the best boat driver in the world and knows that area like the back of his hand. And I think, you know, even if he had a motor problem or something, that guy, well, you know, he'll find an islander. He'll come back. Well, he never did. You know, I don't actually remember time, day or date or anything, but I just remember several conversations with guys on Andros and everybody was very concerned. Everybody had an opinion. He was out lobstering and the boat died or rented some bad people's guns or got attacked by people from Cuba. It's just, it's all those usual suspects. But it was just, it was a sad thing because, gee whiz, even if you drift away in the ocean, no guns, no bad people, nothing. It's horrible.

horrible scenario. Getting called out to Cuba can't be good. Thinking, you know, it's all just horrible. So when you met someone who you really liked, who would have been good to you and your fishing friends, yeah, it was horrible to hear about him disappearing. And then today, it's still, you know, since it's unsolved, that mystery really never goes away. You know, I think about our times down there. You know, I'll go through my library of photos looking for something and boom, here's our trip to South Andros. Yeah, it brings back a lot of great memories. You know, I don't know if this will ever be resolved. Come, follow us down the path.

Episode epilogue, number five.

Thanks for sticking around for this episode epilogue. Today's epilogue is going to be pretty quick. If you're digging into a story like this that doesn't have an exact start, middle, and definitive ending, it might feel a little bit unsettling at times. It's unsettling talking to people about tough topics, but here's the thing. It's okay to feel a little nervous about what you're working on and what you're writing about. Sometimes that's a sign you're working on something special.

If you can, as I mentioned before, try to sell the story concept or framework with an editor. Check in with your editor and share the direction you're working in, stumbling blocks you've come across, or brainstorm ideas on new directions or new questions to ask. In lieu of that, trust your instincts and keep doing the hard work. At some point, you'll get the rock up to the top of the hill. Thanks again for listening, and I hope you enjoy the finale of Down the Path Season 3, Episode 6.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Down the Path?

This episode is 40 minutes long.

When was this Down the Path episode published?

This episode was published on January 20, 2023.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Down the Path episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.