Skip to content
Season Three | Episode Four: "The Simplest Explanation" episode artwork

Jan 20, 2023 25 min

Season Three | Episode Four: "The Simplest Explanation"

from Down the Path Hosted by Will Rice

In Episode Four, host Will Rice begins by digging into what feels on the surface like the most probable of the scenarios – did the boats and crew have a mechanical issue that turned fatal or were they victims of a bad storm out at sea – or a combination of the two? He also shares research about the storm systems that were documented before during and after the disappearance of Stanley Bain. Music: Theme music for Down the Path was written and recorded by Alex Flock: www.alexflock.com. Season Three of Down the Path is being supported by The Flyfish Journal. Visit www.theflyfishjournal.com/downthepath for a special offer available to Down the Path listeners.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Season Three | Episode Four: "The Simplest Explanation"

0:00 25:27
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hey listeners, this is Will Rice. Welcome to season three of Down the Path, which is being supported once again by the Fly Fish Journal. The Fly Fish Journal is a quarterly print magazine and digital platform that showcases the highest quality imagery and fly fishing's greatest stories. FFJ supports independent projects like Down the Path and other freelance journalists, photographers, and storytellers in each one of their issues. They'd also like to offer Down the Path listeners a special subscription offer. To learn more and subscribe, visit theflyfishjournal.com backslash down the path.

I'd like to think the boat broke down, he drifted down by Cuba, and he was hauled in. I mean, that in itself is a wonderful ending. The boat break down in the sink. Did he get attacked by pirates? Did he have something go wrong, something go south of their gun? I don't know, nor I really don't think anyone else does. And I have been on boat fishing trips where the boat are conked out. We've been out there all night, and I've been dropped off on a small island while my boat fisherman was out fishing. His boat broke down, and I was stranded on a flat at night. I knew things happened. And I've got a boat, I've got a boat, and I've had him conked out.

Stanley Bain, his brother, and three crew members went missing on or after August 5th, 1995. The five men, the three boats, were never seen again. This is the story of that disappearance. You're listening to Down the Path Season 3. I'm your host, Will Rice, and this is Episode 4.

One of my goals with this podcast is to talk about what we know and what we don't know about the disappearance of Stanley Bain and his crew of four. But I also hope to give listeners a feeling who might not be familiar with fishing saltwater flats and sight casting to very loose to fish, what it's all about. To understand this story, you really need to understand the area where Stanley Bain went missing. To better understand Andros Island, Cargo Creek Lodge, and the newly constructed camp on the southernmost tip of the island, you heard from Brian O'Keefe in episode three. Here he is again to give listeners additional perspective on fishing South Andros Island and Grassy Key back in the day, as well as meeting Stanley for the first time. You'll also hear him describe the Field and Stream article, which I read excerpts from in episode two. If you missed that reading, jump back and give it a listen.

Here's Brian. Stanley, things going on, and he's involved with stuff at NASA. He's just the ultimate entrepreneur, I thought, and a nice guy, and a tough guy. I mean, he really liked doing what we were doing, the camping, the exploring, and all that stuff. Another year goes by, and I was doing some work with Field and Street Magazine, doing quite a bit of photos and traveling with their editor, Duncan Barnes. And Duncan had heard my stories about the South Andros, and he thought, wow, let's go down there. That sounds like a great trip. We went down and fish with Stanley again.

And, oh, he was great. He showed us around. We went to, now, a little bit of a lodge down there. And we had a little bit of fresh water problem. But other than that, you know, nice little rooms and some flat skiffs. And it was a little bit easier than camping in on a sheet rolled up like a burrito. So Duncan and I fished with Stanley and a couple of his guides. And fishing was outstanding. And the feature turned out in Field Street Magazine more about Stanley than the fishing. But it all rolled into one and was a great read.

I'm not sure I actually fished with Stanley more than Dad. I fished with his kids and his guides from Cargo Creek or from other places around middle to South Andros. But back then, when you went to that part of Andros, you never saw him on a boat. Today, there's still a few guides that run over there, but it's still wild, big country, some of the prettiest flats in the world, lots of bones. And so, I don't know, maybe in my life of bone fishing all over the place from...

I'm really one of the first people to ever fish those rocans in Venezuela just sort of by accident in the Pacific. It's about everywhere, all over the Caribbean and the Atlantic side. I still think some of the best fishing I've ever had were those early trips to Southwest Andros with Stanley. For anyone out there who's not familiar with saltwater fly fishing, to hear Brian O'Keefe say that some of his best fishing days ever were on the south end of South Andros Island with Stanley is a testament to why we're spending so much time with this part of the story. I wouldn't be doing my job if I didn't ask O'Keefe what he remembered about the disappearance of Stanley Bain and what he thought about it.

the fly fishing scene in the Bahamas, and he had Cargo Creek Lodge, and a lot of other things going on, and just, you know, hanging out in the bar, having a beer, and stuff. He was mentioning, you know, these construction projects he was doing, and he had some lobster interest, and he had, of course, the hospitality business, you know, hotel lodge, guides, and all that. He was a really busy guy. I always kind of looked at him like not just a, you're not a typical businessman. He might be shrewd and a super hard worker, but I saw him more as a strong, tough guy, like a rugby player or something. He was built.

You know, like, employees knew when he walked in the room. I mean, he had some clout. And also, you know, a very genuine, nice guy. He was really into expanding the horizons of his business and his own personal fishing, which he liked to do. And so, you know, back then, as an American fly fisher, bopping around the Bahamas, you met a lot of neat people, a lot of characters, and people with strong personalities, and other people who were, you know, more into the, even the science of fishing. And it was fascinating. It was just a great experience.

And Stanley was sort of all that rolled into one. But first and foremost, I thought he was kind of a tough guy. He was a big, strong guy. And I just thought he kind of ruled. And I didn't know him well enough to know what were those construction projects he did. I just needed construction. Okay, that's fine. I mean, lots of people do that. But they had some abode or something for lobster, and he did that. But that's pretty common, too. I didn't need to dive into that. But I was more interested in his interest in the far-off places, off-the-beaten-path places of Anda. So, you know, we mostly talked about that. I could tell when people came up and talked to him, he would sort of switch gears into boss mode.

and tell people what to do, how to do it, and when to do it. And they were literally like, all right, so they were gone and they would do it. He was a boss. And so I think that, now that I think back on how all the things that happened, he was a boss. He directed people to do things. He was into lots of interesting things. He liked to make money. You know, he had the gold jewelry and the boats and everything to prove it. Now, I never thought that who knows what all that stuff led to or who knows what people he was involved with. I didn't know his affiliation with any government, government party, political party. He was just a...

aggressive, ambitious, hardworking guy who kind of ruled with a hammer, you know, and a baseball bat. And so, you know, he put our trip together in, this was before email, but in one or two phone calls. And today it would have been 50 emails and who knows what else. So he got things done. He had resources. He was really interested into expanding his fishing operation. And I just loved it. I thought, wow, this is a cool opportunity. And that's when the Patagonia group, which can argue everything, came together in the film stream article. Duncan Barnes editor came together. And, you know, so I don't know that much about any other part of his life. I've learned.

more about it from you than anybody else. Great to our people on our trips. And I loved every minute of it. He was a real waterman. He could drive that boat in and out of channels and knew the tide, knew great places to anchor. It was like he had a GPS in his head. I don't think he ever had an electronic GPS or a map. But just from life experience, from being a kid and growing up, palm fishing, lobstering, snapper fishing and guiding and all that, he just really knew the area well. And we never had even a doubt that this guy knows his stuff.

We spent a considerable amount of time talking about what ran through O'Keefe's mind after hearing the news and thinking about the different possibilities. involved with other people. I just have no idea who and for what motive. Did the boat hunk it out? No, you could even that big boat, you couldn't tow it with a skip, but you could certainly upload fuel and food and get back to Southern Andros.

let the chips fall where they may about what happened because I had such a good experience with Stanley. I don't know anything about his contacts in other businesses and anything legal or illegal. I just have no idea and who knows. I guess there's a lot of speculation and any of it or none of it could be true or based on reality. He was just a dynamic guy, pretty serious about business, pretty serious about making money and I've probably been asked by 25 people, what do you think happened to Stanley Bates?

I've had years to talk to friends and family of his. I've read your stories and your stuff, which is really well done. And I still have no idea. As I mentioned in episode one, there were people who I wanted to interview back in 2005 and 2006 that I just couldn't locate. That all changed in 2022 when Jeff Shainer and Sandy McMaster agreed to sit down and talk to me about their experience on Andros Island while working at Cargo Creek Lodge in 1995. I was also able to track down a retired Coast Guard captain who spent time working and patrolling the Bahamian waters where the disappearance likely occurred.

We'll cover all of this in episode four, five, and six. In addition to giving listeners a feel of what fishing in the Bahamas was like in the 1990s, I wanted to begin by digging into what feels on the surface like the most probable of the scenarios. Did the boats and crew have a mechanical issue that turned fatal, or were they victims of a bad storm out at sea? Or a combination of the two? In 2005, I was able to research the storm systems that were documented before, during, and after the disappearance, which was included in my 2007 article. Here's what I concluded and summarized at the time.

And if Baines' boat went north or east, it could have simply fallen under the spell of the Bermuda Triangle and be added to the roster of more than 1,000 boats and 200 airplanes that have gone missing there in the past 200 years. But the most benign and logical possibility is the most natural of events. What if Stanley ran into bad weather and simply capsized? Now fast forward to 2022, and I wanted to unpack this scenario with someone who had experience on the water in this exact area. I tracked down and contacted a retired Coast Guard officer who worked in and around the Bahamas precisely where it is believed that Stanley and his crew went missing.

To that end, in August of 2022, I spoke to this retired Coast Guard officer and search and rescue specialist who has spent a significant amount of time working in Florida and throughout the Bahamas. Our conversation was on the record, but he asked to remain anonymous for this story and podcasts, which I've agreed to and respect. I provided him with all the information that you've heard so far as a prerequisite to our interview. I wanted to have him to have as much information about the disappearance as possible. Our conversation first started with his background and the area he worked on as a Coast Guard officer aboard numerous ships while coordinating search and rescue operations, which I'll later refer to as SAR.

and law enforcement operations throughout his career. It was very clear that he had intimate knowledge about Andros Island and the surrounding waters. One of the first topics we dug into was the timeline and the storm history from August 5th, 1995 to August 22nd, which you heard details about in episode two. At the time, and with most people I originally talked to, both of the major storm systems that bookended the trip and timeline don't support the assumption that whatever happened to Stanley and his crew was the result of either a Category 1 hurricane, Aaron, or tropical storm, Jerry, at least initially. Furthermore, if Stanley was still on the water on August 22nd, 17 long days after their departure, was Jerry the type of storm to sink a 36-foot cabin cruiser, two skiffs, and drown an entire crew without a trace?

Although the retired Coast Guard officer did agree that the storms documented in the NOAA history didn't sound overly aggressive or catastrophic in nature, he didn't rule out the deadly potential of a more localized storm system that tend to pop up throughout the Caribbean, especially during the hot summer season. I've always thought of an accident caused by Mother Nature as one of the most probable of scenarios. But the one piece that always bothered me was that there were three boats, three engines. A single boat capsizing makes a lot of sense, but three and no trace? That always nagged at me, and I know it's nagged at other people as well, including locals.

When I asked whether or not a local storm system could capsize three boats, my Coast Guard contact thought it was absolutely possible. However, the probability is an entirely different discussion depending on the scenarios. Here's what he said. If the crew was sleeping on the cabin cruiser and something catastrophic at night happened, they might not have had time to make it to the smaller skiffs. He also mentioned that those small and localized storms were common in August. Here's another quote.

If a catastrophic event happened at night and everyone woke up to their boat taking on water and they were immediately in the water, all bets are off. He also had a lot of questions about the material and mechanical condition of the three boats. Were there known engine issues? Were they well maintained? From our conversations, here's what he said. Depending on when and where they were during the trip, if they had a major mechanical issue or started to take on water, there was likely no one in their immediate vicinity to help back in 1995. And that's a big problem, especially if you cannot maneuver or pump water off your boat.

Every day spent on the water disabled is working against you. Our conversation drifted to other possible scenarios. On the history of the Bahamas, here's what he said. The Bahamas was, and is still, a significant transshipment route for contraband, especially during the 80s and 90s, contraband being drugs or people or other things. Is it possible that they were simply in the wrong place at the wrong time and crossed paths with people involved in nefarious activities? Absolutely, but you'd have to talk to people that were closer to him to understand how big of a possibility it is. We talk more about the fact that no evidence was ever found. Here are his thoughts on that, and I think this is pretty important.

In a search and rescue operation, the SAR team will go through a list of questions in order to develop assumptions and ultimately a search plan which will give them the greatest probability of successfully finding the subject of their searches. They gather information about the boats, people on board, safety equipment, where and when they departed, where they were going and how long they were supposed to be gone, observed weather, etc. Each of which can impact the search area significantly. Unfortunately, time is not an ally when SAR planning, and if you are talking about a vessel or people adrift out in the ocean for 10 or 12 or 14 days before anyone reports them missing, the search area just explodes in size, and the probability of success decreases significantly. The fact that no one knows for sure what happened or exactly when something might have happened adds a layer of complexity to this story, timeline, and narrative. Remember this, as it is going to play out again in a later episode.

When I asked him what else I should be looking at to narrow down the probable scenarios for what might have happened to Stanley and his crew, he said, if I were you, I'd try to find out more about those boats and their condition. Were their engines, pumps, and generators reliable? Were there any known leaks that could have resulted in them being disabled, sinking, and ultimately disappearing? As it would turn out, in 2022, I was able to interview the two people who were hired by Stanley Bain to manage the Cargill Creek and Grassy Key Lodge for the 1995-1996 fishing season. Just one of their responsibilities was managing and maintaining all of the boat. Here is Sandy McMaster.

I saw in him, and that's what really inspired me, because I thought, he just thinks he can do anything he sets his mind to, and he could. I mean, even just building Cargo Creek Lodge. I mean, the lodge was, for being on Andros, it was an amazing lodge. It had all the amenities. It had everything you could ask for in Andros at that time. And just even getting down there, it was 75 miles away from the lodge. You had to be an expert navigator to get back and forth in the weather. They used to go in with the supplies. I remember one time that I was there, they just scared me to death. They were taking the sea cat and all these skiffs down.

And they just put drum after drum after drum after drum of fuel on them. And it was like, oh my God, nobody in their right mind would do that. And then Jeff goes along with them. You know, it was just like Stanley did whatever he needed to do. This is Jeff Shainer, Sandy's brother. It's a big ocean. So many things could have gone wrong.

And the fact that someone could disappear or a group of boats and people could disappear in those hundreds of square miles, to me as a captain and a mariner, it's plausible. It's plausible that just mundane bad luck could have disappeared them without a trace. I mean, that's my first thought. It's still my best guess. Just mundane bad luck happening in a big ocean. I don't know what happened.

Foul play is definitely a possibility, and I heard all the rumors, and I can imagine things myself, but I never heard any credible evidence of foul play. Not that I'm saying that didn't happen. I just never heard any credible evidence of foul play. Come, follow us down the path. Down the Path is an independent podcast series written and created by me, Will Rice, with sound design and editing by Rick Mikesell and co-produced by Jason Rolfe. This season of Down the Path, once again, is being supported by the Fly Fish Journal.

I'd like to give a special shout out and thanks to Alex Flock of British Columbia who wrote and performed the title track and other supporting music included here. Down the Path is available on Apple Music, Spotify, Stitcher, and also downthepathpodcast.com. If you listen on Apple Music, please rate and review. It's great to get your feedback. Episode epilogue, number four. Thanks once again for sticking around for this episode epilogue. I'm going to spend just a few minutes talking about sources. I've mentioned before that this type of story is very dependent on talking to people who have some type of knowledge about the story or the situation or the environment.

For example, in this case, you heard from a retired Coast Guard officer. You'll also notice that although the interview was on the record, the officer did not want to be named or recorded for this podcast. As a writer, this is a bit of a judgment call. For the most part, if a source doesn't want to go on the record or be named, I'm pretty reluctant to work with them or use the information they share with me in a story. The exception to this is that they have something that is very germane to bring to the table. In this case, he did.

And I was very careful when I quoted him in the story. And I made sure to get permission to use the quotes exactly as you heard them. Now, is this more work and effort? Absolutely. But I think it's an important step when making a story like this. For me, this is also a lesson in how you have to work with sources. When I listen back to some of my original interviews from Down the Path, season one and two, and listen to the raw recordings, I'm almost embarrassed at my job as an interviewer. I sound like I have very little empathy for the people I'm talking to.

especially that in some cases they had loved ones who disappeared or were murdered in very distressing situations. My takeaway or what I'll share with you, when you're on a story and find someone with good and useful information, treat those sources like gold. This might take two or three conversations. Make sure you share with them why it is important for them to go on the record. And remember, these people don't have to talk to you. And if someone doesn't want to talk to you, be respectful of that as well. And most importantly, be compassionate with your sources, especially if the situation dictates that you do so. Okay, thanks again for sticking around for this episode epilogue.

I hope you tune in to episode five of Down the Path, season three.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Down the Path?

This episode is 25 minutes long.

When was this Down the Path episode published?

This episode was published on January 20, 2023.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Down the Path episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.