Skip to content
SEC Drops 'Reg Crypto' Rulemaking: Do We Still Need Clarity? episode artwork

Aug 21, 2026 23 min

SEC Drops 'Reg Crypto' Rulemaking: Do We Still Need Clarity?

from CoinDesk Podcast Network Hosted by CoinDesk

CoinDesk's The Policy Protocol hosts Rebecca Rettig and Renato Mariotti open on President Trump's White House remarks about bringing Hyperliquid onshore, then dig into Judge Vernon Oliver's Connecticut ruling that slammed the CFTC's emergency order in the Kalshi fight. Alexander Zozos, General Counsel of Superstate and a former SEC staffer, joins the hosts to break down what “Reg Crypto” actually does: two fundraising exemptions plus a safe harbor that acts as a "barbell" on when securities laws apply, solving crypto's "Hotel California" problem of checking in but never checking out. Plus, Rebecca and Renato debrief on whether the rule is a foundation or a window, and name crypto lawyers as their Person of the Week. - This episode is brought to you by RealFi, a smarter stablecoin, backed by real-world assets. Find out more at⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ realfi.co⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠. - Register now for CoinDesk's Policy and Regulation event on September 22, 2026: policy-regulation.coindesk.com. - Chapters/Timecodes: 00:00 Welcome to The Policy Protocol 01:54 Hot Topic: Trump Talks Hyperliquid at the White House 04:36 Renato's Hot Topic: Kalshi, the CFTC, and Loper Bright 06:34 The SEC Drops Its 'Reg Crypto' Rulemaking 06:42 Alexander Zozos of Superstate Joins the Show 06:55 What Is Reg Crypto? The 30,000-Foot View 10:04 Foundation or Window? The Rogue Regulator Question 12:16 Inside the SEC: How a 400-Page Rule Gets Made 17:40 Does the Exit Ramp Depend on the CLARITY Act? 20:04 Rebecca and Renato Debrief 21:44 Person of the Week: Crypto Lawyers

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

SEC Drops 'Reg Crypto' Rulemaking: Do We Still Need Clarity?

0:00 23:37
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Look, the SEC just built an exit door out of its own jurisdiction. I'm not sure it can build a road on the other side. I mean, the CFTC can police fraud, but it can't register anyone without clarity. It doesn't seem to me. This episode is brought to you by RealFi. Most stablecoins leave capital sitting still. RealFi is different. It connects on-chain capital to real-world markets like U.S. Treasuries, money market funds, and private credit, real transparency, real impact, RealFi. Launching August 2026, join the testnet now at realfi.co.

Welcome to The Policy Protocol, your weekly espresso shot of the latest in fintech law and policy. Not just what happened, but distilled down to what actually matters. I'm your host, Rebecca Reddick, here with my co-host, Renato. How are you, Renato? Hi, great to be here. Where are you, Rebecca? That looks amazing. I'm on the frontier, so crypto is a wild west, so I'm out west scaling the mountains and bringing all the good word on the digital financial revolution out here. So, yeah, happy to be here this week. What a week it's been. And also, like, I don't have a lot of service out here, so I sort of am getting drips and drabs, but so much has been going on. So glad that we can connect and talk through all of it.

Yeah, absolutely. Well, you know, the chairman, the CFCC has been using this frontier imagery. We had a big meeting going on today, you know, today, obviously, the Innovation Committee and yesterday at the White House. Lots of big news. I'm sure we're going to be discussing quite a bit of that today. Yeah. So to that end, I'll kick off with my my hot topic of the week to start, which is President Trump's mention of hyperliquid at the White House. Let's take a listen. I understand that Mike is also working to bring hyperliquid into the United States in a fully compliant and legal fashion.

Working very hard on that. So much to say just about that image alone. Chair Selig smiling big. Jeff Sprecher, who's the chairman of ICE on the other side of the president, who really represents so much about the traditional financial system and all the big derivatives players there. There's a longtime joke that Terry Duffy, who's the chair of the CME, was always the sixth commissioner at the CFTC. But ICE is also an equally big player. And anytime you speak to a CFTC chair.

in the past, they would say something like, well, you know, I have lots of constituents, but I always have to make sure I keep the CME and ICE happy. So very interesting to have hyperliquid mentioned in that vein, too. What do you think, Renato? Yeah, look, I've got to say, I don't really see any way in which hyperliquid is going to be brought on shore. in the way that the president said. It's just hard for me to understand, given the state of the Commodity Exchange Act and existing CFTC regulations to see how that's going to happen. It'll be interesting to see what exactly he has in mind or what the chairman has in mind. But the way that the president described it just seems to me like that's not going to happen. And I'm interested to see not only what happens, but what the reaction is to it in the United States, because I think in 2027, I could imagine a lot of members of Congress very interested in what's happening with hyperliquid.

So I'll take a spicy take back, which is the president didn't say what was going to happen. He didn't say it was just coming on shore in a fully unregulated manner that we were going to yellow it. I mean, he just said he's working very hard to bring hyperliquid on shore. Now, what that means remains to be seen, as you said. And look, and I think Tierselik has been pretty honest about this, that we're not just going to have regulated derivatives brought on shore in an unregulated manner.

What Jersey has also been clear about is that there are ways or core principles under the Commodity Exchange Act and the enacting regs that may or can be modified to actually accommodate a lot of these innovations. So it will be interesting to see what comes out of the IAC today, the Innovation Advisory Committee meeting, and if there's any discussion about how to bring crypto perpetuals or perps onshore in that kind of way. But what's your hot topic of the week, Renato? Well, there is a very interesting court decision this week. I will say it follows on a court decision that occurred earlier in the month. So there was Judge Vernon Oliver in Connecticut.

On August, Kalshi at defense sports, sports event contracts aren't swaps, no exclusive CFTC jurisdiction. The next day, the CFTC declared a market emergency and ordered Kalshi to keep operating regardless of what state courts say. And Kalshi took that order back just to Judge Oliver's courtroom. And he wrote a decision. Look, you can see it right there, the graphic slamming the CFTC's use of emergency powers, saying that it lacks jurisdiction to contradict the courts. I mean, he essentially said that the agency's order ignores what the court had held and that nothing in the Commodity Exchange Act hands statutory interpretation over to an agency. And he cites Loper.

Right. Which I think is really interesting because, of course, Rebecca, a lot of people were cheering when that rolled back or clipped the SEC's wings a little bit. Of course, now it's being used against the CFTC. And so while emergency orders obviously can tell Kelsey what to do, at least according to Judge Oliver, cannot tell an Article 3 judge what a statute means, which I think is very interesting. It is interesting. I'm not exactly sure that's what Loper Bright says. It does say, you know, it doesn't have to give what's called Chevron deference to agencies and agency interpretation. But I do think that the CFTC's interpretation of the Commodity Exchange Act.

does itself deserve some deference. So we will see, you know, I think we talked about it a lot here that we're going to see the prediction market showdown, including over gaming in the Supreme Court, likely in 2027. And so it would be interesting to see how the Loper Bright decision comes into play when we see that coming into the Supreme Court. So the other big news of the week is the SEC has put out its long-awaited reg crypto rulemaking. And to be with us today to talk about this is a great guest, Alexander Zozos, who is the General Counsel of Superstate. Welcome, Alex. Hey, guys. Happy to be here. Thanks for having me join. Yeah. So just to kick us off, tell us, what is reg crypto? Give us the TLDR, as we all like to say, or the 30,000-foot view. And at the very end of that, tell us, does it affect Superstate in any way, shape, or form, in your opinion? Yeah. So reg crypto...

fantastic job by the SEC in finally getting something out the door. I think it's a culmination of a lot of engagement, a lot of hard work from and thought leadership from Commissioner Peirce. But really what it is, is it's kind of carving out and allowing for the raising of funds for things that really shouldn't be securities, but involve the raising of funds in an investment contract. So it really is a flavor of what's been called like the embodiment theory. But it has two exemptions for fundraising that allow you to raise funds with some minimal disclosure and to distribute your tokens. And then on the back end of that, it allows for a safe harbor for you to, for your tokens to not be considered securities.

and the outside of the purview of the SEC. So it's really a barbell both on the entryway and the exit way of how securities laws apply and how they don't apply and really takes about an interest in, you know, what makes crypto different, right? And so some of that is, you know, network effects and the underlying asset itself not actually being a security like a stock or a bond. So a really positive step forward in clearing the deck and an extension of this interpretation that the SEC put out earlier this year, which really defined digital assets in a number of categories. you know, such as digital collectibles, digital commodities, stable coins. It went through five of those, the fifth of those being digital securities, which always will be within the SEC's ambit. But I think this reg crypto assets kind of deals with, not with stable coins, but with the first four and how, if you as an entrepreneur want to raise funds and it involves a digital asset and a token, how to do that and then how to solve the Hotel California problem of checking into the securities world but not being able to check out. This episode is brought to you by RealFi. Most stable coins leave capital sitting still. RealFi is different.

It connects on-chain capital to real-world markets like U.S. treasuries, money market funds, and private credit, real transparency, real impact, RealFi. Launching August 2026, join the testnet now at realfi.co. I have to ask you, Alex. Chairman Atkins himself had said that it'll take legislation to stop a, quote, future rogue regulator, unquote, from unwinding this. You were obviously inside the building when the commission changed hands. So is the right crypto a foundation or is it a window?

Yeah, I mean, I think rogue regulators are dangerous in all forms, but I think the focus of what regulation crypto is, is narrow and deals with what actually right now is within the SEC's purview. I think... There's a lot of things that aren't covered by this regulation or this proposed regulation that we can maybe talk about the distinction between. But what happens with spot market authority and developer protections and things like that still is left to Clarity Act and the legislature to define whose jurisdiction those are. With regard to a future rogue regulator and what they could do, the process of making a rule is a long one and needs to...

be carried out consistent with the Administrative Procedures Act, known as the APA. And so I think what's important now is this proposing release is out there. It starts the clock on the rulemaking process. It's important to think back when the last administration changed, what happened with all the proposed rules that were out there at the time, and they were kind of wiped clean. And so what this does now is it starts the process of rulemaking, and there's a clock before there's a potentially new administration to come through that this rulemaking gets formally adopted. That doesn't protect a threat from

the judiciary, which you guys are more familiar with. But as was mentioned in the earlier segments, the judiciary looms large and can move much more swiftly than a rogue regulator can in disrupting forward progress that an agency has made. Yeah. So you talked a little bit about what it's like in the building and maybe what happens next. But since you've been inside the SEC, and just to give our viewers or listeners an insight, this is a 400-page rulemaking. There are a lot of pieces to it that people don't always think about, like economic analysis and these balancing tests and things like that. And I can say from some of my discussions with the SEC, this traveled a long way over a long period of time inside the SEC. This was probably over a year-long process to put together this rule, to get it through the building, to get it through all the various channels. So give us a behind-the-scenes view of what it's like to put together a rule at the SEC.

Yeah, I mean, the construct of the SEC is there's a number of different divisions. The largest division is the enforcement division, but there are a handful of other divisions that are known as policymaking divisions. One of those is trading markets where I came from. The division that was primarily involved in this rulemaking is the division of corporation finance. But regardless, there's rulemaking teams within those divisions that are subject matter experts and then use the breadth of the commission in sourcing knowledge. And so what it really comes down to is...

not to go back to Schoolhouse Rock, but there's some authority, vested authority from the legislature. Then it comes to the agency. The agency with its team of experts crafts rules derived from that authority. But then it's a lot of workshopping and understanding the various implications. You mentioned economic analysis. I mean, again, that really has been a focal point as a result of some judicial challenges that were made previously, commonly known as business roundtable decisions. And so you need to make sure you're following the Administrative Procedures Act. You're getting...

public comment, notice and comment and input. Once something is proposed, you show evidence that you reviewed and weighed that input, and then you put out an adopting release from there. But I mean, yeah, you mentioned the length of the rulemaking. If you go back just a few decades, like 20, 30 years ago, rulemakings were 15, 20 pages. Now they're, like you said, 400 pages. I think a lot of that is to cover yourself, to ensure that you're following, to show your work that you're following the right process in the Administrative Procedures Act. Another thing is these rules are just...

really complicated and they also serve as like talismanic uh reference points for people in the space and so like anyone who doesn't know anything about securities regulations or wants to get smarter on a certain area read a proposing or an adopting release and you will find significant background and history and reference and citations i mean the amount of footnotes in each of these is is immense and again like that's all to kind of show your work so in a future point where someone's coming to say There's no basis for this, or this was just you putting your thumb on the scale. You as a regulator that's defending this regulation can come and say, no, all of these things are from input or based in fact and not opinion. So yeah, it's a long road. We're at the starting point, right? A proposed release doesn't mean anything is effectuated or changed from the regulations. It's themselves. But it starts the process. There's public input that is now being requested for the next 60 days.

then there'll be a period for the commission to digest that public input and comment. And then from there, they likely will put out a version that's updated and reflective of those comments in what's called an adopting release. And then from the adopting release, it can become effective. Something that is unique and new and relates to some of the Supreme Court activity that has just come down is the fact that the White House has a bite at this now. Obviously, independent agencies have had more independence in the past. Now, since the slaughter cases come down and even before that, these administrative agencies are

providing draft versions of these rulemakings to the White House for comment before they go reach the public. And all of that's available to see what's happening, but not the actual rule text. So, you know, regulation crypto assets was submitted to the White House, I believe, in March of this year, and wasn't publicly released again until, you know, Monday of this week. Yeah. I mean, I resent...

the 400 pages versus the 15, but I will say, and you know, I'm a former litigator and Renato is a litigator. We've, you know, we saw the CME sue the CFTC and we've already heard rumblings that some of the TradFi associations are planning to sue potentially over this final rule. So it makes sense to show your work. I will say I was taught in brief writing that you should never use footnotes. And if you have to, you should make sure that it all can go up in the text. But you know, we got to give the SEC their flowers because this was, this was a lot of work. Renato, any, any final questions for Alex?

Well, I've got to ask, because you mentioned, Alex, that there is still a room for clarity or need for clarity in the Clarity Act. Obviously, look, the SEC just built an exit door out of its own jurisdiction. I'm not sure it can build a road on the other side. I mean, the CFTC can police fraud, but it can't register anyone without clarity, it doesn't seem to me. Can the two agencies build a real handoff without clarity, or does the exit ramp really sort of depend on the passage of that legislation?

I mean, I think the underlying, I think there's two separate points that are kind of being made there is, you know, what this regulation I think is attempting to do is to say, these are securities in a period of time, and they're not securities during a period of time. What happens outside of that, they're not securities, they're not the SEC's problem. I think your point is to say, well, who is responsible for them? I think the logical place for those would be the CFTC, but they don't have that authority vested in them right now. So I think that's not...

the SEC's problem, right? I mean, their problem is dealing with securities and how we, and when something is not a security, then that is not the problem. I think it will probably spur and hopefully does spur action from Congress to draw within the lines and complete and fill in those gaps. But I applaud the SEC for the great work of getting this out the door because there was a challenge for innovators and entrepreneurs to raise capital in the past. And then this also then clears up a lot of confusion on what happens and how those assets should be treated. And now I think it opens up the SEC's.

availability to focus on tokenized securities and digital that are using, that are traditionally within their wheelhouse, but are now utilizing new and different technology. And so I'm excited to see where the SEC goes with that and hopeful that Congress addresses the gaps that exist. Great. Well, thank you so much for joining us, Alex. We appreciate it. We appreciate all the behind the scenes, thoughtful work that you've done and both, you know, inside and outside. And thanks for coming on to chat with us about this today. Pleasure. Thank you guys. All right. Well, what a big week. What do you think sort of, you know, about all of that, Renato?

Yeah, look, I think it's really interesting, Rebecca, but from my vantage point, I think, I don't remember if it was you or Alex who mentioned the fact that there's some TradFi folks who are already considering challenging this. I mean, it's interesting. I alluded in a question that I really, is this a foundation or a window? And I really view this as a window. People can take advantage of the fact that this is the SEC's position right now, but I expect there to be an APA suit and who knows what's going to happen in the future.

2029 and beyond. So I really think it would be nice if we could have legislation that would make this all much clearer and allow people to build and plan for the future. But I think what we're seeing here is really the consequence of potentially not having that legislation passed. Yeah, I think that's right. I did really appreciate all your different metaphors around this window, door, road, all of that kind of stuff. But I think it'll be really interesting. The one thing that I think Alex alluded to a little bit and is important to really mention is that rulemaking, yes, everyone says you can have a road regulator and they can roll it back. But first of all, rulemaking itself is extremely difficult, as is rolling it back and changing it. And so, look, we do want these durable, we do want durable legislation.

So we have a real framework around it, but rules are really an important step. And so I don't want to undermine how important that is as well. Okay. Well, who are our people of the week? I'm excited to say that our people of the week are crypto lawyers. Renato, tell us a little bit about why crypto lawyers are our people of the week.

You know, I got to say, Rebecca, one thing that's really fantastic to see here is just how much a difference so many different people made. I mean, there's all these affiliations here, but really there's a lot of lawyers who are out there coming up with ideas, even when a lot of people weren't listening and the SEC was hostile. CFCC at times was hostile to digital assets. And you're seeing some people here and some institutions that were making their voice heard. And I think it's great that the SEC is listening.

Yeah, I think the other thing to take away for all of us who've been working in this emerging space, whether it's crypto or whether we're now calling it, you know, sort of this broader digital financial markets, is like you actually can make a difference. We've seen in Commissioner Purse's speeches or writings or in the rulemaking that submissions to these regulators actually do get paid attention to at a certain point in time. And so even though sometimes it might feel like you're yelling into the void, you actually are making a difference day in and day out with the work that you do. So really big kudos to everyone who contributed and who continues to contribute and all this thought leadership in all sorts of different ways. That's all that we have for this week. I will be back from the frontier next week, and I am sure we will have just as much to talk about.

You know, things do not seem to be slowing down. It'll be interesting to hear what comes out of the IAC meeting, you know, whether there's more hyperliquid news or not. And thanks, as always, for listening and give us any of your comments, too, so we can make sure we're talking about the things you want to hear about.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of CoinDesk Podcast Network?

This episode is 23 minutes long.

When was this CoinDesk Podcast Network episode published?

This episode was published on August 21, 2026.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this CoinDesk Podcast Network episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.