Skip to content
Setting the record straight episode 3: Mac Miller’s “Circles” episode artwork

Feb 7, 2020 28 min

Setting the record straight episode 3: Mac Miller’s “Circles”

from The Daily Californian Hosted by The Daily Californian

On the third episode of Setting the Record Straight, co-hosts Jack Graves and MJ Harris review Mac Miller’s posthumous release, Circles.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Setting the record straight episode 3: Mac Miller’s “Circles”

0:00 28:30
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

what's up everyone welcome to the third episode of setting the record straight this is mj harris and this is jack graves and today um we're going to be reviewing mac miller's album circles um so not a whole lot on the agenda today um also for anyone who's a cal student welcome back to the spring semester it's um you know even though 2020 hasn't been that good to start uh i do wish we only get better from here yeah we can also get worse from here too so i i i don't want to i was knocking on wood but i don't want i don't want to jinx anything but yes um yeah those other things can happen but um yeah without further ado mac miller circles um mac miller also known as larry fisherman um american rapper record producer um uh passed away september 2018 uh back when yeah there was a that time his death was definitely a shock to everyone in the music community and to all his fans uh i think i remember when i think i was in uh on campus and one of my friends was telling me oh mac miller passed away i was like no way oh it just seems it was like i felt like i was like the last person who would i think would have you know died like that and i don't know i was shocked um anyways uh yeah mac miller he's had a pretty uh uh what do you call it extensive discovery pretty lengthy career yeah in terms of the discographies put out um apparently he has 13 mixtapes two ap's two eps and six video albums which is crazy without that amount of music yeah and the fact that he started from 2010 too yeah so his career that's like three albums a year i don't know you uh can't do the math but um yeah it's you know i think he was also pretty well respected among his peers uh he came up as a double excel freshman 2011 uh with kendrick lamar um and yeah one of my favorite mac miller songs is actually the one song that he and kendrick did together on one of his early two albums i want to say yeah the good a.m fight the feeling yeah yeah yeah that was a pretty good song um uh i haven't really listened to mac um just in general and even prior to his death especially uh i don't know i i have heard songs from him in the past like fight the feeling there was also on the weekend with miguel i thought that was a pretty good song i heard that in la once um and i i liked the vibe i didn't know who the artist was and just named it mac miller so this is cool yeah i want to say i never really um even knew like who mac miller was basically come uh before coming to calo my fall semester because my two roommates are both big mac miller fans they're constantly playing out loud in the room and um that definitely got me into some of his songs i really like another song i really like is a song with anderson pack it's called dang i think yeah yeah yeah and i think that's also one of his first posthumous releases he was on the divine feminine oh i think i think it was always still alive okay well i'll cut that out yeah that's yeah uh so i've also met a lot of people who are a lot of mac miller fans and personally i've never really seen the the appeal um but yeah i think a lot of cal kind of likes that mac miller like kuko like i don't know who else kind of like vibey summer it's like i feel yeah yeah that makes that makes sense um that makes sense uh i think one thing that's interesting though um in so basically how i was trying to approach this review uh was you know because i haven't had a lot of experience with mac i i decided to give circles a listen but as well as um swimming because i was also um i've heard that swimming in circles are supposed to be kind of like two parts of the same concept type thing um so i wanted to make sure i was able to get anything that um what else was i doing i think oh one thing that i was also observing was like just how different um his sound was as he matured as an artist i think starting from like early 2010s i remember he did those features with ariana grande yeah those were the songs i was jamming to back then um but as he started progressing and as time went on he started to do a lot more experimental work especially around funk and r&b and soul and stuff that he did in the divine feminine i'm not familiar with the whole album but i've heard some singles from it that um i i pleasantly liked i thought it made for a pleasant experience listening to it um yeah yeah and this this album i want to say came out on a i guess a pretty big friday for for hip hop music in general there was a big release by um dreamville who released 12 new songs on their revenge of the dreamers album and eminem also released an album with a posthumous feature from juice world on it so um took me a little bit to listen to the album to get around to it but um i guess we wanted to get into what we thought about it yeah um so my expectations going into this album like i said i haven't had really any experience listening to mac miller and i think the only thing i was concerned about was if this album release was a genuine kind of tributes or paid honor to mac miller uh as opposed to just a simple cash grab or because i've um i feel like the the scenario kind of happened with xxx he's a pretty controversial artist in a nutshell but i think just the way that um his posthumous releases have been handled i feel like um like what's happened with him was you know record labels kind of took the opportunity to to kind of utilize his appeal by releasing unfinished demos and unpolished songs songs that weren't not even that good in quality because they weren't finished and um that was something i was kind of scared of with this album but i can gladly say that after listening to it i did not get that feeling i was thoroughly um impressed and awed with uh the work that john breon the collaborator for mac miller and like kind of what he did to make sure that this album truly paid tribute to mac miller's career yeah i want to say too that i thought the rollout of the album is exactly how they should do it for people with posthumous releases i think the family of mac miller put out a statement um just basically detailing how the album was almost finished before and john breon was hopping with it and they put out some really cool music videos to go with the songs which are definitely just um in a very mac miller style if you look back at his old music videos it feels like they almost kind of captured it perfectly and it just does not feel like it's um really for profit like in any way it just feels like it's totally meant to honor mac miller's um legacy and really just stay true to him so yeah i just wanted to give props to the to the family and the producers and everybody who helped with that yeah yeah um that's well said um you know i was thinking of putting sound effects there but i'm not gonna do that yet um so i think yeah just getting on to what i like about the album i personally like i said before i thoroughly enjoyed listening to it um i'm kind of glad i did um i think one thing to note from this album i think was interesting was just kind of the the shift in in the tone and kind of the the genres that is employed in the album uh i you know i had a lot of assumptions that maybe circles would be a lot more hip-hop oriented or that focused but i found that this album was much more uh genre-defined and not necessarily hip-hop and just kind of like folk in a way um it's just really hard to categorize it but i think it's like i don't know i got some folk elements like i was reminded of folk i was reminded of semi-songwriter type songs um there's a lot of r&b in there too which is interesting um but i think and you know despite this kind of um not despite but i think in general just the kind of the quality in the production of um this the quality of production of the album was just top-notch yeah yeah when i was listening to it yeah i wanted to say that it just really stood out to me how well the album was mixed like i mean it really just sounds like you're like the music is in like a circle around you i want to say like it's spread out like really well the vocals are like perfectly layered on top of the songs and it kind of like i guess it kind of goes unnoticed um and then on my second listen i was just like wow it's just so smooth i don't know like yeah yeah like i think one of the tracks uh i can see um that was one example of a track that i thought was really captured kind of um really well mixed r&b song one that was very sensual and a little bit psychedelic way yeah yeah i really liked the chord progression on there was kind of like a what's the word like a dirty chord progression like an alternate yeah like an altered chord progression or something i don't know yeah i felt like that song i guess it's kind of like it's kind of like straightforward feel to it but at the same time i almost want to say it's like kind of experimental just in the in the like harmonies and melody that he does in the song yeah that was um a really good use of his um not only just of lyrics but his voice in general um yeah uh i kind of agree with jack uh for the most part that the mixing in the production was top-notch and handled really well i think the only problem that i had in terms of that aspect was one of the songs and that was complicated um the beat for that song i felt was a little generic and a little bit yeah that was a little corny yeah like the drums were or something i could have gotten from an ipad um like garage man or something like that um yeah that was definitely the song that i would say i had the most problem with too complicated um i guess i kind of yeah i mean i don't really have a problem with the lyrics i really feel like he does a great job of conveying the themes that he wants to convey in the album and making it like a really a really wholesome like like add-on to the journey of swimming but i would just say the instrumental on this one um just seems a lot out of place among the others and or maybe not out of place but it just it just feels like you could have added something more to it or maybe just pick a different instrumental in general yeah um a lot of the i think a lot of that album was very grand and surreal kind of the vibe i got from it and complicated was just one of those songs that felt like a chit tune kind of yeah bouncy type thing which there's nothing wrong with that but i felt like just the the way that it was uh uh kind of arranged and mixed felt a little weird yeah kind of offset the tone of the album a little bit for me um but yeah um i think speaking um you you brought up about um you brought up lyrics which i think are another um i think it's another positive aspect to this album and uh i was really surprised with how um well the delivery of the lyrics was and how kind of simple the like the lyrics were too yeah um like he it was straight to the point uh he was able to just kind of convey what he needed to convey in not a lot of words and you can sense that in the emotions that he kind of conveys yeah absolutely i wrote down on for a lot of songs particularly like good news that's the fourth song and i feel like it's like the way that he um the way he delivers his lyrics on the verses it almost just feels like it sounds like it's so familiar it feels like listening to a chorus like the whole time like a catchy chorus yeah and like not like it's not like you're getting tired of anything it's just i feel like his delivery and the melodies comes up is so unique and like ingenious that it um i don't know if there's really too many other artists like that that i can say um can deliver like a verse in that way yeah that's interesting you brought that up uh i it definitely clicks now um i remember good news um when i first listened to it it was a single when it was first released i think right yeah um yeah it's interesting that you brought that up because um the chord progression is definitely the same uh you can hear the same guitars it felt like the guitar loops were looping but um at the time i was listening to it it felt like it wasn't a loop but it was and i think it also kind of speaks to how well arranged the lyrics were and kind of the instrumentation of it was too because it didn't feel just like a loop like of course it was a loop but um like mac the way mac came in and when he left um kind of helped make that song much more like a like a journey in a sense as opposed to just like oh i'm stuck in this cycle can't get out um i felt like good news really like captured like a um mech on this um therapeutic journey of him trying to like understand you know the concept of good news being people who want to hear good news and um i don't really want to hear what's bad yeah um yeah yeah yeah i guess yeah i want to say my favorite song in the album by a good margin was blue world third track i guess that's kind of partially in and um just personal preferences i kind of like the more upbeat songs i guess i would say but um yeah the sample in the beginning was from the four freshmen also called it's called it's a blue world it's actually called blue world but um i yeah i just love like um kind of just harmonizing vocals like that's just one thing i really like sound sucker for but um then so i was already buying to that at the beginning and then it kind of it did the spiral out or whatever and then the cool like um it's like a gate like a gate like type of effect on that sample yeah yeah kind of similar to that song waves by kanye i don't know yeah yeah similar to that but yeah i thought that beat was super uh super dope i really liked it and and then that came in with a really nice flow too i thought and he wrote the beat well yeah definitely just ran on top of it and the chorus was super nice um and i thought yeah it's almost kind of like crazy crazy how so much of this album um it's almost like if you think about it like if mac's talking about himself it's like almost like about him just being gone or like just like in the song he's like it's a blue world without you you know like a lot of it um i know the first song circle is one of the first lyrics on the song is like this is quote this is what it looks like right before you fall and like that's crazy that's bad as a posthumous release like some things are just like wow it's definitely surreal i think also with the track good news like we just went about before um i thought you kind of got a really good look into his headspace prior to his death and just the mood that he was in before it's just all really tragic and tough you I'm sure as a fan of Mac Miller, it must have been really devastating just to listen to that track, probably, you know, in tandem with understanding the death. Yeah, it's just all too surreal and trippy for me. Yeah, I guess if I wanted to say like a gripe that had on the album, I would say, obviously there's a couple acceptance issues, but overall it felt like most of the songs, they started off kind of just like a slow beat intro and then just constantly building up throughout the song. I feel like I would have liked to hear a little more like different structures in the song in terms of just how the song built.

I mean, it just, yeah, because like every, I mean, there were a lot of guitars on the album, and it kind of just felt like they just added more layers to the guitars a lot as just as each minute went on in the song, or they added like a new little instrument playing a little solo in the background or something, and like all that obviously sounded really nice, but I think I would have just liked a slight bit more of a variance just in terms of the song structure. I personally liked it. I felt like the kind of what, I feel like just kind of the vibe that all of those songs kind of portrayed was, I don't know, it just, I think one thing about this album to note is just how different it is from Swimming, in a sense. Swimming, when I listened to it, was a lot more hip-hop oriented.

It was a record that after listening to it, I felt like was the weaker one compared to Swimming, I feel like, because I felt like the production in Swimming and wasn't as well arranged and developed, and it further kind of inhibited like Mac from getting on the theme of Swimming, which was supposed to be like him trying to navigate his depression and kind of all the troubles that he had faced. I thought that theme was good, it just, it didn't really come off well in the album, it could have been executed way better. Whereas Circles, on the other hand, I got a much different vibe from it, definitely not hip-hop, but more, yeah, more mellow, it showcased a lot more of Mac's singing, which, in terms of like gripes I've had, for the most part his singing came off okay. I think there are parts where he does fall a little bit flat, but it's not too distracting.

I feel like the honesty and emotional vulnerability that he brought in his songs kind of overshadowed a lot of that, like, you know, missing a pitch or two. Yeah, another thing that I really appreciated on the album is that I think a couple times he had, like, actual guitar solos or little, like, synth solos in the background, or not even in the background, in the foreground, during portions of the song, and, like, I just really like that coming from, I played in the jazz band in both middle school and my high school, and that's not a lot of things, or, I mean, that's not a common thing in really any hip-hop music to have an instrumental solo with no lyrics, and I just thought that was a really cool addition to the album, definitely a highlight for me. So, yeah, in terms of favorite tracks, not-so-favorite tracks, I really like Woods and Good News, there's also That's Not Me, Hand Me Downs, Blue World, a track I can see. But, yeah, yeah, for me, I guess, yeah, Blue World, definitely my favorite one.

Good News, also, that was a single we talked about earlier, yeah, I really like that one, too, and I can see, yeah, tracks three, four, five was definitely one of my favorites there. And then I guess I also liked the penultimate song Surf, I thought that had a really cool, like, synth sound to it, really cool sound design on that, I thought, and that was also one that had a guitar solo, so, yeah, definitely a great song for me. Woods, I mean, I talked about Woods already, but I think I really like the theme of Mac, just, or I really like how Mac conveyed the theme of being lost in a relationship, typewise, you feel like, you kind of conveyed the sense of, will I ever be able to love, things like that, and this sensual type beat, that psychedelic type sound just really made the song that much more impactful and powerful for me. Yeah, should we give it a number rating, if you want?

I haven't really thought about it, to be honest. Me either, this could be an interesting one. Yeah, and also, I guess that's another note, is that obviously, Mac wasn't finished with the album when he unfortunately passed, so any gripe that I have with it or anything, I mean, who's to say he could have completely gone a different direction or changed? No one could ever say, so the rating is really to be taken with a grain of salt from anybody.

For real, yeah, most definitely. I'm leaning more towards an eight, maybe a slight nine. Wow, okay. But, yeah.

Yeah, I think I was leaning towards, like, a strong seven, almost an eight, but I think, actually, now I think about it, I feel like it's a very good album. I think I'll say an eight, I'll say an eight. Yeah, yeah. Mac Miller Circles, it's a good album.

RIP to the man, unfortunately, but I'm glad that his fans got an experience that was true to him, not some corporal scheme. Absolutely. Yeah. All right, well, this has been episode three, setting the record straight.

Yeah, we set the record straight there. I don't know what we're going to do next. Yeah, we're still milling over a few ideas, but expect to hear us back for episode four. The Grammys happened, but I don't know, it just came out at a terrible time.

Yeah, I thought, I don't know if we should talk about this, I thought Tyler, the creator's comments on the Grammys, I don't know if you saw that, but I thought that was a really good comment on it. It was a good clapback, for sure. I'm glad that he was able to speak out on the, you know, categorizing artists into, or specifically black artists into urban categories, when that really isn't a thing. Yeah.

Yeah, maybe we can talk about that in a different episode. I guess we should sign off. This has been Jack Graves. I'm Jay Harris.

And goodbye.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of The Daily Californian?

This episode is 28 minutes long.

When was this The Daily Californian episode published?

This episode was published on February 7, 2020.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this The Daily Californian episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.