Skip to content
Sharon at the al-Aqsa compound episode artwork

Sep 28, 2012 8 min

Sharon at the al-Aqsa compound

from Witness History: Archive 2012 Hosted by BBC World Service

In September 2000 the Israeli opposition leader visited the Al-Aqsa compound in Jersualem's old city. Hear from an Israeli, and a Palestinian who were there that day. Photo: Ariel Sharon at the compound. Credit: AFP/Getty Images.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Sharon at the al-Aqsa compound

0:00 8:53
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello, and thank you for downloading Witness from the BBC World Service. Twelve years ago, the Israeli politician Ariel Sharon visited the compound around the Al-Aqsa Mosque in Jerusalem. His appearance triggered anger throughout the Palestinian community. Mike Lanchin has been speaking to two people who were there that day.

It's September 28, 2000. The leader of the Opposition Likud Party, and one of Israel's most controversial politicians, Ariel Sharon, has come to one of the most controversial places in the whole of the Middle East. Sharon is a provocator. He and Paul, the people who joined him, he came here in order to burn up the area.

Al-Aqsa Mosque is an Islamic place. Al-Aqsa is a Palestinian territory. For Muslims, the Al-Aqsa Mosque is sacred, but it sits alongside the Temple Mount, a holy site for Jews, Muslims, and Christians. It's central to the age-old dispute over who controls the holy city itself.

But Ariel Sharon claimed that his visit wasn't intended to provoke. I came here with a message of peace. I came here to the holiest place of the Jewish people to have the feeling how we need to move forward, not provocation here, provocation, but only on the other side. From early that morning, the police had flooded the area, in anticipation of trouble.

They'd effectively closed off the Al-Aqsa Mosque, shutting inside those who'd come to morning prayers. Khalid Sigari is a Palestinian cameraman who was working for Reuters news agency. So I went early morning, two hours before Sharon arrived to the mosque, and I stayed inside the building of the mosque. While the tens of security members of Sharon, of the Israeli security, were really scanning and making clearance that everything is okay and it's very safe for him to get in, and a series of policemen, as a ring, they were around the building that I was inside to prevent any prayers or any Palestinians to leave the building.

As Khalid negotiated his way out of the mosque, Sharon and a group of some 20 supporters began making their way along the narrow winding streets of the old city, past the Wailing or Western Wall, and up towards the Al-Aqsa Mosque. When we actually reached the area of the Western Wall and the walls also of the Temple Mount, which is the same thing, there were already quite a few prayers at the wall, and they all applauded us and cheered us and things like that. And obviously there was some excitement, but not too much. Zalman Sheval is the former Israeli ambassador to Washington.

He decided to join Sharon on his controversial visit after attending a Likud party meeting earlier that same week. He didn't make a speech at the beginning in saying that he was going to do that, but the rumor flew around in the meeting itself. Then he got up and said, yes, we're going to do it. And whoever wants to join him, he'd be very happy if there will be many of us coming with him.

But he didn't say, you have to go with us or anything like that. It was completely voluntary, of course. Did it not occur to you or did it not occur to Mr. Sharon that it could be a provocative move?

It could be, but you know, there's another side to that. For some Arabs at least, for some Muslims at least, the very possibility of a Jewish presence there is provocation. So maybe there was some reason or some logic in saying, look, we don't interfere in your religious practices, but don't interfere in our religious practices. We pay full, I would say, respect to what you are doing, even to the point where the Israeli government has forbidden organized Jewish prayer on the Temple Mount, but don't interfere if we want to go and visit.

But the visit was a political act. Peace talks between the two sides had collapsed despite the direct intervention of U.S. President Bill Clinton, and relations were extremely tense between the Israelis and the Palestinians. I was jumping from place to place.

You can see the shaky sequences and you can hear the voice of everything. And I was from time to time being pushed by his bodyguards and by the security there trying to get us away from him because they were afraid something's going to happen to him. A few people managed to get close to him and they were chanting and saying slogans against. It was really difficult to film his face because he was really behind top security and the famous frame or the famous picture of Sharon, it was his close-up picture of his face with a bodyguard covering his face.

Sharon and his party were careful not to enter the Al-Aqsa Mosque itself that had been agreed with the Israeli government beforehand. And according to Zalman Shaval, it wasn't until the Palestinians began protesting that things turned sour. At first, I must say, it went rather peacefully. Of course, there were Arabs up there, but, you know, we kept to ourselves, they kept to themselves.

There even was a sort of humoristic interlude as far as I was concerned. A fairly aged Arab, completely white-dressed, dressed in white, came up to me and said, you know, I also lived in Washington and I met you there. So we started reminiscing about our experiences in Washington. All that changed radically when an Israeli Arab member of Knesset, there may have been others, but I remember him, and he started whipping up the protests, the enthusiasm and making all sorts of inflammatory statements.

And that is when things got out of hand, or began to get out of hand. As soon as Sharon lifted the compound, you know, there's hundreds of police there in the compound, you know, and at that time, the people started throwing stones toward the Israeli police, and the Israeli police opened fire, but not in a big amount, just a few, you know, maybe a sound grenade, one gas, maybe rubble at that time. The protests petered out, but the next day, Khalid was back in the old city of Jerusalem. Palestinians, still angry at Sharon's visit, were pouring out of the mosques from Friday prayers.

And it was very severe clashes. I never saw such a thing before. Everybody, youths, old people, kids, everybody was holding a stone or anything, and grabbed it and thrown it to the Israeli police. Soon it wasn't just Jerusalem, but across the Palestinian territories of the West Bank and Gaza.

Palestinians were in a fury. Today, the whole West Bank exploded. The streets were on fire across hundreds of miles of Palestinians... The confrontations developed into what was known as the Second Intifada.

By the end of its first year, around 800 people had died. The peace process was in tatters. But Zalman Chaval refuses to accept that Sharon's visit sparked off the violence. The Al-Aqsa Intifada had been pre-planned as part of the faith peace process, the Second Camp David conference with Barak Arafat and Clinton.

And as that conference failed, because of Arafat's refusal to make any concessions, he already had in reserve the decision to start the Intifada at the time, and so he retrospectively put the name Al-Aqsa Intifada to something which had already been decided before that. In elections the following year, Ariel Sharon won a landslide victory and became Prime Minister. But since 2006, he's been in a coma following a massive stroke. The status of Jerusalem and control over the Al-Aqsa compound remains one of the many sticking points in reaching a peaceful settlement between Israelis and Palestinians.

Mike Lanchin. For details of our complete range of downloads and our terms of use, go to bbcworldservice.com slash podcasts. We'll see you next time. We'll see you next time.

We'll see you next time.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Witness History: Archive 2012?

This episode is 8 minutes long.

When was this Witness History: Archive 2012 episode published?

This episode was published on September 28, 2012.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Witness History: Archive 2012 episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.