Shaun Puts Jason Giambi Over Thurman Munson and Gets Crushed

A caller delivers a hilariously backhanded tribute to Tiki Barber, praising his Giants career while repeatedly bringing up his fumbling problems. Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash try to make sense of the bizarre compliment before comparing it to their own awkward encounters with former New York athletes. Shaun then ranks the New York baseball legends he believes belong in the Hall of Fame, including Alex Rodriguez, Roger Clemens, Keith Hernandez, Don Mattingly and Jason Giambi.