Shetland: Jimmy Perez vs Ruth Calder — Who's the Better Detective?

When Douglas Henshall walked away from Shetland, fans were furious. How dare they replace the beloved Jimmy Perez? But then Ashley Jensen arrived as the messy, impulsive Ruth Calder—and the real debate began. Some viewers think she's brilliant. Others find her unbearable. In this episode, we settle the score: Who's the better detective? Can Shetland survive without its moral compass? Or is Ruth Calder exactly what the show needed? We're diving deep into one of British TV's most controversial cast changes, exploring what fans love, what they hate, and why this windswept crime drama refuses to die.Episode 2025-24 "A New Sheriff in Town"Shop at Cozy Earth today for luxurious bedding and bath items. For a 21% discount, use promo code BTVW1