Should Judges Be Elected Like Politicians?

Hello listeners, we're taking a much-needed spring break here at the podcast, but we want to re-share one of our episodes that has become increasingly salient. One of the defining features of the Trump administration so far is its entanglement with the courts. The legality or illegality of many of its actions are currently being decided by federal judges. Which means that judges suddenly have a lot of say over our politics. Is that good? There is a long running debate in political science: do we get better judges by letting the public vote in elections or by giving our leaders the power to appoint them? One side says that judges should be insulated from the influence of politics and elections, focusing entirely on the rule of law. The other side says that our judges should be accountable to the public for the decisions they make in office. Who is right?

Episode 136 of the Not Another Politics Podcast podcast, hosted by University of Chicago Podcast Network, titled "Should Judges Be Elected Like Politicians?" was published on April 25, 2025 and runs 51 minutes.

April 25, 2025 ·51m · Not Another Politics Podcast

0:00 / 0:00

Summary

Hello listeners, we're taking a much-needed spring break here at the podcast, but we want to re-share one of our episodes that has become increasingly salient. One of the defining features of the Trump administration so far is its entanglement with the courts. The legality or illegality of many of its actions are currently being decided by federal judges. Which means that judges suddenly have a lot of say over our politics. Is that good? There is a long running debate in political science: do we get better judges by letting the public vote in elections or by giving our leaders the power to appoint them? One side says that judges should be insulated from the influence of politics and elections, focusing entirely on the rule of law. The other side says that our judges should be accountable to the public for the decisions they make in office. Who is right?

Episode Description

Hello listeners, we're taking a much-needed spring break here at the podcast, but we want to re-share one of our episodes that has become increasingly salient. One of the defining features of the Trump administration so far is its entanglement with the courts. The legality or illegality of many of its actions are currently being decided by federal judges. Which means that judges suddenly have a lot of say over our politics. Is that good?
There is a long running debate in political science: do we get better judges by letting the public vote in elections or by giving our leaders the power to appoint them? One side says that judges should be insulated from the influence of politics and elections, focusing entirely on the rule of law. The other side says that our judges should be accountable to the public for the decisions they make in office. Who is right?

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

Share this episode

Similar Episodes

Attached on American soil,on our capital no water hoses, no night stick,no patty wagon

Jan 7, 2021 ·22m

The year end review part 2

Jan 4, 2021 ·22m

The year end review part1

Jan 4, 2021 ·23m

Hon. Carolyn McLaughlin, Albany Co. Legislator

Dec 22, 2020 ·30m

Pamela Howard, Historic Albany Foundation Executive Director

Dec 22, 2020 ·30m

Hon. John McDonald, Member of the NYS Assembly

Dec 22, 2020 ·30m

Similar Podcasts

Not Another Feminist Podcast Alex Martinez We know what you're thinking, another one?! Although this podcast was created to educate on ALL things femme (entrepreneurship, menstruation, women's rights in politics, hormone health, etc). Expect conversation style interviews with feminist thought leaders who know all about being your own boss bitch. Whether you might be seeking advice on something big like quitting your corporate 9-5 to work freelance gigs remotely, or small, like switching over to a menstrual cup -- give us a listen on your commute home, or whenever you're in the mood to radically amp up those feminist genes. This And That Podcast (w/ Jeff and Gretchen) Jeff And Gretchen Jeff and Gretchen's weekly comedy and audio blog podcast. Oh no! Not another couple cast? Well - Jeff and Gretchen are quite different than the norm. For starters, Jeff and Gretchen are not romantic partners. They approach their weekly show as two friends catching up over a weekend lunch. Extremely well produced, Jeff and Gretchen develop National Lampoon style comedy bits and talk about their fun lives in Dallas Texas. Topics cover politics, music, dating, relationships, sex, science, math (it's true!), religion, movies, their home town and of course this and that! Jeff also writes and performs original music - usually silly, always entertaining. If you haven't heard "Podcast Star" yet (heard by thousands all over the internet), you really should go to their website and check it out. Also on the website you can find all you ever wanted to know about Jeff and Gretchen and their studio. They even keep a blog to keep their fans completely up to date. Not Another Election! Simon Allinson A guide for the exasperated. We're building up to another election, our third in the UK since 2015. Political debate has become increasingly hostile as Brexit continues to divide the country. Traditional party political affiliations are shifting and the rise of the floating voter without a political home continues. So ... the only thing to expect from this election, is the unexpected. That's where this podcast comes in. Rather than get irritated and frustrated - listen in for a light hearted look at the campaign and join in our conversation. twitter.com/anotherelection Sandy Rios 24/7 American Family Association Sandy Rios is a seasoned radio host and former longtime Fox News contributor who has traveled the world and served in various leadership roles in Washington, D.C. Her new podcast, Sandy Rios 24/7, promises to bring unfiltered, insightful commentary from a Christian worldview.Here is what listeners have to say about Sandy: "A trusted source in a sea of fake news!", "There is not another Sandy Rios!", "Spectacular range!", "Great discernment and understanding for our time", "Irreplaceable!"

URL copied to clipboard!