Skip to content
Should MSP Owners Sell Their MSP Themselves or Use a Pro? episode artwork

Oct 15, 2026 22 min

Should MSP Owners Sell Their MSP Themselves or Use a Pro?

from SMB Community Podcast: Business Advice for Small MSP Owners Hosted by MSP Radio

The discussion centers on the tradeoffs and risks associated with self-managing the sale of a Managed Service Provider (MSP) business, highlighting a real case in which the absence of professional M&A, legal, and tax advisory led to contract errors, unfavorable terms, and substantial financial exposure. Both James Kernan and Amy Babinchak, drawing from direct advisory experience, argue that while selling an MSP independently is technically possible, the lack of specialist counsel introduces significant pitfalls. The synopsis emphasizes concrete instances where negotiation leverage, contract accuracy, and legal safeguards were either secured or compromised depending on professional involvement. Supporting details include a specific example involving a failed contract provision: a business sale transacted without an M&A attorney resulted in an omitted clawback clause. Subsequently, more than half of the recurring revenue was lost after the sale, and the seller remained liable for the note without protection. Remediation only became possible after legal intervention, which reduced the seller’s exposure, though such outcomes are considered rare. Both speakers recommend establishing an advisory team comprised of an experienced M&A advisor or broker, a specialized tax expert, and a dedicated M&A attorney, underscoring that operational familiarity with contracts is insufficient for high-stakes divestments. Secondary topics addressed include risk management in cyber insurance procurement and leveraging Cybersecurity Awareness Month for internal team development and customer marketing initiatives. Amy Babinchak distinguishes between basic, low-cost cyber insurance add-ons and comprehensive policies, noting the latter’s higher cost is justified by enhanced coverage, embedded compliance services, and access to consultative support. The segment also briefly references the importance of leadership mindset, noting that focusing on team strengths as a management approach can drive better organizational outcomes. For MSPs and IT leaders, the episode’s discussions reinforce the operational risks of do-it-yourself approaches in high-value transactions and regulated domains like cyber insurance. Key takeaways include prioritizing qualified external counsel for significant business events, maintaining adequate and tailored insurance coverage, and adopting intentional leadership and governance strategies. These measures serve to reduce organizational risk, safeguard asset value, and enhance decision quality in complex or regulated IT services environments. Can I Sell My Own MSP? Show Rundown & Banter: Why selling your MSP alone can be risky, the importance of cybersecurity insurance, Cybersecurity Awareness Month, leadership mindset, and more stories from the field. Question of the Week: What if My Clients Resist Change? Can I sell my own MSP? Yes, but should you? No — get professional help. Topic: Cybersecurity Insurance Understand different insurance options and scenarios. James recommends working with an insurance professional to find the right coverage for you and your business. Topic: Cybersecurity Awareness Month Highlight the importance of cybersecurity awareness and staying proactive about protecting your business and clients. Topic: Leadership Mindset Instead of asking, “What’s wrong, and how do I fix it?” ask, “What’s right, and how do I grow it?” Tales from the Field: The Importance of Using Attorneys Be careful with DIY contracts, agreements, and business deals. AI is not a substitute for legal advice. The NORCAL deal involved a seemingly favorable LOI, but handling the agreement himself led to a key detail being missed. Good agreements matter. About the SMB Community Podcast: Weekly business advice for small MSP owners from Amy Babinchak and James Kernan of the Small Biz Thoughts community — MSP sales, MSP pricing and agreements, hiring and leading an MSP team, MSP operations, selling your MSP, and AI for small MSPs. Produced by MSP Radio. More for MSP owners at smallbizthoughts.com. SMB Community Podcast is supported by our partners: Oveka Supporting the IT services community through insights, analysis, and transparency.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Should MSP Owners Sell Their MSP Themselves or Use a Pro?

0:00 22:46
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

So, your decaf oat milk extra but not piping hot, four pumps of caramel, no sugar, small latte in a large cup, that'll be ten minutes. No worries, I'm having fun on PlayOjo. And I keep it fun with all the latest slot and live casino games. Plus I get instant payouts with no minimum withdrawals. Oh, and no wagering requirements, ever. Here's your decaf oat milk extra but piping hot. Ah, thanks. Playtime's over. Mmm, lovely. Feel the fun, PlayOjo. 19 plus Ontario only, please play responsibly. Concerned about your gambling or that of someone close to you, call 1-866-531-2600 or visit KennexOntario.ca. Alright, hey Amy, good morning, how you doing?

I'm doing all right, James. How are you? I am pumped and fired up. Big week here. College football. We got all sorts of good games this weekend. Oh, awesome. I'm a little disappointed in Michigan State's performance. It's early season and the team is completely injured out.

It's crazy. Yeah, that's football. That's football. Crazy stuff. But yeah, an exciting season. And I'm going to one of the big games this weekend. So I'm going to keep my fingers crossed. So the Huskers win. We got a lot to talk about today. So I'm going to kind of roll through. Here are the topics that we've got. Number one, we're going to talk about why it's not a good idea for you to sell your MSP by yourself. You know, it's important to use professionals. I'm also going to talk about it's cybersecurity month. I want to point that out to everybody and ask what you're doing marketing wise for cybersecurity.

Also, there was a great webinar this past week on cybersecurity insurance. I wanted to talk about cybersecurity insurance. And then another topic that really caught my eye this week was about a leadership mindset and why it's critical for your success. And then we're going to wrap up with a story from the field. So you're ready to go? Let's do it. This is the SMB Community Podcast, the longest running MSP-focused podcast in the industry.

I'm James Kernan. My background is IT sales, marketing, and leadership, and most recently, M&A Advisory Services. And I'm Amy Babinchak. I help MSPs run stronger, more profitable firms from a tech-first perspective. Here, you'll find practical insights for MSPs and IT service providers. Powered by Small Biz Thoughts. All right, Amy, let's get started. So the question of the week is really about, you know, can you sell your own MSP yourself?

And can you do it? Of course you can. But should you do it? And I'm going to say no. And there's lots of reasons. There's lots of pitfalls on that. But it's a tricky thing. To me, selling your own MSP, it's all about marketing because you want to create leverage and get lots of exposure on the opportunity. And you want lots of people bidding on this. You don't want to just have a one-on-one conversation because when somebody realizes that, you're not going to get the kind of deal you could if it's a competitive scenario. But Amy, I know you've been an advisor in the channel for a long time as well. What are your thoughts on that question?

Well, first, I think, James, we need to tell everybody that we may have a conflict of interest on this, or at least just acknowledge it, right? You're a broker. You sell businesses. I'm a consultant. I walk people through this process. I've been doing it for a long time. So that out of the way, we do have an opinion on whether you should sell the business yourself or not. And the thing is, there's a lot of tricky stuff in here. What I always tell people is, you sell your MSP once, so you have to get this right. And this is probably the biggest asset that you own.

And those two things together mean you've got one shot at this to get the best deal that you can for yourself. And that's why you do need to hire professionals. And by professionals, particularly, I mean, you've got to have a business lawyer who's experienced in M&A. Whether you do business with James and me or not, you still need these people. You also need an actual CPA, preferably a tax specialist one, and maybe two, maybe one who's into the tax and one who has experience with your business. And I would say you need that CPA whether you're going to sell or not. I can't believe the number of MSPs that operate without having an actual finance professional in their corner. So that was such a huge advantage for me as a young business owner. I think I sort of stumbled into it. I heard somebody say, oh, you should get a CPA. And I went and I did. And the guy was awesome.

I met with him every month for like two years in the beginning because I was learning everything. I had so much to learn. And he taught me everything about how to, you know, how to do the finances of this business and all that was such an advantage. And then when it came to time 23 years later to sell the business, same thing. He had experience in that area. He brought in a tax specialist person with him. And, you know, they were with me every step of the way in selling my company. And then the legal part is also really crucial. I've seen people do this without a lawyer and I'm just baffled.

They're like, oh, yeah, I've been reading contracts my whole business time. I'm a really good contracts guy. I'm like, yeah, well, when's the last time you read an M&A contract from a business that's trying to purchase you? Like, never. Couldn't agree with you more. And obviously, we are a little biased. But why we're biased is because we've seen people screw up royally. And we've got some stories about that.

To recap what Amy just said, because it's really, really important. You need three people in your corner when you are selling your business. You need an advisor or broker to walk you through the whole process and avoid the pitfalls. Number two, you need a good tax person, right? Because there's all sorts of tax loopholes, tax ramifications about how you sell the structure, payments, all that. And then you need a great M&A attorney.

OK, not not a divorce attorney, not a business attorney, but an M&A attorney that has real world experience with M&A. And if you're if you're buying a business, you need for the fourth person would be a finance, you know, a good banker. And I'm sure Amy does. And I've got great referrals on all of those if anybody ever needs it. But you need those professionals in your corner to avoid the pitfalls. And I'm going to I'm going to wrap up today's episode with a real world story about someone who screwed up and we fixed it. But I'll talk about why that's so important. But, you know, the lawyers know the language and the language is really important in this because when they present you their contract, it has all the protections for the buyer.

And then you have to go back to them and say, these are the protections that I need. Right. That's what your lawyer is going to do for you. And so there's a there's a lot of a lot of little things you want to make sure are in that contract and they're not going to be in there from the get go. So you need to understand the contract language in order to make that happen. And that's the role of your lawyer. Your lawyer is also there to look out and say, hey, you know what this what they're actually saying with this phrase is, you know, are you OK with that? They'll come back and ask you if you're OK with you understand what this means and are you OK with that? You know, and they'll have their experiences. Well, some of my business owners are.

For these reasons, some of them aren't. For these other reasons, you know, where do you fit? And so they're going to present you with all of these challenges to that contract and ask you to make decisions on, are you okay with this? Are you okay with that? That's the real value of the lawyer. It's not just like, oh, they're going to charge me by the word to write a contract.

no, your lawyer isn't writing a contract if you're the seller. Your lawyer is reading that contract and helping you improve it to your advantage. That's why you're spending that money. When you're in front of your customers, you're pitching the importance of hiring an expert for cybersecurity, for cloud, you know, for managed IT, you know, and you've got do-it-yourself or end-user customers. Oh, we're going to do our own IT. And you always tell them that's not a good idea. It's exactly what Amy and I are saying right now. You know, hire professionals.

All right. I was on a great webinar this past week about cybersecurity insurance. And Joseph Brunsman was running the webinar with Dave Sobel. And I thought it was really interesting. And 10 minutes into this hour-long banter about how complex cybersecurity insurance is, I just quickly came to the conclusion, again, work with professionals. There were a couple of people that had questions that they just bought their cybersecurity insurance without talking to anybody. They just bought it online from an inexpensive company. And you don't really know exactly what coverage when you sell your business.

and you sell your employees, you sell your contracts, and then you're the business owner. Most sales are asset sales. So the owner there would sell the business, and then you still have the corporate entity, right? Maybe you're still collecting receivables. You're still operating. You don't need the same coverage that you once had because you don't have any employees anymore. Maybe you don't have an office anymore. The revenue is going to go down dramatically. So there's other insurance that you can get, you know, much less expensive, but you need to get the right coverage. What I know is that I spent a lot of money on insurance over the years, and I worry about people that don't.

You know, there's some opportunities in our industry to purchase really inexpensive insurance. And that's a route that I never went. I spent good money on insurance and fortunately never needed it. But, you know, that's what makes people not want to spend the money. But I was I was OK with spending it. You know, we had, you know, insurance from one company, but we went cyber security. We went with a specialist for that. You can get it from your general business insurance guy. He's like, oh, yeah, we have cyber insurance. And they just tick a box and it says, tick, you know, you have cyber insurance now. And there's no details in that.

When you get an actual cyber insurance dedicated policy, it's thick. There's a lot in it. There's a lot of coverage. There's usually some services built into that as well to help you stay in compliance, to help you keep up to date. They've got some consultants on there and some staff you can call on when you have questions. So there's a lot of things in those dedicated cyber insurance policies that make them stand out from your business insurance guy just ticking the box and saying, yeah, we have cyber insurance. It's only going to add $100 to your policy.

That should actually be a red flag because this cyber insurance stuff isn't inexpensive. It's not inexpensive for a reason because the liabilities on it are so high for you as the MSP. I'm Dave Sobel, Dean of IT Service Provider University, and I want to let you know about a new class we're offering with instructor Lori Hartke. This industry has a habit of asking one question first. How big is it? Revenue is the number that gets shared from the stage and in the group chat. Also the number that tells you the least about whether the business is actually working. Here's Lori on the gap she wants to close. I think one of the biggest.

signals is when a business looks successful from the outside but it's really doesn't feel like it's successful to the owner and maybe their revenue keeps growing but their pay doesn't or perhaps they are always worried about cash and we have money moving around from personal business i know that was me for a lot of years maybe racking up a lot of credit card debt to bridge that gap perhaps they're simply working a lot of hours and they just feel like the business could be rewarding them for the time and the risk that they're putting into it. Lori's class, Building a Better MSP, starts in October and runs weekly starting Tuesday, October 13th at 1 p.m. Eastern. Register today at itspu.com.

All right. Friendly reminder, it's October is cybersecurity month and most of our listeners are selling cybersecurity. So my question to you is, what are you doing? It's a great marketing opportunity. You know, you're talking about it on social media. Are you running email campaigns, postcard campaigns? You should be doing something, something. Have you seen anything, you know, that caught your eye from a marketing standpoint, Amy, this month? You know, yes, but it's geared to the MSP. So in my newsletter recently, I shared a blog post by AdminDroid, which has this really cool 31 day.

cybersecurity gamification challenge, right? They've gamed out the whole thing. So your tech staff, right? This is for MSPs. Your tech staff can learn it. And I would get all your tech staff on that for sure. So be sure to look that up and take advantage of it. It's free, which is awesome. They put so much work into that to develop it. It's really cool. But as far as marketing goes, I'm with you. I haven't seen any great cybersecurity marketing, but it wouldn't be hard to create it. You know, you just sit down, sit down at your staff meeting, right? We need 31 tips.

And, you know, just email one out to your clients every day, post it to your social media every day. You know, super easy to do. Makes you look like the expert. It's good stuff. So, Amy, this is more of a mindset question. Just imagine you opening your staff meeting with the question to your team instead of saying, what's wrong? How do I fix it?

You say, what's right, how do I grow it? Okay, what's right, how do I grow it? And I see this time and time again, everybody's always talking about problems and how do I work through that? And that's important too, but it reminded me about the book called StrengthsFinders and the StrengthsFinders whole premise was that all of us have some type of talent. We all have some God-given gifts that we have and that we bring to the market. And the point is develop those further because the things that you're good at.

you probably enjoy them more than things that you're not so good at and that you avoid like the plague. So, you know, that's where good team members can come in and kind of compliment you where you're not so strong. But just as a human being, I love that thought, you know, what's right and how do I grow it? I love that. I love that idea. I'm with you on the StrengthsFinder. I used that with all my staff. I had everybody take it. And the results helped them understand their fellow employees and it helped me understand them better. Before we took it, we all agreed to share our results. And it tells you...

how to talk to people. It helps you manage people. It makes you understand what their, how their brain works because we're all a little bit different. I love that. Love, totally love, love, love that tool. It's one thing to do the strength finders exercise and find out who you are and what you're good at and what you're not so good at, but it's more important to find out more about the rest of the team and then share those results with each other because you all compliment each other to create, you all make up the team, right? And you need, you know, other team members to kind of compliment where other people aren't so strong, but more importantly of how you treat each other and how to influence people. You know, those are really important that you share those results with the whole team. Yeah.

Yeah, it really helped me as a manager of the team so that when certain kinds of things came up, I knew exactly who to give it to and who not to give it to because of those things. But I love the idea of asking what's right and how do we grow it at the end of your meeting because businesses are just one problem after another. You're right. We do have to solve those problems. And, you know, as the person in charge, we get really used to solving problems.

So much so it can become a detriment in your personal life. I know it did mine. If you ask me any question at all, I have an answer for it right now because that's what I do all day at work, right? That's not always the right thing to do at home. But so asking this question at the end, what's right and how can we do more of it? I think that would be a great question to have at your weekly staff meeting.

So Amy, I wanted to wrap up with a real world story that we've kind of been hinting at and talking about it already, but this actually happened. It was on an acquisition deal. I was representing a buyer and we negotiated a sweetheart deal. They were in the right place at the right time. They were the only ones, we were the only ones at the negotiating table. It just was a unique deal and they were perfect to acquire them because they had the right skill sets for these clients. And we...

I wrote out the LOI, the letter of intent, you know, the term sheet, whatever you want to call it. And we teed up a deal where we had a low deposit and there was a long, it was a two-year note, but it had clawback provisions based on these new contracts all being renewed over the next 24 months. And that's really important because you're essentially, all of you, when you're buying something, you're buying the contracts. You need that revenue, you need that guarantee. And without that revenue coming in, you don't have the money to pay back on the note. So I had a clawback provision written in there. The seller agreed to it.

OK, and and again, it's one of those things where it's like, hey, remember, you need an advisor, you need a good tax person and you need a good attorney with M&A experience. Well, this person didn't tell me they didn't have an attorney representing them. When it came down to the tail end of due diligence, they ended up using chat GPT in Claude to help kind of write out and edit the purchase agreement. And what actually happened was they had all the other deal points in there except that clawback provision. And they missed that. And it basically came across as a promissory note where they promised to pay the full amount. And guess what happened after year one?

They lost a bunch of contracts. They lost a bunch of contracts. And the revenue got cut in over half of the revenue disappeared. And the person called me and, you know, this is a year later and said, hey, I need your help with this. And I said, OK, well, what? And he said, well, the final purchase agreement that we had, you know, didn't have the right language in there. And I said, well, you know, what did your attorney? And that's when he told me, like, well, I really didn't use an attorney. I was kind of doing this myself. And I was like, this is a major faux pop.

And what we ultimately did is we did work with, we did get him an attorney and we did go back to the negotiating table with the other party and said, hey, remember the spirit of the deal was this clawback. Remember, we talked about the importance of you having this conditional note and us getting all the renewals. We talked about that. That was in the letter of intent, but it didn't make the final agreement. Well, of course, the seller did everything in the world they could to avoid it. And then once we got an attorney involved, then the attorneys ended up working it out. And then they ended up doing a final payment that was dramatically lower than the remaining one-year note that was owed. But it really saved their bacon. And that's rare. You know, when you have a contract in place, it's pretty hard and everybody agreed on it and signed it. And then a year goes by of performance and then something changes and you want to renegotiate things. The moral of the story is just work with professionals. Don't try to do it yourself because things like this actually happen. And I hope it doesn't happen to you.

So, all right. Well, hey, Amy and I want to hear from you. So please submit your question of the week. Any feedback that you've got for Amy and I, we'd love to hear from you. So you could submit your audio file to the smbcommunitypodcast.com website or send it to me, james at kernanconsulting.com. So until next time, we'll see you soon.

Thank you for listening and or watching. Remember, Dave breaks down the IT news of the day on his show, The Business of Tech, which drops at 5 p.m. Eastern, Mondays through Fridays, with bonus content on the weekends.

So, your decaf oat milk extra but not piping hot, four pumps of caramel, no sugar, small latte in a large cup, that'll be ten minutes. No worries, I'm having fun on PlayOjo. And I keep in fun with all the latest slot and lot of casino games. Plus I get instant payouts with no minimum withdrawals. Oh, and no wagering requirements, ever. Here's your decaf oat milk extra but piping hot. Ah, thanks. Playtime's over. Mmm, lovely. Feel the fun, PlayOjo. 19 plus Ontario only, please play responsibly. Concerned about your gambling or that of someone close to you, call 1-866-531-2600 or visit cannexontario.ca.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of SMB Community Podcast: Business Advice for Small MSP Owners?

This episode is 22 minutes long.

When was this SMB Community Podcast: Business Advice for Small MSP Owners episode published?

This episode was published on October 15, 2026.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this SMB Community Podcast: Business Advice for Small MSP Owners episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.