Skip to content
Should we have a Universal Basic Income? July 17, 2026 episode artwork

Jul 17, 2026 1 hr 22 min

Should we have a Universal Basic Income? July 17, 2026

from Motley Fool Money Hosted by LiSTNR

What if there was a way to reduce the cost of administration, and the friction of changing jobs? But what if it led to worse outcomes? That’s the quandary the boys are throwing around in this episode on the merits of a Universal Basic Income.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Should we have a Universal Basic Income? July 17, 2026

0:00 1:22:41
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

A listener production. JEREMY MALKE. The disappear the Isaac Stolfes. This is Motley Formally. Welcome to Motley Formally, the podcast that may not be universal, but is certainly very basic.

I've got to go from Motley Form the basic one. He's the universal one. He has Andrew Page, the man who invented Stromand.com who breathed life into its steel body, animated it from nothing and proved that a macular conception really is a thing. Mr Page, how are you? Good mate.

You've got me chuckling with that one because we do put the B in basic, don't we? Like it's a... And B in BS, but it's a whole different conversation. Yeah, that's a whole other thing too. My turn.

We are going to... we exist at another pre-recorded podcast and it's a usual joke. I'm getting home at this point, I suspect, as long as everything's gone well. And we had a couple of questions over time, speaking of universal and basic, to talk about a universal basic income. Now, this is kind of... you know, at least in theory, an investing-based podcast, and we

still will do lots of that, and there's kind of touch on that stuff as well. But it does also touch on kind of policy, right? And what I think you and I find regularly is you pull a bit of string and it kind of... nothing through the unravel, but it's all kind of linked, right? We talked a lot in the recent weeks about the tax policies, for example, are part of the budget.

And this is kind of the other side of that. It is part of the functioning of... not me beyond necessarily, but these conversations are part of what creates the circumstances in which companies live, survive, thrive, hopefully. So it's kind of... I guess we'll try and link it back in my description here.

But I think it is relevant, right? Policy settings are relevant. You know, I've said lots of times. The best circumstances for a company to be existing within are those that create prosperous people in a prosperous economy and prosperous country because that's when people are going to spend their companies are going to thrive for the most part. If you need a dystopian stuff, maybe you can buy weapons makers or something, but for the rest of us, you know, the economy only does well.

Companies tend to do well. And we can't give out what's caused and what's effect, but broadly speaking, we want to leave in a country that has a... for our own sector. But even on behalf of the companies that we invest in, thriving economy is pretty much not very well, but it's the best possible way to start, right? Oh, it is.

I mean, I actually... I bristle a little bit with all of that. Everything that you just said is 100% accurate. And it's always the talk about the economy, the economy, the economy. But it does... it's a part of me that there's an eye roll with that.

Because I feel as though we've forgotten what we actually mean by that. What you mean by that, if I can put words in your mouth, is just like, we want a more comfortable life. Yeah. Let's get rid of the BS. That's what I would like to have more stuff.

Not for a hedonistic reason, although maybe. But just because I... for the last... whoever made you 100,000 years, that has been what we have striven for. We want to be able to acquire more things, leave a comfortable life.

Or just... even if you want to live like a monk, we want to provide for the basics with as little work as possible. Because we're here for a finite amount of time. Life is precious. I want to spend it with my family and my friends, having great experiences.

I don't want to spend it near a tiny cubicle filling out a 2C slash 7, 8, 4, 9, B form. That is not living. No, no, no. At the same time, let's be realistic. Sometimes forms have to be filled out.

Sometimes stuff has to get done, right? But it's about managing those two things. And so, yes, I just... I've just got to jump on my hobby horse very quickly and say, yes, it is about the economy, but let's just be real. It is not about trying to make GDP go up.

It is not about all of these sort of vanity kind of new term metrics because it just sounds good. That's what it's all about. It's funny, we're getting off track of this podcast. We do this podcast all week. It's all week.

It's all week. We have to do this podcast. I'm going to hit this podcast. But you're reminded a little bit of four things, Maslow's hierarchy of needs. It's probably one of the most famous diagrams in all of... probably, I don't know, certainly

in psychology and even those of us aren't psychology majors know about that. Then you kind of talk about... you kind of talk about the stuff that we need. And it's kind of... we do instinctively move up the hardest way.

It's like, this, right? You start with, do I have enough to wait? Do I have to drink? Do I have to move up my head? Am I warm?

Those things are just fundamentally... And then when you get to that point, so right, how do I make sure I keep them? Don't worry about it. You're like, you're like, please subscribe when you're starving, right? Or you're freezing cold in the rain.

But... But you've got it. Then you do want to go. Okay, well, I'm going to get it. Then I'm going to secure it.

What's next? What next? What next do I want? And that's the kind of... that idea of... of... of...

of... of... headness and... if we want to call that, just, you know, getting the best out of life is exactly that. It's just...

And then, by the way, there is diminishing returns at some point of film come. But that idea of like, well, let's just get to the point where I don't have to rely on others and I can withstand the unexpected. And, you know, I'm... I'm not only making my life better, so I do that first. When I get too better, I go to work out how do I make sure I don't jeopardize it.

And then you kind of... Right, exactly. So... And the only thing that I love you... you can mention is really important.

It's almost like... I don't have a gun of capitalization, right, when we speak. But it's almost a lower case. And this is... I think you make a really good one.

I'll just double down on that. The economy is what we've termed the aggregate of those things described by economics. And that's kind of like... and it sounds like we're being funded with, but we're really not. And your point is absolutely right.

When you say, well, how do we grow the capital... the economy capital, the... well, we have GDP go up. I mean, that's truly an aggregate. And to some degree, GDP is a little bit useful to help us know whether we are an aggregate, you know, improving things, but it's so far away from what is... and as always, the same economics is about those trade-offs

and the interactions and the way we price things, the way we value things. That's really useful. It's really like predictions and theory. That's like... as much as the old Yogi Bear coming back practice and theory is true, the theory economics is really, really useful because it helps us understand the interactions.

So we can take those broad ideas into the world. And that matters for policy center, like capital C, capital E economy. It matters when we go into the world. Because it matters to think about, right, what are things that are going to make things better for people or worse for people? The economy gives us lots of that stuff.

But as you say, we absolutely fall over when we start to say, let's do things for the economy rather than let's do things for people and the result will look after itself. And it's kind of... you know, what gets measured gets done. We're going to get to GDP, so we focus on GDP. We've talked a lot about different measures before, a lot of times.

But I think it's a really, really important point you make. It's one that we... when I talk about the economy, I talk about some total of these things, not some top-down aggregate number that matters more than the actual experience of individual people. Yeah, well said. I mean, it's purely the study of CSED versus unlimited human-wise.

Exactly. That's right. It's not true to cost them all the things we always want. We want stuff. We've somehow got to get it. There's only so much of it.

Who's going to do it? Who's going to do the work? And when the work gets done, who gets to share in the upside? How do we coordinate ourselves? How do we distribute this stuff?

How do we do it in a way that's really for one of a better term for fair? Because that's a lot of different people who have different measures on that. But in a way that I suppose I won't even try and unpick that. It's harder than it sounds. It's a bit of an hour.

And that's what it is. And that's where I guess, which is the nice segue into the UBI, because it's an idea, universal basic income. It's this idea. It's kind of like a welfare-based idea, but one that basically says, listen, rather than sort of having means, tests, and this and that. Why doesn't every single person just get the same amount per year, per month, per week, however you do it.

And that's just it. That's your welfare. That's it. There's nothing else. And it's an interesting idea. It's like a lot of ideas that sort of like the first time you hear it,

that's ridiculous. I'm actually not convinced that it isn't, by the way. I really want to start off by saying, I don't actually have a really good view of this yet. I kind of don't mind that, but on the other hand, I'm sort of in that. Which I think this will be an interesting conversation, because I'm keen to sort of...

We haven't... as everyone about listeners, like we have not rehearsed or planned at all. We've been talking about this for a while, should we do that? Yeah, let's do that. So I'm keen to have the conversation and bounce it around.

But yeah, that's where we're really starting with. I suppose it's been catalyzed more recently because, I'm just to dumb it down, robots and AI. Which is... If machine's doing everything, what are humans going to do? And if humans aren't going to do anything, are you going to have a job?

How are they going to pay for stuff? Oh, that's a prickly one. Now, it might be... I'll throw this hand grenade into the mix and then you can go for it. It may well be that the entire premise of how I just framed it is absolutely flawed.

People were talking about this idea a long time ago, just when automation was really kicking off. It was like, wow, wait, if the steam powered engine and factories are going to do everything, what's the ordinary person going to do? And then you sort of fast forward, it's like, that turns out that podcasting is a career. It turns out that Biflorn's out is a career. Things that just weren't even imagined, but just humans just sort of, you know, not retreat, but I guess go to other areas.

And what may well be that... Well, maybe two things. It may well be that AI and robotics doesn't leave up to the premise, or at least not in any practical near-term kind of sense. Or that it does, and we all become artists, you know? And that's enough to sort of sustain us.

I don't know. What do you think of that? So, just quietly, if the argument or excuse for progress is, at least we have podcasts and influencers now. I'm not sure you've made a strong cut, strong cut for progress round. This is a shaky ground, right there.

Exactly. Look how well we've done. We now can do this. Contact graders are a thing. Yeah, they are.

So I'm going to take half of it back, actually, because I want to address the ideological kind of basis from both perspectives, and then I'll get back to you for what happens next. So it's fascinating to me, and this is... I mean, I try to be pragmatic rather than ideological right, and I look at some of the ideologues on the edges, and I guess there was some justification where it comes to this is how I see the world, and how we have our value systems, and we call our ideology, our philosophy, our views, our values, our ethics, or something else. But it's fascinating to me, those on the right will say, we can't have UBI because no one will work. Everyone's lazy.

And if we have UBI, there's no incentive, and things will be under a halt, right? On the left, ironically, they're not even on the right. They're on the left, right. So I know this. I'm just pointing out, because it's both universally supported and universally despised.

On both sides, we tell you maybe something's there, or maybe nothing's there. On the left, they say, no, no, no, UBI is excuse for not having a job for everybody. And we can have UBI, I couldn't have jobs guaranteed. If you're not a job, you're going to need UBI, because you're going to want to work good, because you're going to be a job for everybody. And so you kind of got this really weird scenario where the right is saying, the left is just trying to give up welfare, and the left is saying, the right is making us all take UBI, some sort of neo-liberal dream rather, actually give me a wrong job.

And it's just a weird, weird sort of. I say that because there'll be people who are on either side of that con, and have that viewer on the left or the right. And I want to be really clear, this is not an ideal logic. I don't know, it's not only sides, you guys are sides question. So if you think, well, that's all the left you're doing this, trust me, I can't do this, I can't do this.

So I find that right, we just run to the other real thing. No, it's not right, we just are saying, it's all worth it all right. So I want to paint that, because I want to ask our listeners to step out of what might be the knee-jerk reaction. So I understand what the mechanisms might be and how that might work. I mean, I've said before, so I'm not giving you any way. We should trial it, it's my view.

And we should trial it in a geographic area. I've seen it in 10, nine years before, and it's a realistic view. It's like, it's its own island. And you know who's there? And you don't have people crossing borders when you cross the bus straight.

But realistically, it's a reasonably self-contained group. And you could trial it there without too much drama with some reasonable rules for a period of time. And so I would not work. So I'll give that away. That's the conclusion I've come to, which is not so very scientific conclusion.

Really, it's like, I don't know, let's run the test. I think it's worth trying. I think it's worth trying because I think if it works, it would be great. But by definition, everything works, if it works, if it works, it's self, you know, and by the way, people object to the trial too. We shouldn't try it because it makes people lazy, but we can try and find it.

No, no, it's not going to work. So we can try, then you'd be right. You could tell me you're right, you could say, how's it going to do that? I was like, oh, it sounds like you're just having an ideological opposition to it rather actually wanting to find out. So you might see the question, I'll get back to that because it's important.

There's two ways to think about UBI in my mind. The first is as a potential catch all for periods of meaningful unemployment in my country. And that's the modern energy. I have been a supporter of trial and UBI before I became a thing. So my view is actually not driven by that primarily. So I'm going to talk about that particular question as you asked,

but just to kind of flip it up. Really? It's because it's the idea. It might be absolutely necessary to think, oh, we're talking about it because all of a sudden, three months, three years, 10 years, like, oh, I've got 15, 10 people out of work. Now what the hell do we do? So we're talking about it. Now it's useful.

My voice to honey point, mate, is you talk about simplicity before. So take a situation. There's two things for me. There is the removal of stupidly large unnecessary bureaucracy around the management of what we call train service payments in the jargon, basically, well, for other types of payments, whether that is the doll, the age pension, single parents pension, family tax benefit, I say the doll, I guess the doll, etc, etc, etc, etc. Right? I'll study, I'll study, I'll study, like just all the stuff, like the reams and reams and reams of literal paper and metaphorical paper.

I don't know if the text is collected, but only 50 cents gets distributed because of the administration burden. No, I don't know if that number, I don't know what the proportion is here. No, that though, for the people who are getting it, there's a whole lot of inefficiency, I've got to go and justify my life, I've got to show that the government of the public has to read them all, and hang out, some small proportion of the text is collected, and most of them are getting it, has to have to have a whole lot of ring moral and hassle. And then think about changing jobs. If you change jobs, I go, I drop the mother's mouth, I come work at Strongman because I hear it's going to be a billion dollar business and I really want to say equity.

I do that. Because we only pay inequity. We don't pay in cash. It's as good as money, sir. Next time we talk, it's really good to make. That'll be a whole lot of good possession.

Don't get me sick. No, I'm getting out of the way. Never send it. Can you spin it on me? So in that situation, I'm going to leave my job.

Now let's actually leave my job. That's fine because I leave my resign because I'm giving another job. Let's say that I come to financial services and let's go back to my own. No, I'm going to do it because I want to keep it out of it. Let's say what comes to me, Scott, it's been great, but the podcast sucks and you stop because you're awful and you're pretty rubbish, but you're all sure that it's the business anymore.

I go, whoosh. Go to something that low. It's a gold luncheon. Thanks for the years. With the bubble, with the bubble, with the bubble.

So I get the result and it takes me six months to find another job. I'm doing that period of time. Not only am I out of work, so I'm going to come here and come and come and apply for the doll and I've got to get there, go and do my meetings. So this friction between periods of employment. Even though the doll is there, I went from tax payer to tax payer again.

The process of that, how long do I have to be out of work? When do I get the money? The friction of changing jobs voluntarily or otherwise is really significant. So then imagine a scenario, this is the account. I just very quickly add, there is a, I would advocate for a personal responsibility, I'm an obit, like, hey, maybe if you're going to quit your job without having another one, maybe build up some savings.

Saving's a good, you know. You're implicit in your framing and you're right to do it because the statistics back you up. Exactly, yeah. So you're right to do it, but it is kind of that tragedy. It's just sort of like, we're all living, actually I looked it up the other day, something like 40% of Australian households hand to hand to mouth.

And so it's kind of like, what? You know, anyway, that's a whole other conversation. But, yeah. There is another path to sort of suggest that's sort of like that's why we have savings there. I'm actually, again, there's so people who can't write. So I'm going to be fine because I'm working on a six-year job and I will lose my job and I'll get another job.

I've got some savings, I'm fine. Those 40% of people who, some of which are just absolutely profit with their money and whatever, whatever, or they literally literally struggling to pay the rent, which are called about housing costs and inflation, anything else. You know, some can't have savings, some can and shouldn't, and there's a group there. But in other cases, the other case, the other universal way is income being back to it. You know, I certainly don't want to suggest blame.

No, no, no, no, no. I'm going to say that back too, because there's plenty of people who say, you're safe what, man? Safe what after I've paid for rent and food and food and food. So, yeah. I'm already on backwards and yeah, exactly.

I'm going to have to pay what you want me to do. So, I'm advocating for it. I'm making the case for a trial. So I'm going to sound positive about it because I want to explain why it might be worth trial and just to say that thing as well. Rather than the podcast advocating for it entirely, I'm going to advocate for a trial because some of these things might be useful.

This is, why would you try to get this is what I'm coming from. So, before we even get to AI, if in a situation where you could say, right, let's say, I'm going to pick it up. I'm going to say 20,000, because if I like it, it's 500 bucks, so I'm going to pick it up. By the way, that conversation is why much is the right number. So, that's all different.

It's like talking about communism, it's like there's the idea and then there's the execution. It's like maybe it's a great idea, you'll be like, it could be really badly executed. Quick aside, by the way, every citizen gets $5,000 from their oil sales. So, there are versions of this kind of thing. That's not going to be making way to small to be a genuine base income.

But there are examples where people are given shares of spoils of something, less because the obvious ones around the world. So, my point about the UBI is in a situation where the tax tax is granted to you. And the way I would do it, that's trial, it's the case, loss of options. You just say everybody, right, you get 500 bucks a week. And the boss, your payoffs is required to tax you 100% for the first 500 bucks a week you won.

Because you're getting that from the government. So, it's a pass through payment, tax on numbers, all that's required. You would demand the tax sales. So, the first 500 bucks a week you won, you get taxed 100%. Thereafter, it goes back to the marginal sales, the tax free thresholds we know.

So, just to explain, I have to pay one extra money, if you work, you don't get an extra money, that's the point, right? So, it's effectively taxed back from you from work. But without any obligation to prove your work or not working, no dollar, comment, a single parent, it's just literally you get the money, right? So, what does that mean? It means that you take away the friction, or if I change jobs tomorrow, I'm going to get 500 bucks an week from the tax office going to drop in my bank account.

It's not enough to live on for the long term, but I know I can do it to the week after. Then, how many go for the dollar, apply for this, go to that interview, go to that meeting with us. What's the, what's the department government? What's the department government government? Anyway, change every two years.

Anyway, that's the kind of idea of, you know, remembering all that paperwork, then all the bureaucracy, right? And yes, it's going to be a stage change. You can't throw that many public service that work on day one. But realistically, think about the cost savings, the friction savings, and it could be relatively, relatively revenue neutral at a total level. Some are better off, some are worse off because that's what's how it happens.

What we don't know is who would stop working or work less and what burden that would add and how that would compare to the savings made from the administration of friction cost for the economy. We don't have efficiency in the economy all the time, right? And the government, one of the great things that's doing at the moment is many non-compete clauses. I think it's between anyone. Because it was the kind of restraint of trade, right?

The idea of you can move between jobs that being told, I was like, I was like, man, if you're going to do any other software, you have to be a 12-month software ridiculous. And it's kind of like, you can do it. I don't blame Y-State for wanting to do it, but it's kind of restraint of trade and competitive. So that idea of what if we had no friction of changing jobs, we could just change jobs when we wanted to, without penalty, personal penalty, not penalty, but without having to weigh up that impact. And when there's a mean-for-it again, think about COVID, right?

In a COVID type time, there wouldn't be no other requirement. You just get the money. So you lose your job tomorrow. Okay, we got the money. Okay, back to the work.

We got our first five-year-old. Five-year-old. And we're back after the races. So that's kind of in my mind, mate. That's how I would trial a universal basic income.

And the reasons I would do it are for the friction for workers, for a risk of friction, and with a whole lot of massive distortion and overhead from the tax system. So it does not require it. Now, we'll say very quickly, there would still be need for some additional top-up payments. Think about the NDIS, for example, the reality is someone who's able-bodied and is an influencer, someone who needs meaningful amounts of care. So this is not a panacea, and it's not some utopian.

This would be only a payment ever required, get rid of the rest, but it would be a, for the most part, a simple 98% of the population, an IP in the population payment, which has covered all of the things that needs to cover in that. That's kind of how I imagine trialing it. Now, how much of the right number, it's probably somewhere around the old education, I suspect, just because we already at that level. Right? No, it's not.

Frankly, politically, that economically. You're not going to get away with saying, actually, you get less. So I'd start with that for everybody, and just say, right, at pro, it's probably at all, whether it's 16 or 18, we can have the conversation about, or we've got to leave school to do it. It's going to be some sort of process by which you start to, to learn or receive it. Yeah, that's kind of what I would trial, mate.

So, and AI is, by the way, a really great reason why, which is that the COVID, right, that the COVID kind of surprise shock, whatever. The next one comes around. The system's already in place. It's already working. It's already been paid out.

This thing is already working doing its thing. So, to my mind, that would cushion the blow of those types of snows without requiring, again, much in the way of additional payments and no delays in those payments, no emergency measures that are required. You're not talking a recent podcast made about throwing things at people in case of desperation. And we talked about the fact that the budget balance, a fiscal structurally balanced budget would do that job of the stock, which is all we're supposed to do. If it was set properly, do you be able to do a similar kind of thing as a welfare payment?

And again, just be really clear, it would cost more probably than we're currently paying. I suspect if you just think about the wrinkles and stuff, but given that most of us are working or already receiving it, a payment of something like that level, the increment is nowhere near as much as people sneakily kind of recoil from it. Hang on, everyone's getting an extra $x a week. For those who are already on welfare payments, they get that instead. Those are working, we get it and get it taxed back out of us anyway.

So, the only change really those who choose to leave the workforce because they're getting UBI or those who are getting a lower payment side. I don't know what the payments are, but the $x the age pension, right? So, that person would get kicked up to the higher level. Whatever you go with, and that would cost an extra. So, that's kind of how the mechanics would work.

And then we try it. We don't have it for months, probably. Do it 10 million. And just say, and it's going to cost $x million or $100 million. It's probably going to be real.

Incredibly, probably not. It's a small population. You don't have to have 12 months. You are collecting the extra tax anyway. What I mean about the cost is the cost relative to what we've heavily, kind of factually talked about.

Yeah, it costs more. Would it cost? If it went really, really badly? I don't know. I can't believe it probably in Tasmania.

If it went really, really well, maybe nothing. Some combination therein. Yeah. That's why two of us were kind of just a dump of what I would do. And the question to your point, we should probably separately talk about the pros and cons of an AI world.

What an AI world might look like as real-of as a world of abundance and others, don't have a world of massy-man employment and no one knows. Real guessing. Yeah, that's why you'd be like, I can't understand. I can be sure it's only point. Yes, that's true.

I can be a London employee. I'm at a point. A lot of the time again, a job is a means to an end. Now, it's different if you've got an incredibly rewarding, fulfilling job that you would do anyway, and you're an incredibly fortunate person if that's your situation, but for most of us it's not. So it's sort of like, I do reject that idea that everyone needs a job and we should all be working.

I think there's a great merit in having a craft and having a purpose and putting a shoulder against the wheel. I've got to always say, I have to flesh these kind of statements out because they can be taken in very wrong way. But I would say that almost anyone with given the choice, if you were to sort of say, listen, here's a winning powerball ticket, you don't ever have to work again. I reckon 98% of people go, that's it. I'm done.

And then I might hold a bunch of hobbies and stuff, and I think you should, because you can't just sit around eating Doritos on the couch watching Netflix all day, even if it is in a golden mansion, you'll get pretty depressed pretty quickly. But anyway, nevertheless, that's the point. So as I said, I'm not four against anything, but I'll play devil's advocate because it probably makes for a more interesting conversation. And also because I need you to think something's all mixed up. I just don't know.

The first one you've actually already answered, because my first question was going to be, well, how do we pay for it all? And I think you make an interesting case in terms of the net idea of things. But one of the things, and this has always been my biggest stumbling block with it, is that the economy, not withstanding all the comments from before, is a reflexive organism. It's adaptive, it's self-referential. So it's sort of like, let's just play it through for a moment, and all of a sudden everyone gets a minimum here.

Now, there'll be plenty of people, if that minimum was enough to, let's say that you own your house, right? Because again, it's not means tested. It's only against the income that you own. So I own my house outright. It's like, I actually don't, my need to work is far less than someone who's paying off a mortgage or paying rent, right?

In fact, if you're paying rent in any of our capital cities, you'll be either not even going to cover that. Not even half of that, right? So that makes it, there's already going to be a little bit of a distortion in there. But even if we just say that you can sit back. Now, what does that mean? What does that mean? What does that mean? That means less stuff is being made and produced.

We know that supply and demand means if there's less supply out there, then prices will rise. And so it's sort of like what was deemed an adequate amount. Now, I know you've plucked. I'm just going to go with your 26 grand year. It's a nice round. Who knows what the actual number might be.

But let's just say that's what it is. It's like, well, when we envision this policy, it turned out that 500 bucks a week, would actually, if someone who wants their own home allows them to do this, this and that, and it provides a nice little cushion. And it's just like, yeah, but in a world where everyone's, or enough people, again, things are always determined on the margin here. If enough people sort of choose to just opt out, less stuff is being made, prices go up, all of a sudden that 500 bucks a week is, we kind of have an inflationary impact there. It's not quite inflation. It's a little bit different because it's more on the,

anyway, that's not going down that rabbit hole. But do you know what I'm getting here? And sort of like, oh, OK, we need to increase it. 750 bucks. Yeah, and that changes.

It moves that equilibrium point. And then the economy routes around it. We've got to remember. And I think, again, I bang the table on this all the time. These are complete arbitrary nominal values. We want to convert to pesos or yes, it's a different nominal value.

It doesn't matter. I mean, the only currency that matters here is time. How much work do I have to do? What do I get for that? And I just wonder, again, I genuinely don't know the answer.

But I wonder if even a yield point is a year, I try a long enough. Also, yeah. Maybe it's not, right? Because it takes time to put for these for a new equilibrium to be reached for these sort of effects to ripple through the economy. So what's your thoughts on that? Is there a risk that we just, we find that at the end of the day, we're continually ratcheting it up just to account for the fact that it's the more adequate the UBI is.

The less incentive there is to work, the less stuff there is, the more the prices will go up, the more the, you know, and so on and so forth. And we have this self-referential positive feedback loop. Yeah, for sure. Motley for money. For more, subscribe to the free newsletter at full.com.au forward slash listener.

You make a point about the unemployment, there's also international unemployment, this right? Because goods aren't just goods, I'm just making this right. So they're always going to be provided from elsewhere. And so I suspect you can pay for them from elsewhere, though, too. Yeah, you're right. I'm thinking in your example, the locally produced stuff for local services probably have more risk of that.

So half the nurses decide to take the UBI, send an issue, and then we've got issues, or half the Fijathir, or half the other sources. Which means you've got to pay more to attract them back into the workforce. I think my view, honestly, is as long as the UBI set a low minimum wage around the level of current welfare spending, I think it's unlikely. Because you can kind of do that now, right? There's usually a pocket full, but also real at some core.

A group of people who will say, I'll take the doll and leave it in a smokdoke all day, and I'll get the money and do my thing, right? Or those who say, well, minimum wage is bad because it rashed up and it does all these things that it's supposed to do. So I think it's a nice idea. Again, you may be pretty exactly, I don't think this is very bad. It may be pretty exactly right in time.

I don't suspect that there's a meaningful change in the workforce as a result. And I suspect, honestly, those who are leading work, will actually have less money than those who are currently working anyway. And so as long as the UBI is listening to minimum wage, there is no increment to demand and the reduction in supply of workers is probably going to be unlikely to be inflationary. Which prices are probably going to be what we want to use in that context I would suspect. Now, the might be something I'm saying, I'm working for minimum wage now is 50 years.

That's about to work. Just to let you pass this year. So, because I think of post-text, pre-pre-pre-pre-pre-pre. So at that level, you're paying 16% tax on things about 20 grand and 35 grand. So it's paying by context.

I only say that because the difference is you have to take less money to work less. And so I suspect there'd be probably some similarity, and not not exactly, but directionally between the reduction of supply and the reduction of demand because there's money out there. You know, those people are doing less work, less work, less money to do less work. So again, it's entirely positive. We are hypothesis, right?

And again, that's what you hope to be able to show. We look at changes in all of those things and working out from there. There's a really interesting sideline which is entirely uncovered here. But it's like a GDP which fall, right? So I think, for example, about a parent who could stay home and look after the kids with the UBI, for example, and what that might do to childcare.

And again, we don't count stay-at-home childcare, but we do count paid childcare because it's in GDP, which is again, assuming that GDP. So there are possibly those sexual changes as well. Where it happens, how it happens, I don't honestly know, but that's probably, I don't suspect it's directionally problematic, though it may end up being, and it might be on the margin of some circumstances. I would suspect. But I think if you have a payable minimum wage or more, then absolutely you're getting paid the same for doing nothing, and therefore, your demand doesn't change what your supplier work has changed.

That's absolutely true. I think you're right. As long as the UBI is set meaningfully below minimum wage, I think you're properly fine. But that's a speculation. Yeah.

But then you wonder if it's set below the minimum wage, is it enough to do what it says? To do as advertised? I mean, there were plenty of good arguments. Yeah. I mean, minimum wage is too low, or the other side of your minimum wage's concept is silly in both ways.

It's a very deep rabbit hole in this particular one. I think as long as we know what the pension and the dollar and those little care payments are at. So I suspect we know the answer. If we were going to introduce a social safety net from scratch and say, how much do we give people? You know, currently it's work or charity.

We're going to choose something. The new deal, if the other thing was, maybe there's a conversation like, well, how much was going to the workforce? I suspect we know because we have the rough structure. Again, we move it. That's a good thing.

I suspect. I think if I work, I'm out of here. I'm out of here. I'm a low-paid job anyway. I hate to hate it.

I agree. I can probably swipe by. I can get the minimum wage for 40 hours a week or the zero hours a week. Let me just think about that for like three, three, two seconds. I mean, you've already said minimum wage.

You can know it for me. So this kind of, you're going to have the right level. I think around the old, old-day pension is probably the right level because we kind of know that kind of worked. Right? And yes, working out people would suddenly be eligible for something similar.

But I think that's probably, by the way, I spoke about time. I'll ask that. Speaking of universal things, the key ways, give everyone the old-day pension wants to hit a certain age regardless of what they're working or not or their assets or what it's just essentially, yeah, which is just yourself. Right? So I think there are enough examples of, there are enough examples to justify my mind, giving it a go and not expecting absolute calamity.

I'm not arguing for not a go. No, no, no, no, no, no. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So I think there's enough out there, by the way, I think that's enough to mention the key ways with universal pension, I'll ask you what's universal universal.

I can't remember the call of things all the time in the description. That kind of idea. I think there's enough to not think that a trial would be catastrophic. And so again, maybe those things do anything you're not saying, you're not saying this but you'll have others to make play out or not. But again, I'm going to do it as a tryout.

And I think that's, you're not talking a previous part about the status quo effect. I think this is one of those things where you kind of go, what's in hand side? Yeah. And it sounds wasteful. Oh, why?

How much? I'm not wasting that. We waste that matter, of course. That's not an unusual thing. Would you pay that to trial something that might actually work?

I mean, we should. It's just a risk-versal reward is the game that you and I have been in for all the decades. We will talk about this. We will talk about this. I hope by the time people listen to this podcast, but just because we're calling out a sequence.

Daniel, we're calling this on the 9th of June, just a day. Daniel would the chair of the productivity commission. Oh, wait, instant. I'm like, yeah. I'll talk about that later.

You know, that's my health. I've been re-amiling about that. I was like, what? That's what I'm saying. Yeah.

Oh, she said it much more eloquently and better. Oh, she said it was always the heartless bathroom. It's the perfect vibe, right? Anyway, my point is, you know, taking resources off. No, no, it wasn't.

She was basically saying that we have a view that any problem can be fixed instantly by government without any negativity whatsoever. And that the actual, the incentives around that mean that no one's prepared to sort of tell it like it is, and that we sort of we go in with false expectations, false promises, destined to failure, afraid to try anything, all of that kind of stuff, which is this very easy, is a caring, heartfelt human. I was like, oh, I see someone suffering. Someone should do something, not me personally, but we should do something. Like, that's how the thinking goes, right?

And she just made, I thought it was an excellent point. I'll direct people towards your tweet into that report. We all probably talked about it hopefully, because we'll probably just record it, actually put it out in a couple of days rather than rather than when a month looks for the gonna be. So my point though is just the risk thing of like, you know, it sounds reckless, but I might cost that. I know what that's the worst case I know it is.

It's probably just as small as possible. The camera's cost. I can't cost that much more than that. Well, well, this was my other point. I think I saw 100% with you.

But I think if we're gonna do a trial, if we're gonna do an experiment, it's gonna be a proper experiment. Yes, 100%. And if we're gonna do this experiment, where the tasies are funded by the mainland, it's gonna be like, wait a second. Well, it won't be that right, because they also have been taxed accordingly. So the whole thing is gonna be done.

What you won't get is the- It needs to be an isolated- Correct, correct. You know, there can be nothing going in around about particular. Here's the test tubes. Let's see what happens. As soon as we start interfering from the outside, it kind of like, because in the real world, if we just all did it, it's like the Martians aren't gonna come to top up the fund and it's like when it gets a bit short.

I think that's right. Although, definitely now, who pays the bill in the case of the trial, because as long as you mention, he puts apples correctly. You know what I mean? He doesn't know who funds the experiment as long as the experiment is done in a pastry machine as you're up on that. Well, but it needs to be, at least in theory, fundable from those inside the test tube.

Because otherwise, it's gonna collapse under its own weight. Well, that's what the trial would tell you. So even if it was a total country, we might have more debt because we spent money. We thought it would cost them. We have to reverse the whole thing.

So my point is just that there is, it wouldn't be so funding in the trial, it couldn't be because you wouldn't sack the entire Department of Aging and Department of Employment because you couldn't do it in the national way, right? It wouldn't work. So what you have to do is you'd say, let's look at the economic outputs. So you look at, and this is very point, actually, you look at, you would look at GDP as part of it. You look at unemployment levels, you would look at health outcomes.

There was a heap of literature saying that when the job seeker payments were topped up during COVID, a whole lot of people have like health, you could say about fruit and vegetables and that sort of stuff. It is real bad about that. So you have a full scorecard. Like how, what did we do and how did it go? You would have to approximate the savings for admin because you wouldn't, if you go to a trial for your own, if it has, you're not going to lay off the entire set, the time, come up with employment service, right?

It's not because you can't rebuild that to be obvious. So you'd have to basically say, the Tasmanian component of this usually costs us this. That is the theoretical savings you can do. As we say, well, we have to provide the services to those people who have to take the people away. So we're going to double pay the Tasmanian component of those national bodies and state bodies to keep them alive, off the trials and work.

You simply can go back to normal. So we need incremental costs during the trial, but you could absolutely quarantine that and say these are the people that would not have a job in if it works, this is the same we would make ongoing and you can still experiment with what happens in the actual economy itself. And also for the funding, it's like, so whatever rate was decided for the trial, that would need to be funded from the Tasmanian economy. Correct. South Australian economy or New South Wales.

Whatever the boundaries were, because if the math don't math, it's inevitably going to fail. So even if we normalize for the jobs side of things, as you were just saying, it's like, yeah, but it costs us more money than what the Tasmanian economy produces, that's not going to work either. So I'll lead in with another concern or question. So there's that, okay, if it's going to be an experiment, let's do a proper experiment. There's a lot of pseudoscience out there that proves all kinds of nonsense because it's not done in a proper rigorous kind of way.

Yeah, I do wonder about the slippery slope of exceptions. In other words, because this isn't me going, this is a possibility, this is how it goes. And how it goes is this. Here's the problem, here's the solution. Yay, oh, okay, there's a little problem with that.

So let's make this little change here. Okay, right, cool. You actually already touched on it. Okay, everyone gets a UBI, it gets rid of the welfare state, we do this super efficient, much better off. Okay, brilliant.

Oh, what about people in exceptional circumstances? Oh, that's a good point. Yeah, okay, great, great. Oh, what about our return service people? Like they're giving, oh, yeah, actually they did need a little bit more.

Absolutely, that's true too. And so on. And so there's elections every so many years, right? And there's going to be a following. Well, hey, vote for me.

And I'm going to look after special interest group X. And it is that death of a thousand cuts kind of issue. So it's not that this is an argument against it or for it, but it would almost have to, it would defeat the purpose of it. If we're going to do a, I mean, it takes the U away, right? Like if it's universal, but there's all these non-universal satellite programs around it.

And as those grow and evolve over time, I can see us starting off in a very pristine, mm, these words aren't great. Pure, mm, these words aren't great. Yeah, okay. Clean up, clean this middle word. A cleaner kind of set up, right?

And then two generations later, there's 4,000 different carve outs. And it's kind of like, actually it turns out that UBI is just one of many, many different welfare programs. And it's like, what's the point of doing it, if we're going to do it? How do we avoid that problem? Because it feels like it's a very easy direction to step into.

So I'm going to say, I'm going to make you very unhappy. I think we try. Because slippery slope is right, but that would apply from the New Deal forward. Why have welfare and office? I'm going to want to second welfare.

Why have health? Because we have health people want to get covered for this. Why have education, we have education, we have to be covered for that. Everything must be a different slippery slope. And I don't think the possibility of the slippery slope should preclude us from doing better than whatever we have now.

Again, you may be able to be better. Sorry, let me be really clear on the drill. I'm a drill at trial. I'm absolutely right, it's absolutely possible. Except that if we've got the working Australians tax offset, there was an ounce in the reason budget, right?

So what's stopped at nothing? So is it likely we have something on top of the UBI possibly? Do I think that we shouldn't do something that's better than we have now? At least adding from a better point. Next, next, next, next, next, next, next, and then we're going to put on the stuff.

Right? Then you're going to talk the current system. So you don't have to believe in a UBI in an absolute sense that and never anything else to think it might be better than what we have now. So again, my view is ideological, which is, I know you were kind of just, yes, people are getting rid of the welfare. So it's not really about how you, if we could do what we're doing now, but do better for all the reasons, then we should do that.

And certainly, the workers' tax offset will be proposed this year, whether it was UBI or not. Right? Because probably it's going to give more stuff to us. That's my worry though. That's just, I mean, I know it's gone.

I mean, we've got to know structurally in deficit, debt is ballooning more and more government handouts, particularly middle-class welfare. You know, there's a directionality to it, which is it's not, it's even beyond, it's just observation and empiricism. It's just like, yep, that's the way it's gone. If you look at it, try to remove any sort of emotional or judgmental value around it. It's just like, yeah, that's just the way it goes.

My point is, you're right, I mean, maybe it is still better, but it comes back to this, it comes back to, here's our raison d'etre, our rationality, our whole underpinning argument for a UBI, or at least a very significant part of it, is that makes it so much more efficient and better. And it's like, then now, not then ever could possibly be in future. I think we're starting from here, all the way they do next. So I honestly, I think it's a little bit of a, not a rate of time, because that's just intent, but I think it matters. I don't think, if they're not for something like in any way, let's go to the next election with the best possible starting point.

And then sorry, because they're not going to not do it. So it's not really as it. That's the feature. That's kind of like, we're screwed either way, because no matter what happens, we're just going to be throwing more and more money at dumping. And we're going to get poorer and poorer and less prosperous as a nation.

We don't solve that with any kind of policy. You solve that with electorate who holds politicians to account. That's what you do now. Yeah. But it's not solving anything if you're telling me you're going to work for a little bit, and then we're just going to like a thousand kind of way to a different type of, you know.

We're going to do that anyway, right? So the question is, do you start from one or do you start from two? We're going to add two to it. Kind of a relevant one term, right? Like we'll still end to zero.

I mean, yeah, but again, to me, it's the outcome that's the way we get to. I don't think if we agree that they're not going to do anything differently, I mean, that's the argument for anarchy. Well, I guess we're going to be about to spend government because it's all rubbish. And I'm being literally facetious. But there's no change we made because our future government might do things differently.

I mean, if that's the standard, I think it's a, I don't think it's relevant to the change we're looking to make. Otherwise, otherwise, watch change capital gains and they're going to be gearing. Why change, tax thresholds, why change, don't index tax rates, because they're just going to do it anyway, don't index, because any way, every change would be objectionable because there might be some future thing happening. I just don't think you can make no policy at all where you accept that the future's not nullable. Let's get things as right as we can now, because we can.

And then let the future do what the future does, including our conversation, which I mean, your minutes, that right now. I just don't think whether we go to the next election with the current system or UBI, they can offer us the next thing. So which is the best system to do now to get to the next election. So we're in the best starting point. I would start with, I get trial, not particularly.

I would start with trial and that because it may be more efficient, then we got more efficient system. They got to pull out stuff too. That's a win. You're going to get more people in work, but we'll be able to change what we've got. That's all, though.

Because if you pass forward a couple decades down the track, it's like, yeah, better starting position. It would have been worse. We've paid. We've not done it. And that's probably the argument there.

And then, OK, all right, let's do that because we're off. And otherwise, it would have been. But we're on the same trajectory. And now we've just got one extra welfare payment that we didn't have before on top of the 50,000 others that we do have, in which case it's like, and we are starting here from a point of theory, right? So the theory needs to be like, though humans are messy societies, at least in theory, we need to be clean about it.

Because it will undo itself if we're not. I'm not even disagreeing with you. I guess what I'm saying is it's just like, I'm far less enthusiastic about it. If the inevitability is, yeah, it's just going to be bastardized. It's going to be very poorly executed.

It's just going to be tinkered with until it becomes useless. It's kind of like, well, that doesn't excite me. Whereas, at least, even if it's in a fantasy land, it's like, well, let me lay out the theory for you. And this is why it's so much better. And it's kind of like, if that's where we are, we need to have that theory to be very self-well self-contained.

Be able to stand on its own feet with its own merit. Because as soon as there's a butt, it's going to be like, it starts to look very much like we've got now. And this is more a question on any kind of philosophy or approach, whether it's just welfare in general, taxation in general, capital gains tax in general. It's not that the ideas at a high enough level aren't good, but it's just so much in the execution. It's so much in the execution.

And so it's kind of like you've got to have, I think, a firm view that the execution part while it will never be perfect, at least has a bloody good chance of being done well without it. If we're going to rest on a whole bunch of subjective judgment and what current conditions are like, we're setting in stone policies that may be entirely irrelevant, 15 years down the track. And that doesn't mean, again, that we don't try it, but it makes me less enthusiastic about the whole thing, because it just feels like it's a slight course correction for a very short amount of time before we just go back to a different flavor of what we've got now. And I'm not really that excited about that.

It's actually the opposite. I'm actually depressed about that. I actually hear your objection to the future changes, but I think that's not far out distant potential theoretical changes, like very near to medium term. But getting a thing to know why you're changing. The only question we should be asking is versus the kind of factual, right?

So let's go forward. Let's go five years. I don't know what you're going to need to. Let's go five years to a lecture. And at that point, Paulies will offer what they offer when they go off on a matter of what office do we currently have, because they're going to buy fights, right?

So short of spending democracy, which is a bold call. We could do it if you wanted to. You know what I could, but it's a bit of a gun. It's good if I went to what I suppose. I don't think that would happen, but let's say they did.

Take good time, man. I'm every day. They could sort of change on that basis. Yeah. But what you're really saying is I don't want to make the change because democracy might be democracy in which case.

And I don't really know how. Like no policy will ever get passed. There's no point in having parliament because they got to screw up at some point, the future. Let's not even try it. I think I think I know what climate is the same outcome, because it's like...

Let me reframe it then. I don't know what you're saying. If there was, let's say we did a trial, and it was just spectacularly good. Let's take the optimistic view here. It was just great.

It was cheaper. It was better. People were happier. We covered for everything. You would then sort of...

It's sort of the very success of the programme wouldn't prevent but would seriously mitigate the potential for tinkering because they wouldn't be the need for tinkering. Someone goes, I'm going to do this. I'm actually really comfortable and everything's really good. And I guess I can take it. It's not that it's a prevention of that kind of stuff.

But politicians win votes when people... ..when they're as they perceive pain that they tap into. And it's kind of... You know, it's sort of like... The very fact that they could win votes and power on a platform of I will give you more kind of says, well, so it turns out the UBI wasn't that great.

Because if it was that great, people wouldn't be saying, actually, I need more. Right? It's kind of like, so we did the thing and you're all still unhappy and miserable. And there's these reasonable arguments that are out there to say that we need different things. It's kind of like...

I'm being a little bit pedantic, but at the same time, it's kind of like that is fine if that's what it happens to be. But then I would say, well, then the experiment was... Failure might be too strong a word, but it's just like... A failure in terms of the potential. Because it just wouldn't be...

I don't need to change anything when things are great. Oh, they're not great. Okay, that's what didn't work. There's a self-referential component to it that it only gets synced with if enough people think that it needs to be synced with. If it's great, it doesn't need to be synced with as much.

That doesn't mean people won't. I'm struggling to sort of articulate it, but do you get where I'm coming from? I do, I still think it's... I think it's an unfair burden for a new system that the country doesn't hold because this has got to fit. So the current system is working as a ticket with it in future.

So we're going to blow it up. No, because what we've got, okay, is the best thing we can do. I don't think it resolves us off the responsibility to any policy everybody, don't you, VBI. We shouldn't do this because it might change in future. It's kind of like, if that's the standard, nothing ever gets done because it's not...

I guess I'll frame it slightly differently. When you put it like that, I 100% agree. I can't argue against that. But I would just like if there is a need to tinker with it in the future, then it was... Right, right.

That's the issue. I guess although very in mind, to your point, we're both primarily going to have to know, they're not going to ask for something or to offer something because they can't or be elected to be more stuff. We'd start talking about Hinduism and wanting more, right? So do unions ever say, oh, thank God, I don't want any more money than the next time. I can be fair work commission, minimum wage here.

It's okay, just leave it, it's fine. They're always going to complain, right? So I think need is right if it's either your objective need as opposed to, would be all likes and more. Yes, if the office of law would be vote for them, history says yes. So we're always going to confront that.

In whatever form it exists. P I don't think in future I'll probably not offer something because I want to buy our votes. You'd never make a single love for huge change. Is this a less tenable proposition to take to the electorate? If you've got a suspended disability because this requires a competent position.

Yes, yes, yes. Suspending that massive disbelief in there is a competent opposition. The retort would be, listen things are far, every since we introduced the system, things are far better. My opponent is offering you this, okay, that's fine, I get that. But let me just be the wet blanket here and point out to you that for them to deliver the thing that they're promising on is going to be more tax or money taken from elsewhere.

And that's fine, but this isn't just a positive with no negatives, right? Now, now. I'm already chugging in my own words. I know, I know, I know. What if the whole room was great?

I'm like, I'm a catch. I remember like, well, we're all dying. If that's Mars, we'll be on the spaceship. Yeah, look, you're right, you're right, that you could get screwed with. I think this is where my, so to take a bit, my view is not ideological here.

It's not, I'm not doing it because we only have one payment or because there's some sort of, you know, there's a lot of love out there for, you've talked a lot about the two lines, right? Simple but wrong and difficult, but right, kind of, you know, no one lines up for the second one. And I think there's a lot of love out there, we can make taxes up, it was like, oh, it should be efficient and should be clean. And my point is, be like, I'm not in sight, right? So I see if the outcomes are better.

So there are people who just want it to be perfect and beautiful because I just feel good about it like we just have this. And humans, I don't know, I've never looked enough. Humans have this real love for kind of like, what if we just have a single thing and it'd be beautiful and easy? It'd be fine. It'd be perfect.

I mean, I'd be up for that too, it was all those things. Do I want people to put to bus or your carton, your share regularly? If there was efficient and bad or slightly less efficient and better, you take the second one because the outcome that matters not the inputs. So I totally take your entire point. I really, really do.

I just, from my perspective, I don't think we need to, it doesn't, no policy needs to be the final word because there was no final word because democracy remains. There's no guarantee ever about any policy that will ever be changed by a future coming. No capital gains, thanks. No capital gains than key things than how it's been announced. By now it could have been part of the law or changed.

We're recording the future, we're recording the past. So all that, I just think you never change anything if the question was, why they changed the future? I think I'm going to ask to say, what is the best way to provide a particular outcome based on what we know? What's great about you and what's going to happen for office, right? So we think this is better and people vote for what they want and politicians have to say, I hear you, but no one's going to vote for it.

We get to be unpopular because who they'll care to do, like some of the podcast microphone. I don't disagree with you in terms of, should they change it? I want that you need to take it with you, like just fix it and let it alone. But I don't think the fact they might change in any policy area is enough to say we should not do anything just in case it changes in future. I think that's a too high a bargain.

We have a status quo. We say, you've won't, that might be a different question. It's just an totally fair point. It makes the whole debate a little moot because it's kind of like, that exact thing that you said, I can also say, well, yeah, well, what's the point because it will change? You're saying, we shouldn't not do it because it will change.

You can also say, yeah, but why do it if it's going to change? It's sort of like, no one's going to have to say every policy is here on. But that's the same thing, right? It's just sort of like, these laws that we're currently discussing with tax, are they going to be set in snow for a while? No, but I mean, the very premise is that kind of we sort of naively at least expect them to be sort of the new normal going forward.

If not, I'm going to the electorate saying, hey, I want to do this thing just for a little while, and then someone's going to change it in the future. Like, what? I'm not getting behind that. I don't know what I'm trying to say. It feels like it's defeatist to kind of in both directions, in both directions.

So we've got to give a point of point of view. Two people, naively, gazing on a podcast, they're talking about the potential elegance of a theory. It's sort of like, I just feel that that consideration needs to be folded in because if all those things that you say kind of just, to me, if anything, I'm less enthusiastic for a trial knowing that it will without doubt, 100% change in the ticket and probably in a poor direction. Because I feel as though I'm very much on the with all things. I try to look as long term as it's practically possible.

And if it's like, my concern is that we always say, the road to hell is paved with good intentions. Someone recognises a horrible wealth distribution in society, a problem with falling employment because of big, big structural changes to the economy. We do a thing in an attempt to fix it, but really all we do is we fast forward ten years, and we've just got a far more bloated and heavily bureaucratic kind of wealth-fest thing, which kind of was the thing we were trying to solve for in the first place. It's not that we don't try, but it feels, to me, it's kind of like, unless there's at least some expectation, at least we can't even suspend the disbelief on that. It's kind of like, then why? Then why?

I mean, we might as well just stick with a more bespoke specific targeted system because that's where we're going to go anyway. Then the argument is, well, I forget UBI. We'll just continue doing what we're just doing better. You know, because it's going to be like, no, but UBI, the whole point of UBI is that it does all the... Yeah, but if we know at the outset that it's not going to end up that way, it's not going to persist in that way, then we are going to tick.

Like, this is tick tick tick tick, right? Maybe we just get a better run for five years. I don't know. I think the difference I'm as you're talking in a relatively absolute sense. I'm talking in a relatively sense.

The letters E are in the end of all the words is where I think we go. Is it clean? No. Is it clean? Yes.

Is it totally elegant? No. Is it more elegant? Yes. Is it more efficient? No. Is it more efficient? Yes.

I think there's still an argument to be made. Again, I mean, it's not an argument for a trial. But in this context, there will be a change in future. I think you and I can give up politics and economics from this point forward. If I rule it down, don't change anything because I'll change it later.

There's like, well, none of our comments or anything. Give us intro banks. We'll report on that later. It's more like the Communist argument. It's great if we can only administer it.

Well, yeah, but we can't. Yeah, but we can't. Yeah, but we can't. That's more my argument. It's kind of like, I don't think your eye or any sane thinking person would sort of argue that communism is good because we just have the evidence of history.

By the way, I think it sounds great. I'm all on board in terms of the concept. And maybe there is a way that we could somehow administer it by highly doubt. But you and I don't entertain that nonsense. And so there is, I don't know.

We're kind of circling the same point, I think. It's just that there's a question of degrees here. And I only raise it because I wonder if it is something that is sort of like, oh, it is objectively better and will be better than what otherwise would be the case in that could be sustained. Or if it is something that is absolutely just an ideological boom-dobble that sort of has a little bit of an impact and then it leads us to a worse position. They're two different outcomes.

And I need to at least have a strong reason to believe that it's not going to be the more negative version of those two scenarios because otherwise we are just doing something about how great communism would be if only people would administer it properly. Yeah. So I will throw it for just a second. I'll throw it the other hand on for a second. If you're kind of arguing, why would you not trial it?

If you're asking me that question, have you asked myself? Then I think something about question of right reasons to think about. I think that's absolutely valid. I think the reason is not to trial it kind of come down to whether you can run the experiment properly, which is kind of the point you were literally to before in the words, is it actually, can we get outcomes that are at least, and by the way, let's be honest with each other and anywhere else. There's no perfect experiment in humanity because all else is never equal.

But can we do a sufficient, especially high quality experiment to be confident in the outcome that we have to be pretty clear on that. There are issues with people moving towards from. It doesn't mean you do get it if you leave, it doesn't mean you lose it. Can you imagine starting to sell the experiment? It's like, hey, everyone who's on this current existing form of welfare, you're going to get there anymore.

What? Yeah. It's almost impossible to do. I mean, we can't even talk about GSD or capital gains. They're like the world, like, oh, we're going to completely rearchitect the welfare system for the ground.

No chance. So the kind of movement inside the thing is probably relevant. The risk of trialling with a small population is you haven't got the breadth and diversity of an economy. If there were to be sectoral changes, is the economy representative and have a large enough to absorb those? Probably, by the way, not today.

Can you run a trial of sufficient sahis to actually know? I think about Tasmania. I don't know. It means I know you have a complex economy that's not super complex. It's much less complex than other states, because there's more stuff to do when guns close down.

Right? Of course, meaning for job loss and really hit the Tasmania economy across the board. So you've got to be a little bit careful with sectoral issues. So that's one reason not to trial at all or in a small community. So you've got to think about how you might make that one work.

You've got, I think it's a huge reason not to trial it, but you do have changes in behaviour, you've got to be a real complex reflexive thing. Do people leave work and not go back? What happens when the trial finishes? If it's not continued, how much dislocations or disruptions are caused? I take stuff away.

Right? But if you're doing it because you want to make things better, it makes things worse. It might be easier to take away, but if they're smoking real and behind you. So both of those things are true. It works.

People don't get it because you don't extend the trial because it's great. If it doesn't work, it's probably because if you say, we paid too much money or we've created too much, then you're expected. And if I'm going from 5% to 40% to 20%, then I'm off to the pub. And I'll drink and live under the bridge. I didn't expect that.

And then you're taken away and they're not going to get back to whatever they were doing. So the dislocation of the end of a trial would be another reason not to do it. So again, I'm still doing it regardless. I thought it was worth pointing those out. They're some of the reasons why you might say, get it, but either do it or don't do it, either.

The trial itself, not the UBI. Because again, there's no, the trials doesn't succeed. You don't do it so it's easy. You don't have to do it so it's not what you do UBI. But the trial would rely on some of those issues in my mind.

Yep. I mean, with anything, the thing is, I know you're speaking at the aggregate level, but there is, regardless of how it goes, let's say it's a total failure at an aggregate level. There'll be people within it that goes, no, not for me. It wasn't. That's brilliant.

It was an incredible success. But you'll be able to find a pretty significant cohort. It's not for me. It wasn't. That is always the challenge of all of these things.

You don't want to say that is the political problem, right? Yes. Exactly. Someone's going to be happy about it, and that's having a trial or having it taken away or both. And it's all that stuff.

And again, the one, it's like a lot of negative gearing, capital gains, tax change, the other papers. The one on Twitter is going to move to Europe because it's like, maybe it's representing, no, I'm not expecting you other than this. It says they're leaving the country for good because of your laws. So one person leaving, they might be leaving, they might be making up, might be ideological. They might be wrong, but that's the headline.

So if you're a fan of every cafe owner, no one wants to work in my business because they'll be EBI and no one will pull the coffees. By the way, back to your point about the challenge of politics and what changes in future. That's where we're back to the same challenge of finding a reasonable politician, reasonable conviction politician who can then talk and tell them, say, this is what we're trying for these reasons. So we're going to go for everybody but we're trying to get the country better, come with me. If it doesn't work, we'll stop it.

Is it what we're trying? Yes, it is. We're going about taking risks. This is exactly where we are right. We can find reasons not to do stuff so we don't.

And that's, again, I'm sure I'm just saying that if we start with the mentality of what something goes wrong, we're going to start with what something goes right, which is kind of back to taxes. I'm not saying people say to me, I want you to invest with the camera guys. I'm not the profit you make when you... Yeah, but you're not going to do it to the upside. That's literally the point.

I'm going to go to tax rates, but just that idea of people who are going to go on. So look at the risks. Yeah, looking at the returns, well, no, no, just the risk. Okay. I think it's probably slightly one side.

But that is the challenge of UBI. The other option we've got is obviously learning from others. They have been other trials and around the world, there's always reasons to do it, not do it. This is why I want to do a trial is because the ideology that comes to it from the left and the right pro-encon. Again, it's a weirdest policy I ever wear.

You've got those on the left and right both. I mean, that's the right way of hating it, which is just... You would hope, actually better, better, but kind of thing. You can find no, you know, there's not enough true to live anywhere to do it. Then no one's going to want to give it a go.

That's why I should be a trial. In any sort of reasonable world it would be, let's give this thing a go and see what happens rather than probably work with the next one or probably work with the other charges. It's like, no, there's making any sense to that. Again, not saying the reason I said you might not do a trial or reason to be mindful of or aware of before doing a trial. Just I don't get why we wouldn't.

It seems like a really... To fit this attitude, maybe. I'll be on both sides. Left and right. I'll be like, oh, no, don't be cool.

Give it a go. Are you worried about the outcome being bad or you worry about your ideology being threatened? Because if it's a ladder, can I tell you? I've got no time for you. I'll be like, you know, I'll be like, here as the outcomes here.

You might learn something. You might learn something. Wouldn't you actually like to know better? No, I'd like to be wrong. But wrong, you know what I'm wrong.

Then, aware and wrong. It's just one of those people, that's just people. That's my take on anyway. I mean, it's such a fascinating policy discussion because very rarely do you get something that you can find people at the opposite ends of the political spectrum who can advocate for it. Yeah, right.

So the left, the progressivists, they would love it because it's a massive tool for wealth redistribution, social equality. You know, that's like absolutely what they like. And then you go all the way to the other end and the libertarian. Not on free when argued for a form of it as well. Is that right?

Yeah. It's just, it just mantels a welfare state. And importantly, because he's a big free market advocate and he basically said, well, people will spend, we will give them the means to spend on what they want, but they make the decision. Adam Smith's invisible hand. Coordinate, direct and do all that really, really good stuff.

So it's very rare that you get a policy that is like, and you would think, you would think, that that is what would make it such a popular thing to trial because you can sell it to everyone across the political department. Where it gets into trouble though. This is where, when reality hits though, because when Friedman talks about it though, it's like, it's no point doing it unless we dismantle everything else. The point is to get rid of everything, almost, I'll say, almost everything else. And the other side would be, well, no, it's on top of everything.

And then once more we have it divide again. We're back in that territory. I don't know. This is why, forever you and I have been threatening to talk about this. And I was just like, I've many a long, hot shower pondering things.

We're on a boat. Except for the record, just separately. Can we tell at least an hour, 30 minutes on the pond? Such fascinating thing, pasta shing boots. Let's just leave that where it is.

But do you know what I'm getting at that? It's sort of, I can't, because I am like a lot of things. There's a part of me that, like Friedman, on his view of it, I say, yeah, that's a great idea. And then, oh, yeah, what about that? And what about this?

So I'm going to end this conversation as we start to wind it up. It's just on that, I don't know. I started at the same time, I don't know. I think I probably land where you are, which is, I guess, I guess we try it. And the only thing I would add to that, I've already said it, but just to emphasis, I would just say, yes, I agree, let's try it.

But we want to make sure that we structure this in a very, very careful, intelligent way. I don't think a year is nearly long enough. A year is such a blink of the eye, right? Especially in terms of big lifestyle decisions, in terms of getting used to things, right? I was thinking the other day, someone was talking, because everyone on the podcast, no, we bought a house a couple of years ago after a decade of renting.

And it's only about two and a half years almost now, and I'm still finding it hard to get out of certain mindsets. And definitely not trying to change the topic of conversation to that, or make it about me. But my point is that it takes time to get used to a thing. I would say it too, in terms of these tax changes, capital gains. Well, what do we have housing prices at, and auction results the weekend after the budget?

I'll see, there's way too little time to have passed to base other merits of this kind of thing. So, I think we try it as properly and as thoroughly and as cleanly and as long as we can. I think the challenges of that are legion, like they're just massive, convincing. We've got to pick on the poor tazis, but by the way, I was very close to moving tazimally just quietly. I love it down the air.

It wasn't for family and friends, I think I would have done it. I love it. I think we are asking a lot for our southern brethren, because it was like, you're like, my god, what if it doesn't? What am I? What?

Am I not either? That's the right chance. I don't want to restart a conversation, but I will just acknowledge some degree of parallel with the sovereign wealth fund idea. I don't know if this says it, I don't know if this is a kind of bedrock or not, but the kind of what we do with the common wealth, literally the common wealth of the country in theory, each Australian is entitled to one 28 minutes of every ounce of gold or a ton of iron or whatever, a ton of gold. It's not gold.

How we collect that and share that? I think it's a really, really interesting question because that Alaska decided to want to get a per person. I don't know if that's your right. We sold this much oil, you all get this money. There's also something about that that kind of talks to the way we think about how we do these stuff up.

I think that's a whole other conversation, but I just want to raise it because there is some parallels there. I don't think it directly impacts my view. You know I'm messing with myself, I don't think it affects my view. I think one is determined by the other, but I will admit to some sort of, not me, it's not horrible. It's likely that my brain processes the values, the approaches, the ideas I bring to it are similar to origin.

There's just some potential, it's an interesting conversation. I think the Alaska one is fascinating, not because it's not a UBI in the sense that everyone gets a certain amount of money for it, any other reason other than if the share of the resources and everyone shares in those resources, how we share the resources and what that looks like. It could be as Alaska does a royalty distribution effectively, right? We do it that way. Just Australia, I think that's what we can say goes on revenue and you're back to Freeman, right?

They use the page and we get an amount of money. You just say, how you do it? In Australia we say that money goes to the tax coffers and then the government divis it up based on need, hopefully, and spiritually, efficiently. But there's one of those where there are some parallels and similarities and parables and feedback loops, am I thinking on that? One closing thought as well I'll have is I'm not convinced that AI and robotics, even if developed in a fairly optimistic way, actually negates the need for work.

I think, well, let me flesh this out. I'll start by saying I'm not sure about this. It's another shower idea. But I, they are tools and I might have three really, let's say I've got perfect humanoid robots that can do anything that an able-bodied person can do in the prime of their life, and that they're as smart as the average person or smart than the average person. It's kind of Star Wars touch on this actually.

It's the problem of agency. It's the problem of, unless they can decide what they want to do and do it, you still need a human to direct that capital. Whether it be, I'm going to say it's a new form of capital, it's like artificial intelligence capital. But you've got ten robots and a data center worth of compute. I've got ten robots and a data center for compute.

We assume that that means that we're equal. I don't think that's true. I wonder that you might be able to marshal your resources. You know, where it's like, you know what, robots go and do this thing. And I go, no, do this thing.

And it's like, I waste a bunch of capital and you actually create immense wealth for everyone around you. I don't know if that, I suspect that that's where we're at now, right? It just turns out that, you know, where as 10,000 years ago I was digging with a shovel and now I'm using a backhoe. It's like, I'm still doing the thing. What's the thing that I can do?

I suspect in a world, sort of, Elon sort of goes in this direction. It's just like, yeah, there is incredible abundance and there's less of a requirement for, there's far less of a worry to satisfy the lower realms of Maslow's hierarchy of needs. But in terms of still doing stuff that will provide value, and some people being able to do that better than others, and capital seeking out the best forms of return, and that being determined by what other people, whether they consume or don't consume your output, I'm getting very big picture here. And again, I don't know. I just don't know.

I don't know it's just this world where the robots just do everything and they can somehow divine what we want, what we need, how we value it. Whether things will work out on a particular idea or concept or product design or initiative, I don't think so. I didn't even do it far faster, far more efficiently without having to get off our big back sides. But those core problems are still there. It might well be that, sorry about that, my dog would be.

He's not happy with this. We're not going to replace you, we're not going to replace you. Although I'm like a robot dog, I don't have to pick up after that would be nice. That would be nice. That's right.

That's right. Does that make sense? Does this join a dramble make any sense? No, it does. I don't know.

There's a range of outcomes. History would say that we've always managed to find a way to solve it and solve for it. Whether that remains the case in the future, I guess that's the big question. But that's the question we'll have to answer. Maybe another podcast.

Maybe that's the point for another day is the AI revolution, the possible outcomes. Am I coming back to that one? I mean, it's just like talking about the start with the job of the podcast, right? Who would do against that? And again, it's a job of a robot coordinator in the future.

I know it's a silly example. No, it's a podcast. It's a good one. I'm not sure if it's a good question. I'm not sure if it's a good question.

I'll make that decision, including those who have been listening to us. I'm going to give you a couple of a bit and then say thank you very much for listening. We'll be back on Sunday, which I'm at. Of course. Until then, stop me.

Full on. Cheers.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Motley Fool Money?

This episode is 1 hour and 22 minutes long.

When was this Motley Fool Money episode published?

This episode was published on July 17, 2026.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Motley Fool Money episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.