Skip to content
Sidewalk To The Kerb: We Need A Quantum Internet episode artwork

Jun 20, 2021 26 min

Sidewalk To The Kerb: We Need A Quantum Internet

from MSP [] MATTSPLAINED [] MSPx Hosted by KULTURPOP

The Quantum Internet. No, don’t go away. The launch of mesh networks like Amazon’s Sidewalk are highlighting a need for ever greater levels of encryption and security in our communications. The Quantum Internet may hold the key. Hosts: Matt Armitage & Richard Bradbury Produced: Richard Bradbury for BFM89.9 Follow us: www.kulturpop.com https://www.instagram.com/kulturpop/ https://twitter.com/kulturmatt

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Sidewalk To The Kerb: We Need A Quantum Internet

0:00 26:37
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

This is a download from BFM 89.9, the Business Station. BFM 89.9, of the Business Station. My name is Rich Bradbury, this is Matt Splein. The quantum internet, two words that when combined spread a bafflement and confusion, wherever they go, most people struggle to understand how the internet works without adding an even more befuddling quantum dimension.

But advances in material science, as well as the growing threat of ransomware hacking and privacy intrusions, are making the reality of that quantum internet not just more likely, but more necessary as well. Are you ready to boldly go where multiple views are concurrently going? Hey Richard, actually two words that also spread bafflement and confusion are Matt and Armitage. True.

Yeah, I'm glad we're starting the show off like this today because we've talked about quantum computing kind of on and off over the years. And, you know, I've been, or at least I've tried to be, honest about how difficult it is to visualize and understand quantum computing. You know, it's very easy for me just to say that, well, you know, in order to understand quantum computing, it helps if you have a basic understanding of quantum mechanics and the concept of superposition. But, you know, of course, it's my job to try and explain those things.

And that's tough because, you know, I don't have a science degree, I stopped studying physics at the age of 16. So I can create a picture of the way quantum supercomputing works in my head, but that's not a huge amount of use on a radio show. So in other words, just imagine that the computer is doing things in dimensions that we can't see. Well, that's the answer that a lot of people sort of default to, and it is a really rubbish answer, you know, it's a terrible answer.

At the same time, these misunderstandings then lead reporters and commentators like me to make grand pronouncements about the potential of quantum computing that we're either assuming or we simply read somewhere else. And then we create these kind of self-perpetuating myths that just build on top of each other. So, of course, the reality of quantum computing is extremely complex. So we mentioned a handful of shows back how certain computer processors that can run on a standard office or home type computer system can outperform supercomputers for certain specific tasks.

And this is widening as well the potential of open world platforms with GPUs that can render these increasingly complex worlds because they essentially concentrate on the small fragment of the world that that user currently occupies. And how does that bring us back to quantum computing? Well, because of all the hyperbole surrounding quantum computing, the kinds of claims that are made about what it will be capable of doing. And like the principles that underpin quantum computing, our inability to grasp how it works will also take how we view its abilities.

And that's why I mentioned those GPUs because our default assumption is that a supercomputer will run calculations faster than a normal computer because we approach it from another default assumption, which is that all problems are the same. It's just the amount of power and time that it's going to take to solve them. The reality is that standard or classical computers are likely to outperform quantum computers for many tasks. So, you know, it's a bit like giving something simple to this really complex being.

It's like overthinking the problem. Right. How would we decide which problems would benefit from a quantum approach and which can be solved using those classical computers? Well, that's another problem.

There's no real and clear guide that can tell us that. So, of course, this is all a bit of a digression. Today is more about privacy in the quantum internet. But I wanted to bring this up because when we talk about this quantum internet, we will also have to take similar considerations into account.

So I would suggest, though, that anyone who's interested in diving a bit more deeply into what we've just been talking about, reads an article called What Makes Quantum Computing. So hard to explain. It's by a guy called Scott Aronson. It's over at Wired.com.

And he makes the point that tech writers and broadcasters should be saying, you know, there's all this really deep quantum stuff. Under the hood, but just try and understand the bottom line. So I imagine that was a bit of a relief for you. Well, not really, because it's not an excuse to say this is really complicated and it's too complicated for me to explain it to you, which I will probably do later.

It's to say, approach the claims with caution. And I do echo that. You know, maybe I've been guilty of it too. It's easy to get carried away, to build a picture or a world view around what you perceive that information to be.

But the more misconceptions or misperceptions you build into that picture, the more distorted that picture is likely to become. I know you very well, Matthew, and you're giving yourself a get out of jail free card for the picture of misconceptions you're about to build, right? Yeah, bang on on the money. We touched on this story a couple of weeks ago.

This is the mesh network that Amazon announced recently. It's called Sidewalk. The idea is that all your connected Amazon devices will create a low bandwidth cooperative mesh network with all the other Amazon devices, not just in your home, but in your, you know, environs that they can speak to. So the idea is I said, it's that your devices will always be seamlessly connected.

For example, if you have an echo speaker in your garage or cardboard and your Wi-Fi signal doesn't reach that area, but you can get a signal from your neighbor across the street because they've got a bunch of Amazon devices as well, then your speakers stay singly connected through that sidewalk network. So that's all well and good as long as you decide that you do want to make some of your Wi-Fi connection available to anyone who might be writing through the neighborhood and using Amazon device. The controversy came because Amazon kind of, you know, announced it in a hurry and decided to switch it on by default. Meaning that you've got an opt-out rather than opt-in?

Yeah, so unsurprisingly, there was a bit of an uproar. People with Android devices and increasingly with Apple devices, you know, they're getting more used to having to dive into those sub-menus, to look into those settings, to toggle things and tweak the devices, to get them to function exactly how they want. Android has always been a little bit more geeky in that respect, but we seem to find ourselves increasingly at loggerheads with the way technology companies want us to use their products. And of course, the way that we want to use them.

So I was discussing this with the founder of a design experience company this week. And we were talking about the fact that, you know, in terms of commercial business services, we're often pushed to buy a bundle of products or a suite of services that has no real relation to our actual needs. It's simply a more effective or profitable way for the company to sell their services. Yeah, but this isn't a quantum internet.

No, not in any way, but networks like this, mesh networks like Sidewalk may be the reason or part of the reason that we need a quantum internet in the future, or at least that we will need a quantum internet within the next decade or so. And a lot of it will depend on where you sit on this overall privacy debate. Of course, Amazon claims that the new network is secure, but because it's built around similar types of technologies that exist in Wi-Fi and Bluetooth networks built around, albeit on Amazon's own proprietary encryption services, some security experts are worried that it will create new points of vulnerability. For most people, though, the biggest rank of seems to be that they're expected to opt in by default, even though this wasn't a vision that they bought into when they purchased a speaker or a home security camera.

Does this read into the geeky settings aspect? Well, yeah, because Amazon's devices tend to be very, very simple, you know, by design. So many of them are voice activated, so that they're particularly easy for people who aren't tech savvy to use, which comes back to the importance of the opt-out clause. It doesn't serve users very well if they're the kind of people who struggle with managing their devices, you know, users who have the same kind of existential problems with figuring out what the Wi-Fi is that I do with understanding the quantum internet.

And then there's the added complication that some internet providers prohibit or limit the way an internet connection can be shared. So without knowing it, those users may be breaking the terms of their contract with an ISP. Without even understanding that sidewalk is on, let alone knowing what it is or what it does. So it's not a data issue.

This isn't going to consume a lot of data. It's more about tech companies imposing their vision on the people who are supposed to be their customers. Would you be concerned about this if it was simply an opt-in service? Not really.

I mean, in some ways, it's very practical and useful. Amazon's reputation as far as security is concerned is as good as any of the big tech companies. The fact that most of their devices are quite hands-off means that patches and updates are generally automatic, so bugs can be resolved as quickly as they're found. The idea that if there are any issues with your own home connection, so for example, something like your ring camera might stay online by riding on that portion of the network supported by neighbour, that's an additional security layer for you.

Not that, of course, many thieves are likely to sever your internet connection before they break into your house, but it does mean that you have a little more flexibility there. The issue of whether we should be looking at mesh networks that are proprietary in this way, that's another issue, of course. This idea of common standards, open protocols, or this seems to be eroding in the face of this battle for corporate supremacy between Apple, Amazon, Google, Facebook, Microsoft, Tencent, you know, you name it. Yeah, well done.

You've managed to get through the first half of the show without actually explaining anything about the Quantum Internet. Hey, this is important work that we've just done over the last few minutes. I don't want to say to people, you know, imagine an internet that's here and somewhere else at the same time, otherwise we'll just end up sounding like, I don't know, a chapter of Harry Potter that the publisher threw out. What do you say to that?

Nothing. That's probably the best answer. You're listening to Matt's explain here on BFM 89.9. Business, Finance, and more.

BFM 89.9. BFM 89.9, the Business Station. My name is Rich Bredbury. This is Matt Spleend.

We've talked about tempering our expectations for Quantum Machines' assistance. We've looked at some emerging privacy concerns. Are we ready to talk about the Quantum Internet itself? Why do we need a Quantum Internet?

Well, the first reason is quite basic and straightforward, and it's relatively easy to understand without having to understand how any of this works. Now, bearing in mind what I was saying about tempering expectations and that article by Scott Aronson at Wyft, a quantum computer also brings with them the promise of quantum encryption and the corresponding problem of quantum decryption. Now, as I said, we could be a decade away or even longer from machines that could compromise things like online banking or any other account that's secured by cryptography. It is the concern that we tend to wait for those problems to become a reality.

In a sense, we're also seeing this creeping authoritarianism in governments around the world, and as one article I read pointed out, there's nothing to stop internet traffic and communications being intercepted now and stored until such time as quantum computers can be used to decrypt them. Now, of course, you can look at that as scaremongering, and that's not what I'm trying to do here, but as we increasingly see money and financial transactions turning to the blockchain and cryptocurrencies and the rise of non-fungible tokens and similar technologies being used as a proof of origin, we have to work to future-proof those systems, not to mention our own well-being and our own privacy for things that might happen tomorrow. And how exactly do you think that quantum encryption would work? This is where we get to the bit where I'm not sure how accurate my descriptions are going to be.

I'm going to try. When we talk about the quantum internet, there are a number of different models that researchers are developing and tinkering with. So one method would be to use the existing, I guess if we're talking in terms of classical and quantum computing, then this would be the classical internet. One way is to take that classical internet and add a layer of quantum communications on top.

In classical computing, of course, the data packets, those pieces of information are bits, so these are buying, so they're either a one or a zero. In quantum computing, these are called qubits. And without getting lost in the detail, these qubits, these ones and zeros, can exist in more than one position simultaneously. So if we're trying to simplify it, the question is essentially about determining which of those positions these quantum data packets are in.

Yes, so that's one of the things that Scott Aronson is warning about when it comes to actually making quantum calculations. In a way, you're generating a lot of answers simultaneously and you don't actually know which answer it is that you need. He likens it to having dozens of scores or hundreds of outcomes and randomly choosing one of them as the correct answer. In the case of this layer of qubits, the sender and the recipient have a key that allows you to see that one particular thread within all of that noise.

I told you, I'm probably not describing this very well, but it's a bit like the apocryphal infinite monkeys on typewriters and you and a friend have the Shakespeare key. It's not so much that the signals can't be decrypted. It's just that you can see it. Someone has tried to decrypt those data flows.

Quite information. Yes, it's very fragile and we're getting into a Schrodinger's cap territory here, but the act of observing the information actually alters its state. So if it has been intercepted, both the sender and the recipient can see that it's been observed and they can act accordingly. One possibility, of course, using the same theory is that quantum networks could enable the creation of secure distributed quantum supercomputers.

So the various quantum computers can be linked to form a supercomputer to collectively harness and concentrate the power of each individual machine. And how close are we to having quantum networks? Well, there was a paper published earlier this year by a Dutch Research Institute called QTech. They've created a basic network of entanglement links consisting of three very small diamonds.

Other researchers are experimenting with lasers. There are examples in, I think, Japan, Canada and the US as well. But the greater problem comes when you try to extend that network. Traditional internet networks use amplifiers to boost the signals as they travel hundreds or even tens of thousands of kilometers along fiber optic cables.

That's not going to be possible with a quantum internet, at least not with the technology we have now. The cable absorbs quite a larger percentage of the photons that the quantum traffic consists of, so the longer the cable, the less data is going to reach the source. And currently, those networks have only been pushed in practical terms to a few hundred or maybe a couple of thousand kilometers. And it can't be amplified or boosted?

Well, not in the same way. As I mentioned before, the quantum traffic is very fragile. So the act of amplifying the signal only increases that quantum version of noise. What is possible is to locate nodes along the network that essentially decrypt and re-broadcast the traffic.

According to the new scientists, China has already built a 2000 kilometer long quantum network between Beijing and Shanghai. And that uses 32 nodes to maintain that flow of data. Now, forgive me, but if we're talking about this from a security perspective, don't those nodes present a security risk? Well, yeah, obviously every time the information is decrypted and re-encrypted, those nodes, there will be a risk.

A risk that the node is compromised or hijacked. What would make things easier is if we had a straightforward quantum repeater. And this involves a complicated process called entanglement swapping, which you really don't want me to go into. We are getting closer to having working usable repeaters.

Researchers at Stony Brook University, New York have created some of the starting blocks for a repeater. One that's actually showing a lot of promise in real-world applications. Their designs are small, they're portable, they operate at room temperature rather than sub-zero temperatures, and can function using the kind of wavelengths that are typically used in telecoms traffic. But we are talking about them being based around an atomic version of the cloud here, which for people who struggle with what the regular cloud actually is, rather than what it does, then that may be something we want to pretend doesn't quite exist.

All for pretending. Based on those limitations, I'm guessing that it would be almost impossible to send this kind of information along undersea cables. Yeah, even with those quantum repeaters, because the limit of each repeater would be limited compared to what you can achieve with classical internet data traffic. If it exists in more than one state and a location at once, and yes, I realize that's the bit of an oversimplication, couldn't we just teleport it?

Well, weird as it sounds, that is actually an option. So scientists at the Institute of Photonic Sciences in Castel de Fels, Spain, are trying to create this kind of network. Again, just a very basic description of the science behind this. You're not sending the actual physical information, which is one of the reasons that this is such a slippery and difficult topic to try and understand.

What you're doing is measuring entangled photons, and I'll leave the physics at that point, but essentially what you're doing is reading the information at the source by measuring those entangled photons at both the sender and the recipient's ends of the chain. And I'm sure a physicist is going to tweet us and tell me I'm completely wrong with this, but my understanding is that by reading those entangled pairs of photons, you're essentially instructing the photons at the receiving end to replicate the information from the sender. So not like Star Trek? You're not physically taking the original information apart and reassembling it at the other end.

You're kind of telling those photons to create a photocopy of it at the other end. And to do that, you need a quantum memory, which is what the team in Spain has been working to create. So we were talking about creating networks using diamonds earlier. So this team has created crystals from a substance called E3M or Facilicate to create this memory.

They've managed to link two labs around 50 metres apart using fiber optic cables, and they've been able to store pairs of entangled photons into separate memories, one in each lab for 25 microseconds. Again, they've designed the network so that they're not just theoretical. They should work in practical applications outside the lab. The next step obviously is to increase that range beyond 50 metres because that's not very useful.

And hey, presto, we have another option for a quantum repeater. Now, like any good science show, you mentioned lasers. Yeah, I kind of wondered if you picked up on that. I thought I might have managed to deflect you with the teleportation, but obviously not.

Yeah, earlier this year, researchers at the Nanjing University used lasers to send entangled photons between two drones hovering in the sky about a kilometre apart. Now, the team hopes that by increasing the altitude of the drones, they can achieve distances of around 300 kilometres. Obviously, it's not just making them go higher. I have to do a lot of other stuff too.

But reason for going higher is because it reduces the effects of pollution and weather, of course, on the efficiency of the laser. So you could then potentially create a much cheaper quantum network. Now, cheaper is, of course, a relative term. I'm talking about drones hovering thousands of metres in the sky 24 hours a day, but it would certainly be cheaper than a network based on satellite uplinks.

So satellite uplinks would form a component of this network, but using the drones would give you more flexibility to broadcast locally. Do we know how scalable that would be? That's a really big question with any of these quantum solutions, I think. So one of the suggestions of this drone based system is that they may be used more in an encryption type setting.

So they might have more of a military or political application. The drone could even be used to accompany specific individuals to protect their communications traffic. The likelihood is that we're going to need a lot more satellites, not the big ones that we didn't think about, but a lot more small satellites. And we've talked about that before in terms of creating a satellite based Wi-Fi networks as well.

All of this is just simply the infrastructure. We haven't even talked about the layers of software, that quantum internet stack that would allow developers to write applications that sit on and use this quantum internet. OK, then, we've got a wrap up. So I've got one final question.

What do you think we'd be able to do with the quantum internet that we can't do with the one that we've already got? Well, the simple answer is that nobody really knows. There are those aspects like encryption and security. Those are obvious, but it's a bit like going back to ARPANET in 1969 and immediately predicting TikTok.

We have no way of doing that. So without getting into more hyperbole and making massive claims, it will enable us to do things that we haven't even thought about being able to do yet. Some of those things will be practical and helpful. Others are just going to be fun.

What would quantum gaming look like? Would there be quantum entertainment shows that we could all start or participate in in real time? Could we potentially create avatars of ourselves to walk around and experience remote places? I know I could do with an avatar right now.

I don't know. The one thing I do know is that I really want to find out. Thanks for that, Matt. My pleasure, as always.

Now, of course, you can find Matt on Instagram and Twitter at CultureMatt. You can also head over to CulturePop.com for transcripts of these shows and information about CulturePop and its consulting services. If you miss any part of the show, go and download the BFM app. It's available at the Apple App Store or Google Play for BFM 89.9.

I'm Rich Redberry. Thank you for listening to this podcast. To find more great interviews, go to BFM.my or find us on iTunes, BFM 89.9. The Business Station.

The MSP Show The Digital Nomad Podcast Where can you turn to speak with the movers and shakers in the IT industry? The MSP Marketing Show is your source for up-to-date business info. MSP Unplugged Paco Lebron MSP Unplugged is the weekly podcast for growing MSP owners running shops under $1M with 10 or fewer techs. Each week, our hosts sit down with MSP owners, operators, and the vendors who serve them for real, unfiltered conversations about what's actually working: growing revenue and landing better clients, cybersecurity, AI and automation, sales and marketing, and leading a team without burning out. Watch on YouTube or listen wherever you get podcasts. Business of Tech: Daily MSP News & IT Services Analysis MSP Radio, Dave Sobel, Managed Service Provider (MSP) Industry Analyst Vendors are rewriting the rules on MSPs faster than anyone can track — pricing, partner programs, liability, and now AI. Business of Tech is the daily MSP news briefing that tells you what changed and what it means for your business.Every weekday, channel veteran Dave Sobel picks the MSP and IT services news that actually moves your margins, contracts, and risk, and answers the one question that matters: Why do we care? No vendor cheerleading and no press-release rewrites — independent analysis for managed service providers, IT services leaders, and the vendors who sell to them.Short daily episodes keep you current in about 15 minutes. Longer interviews go deep with MSP owners, investors, analysts, and channel executives on where the managed services market is heading.What this MSP podcast covers:• AI for MSPs — AI pricing and consumption billing, AI liability and governance, and AI agents in the service desk• MSP pricing and profitability — per-user vs. usage-based pricing, margi SMB Community Podcast: Business Advice for Small MSP Owners Dave Sobel, Amy Babinchak, Small Biz Thoughts, James Kernan Running a small MSP means being the CEO, the sales team, the HR department, and the escalation tech — usually in the same afternoon. The SMB Community Podcast is where MSP owners get straight answers on the business side of running an MSP.Every week, Amy Babinchak, and James Kernan — MSP owners and advisors from the Small Biz Thoughts community — take on the questions small MSP owners actually ask: How should I price? When do I hire? Should I give a proposal at the first meeting? What is my MSP worth? No vendor pitches and no theory — practical advice from people who have run, grown, and sold IT businesses.What this MSP podcast covers:• MSP sales and client growth — the MSP sales process, proposals, price objections, referrals, local marketing, and choosing a CRM• MSP pricing and agreements — MSP pricing models, single plan vs. tiers, price increases, managed service contracts, margins, and cash flow• Leading an MSP team — MSP hiring, tech compensation and commissions, accountabil

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of MSP [] MATTSPLAINED [] MSPx?

This episode is 26 minutes long.

When was this MSP [] MATTSPLAINED [] MSPx episode published?

This episode was published on June 20, 2021.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this MSP [] MATTSPLAINED [] MSPx episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.