Skip to content
Simblifying Economics with Ashish Kulkarni Part -2 episode artwork

Jan 30, 2023 42 min

Simblifying Economics with Ashish Kulkarni Part -2

from Simblified Hosted by IVM Podcasts

The mark of a truly good teacher is when their former students invite them as experts on their podcasts" - Plato [citation needed] The Simblified gang (minus Tony) taps into the expertise of Srikeit's former professor, Ashish Kulkarni to 'simblify' the world of economics. Ashish, an engineering dropout turned Econ PhD, talks to us about how economics principle govern every micro aspect of our lives yet the way the subject is taught in India drives people away from it. We also discuss how movies and popular culture subtly point to the prevailing economic conditions of the time and delve into the indicators and implications of a potential upcoming recession. So please tune in to this absolute beauty of a double episode. You can follow Ashish and his musings on Econforeverybody.com We'd love to hear from you and even have you on the podcast! If you'd like to get in touch, say hello on our shiny new email ID, [email protected]. We promise to read and reply to every mail, even spam. Especially spam. Add one part news, one part bad jokes, one part Wikipedia research, one part cult references from spending too much time on the internet, one part Wodehouse quotes, and one part quality puns, and you get Simblified. A weekly podcast to help you appear smarter, to an audience that knows no less! Your four hosts - Chuck, Naren, Srikeit, and Tony attempt to deconstruct topics with humor (conditions apply). Fans of the show have described it as "fun conversations with relatable folks", "irreverent humor", "the funniest thing to come out of Malad West" and "if I give you a good review will you please let me go". Started in 2016 as a creative outlet, Simblified now has over 200 episodes, including some live ones, and some with guests who are much smarter than the hosts. Welcome to the world of Simblified! You can contact the hosts on: Chuck: twitter.com/chuck_gopal / instagram.com/chuckofalltrades Naren: twitter.com/shenoyn / instagram.com/shenoynv Tony: twitter.com/notytony / instagram.com/notytony Srikeit: twitter.com/srikeit

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

The Simblified gang (minus Tony) taps into the expertise of Srikeit's former professor, Ashish Kulkarni to 'simblify' the world of economics. Ashish, an engineering dropout turned Econ PhD, talks to us about how economics principle govern every micro aspect of our lives yet the way the subject is taught in India drives people away from it. We also discuss how movies and popular culture subtly point to the prevailing economic conditions of the time and delve into the indicators and implications of a potential upcoming recession.

Ready to play

Simblifying Economics with Ashish Kulkarni Part -2

0:00 42:40
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

I, V, M. which shows or tries to show that growth, even if it does increase economic inequality, income inequality, it actually improves outcomes for even the poorest people. So you'd rather be a very, very poor people in a rich country than a not so poor person in a poor country because overall, that kind of thing. So then that starts affecting the way you think about life as a whole.

So what is your sense of how economics or what you see, what you expect is your view of the world. Your view on life or your view on the purpose of life. Whatever big questions the philosophy improves. So my favorite definition of economics is it is a study of how to get the most out of life and what economics will tell you is what are the goals that will help you get the most out of life.

But what is for you the most out of life that can't come from economics, that must come from philosophy. And that nobody else can answer for you that only comes from within and from figuring out what you want out of life. But now that you've decided this is what I want out of life, I want to make simply my deepest forecast in the world. Then sure, economics can help you in figuring out how to make that happen.

Do you mean to imply we already aren't? Ha ha ha ha So do you feel then, Ashutoshi is a big part and again, this kind of goes back to the problem with today's pedagogy. Do you feel a large part of the problem is not teaching that second part, that also vital what you want out of life. Like arguably, no education system is equipping you with the tools better.

It's just that you have these huge bunch of tools and you don't know what to do with them. Would you think that's a problem. And other education, but overall, India and others will be the last education question. including for myself, this is equally to myself.

I don't think we ask often enough to ourselves, what is it that we want our life to be simply to look at what other people are running behind it, so this is what we want to do. Exactly the only time that that question is ever asked is during MBA interviews where everybody gives the same answer. Very seriously yourself, I'm very serious. But I don't think all of us ask us a question or no.

I'd like to sort of, I don't know if I mentioned this on the spot-traster before. There is this book I read you once ago called Wanted by a guy named Luke Bergis. So this wanted about a topic called MIMETICS. Oh, yes.

Yeah, it's very interesting. So it's very simple also. And the fun is that you have intrinsic desires and you have desires which are imitative. And a lot of us aren't able to make the distinction between the two.

And we get trapped into having imitative desires, which give us a lot of stress and don't give us a satisfaction when those desires are actually fulfilled. Whereas intrinsic desires, things which you really want to do. And it's a good lens to look at things that are like. And that sort of somehow in my mind devolves into behavioral economics as well, which tells, so there is very nice anecdote in thinking first and slow about how a statistician, a friend of Kahneman's, falls for a bias, even though he's a guy who actually discovered that bias.

So it is how we are hardwired into having things of that. And that's why the new age of economics seems to be the behavioral part where humans are essentially not rational creatures, which was assumed. That was the core assumption in the economic theory of yesterday. What are your views on?

So it's very empirical. People do a lot of very clever experiments. But economics being economics, a lot of those experiments are very difficult to parse. You could brittle the knobs of that experiment a little bit and get entirely new.

How does one deal with things like biases, things like one's own irrationality? Does in your experience knowing more about something, improve your resistance or your tendency not to fall into that trap? How do you look at this whole subject? I would like to say that knowing more helps you over those mistakes.

And I would love people to say that. I end up having wondering too many, for example, friends come over. I'll end up wasting a little bit too much time. The only thing that economics does is if the moment of regret eventually occurs, at least you move various good.

That's a very good thing. Very nice way of putting it. It doesn't mean you're not going to screw up in the same way again. But yeah, you're going to screw up for that real.

I mean, in some ways, that's taking an analogy of just taking the extending that particular thing. I mean, I won't say it's based on theory, but it's economics led thinking in some way where I'm like, I have specific, like Chuck is solidly into, at least the last year of spending significant amount of time working out and building his fitness in some way. I have neglected that aspect. But the one aspect that I really look at is in some ways where I'm looking at something, eating something, sweet or looking at something like that.

I'm like, there is a particular, some mom's friend that's got some vitae and stuff like that. It comes in the house and all that stuff. And she's like, hi, Gileli. And I'm like, no, I'm saving my calories for when I'm really tempted.

Because I'm like, yeah, I know I shouldn't be eating this stuff. Eating garbage is not going to help me here. Because again, I know that I'm going to end up eating this. I will succumb to this.

But in other circumstances, on my own terms, rather than succumbating to it, I'm like some other concepts. So I'd say economics led thinking is at least help me. I mean, in some ways, erasure my mistakes. So I'm able to do them better while I continue to do them, but just do them better, I guess.

No, that's not right. Yeah, I know. I think it was very interesting thinking. Especially you're saying at the beginning of the year, everyone has resolutions and everyone's trying to learn about habits and things.

I've been over the last few years. This is good. Then you would emphasis on building habits rather than that one outside is forced. If you're probably read an article, you're probably probably entirely about the entire book by James Clear on the topic.

Atomic habits. So it's a brilliant book I think. What I find fascinating is the little thing that Shriek had just spoke about. I see that kind of advice being said more and more, like take the measurable things and kind of break your life down into small numbers so that your decision to do things becomes easier.

So I'll take what Shriek has an extended a little more. One fascinating way of thinking about junk food and rewarding yourself and all that is to think about calories, not from a daily basis, but a weekly basis. And to aggregate your saved calories through the week and completely slow down the weekend. And you can do that guilty free knowing that you're still well within your limit or whatever the case may be.

And I see that possibly happening in other places. But if you want to build a reading habit, start with, OK, today I will commit to reading 10 pages, for instance. So I find this breaking down of vague goals into these tangible little things. One way of, I guess, thinking about, I don't know whether you would call it economic theory, but I find it quite interesting when you break it down into actual tangible numbers that you can quantify, maybe check out for something like that.

That's an observation, not a question. No, absolutely. So my favorite blog, to read about economics is blog for marginal revolutions. And there are multiple interpretations to the phrase, marginal revolutions.

What you spoke about is a classic example for marginal revolutions. You are, that's one effort. That's what I do. That for a week, you show up and read those 10 pages for a week and over time it ends up becoming the habit.

So when I started writing the blog, I started the blog in 2016 and wrote fairly regularly for about a year and then I gave up with I think everybody's very good at doing. And then a couple of years later, I said, you're going to start writing the blog again. But what I promised myself was every day, I'll share five links that are in that. It was nothing more.

Did that log in? I myself were putting up only five links and then I said, you know, you should do something more. And then basically, you can call it, I don't have it, it's been calling marginal revolutions. But taking one step at a time and adding two steps, two long steps, two days, and do a very long way.

Yeah, absolutely. 100%. Yeah, the eight, the one who was going to set the eight one of the world is compound interest. Yeah, absolutely.

Yeah, so what I was mentioning was this entire thing about this aspect of doing it. And similarly, another one, I think there was another theory, which I mean, for working out and all that stuff. There are all these different hacks. So one of the ones that I saw, which was very simple, which said that basically working out principle is like no second day off.

The whole point is like, we can work out, it's okay to take a day off, right after third year, you work out, just make sure you don't take two days off, back to back. And then I try to get a bit of behavioral hacking by understanding economic principles and understanding how people function in certain ways and what are like those motivators for them. Like one aspect which I used and more mentioning into behavioral science, and that's actually a question which I want to post later about behavioral science and behavioral economics begins in some ways. But there was this one aspect which we were talking about was cholesterol.

So I was working on this one brief in Malaysia, where basically in Malaysia, whole bunch of like half the population has high cholesterol, right? And people generally tend to like, they bury their heads in the sand about the problem because they're like, if you don't think about it, they go away. Therefore, the conventional way of thinking about it was, let's hammer people by telling them that one of the relations have high cholesterol and that would turn people away even more. Like everybody wants to think about it and you're trying to push this scary fact in my face.

And so like we use this one principle called chunky and we kind of showed how people are like, Manate cholesterol is a very small task. All you need to do is like really tiny interventions every day, right? All you need to do is just do one thing here. Just do this one particular thing there.

Go to the island, pick up this one thing at this point of time. So it's breaking up the task into smaller pieces, help people kind of feel like, oh, it's not that big a deal, right? And so that helped me kind of understand it. So I mean, coming back to that question that I kind of asked about that was, I mean, there's a lot of understanding and there's a lot of interest in this space of behavioral science, right?

And I'll admit, even though being a behavioral science enthusiast, I don't really very well understand the difference between how behavioral science works and behavioral economics works and where the line for one ends and the other begins. So I don't know if you would be able to enlighten us on that. I'm not afraid to say this idea, but I would say application of economic principles to behavioral analysis, behavioral economics, but I don't know whether line stops, I would argue everything that we've spoken about can be part of from our behavioral economics perspective also. But another underlying principle is that of incentives, which is just a whole fascinating story.

It's one right, how do you incentivize yourself to get something done? So Tim Ferriss, for example, has his way to incentivize himself to use V8, he spoke about this many years ago, where he'll send a friend a truly embarrassing picture of himself in the most embarrassing pair of underpantative processes and he'll say, if I don't hit my target by a particular day, I allow you to put this picture on social media. That's in our language, we'll call that a negative incentive. And a positive incentive might be to reward yourself that if you can stick to a particular thing and you'll reward yourself with something under the day.

But no matter what you do, incentives is fantastic. Behavior starts is where people figure out how to gain these incentives. And you're very cool. I mean, only I'm very lucky to think that whatever it is, is cool.

Pretty cool. You're expressing the fact that people like to gain incentives. It's all good, hard, slow. And what it says is every measure that becomes a target stops being a measure.

Yeah. Yeah, yeah. The two of us have worked in digital marketing. We know exactly what it means.

If there's a metric, it will be game. And that's a problem. We talked about the small anecdote on this. So one of my early clients when I was starting freelancing was a photographer.

And so I come from a school of thought where we're very comfortable with the marketing of saying, you know, I'm not a number of followers and all that. You know, it doesn't matter. And all that stuff chasing that as a number. Because then that's what you're optimizing for, creating good content.

So this is the idea, this is the school of thought that I come from. So I ran into this photographer who was asking me again where they said, OK, how do I increase the number of followers that I have? I'm targeting all folks in India so that I can increase that number on the cheap because the CPM rates over here are cheaper than the US. And I'm like, excuse me.

I don't really need to do that. I said this entire thing, right? Acting like a grin. Then I understood his incentives, which is I know all this.

But when I go to galleries to publish my work, they look at the number of social media following that you have. And they don't give a lot of sass about whether these are Indians or people who are going to buy your expensive photographs or whatever. I just need to pump up that number. So I don't know if that's an example of this, but it just got me thinking about the whole angle of incentives.

And I think that's another thing that should be taught at a young age, which is the empathy to figure out the incentives, especially when you're being sold to or in any two-way transaction. Anyway, so that is just a small little aside. Just as an addition to this and something that I was working with, I think Chuck and I used to work together in an agency for a brief period of time. And one of the accounts that we both shared was this particular client who comes to me really adamantly and says, hey, I need to increase my follower count for this stuff and all.

And I think the two of us work together to kind of build this entire presentation to show why follower count doesn't matter. The client not at all agreed, everything is fine. I continued working on it for a long time afterwards, like this mission to educate kind of thing, kind of like did a deep dive into it. And the client still always skeptical.

Then one day we finally sat down and as most things get resolved over a drink and we kind of sat down over a drink and I just talked to him and I was like, why are you still, I mean, we have spent this much time, you're not a dumb guy. You spend so much time understanding why are you still insistent on this. He's like, you don't understand. Once I cross say to like followers, I get to release a press release, which puts out there that I have so many followers on social media, that press release is part of my KRA.

So please don't, I mean, I understand where your citizen is coming from and all that as a brand manager, I can never formalize with you that you are wrong. But here is my concern, I need a press release. So just give me the number that I'm asking for. Don't ask me further questions beyond that.

So it's again, everywhere is driven by metrics in a large way, like a corporate sense. And everyone's working towards delivering on those metrics. The classic thing, right? I mean, when I'm being chased by a bear, I don't need to outrun the bear, I just need to outrun you.

So, yeah. So, so, so. So, so, so. There was an outdrive of play in the government and how much said he will play the play by rewarding citizens for having killed the rats.

Yeah, yeah. Yeah. Yes, yes. You proved that you killed the rats by playing your rats play.

So people started playing politically growing rats to cut off their meals and give to the government. The classic example of how a measure stopped being a measure once it became the target. And the way I like to explain to students to say, you are 75% percent, but in terms otherwise, they're not granted is basically the same thing at play, you make sure you let them, but there's no guarantee that you will learn. So, figure out how to play the system.

Yeah. You have very good at giving you, for incentives in entirely the wrong way. Totally. So I run a small manufacturing business and I employ people.

And I've learned the hard way that you need to incentivize people. I mean, incentives are far more important than one imagine. So whatever your objectives are, first you need to have clarity or not your objective to that. And then you have to see very, very carefully how to incentivize people.

And the world, the real world and people are so complicated that almost invariably your first efforts are going to bomb. So you'll put some incentive and people will go game them. Yeah. And it's an ongoing battle.

It's marketing, for example, for us, we need to link marketing to sales because it's institutional. It's a quite automotive company. So you get an order from an automotive company. So you've told someone that he's in charge of this company.

And if he generates more, he goes out and generates unprofitable sales. And because that's his method. And I don't think there is any content right answer on how you can set or design incentives. But is there anything, any book or any sort of body of work that you might have read that talks about these kind of things?

I think nudge theory is one of those sort of goes there. But something less esoteric than that. Yeah. Discover your inner economics by Tyler Poppin is a book basically about figuring out how you can incentivize both yourselves and others, but also the pitfalls of how to think about what might go wrong.

So the technical term, what you just said, that in terms of designing incentives and getting them right, if you want to sound all academic is incentive compatibility design. So how to make sure that your workers and you both have the same use that in a party this week. Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. But so Tyler, I want to speak about a couple of examples which I love to use to illustrate to people the power of getting your incentives right and also what might go wrong. So he speaks about say, for example, imagine that I hate sitting in an industry with anything at all of us. So what if I say to the dentist that I give you an extra amount of money if you make sure that it does not end up being full experience for me?

Is everybody incentive or not? So that is exactly what I want to say. Yeah. Yeah.

So it's part of your simply want to pander to the guy who doesn't want to sit in the chair again, but there doesn't want to feel pain at all. But one way or the other, you want to get your incentive wrong and you need to figure out what you're going to do. The other thing that I love and I use it in the case of my daughter was he says every time you go to a museum, let's face it, every now and then you're going to get bored. But I'm not the other way.

So you're going to look at every damn painting and every damn room. So you're going to look at every single painting. So you're going to try and give me five for yourself. Ask yourself this question.

If you could see only one painting from each room to hang above your bed between you two. So now it's not about having to look at all the different ways exactly. Now, certainly incentives are here and now you're no longer good. And this work in the case of my daughter.

So he spent a very interesting couple of hours when he went to the museum saying he died, maybe you should be this painting. Only time to go to security guard. That's a very good thing. Sorry.

No, no, no, this device we have. This time I visited Bombay. I think Chuck and we discovered this very interesting, unexpectedly interesting museum in the middle of Bombay, which is the Nehru Center, which has the entire history of India from the industrialization, all the way to independence. That's a beautiful museum.

It's a visual treat and it's amazing. Generally needs to go through that. But it's exhaustive. And we went there with like, oh, let's spend half an hour going through this stuff.

And that was so exhaustive that we were like towards the end. We were more than, it was free because we didn't spend any money going in there. But more was, oh my God, there is so much content over here. So we were like, we were like rushing through the exit because we were like, but we are still like committed and part committed itself.

Right? So that particular thing was like, but so yeah. So we have seen this movie called In Time by any chance. So it's fascinating.

Oh wow, that's a beautiful idea. So the movie, it's one of those movies where the concept is better than the actual movie itself, much like yesterday where the movie was okay with the concept of what was the real world without the people's like, no, it's fascinating. So in this movie, there is no concept of money. Right?

What instead people have is time. So when you say time is money, then it's movie takes it literally. So what happens is whenever you talk about this movie, I think I might have mentioned it. Just as I said, I'll just be like, what happened over there and for anyone who might not have heard of it.

So whenever you complete an economic transaction, including work at your office, you don't get paid money. You get paid in time. And how that happens is you almost like your entire army's NFC and your balance, your bank, what is your bank balance gets reflected on your arm. And it's fascinating.

It's kind of fascinating. What happens is when you run out of time, you die. That's when you almost die. And by watching the movie to spend a fascinating, but I was like, hey, this is exactly the same as money.

If you replace the novelty of this movie, the fact that they made us think that time is equal to money. But if you replace everything in this movie with actual money, nothing really changes. The plot is the same. The villains incentives are the same, except the currency here is more seconds instead of dollars and cents.

And that movie really, really is money in some sense. I mean, I just thought. One thing for sure is that take that thought a little further and just put it there is that I think a classic, I think one of the biggest fallacies that economics can help us solve is how much we undervalue time. How much value we need to assign to time and how much we classically go penny-wise from foolish in terms of time is considered.

Like where we say, okay, I'm willing to, like the very simple aspect of like I'm willing to go and stand for three hours in a line where I could get it done for one aspect, which I feel is very relevant with at least our parents in some ways. And I think it comes down over here is like my, the other day my mother was, she, there was some bank work was to be done or whatever. And she had paid the guy in advance. She had paid him some money in advance, 100 bucks in advance.

And then he kind of forgot about it. And my mom has a bad knee. So climbing upstairs and all that stuff is a pain for her. She was like, but I paid him 200 bucks in advance.

And I'm like, bro, you climb up that set of stairs because there's no way to get up there. You twist your hand. Me as going to cost us at least a couple of lakhs in therapy and everything else. Right.

But that 200 rupees by principle is like causes so much race that you had to climb those stairs and go and confront that manager to get whatever done. And that's what I think not just time but also health in that way. Like we trade off on health and time because it feels like it's a we have enough of it and we have an expendable commodity over something that is money which is very quantified running out. Right.

But yeah, from moving from that, this is actually one question that I really wanted to ask. In fact, I met Ashish Agar a few weeks ago in Bangalore and I distinctly held off from asking this question. I was saving it for the podcast was generally, I mean, I would love to hear what the economists outlook is on the upcoming so called upcoming recession kind of situation right now because I mean, there is a lot of conversation about that. Now, in my, I'm just saying I dabble in the markets a bit and like from the markets point of view, it's all there's a lot of speculation.

There's a lot of up and down. The markets are on all time high as yet. Everyone is like, Oh, I'm taking money out of equity is kind of like a reality on some level. Then you talk about it from a more national point of view where everyone's like, okay, inflation is through the loop after COVID the K-shaped recovery happened and whatever else like different kinds of angles happened with all of that.

So there's a lot of a lot of murkiness for the lay person in terms of what is going to happen, whether there is a recession going to happen. Whenever we say recession, at least I would say millennials with the only recession we have experienced was 2009, which was like an explosive kind of recession. Right. There was this one big event and then like the market scratched and then there was a period where jobs went there and then it was followed by a period of economic growth.

Right. And I'd say someone was studied probably more recession than the last one. What is your perspective on the upcoming recession? What is your perspective on the next coming with and like maybe some angles of how we get prepared for it.

Take a quick break. We're speaking with Ashish Kolkani, blogger at Econfer everybody and economics professor. See you on the other side. Stay tuned and simplify.

Namaste. So Sir Kyle, good morning, evening afternoon. My podcast is titled Sales. No guys, no topic and no filters say from Father Brochia.

That's me, Monday to Friday, Saturday Sunday. I'm without kicks. We chat with celebs who never meet traffic jams on streets and people from all professions. Every one day I go live with the show, ask me anything, you tell the questions, I'd also better than a Mumbai Richard Rangel.

I even host a panel discussion called Cocking Bull where we dive into current affairs and wonder why anyone even cares at all. You tune into CyberSayers on YouTube and all our new streaming platforms. Are you looking for finance products and services that can enhance your personal finance experience? Are you looking for a space to talk about your financial product or service?

And are you looking for a Chris Proxio where the conversation is all about money? Well, your search ends here. Hi, my name is Arupak Gupta and I host the best of us at Proxio. And I invite you for the conversation about your personal finance for each Monday on the IBM Proxio app or the website or at any Proxio streaming platform.

See you folks. Welcome back to Semify. We're speaking with Ashish Kolkani, economics proff and blogger at Econfer everybody. He had to talk about the next event back in time.

That was a brilliant optimization of time. I thought if I were like, I'm proud of that is what I would do. Find who won bet. It's a random idea.

I think it should be, it doesn't already exist. You should read movies by economics accuracy or what they should have done to maximize economic economy or something like that. Contact, contact, contact. Superp, yeah.

But yeah, go ahead. The second thing is if anybody does seem to predict the future, this is something that I learned by reading the skinder game by Palim. But ask them if they have adjusted their portfolio. If they haven't, it's just a thing.

Yeah. So I haven't adjusted their portfolio. I don't yet know enough about what is going to happen in 2020 to be short of the market or to go longer than the market or anything for that matter. I'm just trying to say whatever it is that I would do in a normal course.

Which is not missing, there is not going to be a recession. Which is missing, I don't know this one. But having said both of these things is a very long disclaimer. Now what you're speaking about, how will we try and figure out what indications might be that the recession is coming along.

First, quite simply, crowd-sourcing idea. So a lot of professional polls that have been conducted amongst economists. Usually the response rate by now has been in excess of 50%. But more than half of economists are saying that yes, they likely are going to be a recession.

All of them could be wrong. But there does seem to be some sort of consensus gathering. So that's one thing you might want to look out for. At the very beginning, even if you were said to know economics, economics, what are the so-called experts saying?

Second, interest rates are high right now and inflation is high right now. And it is almost all but a guarantee that interest rates will be raised a little bit from here on in. Not just in India, but to do it. And what that means on the ground is a lot of consumers are going to say it is not more difficult to buy homes, it is more difficult to buy apartments, it is more difficult to buy cars, it is more difficult to buy flats, three tepees.

Let's not buy all of this right now. At the margin. So people who might have decided to buy something by taking a look at how low interest rates are, are now not buying that stuff. And so therefore there is now an incentive for people to not produce that stuff.

Second, even if you were planning on producing something you need to ask yourself, am I better off keeping this money in the bank or am I better off employing it and building a new factory? The higher the interest rate it is, the more attractive it is for me to keep money in the bank. So one, consumers are likely to not buy quite as much. Producers are not likely to spend quite as much and that is the very definition of recession.

So in extremely simplistic terms, yes, it is all but a guarantee that there is likely to be a slowdown right now, sometime in the year of 2020. Compounding all of this is the fact that we have that Madwar in Russia, sorry, you know, Ukraine going on right now that shows no sign of trading and that is only going to add to the inflationary pressures. For the simple reason that both Russia and Ukraine tend to be really neither exporters of basic crops. Those are simply not a way to do it.

And food inflation is not going to therefore come down any time soon. Few inflation is therefore not going to come down any time soon. We got lucky because you have got a mild winter this year. But in addition to all of what I said, one high food prices, D, eventually whether you like it or not high fuel prices, combined with high inflation, combined with high interest rates, it's just a perfect, so you can say it's a perfect storm, which is why very simplistically put, yes, there is all but likely to be a recession this year.

The question is the timing. So I know broadly, I'm fairly sure that the direction in which the economy is going can at time it. I wish I could, but I don't know exactly what the recession is going to happen. That's a great answer in that way.

But what also comes down to is what is it going to look like? Like what does it, how do we know that we are going to be, when we are already in a recession and what is it, what are those key indicators that are going to tell us that here here, finally, this is where the recession has begun and these are where the things are going to go off. Like, I know I understand again, all the disclaimers in place, we are saying that, yeah, what I guess you'd be able to modulate on is what the recession has behaved like in the past. So again, on that, what are those key markers and indicators knowing that there is a delta of the stuff that we don't know.

So in the language of economics, what you're asking for is what are the leading indicators? And the reason I think is because there are also what I know is lagging indicators. You can take a look at how GDP has changed over time and you can see that if there is a decline in GDP for two successive quarters, then you might want to declare it as a recession. So the problem with that is we report our GDP two months after the quarter is ended.

So we'll only find out what is happening in this quarter, two months after the quarter is gotten over and move on it, it's getting over, that is going to be... Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, this is also true of the game that, going back to the Fed Chair game, right? The stuff is that whatever actions you take can only impact a quarter or two after that you have taken those actions. So there is that lag that happens in that as such.

So you can't like immediate result, something. So even time indicators you might want to take a look at say for example, particularly in India, you might want to take a look at how two-wheeler sales are doing. And the reason I said two-wheeler sales is because four-wheeler sales are actually not about indicator of how they need to know. Because not many of us actually end up buying automobiles.

So there are literally a very few privileged people end up doing so. But motorcycles almost everybody will get at some point in time in their lives by. And unfortunately two-wheeler sales in India have not been doing all that great. And if you see a sign that they are declining even further from here on in that you have a pretty good indication that things are not looking so hunky.

You might want to take a look at real estate prices, not necessarily only in the urban areas, but especially in the rural areas that might provide another indicator. The stock market average is actually not about indicator because it is driven perhaps a little bit more by hype than anything else. And you might want to take a look at simple indicators that really should begin to cause you, for example, or you see evidence of shrinkage. So Hindustan, Unilever and how it is pricing kids products and not just pricing its products, but also how it is changing the quantity within each product.

So, shrinkage and simply means that keep the prices same but sell you slightly less at quantity. That's what we call so, we call it smaller but also. And when that happens, you realize that a company like HVL is struggling to get sales in rural areas. And rather than cause a reduction in price, they are reducing the quantity.

And the only reason they are doing that is because people are not even willing to buy at 10 rupees. That is likely to be good indicator that we have a recession of company. And this part is not just quantity, but also I used to work with leading chocolate brands. And the other aspect was they used to maintain their price point, but also what they used to do was increase the volume of sugar in the chocolate and reduce the volume of chocolate.

Because chocolate is far more expensive than sugar. So, that was one way of mitigating it. So, even though they get the volume the same, quality effectively of the product kept changing. So, these are interesting markers to look out for.

And so, besides that, I mean, I look at it, these as macro indicators to gauge where the overall economy is getting into recession. What are those key aspects which you could probably tell that an average consumer, an average non-economics person who is living there everyday life, do to identify the points of recession and also what they can look out for. And what they can do to safeguard themselves or at least safeguard their interest in any which way from a recessionary atmosphere. Before, during and after a recession.

Really more question for a personal financial advisor than an economic advisor. And I am not a personal financial advisor, but say that simple rule switch. I would think anybody should practice this. Even if you don't earn anything for the next six months, you have some liquidity, cash somewhere, which I will tell you.

But you would be surprised the number of people who are not doing something like this. It doesn't have to be the same kind of lifestyle, but you should have the ability to make your home run for the next six months. And this money isn't to be inequity. It isn't to be anything, even remotely risky.

I do not want to use the word for a safe house. It's not to be as easy as possible. It should be kept as safe as possible. That goes without saying.

Number one, again, this is fairly obvious stuff, but I worry about the number of people I know who don't seem to follow this. Do not for the level of max audio credit cards and obviously the full amount, not minimum amount due. And speaking to a very small portion of India's population actually has credit cards. But even outside of credit cards, don't ever leverage yourself in terms of debt if you know that a recession is coming along.

But it's interesting to me, over time, the indicator that I have relied upon the most of the number of times I've asked many economics in India, while it's at this recession, whenever I hear, I found to be the best indicator of the recession next year or not. Because nobody's more interested in recessions than people are going to sit for placements. I was like, who would you generate internet? What's the economics?

The economics in terms. That's how it's going to go. That's 2009, Micah. Thank you.

Thank you. Thank you. I'm in companies to come and get up with it. So I'm going to ask you questions.

That's pretty obvious. Yeah. I mean, I think that experience taught me a lot, including how to live in Bombay on a budget. But anyway, we will not get into how we sell these that.

But yeah, that's the same point. Yeah. That's a bad teacher, teaching how to be a good professor. A bad relationship is a good idea.

Yeah. I should have thought that. Very profound actually. Yeah.

So I actually sum up at Round Off. This is by an overall con question. And here is where I would also give you an opportunity to make your plugs if you choose to. As an average leap person who is interested in economics but doesn't really know where to start and doesn't really know where to begin to get a better understanding of this space.

What are those resources that you would recommend and places that you can go to kind of like start off this journey? Sure. So marginal revolution is university. The same blog that I spoke of, the two professors who run that blog have created an online video series which is entirely worth watching.

There are subtitles available in almost all Indian languages. So feel free to follow along no matter which language you most proficient with. But marginal revolution is a good place to begin. And this is for like absolute beginners as well.

Absolute. So you can begin principles of economics, micro and macro. And you need to know nothing. They don't use a single equation in those videos.

It's entirely worth watching. I am working with them on a part-time basis. So there is some bias involved. But I genuinely do think that they are easily the best resources you can use in terms of audio.

In terms of audio, I can't better the planet money. It's fantastic. Everybody should listen to the planet. And it's the system about us, the indicators as well.

Which I think is the case name for the show. Absolutely. And in terms of books. So rather than everybody recommends economics, but you might want to read a book called The Undercover Economics.

I got him half of it. Yes. I got a book. Yes.

So he's also a book. You've got lots of books. You might also want to read about 50 things that change the modern economics. This is both a podcast and a book.

But the under cover economics and the under cover economics prides back. Both very good books too. Oh, very nice. Yeah, both very good books.

Fantastic. Sure. I love my own book. But I don't think you should read a book to learn about economics.

You should read a book to basically listen to me rant about everything about it. I think that's a great question to begin. And that is Econ for everybody. Yeah.

That is the book. So Shriekit, I have a few questions for you. Which I have a situation. Yeah.

Okay. She's free to answer these as well. If you get Narain Hasek, who knows where this is going. So what do you call a thermos that gets a man out of jail?

I'm about to read to ask. Milton Friedman, obviously. Of course. Ahh.

Okay. Now if you were to hunt and eat a raw fish, you could say that the game is in the skin. Oh my god. Yeah.

Okay. Then what I was thinking of writing, by the way, they were like, how on earth is it possible for thasers to exist because of supply shock economics? No supply shock? Why?

Oh my god. I was feeling very much about the fold on this paper. You know in... You're scared of future experts.

All the people coming back. All the people coming back. He tends to write them during the episode. He says, believe me.

So, so... Or for the depending on your point of view. So you see sub-kit of books, right? Which you've probably seen your...

Okay, Rana, what I'll use. So, at the end of the day he sits and adds, you know, how much he has on the side, right? That is called marginal revenue. It's kind of proud of that one.

Okay. What do you call... You know, there are various kinds of markets, right? What do you call a kind of market in which you sell only one small horse?

And this you should definitely get. One of you should get. What do you say? One trick.

No, not one trick. No, no. One trick. One trick.

One trick was a great answer, but I was actually going for Monoponi. You know, like Monop Sony? No, no. So, instead of this beach, we could have gone to that one.

And now we are wasting our time over here. This is an example of opportunity coast. Coast opportunity coast. Oh, wow.

So, yeah. So that was fantastic. I mean, Ashish, thank you so much for taking the time. I'd like...

This is great. Yeah. So, thank you so much. And yes, please, we will leave all of our places where you can follow Ashish, importantly, his blog, Econ for everybody, which I feel is a delightful read.

I mean, blogging is a dying art form in some way. And I think Ashish, you know, those people who are still following. No, I think we need to... I think one or two things.

One, I think we need to make blogs great again. I think... Yeah. And two, I am fully on board with anyone who puts a little bit of their personality and a little bit of their story into the way they write.

And my favorite current writers, whether it's, I don't know, somebody like a Scott Galloway or somebody who's like a Shutti Vazvopala, or something like all of these guys, they aren't just good at what they do and how they think, but also putting themselves out there. And I definitely see that having me. So, thanks so much Ashish for appearing on the show. Thank you.

Super. So, thank you so much. And Narim, do you want to sign us off? Yes.

Stay safe. Stay economical and stay simplified.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Simblified?

This episode is 42 minutes long.

When was this Simblified episode published?

This episode was published on January 30, 2023.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Simblified episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.