Skip to content
Six Weeks to Go episode artwork

Sep 20, 2024 22 min

Six Weeks to Go

from The Daily Hosted by The New York Times

As the presidential race enters its final 45 days, we assemble a campaign round table with our colleagues from the politics desk. Maggie Haberman, Shane Goldmacher and Nate Cohn interpret this week’s biggest developments. Guest: Maggie Haberman, a senior political correspondent for The New York Times. Shane Goldmacher, a national political correspondent for The New York Times. Nate Cohn, the chief political analyst for The New York Times. Background reading: Harris had stronger debate, polls find, but the race remains deadlocked. Here’s the latest on the 2024 elections. For more information on today’s episode, visit nytimes.com/thedaily . Transcripts of each episode will be made available by the next workday. For more information on today’s episode, visit nytimes.com/thedaily. Transcripts of each episode will be made available by the next workday. Subscribe today at nytimes.com/podcasts or on Apple Podcasts, Spotify and Amazon Music. You can also subscribe via your favorite podcast app here https://www.nytimes.com/activate-access/audio?source=podcatcher. For more podcasts and narrated articles, download The New York Times app at nytimes.com/app.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

As the presidential race enters its final 45 days, we assemble a campaign round table with our colleagues from the politics desk. Maggie Haberman, Shane Goldmacher and Nate Cohn interpret this week’s biggest developments. Guest: Maggie Haberman, a senior political correspondent for The New York Times. Shane Goldmacher, a national political correspondent for The New York Times. Nate Cohn, the chief political analyst for The New York Times.

Ready to play

Six Weeks to Go

0:00 22:12
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

What do you think makes it difficult for people to turn an idea into an actual business? Shopify is the platform for a record-breaking, reliable holiday-selling season at every stage. Launched before Black Friday, a time of year when people are already shopping and ready to buy. If you're ready to launch your business before Black Friday, go to Shopify.com to start your free trial. That's Shopify.com. Go to Shopify.com today to hear your first... From New York Times, I'm Michael Barbaro. This is The Daily. The race for the White House has kicked into overdrive tonight with a tax... As the presidential race enters its final 45 days...

Hello, Pennsylvania. How are we doing, Pennsylvania? We assemble a campaign roundtable with my colleagues from the politics desk. Today, Maggie Haverman, Shane Goldmacher, and Nate Cohn make sense of the week's biggest developments. The Federal Reserve cut interest rates today for the first time in four years. You know, the Democrats have always taken for granted that they're going to get our vote no matter what. And the Republicans are fancying themselves as the working people's party. Former President Trump has now faced two apparent assassination attempts. It's sort of mind-boggling. It's Friday, September 20th. Maggie, Shane, Nate.

Thank you all for doing this. Thank you for having us. Thank you. Yeah. So just to explain what we're doing here, it feels like we've reached the point in this campaign where the news is coming at us so fast that our normal format of telling one story a day is not quite keeping up. And so to meet this moment, we recruited you three to come kind of walk us through the thicket that is the news at this phase of the race. So it's an experiment for us. We invented something. It's brand new. It's called the political roundtable. Congratulations. Wow. What an honor to be part of the first. Yeah, yeah, yeah. The first of any kind. Ever. No, ever, ever, ever. In history.

So let's start with a very big new poll, co-conducted by the New York Times, that came out just a few hours ago. Could each of you just tell me what you took from this poll? I think that this is a poll, there's actually two polls, and there's some contradiction between the two of them. The first poll is a national poll, and it shows a tied race, which isn't really a surprise. And it shows no movement, basically, since the debate a week ago, even though voters overwhelmingly said that Kamala Harris performed really, really well. So that's the first part of the poll. Is that worth lingering on, that people told us in this poll, Kamala Harris did great, it had been our understanding that if she did great, she'd get a bump in the polls, nationally she doesn't. Yeah, I think that's definitely worth lingering on.

The fact is that overwhelmingly voters said she did really well. If something close to 70% of voters said she performed well in this debate, far more than the 40% who said the same of Trump, that means a big chunk of people who said she did well are not voting for her. But that's also part of the story, which is that she might have done better in the debate, but it didn't actually change how people said they were planning to vote in the head-to-head matchup with Donald Trump. And it wasn't just on that top line, who are you going to vote for? It was on a whole suite of issues. Who do you think is better on the economy, on immigration, on abortion, on democracy? All of these issues were essentially unchanged by this debate that was watched by 67 million Americans, the most who watched anything since the Super Bowl. And yet, no difference in the head-to-head. Why not, Nate?

Well, it's a pretty polarized country and the number of undecided voters did tick down from our previous poll to this one. So a lot of voters are making up their minds and they're mostly falling into the place where they were before. This is a matchup that neatly divides voters in a lot of ways. We have a populist, older white conservative against a younger black and South Asian woman from California who has liberal views on all the issues. So, you know, there's room for someone to be torn between these two options. But as far as choices go, this is a relatively clear one.

Okay, but this poll did something else, which was it told us about how Kamala Harris is doing in the very specific crucial state, Maggie, of Pennsylvania. What do you take from that result? What's striking, and as Shane said, is it's contradictory to what we saw in the national poll where they're tied. She's up. It's 50 to 46. In Pennsylvania. In Pennsylvania. And one of the reasons that might be is the Democrats have done relatively better with white voters this cycle than previous cycles. And Pennsylvania is a particularly...

white state compared to the rest of the country. And so if you look at how Joe Biden did with white voters in 2020, it was slightly less. Hillary Clinton, substantially less. And so if she has made some modest gains there, that could be why. Does that feel right to you, Nate? Because I think my inclination would be to think that if Kamala Harris is tied with Trump nationally, I would not expect her to be doing better in a swing state where I would just imagine demographically things might be stacked a little bit against her. Look, I wouldn't expect it either. And, you know, they are polls. They're subject to a margin of error. It's possible that if we did the polls again, that they would come a little closer. But this doesn't come from nowhere. In the 2022 midterm, Democrats swept the key Senate races, including...

winning Pennsylvania by five points, even while Republicans won the House popular vote. So there could be a change from the last election, maybe not all the way to this poll result, where Harris does four points better in Pennsylvania than she does nationwide, but one where the gap between the key battleground states and the electoral college is a little smaller than we're used to. I was going to say, I mean... there's like two stories you can tell about the race right now that I think that these polls capture. And we talk about how polls are a snapshot. This snapshot shows a really close race nationally and maybe a slight edge for Kamala Harris, not just in Pennsylvania, but looking at other polls across those key battlegrounds around the Great Lakes. And so how do you get the story of what that means next? And it's not at all clear to me what it means next because we got here and it's like Kamala Harris just had an incredible two months, right? She's gotten almost exclusively positive reviews and coverage. She had a strong debate. Her favorability rating in Pennsylvania is above 50%. All these things are going in her favor. And yeah, you get all of that and she's tied.

just maybe marginally had in these really, really important states. It's not just that she's had a great series of weeks, although she absolutely has. Trump's had a terrible series of days. Trump had a debate in which he was spreading a baseless claim that Haitian immigrants in Springfield, Ohio, are eating pets. And doubling down on that ever since, he posted inexplicably on Truth Social, I hate Taylor Swift, who is an incredibly popular figure. Yeah, a lot of people don't hate her. A lot of people don't hate her. And now he has done any number of self-destructive things while also facing one clear assassination attempt, one apparent assassination attempt. Normally speaking, a politician would get some...

measure of sympathy or voters feeling sorry for them or feeling more open to them. And because of Trump's own behavior, he just does not. Okay, are you guys a little bit reigning on Kamala Harris' Pennsylvania parade? Because I'm hearing, if I'm reading between the lines, you all say, she's up in Pennsylvania, but not that much. And after a really great run, and Maggie, you're saying Trump's had a rough couple of days, so she could be up even more. Well, I think the poll shows that a lot of the vulnerabilities that we've talked about before are still there for Kamala Harris. You know, in the last episode that I was with you on, we noted that more voters thought Harris was more of the same rather than change. And Harris has tried to pitch herself as a...

new generation of political leadership that can take the country in a new direction. But the poll still finds, even in Pennsylvania, that most voters think she's more of the same and most voters think Donald Trump has changed. And to me, that just shows that she is swimming a little bit upstream in this election. One related issue here that may be another reason to rain a bit on Harris's parade is that Harris's strength in this poll comes out of white college graduates. She's still doing really poorly among white working class voters just as badly as Joe Biden did or worse than Joe Biden four years ago, both in Pennsylvania and nationwide.

White college graduates, that's a different story. Now, they're somewhat insulated from the economy. They may have the disposable income to survive rising prices. But it's also, to me, a possible indication that maybe we're talking about a lot of overeager Democratic voters who are looking to pick up the phone right now after a debate and after a month where Harris fared really well. And that perhaps might explain why she's doing well in Pennsylvania, a state I think of as being very working class, having a lot of voters who didn't go to college. That's right.

Okay, something happened right before this poll, and that's that the Fed lowered the interest rate, something we've been waiting for and talking about for a really long time. In theory, that should make certain prices, especially the price of a 30-year fixed-rate mortgage, start to come down. When it comes to the economy and how voters view these two candidates, is that too little too late if you're Kamala Harris? Is that a frustrating bit of timing for Donald Trump, or does it not much matter at all? I mean, Donald Trump was complaining about it as political yesterday, so it tells you how he sees it. He's clearly frustrated and thinks that it might help Democrats. And could it help Harris? Sure, it could help Harris. But I think you are going to see Trump and Republicans claim that this was some form of interference by Democrats.

Yeah, I mean, I think that the interest rates lead to changes in some of the few economic numbers that people experience in their life, right? This is the kind of thing that it juices the economy in a way that, like, people don't see immediately, but it can change how people feel. Right. I think it's going to take a bit of time. In Pennsylvania, only 22% of voters thought the economy was excellent or good in this survey. There's a lot of ground to make up here before the economy starts being anything like an advantage for Harris. Voters have believed for years that the economy was bad. I don't know that they're going to change their views on this very quickly. I think we're going to go take an ad break. We'll be right back.

Law transforms agreement into reality. A word becomes an agreement. An agreement becomes a contract. A contract becomes law. Today, Harvey, the AI platform for legal work, is writing the next chapter. More than 200,000 lawyers are building with Harvey, accelerating review, sharpening negotiations, and more. This is how the future of agreements is being crafted now. Harvey. Learn more at Harvey.ai. Harvey does not provide legal advice. Users should always independently review and verify any output from Harvey.

I'm Deborah Kamen. I'm an investigative reporter for The New York Times. One morning a few months ago, I got an email from an anonymous email account, and this person said to me, hey, I have some documents that I think you want to see. And they said, I can show them to you, but I won't send them to you. It's too dangerous to send them. They weren't willing to do it. So I got on a plane that afternoon, and I met them in person, and I photographed the documents, and they proved something that we'd suspected, and now we had a chance to verify it. And we were able to tell a story that moved our reporting forward in a really significant way.

If we tell you a source was anonymous, they're not anonymous to me. I verify their identity, and I'm going to ensure that when we take the information and we share it with our readers, we do it in a way that is responsible, concerned about their safety, and also most of all, focused on making sure we are moving the story forward. When you subscribe to The New York Times, you're getting a whole team of reporters who understand that part of their job is going as far as is required to tell the truth and shine light on things that other people would like to keep hidden. If you're a subscriber, thank you for being a part of that. All right, let's turn to our next piece of business here, which is news of something that kind of sounds like not news, because it's the non-endorsement from a very big union in the U.S. with 1.3 million members in the transportation industry. So tell us that story. Sure. The International Brotherhood of Teamsters, they are in a variety of states across the country, hugely influential, for 30 years endorsed Democrats. This year, Sean O'Brien, the head of the Teamsters, for his own personal internal political reasons, started flirting with Donald Trump as a possible endorsement. Why?

He went to Mar-a-Lago to meet with him. A lot of his members are in southern states, and they are more Republican-leaning, and he is trying to appeal to them and show that he is not just going in one political direction. So it is not a surprise that he spoke, say, at the Republican National Convention, because he had been drifting toward Donald Trump. Now, his advisors said that he asked to speak at both party conventions. The Democrats, after he spoke at the Republican Convention, did not have him. And he gave a pretty aggressive anti-corporate speech at that convention. But nonetheless, it was seen as a boost to Donald Trump because it tied him to organized labor.

And working class voters. And working class voters. And working class voters. And the union has now decided not to endorse this cycle. This is at minimum.

a harm to Harris. And it is helpful to Trump to be able to say, as he has been for the last day, rank and file members support me. Now, he said that on Long Island, where the local Teamsters affiliate had actually endorsed Harris. But it doesn't matter. It gives Trump a talking point. And that's the strategy here. They didn't exactly peel off the international brotherhood of Teamsters, but they did get neutral. And that's good enough for them. Yeah, I mean, I think it's a reflection of the shifting voting patterns of union members. This is union leadership reflecting union members, which is in some of these trade workers, they're increasingly been.

for Trump, right? They released some of their own internal surveys about where they were. Even when Biden was in the race, there was a big chunk in favor, right? So if you look at union leadership across the country, it's almost universally for Democrats. This is an exception. The exception is a non-endorsement, right? Most are not going anywhere near Trump. But it's a reflection that the membership has shifted on these issues. And again, for Trump, that's a win. He wants to be making inroads with those voters, and he wants people to have a pass, that it's okay to consider him. And I think that that's what helps. Look, it's also a positive for Harris that a person who spoke at the Republican National Convention didn't go all the way to endorsing Trump, right? Nate, why does it matter that the Teamsters Union has, in effect, de facto,

kind of signaled an affinity for Trump and not given the Democrats what they may have viewed as their kind of birthright, which was the endorsement of such a powerful, longtime Democratic-leaning union. I want to go back to something Shane said, which is that the Teamsters conducted their own surveys of their members. And previously, they found that most of their members backed Biden, only narrowly. Now, they find their members backed Trump over Harris by a wide margin. Now, not all of these surveys are scientific. Some of them attempt to be. Others are just a strapple. But this is part of a larger pattern that we see in our data, which is a further decline in Democratic support among white-working-class voters since Harris became the nominee. And a group like the Teamsters is suddenly up for grabs.

This is something of a sharp turn, but I think we do need to talk about the fallout from what happened five days ago. It feels like it's a lot longer than that. And that is this second plot to try to kill Donald Trump. And so I want to ask you all to help us think through what this second attempt means for Trump and what it means for the electorate, because we're really dealing with something truly unprecedented. I mean, I remember seeing the first statement that Kamala Harris put out, which is that violence has no place in this country. And, you know, it just made me think that I'm not sure that's true anymore, that there is increasingly a place.

where violence is in our country and in our politics. And when you go back and think through all the different people who are political leaders who've been subjected to violence recently, it's a long list. And of course, we had the violence on January 6th. And so, you know, these are horrific things. And they're a reminder that this country isn't that far from violence anymore. Maggie, what's your sense of how Trump personally is handling the fact that two people seem to want to try to kill him in the past two months? How is that affecting him based on your point? Is it affecting him? It's an interesting question, Michael. We got a bit of an answer at the rally on Long Island on Wednesday night.

After the shooting in Butler, Pennsylvania, Trump was clearly in shock, and lots of people around him described him that way, and I think he probably still is to some extent. After what happened on Sunday in West Palm Beach, people who talked to him that afternoon and saw him that afternoon said it was as if nothing had happened, that he just basically resumed life. You know, it just became more grist for his storytelling, but he wasn't stuck on it the same way, and he wasn't processing it the same way. And yet, at his rally, in the middle of an answer about, I don't even remember what, I think it was tax policy or economic policy, you can see on the live stream, if listeners were to watch it, his eyes flicker to his right, and he sees someone moving. he sort of startles. And he says to the crowd that he thought, essentially I'm paraphrasing, but he thought somebody was coming up, meaning coming up on stage. And he said, I thought that I was going to have to get ready to fight. And then jokingly says that he's got a bit of a yip problem. Just translate that. He means anxiety, yip, anxiety. And he's... How could you not be constantly looking over your shoulder right now? 100%, as any normal person would do. But when have we ever heard Donald Trump say something like that? Right, vulnerability expression is not his natural state. It's not his natural state at all. And so to hear him vocalize that and to see it in real time...

was pretty striking. Now, there was a moment in the 2016 campaign where someone rushed the stage when he was speaking. I remember that. He sort of ducked. That was his impulse. That was the only time I've ever seen anything close. This was really somebody who is on high alert right now. And so even if he is not saying, yes, I'm worried, yes, this is scary, because he will never say something like that, he clearly is and is clearly experiencing it. Very understandably. Nate, when we think about these back-to-back plots, how do you try to assess the way voters think about it? I don't think we have asked people in polls about this, but just knowing what you know about how the electorate processes things.

What are you thinking? We haven't asked a single question about it, to your point. And what would we ask, really, if you think about it? But if you step back for a second, take the long view of Donald Trump's political career. Donald Trump today is more popular than he has ever been before. Back in 2016, voters disliked him by nearly a two to one margin. This year, it's much closer to 50-50 because almost all of the people who support him today have gotten behind him. And I wouldn't rule out a role for these assassination attempts in that process. Consider this. In the nine national polls that we took this cycle before his assassination attempt, between 21 and 24 percent of voters said they had a very favorable view of him since the assassination attempt.

The numbers are 31, 27, 30. So there has been a big step up in the proportion of voters who say they have a very favorable view of him. Those reluctant Trump supporters over the years, a lot more of them are less reluctant. And then there's an overall increase in favorability as well, where now he's consistently in the upper 40, something we had never seen in the course of his time as a major figure in national political life. I mean, Nate, you've touched just on something that I think is really interesting about what my expectations were for how this election was going to go, not just because it was originally going to be Trump and Biden, but it was going to be two deeply unpopular people that the American people did not want to send to the White House. And that's just not what the polling is showing anymore. It shows with all the attack ads running against Kamala Harris that she is more popular than she's been before. And Donald Trump is more popular than he's been before. You have two people in the upper 40s, sometimes tipping at 50 percent. That's really popular right now in this country. Like we've had people in the 30s and the 40s. So we actually have a shifting dynamic of what.

voters are thinking about these choices. They don't dislike these choices nearly as much as we expected a few months ago. That's very true. And 2024 was beginning to look like a replay of 2016, where there were these two deeply disliked candidates, and it was going to be whoever was less disliked ended up winning. That's still usually how elections work. But if there is an election that could scramble that, it could be this one. Well, guys, that's it.

Wow, a historic first of a roundtable in America. That was fun. Thank you, Michael. Thanks for having us. You know, when they set up the exhibit in the Museum of Media History, I'm going to be really proud to be in that photo. Thank you for having us. It was fun. Thank you, Nate, Maggie, Shane. Appreciate it. Thank you. Thanks, Michael. Let's do it again. We'll be right back.

Law transforms agreement into reality. A word becomes an agreement. An agreement becomes a contract. A contract becomes law. Today, Harvey, the AI platform for legal work, is writing the next chapter. More than 200,000 lawyers are building with Harvey, accelerating review, sharpening negotiations, and more. This is how the future of agreements is being crafted now. Harvey. Learn more at Harvey.ai. Harvey does not provide legal advice. Users should always independently review and verify any output from Harvey. Hi, this is Carolyn Ryan, Managing Editor of the New York Times. At the Times, we strive to help everyone stay informed. And at this critical moment, we're making all of our election coverage free in our app.

We have more than 100 reporters out there talking to voters, seeing what drives them, helping you figure out what's going on. On election night, we are the place to go for race results. Our maps are updated minute by minute. Come experience all of our election coverage for free right now in the New York Times app. Here's what else you need to know today. On Thursday, the leader of Hezbollah accused Israel of breaking, quote, all conventions and laws by blowing up thousands of handheld devices belonging to Hezbollah fighters over the past two days and vowed to seek revenge.

As he spoke, Israeli fighter jets flew overhead, producing large sonic booms and shooting off flares in an apparent show of Israeli force. So far, the attacks have killed 37 people, most of them in the second wave of explosions targeting walkie-talkies. To prevent further deaths, the Lebanese army is now carrying out controlled explosions of electronic devices across the country. Today's episode was produced by Diana Wynn and Nina Feldman. It was edited by Rachel Quester with help from Paige Coward. Contains original music by Pat McCusker, Alicia Baitoop, and Dan Powell. And was engineered by Chris Wood. Our theme music is by Jim Brunberg and Ben Lanford of Wonderly.

Remember, you can catch a new episode of The Interview right here tomorrow. David Marchese talks with the Irish writer Sally Rooney, who's written a new novel called Intermezzo. One of the things that I find difficult to accept is that I only get one life. That's it, I'm just me, and I can never be anyone else. And in a way, being a novelist allows me to get around that problem. That's it for Daily. I'm Michael Barbaro. See you on Monday.

I'm MJ Franklin, and this week on the Book Review Podcast, Switzy by Emma Klein. Hands down, the novel with the most impressive control I've read this year. Someone is losing their mind, and they're approaching their death. Completely moving, elegantly written. I just got lost in the prose of it, which sometimes feels like poetry to me. What does a life add up to? What does it all mean? Listen to the Book Review wherever you get your podcasts.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of The Daily?

This episode is 22 minutes long.

When was this The Daily episode published?

This episode was published on September 20, 2024.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this The Daily episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.