Hey, it's Willa. Before we start this episode, I want a moment of your time. Something we really pride ourselves on here at Decoderang is curveballs. That it's very hard to guess what our next episode will be about. Whether it's the Tooth Fairy or the 90s Swing Revival or the Origins of a Bird that shows up for 10 seconds in the Charlie's Angels Movie, the polymarket offered the chance to bet our next topic, it would be a loser's bet.
But at the same time when you finally do see our topics, you're like, yes, of course, that's totally a decoderang. Since 2018, we have been at this, delighting, fascinating, and provoking you by excavating deep into mysteries. You may never have realized you could possibly be curious about probing farther than any sane person would dare. And that kind of consistent surprise and variety. It's rare.
There aren't a lot of shows like Decoderang and not a lot of outlets left late, willing to give journalists like us the space to be so seriously playful, to chase Daffy Larks and to uncover forgotten stories that can make you cry. We have an episode for you today that touches on the state of the media landscape and how it's affecting podcasting in great detail. But the plain truth is that in a moment where it is much safer and more lucrative to bangle a podcast that consists of two celebrities sitting on a couch, the only way to make a show like our sustainable is through our community of listeners. And those listeners willingness to become subscribers. And so we are asking you to join us in becoming Decoderang plus members.
Now through October 16th, we are offering 50% off for one year of a decoderang plus membership. All you have to do is head to slate.com slash decoder plus and enter the promo code decoder50 at checkout. For $59, you can help support the show in a way that truly matters. But that's not all because we have enticements. Oh boy, do we have enticements plus subscribers get access to every episode of Decoderang's back.
That's our series where I call up a listener just like you and answer their burning question about a cultural mystery directly. These have been so fun and rewarding for me to do personally. And they've also showed me that there is a community of decoderang listeners out there, people who are as deeply curious as we are and we want to be more connected to you and with each other. So at the end of the pledge drive, new subscribers will be invited to sit in on one of the decoderang team's regular production meetings over Zoom. You get to see how the sausage gets made as we plan out the logistics of episodes, hash out ideas and debate how to tell certain stories and even pitch each other potential topics or future shows.
Before the meeting, you'll also have the opportunity to submit questions for me and the rest of the team and we'll try to answer as many as we can during the meeting. Subscribers also get ad-free listening across all Slate podcasts unlimitedreadingonslate.com and the Slate app and every Slate game. You can get all of this again for 50% off by going to Slate.com slash decoder plus and entering the promo code Decoder50 at checkout. If you care about the show, if you like the show, if we have kept you company while you were doing the dishes or walking the dog or commuting to work. If we've been there when you needed a crowd pleaser, everyone in the car could agree on for a long road trip.
We need you smash that subscribe button or as I said head to Slate.com slash decoder plus and enter Decoder50 at checkout. We appreciate you. Thank you. I'm with the show. Just a heads up before we begin, this episode contains some adult language.
A couple of months ago, a new program premiered on Netflix called The Pete Davidson Show. It's an interview show and in each episode, the comedian Pete Davidson chats with another comedian or celebrity on camera. Hi guys. Welcome to the show. Today we have a very special guest.
The whole thing is very loose. Pete and his guests sit in slim leather chairs with big black bulbous mics beside them on a darkened stage set which may or may not be Davidson's actual garage. They banter about sobriety, depression, about his guest life and career. My mom was the one who was encouraging me to play the piano and then I started playing. And then like, something happened.
Historically, we've long had a term to describe this kind of show. Like, if you time travel from any time in the last 40 plus years to right now and for some reason you use your miraculous ability to move through time to watch The Pete Davidson Show, you'd be like, I recognize this. I've seen this plenty of times before. I didn't want to be on a movie set. I want to be on the arena. That's fucking dope.
Thousands of people going, oh, I fucking it's the best. Sure. They're cursing and meandering. But this is two people sitting and chatting on screen. This is a TV talk show.
Except you'd be wrong. Pete Davidson, the former SNL star, stepping into the world of podcasting yesterday, Netflix announcing their teaming up with the comedian for an original video podcast called The Pete Davidson Show. A few years ago, I would have thought a video podcast was an oxymoron. What made a podcast a podcast was that it was audio. Something you listened to, not something you watched.
But now that seems to be flipped. Almost all of the most popular podcasts have video also. But the Pete Davidson show stuck out to me because it's not just a video also. It's video only. There is no audio version. You can only watch it on Netflix.
Now, perhaps Netflix is just being weird and clever with their marketing. They're using the term video podcast to make their new talk show seem like something more contemporary and maybe avoiding paying staff, typical union rates for TV while they're at it. But I don't think that's all that's going on. Something else is happening. The word podcast and the visual tropes associated with podcasts, a medium that until recently had no visuals at all. They're metastasizing and showing up in strange places.
Like earlier this year, CNN briefly gave podcast mics to some of its anchors, presumably to make the news feel podcastier. Welcome to the lead. I'm Dick Tapper coming to you live from my actual office. We thought we'd experiment, bring you to the desk where there are multiple channels on YouTube that feature AI generated dogs talking into giant studio mics that call themselves podcasts. Welcome back to the dog pod. I'm glad you're here. I hope you brought treats today.
We're talking about one of the world's worst topics cats. Speaking of cats, here's a clip from Instagram that looks and sounds like a podcast, but is actually just an ad for catler. My big thing with crystal litter is that it doesn't clump. I can't stand the feeling of walking through stray litter on Laura's. Our mission here is to crack cultural mysteries.
And what's happening to podcasts counts? The platonic ideal of a podcast, like what most people imagine when they close their eyes and envision one, has changed so much in recent years, going from an audio to a video format. But as we set out to crack this mystery in our usual fashion, researching and reporting and interviewing experts, we found it hard to behave like neutral observers. You may or may not be aware, but our show is not a video podcast. After the umpteen staff meeting devolved into an emo conversation about our big Mike Envy, or you know what it means to make a non-video podcast in 2026, we decided to try something different. This episode is largely a conversation between me and Evan Chang, our supervising producer.
And we really let ourselves get into it, our feelings, our anxieties, and we did it in part on video, the format that's vexing us so very much. So today, on Decodering, we are embracing our inner chat show to ask, what the f is a podcast anyway? In 2002, Ryan Wedding was an Olympic snowboarder at the top of his game.
Ryan's style is really gutted and gold. And in less than a minute, it slipped away, but he continued to chase the high. Ryan James Wedding, he controls one of the most violent drug trafficking organizations in this world. I'm Michelle Shepherd, and from CBC Podcasts and the Toronto Star, the most wanted Olympian, available now on CBC Listen and Everywhere You Get Your Podcasts. What's happened to podcasts is not some overnight thing. Whatever that they are now,
they evolved from somewhere. And we realized that we could lay out the history of podcasting by talking about our own personal histories. That how Evan and I each got into podcasting as a window into how they started, how they got bigger, and how they've changed. And so that's how we're going to begin this story, you know, by talking about ourselves. So Evan, like how did you get into podcasting?
Well, I didn't see out podcasting, but I got into it. I planned to be in radio, or that's what I fell in love with with radio. I mean, I first discovered radio as a kid. I remember as like a fifth sixth grader having like, you know, a clock CD radio in my bedroom, and I would listen late at night to like whatever I could find, like old time radio from the 30s and 40s, like suspense or the Whistler or Dimension X. Adventures in time and space told in future tense.
There's like a pivotal moment for me. I discovered during my like late night surfing of the airwaves. Have you heard of Word Jazz? I've heard of him. I've heard of Word Jazz. I'm not really sure.
Yeah, no, I didn't. The word jazz. Stare with your ears. So Ken Radeen was this classic Chicago guy, and he would do this kind of like beat poetry on top of these sort of strange ethereal soundscapes. Everything about how something begins could be this radio show. It would be this. It would be
anything. And I would listen to this, and I was honestly super creeped out by it as a kid. Like I didn't know what was going on, but at the same time I found it so mesmerizing and like felt like enveloped by it. That's sort of the moment I think that sort of expanded my idea of what this medium could be that it's like really can contain anything. Any kind of weird sound art, like just the possibility of radio came clear then. The thing that I did as a kid is I recorded
radio shows like set tapes. Like I would pretend to be like the news. So like there's something about it. I was liked, you know, but I never was like I want to be a news anchor. Like you're a radio guy. But I didn't like plan to be a radio person. Like you thought you were going to make
movies. Yeah, like many like a teenager like filmmaking. Yeah, I'm going to be a director and writer director. And then you were like, oh no, that's wrong. I don't want to make movies. I want
to make radio. Yeah. Why did you decide you wanted to make radio instead? What happened? I went to film school when I was 18 thinking that's what I was going to do. And like your freshman
year in this film production, conservatory training, you don't touch a film camera at all or like a video camera. You don't make any motion pictures. You have a class on photography and you have a class on sound. And it was in the class on sound where I just sort of felt at home. It just felt right to me.
Yeah. And part of it was just like it was so immediate. Like I remember we had one assignment where we had to make this kind of like audio drama thing that was set in a diner. So I remember going to a diner with like a classmate and we just sat eating a meal for an hour and a half in silence, holding a microphone like total weirdos, just collecting the ambient sound of like the tables and the dishes and the knives clinking and people chattering away. And then we use that sound that we recorded and sort of like underlayed it underneath like the dialogue of your corridor of actors. Like you
listen to it. It's like, yeah, that sounds like we've transported you to a diner. And that's just so easy to do in a sort of logistical sense in the way that like making a film is not. If you want to make a film send a diner, you have to like get permits, rent out a diner, you got to get lights and a crew and money, but with audio with radio like in terms of making it like you could just go do it. You can just go do it. Did you feel like you were giving something up by not having people see like the visual
part? No, the opposite. I think that there are such advantages to radio, not just the quickness of it and the immediacy, but it's you know, it's sort of the cliché, but it's the theater of the mind. Like there's a radio drama adaptation of Lord of the Rings like we're up listening to, the BBC made in the 80s that I still think is far and way better than the Peter Jackson movies, partially because it's like, I want to imagine what these hobbies like I want to imagine what Mordor looks like. I don't want the CGI to like dominate my own imagination. It is the visions of it. But even the more
sort of documentary, you know, space, not just like fiction, I think there's a lot of virtues to just having sound and not having images to distract you. Like in an interview, I think there's so much communicated in people's voices, just like hearing the way they falter, the way they take a breath and gather their thoughts like that communicates so much that I think that having the image of them just like keeps you from picking up on those clues. It's funny. I think about like on entertainment tonight, you know, like there's a most banal interviews with celebrities that have ever existed, but kind of because you can see them. It's not that boring. I love that there's a new Star Wars movie
on the biggest green possible that audiences can experience together and have and I don't know a new generation of movie goers. But it is actually not boring. Like it's like in a weird way where like the video is like, oh, I have something to look at. So on the one end, the video is like doing the work of making it interesting. But it's also totally papering over that it was like a nothing burger. Right. Totally. And I think that does lead to a different style of interview where you
actually probe and ask questions that are not just banal. And that's the point, I guess, is like it's not like poor man's TV. It is its own craft, its own medium that is durable. And in the early years of the 21st century, right when Evan was falling in love with the craft of radio, the technology to make and distribute radio was radically democratizing. It started in the late 1990s when the MP3 made it possible to condense previously huge audio files into something much smaller. Then came the RSS feed away to push those vials to lots of people
at the same time. Suddenly anyone who wanted to could make audio and distribute it over the internet. In 2004, a columnist writing in the Guardian gave this new kind of audio a name, a portmanteau of broadcast and the relatively new MP3 player known as the iPod podcast. And it's kind of like an I think unfortunate accident that we got stuck with this name podcast. Like it's not even the last one he went and he just wrote that a bunch of possible names.
Like what do you call this new thing of people putting audio online? But somehow that stuck and still with us long after the actual iPod. It's been gone. Got an urge to speak your mind and reach an audience? Well, you might want to think about creating a podcast thousands of people already have. Podcasting is spreading all over the internet.
But it was really exciting because it just suddenly opened up this kind of utopian vision of what the internet could be that was like, oh, now anyone can get audio to other people that we can create new things. There's no mediators, there's no gatekeepers or you can reach people around the globe. Podcasting's difference is in who can produce programming and when and where users can listen. Just about anyone with a computer, a microphone, some basic software and a topic can create a podcast. But I think what's really interesting and important is that at that moment, what they were referring to as a podcast was all sorts of things. It wasn't limited to any particular kind of genre or form.
It was just like the idea of audio on the internet, which was like a novel thing. So some of it was kind of just sort of an extension of blogs. People were just basically bloggers who were doing kind of talk radio self talk radio professional just like diary posts, but also just weirder things too, like field recordings. Not just for sort of amateurs. It also was exciting for actual radio professionals too, because like now your actual terrestrial broadcast radio show, you could put it online and reach people who didn't live in your local area, you can reach people around the globe.
Or also, and this is what really drew me to podcasts, it just made it more convenient to listen to radio shows on demand. I was in college, I couldn't reorient my whole life around getting back to the dorm to make sure I heard the new episode of Radio Lab. It's like the VCR of audio, like whatever the DVR. But look right, you weren't going to make a point in viewing to listen to your radio show necessarily, but now you can just take it with you. Right, I listen to it on my iPod, on my walk to the quad.
Totally. So I mean, okay, so we're sort of like the mid 2000s, right? And podcasting exists, it has a name, it's starting to be a thing people have heard of, but it's pretty eclectic. And insofar as like if you're a normie, like me and you've heard of a podcast, it's probably a radio show that's like distributing itself also as a podcast. It's like Radio Lab or this American life. It's like something where it's like, this is a radio show and now we've made
it so you can listen to us whenever you want. Right, I mean, I'm curious, did you listen to podcasts in this era when it was first starting to become like a buzzy thing? I mean, I was definitely, it's very hard to remember what was going on. I was a print journalist, I was not in audio. I was like aware of podcasts, like, so it started making the political gap best in 2005, culture gas in 2008. Honestly, I can't like, did I listen to a podcasting in the entire 2000s? I can't be
sure. I think probably, but it could have not happened, you know, so I think really podcasts like percolated to another level when it started for everybody else in America, which is when serial happened. It's kind of a cliche, like how much in these conversations about podcasts and was like, then serial happened and it was like a giant changing moment and you're like, oh no, but it was, that's what happened. From this American life in W.B. E.C. Chicago, it's serial. One story
told week by week. I'm Sarah Koenig. Serial comes out 2014. It's basically a spin off of this American life, a venerated public radio show, but their big thing was like instead of telling, you know, small stories on their broadcast that exist only as like 115 in the chunk, they could spin. They could serialize it. Like, can you tell a serialized story in a podcast and have people like
show up from episode to episode? Like, can you generate audience? Can you keep people and turn out hell yeah, especially when you do it, investigating a murder in real time, like, it just really clicked with people and people, as we know, people got obsessed with it and podcasting just jumped from being like a weird, buzzy, but kind of niche thing to a thing that's being literally parodied on SNL. I'm Sarah Koenig. On December 25, 1999, a small boy awoke in Baltimore, Maryland. He went down to his
living room and found a nerve and in the years after serial, a slew of new ambitious narrative series like it were launched, but all sorts of podcasts drafted off its cultural breakthrough. From the New York Times, I'm Michael Barrow. This is the Daily. The New York Times debuted its flagship news podcast, The Daily, in 2017. It soon inspired new series from The Washington Post, The Wall Street Journal, and yes, Slate. Long-running series like
Mark Maron's WTF were suddenly awash in new attention. Maron was now even able to get then-President Obama to stop by his garage. You're like a big cheese man, man. You can't pretend like you're just some- What do you mean? Can I go on pretending?
You can't pretend like you're some- Well, then you're a little guy. You're not big-time. Meanwhile, true crime shows like My Favorite Murder and Crime Junkie were getting off the ground. Bill Simmons founded a new network of sports and culture shows. Actresses from the office started recapping the office, and in 2018, we started decodering.
From Slate Magazine, this is Decodering, a show about cracking cultural mysteries. I'm Slates TV critic Willa Paskin, and every month I'll take a cultural object. Let me back up and ask you. Yeah. How did you decide to get into podcasting?
I was a print journalist. I was a TV critic. I had always wanted to be a TV critic since I was new what a critic was. There's certainly since college, but I'd been obsessed with TV my whole life. But I was getting bored of television.
It's really hard to stay impassioned about a medium when you're a critic, and TV was structurally changing. There was just the air of peak TV. There was so much more television. They weren't just sending you an episode. They were sending you 10, because there were like the earliest of Netflix.
I had kids suddenly having to watch 10 hours of TV films. Burd and some and not like an incredible perk. And also I was just sick of like real people. You watch what you're interested in. You don't just watch things because they're premiering.
I was like, I don't want to watch these things that I don't want to watch. I want to watch what I want to watch. And I was feeling exhausted with it. And I think also at the time, journalism has not been in a great state for a long time. You're always as a journalist.
You're like, oh, what are we going to do? It's a thinking industry where we're all trying to get on the last ship. And then you look around and you're like, what happened to the mid career? Where are all the 50-year-old journalists? They shoot old journalists?
Where do we go? And you're always thinking, what's going to happen to me? And so podcasting did also seem like it had, maybe this is a lucrative way or a financially stable or growing way to do the kind of journalism that I am interested in, which is like, Chewy has ideas, is reported, all the things. And so I just was able to basically convince late that they should give me a show. And I think this sort of speaks to the chaos and looseness of the time, which was sort of like, yeah, sure.
Okay, like, yeah, try something. And I had zero audio experience, a lot of you experience. I guess my question is when you started, did you think of a podcast as a particular genre or genre? Certainly the thing I was interested in doing was fully what I now recognized to be, like the this American life school of podcasts. I was like, I want to make a narrative podcast that looks like these other ones.
You know, I think in my mind, that's what a podcast was, like, extremely crafted narrative shows. So I think this is the key distinction that sort of explains some degree what's happening and why I feel differently from other people, maybe about this. I think that for many people, the definition of the word podcast is a definition that's centered around genre. And that what genre that refers to it has shifted, it's never been a singular genre or really didn't start as a singular genre. There's a few genres.
For me, podcast was always completely genre agnostic. A podcast could be anything as long as it was sound, the same way that radio has been anything as long as it sounds. But as many different types of shows as there were, one format did accrue the lion's share of prestige, narrative. Shows like In The Dark, S-Town, and Missing Richard Simmons were sparking cultural conversations and winning awards, and podcasts like Dirty John and Homecoming were being picked up for glossy TV adaptations. Suddenly, being a podcaster is an actual potential job.
There's a whole new industry that never existed when I first started thinking about working in radio, like, yeah, you can just be a podcast maker and never have anything to do with broadcast radio. There were all these new jobs in podcasting because there was new companies devoted to making podcasts, companies like Gimlet, an narrative podcasting outfit founded by public radio veterans not long after the premiere of Serial. Gimlet was a startup, the kind of company that's supposed to provide investors with an exponential return. And in 2019, it did just that when it was acquired by Spotify. Fresh off announcing that it made its first ever quarterly profit, Spotify also revealed a big bet on podcasting. The streaming services buying podcast companies, Gimlet Media and Anchor FM,
price tag, are reported $200 billion. In 2020, Amazon purchased the narrative podcast studio Wondery. Spotify made even more acquisitions snapping up the ringer network and the Joe Rogan show. And these are just the most high-profile deals. The business of podcasts was flush, growing, and brimming with cultural cache.
You know, I was working in public radio, but at that time, at that moment of 2018, when it really was peak of podcasts like buzzing as an excitement, I started to feel a little bit embarrassed to tell people that I was a public radio producer because public radio felt conveyed a kind of staging. It wasn't cool. It wasn't cool. And podcasting was cool. It was cool.
I felt like left behind because I couldn't say that I was a podcaster. And then things started to shift. It's not that podcasting stopped being cool exactly. It's that what became relatively cool is a certain kind of podcasting. One, the totally upended the medium.
All that when we come back. Not dropping jack, keep it moving. Whoa, beautiful new Kia EV5. Thank you. It's so quiet.
Family must love how spacious it is and you must love skipping the gas pumps. Sorry, others are waiting, so large touchscreen, available on-wheel drive, tons of cargo space. Lady, wait your turn. Get more of what matters to you with a new Kia EV5. ckia.ca for details.
Kia. Movement inspires. Welcome back to Fresh Matters where we discuss matters of freshness. I'm the grossier you with cat from Metro, cat! Your produce is impeccable.
We have high standards. We meet as custom cut on site to my very delight. Yep, it's important that we- And the big goods? More like baked grates. Fresh in store every day.
So at Metro you would say fresh. Matters? It does. Fine, fresh meals and deals at Metro. At Capital One, we don't just use technology.
We architect it. Our teams have true end-to-end product ownership. Shipping distributed systems at scale. Right here in downtown Toronto. That's technology at Capital One.
Search technology at Capital One Canada. So before the break we were talking about how the 2010s sort of starting post-serial is this kind of like feverish, exciting, economically fertile, creatively fertile boom time for podcasts. And specifically for this sort of involved obsessed over reported high touch narrative podcast that like if you went up to someone on the street and were like what's a podcast that'd be like it's serial or one of the many shows that sort of was started in serial's image. And it's all like going great. We get to start to go to rig.
There's all these jobs. People want to be podcasters. It's a cool hip thing to do. It seems respectable but like edgy. It's all great.
And so obviously things have changed. Indeed. Podcasts are still extremely popular. They're maybe more popular than they've ever been. They're more salient than they've ever been.
What exactly a podcast is, like what people close their eyes and imagine a podcast, has changed quite a lot though. And I'm curious like what do you think, how do you explain what happened? Like what has happened since then? Well, I think what happened was that the dreams, the economic dreams for what podcasts could be were never going to be fulfilled. They were a mirage.
The idea that all these shows were going to be the new serial was never something that could have happened and didn't happen. There was only one serial in terms of there ever being one show that like everybody was talking about in culture that like dominated the conversation. Instead, you had a bunch of new shows, a glut even of new shows, that were in the serial model or innovated in the form and they were good. And they had good audiences. They were successful by most metrics.
But that success didn't actually translate into like financial viability. I would think about it almost this way. It's like serial and sort of startup culture around podcasts. Like made it seem like podcasts could be movies. They could be things that made money the way Blockbuster movie made money.
And that was like the draw. They're not all going to hit. But like when they hit, you're going to make a lot of money. When really, I think the economics of narrative podcasting is much more closely aligned with journalism. And anyone who's in journalism will tell you like, it just doesn't, it can't make money.
It's too much work. It's too much effort for what it is. You know, you see like rich guys buy magazines because they want to make like, they're going to do like serious magazine journalism and they always are like, let's start the clock until they realize like they too will lose money and get bored. And the economics of narrative podcasting are much more closely aligned with that. With like, this just being like, you can make something really good.
You can make something that breaks even. You can make something that people listen to. But you can't really make something that's like 10 acts on your investment. Listening back to this, I hear myself skirting something important. When I say serious journalism can't make money, that wasn't always the case.
For decades, newspaper and magazine journalism absolutely did make money. And they largely made it from advertisers. Then along came tech companies like Google and Facebook. Basically the greatest advertising services that have ever existed. Able to target a brand's potential customers with unprecedented accuracy.
By the late 2000s, they had accrued enormous power to decide what kind and form of stories their users would actually see in search results and on social media feeds. And though they were directing their users to lots of journalism, they were taking almost all of the ad money that had once funded such journalism for themselves. Hundreds, if not thousands of local newspapers and magazines went belly up as a result. And online outlets found themselves constantly chasing algorithmic traffic to say a float. For a little while though, in the mid to late 2000s, there was one segment of the industry that seemed to be bucking this terrible trend.
Podcasts. Podcasts were the last great hope for serious journalism supported by ads. Ads from mattress companies and meal prep startups. And famously in the case of serial email newsletter services. Support for serial comes from mail.
Mail. Mail. Mail. Chimp. But in the early 2020s amidst larger economic headwinds, advertising for podcasts began to dry up too.
The shows that felt the consequences of this first were the ones that were the most expensive to make. Short run narrative series listeners were getting for free. Lotted end-to-11 narrative series lost their funding, shows that could scramble to become more appealing to advertisers by publishing more often, as we did in 2024. Coming out every two weeks has worked for us, thankfully. And we feel fortunate because believe me, not all of our peers have survived.
Four years after spending over $200 million to acquire gimlet, Spotify folded the company altogether. Last year, Amazon decimated wonderie. Ad money in podcasts has continued to contract, and the money that has stayed in podcasting tends to go to formats that air consistently and often. There are podcasts that can make quite a lot more money. Chachos and interview shows and things that are easier to make, and people also love.
And so it's like, oh, we've been looking in the wrong place. For money. There are podcasts that really can make their creators tons of money can make the companies. Make them a lot of money. Like there's really money here.
It just wasn't at all in what we thought it was in. Right. You're Joe Rogans. You're call her Daddy's. What is up, Daddy Gang?
It is your founding father, Alex Cooper. We call her. But also this whole crop of celebrity shows that are like actors talking to their actor friends, or comedians talking to their comedian friends. That Mark Merrin and Joe Rogan had sort of pioneered in a sense, but now you just take people who are way more famous than Joe Rogan. They were hilarious, like they had to do it because they weren't that famous.
They were de-listed, like washed up de-listers kind of. They proved themselves, they clotted it now. Like, any people are on all these people that have shows. Right. Hello everyone.
Welcome to another episode of Good Hang. We have a comedy legend on today. And so what you get as the 2020s are going on is like, oh, stops them on the street. What's a podcast? It's not cereal anymore.
It's a chat. It's Bill Simmons. It's a comedy show. You know, like it's all these sort of like much more interview-based chat show. Like a famous person.
Just like a more casual hang. Right. But I don't think that narrative podcast listeners ever lost their appetite. Partially, it was because people liked podcasts so much that we made thousands of them. And like the audience became super fragmented, which was I think inevitable.
But like the total number of people interested in this stuff, I don't think really diminished. To push back a little bit. I think the thing that did become clear. And I feel this myself as a listener is that whatever it she wants scratched by a podcast, like whatever is going to satisfy you, whatever is going to be fun to listen to, you're going to learn stuff from or just like have something to listen to, or watching the dishes or driving the car or whatever it is, it became clear that a cheaper, more consistent, less worked over podcast could actually kind of like deliver a ton of those pleasures. Like I personally, like when I started listening to podcasts, I was like, I don't understand shows at all.
Like I really don't get it. Like I want to only listen to like narrative shows. That's all I listen to. And at some point, you know, it took years. But I was just like, oh my God, this is so effortful.
Like, yeah, I just want to hear some people talking. I was like, I think it's interesting. And it's like, there's something really generative about that. Like when you listen to a conversation, your mind is actually in a place where you're like listening to a conversation. Like you're like ready to jump in, you know?
And I'm not saying that the audience for narrative podcasts disappeared either. But I don't think it's just like the money men were like, this isn't worth it. It's like, it turned out that you can do a lot by doing just a little less. All the stuff we've described happening in the world of podcasts was already causing narrative podcasters, like yours truly, some soul searching discomfort. But I surely would have had the decency to keep my professional navel gazing to myself if not for the existential development that has ratcheted my anxiety way up.
And that's the arrival of video. The practice of simulcasting the same show on both video and radio goes back a long ways, like all the way back to the very early days of TV. Howard Stern aired his radio show on E starting in 1994. Don I missed it the same on MSNBC. Plenty of sports radio shows got shown on cable too.
And podcast wise, it's been going on for a long time as well. Some of the very first podcasts ever, like before they were called that, also featured video. Joe Rogan started streaming his show on video in 2009. Yeah, how's the quality? Sound video wise?
Does it sound alright? Can you see us alright? Still, as YouTube got bigger and bigger over the 2010s, the YouTuber and the podcaster were mostly separate. It related categories. They really started to change in 2020 when the pandemic hit in a new crop of celebrities and comedians stuck at home decided to give this podcasting thing a go.
And they didn't mind being on camera. And so they were happy to start their podcast with video and put them on YouTube. Basically what happens is Spotify realizes in its quest for attention that it is competing with YouTube. Like it's not just competing with like Apple iTunes. It's like, oh wait, the streaming service that people are spending a huge amount of time on is YouTube.
Like that's our competition. And YouTube is like, oh, Spotify, you want to tangle? We can also play this game. We have all this content. We'll give our creators the option to call their video also podcast.
And like a lot of YouTube creators are essentially like, okay, cool. Like we'll be podcasts too. Like we had a video, we talked like we were happy to be both. We're happy to be everything. And YouTube becomes sort of like the biggest podcasting platform in the world.
According to the latest data from Cumulus Media, YouTube is now the number one podcast listening platform with Spotify and Apple Podcast in third place. This actually has huge ramifications for podcast creators. In a moment, I'm going to give you five key reasons. It's time to consider adding video to your show. Up until this point, whatever a podcast was, like it was mostly supposed to be audio.
Like it wasn't video. That kind of was definitional. And suddenly that definition has just been like poofed. It's gone. Right.
It's for me, the definition that I always had going into it, which was like an evolution of radio is completely gone. Even sort of the RSS feed component that's gone to, an also important thing, the YouTube shows and channels that are now calling themselves podcasts that now everyone is calling podcasts. They are a particular kind of show. It's really, really limited to those kind of chat shows, those interview shows and those chat shows. And then layered on top of that, what's happening simultaneously, continuously is a rise of social video.
It's the popular app taking over social media, short and punchy videos uploaded to TikTok. TikTok's biggest competition may come from Instagram Reels. It has incorporated many of TikTok's core features, including that endlessly scrolling feed of short videos. TikTok and Instagram Reels arrived in 2018 and 20, respectively. In just a few years, they made short videos, meant to be watched on the phone, the stickiest and most viral format of all.
And video podcasts proved to be a natural fit. So much so that in the last few years, most people encounter podcasts and particularly ones that are new to them not as podcasts, but as a video clip, a couple of minutes long flitting across their social media feeds. And if you're encountering a clip from a podcast on your phone, how do you know it's even from a podcast and not some other kind of content? Well, you know because the podcast clips set themselves apart by having a very specific look. People sitting on chairs and couches, talking into large mics, mics that are not strictly speaking, necessary.
We developed decades and decades ago, a way to hide the microphones. And that's- That's what newscasters- So newscasters and talk shows- Yeah. TV talk shows. And actors and all that. Actors, they wear lavalier mics.
That was the whole thing for many years, was like, how can you hide it so it becomes as invisible and unobtrusive in the shot as possible? So like the microphones, these big microphones in front of podcasters, the ones in front of us now, in a video, they're really dysfunctioning as props. They're just there to fulfill that expectation of that trope. It makes sense how we got to this look. People had always been making podcasts while sitting on chairs, talking into big microphones, not bothering with lavalier mics because no one was seeing them.
But when they started filming, that's what there was to put on camera. And this was distinctive. So distinctive that at some point it became almost definitional. How do you know it's a podcast? It's got that mic.
And that's opened the door for all kinds of things from the Pete Davidson show to CNN, to kitty litter ads, to the AI dogs we mentioned at the top of this episode, to lay some kind of claim to being podcasty. What do you think the word podcast or like this visual trope is communicating? Like why bother? It communicates at least a fiction that this is off the cuff and casual, that you're just sort of like hanging out with people in their living rooms, in their basements, in their garage. But like the truth of it is that it is just a trope.
The Pete Davidson show is like a professional production. You know? So about the Pete Davidson show, specifically like when I think about what being a podcast does there, it communicates a couple things to me, kind of like authenticity, like the willingness to go there, to say outlandish things, to not be a stache, it's like television show. But I think it also communicates in a nice way, like lower visual expectations. Like the Pete Davidson show actually looks like pretty good.
But I think when you hear podcasts, you're like, I'm not expecting something slick, right? I'm expecting something kind of like pared down. And I think right now, like that is like all very appealing to people, like these like unfussy, more authentic, less, you know, not mainstream media, basically. Right. But again, it's just the illusion of it.
Like how can you say it's authentic when it's just a fake podcast for a cat litter company, right? Or when you're sticking it in front of Anderson Cooper, just for the heck of it, even though you don't need it. Like this is true in every medium, but like chasing authenticity is a trap. That's all true. But it's like it is sort of working, right?
Like maybe we're going to look back on this moment and be like, Oh my God, that's so 2025, 2026. But it is for right now. I think it is working enough, where it's just like, Oh, I see what you aspire to be. What you're aspiring to be fake as it is, is something like a little less fussy and that's appealing. It's just like funny to be like this idea, like, Oh, maybe like this thing that we've been doing is passe.
So what are we going to go to a video chat? A TV talk show is public access TV from the 90s. Visually looks exactly the same as public access TV from the 90s. And I think that's totally great. I love public access TV from the 90s, but like we're acting like we've invented some new form with a TV talk show that just happens to be on YouTube.
And like that's not new. It's just even more conservatism than we had in the previous areas of public radio and commercial radio constricting. If you look at music, they're basically two companies own all the radio stations, and they all have the same playlists in every city. And then the public radio sphere, which is where I come from, you have your own kind of conservativeness, which is that there was never any room for anyone to break through. Like if you wanted a new show, you want to do something new, there's just no room on the schedule anywhere in the country for the most part.
And that was the promise of podcasting. It's like everyone can get past the gatekeepers who are so narrow in thinking what these things should look like. We can keep on experimenting, keep on taking the format in new directions. Now we're saying even podcasts can't be expansive. They can't be all these things.
They can only be video shows that were two people talking with big microphones in front of them. That's what drives me crazy. It's like the age old story of every new medium is that inevitably the conservative forces take over, conservative in a small city. And we just sort of settle on one or two formats that the masses seem to like enough and that are cheap and easy to produce. Whatever words you use, like we're kind of converging on some universal form, right?
We're sort of heading towards this moment where all content and content is a gross word, but everything everybody makes is getting very samey. It's all supposed to be able to be viewed in a video format on your phone. So all of this stuff, like television, online video, audio, it's all blabbing into this one thing. And so you can have a conversation that's similar that we've been having about so many different mediums, right? Like you could be making movies and you'd be like, I'm worried.
It's all going to turn into like, Christopher Nolan aside. It's all turning into like short form reels. Or like, I make television and I'm also worried about that. Or like, I make social media and I'm really trying to make that. Because that's the only thing that's going to pay me.
Like it's all kind of like converging into the same kind of looking thing that's kind of like trying to do the same thing, which is really just to get your attention for a short period of time. And like that sort of sucks. Like just not because people aren't even happy with it. It's just like for those of us who would like a little diversity or would like to make sure that people are still trying to do weird things or not even weird things, but totally normal things but in forms that have their own languages and their own codes and their own like histories. Like that's a bummer.
And it's not just a bummer in a theoretical way. When we come back, we get as far into our own belly buttons as we can go. But all this means for us. Now more than ever, quality matters. But so does Price.
At Marshall's, you don't have to choose. You can get the good stuff for less. The stuff that lasts. Because there's no point in tightening your belt. It's just going to break when you do.
Get the good stuff in store at Marshall's today. For most of the history of professional sports, there was a wall between the game Then suddenly it was everywhere. Ontario is all in on sports back every moment more. Fans but that wasn't supposed to include the players themselves. For ever sport, Jotay Porter is under NBA investigation athletes are the perfect gamblers.
Understood the big bet. Find us on CBC Listen or wherever you get your podcasts. So we've talked about the history and the present of the podcast. But so much of what is animating our interest here is the future. What does all this mean for podcasts in general?
But yes, for sure. What does all this mean for us? If Decoder and could just become a video podcast, maybe I'd feel differently. Palmer, Jiller, pumped about this whole video thing. But it's not that simple.
For something like Decoderang, for us to make video, it's not just something inter-chatting, it's like we would essentially have to make a documentary. So that would mean totally like cutting the interviews differently. It would mean having to go out and get footage for all the moments and we don't have something exciting to show you. Yeah, we had to put a lot of b-roll on screen, which is like often just unnecessary. It's just like to put up something, destroying a bunch of graphics animations.
Maybe that could be fun, but it's also incredibly time consuming. And we wouldn't be able to put out the number of episodes we do now if we had to do all that stuff. Right, and it's like, would it really improve the show? It's like we'd almost have to break it apart and like totally we can see it. And actually there are YouTube shows that I think are doing something, like even a good version of what we would look like if we were to reimagine ourselves as video.
So what's going on? Why is there all this contradictory information? Is moderate drinking good or bad? Here at Howtown, we investigate where information comes from. The joke is they are not podcasts.
Like they are YouTube shows. Like they don't say their podcasts. Because they're not two people who have a conversation. That's what I find so scary and disheartening is that we completely redefine what the word podcast means, which find, I don't care about, I have no investment in that stupid word. But what I'm worried is happening is that we're redefining our show and shows like it.
And the shows I want to listen to out of existence. There is no new word that's come up to describe the kind of stuff that I want to listen to. And as a consequence of that, that stuff is just not going to be made period. I think the thing you said about genre, that for you podcasting, or radio with genre agnostic, and like I really understood podcasting as sort of like a genre specific is helpful because it sort of explains why through our security roots, we've ended up in a similar place. I'm just feeling like freaked out.
Because for you, it's like, okay, I'm agnostic about the genre, but like, I know radio isn't video. So now we're trying to do video and like all the expansive sound things, like this sort of forecloses adventurousness in that sphere. It just like makes it about video. And for me, I'm like, oh, the pivot to video also like forecloses on the genre of podcasting that I was like the most interested in. I think maybe where I feel more, this is also explicatory of why I feel like a little bit more tortured or like less sure than you is like, I think you're like, no, sounds really good.
Like we should we should be making cool radio things. And I'm like, oh, is the genre of like the narrative podcast like a hill I want to die? Like is that really even the best way to do it? Like I'm not sure that it's really better, more fun, more interesting, more illustrative than a chat format that does lend itself to video. I can see I can really see the virtues of the chat format.
And I the thing I most care about is like the thinking is like the idea is the argument. And so sometimes when I hear the chapters, I'm like, oh, like, if what I want to get across is like a way to think about a thing, like am I even doing it the right way? Well, first of all, I don't think radio precludes thinking or com- Of course, of course, of course. That is like a thing that we do too. We just steal a lot of things to something that's digestible and fun.
Yes, but are we saying the thing we want to say to the most people? I think there's lots of people who like give it up. You lose some things in doing it in a chat way, but you gain an audience, you know? And I hear people talk about this sometimes who are very like matter of fact, where they're like, yes, the kids are somewhere else that people are on YouTube. Like you can feel any way you want, but if you want to reach the most people, like, get on board and maybe that's not wrong.
Like maybe I should be like, okay, this is what it is. I want to express myself to all these people. Like I should do it. The difference for me is like I'm invested in the medium itself. I can't just chase like the next thing, the next avenue to reach the most people.
I want to make radio. So if this all goes belly up, if it all completely implodes. You'll be making radio on the ashes? No, I don't know. But that's the thing.
It's like I can't just like move on to the next thing. I can't, I would have to like really start, I'd have to learn a whole new thing. I need to become like a pipe fitter or a plumber or something. I don't know what I would do. Yeah.
I mean, to be clear, like having done this, like I am aware of their, like the effort and the labor that go into making the polish thing requires so much more research and reporting and honing and thinking that the idea you end up with at the end, the ideas you end up with are so much better formed. They're so much sharper. And I appreciate that. Like it helps me understand what I really think about something. That's what writing those two, right?
And you can't have that in a chat show. But in so far as yes, like I want to talk to people, I am not wedded to the way that we're doing this, particularly. But that also makes me feel like you have a lot of clarity. I wish you wish you wish. We've been going back and forth about how to finish this episode.
We were worried that ending with me sounding so ambivalent might seem like some implicit announcement that I'm over making decodering. But I'm not. Not at all. I'm not ambivalent about our show. I love making it.
I love making it the way that we do. I love finding stories that have been forgotten about and getting to go all investigative reporter mode to track down the people who lived through them. I love talking to people who always, always remember things a little differently than how they've been written about in even the best books. I love that we find out what so many others think and work and write through it all to figure out what we really think. I love that we take the time to fit everything together just so so that if we did it right, it sounds effortless.
Like it just had to be the exact shape that it is. What I am ambivalent about though is this moment. It's such a confusing and strange time to make a podcast, let alone one like ours. Are we supposed to keep doing exactly what we're doing and maybe get stayed and lose our audience? Are we supposed to totally change?
And if we're supposed to find some middle ground, how can we figure out how to change the exact right amount without giving up the things that we care about and that make us distinctive? That's what I hear listening back to Evan in my conversations. That I don't yet know quite how we're supposed to navigate all of this. And I hope that ambivalence is one it is okay to leave you with. We're not going anywhere, not would.
But now you know the mystery we're trying to solve all the time. The mystery under all the other mysteries we take on. Not what's the best way to be a podcast in 2026. But what's the best way? If we're lucky to keep on being this one.
This is Decodering, I'm Willapaskin. You can watch video of me and Evan talking about all of this on our show page. Be kind. And while you're there, please sign up for Decoderring Plus. One way for a podcast like ours to be less reliant on the whims of the ad market we just described is with the support of our listeners.
If you sign up right now through October 16th, you get 50% off for the year. You'll be supporting the show directly in a way that truly matters. You'll also get to listen to the show without any ads. Get unlimitedreading on Slate.com and so much more, including exclusive access to every episode of Decoderring's Back. Our latest Decoderings Back is about something you have surely noticed, but perhaps never really noticed.
It's the collectible souvenir spoon. Like who came up with this idea? Who came up with the idea of we're gonna sell spoons to people? It just seems weird. Why would you buy a spoon?
All that for just $59 by going to Slate.com. dCoder plus and entering the promo code Decoder50 at checkout. I want to thank Amanda Dobbins, Leonnei Fack, Nick Qua, Ben Richmond, Amber Robinson, Susan Matthews, Mary Harris and Neil LaBelle. This episode was produced by Max Friedman. Decodering is also produced by me and Evan Chang, our supervising producer.
Merit Jacob is Senior Technical Director. Our intern is Phoebe Mulder, Video Production by Michael Phillips. If you have any cultural mysteries you want us to decode, please email us at Decoderring at Slate.com. You can also leave us a message at 347-460-8281. We'll see you in two weeks.
You keep on talking about Chachos being less fussy and effortless. This is like an endurance test to make them. We will learn that Chachos are really hard. We take it all back. Now more than ever, quality matters, but so does Price.
At Marshall's, you don't have to choose. You can get the good stuff for less. Because there's no point in tightening your belt. It's just going to break when you do. Get the good stuff in store at Marshall's today.
Welcome back to Fresh Matters, where we discuss matters of freshness. I'm the Grozier, here with Cat for Metro. Cat, your produce is impeccable. We have high standards. We meet as custom cut on sight of my very delight.
Yep, it's important that we- And the big goods? More like baked grates. Fresh in store every day. So at Metro you would say fresh. Matters?
It does. Fine, fresh meals and deals. At Metro!