Skip to content
Snooki and the Handbag episode artwork

Jul 10, 2018 23 min

Snooki and the Handbag

from Hidden Brain Hosted by Hidden Brain Media

Look down at what you're wearing. You picked out that blue shirt, right? And those sandals — you decided on those because they're comfortable, didn't you? Well, maybe not. Researcher Jonah Berger says we tend to be pretty good at recognizing how influences like product placement and peer pressure affect other people's choices...but we're not so good at recognizing those forces in our own decisions. We talked with him in December 2016.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Snooki and the Handbag

0:00 23:42
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

This is Hidden Brain, I'm Shankar Vedantam. Many of us like to think that we're not affected by peer pressure. Come on! What's your problem?

Great. We believe we're independent thinkers, that our choices are our own, that our values and preferences are inherent to our personalities, not the whims or wishes of others. It turns out, reality is a bit more complicated. Everywhere in life, at work, at school, in a big stadium with thousands of other people, at home in the privacy of our own bedrooms, it turns out our behavior is shaped by the judgment, norms and actions of other people.

Sometimes we can feel these influences, but more often than not, they're so subtle, we don't even notice their existence. Today we bring you a favorite episode from 2016 that looks more closely at how these forces act on us. At DID Electrical, we know getting a new appliance is genuinely exciting. A fridge with more space?

Trilling. A washing machine that's actually quiet? Even better. This weekend only, at DID Electrical, buy selected Samsung large appliances and get 10% back on a DID rewards card.

Plus enjoy 5 euro delivery and half price installation on all large appliances right now. The DID Electrical for everything you. Iriner Therein wishes to advise customers that this Saturday, Sunday and Bank Holiday Monday, the Northern Rail Line between Dublin, Connolly and Drahdae will be closed for essential works. There will be no dark service between Connolly and Malahide or Hose.

A limited bus service will operate between Drahdae and Dublin. Thank you for bearing with us as we deliver improvements and ensure a safe and sustainable rail network. For full details, see irisrail.ie. Iriner Therein is part of the Transport for Ireland Network.

The Bank Holiday is finally here. Enjoy Summer Saver's Act Central with great offers. Like Central Fresh Arts, Triple One's Day, two pack only 8 euro offer in Sunday. Selective Pringles 165, Grand One's 75 each.

Dye Coke and Coke Zero 12 Compact only 6 euro each plus deposit. Bank Holiday Value Sorted. Sentra. Live every day.

Joanna Berger is a marketing professor at the University of Pennsylvania. He is the author of the book Invisible Influence, the hidden forces that shape behavior. Joanna, welcome to Hidden Brain. Thanks so much for having me.

Companies often pay celebrities to hawk their merchandise, so I often see athletes wearing clothes with a Nike swoosh. Tiffany apparently once paid Anne Hathaway $750,000 to wear its jewelry at the Oscars. But a few years ago, you tell the story of how Abercrombie and Fitch made an unusual offer to the stars of Jersey Shore. What was that offer?

So you may remember the Jersey Shore, sort of a bunch of early twenties folks, lots of fake tanner and big muscles. Listen to Juicy and clothes just started coming off, so we decided it was fun. And one of them was a guy named Mike the Situation Sorrentino, and he was called the Situation for his famous abs. You can hate on the all you want to, but what can you possibly say to somebody that looks like Rambo pretty much with a shirt off?

And Abercrombie and Fitch sent him a letter offering to pay him money. And that by itself is not unusual, right? As you mentioned, product placement is a major thing that the companies often use. What was interesting about this letter though was they weren't offering to pay him money to wear their clothes.

They were actually paying him not to wear their clothes. And it turns out he wasn't the only Jersey Shore cast member who had a recent run in with a brand, another cast member Snooki. She was the short one you may remember who's been termed as looking like a parking cone because she wore so much orange fake tanner. She got a free handbag in the mail.

And obviously again, sending a free handbag makes sense. Brands may want to send it to her because she shows up in people magazine or in touch and because she's wearing it. Other people might wear the brand. Except she got a Gucci handbag, not from Gucci, but one of their competitors.

And so why would a competitor send her a free handbag? Why would Abercrombie and Fitch offer to pay Mike the Situation not to wear their clothes? And it turns out, influence is very much like a magnet. We often think about attracting doing the same thing as others.

But just often repels us and leads us to the opposite. And the idea here is, well, if Mike the Situation is wearing Abercrombie and Fitch, maybe other people aren't going to want to wear it anymore. Or if Snooki's hanging onto a Gucci handbag, maybe that'll help their competitors because no one will want to wear Gucci anymore. So we need to understand how socials with the tracks, but also how repels.

UN CHIPEE that Stanford University ran a similar experiment some years ago. And this one involved wristbands walking through what you did and what you found. This is one of my first studies that I ran early on in graduate school. You may remember these yellow, strong wristbands.

They were for Lance Armstrong's Livestrong Foundation. And they came out. They were people quite interested in them at the beginning. And we sold them to a group on campus.

So we knocked on doors. We said, hey, we're raising money for cancer awareness. We buy one of these wristbands and wear it for a dollar. Most people said yes, they were more than happy to wear it.

We followed up a week later to see if many people were wearing them. They were so deep people wearing the wristband. And then we did something interesting. We sold them to a dorm next door.

And we wanted to see, similar to this example of Mike the Situation Ring Abercrombie or Snooki Carrey Gucci handbag, how would people feel when other people they didn't want to be associated with, started wearing the band. So there's a dorm on Stanford campus, sort of known as the geeky dorm on campus. And basically we went next door and we sold these wristbands to the geeks. And so the question was, what would those original wristbandwares do, the people that like the wristband that were wearing it all the time, do once the geeks started wearing it?

And sure enough, as soon as the geeks started wearing it, about a third of the people in that initial group stopped wearing it. And they stopped because they didn't want to be associated with the geeks. Once those geeky folks were doing it, they didn't want to do it anymore. So what you're really saying is that one really effective way to get people to buy your brand or buy your product is make sure that the people they despise are buying other brands.

Is that what you're saying? A little bit. Yeah, we often think about sort of aspirational identities. So Abercrombie shows people that we might want to look like in their ads.

But we think a lot less about what might be people want to avoid, right? We did another study with health behaviors showing people actually avoided binge drinking in college when we associated with an identity that was undesired for them. And so it's not just about associating things with desired behaviors to get people to do it. It's also about saying, well, how can we associate undesired behaviors with undesired identities and use that to avoid people doing the wrong thing?

One of the interesting things about the entire field of social psychology, and you talk about this at some length in the book, is the idea that people don't see themselves as clearly as they see other people. Or they see themselves in their choices differently than the same choices made by other people. And part of that is the access we have to the reasons that we bought things. When we look around, we see lots of people doing similar things.

At the end of the day, we're all pretty similar, right? Most of us are not like Lady Gaga walking around in a meat dress. Most of us are wearing shorts and t-shirts, jeans and a collared shirt, dress pretty similarly, which I have similar cars, we buy similar things. And so indeed, when we look around, we see a lot of people acting similarly.

And we see influence and assume it's happening. When we look to ourselves, though, we look to our introspections. We don't just say, well, what did I behave? What did I do?

But we look for evidence that there's a reason that we behave that way. And because when we think about it, well, I don't think I bought that card of fit in. I wasn't sitting there going, I really want to keep up with the Joneses. You thought you bought it because of price or you thought you bought it because you liked how it looked.

So you don't think it affected your own behavior, even though at the end of the day, it actually did. You tell a story in the book about a friend of yours who's a lawyer, and he has some strong views about younger lawyers and their BMWs. Yeah. So I was writing this book, and I was talking to a good friend of mine who's from Washington, DC, and they happen to be a lawyer.

And I was telling them about social influence, and they were lamenting the impact of social influence on their peers. And they were saying, God, all DC lawyers are the same. They make it big, they become partner, whatever it is. And they go out and they buy a new BMW.

And I said, well, that's interesting. But aren't you a DC lawyer? I said to my friend, don't you drive a BMW also? And he said, oh, yeah, yeah.

But they all drive gray ones, and I drive a blue one. And I was sitting there going, OK, I guess. But what I love about that story is two things. One, again, we see influence.

My friend could see all the other people driving very similar cars. Except when that light shone on his own behavior, he couldn't see it. Then it was invisible. There the influence was invisible.

But second, it wasn't just about doing the same thing. It wasn't just about buying the exact same car. And it wasn't about being completely different. It's about being similar and different at the same time.

And so there are many flavors of influence that often invisibly affect our behavior. One of the interesting ideas you explore is that social influence can have implications for innovation. Because it suggests that if we're shaped by those around us, then an idea that in some ways is too far ahead or too different from the norms that we see around us might have a difficult time getting adopted. Can you tell me the story of the 1899 invention known as horsey horseless?

This is an amazing story that I came across while doing for research for the book. And it turns out that when automobiles came out, it's hard to remember that in today's day and age where we see automobiles all the time. But when they first came out, they were very scary. People had never seen a non-horse driven carriage.

Imagine this thing sort of almost like a ghost rolling down the street by itself. No horse pulling it, no person pulling it. People in rural areas called it the devil's work and band it from town. And so people were trying to figure out, how do we get this thing adopted?

Obviously saved costs in a certain way. There was a huge amount of manure on the street. So getting rid of horses was good in some ways. They could travel further.

How could they get people to adopt this new innovation? And what's interesting is the challenge wasn't a functional one. It wasn't that the product didn't work. It was a psychological one.

The product was fine. But they had to overcome it feeling too different. And indeed, it's a little bit like Goldilocks and the Three Bears, if you think about it. One end is too different.

Something's too different. It's scary. We don't want to adopt it. It's too far away.

That's what people are doing. People don't want to adopt it. Why do I need to change my behavior for something that's exactly the same? But in the middle is just right.

It's what might be called optimally distinct, if you will. And so going back to the automobile, this inventor came up with a really interesting idea to solve this problem. And he'd come up with many innovations, including a desk for students and a sort of a leg cast to help people recover after injuries. He said, God, if the problem is psychological, I have an idea.

So he came out with this innovation called the horsey horseless, which is essentially taking a fake horse head and putting it on the front of an automobile. And you look at this thing and you say, why would a fake horse head be anywhere near useful in helping people adopt an automobile? But what it did is it made the different feel more familiar, made it feel more similar. It was just a fake horse head, but it made it look like these vehicles that people were used to already.

It made horses feel more comfortable, and this thing pulled up next to them at the stop sign or the stoplight of the day, if it were. It made people feel more familiar with the difference. And so this idea of optimal distinctiveness is really important, not so different. If it's so different, people are scared.

They don't want to adopt it. It's scary. It's new. It's, you know, why do I want to do this thing?

Same if it's too similar. But in the middle, it's optimally distinct and much more likely to catch on. So as I was reading this section of the book, I started thinking immediately about driverless cars and the concerns and trepidation that many people have about cars that seem to drive themselves. I mean, talk about, you know, ghosts in the machine.

And you know, I was thinking about, you know, people sometimes have these mannequins that sit in the car with them to give people the impression that they're someone in the car with them. So if you're a woman driving through a city street at night and you want to give people the illusion that you're not alone in the car and you're maybe less vulnerable to crime, you have this mannequin sitting next to you. And I realized what we should do is take the mannequin and put the mannequin in the driver's seat. And if you did that, that's essentially going to be our version of horsey horseless.

It's almost like a taxi driver. It's a mannequin. I love that idea. I mean, I'm not sure if I should write to Google and Uber and suggest it.

I think, but again, you're thinking really quick about it. A driverless car doesn't have to look like a car. Right? I mean, if all it's doing is getting us from point A to point B, why does it have to look like a car?

Why does it have to have steering wheel? Any of these things. But part of it is not just the function. It's the psychology.

Does it feel safe? And having someone, even if it's a mannequin sitting in the driver's seat, might make us feel more comfortable. Coming up, we're going to explore how invisible influence affects the way we think about politics. So the simple idea here is it's often party over policy.

Even the same policy, even the same actual thing, we interpret that thing based on who's supporting it. Build a beautiful store, write with AI and manage marketing, inventory and shipping all in one place. Join millions who trust Shabbathai to launch and grow their business effortlessly. If you're ready to sell, you're ready for Shabbathai.

Turn your big business idea into sign up for your one euro per month trial at Shabbathai.ie. Go to Shabbathai.ie. It's time to see what you can accomplish with Shabbathai by your side. Every day.

Okay Frank, back it up. Keep coming. Go through. Go through.

Frank just got himself a new Kia EV2. He loves everything about the car. How it looks, how it drives, its class leading range and its highly impressive spec. Back back back back back back back back back back back.

In fact, the only thing Frank can get used to is how much bigger it feels than it actually is. Go through. Discover the EV2 for yourself at your nearest Kia dealer Kia. Movement inspires.

This is Hidden Brain, I'm Shankar Vidantam. We're talking today with the University of Pennsylvania's Jonah Burger. Most of us believe we come to our political views after careful thought and consideration. But there's been a lot of recent social science research that shows that our views are heavily shaped by social context.

Even when it comes to our understanding of the facts, we're biased by the thoughts and opinions of those around us. I asked Jonah Burger if this was part of the world of invisible influence. A colleague of mine did a great study a few years ago looking at exactly this. So he gave both liberals and conservatives a number of different policy propositions.

So one was about helping disadvantaged people, one was about taxes, a bunch of different policies. And he told them that those policies were either supported by Democrats or Republicans. What he found very much along the lines of what you just mentioned is that when conservatives saw policy, the same policy, if they thought that policy was supported by conservatives, they loved the policy. They thought it was great.

They supported it, even if it was a welfare policy, even if it was a generous welfare policy, the fact that conservatives seemed to like it, the fact that they were told that other conservatives later supported it, they thought it was great. They thought it was terrible, though, if that same policy, that same liberal welfare policy was supported by liberals. Oh, the liberals, they're always doing this helpful stuff for welfare. I'm totally, totally against it.

Same policy, completely different reaction. Liberals did exactly the same thing. When liberals were told that policy was supported by liberals, they loved it. When liberals were told that conservatives liked the policy, they hated it.

So the simple idea here is it's often party over policy. Even the same policy, even the same actual thing, we interpret that thing based on who's supporting it, right? Based on the identity signals. And this actually happened to me just a few months ago.

So I was doing a consulting project with Messaging for an organization that wanted to help clean energy catch on among conservatives. And clean energy is something that they thought conservatives would support. After all, it saves tax dollars, reduces the size of government, all things that conservatives should like. Yet, when they surveyed conservatives, they found that conservatives weren't supporting clean energy.

And so they dug a little deeper and they found that there was a clear reason why. When they asked conservatives, particularly conservative leaders, why conservative leaders weren't supporting the policy, they said, oh, yeah, clean energy, solar power, wind power, oh, isn't that something that Al Gore likes? And if Al Gore likes it, it's probably not for me. And what's so interesting there again is same policy, right?

Yet the mere fact that it was associated with a prominent liberal like Al Gore made them not want to do it. And so we really need to think about the politics, not just of actual politics, but the politics of identity. What does it mean to engage in a certain behavior? What does it signal about me to do something or not do something?

And how can we use that to help people do better things? I mean, there are a lot of political scientists who talk about our affiliation with political parties as being very analogous to our support for various sports teams. So I'm a devout fan of a football team. And of course, every year the players on that team change.

It's completely rational to support the team when all the people playing for the team have changed. But that's a famous line from Jerry Seinfeld. You know, what we're really doing is we're rooting for laundry. And at some level, we're doing that with politics too.

I mean, what we're really doing is we're rooting for laundry. I love that phrase, rooting for laundry. And certainly, you know, that's part of it, right? Part of it is it feels like a team identity.

There's also some information there, right? There's this notion that God, if a lot of people that I feel similarly to in the past is like this and support this, I'm going to like it and support it too. Right? If I walk by a restaurant and there's a long line out in front, I assume that restaurant must be better.

Same thing with politics, right? I mean, the party views change, but everyone still thinks it's that same organization that they know and love, sometimes they end up following the wrong thing. You know, a few months ago, we cited one of your other studies on Hidden Brain and had to do with the likelihood of winning basketball games and what the score was at halftime. I absolutely loved the study.

Can you tell us how you came to do the study and what it found? I used to be a soccer coach. And this is where it actually came from. So I went to a graduate school in undergrad in California at Stanford.

I loved soccer growing up, and so I decided to become a coach. So I coached AYSO, sort of the little league of soccer. Coach is generous, by the way. I was basically sort of shepherding 15, 12-year-old boys and trying to stop them from fighting for an hour and a half twice a week.

But we'd run drills and we'd try to get better and hopefully they learned one or two things along the way. But when it came time to games, I noticed something weird. We were a good team. We weren't the best team out there.

We were a good team. But when we were behind at halftime, we always seemed to figure out a way to win. So if we were down by a goal, we'd win two won. We'd win two goals even.

Sometimes we'd win. We'd win two to zero. We'd win three to two. We'd always figure out a way to pull it out.

And other times, if we were tired or we were ahead, we sometimes figured out a way to lose. And so I was just trying to figure out, God, what am I doing wrong? If we can come from behind, shouldn't we win all the time? And so with a friend of mine, a colleague of mine named Devin Pope, he's now at the University of Chicago, we went out and got tens of thousands of professional basketball games.

We had a bunch of NCAA games, a bunch of NBA games. And essentially we looked and said, OK, how does the score at halftime relate to the score at the end of the game? So how does a team of ahead or behind it halftime affect whether or not they win or lose? Similar to my youth soccer team, it's hopefully a little more data.

And interesting, by the way, hopefully a little more motivated. If you're an NBA player, you're getting tens of millions of dollars based on your performance. So you might say, OK, if you're a 12-year-old kid and your coach sort of controls you and encourages you to play harder, you're more like a win. But it shouldn't matter for NBA players.

It's a real big stakes whether they win or lose. They make more or less money. Of course, it doesn't matter there, right? So that's what we wanted to look at.

And so we looked at the data. And similar to soccer, we saw something really interesting, which is there was one place where being behind was actually a good thing. And that was being behind by just a little bit. Teams that were down by one at halftime, they weren't more like it to lose as everyone else would have been if they were behind.

They were actually more like it to win. Teams that were down by one were more like it to win than teams that were up by one. Even though they were worse teams, down by two points relative to the teams that were up by one, they had to score more to win. They came out, they played harder in the second half, and they were more like it to win the game.

And so being behind can be motivating, but only if you're behind by a little bit. If you're high by too much, you give up and you're more likely to quit. So I have to tell you, Jonah, that it's been a little more than a decade since I began learning about many of these studies and ideas. And I was really taken aback by many of them when I first came by them because I think of myself as being a very rational and deliberate and intentional person.

And the idea that my own actions or beliefs or judgments were being shaped by these factors that lie, many cases outside my conscious awareness, was sort of a really disturbing idea to me. I have to say what's interesting is that at an intuitive level, it still feels to me that all my decisions and judgments are conscious and intentional and deliberate. I don't feel the effects of social pressure except that you look at the mountain of evidence and you have to say if it's affecting all these other people on the planet, it must be affecting me as well. And I feel like one of the great values of this body of research is it might prompt people to a certain degree of humility of saying, yes, I feel very strongly about the political party I support, I feel very strongly about the sports team I support, I feel very strongly about my beliefs, but it's just possible that maybe these beliefs are actually shaped by these other factors and I might want to be a little humble about the things that I think I know.

I'm wondering as you've looked at this body of work, what's been the effect on you personally? What's been the effect on your personal life as you look at all the ways in which human beings are shaped by other people? You know, you read this literature and you do some studies in this literature and you can almost have an existential crisis. You can say, God, I'm not making any of my own choices.

Other people are making all these things for me. Is there no free will? Am I just a mindless automaton? Take a great example and this is something that always struck me.

Think about the person that we marry or the person that we end up being our long-term partner or relationship partner. We all have the sense that they're perfect for us. We all have this belief in true love and that we're finding the right person out there that completes us, that the one person who shoe perfectly fits, the one person who will make us whole. And yet, is that right?

You know, is it? There's a one person out there and we just have to find them. Are we suddenly being influenced by our environment? Do we like them because we saw them more often and so we got exposed to them more and so mere exposure leads to liking.

Were we influenced by our environment or do we really make our own choice? And for a while, I think personally that was something I struggled with a lot. Think about, well, do we really make our choices and if we don't make our choices, what does that mean about who we are? And I'm not sure I got to a perfect answer honestly, but I think where I ended up is influenced by itself is neither good nor bad.

It is just a way of life. It is a thing that helps us make our lives easier. Imagine if we had to make every choice by ourselves. We couldn't use any information from others.

We couldn't figure out what book to read or what movie to see. If we moved to a new town, we couldn't figure out what car mechanic to go to without looking at an online review. We had to just figure it out by ourselves. Life would be extremely difficult.

And so along the way, we've evolved to take advantage of social information, to use others as a heuristic or a shortcut to judgment, to make it easier to live faster and easier than it might be otherwise. Does that heuristic always lead us to the right answer? No. There are many cases, some of which we've talked about where other people lead us astray.

Yet, most of the time, influence is a valuable tool. And so I think the more we realize it's a fact on us, the more we can spot it in the environment around us, the happier and healthier we can be. We can't fully control it. It's going to be there all the time.

But the more we understand it, the more we can take advantage of its upsides and avoid its downsides. John Barger, I want to thank you for talking with me today. It's been a pleasure having you on Hidden Brain. Thanks so much for having me.

This week's episode was produced by Tara Boyle. Our team includes Jenny Schmidt, Partsha, Raina Cohen, Thomas Liu, Laura Corral, and Aditi Van Le Moody. Our unsung hero this week is Dana Farrington. Dana's an editor at NPR and helped us a while back to interview candidates for a new position on our show.

Dana's thoughtful feedback and calm demeanor helped us pick the right person. Thanks, Dana. For more Hidden Brain, you can find us on Facebook and Twitter. And if you haven't given us a review on your favorite podcasting app, please do so.

It really helps others discover the podcast. I'm Sean Carvietantham, and this is NPR. Go to Shopify.ie. It's time to see what you can accomplish with Shopify by your side.

Sometimes your search for a new home can feel like it's going nowhere. But every month at AIB, we help hundreds of house hunters become homeowners. Our specialist mortgage team are on hand to help you every step of the way, moving mortgage applications to mortgage approvals, changing can we, until we can, and turning hoping into owning. Because we don't just help.

We help make it happen. Apply for your mortgage today. Online, in branch, or on the phone. AIB for the life you're after.

Aladdin, SPC and AIB mortgage bank you see are regulated by the Central Bank of Ireland. Movement is great for your heart, but if you move every day in May, it could be amazing for everyone's heart by raising vital funds for the Irish Heart Foundation. Your pace, your target. Register now at moveinmay.ie and get a free T-shirt.

Move every day in May is supported by your local Macaulay pharmacy.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Hidden Brain?

This episode is 23 minutes long.

When was this Hidden Brain episode published?

This episode was published on July 10, 2018.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Hidden Brain episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.