Skip to content
Social Media - Never Read The Comments! episode artwork

Sep 30, 2021 44 min

Social Media - Never Read The Comments!

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

This week we turn to two burning issues around social media. The first being the now toxic environment for journalists on twitter and we also look at the fall out from Dylan Voller defamation case. Our host Monica Attard was joined this week by Kishor-Napier-Raman and Michael Roddan.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Social Media - Never Read The Comments!

0:00 44:03
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome to Fourth Estate, a show about journalism. We're coming to you from 2SCR in Sydney on the Gadigal lands of the Eora nation, right across Australia on the community radio network and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. I'm Monica Atard. This week, the NSW vaccination rate has passed 86% for the first dose and the roadmap out of lockdown has become clearer for our two most popular states.

Having a clear path and a sense of purpose certainly does remove many worries, but not much of it has appeased a large section of social media which remained a quagmire of ranker and dispute. Following Lisa Miller leaving Twitter altogether and Lee Sails' a stinging takedown of much of what passes his discussion, we ask what's happening in our digital town square. And whilst we're on the subject of social media, we'll also take a look at the implications of the Dylan Vol and Defamation case and just what it means if many media companies are forced to shut down and comment. Joining us today via Zoom is Kishore Nappi Arahman, Politics reporter for Crikey and Michael Rodin, who's a senior company's reporter for the Australian Financial Review.

Kishore and Michael, welcome to Fourth Estate. Okay, thank you both for being here today. Let's set the scene. We've had long drawn out lockdowns, riots in the streets of Melbourne, the French haters.

So far, this hasn't been a fantastic year. A lot of people's frustration is being expressed on social media, which for me at least has been a really disheartening place to be this year. Have the two of you felt that social media and Twitter in particular in recent times has become a less hospitable place for journalists in particular? Kishore, we might begin with you.

Well, I mean, I questioned whether Twitter was ever a particularly hospitable place for anyone, but definitely I think we're seeing a situation. Yeah, look, probably. I mean, you would expect something to worsen when we've all been indoors for 18 months and we've all been slowly going insane, well, most of the last 18 months. Yeah, I think there's definitely a situation where it's melted people's brains a lot of the time.

It is the sort of place that rewards things like snark and tribalism, which of course leads to a place that is not particularly pleasant. But at the same time, you know, if you're in the media, you sort of feel like there's this endless pool to keep you on there. So you really exposed a lot of the nastiness. I think one of the things we've definitely seen though, recently, in particular, this year is just sort of a reflection of the broader community anxiety around sort of the way out this pandemic around things like reopening, around things like lockdown.

And that has led to a very sort of, I guess, quite tribal Twitter experience. And I think that's probably one of the main reasons this means a toxic environment. Michael would be questioned, I guess, in terms of what we're seeing on Twitter, is it just that people are going stir crazy from being locked up for so long? Or are we, as many people fear, seeing a quarsening and calcification of political debate that, for example, we saw happening in America some five years ago?

Yeah, I think it's interesting. And it's not just like an immediate thing that's happened in the last one or two years or something like that. I remember like Twitter, a lifetime ago, a decade ago, it was mostly just gags and a few links. Maybe there was less people on it.

It was a bit more of a more engaged group of people. But it was just sort of there for ridiculousness, entertainment. And slowly over the last decade, it's sort of, everything has become sort of politicized on that platform. And not only is that really not fun, it just means that anything that you utter is used as an attempt to play to your own side.

And it's not just left and right, but it's any sort of cause that you can imagine. Everything's being picked apart. And it makes sense. Everyone talks about the democratization of the national debate.

It's a good thing that more people are able to put their views out there and see how they go. I think just the problem with it is that we look at Twitter as if it's sort of like this representative thing, or it might be like sort of innocent like Facebook. But journalists aren't being influenced in the way they behave by what their uncles and aunties are posting on Facebook. But they are being influenced by what the same people are posting on Twitter under different pseudonymous names.

Is that because they're being criticized? Is that what you're saying? That the criticism of them is forcing them to take a different stance in their journalism? I think you'd be kidding yourself if people thought that they didn't think twice before saying something or they might tweet something and delete it.

And many people would say that's probably a good thing to think about what you say, think about how they received and everything like that. But then on the other hand, it's not like people are thinking twice about saying something stupid or racist or blah blah blah. But they're also thinking twice about saying things that are entirely defensible within reason, something that you might think that 95% of the population would probably agree with you. But you're saying that you think that journalists are thinking twice about what they post on Twitter in order to avoid pylons and in order to avoid a tech?

Well, as they should. Because journalists probably shouldn't be sharing their opinions online all the time. And I'm as bad as anyone at refraining from commenting on things because it's fun. But I do think that even when you're posting links to stories or sharing information, say from a press conference, you'll go to the Rachel Baxondale in Victoria during their first lockdown.

All she was doing was asking questions at a press conference. And she was just being abused nonstop. And I think that that's a strange way for journalists, a strange environment to sort of the journalists to conduct their profession in. We saw something similar this week with Casey Briggs, Dibbik Kishol, where he was merely posting the latest COVID numbers out of Victoria.

And all of a sudden there was a part on, there was an accusation, there were many accusations that he was taking a stance and passing comment, which seemed like an odd thing. Did you notice that and did it bother you? Look, I think there's a couple of things going on here. The first goes back to what I was saying about people having maybe too much time on their hands and focusing on politics, I think in a particularly harmful way.

I think that there's all this sort of scrutiny on specific journalists and people watching every single ABC News Update and viewing it through, I mean, people always going to view things through a hyper-partisan frame, but for a particularly strange and blink of hyper-partisan frame where I guess almost the political binary gives way to some kind of weird state versus state thing. So you get this situation where anything that is considered negative towards Melbourne, Dan Andrews has seen as some kind of conservative plot and that sort of warps people's perceptions and thank you everything through that lens. I think the other thing to say here is that, I mean, I don't know if it's particularly healthy for members of the public to focus on an independent sort of pick their favorite or least favorite journalists and sort of accuse them of things like bias and that kind of thing, but I think the reason we're seeing that is because people are sort of getting more of a ringside seat into how journalism works than they've ever had before. I mean, we never had this situation where people would watch like five premier press conferences a day most of all, I don't think many of us do anymore, but do you think that kind of critique that's coming from the public from that body of people that we used to call an audience is pushing journalists to take a stand.

Is it pushing them to be more of one side or another? Look, I'll preface this by saying that I think journalists can sometimes be some of the most finskin people in the world. A lot of the time there is this worrying trend I see particularly online of journalists conflating quite legitimate criticism of stories which are often maybe not very good or badly framed or misleading in various ways as abuse and attack. None of this is to condone very real abusive comments that you do see on social media all the time.

So I will preface this by saying that journalists can be a little bit in skin about how they relate to their audience and obviously the demosquitization of this cosyada blurs the lines means they can suddenly interact with that audience. I think that is sometimes genuinely a good thing, right? And it can lead us to sort of maybe interrogate our own biases and whatnot when we're putting a story together when we're doing anything. At the same time, I do think like a kind of relentless stream of just quite frankly weird comments that you get does maybe influence you like.

I mean, some of the most absurd comments I've gotten have just been from writing relatively straight news stories on like Victoria and Dan Andrews last year and getting accused of all kinds of nonsense. You know that stuff's ridiculous and the people who are doing it probably not read beyond the headline. But it still obviously does affect you and it does shape the way you kind of think about what you're thinking about when you're next story and how you kind of relate with the audience and that kind of thing. You'd be lying if you said you didn't sort of influence you in some way but how it does influence you was not always I think immediately clear.

Does it influence you Michael? Well, I've been cancelled more times than I can count. I wrote a story yesterday just about one of these COVID academics and people were sharing it online and saying like, oh, I don't agree with Michael Rodin. I don't like him but this is good.

It's just like, who cares if you don't like me? It's like the stuff under my byline has covered every single topic in the world from every different angle. It's like I don't I'm not like a crusader for anything. I write stories, I print information from where it comes.

It's my personal views or my byline is pretty irrelevant to the story most of the time. I think it one of the issues with the industry at the moment I think is that there are you can probably carve them up into two groups. One would be much larger than the other but one group is very desperate for the adulation of their audience and and their colleagues and the other part of the industry is ambivalent and doesn't mind stirring debate and losing friends and I think that the part that craze adulation is much bigger and that's I think that's an issue because being a journalist isn't about making friends. It's almost about losing them really because are you saying they're Michael that you think that journalists perhaps float too much and blue with their with the audience on Twitter and that they ought to kind of keep it more keep their views themselves, keep their conversations limited or at least nice and pull back a little?

I think the sad thing is that like the more I've seen and people would apply this to me as well but the more I see personal views creeping into online discourse and chatter and stuff like that it does affect the way that I read their professional work and I think it would be hard for anyone to admit that they don't see that. News pages didn't used to have bylines, the economist still doesn't. The bad thing about that in the economist is it's usually written by very young people with a little experience but it has this sort of esteem because it's anonymous and it has this intellectual weight because you can't penetrate into it and it's just like well more often you see on just straight news stories you know a dinkus you know an excellent byline it's very personalized you know the journalist has personalities online and it's just I don't think it's very good for the dissemination of facts. No I didn't agree with you and so what's the solution is it is it just just getting off Twitter?

Well I'm much more productive when I'm not on Twitter but then Twitter is usually a recourse when I don't have anything bubbling away in the back of my head at the moment and the bad thing is it's very useful for lazily following the news you know it's like I can read the you know four or five newspapers in the morning and be very across everything but during the day it's sort of just you you follow the news through osmosis really whether it's the right sort of news or in the right sort of depth you do sort of absorb a lot of stuff you know it's it's it's a prisoner's dilemma you know no one wants to get off Twitter first because you vacate the field and it's like sometimes I feel like you know if I didn't say this one thing then it's just like you know all my feet probably curated very differently to many other people but like what I see just does not reflect a lot of the times accuracy you know or or the full gamut information I think it can be very one-sided and it's sort of you know I'm going to sound like an insane person right now but it's just like you think about what happened with like the Wuhan lab or something like that and just how it was immediately derided by the entire sort of media ecosystem particularly on Twitter because it was it was viewed as uneracist or global warming was a better solution but a better explainer because of humans interacting with animal ecosystems but it's just like we know now that neither origin is fully backed by any evidence you know both equally as sort of probable or plausible as one another and the US sort of intelligence report issued by Biden sort of went to that and it's just like why was the media so quick to judge and corral around this narrative and I can't help but think that Twitter in the sort of the way that it homogenizes these views is part of that yeah and of course that that that caused a lot of mainstream media to have to walk back a lot of their original criticism of the of the lab theory Kishua I want to take you a little to the Lee Sales piece that was run about two weeks ago now which is pretty direct with how she saw the problem playing out recently on Twitter in relation to COVID she wrote you know in the Australian corner of Twitter the space is dominated by views that are militantly prolocked down pro-COVID-zero pro-label premiers and even the tamest of questions in those directions prompts and onslaught I have to say that when I read that I thought that's precisely the way I've read it recently but to underline that point that you know Lisa Miller has been trending on Twitter all of yesterday she's still trending today for us some pretty benign questions about Queensland's COVID case on the program that she co-presence ABC News Breakfast and I think what she said was Queensland is in a state of panic after one COVID case was reported which is kind of insane to attack her for that do you relate to you know to to that kind of idea that much of what we're seeing is simply driven by party alliances and has COVID hardened those kind of parameters yeah I think there was a lot of sense to what Lee Sales was talking about in that piece it's a particular phenomenon and I think I mean I have a theory that this all really sort of goes back around the time of the 2019 election where you had a sort of I think an extremely online kind of progressive labor voter who I think was very shocked by them losing the un-lucable election perhaps instead of reflecting on the weaknesses of the labor campaign or you know one of the million reasons I'm out of loss of election sort of turned and hardened to this narrative that labor lost because the media were again there are some news outlets that have history negative of you of the Labor Party but you know it's idea that this is a whole grand media narrative that screwed over labor and you know ABC you present as well you know it too because they you know wanted to support the Olympics and whatever whatever all of this hardening I think into this narrative of everyone's sort of against the left in the media and I think a lot of those people also sort of rallied around down Andrews as a kind of progressive figure head at the same time now I think this is important to note there's a phenomenon that we're seeing on Twitter but importantly going back to what Michael was saying about you know not everyone being on Twitter most progressives aren't like this they aren't deeply deeply brain poisoned to the extent that they will look at a fairly benign interview on news breakfast and see it as evidence as some kind of right-wing conspiracy in the ABC most people don't mind this ship right they're offline they you know might have opinions on politics but they don't see it in this way so I think this is a hyper-nesh sort of corner of Twitter and I think it's very much true that they there is a sort of you know particular view around things like lockdowns among sort of around how various states have handled the pandemic as well I was really struck by this sort of I think last week there was polling in one of the things and yes I'm sure something showing that there was widespread support for you know reopening part of yourself while I was when the 70% vaccination targets have been hit now a lot in corners of progressive Twitter that is seen as like a kind of you know devastatingly evil thing that will kill thousands of thousands of people yeah and obviously there are like very legitimate debates about when the safe place at what point we can safely open up the country about hospital capacity all those are quite legitimate debates but the kind of progressive group think on Twitter it was quite different from the progressive group think among say my offline progressive friends so yeah there is certainly this phenomenon I think would be very clear-eyed we should be clear-eyed about how marginal on the grand scheme of the entire election it is but it certainly exists and it certainly does tend to dominate the conversation that it's probably why someone like Lisa Miller wanted to take a break. Michael what do you think you think a lot of this stuff on Twitter now is aligned to two party alliances? Well it's a great irony of everything it's just like you know all these journalists are on Twitter you know it used to be you know pretty engaged people whatever and there's this rump of you know it's sort of you know an insane amount of crazy people and it's just like left right whatever it's like the majority of Australia is just like you know tuned out don't care you know neither left nor right well they don't see themselves as that way you know going about their business not engaging in the stuff and the crazy thing that like the the most repulsive thing about the way that Twitter sort of infects the conversation in the media is that it's so irrelevant to our business because you know if you look at the stats on where readers are coming through to our stories and this is you know this is any sort of traditional masthead big website or even the Guardian which is just online it is tiny it's it's not even if all the traffic that came through to those websites via Twitter was ended tomorrow it would be one two percent maybe three if you're lucky sometimes the story blows up on Twitter and you get a lot of traffic through that thing but it's generally like one of those sort of like salacious controversial stories you know that you know kids a number of these sort of like you know sweet spots it tends to pass quite quickly rath it tends to pass most people that engage with the news do so via the home page on a website or the newspaper you know or less and less than you say but most people don't come through Twitter it's people aren't reading it there they're seeing a headline perhaps but the population is so small you know and so it's just we need to stop worrying about what people are saying on the on that website you know and how often it trickles in from like something happening on Twitter you know causing a scandal and then becoming a print story I mean like people who aren't on Twitter just must view this you know with butter you know sort of amusement because it's like oh someone was cancelled for wearing face paint in the Sydney Film Festival and it blew up on Twitter it's like how is that relevant to their lives you know it's like it's so it documents in it like this unreal sort of like online sort of extremism and then it's in the newspaper it's just like this has no relevance to people's lives you know but speaking of people's lives Michael do you think that journalists also have a kind of responsibility on social media platforms and Twitter in particular where there's a kind of more direct interaction with the public to be aware of the anxieties that people might be going through particularly now in these really harsh long lockdowns we're not particularly good at you know we're very self-absorbed and as Kishore pointed out we're thin skinned and we tend to think a lot of ourselves in our opinions do you think that we have a responsibility as journalists to be very aware that people are anxious at the moment and be mindful of that and not feed into that anxiety with the kind of free the free banter and the you know shooting the breeze yeah well this is the thing though it's like the the problem sort of originates from something that isn't journalists shooting the shit on Twitter it's like we have been soaked in covid news the last 18 months like absolutely drenched it's unreal and I don't think that any other nation in the world would have had as much saturation as coverage as we had here and you've got to think that the fact that it wasn't sort of buzzing around the community has just increased the sort of like the level of anxiety about this unknown sort of virus floating around whereas you speak to like I speak to my friends in you know North America and Europe it's just like everyone's sort of just going about their lives normally you know covid's there but it's not dominating every minute every day as it is here and it's like people still it's still a boogeyman that's unknown even with the current outbreak you know it's like it's still hard most most Australians would be hard pressed to know someone who just had it still you know because it is such a tiny fraction of the population that's contracted it and then an even smaller one who's become violently ill or hospitalized or you know got a bit dead so it's it's a problem that I think the media has exacerbated because there's been nothing else going on and we sort of interrogated every single line like of anything like the press conference is being trolled over any data point has just been like like insanely sort of picked apart but the media is to blame for that is it not? Keisha only where the one's the media is the one who's obsessing about the the the issue and the numbers and the future and what it looks like well I mean it's probably a bit of a rubber assault right like the media keeps pushing out these stories in part because I suppose there's a belief that that's what people are interested in reading about and that kind of thing but in terms of I think dealing with the broader anxiety I think a lot of that anxiety doesn't necessarily come through you know what people are doing on set and saying online and when it comes to journalism exacerbating that I think we probably have to think carefully about how we frame covid stories and what kind of you know headlines we run and that kind of thing like you know I just don't see how stories which are consistently maybe you know pushing the goalposts and warning about future hypothetical things that could happen even when we're very well vaccinated or you know warning us about the possibility of more more variance and more lockdowns into next year I don't see how that helps with people's anxiety frankly I think that that does terrible things to the broad collective mental health of the community.

Yeah they're valid stories. I agree I think they are valid I think that you know there has to also perhaps be a sort of understanding of where the media does come into sort of exacerbating people's anxieties and those kinds of things so yeah I don't think there is necessarily an easy answer when people are also obsessed with covid news and you know also club dynamic you have got this situation where normal people are watching 11 o'clock press conferences every day for some reason and so I mean yeah sure maybe we are a little bit to blame for that but if something I don't know how we necessarily extricate ourselves. No it seems like a very kind of circular problem that we've created. I can say that on the weekend I tweeted a story from the Financial Times written by an Australian journalist who talked about the normalization of covid in Great Britain and I got trolled for three four days to the point where I just had to kind of walk away from it and it just seemed to me that we are perhaps in a situation now where people don't want in Australia that people are not interested in covid being normalised in journals talking about that but they do want those you know that constant drip of coverage that catastrophises.

Do I don't think that we have put that into that? That's sort of like the issue with the politicisation of everything because you know I think that like I think I'll say the media but you know it's probably it's not the media as a whole but there's a real problem in our national discourse where you know you have to take sides on something or if you do have an opinion it represents something so it's like if you're pro-lopdown pro you know like elimination it's like it's a left-wing progressive you know like hard left sort of thing whereas if you're like you know open up you know let business do it at once you know so you're right-wing you're like you're an evil right-person and it's just like it's not the case it's like there are positions that you can hold that don't have anything to do with your political persuasion or even you know looking at anything on a left-right sort of scale but it's just it was just adopted and I think that it sort of really damaged everything because you look at the way that like people view you know what happens in Victoria versus what happens in New South Wales and there was this really partisan debate on it and it's just like wait a minute it's like a global pandemic the government can only do so much and ideologically it can only it can do even less you know and it's like it governments can only do so much to sort of mitigate this thing and most of it comes down to luck and that was the problem with like the media sort of blaming Dan Andrews for the first outbreak last year it's just like well you know there are probably worse on problems in hotel quarantine but like at the end of the day it's a virus you know it's like it's tiny it's microscopic the government can't control nature as much as we would like to think it does and it has nothing to do with ideology and so it's like this is all that break we are now it's just like again it's just like you could have seen that and it's just like we've invested way too much belief in the power of the government to do one thing one way or the other in this and I think that like the deluge of information that we've been given we could have just kept it at high level you know it's like you know keep it distance be sensible you know use a common sense get vaccinated for the love of God get vaccinated as soon as it's there with whatever they're giving you and you know we would have been in a remarkably similar position that we are in now okay look I'm going to move you both on at this point to the issue of Facebook another platform that we love to hate this month for media lost an appeal to the High Court over the Dylan Volo defamation case involving comic made but made on a media Facebook page by a member of the public and he's short the media company and not the poster nor Facebook are now responsible as a result we've seen CNN announce that they are locking their pages from being viewed in Australia that has you know that decision both by the High Court and by CNN has it does pose particular problems I think for the Australian media can I ask you both what are you hearing what are your thoughts do you think that Crickie AFR might actually be looking at this internally and panicking slightly? Isha? Oh well I wouldn't say anything.

Well yeah of course we're looking at it with with um keen eye as much in the way that we looked at it when the Facebook Australian publications um offline a few months ago I'm forcing for forgotten that um look in terms of this decision I would say the reasoning that the courts took was obviously that the companies were trying to obtain commercial benefit by putting stories on Facebook and therefore they bear some legal consequences and that given the state of defamation law in this country it was probably legally speaking applying the law as it is the correct decision um I do think maybe courts need to have a little think about the sort of broader ramifications of a decision like that but um you know I would be so let's look at those broader ramifications. I mean media outlets simply don't have the resources to please those social media platforms do they not at least not around the clock and if it goes lucky enough to have those resources do they want to spend them that way but also is there a possibility that you kind of get a two-class system of media here where small players lock everything down while larger players get to rule the social media roost? Yeah I think the first thing to unpack is to try to work out just how important and valid we think Facebook comments on stories really are um I mean I think often more often than not in fact you're a bit of a cesspit um just like just as what we're saying about Twitter um and the discussion of them is not particularly productive obviously you know Facebook does who's trafficking there are a lot of normal people unlike Twitter are actually on Facebook and do actually get the news through Facebook um I think one of the biggest problems that I thought would arise when all news was going to be written off Facebook in the first place was this concept of this sort of you know low information news consumer so not the kind of person that's watching press conferences or you know scrolling through the homepage of the paper delivery but the kind of person who maybe stumbles across an article because a friend has shared it on Facebook or you know they've seen a link that's just bouncing to their feeds somehow through whatever wizardry of the algorithm and I hope that person stays engaged with news whether that person loses more engagement because there aren't Facebook comments where they're seeing friends getting tagged or where someone could tag them in something whether that person sort of misses out or consuming the news that's it I think that media companies yeah obviously this is a challenge I think that there is a chance to turn this challenge into some kind of opportunity and actually think really long and hard about what our relationship with social platforms are what our relationships with Facebook are but also how we can use this to maybe move away from Facebook and diversify the kinds of places that we're sharing content on like you know I think young arenas aren't on Facebook like now we're on the edge of their users now they're on Instagram or on TikTok whatever and frankly I don't think most Australian news outlets do a particularly great job at really sharing their stories through those outlets I think there are overseas publications that are sort of a little bit more ahead of the curve on that. Can I ask you Kishol that we're moving social media platforms is that the answer because the same the same ruling would presumably apply?

Yeah I think I mean in terms of stuff like comments I think that's less of a sort of issue on Instagram obviously you have Instagram posts but you've found things like stories and that kind of thing so I mean it wouldn't apply as much to say any Instagram story which is probably a really good probably more effective and engaging way to sort of get readers on site and probably the way people are really relating with a lot of news content on Instagram so I think it does obviously yeah there are challenges if you move platforms. I think it does sort of raise the question of moving platforms and thinking about that with the people's depth and creativity you know look the situation with the media you know where how people sort of get media is refracted through these these these these these tech platforms so it's always going to be a difficult one and it's one that forces media outlets to think creatively and I think you just have to continue to do that. Michael one of the aspects of this is potentially reducing freedom of speech if we lock down comments aren't we simply saying to people you know we really don't care what you think what you have to say should we be worried about that? Yeah I like you know I love freedom of speech but I'm not sure whether the Facebook comment speech is the one that I'm going to die on the hill to defend um the like Kishol said what we actually get out of Facebook comments isn't a lot it's just it's sort of people just arguing with each other the issue as I understand it and you know I'm not fully across this but I don't understand it it's it's if the publisher posts their stories their own page and the comments are found to be defamatory by court that the publisher is liable as in the news publisher but if you know uncle Lou posts the story you know the Sky News video on his personal Facebook page and his relatives and mates comments on it and those are defamatory Sky News is not the at fault in that situation so I don't think that it's going to be a freedom of speech issue at all and I think you know like I'm philosophically opposed to to social media you know as it is I don't think it'll be bad for news organizations to hit the end of comments and just to move forward like at the financial review on our website you know we don't we don't have a place where people can comments at all and we're a different news because it's you know bringing in publication for very engaged people and you know decision makers we obviously have a letters to the editor page where people can engage with the media there but we haven't lost any sort of opportunity I don't think through through not having comments when I used to work at the Australian the comments were you know a continual headache for the business I think that'd be fair to say because obviously you'd have to police them a lot and there was this whole sort of you know operation I don't even think it was local that sort of moderated the comments because obviously we were publishing them to the website and you know if you had a legally sensitive story you would turn them off you know but I think it just opens more problems than it solves a lot of the time if we really wanted the one thing they're good for is for the people to give you information to enhance the story that can be done by your email which is probably where these conversations should be taking place anyway or over the phone the issue is that you know we've created this online replica of the Saturday barbecue and it's just like we don't the news media isn't there to facilitate you know offline or conversations that should be having offline I don't think that's our role so you'll say you'll say then turn the comments off and live with it yeah I don't personally see a problem with that okay sure do you agree with Michael just turn them off and live with it I always breathe a sigh for leaf from comments to turn off on one of my pieces I've got to say you know yeah look at every publication that has comments has the challenges having to moderate them probably harder for a smaller publication to moderate all those comments but unfortunately I read it's a thing to really love them so okay well look I think we'll leave the discussion there thank you both very very much for taking part in today's program it was a fabulous fabulous discussion and let's see what happens on twitter and facebook thank you both thanks Michael cheers on that note I'd like to thank Kishua and Appiah run and Michael Rodin for being on for the state and thanks for listening to the program this edition was recorded at the studios of 2scr and heard across the country on the community radio network for the state is produced with the assistance of the community broadcasting foundation thanks to the foundation for their continuing support make sure you subscribe to for the state on your favorite podcast app so you can hear his top media politics and everything in between we'll be back with more next week but in the meantime you can stay in touch with us on twitter our handle there is for the state au and thanks to our producer Anthony Dottrol I'm Monica Atard thank you for listening

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 44 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on September 30, 2021.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.