Skip to content
Something’s Wrong with Mommy (re-release) episode artwork

Jan 31, 2026 1 hr 10 min

Something’s Wrong with Mommy (re-release)

from True Crime Brewery Hosted by Jill

Please enjoy this TCB premium episode from 2022! You can get access to all of our premium episodes and get all episodes ad-free by subscribing at tiegrabber.com/subscribe From the outside looking in, Shele Covlin seemed like a woman who had everything figured out. She had a handsome husband, two beautiful children, and a high-paying job […] The post Something’s Wrong with Mommy (re-release) appeared first on Tiegrabber.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Something’s Wrong with Mommy (re-release)

0:00 1:10:52
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

True Crime Brewery contains disturbing content related to real-life crimes. Medical information is opinion based on facts of a crime and should not be interpreted as medical advice or treatment. Listener discretion is advised. Welcome to True Crime Brewery, Tiger Ebers. I'm Jill. And I'm Dick. From the outside looking in, Shelly Kovlin seemed like a woman who had everything figured out. She had a handsome husband, two beautiful children, and a high-paying job that she loved. Her marriage, however, was a disaster. Her husband, Rod, could not or would not hold down a job. And he was convinced he could earn a living off of his passion, playing backgammon.

Rod also had a weakness for other women. Over the years he had too many affairs to count. And as if that isn't bad enough, this apparently charming husband and father had become mentally and physically abusive. Join us at the quiet end for Something's Wrong with Mommy. When Shelly finally reached her breaking point, she and Rod separated. Shelly prepared for a divorce and made plans to move forward in life. Unfortunately, before the divorce was finalized, Shelly was found dead in her own bathtub. Was it an accident? Was it murder? There would be a lot of speculation and some fascinating details would be brought to the surface before everything was said and done. So we needed a New York beer and I picked one from Brooklyn.

I know it's the wrong borough, but close enough. So this is Black Ops. It's from Brooklyn Brewing in Brooklyn. It's a Russian Imperial Stout. 11.3% alcohol by Viome. Pretty nice. Delicious, delicious beer. Black, nice thick head, kind of cocoa-colored. Has an aroma of cocoa powder, sweet chocolate, coffee, and bourbon. And a taste of chocolate, coffee, vanilla, and bourbon. It's a big-bodied beer. It's going to warm you up as you drink it. Share this with some friends. Sounds delicious. Let's open it up. All right, Dickie, come on down to the quiet end.

Let's have a seat and talk to the folks, see what's going on. Well, I think we should talk about our story today. Why don't we do that? We could do that, too. So you start us out. I know that you did a lot of research on this, so I'm going to let you go at it. All right, we'll try it. Right now, we'll start with it being New Year's Eve in 2009. In the very early morning hours, nine-year-old Anna Kovlin wakened to the faint sound of water running. Anna was in her mother's bed with her three-year-old brother, Miles. But her mother, Shelly Kovlin, was not in bed with them. So Anna got out of the bed, and Miles was following her, and she walked over to the bathroom. And peeking inside, she saw her mother in the bathtub.

She seemed to be leaning forward, like she was washing her hair. So Anna took Miles back to their mother's bed. Fast forward a few more hours, it's now 7 a.m. Miles wakes Anna up this time, and he wants to know where Mommy is. So Anna returned to the bathroom, and that's when she saw her mother, this time face down, in some red water. So she immediately went to the telephone and called her father, Rod Copland. Rod and Shelly had separated. Rod had moved into a studio apartment directly across the hallway from Shelly's apartment. And even though there was a restraining order against Rod, the parents thought it would be best for the kid's sake to have him close by. I'm not so sure about that, but that's how they were dealing with it.

Right, yeah. Now, he supposedly did not have keys to Shelly's apartment. So when his daughter Anna called him, he said, unlock the door, which she did. Ron ran across the hallway and into Shelly's apartment. When he saw his wife in the tub, he took the kids into Anna's room and told them, stay there, don't move. Yeah, so apparently Rod returned to the bathroom and hoisted Shelly's body out of the water and laid her face up on the floor.

He performed CPR and at 7.14 called 911. EMS arrived within four minutes and they could see right away that Shelly was already dead, likely long dead. She was very pale and rigor mortis had set in. Yeah, so if there's rigor mortis, it's at least a few hours. Yeah, I thought at least a couple. Right. Yeah. But Shelly also had bright red scratches on her lower face and a contusion on the left side of her lower lip. So that was a little suspicious too. That was. And she was pronounced dead at 7.30 that morning.

Now when the police officers arrived, they found Rod in a dry white t-shirt and gray sweatpants. He took them into the bathroom and showed them a cabinet above the faucet that had been separated from the hinges. So he told them his theory. Rod's theory was that Shelly had grabbed onto that cabinet and fell backward when it separated. And then she'd hit her head on the edge of the tub. But this certainly wouldn't explain scratches on her face. No, it would not. But this is not a bad working hypothesis to begin with anyway. Uh-huh. And Rod went on to say that he and Shelly were separated and had a divorce pending. And she had the restraining order against him, but he lived in the studio apartment so he could be close to his kids. And just after 8 in the morning, Hyacinth Reed arrived. Who's that? Hyacinth is the nanny. She goes by Rose. Everyone called her Rose in the household. So she's not a live-in nanny. She's just a daytime nanny.

She did spend nights here and there at the house, but no, she was the daytime nanny. So when she was told what happened to Shelly, she immediately said that it was not an accident. She actually collapsed and told the police that Shelly didn't have an accident. Right, because she knew what the marriage was like. Right. So you can see where this is all headed. Did he do something to her, or was it an accident? That's it. So why don't you give us a little background? We'll talk about Shelly first. Her name is Shelly Mina Daniszewski, and she was born July 13, 1962, in Elizabeth, New Jersey. Her mom was a homemaker, and her dad was a butcher.

Now, his vocation was financially rewarding, but her father, Joel, really didn't like doing the butchering. No. I knew you'd go for that. I wouldn't either. Now, he was quite good at numbers. Actually, he had majored in math in college, so he enrolled in a Merrill Lynch training program and became a broker. One of these American success stories, I guess. I guess so. Now, he had a natural talent for the work, and he worked his butt off, and he was hugely successful. At one point, he managed more than $1 billion in client assets.

That's major league. Yeah. Now, the Daniszewskis had four children. Fred was the oldest, followed by Shelley, Eve, and Philip. Shelley and Eve were particularly close. Well, they were the only girls. That's right. And they were fairly close in age. I think three years apart, two years apart. They liked hanging out with each other. So at age three, Shelley suffered severe burns to her upper chest and upper arms. And of course, she became very self-conscious about her appearance after that.

And for a while, she tried to compensate for this discomfort by binge eating. Also, she was only a mediocre student. And that was in contrast to her other siblings who were also successful. Yeah, they were all gung-ho, excellent students. Work, work, work. Right. So I don't know when this changed for her, but she would end up being successful. And I would say quite lovely. Yeah. Well, after she graduated high school, she matriculated at Pace University in Manhattan.

That's what seemed to do it. When she got out of the home, not that her home life was bad, but when she got out of the home and started her years of college, her anxiety just kind of went away. She lost 30 pounds her freshman year in college, and she decided to accept her scarring as manageable. I mean, a nuisance, but nothing unmanageable could take care of it. Well, you'll just never find peace in life unless you decide you're going to play the cards you were dealt. Right. And that's actually a quote from Mike Ehrmantraut. So I would listen to that. Well, of course, if Mike said it. Yes. So it seems like there was a lot of pressure when she was at home, and that was kind of relieved.

Which got away. You're right. They never said anything like that. It never comes across that way. But that's the impression, right? Absolutely. Yes. After she graduated in 1984, Shelley started work as a broker at Merrill Lynch. And like her father, Shelley had a real knack for finance. She did well, very well. And in a short time, she joined her father's global wealth management team. Later, her brother Philip joined them, too. And they formed a subsidiary group under the Merrill Lynch umbrella. And this was called the Daniszewski Group. Makes sense. It certainly does. But when it came to dating, Shelley was less successful.

Perhaps her criteria were just a little too stringent. And another source of frustration was that her younger sister Eve had found her soulmate and she was already a happily married woman. So Shelley apparently had some misguided idea that because she was older than Eve, she should have been married first. Yeah, something like that. Now, Eve got wakened up late one night or maybe early one morning in February 1998. The phone was ringing.

And there's Shelly on the line. And she announced to her sister that she had met her soulmate that very evening. And the two of them were on their way to Las Vegas to get married. That's kind of crazy. Isn't it? That's a bit impulsive. Yes. And not what you'd expect from this seemingly grounded financial person. Well, see, that's what makes me think he had a real influence over her. If he could get her to do something like that, it really doesn't seem like something she would normally do. Oh, no. There's no question that she was really smitten with him. Yeah. And would do whatever. Yeah, it seems like it. Kind of under a spell, at least in the beginning. Yeah.

Now, Eve did manage to dissuade Shelley of this idea of eloping. Well, basically, because she said their parents would just go crazy. Yeah. They wouldn't like that. It worked. Very traditional family. Yeah. But nevertheless, just six weeks after they first met, they became engaged. Now, at the time of the engagement, Shelley was 36 years old. Rod was 25. So he's 11 years younger. Yeah. And he's pretty young, 25. Yes. I think if she was 46 and he was 35, it wouldn't be such a big deal. But that's a pretty big difference in where you are in life, usually. Yeah. Yeah. We talk about this all the time with age differences. Sure. And like you said, where you are in your...

time of life plays a role. Oh, absolutely. And I would certainly agree that a 36-year-old and a 25-year-old might not be the most compatible mixture. Might not be. I'd say it's something that could be an obstacle, but could work out either way. Possibly. But in this case, it probably was part of the problem. Maybe not, though. Maybe he would have been terrible no matter what. We just don't know. Rod had grown up in New Rochelle, New York, and his father owned a dry cleaning business and later in life became a stockbroker. His mother was a pharmacist. When Rod was a young child, though, he liked to blow up frogs with firecrackers. So there was some disturbing...

disturbing behaviors. His mother took him to a psychiatrist. Yeah, no, I couldn't find really anything that said there was some follow-up on that. This, to me, is a serious enough problem that you'd want to have close follow-up. I mean, blowing up frogs. Yeah, that's very disturbing. She took him to a psychiatrist and end of problem, which I don't think it works that way. Well, maybe not now, but maybe then it did.

Yeah, maybe. Maybe they kind of wrote it off as a phase and he wasn't doing it anymore. I don't know. But I'd be very disturbed by that, certainly. In his early years of brokering Dave, Rod's father worked with his father-in-law. Now, they had a falling out and Dave demanded half of the client lists, which are very valuable. But when this request was refused, Rod falsely claimed that his grandfather had sexually abused him. Now, this must have been something that Rod's dad told him to say? Yes. Because this was when Rod was a child. This is when he was a child, a fairly young child. So this dysfunction goes back a ways. It wasn't just started with Rod and his family. No.

And you're going to see, though, that Rod learned his lesson quite well because he's going to use the same claim against Shelley. Right. And his parents. Well, and it worked with the grandparents because the client list was released to Dave. Yes, got his way. But growing up, Rod did seem to have a lot of quirks. I guess that's a nice way to put it. But they seemed to be balanced out because he could be really charming and win people over. Still, everyone knew he had a pretty quick temper and he wasn't afraid to show it. No, he wasn't. He would lose his temper about pretty small things, right? Trivial things. So he's one of those kids where if he lost the game, he'd throw a fit. Oh, he would. Yeah.

So it's too bad he didn't have presidential aspirations. Sounds like he would have fit in real well at the White House. You can't leave that alone, can you? So Shelley's parents were paying for their wedding, but there was a lot of tension between the Daniszewskys and the Kovlins over things like the guest list, the alcohol, and the rabbi who would officiate. But what was the deal with the alcohol? Well, the Daniszewskys wanted a more modest selection, and the Kovlins wanted a huge spread. They wanted every known alcohol. So they were more showy types. They were.

And the rabbi who would be the officiant, Shelly's father was a rabbi. He had married the other kids. And that was a huge sticking point. He wanted to marry all his kids. He wanted to marry Shelly. Sure. And Rod's parents did not want him to do that. They wanted their own rabbi to officiate. Well, shouldn't it really have been up to Shelly and Rod? Why are the parents even getting involved in this? Very annoying. It's very difficult. And the rabbi issue was the deal breaker until Shelly's father, Joel, threw in the towel and said, OK.

You guys can have your own rabbi do it. Okay. Is that what Shelly wanted? No, that's what happened. I don't know what Shelly wanted. Right. It was just her wedding. Who cares what she thought? Right. So they got married. They moved into Shelly's apartment together. Then Rod earned his MBA, and he really seemed to be on track for some big things in the world of finance. They were going to be kind of a power couple. But of course, Shelly was really focused on wanting to have children and start a family. Yeah, remember, she's in her late 30s. So it's time to get moving on that if she wants to have biological children. So after several months of trying to get pregnant, Shelly and Rod decided to try in vitro fertilization.

And then she was super happy when she got pregnant on the first try. And this pregnancy was fine. She did well. She delivered her daughter, Anna, on October 12, 2000. Yeah. And this was the newborn to end all newborns. The way the parents acted, they were just totally in love with her. Now, for Rod, this lasted about a month when he took a weekend off to go play in a backgammon tournament. And Shelly, of course, would prefer he stay home with his wife and new daughter. Well, I don't know. Going away for one weekend seems okay to me. Well, he went. Yeah. Because he knew he was a player. Well, he thought he was a great player. And he actually had dreams of playing professionally, which I didn't even know was a thing.

Professional backgammon. Never heard of it. Well, I think it's still in existence. He founded a professional league with some others. And there were tournaments and prizes, prize money. But nothing like you'd expect. It's not like they're going to sit down and win $500,000 playing backgammon.

Well, yeah, I didn't even know there was really that much to it. I enjoy backgammon, but I didn't think it was so much a skill that you could make a living at it. Well, I guess that's part of the problem in terms of making a living because it really isn't a skill. You're so much dependent on the roll of the dice. Right, right. So that's a lot less skill required for that or comes into play with rolling dice. I guess so. But with poker, you're dependent on what cards you get. So I guess it's like anything else. Well, that part, sure. But you can also work around the cards a little bit. Right. Not so much with the dice. Then when Anna was four months old, Shelly returned to work.

Rod had yet to find any work, although he was always telling Shelly that the right job was just around the corner. And she was really trying to have faith in him. But as time were on, Rod's enthusiasm for getting employment was really falling off. He spent most of his days playing online backgammon and working out at the gym. Some days he'd go to the gym three or four times. Now we don't know, was he really working out or was he seeing women too? Hard to say.

Well, we know that he enjoyed the company of other women, many other women. And the gym certainly was a good place to help in finding those women. Oh, okay. So I'll just leave it at that. Well, and it seems that way because this really coincides with his enthusiasm for his marriage falling off. So he wasn't acting as lovey-dovey as he had been. So that would also make you think that maybe he was getting a little action at the gym. Exactly. And he began to criticize Shelly more and more, trying to just beat down her confidence. And this was usually about her appearance, which she was very attractive, but this was a real easy target because of her scarring.

And then, of course, she was older, so he began to poke fun at her age, calling her the scarred old lady, really messing with her self-confidence. Yeah, you know, when you kid me about my age, I just let it roll off my back. I don't do that. No. You're merciless, but I've learned to deal with it. Oh, okay. You're very brave.

Now, compounding all this other stuff, the marriage isn't going as great as she would like. He doesn't work, spends all his time playing backgammon and working out. On top of all this, Rod's parents, Dave and Carol, began dropping by the apartment more and more often. Which might have been nice, but it wasn't. Oh, not these two. And they'd come and visit and they'd start bad-mouthing Shelley's parents, the Daniszewskys. And they always had some imagined slight that they had suffered at the hands of Joel and Jaylene Daniszewski. So it sounds, if you think about it, sounds like not a very fun household right now. No, but despite these difficulties, Shelley decided to undergo another round of IVF.

She wanted another child. So by this time, she was 42, but did get pregnant with twins. But then tragedy struck. At six months gestation, Shelly went into preterm labor due to a placental abruption. And that's where the placenta tears away from the uterus. Yeah. So there's no oxygen supply or blood supply. Yeah. So it's pretty quick death for the babies. So you got to deal with it quickly. Yeah. So both of these babies did die. One survived for about 24 hours, but there was never much hope for that one. And the other one was a stillborn. And this was all because of oxygen deprivation. Yeah.

So, of course, this was very depressing for Shelley, who had been so excited about this pregnancy, all prepared to bring twins home. really depressed, and her husband was not supportive, which made it worse. But she was a tough one. Less than a year later, she started a new round of IVF treatments. This time she went with a donor egg just because her eggs had, I don't know, reached the statute of limitations or something. Well, she's 43 at that point. The fertility team didn't want to use her eggs. So they got donor eggs and they had a son, a little boy named Miles. And Miles was born September 26, 2006. So now we've got Shelly's back at work and Nanny Rose taking care of the kids. Rod had plenty of time to engage in his two passions.

chasing women and playing backgammon. And sometimes he could even combine the two, where he'd hook up with women at backgammon tournaments. Well, that's the dream. Yeah, living the dream, right? Yes. Now, he also became more insulting to Shelly, even in front of her family. And then not long before their 10th anniversary, Shelly found a note from one of Ry's girlfriends on his computer.

Now, she suspected he had purposely left it there for her to find. Well, he had never really been worried about her finding out. It's not like he was careful. I mean, it almost seemed like he liked to throw it in her face. I think he did. So he took her out for an anniversary dinner. Tenth anniversary. It's their tenth anniversary. And at the dinner, he proposed that they have an open marriage. And this was quite a shock. It's not something Shelley was even willing to consider. She didn't want that. That's a good try, though. Well, I guess. But it really hurt her. No kidding. So by this time, things aren't going great, of course. And then they began to discuss getting divorced.

Shelly confided to her sister Eve that she was afraid of Rod, afraid he might hurt her. So that's alarming. Yeah, it's like you hear not infrequently. If something happens to me, Rod did it. Yeah. Did she say that? Yeah, basically. Basically, yeah. So they're basically living separate lives at this point. And Shelly came to anticipate his weekend tournaments when he would go away. If he was out of the house, things were better, more peaceful at home. Far more peaceful.

Everyone was happier. The kids were happier because these poor little kids, they're what, at the time they separated, they're three and nine. And it's got to be very stressful for them watching their parents fight. Well, certainly. And I think that he really would talk down about their mother to them, which is the worst thing you can do in many ways. So Shelly and Rod finally decided to separate, which was a good thing. But he was going to move into a studio apartment directly across the hall. And Shelly was willing to co-sign the lease for him.

Because he still didn't really have a job. He had no income, right. So a few days after Rod moved out, Shelley decided that she would go ahead with a divorce. She met with divorce lawyer Lance Meyer, who was a pretty big lawyer in the area, to begin discussing this process, but didn't carry it out at that point. Just kind of discussed it. Because in fact, she was ambivalent about a divorce. It was really frowned upon in her family. She really felt like it was her job to make it work. So this would be a failure that would be hard for her to face.

So in an attempt to preserve that marriage, Shelley set up two Mother's Day outings in 2009. Shelley and her family would be with Rod's parents at the New York Botanical Garden for a luncheon. Then they'd meet her parents in Manhattan for dinner. So she's trying. She's working really hard. However, Rod behaved so badly when they met up with his parents that Shelley realized reconciliation was just impossible. There was just no way it was going to happen. So she did tell Rod she wanted a divorce, and this set him off even more.

because maybe he didn't love her, but he didn't need that money. He was used to a pretty nice lifestyle. He lived a very nice lifestyle and would be really reluctant to lose that. Yes. So he ended up, you know, when she said she wanted a divorce, he took some of his possessions from his studio apartment and moved him back into Shelley's apartment, saying sort of like, I dare you to throw this stuff out.

Oh, he's fun. Yeah, he's a handful. So on the advice of her lawyer, Shelley signed affidavits asking for temporary custody of the children, exclusive rights to the apartment, and an order of protection against Rod. So these were all granted by the judge, and while she was pleased with these results, of course she feared how Rod was going to respond to this. He wasn't going to like it, and he had quite a temper. And then she told her nanny, Rose, that Rod had threatened to kill her.

So things are just escalating. They certainly are. So you can see why when she was found in the tub, there were immediate suspicions. Yeah, well, we'll get into that because there's a lot of stuff suspicious about the crime scene. Absolutely. When he was served the papers, Rod reacted just as Shelley suspected he would. He vehemently denied everything and painted himself as the victim. He claimed Shelley was dependent on pills and that she often acted erratically in front of the kids. Yeah, so a hearing was scheduled. This was for May 20th, 2009. And just before it started, Rod called Shelley's employer and he told them that Shelley was a drug addict who had raided the couple's joint account.

Now, this was really stupid because that's the bread and butter. He's living off that income. But he's just so pissed off. He'll do whatever it takes. Well, that's evidence right there that his temper could just overthrow anything else. So without knowing that he had called her employer, Shelley made several concessions. And the main one was her offer to remove the children from that order of protection. That's a big deal. That means he could spend time with them. And the judge agreed to that arrangement. She also ordered Rod to provide a get to Shelley. Right. This is a Jewish document. I don't know if it's just in the Orthodox Church, but it's a document that the husband gives to the wife.

which states that the marriage is over and the woman is now, quote, permitted to every man, unquote. Well, what the hell does that mean? So that just means it's okay for you to start dating. Okay, well, this is really old school and probably shouldn't be a thing anymore, in my opinion. Well, it is. Well, I'm not arguing that it is, but doesn't it kind of set the woman up as a possession? Well, there's so many things wrong with those kinds of statements. Well.

We don't want to stomp all over anyone's religion. I'm just saying that that statement seems kind of misogynistic. That's all. Yeah. So although the accusations leveled by Rod were false, Shelley still had to defend herself at her workplace. Remember, he called and said horrible things about her. He also began talking to Shelley about reconciling. And this is a violation of the protective order. Right. Not supposed to have any contact. So Shelley's sister Eve helped Shelley realize that a reconciliation just wasn't a good idea. It wasn't going to happen. Which Shelley already kind of knew that, but she was in a bit of denial.

because she just wanted things to be a certain way, and they just weren't going to be. They were not, and they weren't ever going to be. No, and I think that's what her sister really tried to get through to her, that this wasn't a failure of Shelly's. These things happen, you need to accept it. But she felt bad about it. Oh, sure. I would expect her not to feel good about this. This whole situation is terrible. It is, but none of it's her fault. No, it isn't. And Rod also had hacked into Shelly's email, but this was figured out pretty quickly. In addition, he hacked her cell phone account, and he bugged her apartment with listening devices. All these counter-offensives resulted in little valuable information, though.

Still, Rod had other tricks up his sleeve, for sure. Oh, did he ever. One day, he failed to bring the children back after a visit, and Shelley was frantically making phone calls trying to find them. Six hours after they should have been home, Shelley got a call from New York Presbyterian Hospital. Rod had brought the children in claiming that Shelly had been sexually abusing Miles. So sounds familiar, doesn't it? Remember Rod's childhood? Taking a page from his father's book, actually. Yeah. So they were investigated, and there was actually no evidence that Shelly was sexually abusing Miles or Anna or anybody. And the DA's office declined to press charges. Yeah, but can you just imagine what that would be like to even go through that, to even be accused of that? Can't. So then the very next day, Rod was going to visit his kids. Now, why was he allowed to visit them again if he'd done that? Well, they still have this order.

Okay, go ahead. I just can't get over that. He goes to visit the kids. Shelly doesn't show up. Her lawyer had notified Rod's lawyers that Shelly would no longer abide by the visitation. Well, hell yeah. Why would you? That, you know, not only damaging you and trying to hurt your reputation, but even worse, what does that do to the children? I know. Really messes with them. So Shelly asked the court to curb Rod's visitation with the kids, and she wanted the court to reestablish the protective order. Right. So she still had it for her, but she let it go for the kids. Right. And now she wanted that back. Yeah, she's trying to be a nice guy. No more nice guy. Well.

It's a delicate balance to try and be nice and then protect the children. And of course, protecting the children has to come first. Right. So the judge discontinued overnight stays with Rod and reduced his weekday visits to two hours twice a week. And any direct contact with the children was to be done under supervision. So finally, there was to be no unauthorized contact with the children. And to make matters worse for Rod, he was fired from the job he'd managed to get.

So back on the unemployment line. The good news in this was that Rod could now play as much backgammon as he wanted. So he was kind of happy about it. But his relief was short-lived. Appearing before a judge, Rod asked his child support be terminated since he didn't have a job. And the judge reluctantly agreed to this, but then barred him from playing backgammon tournaments. So the judge was like, basically, you don't have a job. You need to concentrate on supporting your children. And you need to stop doing the backgammon because he was kind of obsessed with it by this point. It was weird. It wasn't a hobby. No, it's kind of an obsession. But I think some of that is besides enjoying backgammon.

Gave him a great area to meet women. Yes. For whatever reason, he just loved playing backgammon tournaments. He did. And being told you can't do it, that hurt him. Aw. Aw, I know. So then he came up, Rod, then came up with another brilliant idea, and that's to have Shelley paying him spousal support. The judge denied this too.

So end of story. Ride was ordered to pay $425 a month in child support. But he did score a modest victory when the judge ordered Shelly to pay his legal fees, which were in the sum of $50,000. Well, I'm actually kind of surprised that she wasn't ordered to pay him support because she was the breadwinner when they were together. And that's usually how it works. Yeah. Well, at the same time, he was perfectly capable of holding a job. There's no reason he couldn't have a job. It's not like he was raising the children full time. Right. So yeah. So kind of surprising that she had to pay the $50,000 in legal fees. Well, just the money is chicken feed to Shelly and her family.

But still. But it still would hurt, don't you think? Well, yeah, that's money that could have been invested for the children or gone to some kind of good cause instead of to him. Because who knows if he would even pay his legal bills with the money. Well, I think they'd have to have it. That would be something that would be paid directly by Shelley to his attorneys. I would hope so, yeah. He's not going to get a check and promise to pay for it. So Rod was continuing to be active with members of the opposite sex, and he really found it easy to connect with women at these backgammon tournaments. One of his favorites was Deborah Ohles, who was 14 years older than Rod, married, and had three children.

So I don't know if he liked older women or if he just saw them as someone he could manipulate and get money from. But another older woman. Another older woman. I would go with your second choice that he just figured they'd be easier to manipulate. So despite some eccentricities on Rod's part, Deborah was actually really attracted to him. I think she said she was flattered that this younger guy who was handsome was interested in her and her marriage must not have been great. Otherwise, why would she have gotten involved? There you go. So after some prodding from the judge, Rod finally provided the get, which meant Shelly could start dating.

Well, isn't that nice? She put her profile on JDate, which is a Jewish dating service, and was really amazed at the number of responses she got. She had a couple of dates with a guy, Neil Rothenberg, who was a real estate developer, so a wealthy guy, and he felt she was interested in him and wanted to continue seeing her. So Rothenberg sent her an email in early January 2010 asking her out. When she didn't respond for several days, he called her office and learned that she had died. So that was quite a shock. Wasn't it? So here's his new suitor.

who's interested in her. I think they've been out on a couple dates. And he wanted her to go with him to some big fancy to-do in Albany. And she said, that'd be wonderful. And next thing we know, she's dead.

So Shelly was worth over $5 million, and she didn't want Rod to get any of that money. She had already changed the beneficiary on an insurance policy from Rod to her children, and she was looking for an estate attorney to get everything worked out because she had some assets. That she did. So on the night she died, Shelly had been out with a friend. She got home around 8 p.m., and at 10.30, all electronic activity on her devices stopped. Rod's electronic activity stopped at 1 in the morning and then resumed about 3 hours later. At 4.13 in the morning, Rod left the building, and on his way out, he asked the doorman if there was anything he wanted.

and he wanted a Snickers bar or something like that. So he came back with that, gave it to the doorman, and then went out again at 5 in the morning. This time he exited through a rear door of the building, but he came back not too long later through the front door. So this was not customary behavior. This wasn't a guy who gave one shit about the doorman, and he'd never offered the doorman to pick him up anything before. So we could really see this as just an attempt to have an alibi. We could look at it that way, yes. I think a lot of people have looked at it that way. When Rod entered Shelley's apartment after he'd been called over by his daughter Anna,

He said that he lifted Shelly's dripping wet body out of the water in order to perform CPR on her. But his first phone call was to his divorce attorney, and this lasted six seconds. Then he called 911. When first responders arrived, they found Shelley's body on the bathroom floor, and rigor mortis had set in. Also, there was bright red bathwater in the tub, and that was from blood, obviously. The cabinet above the faucet had been torn loose, but was that really feasible? Well, I guess at the time it sounded reasonable enough. But think about it. I mean, she gets into the tub, and she starts to slip, and she grabs the cabinet. Yeah, it's hard to believe. I guess it would be possible. But responders noted that Rod's clothes were completely dry, his answers to questions were short, and although he was crying, there were no tears. Now, we've heard that before.

Yes, we have. There appeared to be a great amount of tension between Rod's family and Shelley's family, too. And this was mainly over which family would take care of the children. So the first round went to the Koblins. Yeah, they ended up taking Anna and Miles to their home. And as far as they were concerned, that was it. They were going to take care of those kids. But Shelley's family thought something had happened to her, or at least they considered it. Yes. That it wasn't just an accident. Right. And it appeared to detectives that Shelley's injuries were much more than a slip and fall. So they hoped that an autopsy would provide some answers. But Shelley's family objected to an autopsy on religious grounds.

Jonathan Hayes, a senior medical examiner, was aware of this when he received her body. However, when he saw the scratches and contusion on her face, he really felt it was imperative to perform an autopsy. Yeah, because he's looking at these injuries and thinking, there's just no way the story of a fall in the tub matches those injuries. Exactly. So he called the chief medical examiner, Charles Hirsch, but Hirsch declined his request to have the autopsy done. Hayes then called Shelley's father, Joel, and asked him to give permission for an autopsy. Joel wasn't sure, so he called his rabbi, David Cohen, a real authority on Jewish law, and after listening to Joel, Rabbi Cohen...

did agree to the autopsy. Yeah, but then this is almost like a Keystone Cops type thing if it wasn't so serious. So his medical examiner is getting ready to do the autopsy after being told no, then yes. And just as he's ready to make an incision, he gets a call again from Joel, and he's revoking permission for the autopsy. So it's a no, then a yes, then a no. Now Joel has spoken with Rabbi Meyer Weil, who is a member of an organization known as Miss Ask Him.

Ms. Eschem helps prepare a body for burial and works closely with Orthodox Jewish synagogues. So Rabbi Weil told Joel he had spoken with authorities and the police believe Shelley's death to be accidental. So there is no need for an autopsy. This is a lie. Why would he do that? Because they don't think you should ever do autopsies, basically. Wow. Well, he misrepresented himself anyway. Sure. So we're not going to do an autopsy. Shelly's body was placed in a plain pine casket, and her funeral took place on January 3rd, 2010. So that's, what, three days after her death. The Jewish religion, or at least the Orthodox Jews, want she buried as quickly as possible after death. So that took place, her funeral took place on January 3rd, and she was buried next to her beloved twins. How incredibly sad for the whole family. And then the family sat Shiva.

which is the week-long mourning period where you don't receive guests at your house who do anything. Yes. So maybe he was too intent on getting his hands on Shelly's money, but Rod really never worried that the police might consider him a suspect in her death. One of his girlfriends, though, disavowed him of that idea. Shelly's brother-in-law, Mark Karstadt, wrote a letter to the police, begging them to take a closer look at Shelly's death. The DA's office agreed to take another look, and they obtained a court order for an autopsy. Yeah, so now they don't need permission from the family. Right. So Shelly's body was exhumed?

And it was in remarkably good shape. When Hayes, the medical examiner, did an external examination, he found two petechiae in a right eye. So these are signs that strangulation may have occurred. Yeah, we've talked about petechiae before. Yeah. Briefly tell us why that would happen if you're being strangled. If you're being strangled, you are impeding blood flow back to the heart. So you still have the heart's pumping. Arterial blood is still pumping. But then it's obstructed from returning to the heart. So there's little tiny capillaries that burst. And those are the petechiae.

So then they dissected her neck and found that her hyoid bone had been fractured. And we know this is a very common indicator of manual strangulation. That it is. So the remainder of the autopsy was unremarkable. The autopsy report's final diagnosis was changed from undetermined to homicide by neck compression. So that does not bode well for Rod. It doesn't sound real good for Rod, does it? So there were predictions of him being arrested right away, but that turned out to be premature. Shortly after the autopsy results were published, little Anna was questioned by a social worker.

And for many of the questions, Anna responded that she didn't want to discuss that topic. So the social worker felt there were times when Anna was probably not being entirely truthful. So it sounds like someone was feeding her the idea that she shouldn't discuss certain things. No question in the social worker's mind that Anna had been coached by her father. And at this point, Anna was in the custody of Rod's family. Right. The Daniszewskys had little to no contact with the kids. I think it turned out that in the...

The years, just about 10 years from Shelley's death to Rod's trial, the Daniszewskis had seen the grandkids maybe half a dozen times in those nine or 10 years. So it's really sad for these people, right? The twins were lost. Then they lost their daughter, which is the biggest blow. And then they can't even see their daughter's children. Plus, you have to think that these children are being turned against them by Rod's family. So it's really just a bad example of how adults should behave. Horrible. Yeah, well, you know, you just got to let your vindictiveness come to the forefront. Well, apparently in this case.

So the NYPD obtained a search warrant for Shelley's apartment, and they did make a few interesting discoveries. The front door lock had been jammed and needed to be forcibly opened. And somebody had put glue or some substance in the lock. Now why would that be? Just to be a pain in the ass. So we think Rod did that just to get in the way. We think so. Nothing's ever been proven.

So what else did they find that was strange? So besides the door being jammed, a mezuzah had been ripped away from the doorway and tossed on the floor. Now these are little containers that are attached to the wall and they have a simple prayer in there, kind of like blessing the house or taking care of the inhabitants of the house. So that had been ripped off the door. The damaged cabinet in the bathroom had been taken down and placed on the floor. And then maybe the most important thing, Shelley's iPhone was found in its usual spot plugged in next to her bed.

And there were at least two people, one of which was Eve, her sister, who had already looked there. So this is the incredibly mysteriously reappearing iPhone. So what you're suggesting is that Rod took it and did something with it and then put it back there. That's what I'm guessing you're saying. That's what I'm saying. Although maybe I can't say he did something to it, but Rod was the person who took the phone and Rod was the one who put the phone back. That's a theory. That's a theory. So Shelley's death set off a chain reaction of events after that. First was the custody, custody of Anna and Miles. The court was really reluctant to move them from the Kovlins. The Daniszewskys did not want Rod to be the executor of Shelley's estate, and the court appointed a neutral party for that. Then Shelley's parents sued for visitation rights with their grandchildren.

But for some reason, I really can't fathom, they were unsuccessful. Do we know why? No. But this is going to be an ongoing struggle. Yes. And we'll find some stuff out down the road. Well, Rod tried to gain control of an insurance policy that was worth $1.6 million, and it named the children as beneficiaries. But he was ultimately unsuccessful at that also. And then Rod found himself doing battle with his own parents. They were basically the sole caretakers of their grandchildren, with Rod acting more as a friend and a visitor than an actual parent. Rod would become upset with Dave and Carol whenever they tried to place boundaries on his behavior.

So with time, his outbursts became more frequent and more physical. But only when he was threatened with a report to the police did he finally back off. Now, Rod could also be physically aggressive toward his children, especially the little boy, Miles. And his parents were concerned that he allowed Anna, then 12 years old, to sleep in the same bed as him. What do they know about him that we don't know? Too creepy for me to think of an adult male and a pubertal female sleeping together, even his father and daughter.

Okay, but why would the parents be worried about that? Did they think he was a creep? Yeah. I've known he was a creep for years. Oh, all right. Well, then that explains that. But anytime his parents tried to correct his behaviors, Rod would get physically violent with them. Yeah, to the extent of striking his mother, throwing objects at her, taking his father and throwing him into a wall. Well, this guy's a nightmare. Why do they have anything to do with him? Got me. Then after one really epic battle, Rod's parents finally kicked him out of the house. And Rod responded by taking the kids with him. And he wouldn't tell anyone where they were going.

No, he wasn't allowed to do that. This was against the law. He's not allowed to do that. He has no custodial rights for those kids. But he did finally return with the children, and his parents' response was to change the locks on all their doors. He was able to get an apartment nearby in New Rochelle, and he persuaded his older girlfriend, Deborah, to put the lease in her name. Yeah, well, two reasons for that. One is he has no money, so he couldn't do it. The other thing is that there's some notoriety involved here. So once people find out who he is, they might not react favorably towards him. Oh, okay. So the word was out. Word was out. Now, he's probably taking too much credit for himself for that.

So he probably could have rented the apartment without being turned down. He didn't have money. So it was a moot point. So his parents sued him for custody of the children. And at the same time, they continued to assert that they were more deserving of custody than Shelley's family.

The judge gave temporary custody to the Koblins and also issued an order of protection against Rod toward his parents and children. So the agreement was formalized by all involved parties, and Rod was granted supervised visits and phone calls with his children. Rod was supposed to begin therapy sessions immediately, and he was supposed to take any medication that was prescribed for him. Then finally, the judge directed his parents to arrange a meeting with Shelly's parents with the objective of creating an ongoing relationship, you know, for the sake of the kids. Yeah, it's still tough for these parents to work through. Well, I can understand for the Danyshevskis. This is a man who killed their daughter, they believe. Yeah, but even for Rafe's parents. Well, yeah, they never did like them. So in November 2012...

Shelley's sister Eve and her husband Mark petitioned for custody of the kids. Now previously Eve and Shelley's brother Philip and his wife petitioned for custody. So we're kind of switching from one family member to another for custody. So the petition addressed the abuse, both mental and physical, that the children were enduring and stressed how their home and family would be much more inviting to the children. Now Rod also filed a petition for custody. The judge ruled that all parties were to be evaluated by a psychiatrist and that would aid her, the judge, in making the decision. Among the last things Rod would ever want to do would be examined by a psychiatrist. So he withdrew his petition for custody.

And in April 2013, he surrendered custody of his children to his parents. So this left just two parties in this custody battle. Yeah, we just have even marked the Karstats and the Kovlins. So at the time, Anna was having some psychological issues, which is not surprising at all considering what she'd been through. And she'd even cut her wrists at one point. So the Karstats were worried about Anna's mental health.

and withdrew their petition for custody. So someone was putting her above their own needs. That's surprising. We haven't seen a lot of that since Shelly died. Well, these were the main people interviewed on that Dateline episode that we watched. Oh, okay. They seemed pretty with it. So in January of 2014, Rod's parents were granted full physical and legal custody of Anna and Miles. And they did agree to weekly counseling sessions for the children. They also agreed to a plan to reintroduce the children to the car steps. And this plan was a failure from the start. Why was that? Well, the plan was sort of this gradual thing where to be reintroduced to...

Eve and Mark, and just gradually spend more time with them. Now the problem was that the elder Kovlin, Dave, insisted on accompanying them on their visits, and Mark and Eve didn't feel like that was appropriate because he was constantly bad-mouthing their family. So it just turned out that it was too much to try to deal with it. Anna was having a lot of problems separating from the Kovlins, so the Karstads eventually said, okay, we'll get out of this custody battle, which they did. So once the Kovlins were granted custody of the children, Rod's behavior towards his parents got worse and worse.

He told his girlfriend, Deborah, that he wouldn't hesitate to kill both of his parents. And he told her this a lot, not just once. He fantasized about killing his mother and grinding her up in an industrial meat grinder. So how do you like that? Yeah, they were driving or looking around one day at a Home Depot or something. And so he saw this big, huge meat grinder and he started getting all these ideas. Well, wouldn't it be great to have one of these and I could take care of my folks? Yeah, I don't think Home Depot would sell meat grinders. Yeah, they probably wouldn't. Okay. But regardless, that's a horrible comment. And then he would often ask Deborah, do you think I'm a psychopath? But, you know, it was also kind of like a threat she took it as.

So she was becoming afraid of him. She absolutely was. And while she always said, no, you're not a psychopath, she was becoming deeply concerned about his deteriorating mental status and his increased obsession with violence. She certainly was. So Rod goes through a bunch of these murder scenarios and they're just totally far-fetched. Now his first murder plot.

He drew from the TV shows, and you'll like this, Jill, Breaking Bad and Dexter. Uh-huh. So episodes from these shows portrayed the use of the poisons ricin and aconite. But the manufacture of these poisons proved a little too difficult for Rod. So he went on to a new plan. And this involved rat poison. Back to the basics, I guess. Back to the basics. Now, the rat poison, in order to kill an adult person, the poison would need to be administered repeatedly and over a prolonged time period. So Rod's answer to this was that we'll get Anna to deliver it to them. Oh, shit. Why does he keep picking on this poor girl? So the rat poison was going to be in the sugar bowl.

And it would be added to their drinks. Getting Anna to do it, he figured that she'd likely get away with it. But just in case she didn't, she's just a kid. She won't be in prison that long. Is there not one second of thought given to how she would feel about killing these people? Well, no. And I'll tell you, it's going to get worse. So his girlfriend, Deborah, did talk him out of that. So good for her. And she would eventually say that she just stayed with him to protect these people. So I don't know if you believe that or not, but it's possible in my mind. It is possible because he's increasingly unhinged. He's getting more and more bizarre in terms of his plans and how he's going to deal with things. Right. But she didn't really feel like she knew enough to go to the police.

and get him arrested, that there wasn't really any proof. It would just be her word. Right. So in the fall of 2012, when Hurricane Sandy hit the New York metropolitan area, Rod thought he had another great idea. With no power, his parents' alarm system would be disabled. And Rod thought he could break into their house and set it on fire. Then he would rescue his children while his parents died in this fire. So when Deborah asked him, how are you going to explain that you're there at your parents' house? There's a protective order. So Rod finally dropped that plan. But his next plan was to don blackface and pretend to be a canvasser for the upcoming Obama-Romney.

presidential race. So who would he be canvassing for? Obama or Romney? He's going to be in blackface disguised as an Obama supporter. Uh-huh. So then when his mom answered the door, he would karate chop her and then kill his father. So that is really harebrained. Isn't it? So even thinking about it, you have to laugh. I mean, so this guy knocks on your door and you answer and there's a person obviously in blackface. He's not an African-American person. Right. So that gives it away right there. What a psycho. He is a psychopath. But Deborah did manage to talk him out of that plan. But now she's worried that he might kill her.

He assured her he wasn't going to kill her, though, because he said he only wanted to kill people who kept him from his children. Well, of course, that's the logical thing. Well, and that was his argument with Shelly before she died, is that she wanted his children. And he would even torment her about Miles not being her biological child because of the donor egg. Yeah, he would tell that to Shelly, tell it to Anna also, that he's not really your brother. Wow. Yeah. Okay, so terrible. Now, maybe his most chilling scheme involved a plan where Anna would accuse her grandfather of rape. Rod wrote out like a four-page instruction manual to Anna, and they're just truly horrifying.

Oh, yeah. And then to me, equally horrifying was Anna's intention to carry out the scheme. She said she was going to do it to help her father. Well, what does she know? It's not her fault. It's her father telling her to do this. Right. She's like 13, 14 now. Well, I don't blame her at all. I think she was totally a victim in this. Yeah. And in the end, she didn't go through with the false rape claim. So there right there tells you she didn't want to do that. She said, I can't do this. No. But just imagine you're a child and you have a parent telling you these things. When you're a child, you think your parents know things and you should follow what they say. Right. So this has got to be very confusing and distressing for the girl who's already lost her mother.

And was the one to find her mother's body. Let's be honest. This was all traumatic. It certainly was. So now the girlfriend Debra's at the point where she's considering leaving Rod. But she decided to stay because she loved his children. And she said that she saw herself as a buffer between Rod and the kids. And after one confrontation where Rod was physically abusive to her, Debra had begun recording all of their conversations. But she still hadn't gone to the police, which kind of surprises me. I would say, why not go to the police and have them be in on it with you? Yeah, that would seem to be the course of action. But it's not until they arrest Rod that she agrees to testify. Yeah, but Rod continued to scheme and came up with another idea. And so this one's really harebrained.

This involves marrying off his daughter to a Mexican because in Mexico, the age of consent for women was 14 and she was 14 at this point. Then once married, Anna could assume control over her portion of the inheritance. And then Rod could manipulate her out of some or maybe even all of the money. So he's really not that interested in his kids. It seems like he's more interested in the money. Well, his kids are a means to the end. That's all. Right. So Deborah told Rod, this is the worst idea you could have come up with. And it does sound like he's unhinged to even think of that. Pretty crazy. Yeah. When you're reading this stuff, you're just thinking, or I was just thinking, I just can't believe.

the deaths he's willing to go to to get this money. Pretty sad when you think about it. It really is. But his financial status was on the downtrend. In February of 2013, he did take a job as a debt collector for Pearl Capital in Manhattan. So that's kind of a step down than what he thought he was capable of. Oh, this is several steps down. Yeah. Now, meanwhile, the investigation of Rod as the killer of his wife was continuing. They were amassing circumstantial evidence, but they didn't have enough to charge him yet. But that changed in the summer of 2014. And that was when Rod broke up with Deborah. And she met with prosecutors and gave them lots of information.

So a grand jury was convened, and this resulted in a murder indictment. So Rod was finally arrested on November 1st, 2015. Now, he appeared for a bail hearing November 9th, 2015. Judge Bonnie Wittner was presiding for the prosecution, Matthew Bogdanos, and for the defense, Robert Gottlieb. After hearing just these impassioned pleas from both attorneys, Judge Wittner ordered Rod held without bail, and she also barred Rod from communicating with anyone other than his attorneys. Now, that was modified a little bit later to where he could talk with his children. What about his parents?

Did they want anything to do with him at that point? No, I don't think there was anything about the parents. So they really don't want anything to do with him, but they still believe he's innocent of the murder of Shelley. Is that right? That's right. At least that's what they're saying. But it would take three more years before Rod's case would go to trial. Early on in 2017, Judge Wittner retired, and she was replaced by a Judge Daniel Convisor. And in 2018, Bogdanos pushed for Rod's letters to Anna to be unsealed. Gottlieb argued they were too prejudicial to be released. So the judge agreed. And later in 2018, this judge was replaced also.

by a judge, Ruth Pickles. So jury selection began January 14th, 2019. Before the process began, Bogdanos showed a video that he wanted to admit as evidence. And on the video, this is a prison surveillance video that showed Rod demonstrating a chokehold on another inmate. So Bogdanos wanted it admitted. I would too. Since it would show that Rod was familiar with it. Right. Because he's been claiming, I don't know, no martial arts stuff. But he was going to karate chop his mother.

The judge would allow the video to be introduced as evidence. Good. Then there's the usual bickering between the lawyers. But finally, a jury was selected. 12 jurors, 4 alternates. So Rod's murder trial began January 22, 2019. And remember, this was Judge Pickholz who presided. For the prosecution, Bogdanos was assisted by an Anne Siegel and Nicole Dracinos. For the defense, Robert Gottlieb was assisted by Seth Zuckerman and Sarah Letty. Now, after Bogdanos gave his opening summary, Gottlieb asked for a mistrial. And this was, of course, denied. They always ask for a mistrial, right? Pretty much.

One of the earlier witnesses for the prosecution was Patricia Swenson, and this was a girlfriend of Rod's. She testified that on a weekend getaway with him over lunch, he told her that he wanted Shelly dead, and the last time she saw Rod, Patricia gave him some advice. Talk to God and ask for help. Bogdanos then called Shelly's hairdresser to the stand, and he testified that he had given Shelly a keratin treatment the day before her death. So that's like a Brazilian blowout, I believe. It makes the hair straight and silky, but after you have that treatment, you can't get your hair wet for a few days after. Yeah, so you don't want to screw it up by getting it wet. No.

Plus, she wasn't really a bath taker, according to her sister and friends. She was a showerer. So why was she in the bathtub? Doesn't make sense. Well, it could. If she wanted to clean up and not get her hair wet, she could do a bath. But her hair wasn't up in a bun. Yeah, that's true. The police officers who testified really came across badly. Despite claims that Shelley's death was suspicious, there was little to no gathering of evidence done. And the police also had allowed a number of people into her apartment, so the scene was contaminated. Not a great investigation, at least not initially.

Rod's ex-girlfriend, Deborah Ols, was the last person to testify for the prosecution. She detailed her life with Rod, how her love and admiration for him had turned into fear, and when her testimony was completed, the state rested their case. They felt like that was a strong spot to end on. Then the defense attorney stated he would not be calling any witnesses. So there was a conference among the parties before deliberations began, and this was to decide whether jurors would consider intentional murder and felony murder counts. The intentional murder charge required that Rod went to Shelley's apartment with the intention of killing her.

while the federal murder charge occurs when a murder is committed during a separate crime. So in this case, it would be him entering her apartment illegally. Yeah, and then she's yelling at him to get out and he kills her. So the prosecution wanted the second charge left in as like a safety net in case they didn't choose the first one. And the judge did allow that. Yeah, she did, although she told Bogdanos that he was making a big mistake. And why was that? Because she didn't think the jurors needed to have two choices. But why would it be a mistake on his part? Why would it end up giving him...

Not what he wanted in the end. Well, it would be a mistake possibly that given a choice, they might go for the apparently less serious offense. Okay. But those are both really serious. They both are. And actually, the sentencing is the same. Okay. So it really didn't make any difference. So the defense attorney gave his closing argument and had a pretty tough battle because Rod was not a sympathetic character. But the hope was that the jurors would overlook Rod's personality and focus on the facts. And this was...

that the prosecution had no evidence that Rod was even in Shelley's apartment before 7 a.m. on New Year's Eve. So the defense also commented on the timing of Rod's arrest, saying it was made only because Rod was going to be able to collect Shelley's inheritance. Now, he mentioned more than once that even if you looked at Rod as a total shit, that doesn't make him a murderer. So we've heard that kind of defense before. You might hate our client. He may be a horrible husband. Doesn't make him a murderer. Right. And that usually doesn't work too well, does it? No, I don't think so. So the people in the courtroom who were knowledgeable felt that the state had not done enough to win the case. Really? Then Bogdano started his closing argument.

with these words, and I will quote, there's only one person in the universe to the exclusion of every other person on the planet who could have done it. There's only one person who had the motive, the opportunity, and the means to have done this. So that's how he started, and he went point by point down and finished his summary, and the jury went to deliberate. Well, yeah, I could see that. Despite predictions to the contrary, the jury reached a verdict in less than two days, which is fairly quick as far as a murder trial goes, and Rod was found guilty of second-degree murder. He was sentenced to the maximum available penalty, 25 years to life in prison.

Now, he does have one appeal of his pending for prosecutorial misconduct, and his parents still have custody of Anna and Miles, who apparently have been okay, despite all the horribleness in their childhoods. Apparently. I mean, again, things have kind of filtered through Rod's parents. Can you really believe what they say? I don't think so. Because they're still defending him. At least they were in the Dateline episode that came out last year. Well, and his children, particularly Anna, is still very defensive of him. Well, sure, but I just wonder what they've been told all their lives, you know, living in with the parents. Because if they think Rod is not guilty, then why would the kids think he's guilty?

Maybe when they're adults, they'll figure it out. Hopefully, they'll be able to construct their own opinions when they're adults. Yeah, so Anna's in her early 20s now. So she's an adult. Hopefully, she's doing okay. And she figures out what really went on in her life. Yeah, I'm going to keep looking because I really want to see some follow up. I'm really worried about Anna or have been with how she was dealing with things and all this stuff going on with her. Oh, absolutely. Well, she already has the genetics of that family. And then she has all this stuff she's gone through. Just really sad. Sad for Shelly, of course, and for the kids that lost their mother at such a young age. Yeah, it's a tough one. And this guy, Rod, is seriously ill.

Oh gosh, what a crazy person. Yeah. Yep, a bad guy. I certainly think he did it. Who else could have done it? I think we know she didn't fall or her hyoid bone wouldn't have been broken. Well, the defense claimed that it could be broken that way. She fell on her neck? Yeah. I can't find anything to defend or refute that statement, but it just doesn't sound like a fall would do it. No. No, there are a lot of things that make it suspicious. So I think it's right that he's in prison for it. I can live with that. Me too.

All right. Well, that wraps things up. And I'd just like to thank everybody for listening. We'll be back in a few days with a regular episode of True Crime Brewery. And we'd love to get some feedback from you. So if you have any case suggestions, please let us know. You can email us at truecrimebrewery at tiegrabber.com. And until then, we'll see you at the quiet end. We'll save some places for you. Bye-bye. Bye, guys.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of True Crime Brewery?

This episode is 1 hour and 10 minutes long.

When was this True Crime Brewery episode published?

This episode was published on January 31, 2026.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this True Crime Brewery episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.