Hey, Obsessors, this is Julia. You know I am all about getting obsessed with your big ideas and turning those dreams into actual businesses. I work with entrepreneurs every single day, and so many of my clients rave about Shopify. And I get why. Beautiful storefronts, easy setup, and even an AI assistant called Sidekick to help you along the way. And listen, Black Friday is coming. Why not get your business?
up and running before the holiday shopping rush. Are you ready to launch? Go to Shopify.com to start your free trial. That's Shopify.com. Go to Shopify.com today so you can start hearing. This is Believe. One network, every topic, everywhere. From the Homestead Studios in Santa Clarita, California, this is a Headache Soul production. Welcome to Just The Tipsters, America's favorite true crime podcast. I'm your host, Melissa Morgan. With me today is my handsome and talented co-host, Joshua Crime Bevin. Crime. Because crime never pays.
I've been meaning to take it up with you like my paycheck just hasn't I mean I signed up for direct deposit but I see. You throw it back in my court that you're a cheap bastard. Oh, you meant that. Yeah. Not that you don't get paid. Yeah, you don't get paid from here. But you do it from the love of your soul. But yeah, you don't pay. Yeah. Suddenly when we go out, you're like, oh, I left my wallet in my other house. I don't remember. Do they take Google Pay here? Do they take Diners Club? I have my grandfather's credit card from 1972. I'm hoping they'll still take it. Oh, they don't? Darn, you got me? You got me again?
Crime never pays. Joshua, crime, Bevan. I'm sorry. It just made me laugh. You pay sometimes. Sometimes you pay. Occasionally you pay. Yeah, when I have a coupon or something. Yeah, coupons are good. I dig coupons. Yeah, I'm the cheap guy who actually uses coupons on first dates. Oh, me too. Yeah, I weed some people out real quick. I don't usually. If I go on dates, I usually pay.
for my part but if somebody has a coupon and we each pay a little less i would not look down my nose at that no and that's that's i use it as a as a tool to see how they're gonna one because i want to pay less because sure i gotta yes if you're paying the whole thing yeah yeah but then too it's like okay the reaction is oh screw this guy uh he's he's got i wouldn't get that discount code right which is a like that means you're kind of a baller to me you have like discount codes for everything a lot of i mean a lot of times you just google stuff and you're like oh you know this discount code and you take the time and you find it yeah and no i How many times have we gone to like lunch or dinner or something? It's like, Hey, I got a coupon. I mean me. Oh yeah. Like, Hey, look, it's $5 or 20 bucks or something. So I mean, why? I can't imagine anybody looking down at that. Even a first date or a 20th date. I would think it makes you smart. It's good. It's good for sorting. Oh, sorting out the chicks. Yeah. That makes sense. I wouldn't like that. I would not like that if somebody looked down. I will, I will tell you the only thing I can compare it to is my, I almost said his name, my sweet friend.
a comic who thought beforehand to bring a woman flowers. And she said, I just want you to know that carnations are the cheapest flowers you can get. And I thought I dated a guy in high school who he would drive me home from school and he would stop on the side of the road in Kentucky and get me purple flowers. They were growing. Yes. And they were free. Like, Oh, I saw these and I know how much he would, he would.
do a u-turn yeah and and go to the you know and find these flowers and i mean because we passed them and i was like oh they're pretty and he would stop and pick them for me that is he just stole flowers look dumbass they're on the side of the road it wasn't garden yeah he's he's hoping not to get shot as he is on someone's private property no they're on the side of the road more love than uh i think it's really sweet but i felt so bad for my friend when he told me and i said i hope you never go out with her again yeah absolutely i think it's i think that's shitty i just think you should know carnations are the cheapest flowers you can get fuck you bitch how would you like a rock here i found this for you and hit her with it cool that's a small rock a small just throw it at her i didn't mean like bash her skull in i'm just saying she's an asshole and she doesn't deserve anything it's the worst that's the worst thing i've heard all day it's sort of early but yeah wait wait take a seat Do we, you have more gruesome tales? Well, I was thinking perhaps we talked to the tipsters about the Sean P. Diddy Combs fall collection. Yeah. Yeah. Oh, you think he's going to end up on like QVC or late night. Oh my God. That'd be amazing. Yeah. Yeah. No, there's going to be a, you know, those, you know, they have the Tupperware parties. We have those with the adult toys. Yes. He's going to have one of those companies where they like multi-level marketing where it's like, okay, if you get 10 of your friends and have a little part of your house, you get the, uh, the pufferator, the pufferator 3000.
And a free bottle of baby oil. The large, the family size. The Costco. Yes. It's a 55 gallon drum. We buy in bulk. Yes. Yes. Did you hear this bit? The lawyer tried to argue that, oh no, no, he had so many, he had so many baby, baby oils. He had a hundred bottles of baby oil because, because, excuse me, because the Costco is right down the street and he buys in bulk.
Costco corporate put out a letter that says we do not sell baby oil and never have. Okay, good. I was going to say, I've never seen it there, but maybe I haven't used it since 1980. Costco itself full on. Thank God. That's good planning because I mean, so is his attorney fired? No, I think I was like, does he buy involved for homeless people? What else are you going to argue? I mean, oh, he has so much. Why does he have so much baby oil?
Guy's going to have to try and come up with something. He has a lot of babies? He really likes soft skin. I don't know. It's a mineral oil. It's really not good for anything. It's not good for your butthole. Oh, is it not? No.
This is for reals. Why are you interested? No, I put baby oil on my skin all the time. Pretty much every time after I shower. Oh, that might be an okay time to do it. Please don't put it in your butthole to be reamed. Okay. I just, I think if you have a baby put on their ass or whatever, that's fine. I, it's not good to use as a lubricant. God damn it. Why are we talking about this? Yeah. Thank you. Oh, that's all you needed to say. You said it beautifully because I would have just kept trying to go on and explain, but it is not good for sensitive areas. Gotcha. Okay. Fronts or backs. Okay.
For external use only. God bless you, Joshua. You're much more professional than me. Okay. I was like, it's a mineral oil. Don't put it in your butthole or your vagina. You need water-based. I've heard. I don't know. Okay. I'm with you. Right. Okay. But I can use it as lotion because I don't really like lotion. Right. Lotion feels greasy to me. But oil doesn't? No, because the oil after five minutes or something, it'll just kind of absorb. Okay. Well, I just don't want you to put it in your butthole. Okay. Done. I don't want you to put it in anyone else's butthole. Done. Okay. All right. Good. Yeah. I was unaware of more mature lubricants.
I, the last thing I heard about was like Astro Glide or something from like, you know, a long time ago. I think that's still a thing. I heard someone call it a marital aid. So I don't know. Yeah. You know, I don't have, I don't want to say anything else because it's going to go bad from here. It's going to go so bad. Cardi B. Yes, exactly. Very. God love Cardi B. Okay. So, so you know what else is wonderful? What else is wonderful? Magic mind. And has nothing to do.
with being a marital aide, although it could, it could make your life, you know, much better. I know it's made mine much better. I mean, it is a mental performance shot and I love that name for it. It's, um, it gives you a steady energy through your day. If you are an artist, a creator, and you need something to, to help you, you know, keep your concentration, it's, I think it's just really a gift. I, I am not like a healthy human being, but I feel like doing this.
makes me a little bit more of a, have a healthier lifestyle. It's, you know, a balanced lifestyle. I drink it in the morning before I drink my Mountain Dew Kickstart. They are a wonderful partnership, I think. You can have it with your coffee. I just feel a little dense because I just found out you can have it also like at noon or in the afternoon, if you have that afternoon slump. And I one time took it at three in the afternoon thinking, oh no, I hope it's not going to keep me awake all night. And it did not. I know. I was afraid if I took it that late, but no, you can take it anytime. They do have a wonderful sleep elixir, which I'll talk about in a moment. But another
way that they suggest you take it is before a workout. I think that's pretty awesome. I think it keeps your energy steady. You know, you don't feel a slump if you work too hard or, you know, if you feel like you're not working enough. I mean, I just, when they call it magic mind, I don't think they could have a better name for it. I just think it's, it's magical and it makes you magical too. I think of it as a secret weapon. That's, you know, that's how I think of it. And I hope that you'll give it a try. We, the sleep elixir is magical. I don't remember if I mentioned this last week.
Or not, but, um, a friend's grandmother swiped a few of her sleep elixirs and fell in love with it and ordered some, but didn't wait to get the code. So she paid full price, but you know, you can even go back and use the code. If you already, if you used it before, uh, we started talking about it. Cause I'm now, you know, an ambassador and I have lots of privilege and you saw my license plate. It says, you know, um, magic mind ambassador. Um, yeah, I can park wherever I want. It's like having a handicap space, except it's better than that. Yeah. Except I'm not handicapped. So magic mind comes in, um, 15 bottles or 30 bottles, the sleep elixir.
Also comes, I think, in only 30, but I could be wrong, but they are both magnificent and they are the perfect bookends for my day. And if you've already subscribed, but you can still get the 20% off for every subscription is TIPSIS20. And coming up, there's going to be for only 10 listeners, there's going to be a really great 40% off code. And that's coming up in the next few weeks. You can go back if you ordered it before and became a subscriber before the 20% off code, you can go back. It's delivered right to your door. The subscription, the ease of the subscription is it comes once a month. You can cancel at any time. There's no questions asked. You just send them an email and say, I'm either pausing my subscription or I'm stopping my subscription. They don't ask you any questions. There's also a money back guarantee if you try it and you don't like it.
you know, you can send it back, but I think you're going to love it. Sweet. I think you're going to love it. It's, it's a company that I believe in so strongly and I know they're going to probably come out with more stuff. It's all natural. It's good for your body. It helps you get all the vitamins that you need in your day in a small two ounce drink. And it's delicious. Unlike the sleep elixir, which is a little bit weird, but also my friend's grandmother, it likes it. Oh, okay. So it could just be me. It's just a little vibrant for me. Vibrant. And I thought I was going to love it because it's purple, but you know.
I love the green. The matcha flavor is delicious. So try. I know you and me both. I really like that flavor. I really like it. So this is not the typical episode that we would do here because I don't do missing persons. And even though I guess technically she's still missing, I just feel like this story is so fascinating. And we alluded to it last week. It's the recent story of Michelle Vanek, the hiker, the 34, sometimes called 35 year old hiker who went missing.
in 2005 in september of 2005 and it's odd that part of uh her gear was found in september of 2024 wow yeah okay almost an anniversary yeah you know so 19 years ago i feel like the best way to understand the story is to go back i went back to the denver post in 2005 and found because i wanted to know what had been done what they talk about in the present is what was done to find some items of hers but i wanted i had too many questions about what happened for her to have gotten into this position sure And she had gone hiking with a friend. She was, by all accounts, really healthy and athletic. She was a marathoner. And her friend, Eric Sawyer, was a veteran hiker. He had climbed, I think it's 38 of the 50 14ers. They call them 14ers. They're 14,000 foot peaks in Colorado. Wow. Yeah, he is a veteran of like 38 of them. And I guess he wanted to make this one like maybe 39.
It is the mountain peak called the Mount of the Holy Cross. And they started on a, you know, windy September morning at 630 a.m. And it was like, in my mind, a series of things that contributed to what happened. You who listen to this podcast know that you will never hear a story about Melissa being. you know, lost as a hiker, because if you do something terrible has happened and someone has drug me up to a mountain and dumped me because I don't go outside unless I have to my part, my car in the garage of my house. And if I have to go outside, I typically run from my car to whatever venue. I don't like the outdoors. I do not like, I mean, I, okay. So here I walk my goddamn dog every day, but you know, on the sidewalks all around. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yeah. Joshua knows. It's not like I'm, I'm going into, you know, the woods, right? No, it's, it's sidewalks, walking paths. Yeah.
I don't like the outdoors. I love it. I love sitting here. We're on the second story of my house. Looking out the window, there's beautiful trees. I love that. Your neighbor's got trees poking out. You got your purple flowers. Yeah, I love that. Seeing it through a window or a French door, I love it. Don't need to go out and be in it. I don't like the heat. I don't like dirt. I don't like bugs.
I'm not trying to get you on a hike. Yes, you are. Secretly. You're like, come on, Melissa. Let's go for a hike. No, I know. If the report comes back that Melissa was hiking with a new friend. You're calling the cops? No, no, no, no. Question a friend harder. Yeah, lean on them. Yeah. Yeah, I am not going. I do actually have hiking boots, and I got them to go on a search for a person who was missing. Not me. I don't like. Anyway, not going to be me, but Michelle.
And the things I found out about her were so sweet and loving and heartbreaking. She's married, happily married. She has four kids from ages one to 16. I mean, and you know, she's, she and her friend, Eric had been planning this hike for almost a year, almost a year. Okay.
So he is this experienced tiger and she's like a very healthy and shape marathoner. And sometimes things happen that you can't prepare for. And I guess it's just going to it's going to go bad. Even people who ostensibly should be fine. It's a one day hike. They're not going and camping overnight. Yeah. You know, they're going to the top of the Mount of Holy Cross and coming back down 14000 foot peak, which also means that's a lot of elevation shift in one day. Right.
Thank you for bringing that up. I think that might have contributed because what she did was say, I am exhausted. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, you know, from just driving, driving up the hills to Big Bear or whatever, your whole body is like out of whack. Right. Feels differently and your ears pop and yeah. Yeah. Your intestines become a liquid. Well, you see, you look at the Lay's potato chips bags and they get inflated. If you bring a full bag, so you're, you're driving up the hill and I say Big Bear, cause I did that drive a bunch. You bring a chip bag.
The chip bag looks like it's about to explode. It's just super inflated. I did not know that. Because the pressure inside is down the hill pressure and the pressure outside is up the hill pressure. Wow. So it looks like it's about, I mean, it looks like you flick it and it'll pop like a tin of biscuits or whatever. Does it stay that way the entire time you're elevated?
Yeah. Cause they're, cause they're, my, what are you? Mylar? Not mylar. Yeah. Oh yeah. They're kind of mylar. Yeah. They hold the seal really well. Yeah. Wow. Okay. See, you're telling me something I wouldn't know because I wouldn't know. But that also happens inside your whole body. You've got air pockets all the way through. I was thinking hard to breathe. I know people that have a hard time breathing in Colorado. The air is thinner. There are fewer, there are fewer of all of the air molecules. Right. So you have to. The lower humidity. Yeah. You're okay. You're out of breath already. Yes. I think that's what happened. Yeah.
That plus a plus, plus, plus. I mean, it was a, it was like a series of unfortunate things that happened. So they, they start early together. They park and they couldn't find the correct trailhead. Oh no. They go on a, they find a, a longer, um, way around instead of, um, instead of the one they were looking for, which is called the North Ridge route. They found the halo route. Okay. That sounds bad. Like a halo's at the top. Right.
Okay. Yeah. So that's right. So they're trying to make this a one day hike. And Eric Sawyer is like moving and thinking, you know, we're going to make it. Realizes that Michelle did not pack enough water.
She was out of water by noon. She's wearing thin black, like stretchy pants, a thin windbreaker, a hat. And she had gotten new hiking boots. Her husband said that she was so excited. They went to several different sporting goods stores to get poles and new boots. Brand new boots. Okay. Yeah. It's, you know, she says she's four. How long is the football field? I do this every time. She's 400 yards from the peak. Okay.
i seem so close i know i mean i know i get that it's not right you've been hiking all day 400 yards from the peak because people are like why did he leave her why did they why did this happen why did they do this why you know if he's experienced why and i think he took a lot of heat you know and he feels and felt really bad so she insisted that he go on she goes i have to rest yeah so she sits down on a rock and says he says wait right here i'll be back and we'll go down together right don't even start descending yet right He makes it there. 400 yards. 400 yards. But here's the thing. Because of the peak where it is, she is out of eyeline. Okay. Trees in the way or switchbacks or whatever. Okay. So she is out of his sight. She's supposed to be sitting there waiting on a rock. He gets to, according to the sheriff's department, the peak. Right.
at 1 42. I don't know if he took a picture, some sort of timestamp. Okay. There is a couple that are up there. They took pictures of each other. Okay. So there's proof that he, you know, got up there. Okay. So he comes back and she is nowhere. Nothing of hers is there to be found. Did he say how long did he estimate how long he left her or that? I don't know, but if she's out of water by noon and they still keep going.
And he reaches the peak at 142 and it's 400 yards back to where he left her, which is about what? Not quite a half mile or something. So yeah, not even. Yeah. Okay. So it couldn't have been too long. It doesn't seem like that long. Right. It seems like, okay, 400 yards seems like, all right, I'm done. I did it.
I basically got to the top. I got to sit down. Hypers are competitive though. You go ring the bell, sign the logbook, whatever it is that you do at the top. Take a picture, right? Sign the logbook, that's funny. I don't know what happens up there. Pee off the side. I've never been up there. Yeah, me either. But okay, you go do it, come right back. Like I basically did it. Right. I mean, for her to give up, I think she had to feel really bad because she was not a giver upper. Sure. A person who birthed four babies from ages one to 16, who is a marathoner. Yeah, no, she's not going to give up. Yeah. Yeah, it doesn't, I don't know. That's why in my head, I'm like, okay, 400 yards. There's, I would think, all right, I did it.
Not that I'm giving up. I just didn't. I would feel like I gave up. Yeah. And I would also be fine with giving up. No, no. Me would give up. Me wouldn't start. But if I started it, I would keep going. You'd have to ring the bell. Yeah. Or pee off the side or whatever you do. If I start it, I'm fucking finishing it unless I'm in bad shape, which I think she was. Yeah. If I can't physically do it anymore, I guess I would stop and go back. But I would kick my own ass for so long. If this was something I cared about, why do you think I'm still bowling every week?
I hate pulling. I tried to figure that out so much. Yeah, me too. I gave up trying to figure that out. Me too, my friend. I can't get inside here as I'm pointing to my head. Yeah, because I don't want to quit. I'm not a quitter. I could easily quit. Yeah.
Oh, I know how easily you can quit. Yeah. Oh, really? What's that mean? I don't quit. What are you talking about? You just stop going. Oh, that. Oh, you know how the royal you can be done? Just don't go anywhere? Okay, thanks. Thanks, doctor. Okay, anyway. I'm a quitter. You're not a quitter. You're not a quitter. I quit real easy. I know who you are. You're not a quitter. Not at all. So.
Okay. So she's there and I think she's really kind of exhausted. Sure. Yeah. He comes, yeah, he comes walking back down trying to, you know, to connect with her. And it's like, did she stumble and fall? Did she try to get up and walk? And she went on the wrong route. You know, what, what happened? The, the witnesses who saw him earlier and took, you know, they swapped taking pictures. They heard yelling and they thought that it was help, but he was saying Michelle. Oh, he was shouting. He was shouting her name. Yeah. Yeah.
It was a couple, Bill and Julie Taylor. And according to them, he was only at the top of the peak for five minutes and then headed right back down. So she couldn't have been. Yeah, they just took it. What? Doesn't take that long to pee off the side. To pee off the side. Yeah, you can pee quickly. And they took each other's pictures and he headed back down. And then, you know, they exchanged pleasantries and then they hear. Did they take a different path?
if you get to the top at the same time, weren't you hiking the whole way? No, he got there and they were there. They were already there. They were hanging out. Bill and Julia Taylor were already there. They got to the top and they're like, okay, let's probably stand in there taking pictures, resting. They got there earlier than them. He said it took, another thing that was a problem is that she was habitually 60 to 80 feet behind him and he was trying to slow down. He said, I thought we'd get up here much sooner. She was really lagging for a while. And he, you know, he said.
And then that makes sense. If she's like, all right, I'm done. I'm going to sit here. And he's like, okay, cool. Are you cool if I go? No, she insisted. He said, let's head back down. And she said, no, no, go ahead. You're this close. You go meet me back down. Yeah, 39. He had 38 of the, it's actually 53 of the 14,000 or peaks in Colorado. So he runs up, takes his picture real quick, comes back down. Right. And she's gone.
Oh, man. And Bill and Julia Taylor hear him screaming, Michelle, and they think that he's yelling help. So they head back down and they're like, what's going on? And he said, my hiking partner is gone. Oh, man. Yeah, and then what do you do? Well, here's- Do you hang out and try to find her there? No, you look until it gets dark and cold. And I'll explain. It was Colorado's largest search and rescue event. Oh, man. Yeah. So here's poor Eric Sawyer. And he said, I had a bad feeling when we got here at 6.30 a.m. Oh, no. I had a bad feeling.
They start hiking and he, they had started again on the wrong trail. They went a longer, more difficult route rather than the, the halo route rather than the North Ridge. You know, poor Michelle is moving much slower than he had hoped and, you know, dragging. He forgot his lunch and some other supplies. She only packed enough water until noon. Didn't pack enough water. I guess they have those things called camelbacks. It's like a water bladder. It's in your backpack and you kind of have a straw coming. Oh, maybe. Yeah, maybe that's how it works. I don't know. Well, that's how some of them work. Okay. Yeah, I just thought it was like. It's basically the whole back of your backpack. It's a big bladder. Okay, yes. They call it a bladder, like a water bladder. Yeah, I didn't think about the straw. That makes sense. It kind of comes down the strap of your backpack. Yeah. This little thing. That makes sense. Yeah. Hmm.
Okay. I was thinking old fashioned, like it's hanging off your back and then you bring it around, you have to unscrew a thing. But yeah, it makes me, that's like, you know, from the civil war. So yeah, this is, that's a much better. Yeah. So she only had a small camelback. Okay. I don't know how much any of them hold. I don't either. Hers was too small, but he should have known. I don't know. You know, you're planning it for a year and a half and you're forgetting stuff. Are you dressed incorrectly? Yes. That's the next thing. So Ben Vanek said she was so excited about going on this hike that they went to several sporting goods stores the day before to get her the right clothes for the occasion. How webs.
Eric Sawyer takes a picture at the beginning of the trail of Michelle Vanik, and she's wearing a light jacket, a hat, gloves and black stretch pants. Not the clothes that they had just bought. Well, yes, but I don't think they bought the right ones for the weather. I think they, you know, yeah, she only had her ski poles and a small camelback water pack that she ran out of by noon. Oh, OK. Yeah. He he says, I just had a bad.
A bad feeling when we started, I left my lunch and my water purifier in the car. We started on the wrong trail, a much harder, longer trail. You know, poor Michelle is lagging, you know, 60 to 80 feet behind him. Yeah. Within 400 yards of the summit, she's like, I can't go on. And he's like, okay, wait right here. I will meet you and we will descend together. The sheriff's department verifies that he got to the summit at 142.
So the president of the Colorado Search and Rescue Board, Howard Paul, at the time, remember this is from the Denver Post in 2005, he said separating is a common and sometimes critical mistake. Michelle found herself in a position where she can't be seen, you know, and it could have been because she fell, because she started moving, because she decided she couldn't wait any longer, you know, and then she may have just succumbed to the cold. It's a, you know, a chain link of events. And, you know, maybe if your partner were there next to you, these things wouldn't have happened. I just, I hate to say that, but. Well, I mean.
so many so many of these stories are the the cautionary tale or whatever and this okay buddy system right like if you're doing something dangerous yeah or potentially dangerous potentially even though you think it's not you think it's just you being out in nature i mean okay dummy yeah that's just that's we learned that in kindergarten right yeah and we're gonna actually hear some tips hiking tips that i just feels very you know like common sense that you should know but So Julia and Bill Taylor said, you know, he was only at the peak for five minutes. He seemed, you know, rushed because he wanted to get back to his hiking partner. That makes sense. Yeah. And then they hear him yelling, Michelle, instead of help. So over the next seven days, there's 700 searchers in the area. Whoa. Dog teams chased down her scent. Climbers scaled the broken ridge lines that were all rock. Volunteers streamed down into every drainage and as many as five helicopters at a time buzzed the area, including one that used a device designed to detect any heat source on the ground.
Wow. Early on, the searchers found a watch hanging on a tree and it gave them false hope that they were on the right trail. And friends, family, other hikers, just in large numbers, take a look for her. You know, it's like the days turn into three days and four days and then it becomes more complicated because how do you manage efficiently all of these people that are looking for her and keep them safe? Right. There's danger there too. Right.
Rescuers were told, you know, she's in good shape and keep that in mind because they had found a woman who was lost in the same general area eight years earlier and she survived for nine days before they found her. Oh, wow. So, you know, it was like, keep going. Right. Here's some things that complicated even more. On the first day of the search, rescuers encountered a mysterious backpacker. He was coming down the trail that they were heading up and he refused to talk to them. He hid behind a tree and then ran down the trail when they tried to talk to him. Oh, weird.
This is from Deputy Steve Wilson. He said there were reports that he defiantly refused to talk to them. Searchers later encountered a tent with a light on, but the person inside would not respond to their questions or open the tent's zipper. The next day, sheriff's investigators meet someone who they think was the same person from descriptions. He would not provide an ID.
He reluctantly said, my name is Peter Martin. And then he refused any further questions, but they really don't think that he was involved in Michelle's disappearance. They just think he's a weirdo. He's just a weirdo on the mountain. Right. Okay. So that night, September 24th, 2005, a storm brought a torrential rain and snow and searchers began to lose hope because she was dressed in these black stretch pants, a windbreaker, a hat and gloves, and really didn't have any extra food or clothing.
So Eric Sawyer was asked by Detective Doug Winters, why didn't you prepare her better in case of emergency? And he said, it was only a one day hike. We weren't packing for all of this other stuff. You know, apparently if you're going to be hiking in the back country, they say there's 10 essentials, which we're going to go over them at the end. But extra clothing, food and water in case you run into trouble. I mean.
That makes sense. So when Detective Winters gets down to it and asks Eric Sawyer, did you have anything to do with Michelle's disappearance? He said, I'm stopping the interview. I'm not going to answer any more questions without an attorney present. Smart. Yeah. Detective Winters said, you know, we just don't have any evidence that he had anything to do with, you know. Right. I mean, it does. To me, it's obviously you interviewed. You lean hard on the friend for sure. But yeah, from from everything you're saying, it doesn't sound like.
my suspicions aren't on him. Right. But yeah, that's, that's the smart move is you don't, don't accidentally say something that's going to incriminate you. Especially a woman that hasn't been found for 19 years now. Right. You know, you could have been the entire time hanging on, you know, and we don't, we really don't know, even though there is a followup that just happened, which I'm going to get to, we still don't really know. Yeah. So Michelle's husband, Ben told authorities that I know Eric Sawyer didn't do anything to harm my wife, but he made an awful decision to leave her there.
if she was, you know, if she was not feeling well, she may not have been thinking clearly that, you know, the different oxygen. I mean, you know, Michelle's father declined, you know, to talk about at the time he said, this is still too early. So they're still, you know, four days later, they're still looking for her and they find a duffel bag with a shotgun off of a trail and they, the family ends up paying for, um, a helicopter to, you know, that's looking out down and everyone's like, why can't you find her? And the searchers are looking, you know, from, from the vantage point, the camera of the helicopter. And they're like, Oh, people that are walking look like little, little dots. Oh.
They figured out the perspective of these big boulder fields and something called couloirs. They're spelled like coulier. I looked it up. It's C-O-U-L-O-I-R. Couloirs are like a gully that you can get down into the water. So there's people looking in every gully and every boulder field, and they just look like little dots. So it's like, you know what? The perspective does not make this an easy mission. So on the fifth day, there's 336 volunteers, trained rescuers.
They make a final push to find her. And by the end of the day, the family agrees and detectives agree. We're just going to have to call it off. Oh, God. That's heartbreaking to make that call.
The detective said a lot of people came out and said, we're willing to go back the next day. And he said, if you can show me a clue, if you can show me any reason why, I'll crank this thing back up. But we've never found a ski pole. We've never found anything. Typically, if we do, that would give us another week of sustainability if we had one little bit of evidence. Yeah, if you have a direction, anything. Right, right. So here we are, September of 2024.
19 years after her disappearance, a team of all women volunteers, mountain rescuers, have found likely clues to where Michelle Vanek was all along. Okay. Here's this mother of four, you know, hiking with her partner. You know, she says, I can't make it. He says, stay behind. I'll be back. And she's never found again.
The only clue that was ever found was a boot found by a hiker in 2022, and it turned out to belong to Michelle. No other items in 19 years had been found. But last fall, the head of the Vail Mountain Rescue Team, Scott Beebe, has a dream, and his dream says, Michelle Vanek's soul, remains, and body don't want to be found by a man. Wow. I think that's super weird. But he asks the rescues service chief of staff, Emily Brown, would you lead a new search with a female perspective with only women? And I can't believe it, but it's day one. She puts this group together and they have all of the information that everyone else has had over the years that were searchers. They find them the route. They studied maps, try to figure out what could happen.
Jennifer Perogues, a Veil Mountain Rescue member, said, we thought we were looking at maps sitting in a building and there were plausible explanations. But once you're up there and you're in the zone, you can say, no, that doesn't seem likely. And you can really narrow down your search area. The boot that was found in 2022 made them think of new areas, but they know they wanted to start from the last place Michelle was seen on the rock by her climbing partner. This new information really just kind of created a blank canvas to start thinking outside the box, said Jennifer. After months of planning, the team went up when the snow melt was greatest. The team started where she was last seen, then split up and took their own roots down. We stood exactly where she was, walked presumably her exact trail as a woman from the perspective of a man with the instructions of a man, and it led us right to her stuff. Wow. I think a woman's perspective changed things. Wow, that's amazing.
Erica German and another rescuer made the discovery. The last thing she was wearing was a red shirt. We saw a little bit of red material and then we saw one of the ski poles that was hers. And it was such a moment. We are used to looking at this in a photograph, but seeing it in real life, it was unbelievable. We both started shaking and we said, we have to sit down for a moment. We're not in the most stable terrain and we needed to get our wits about us before we did anything else.
So the discovery of the ski pole and her clothing, also a pack that contained her blue hat or a blue hat identical to the one she had on. It doesn't answer what happened. But everything matches the picture that Eric Sawyer took of her at the trailhead, the last picture. And everything is getting forensic testing right now to see if it's a match. But the likelihood of it being from someone else is pretty low. The hat was in a pack that looked, it was exactly what she was. And the picture, the hat, you know.
Eagle County Sheriff James Van Beek said he had kept a map of the search area on his wall since he took the job more than 10 years ago, just as a reminder. And a statement, he really, I will tell you, this man is a beautiful speaker and he says things that as a family member of someone who's missing, still missing, but hopefully it gives you a feeling that nothing nefarious happened, but you still don't know. But the way he speaks is so... thoughtful and authentic and poetic. It's beautiful. In a statement, he noted the women involved in the recovery of Vanek's apparent belongings were all volunteers who have full-time jobs and families. This discovery is heavy and is felt deeply in our community. Michelle has been close to all of our hearts since the moment she went missing. We owe this group our deepest gratitude for the sacrifices they've made and hope they continue to inspire. Apparently, Ben Vanek and the kids are very, very thankful also.
This is very interesting. The area of the discovery of the items is being kept under wraps and being guarded because investigators need to further study the area. Sure. One thing recognized by the searchers was that the location where her partner left her ultimately was not far from the trail. It was right, you know.
she could have gone down. Yeah, she may have. I've been at that spot before and I didn't think about her then. I think what was really shocking on the day that we searched, being where she was, to see how close the trail was that she could have been heading down. You know, reading the story, it was like, why would they ever split up? And being in that exact spot, it was like, oh, of course, because the trail's right there, it would have been hard for her to get lost, but they weren't thinking about, you know.
how she was feeling, maybe physically. The women on the team are glad to have figured out where Michelle Vanek was probably the whole time. Those searches we go on, you don't find people the first day you go home and you can't sleep at night and you think what happened to them, says Jennifer Perog. I'm really honored and glad that I can bring closure to some people, family, friends, rescue workers, and the 800 plus people that have been searching for her for 19 years. Yeah, the sheriff said each item that was found serves as a reminder of the strength of the human spirit, the unwavering dedication of these volunteers, and the enduring hope of a family waiting for answers.
While these items are undergoing forensic testing to confirm their connection to Michelle, the emotional weight of this discovery is already deeply felt. These personal items are tangible connections to a life that touch so many. What a beautiful, yeah, beautiful way. So, you know, I will never be found on a hiking trail. And if I am, there is definitely something afoot. So here is some tips from this rescue organization back in 2005. I just, I thought a lot of it sounds.
I don't know, like condescending. Always stick within your ability level and know when to turn back. Remember, I thought this was an interesting way, but remember the top is only halfway. I guess that means because you got to go back out. That's true. Yeah. Yeah. You got to get back to your car. Right. Every step that you take out, you got to take. Right. Do your research beforehand and be clear about which trail you're planning to take. Carry a map and a compass in addition to using GPS navigation, which they mentioned. Garmin makes something called the in-reach messenger that lets you send texts even if you're in the back country. Okay.
That's it. That's it. Pack the fucking essentials. It's easier to get lost on a 14er than a trail through the woods. Though true lines vary from region to region, any 14er is bound to take you up above tree lines. Once you leave the trees, any soft, well-maintained paths tend to give way to boulder fields where you have to rely on rocks to navigate. That can be tricky and disorienting. And many unsuspecting hikers have planned, have spent an unplanned night out in the cold as a result. So, I mean, you know, if you're a hiker, God bless you.
I can't imagine what that's like. Yeah. Walking my dog is about all I'm going to do. I don't like it outside. But I know me. I'm a klutz also. I would trip and fall off of a cliff. It would be terrible. It would be. I just. Yeah. Yeah. If you're ever going missing in that way. You'll know. Yeah. Somebody did it. Yeah. I just I wish I could be a nature girl. I'm just not. I saw a shirt I really wanted to get one time and it said indoorsy.
Yeah. I'm very indoorsy. I like flush toilets. Oh yeah. Oh yeah. Showers. Yeah. Beds that are comfy. It's not like a bed of like twigs and leaves. Sure. Yeah. Covering yourself with a blanket of moss. No, not happening. Toilet paper. I like that too. Yeah. Real nice. Makes you feel all fancy. Yeah.
Okay, so that is the story of Michelle Van Eyck, the update. And we're going to hope that more things are found. Maybe something that, you know, it sounds like the pole and the clothes are really going to be tied to her forensically. But knowing that she could be found, if not scattered by scavengers, it would be nice to know nothing nefarious happened. And I kind of think nothing nefarious happened. But, you know, until there's some sort of definitive proof, it just really sounds like a series of terrible events that ended up, you know, taking the life of somebody who was...
a very toned, athletic, prepared person, but obviously not prepared for everything. Yeah. And it sounds like, I mean, they weren't, they weren't specific about where they found this stuff, which of course they won't be. They're trying to keep it secret, but it sounds like it wasn't far off the trail. So, so either she said, okay, cool. I got this. You know, she, she took her little break for a minute and then said, all right, I'm going to, I'm going to follow, I'm going to follow him back up. Or she said, okay, I took my break. I'm going to start heading down. So I don't.
delay him coming back down and he'll find me on the same trail and she was positive she was going to be on the same trail but maybe wasn't right and that that in in her delirium or whatever which lack of oxygen yeah lack of water she missed the trail and then like you said something happened slipped fell something people say to me all the time people don't just go out in the wilderness and die yes they do It is so much like the fact that this other woman eight years earlier had survived nine days. God bless her. I don't know how she did it. Maybe she packed a whole lot of water and snacks or something, but it is so easy to become dehydrated, disoriented. You lay down, you think you're going to rest and you fucking die. Yeah. People don't realize that they, it always has to be murder. It doesn't. Yeah. Murdered by nature. Yes. Mother nature is a bitch. You're smart to stay. Do you want to come hiking? Yeah. Come on. Come on. I gotcha. Come on.
Mother Nature is horrible. I don't like her anymore. Yeah. All right. If you have a tip on a missing person or unsolved homicide, or you just want to suggest a case to us, please call us at 832-TIPSTER. That's 832-847-7837. You can always email us at JTTipsters at gmail.com. You can find us on any of the social media platforms, Just the Tipsters Facebook page, at JTTipsters on Instagram, at JTTipstersPod on Twitter, and more cowbell. If you would like to support this podcast and get early access and other cool murderous swag, go to patreon.com slash Just the Tipsters.
if you like the show please take a moment to rate review and subscribe it really does help the show to grow thank you for listening