When it comes to playtime, my dog, Bingo, goes all in. So he needs high-quality ingredients that can do more. That's why I feed on Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula, made with real meat, wholesome grains, fruits and veggies, and all the vitamins he needs. For us, choosing Blue means choosing a lifetime of zoomies, long walks, and plenty of belly rubs.
Good boy! Love them like family. Feed them like family. Learn more at Blue Buffalo dot c-a.
I'm Tia Rosa, Mexico City Can't Hear You, and she's the one on mute. Can you hear me? Download the Remitley after day and keep your long distance game strong. Remitley, trusted by millions to send billions worldwide.
An eye for an eye podcast contains subject matters that many may find disturbing. Listener discretion is advised. A little bit safer. I'm totally safe.
I'm still. I refuse to live in fear. I hope so. Oh, you're gonna be there.
Ah, you're gonna be there. Okay, I'm not sure what I'm here today. That was right. I mean, it wasn't too bad.
What you said right there, honestly, didn't make me sad. So we'll continue on. Okay. Oh, we, oh, boy.
We, it's good on Pokemon. Alright, everybody. Back to the next one. I heard my podcast.
I'm your host, Lisa, and I'm here with you, boy. Madi Ice. Hello, everybody. We're back.
We are back ready to attack the next case. Last week we covered Mary Bell. Thank you guys for your feedback on the case. We had very much patience.
We had so much feedback. I know we seem to be begging, but it's very, very helpful when you rate and review our podcast. Not only does it help our show get noticed more in iTunes, it just really helps our souls be lifted to the skies. It's critical for us.
And the feedback doesn't always have to be positive. No. For feedback. So it's like, whatever your brain's telling you, when you're listening to the show, type it on up and send it on over via Sitcher, iTunes, Podbean, whatever you listen on, I Heart Radio.
We're on there. We're on Spotify. I was told this week that my voice makes me sound like a vampire. Yeah, we wanted to shout out.
For that reason. We wanted to shout out some people out. Yeah, so this is gonna be a little shout out corner real quick for the people that have loved and supported us and have really been vocal about it on all of our social media accounts, Instagram, Facebook, on Apple iTunes, on different reviews. We want to shout out to you guys out.
So the first one that Matt mentioned, we want to shout out is our good friend El Niño. El Niño. Okay, Athena. Athena killed us with her comments.
So she's so amazing on our Instagram account, which is iFriPOT if you want to follow us. But that's a good place to go because we always post visuals of who we're speaking of. Just because I'm a visual learner, I'm a visual person. I like to see who the case is about.
Yes. Matt, tell me what she said about you. Oh, man. I got it.
I got it pulling up here on my phone. It was truly incredible. She's a background. She messaged me and she's like me.
She wants to see visual. Like a visual. She wants to know who's speaking, who's behind the voices. And so I posted a picture of Matt, curled up in a ball over her Majesty's pleasure, sentencing, which if you don't know what it is, go check out episode 11.
We discuss it because it was what ended up happening in that case. It's actually pretty cool sentencing. And as Matt says over and over again in the podcast, it's something that would chill him to the bone. And it literally did.
So we posted a picture of him being chilled to the bone and she is my favorite person on planet Earth now because that's what she said. That is, I was in tears at work. I could not stop laughing. My boss even had to make a comment.
Like, are you all right? I was like, man, I can't even tell you. Oh, it was not as glorious. I've never seen it.
Out of context, it just sounds weird, but it is hilarious. Do you have to pull that? I do. You have to pull that.
So it's just so great. It's so good. I cannot, I cannot, I can't. So the tagline under this post is when Matt was having an existential crisis over what the sentence Her Majesty's pleasure meant during recording episode 11.
And Elinio, our good friend, comments, this isn't Matt. It can't be. It's true to God. It's me.
In my head, he has a beard and shaggy hair, maybe a peach fuzz mustache and is always chewing on a toothpick. My favorite part. With a sexy condescending grin and an intense stare. And I thought he might dress like a vampire.
Oh my God. Plus, his voice is identical with, with, yeah, CA Conver. What the hell? Speaking of that, check out WTH3.
All of you guys, please check it out. Are many stars. Thanks for ruining my vision. Elinio, I, I, I cannot lie.
I haven't laughed that hard in a long time. That had me dying. We love you in your comments. You honestly want to be on your face.
And that one hands down will probably always be the best one. Totally made my day. Honestly, if anybody talks that you guys will be on another level because that was amazing. So thank you for that Elinio.
Mind you, I can barely grow facial hair. This is the truth. I'm 26 and I still struggle to grow facial. Thank my voice like makes me look like because she said, so I posted a picture of myself after from my blem and goo to Instagram page and my eyes missing.
And she said, I always knew you were gorgeous. And I'm like, I love this girl. You're just such a cute songy now. You'd be like, mmm.
We can work on it. All done up. I can understand though. But thank you so much for that.
Thank you. And saying that ruined your vampire dreams. I do apologize about that. We had to shout out a few more people real quick.
So we really wanted to get a huge, huge, huge shout out to Rachel Gregerino. I don't know if I fucked up the pronunciation of that, but she made our bad ass new cover art for all of our podcasts. We got three actually from her. So you'll definitely be seeing all three of those throughout.
As we continue to grow as a podcast, they are the most amazing. If you need a graphic designer, that's who you should go to. Her information is going to be in the show notes of every single episode because now she is the face of every single episode. And we absolutely love her designs.
We actually couldn't even decide ourselves. We had to have a vote. And people were torn. It was literally a 50-50 split.
It was bananas. But we love you. Thank you so so much for the badass logo. We loved our old logo, but it didn't meet the criteria size-wise.
And then it got fuzzy. So we just wanted to change it up a little bit, make it a little bit more clean, more logo-y instead of picture-y. But we love our last logo. We love these logos.
If you have any art that you want to send our way, or designs that you think would be cool for our podcast, please send them to us. We're on Instagram, Twitter, Facebook, email, iFriPod at gmail.com. Everything is iFriPod. So we want to shout out a few people who have been consistently interacting with us leading us reviews just being so great doing above and beyond to make us know that we do have listeners.
And we're not just talking to each other. And that's it. So we want to shout out Maggie. Of course, I'll meet you again.
Aye, aye, aye, aye. Chelsea, Nadine, John Nathan, of course. Uh, Angela, of course. We want to shout out Madeline.
We want to shout out Jennifer. GS-489. F-S-D-A-S-A. That's cool.
Yeah, whatever day you choose, that's fine. We have JS-59-217-R-2017. Five Smiths-01. And Kate.
So we love you all. We're so happy that you've loved us reviews and comments and you've really been such a blessing to our podcast and we hope it continues. We hope we make you proud. If there's anything you ever want us to do or change our case, you want to hear.
Well, anyone, especially you guys, let us know. We love the communication. We love the constant feedback. And we love you.
We just want to say, we love you. Now, real quick, I want to get into something a little bit more serious before we get into the case. Matt and I are doing an episode in the next coming weeks regarding the recent- Public outcry and exposure to the overwhelming, obviously, pandemic that's been going on of women being abused throughout the world. And then- Mainly women.
Mainly women. We're trying to be very frank on this podcast. So we really want to make an episode a little bit more serious about an episode, of course, because as much as we want to take these seriously, we do like to have a little bit harder to banter. But this situation is serious.
It's been going on probably for centuries. I don't know. I've known about sexual abuse, harassment, all of the above forever. It just comes with being a female.
I don't know if you can relate because you are a man. But I'm sure you've heard about it. You've seen it yourself. And it's such a hard topic to cover, but it's something that needs to be spoken about.
It needs- And now it is. And now we have celebrities speaking out. We have athletes speaking out. We have people with such serious platforms speaking out and actually making movements.
And so we'd like to be a part of that. Obviously, we don't have that high of a scale, but we'd love to just have our voices out there as well and say we support you. We love you. We want to share your stories.
We want to have your voices heard. And if you're interested in being a part of that episode, please reach out to us directly. You can email us at iforipod at gmail.com. We have a lot of different things that you can help us with if you don't want to speak on the episode that's absolutely fine.
If you don't want to share a story that's absolutely fine, there are ways you can help us bring awareness to such a serious matter. And really the most powerful way to do that is to have this interaction, to have this conversation, to have this engagement. So if you would like to talk, you can message me, direct message us on any of our social media platforms, or you can email us and we'd really appreciate that we'd love to get in the conversation with you guys directly one on one, as much as you're willing to share, if you have different networks that you could connect us to, we absolutely love to hear from you. And this is something that we really don't want to play around with this subject.
We really want to make this a powerful episode and an episode that reaches everyone. Absolutely. So we just want to shout that out. So if you have a story you want to tell, want to be part of the project, have information, have resources we'd love to hear from you in any other ways that we discussed just a minute ago.
Absolutely. Any feedback that anybody wants to offer. So we're going to make this episode as public as possible and the best way to do that is to have as many voices as we can heard. Yeah.
Absolutely. Yeah. So just let us know. So let's get into today's case.
Let's dive around. We're still on the 12th fucking it up since day one. Alright. Today's case everybody.
So we're getting into it. So if you're true kind of junkie like me, I'm sure you've heard of this case. And this is the quintessential I for an I case. And you know what I mean by the time we get into that part.
But there are really, I would say three different opinions on this case, but there's two very, very, very concrete sides of the fence and both have good arguments. So let's get into it. Yes. Let's dive.
So Byron David Smith, if you guys know what I'm doing, I'll get ready. So Byron David Smith, he's now 71 years old and he is an Air Force vet and is retired from the U.S.D. department. And he was, he worked in the security engineering office.
So he did his time in the government, did his time in the military. Old man. Now he's 71 years old. All of this takes place when he was about 65.
But that's something to keep in mind. He's an old man. Not that that really takes away from the crime. No, it doesn't take away from the crime, but it makes it different.
Yeah, well for sure. Because the heart, pulls the heart strings a little bit if you don't. That's right. Totally does.
Smith was a well-trapped out man and he had been to cities such as Moscow, Bayon, and Kapei, and he was all over the place again because he was with the Air Force. And he did stuff with the U.S.D. department. Smith, Minnesota and home was known to have been burgolized on numerous occasions.
And they reported at least half a dozen times that his house was broken into and shit was stolen. Among the items stolen in these slew of robberies that had happened to this man's house. And mind you, this man lives alone. I don't believe he was ever married.
I do not believe he has kids. And if he does, they do not live with him. He has a loan in this house. But among the items that were stolen from Bayon were thousands of dollars in cash.
The watch his father had received after spending nearly a year as a POW in World War II. Metals in Ribniz and had earned in the Air Force during the Vietnam War. Several firearms in a lot of jewelry. Now the firearms is where some of the arguments come into play here too.
Yes. To keep that in mind, firearms, guns, weapons were stolen from this man's house. That happened. And I'm scary.
Yeah, multiple occasions he was dealing with burglars. Yeah, I mean this wasn't a loan. And the fact that there's still weapons in this house. That makes you feel like they're going to come back for more sinister reasons.
Because why do you need to steal guns? What do you need that for? Once you're selling guns and money and jewelry. And I mean there's a lot of stuff.
What else are you looking for? Yeah, why would you steal someone's medals and trinkets from being a POW or being a vet? That's just sick. That's just horrible.
Why would you steal? First of all, what are you going to fucking do with that? Can you pawn that stuff? I don't even know.
You can. Yeah, I mean anything can be flipped. So let's get into the crime here. Or the quote unquote crime because some people don't believe that this was a crime.
And that's what we're going to go into. So on November 22nd, 2012, which is if you didn't know back then, it's Thanksgiving Day. And this is actually my freshman year in college. This is recently.
Only a few years ago, only six years ago. Now, so it's a fairly new case. I remember that too because it's the laws. The laws are ever changing however it wasn't that long ago.
So think about it as it happened now almost. So on Thanksgiving Day, Hayley Keefer, who was 18 years old and a cousin, Nicholas Brady, who was 17 at the time, broke into the home of Byron David Smith, who was M65. Now, as we stated before, he had been used to this happening over and over and over and over again. They were not the first people.
Well, they might have been the actual people but this was not the first time. Might have been their first time. It was his first time. He was carrying a gun around his home.
Yeah, he after the first couple of robberies, he walked around strapped is what he said. And obviously that means he had guns on him at all times because he was presumably fearful. So video surveillance because he, a lot of being strapped up, walking around his own home, which is a horrible way to live. Sad, honestly, he felt that insecure in his home.
And beyond that, he did have videos to reveal and set up around his perimeters of his property. So he could see when these people over trying to break into his house, because this happened way too many times for this to, you know, fly with him anymore. So video surveillance did catch the teens casing of property prior to breaking in. Now, the two teens believed the home was empty and there was no, because there were no vehicles.
So the two teens believed that the home was empty, presumably because there were no vehicles present on the property. And this will also come into play later. They would be very starting to say goodnight. So little did they know Byron David Smith was home on Thanksgiving Day by himself and he was able to get out of the house.
By himself and he was sitting in his basement with a Ruger Mini 14, which is a guy. Ruger. Ruger Mini 14. Seemingly in wait for the people to who broke into his house to wander down to meet their fate.
So he was there this entire time he was watching on surveillance cameras. And he actually, it almost felt like he was pretty much preparing for it. Yeah, it seemed like he was almost anticipating this happening. I mean, almost like a final showdown.
Which is sad, not happening that often, that you can anticipate when it's going to happen. Yeah, he kind of expected it. Like that's a problem in of itself. Exactly, I totally agree.
Because normally when anyone's burgled, they're not expecting it. That's not something that is a commonality in most people's lives. So he was sitting in the basement, kind of like a sitting away. Like he was almost like a hunter waiting for their prey.
It's kind of how it feels. Yeah, it almost seems like he's just kind of, he's prepared for whatever happened. I mean, if anybody came into his house, he knew what he was going to do. So Nicholas Brady was the first person to come and contact with Smith in the basement.
He came down the basement stairs not knowing that Smith was there. And as he made his way down the steps, Byron shot him three times. When he fell down, he hit the bottom of the stairs and he shot him twice more. Smith also set up a handheld recorder on a bookshelf which captured audio of this.
You can hear him saying you're dead. That recorder captured that audio right before he shot Brady and killed him, right? I mean, right before he shot him. Yeah, so the reports basically say that Brady was coming down to the basement and guess to try to steal some stuff.
Didn't know Byron was there. Byron was sitting in a chair with a gun at the top of the stairs. He shot Brady. He fell down the stairs.
He shot Brady at the top of the stairs. He fell down the stairs and then he walked up to him and shot him in the head. And he said before he shot him, you're dead. Yeah.
So he said you're dead and then phew. And that's all I'm reporting and we'll get into that in a minute because, yep, so don't. So he put Brady's body on a tarpon dragon window in another room, sat down again and waited with his weapon loaded. And ten minutes later, of course, more shots are then heard on the audio and you hear a kyper scream.
And then you hear the, obviously, her dropping falling down the stairs. And at that point, no more shots are because Smith's rifle jammed. And then he had to reload another weapon this time, a 22 caliber and shot her multiple times. And at that point, he says again, you're dying, followed by another gunshot.
So then he, apparently that shot did not kill her though. Mm-hmm. And it ended up being a moment later that she died. When he dragged her into another room, she gasped for air.
When he realized she was still alive, he fired what he just arrived as. A good clean finishing shot under her chin up into the cranium. Yeah, so he realized when he had been dragging her into other room to lay her next to her cousin's body, that she was still alive because she gasped for air. And so he reports that he fired a kill shot basically into her head to finish her off.
He didn't, he claims that he didn't want her to suffer. So he wanted to kill her quick. And so that's why he fired that kill shot into her head to end it. But mind you, he shot both of these teens multiple times.
Several times. It wasn't just like one shot self-defense. No, several times both of them. Yeah.
And there was some evidence from earlier that day that Brady and Kiefer, Kiefer, committed at least a couple of the previous break-ins and were being investigated for prior burglaries, including one earlier on the day that they were killed. So they were being investigated for some of the break-ins on his home and other homes in the neighborhood. So that's something to keep in mind as well. These two were known by the police in the area for prior instances of breaking in and one of two of which were in Byron's home.
And they were seen on video casing his house. And mind you, he was watching them. Kind of reminds me of the Grinchy, not how he has like, and this is such a weird comparison. You know, like in the Grinch, he's like in his lair and they're like, don't know that he's watching them.
Very good. And he's like, how's that telescope watching them? I'm calling him up the mountain. Like, he's like casing them out.
It's kind of like what Byron was doing. He was kind of sitting away. He was watching these kids, you know, get ready to break into his house which had happened so many times before. This is the part where I want to give a warning.
For anyone listening, we are going to play some audio that he recorded that day throughout from here on out of the podcast. It's, I think, important to hear to make a case. Yes. We described it.
So, you know what you're going to hear? It's sad. It's scary. And it is like the end of these people's eyes.
So I don't want to take that with a grain of salt. But I do think it's important to hear what we're talking about in this recording. Now, as Matt mentioned, Byron had set up, it's like he set up a little shop in his basement. He had a recliner.
He had all of his guns. He had water bottles around him. And he set up a recorder. Now that recorder captured a lot, a lot, a lot of audio before after enduring the incident here.
So, I want to play a little bit about for you now. And I want to hear what, you know, if you guys have any opinions on it, just for warning, I would say over this part, it was a sound captured by digital recorders that he strategically placed around his home that served an ear witness to the shootings. So, Smith could be heard talking to himself. Now, like I said, the following is a very disturbing audio clip.
And so I'm just warning you now. That was amazing. That was part of the gazillion hour recordings that he made. And to be honest, listening to it again makes you kind of sad.
And like worried and nervous and angry. Like it elicits all kinds of emotions because it's like there's so many sides to what happened here. And we'll go over those in a second. So, basically in the first clip, you heard, you hear Smith say, I feel a little bit safer, not totally safe.
I'm still shaking a bit, but a little bit safer. I left my house at 1130. They were both dead by one. I refused to live in fear.
I felt like it was cleaning up a mess. Worse than spilled food, worse than vomit, worse than cleaning up a mess, you're dead. He repeats sentiments like the above multiple times to the recording as you've heard. He says, I feel like I was cleaning up a mess.
Not like spilled food, not like vomit, not even like diarrhea. The worst mess possible. And I was stuck with it. I was doing my civic duty.
It is the law enforcement system. I had to do it. I had to do it. It's the law system.
And it fell in my lap. And she dropped her problem in my lap. And she threw her problem in my face. And I had to clean it up.
I have not yet called the sheriff. They weren't together. I don't see them as human. I see them as vermin.
And he said again, it's all fun and cool and exciting, highly profitable until someone kills you. I try to be a good person. I try to do what I should be friendly to other people, help them when I can, try to be a good citizen, not cheap people, be fair. And because I try to be a decent person, they think I'm a patsy, I'm a sucker.
They think that I'm there for them to take advantage of. Is that the reward for being a good person? And they dunk this mess on me? It's not a mess like food, he repeats it all the time.
Not a mess like vomit, it's not even a mess like diarrhea. It's far worse. Then they take a slice after slice of me. And if I gather enough evidence, they might be prosecuted.
If they're prosecuted, it might go to court. If it goes to court, they might be found guilty. And if they're found guilty, they might spend six months to two years in jail, or to a year in jail. And then they're out.
And then they need money worse than ever. And then they're filled with revenge. I cannot live a life like that. I cannot have that chewing on me for the rest of my life.
I cannot. I refuse to live with that level of fear in my life. So that's part of what you said in that long recording. And the bit that you heard it was a little bit fuzzy, I'm sure because his recording device was in 2012.
That's through three recording devices. Here's your phone and our recording device. Before we get into all sides of the fence, we're going to go over the investigation a little bit. Matt, take it away.
Yes. Well, let's get into the actual investigation. The deaths were not immediately reported to police. Please keep that in mind.
Smith waited until the next day to let the police know that he had shot these two kids, claiming that he did not want to bother the police on Thanksgiving day. Morrison County Sheriff Michael Wetzel has acknowledged that Brady and Kuifer were there to burglarize Smith's residence. So has been acknowledged by the police investigating that that was the intention of these. That was the intention that they were there to steal from him.
Brady's sister later claimed that Brady stole drugs from her home two months earlier on August 28th in a case that was still under investigation. Smith's statements to police describe delivering killing shots to the heads of both victims after he had shot them on the stairs and they had fallen to the basement floor wounded. So he shot them to one of them and then finished them off. And he admits that openly.
That was not something that was ever in question. Part of his admission, which maybe I'll try to find an audio clip of it, his excuse after the fact was because he didn't want them to suffer anymore. Like he couldn't see them suffering. So we want to get a look of it.
That's what he said after the fact, mind you, that is not the ramblings you just heard were also after the shooting. So it's pretty much two sides of the fence and I don't know what the reality in his mind is. But just so you know, that's what he told the detectives is why he fired the kill shots. Right.
Which is a little bit ironic, I think, but we'll talk about that a little later. So in his statement, Smith said that, I'm sorry, that Kipher had let out a short laugh after she fell down the stairs. He heard that and he said, if you're shooting somebody and they laugh at you, you go again. The audio tape, however, did not record Geever laughing or at least it didn't pick that up.
Instead she was crying, oh my God, and was obviously in fear. Which you guys heard comes back and said on the audio tape of that happening. So in interviews with police Smith did acknowledge that he fired quote unquote more shots than I needed to. And that he fired again quote unquote a good clean finishing shot into Kipher's head.
So if you're wondering why this case is so back and forth, I hope you took it in from the beginning, but if you didn't, it's because of the Castle Doctrine Law or the Stanger Gown Law or the Protect Your Shit at All Cost or Shit at All Cost or Shit at All Cost. Right. So pretty much every gun out on the planet Earth, I swear to God, has this has the same mindset has the reason they have a gun in the first place for protection, right? And the law states in a lot of places.
If you are threatened in your own home, you can use lethal force, right? If you were threatened in your own in your own place and you are being actively threatened, you can use lethal force and it not become against you, right? So the Castle Doctrine debate has to do with the Minnesotian, the Minnesota Castle Law. Now legal analysis have stated that the initial shooting most likely would have been justified under the Castle Law, but the subsequent shots were not justified once the threat had been removed.
So you have to think they were coming down his basement stairs. He shot them both at the top of the stairs once, right? Or twice. And they fell down the stairs, still alive, but very badly wounded.
That is where the legal definition of the Castle Law draws the line, right? If that stopped there, then he probably would not be prosecuted. He wouldn't even be brought to trial, I don't think, because he was protecting his home. He was two people were invading his space in his home, encroaching on his, you know, they're to steal his belongings and he started his ground, right?
But those finishing shots that he admits doing and the shots that, you know, the three more shots that he fired kind of negate the Castle Law because it's once the threats were moved, it's not justifiable anymore. Now the Castle Doctrine is also known as the Castle Law or the Defense of Habitatian? Habitatian. Habitatian, yeah, all right.
The Defense of Habitatian Law. Now that's a doctrine that designates a person's a voter any legally occupied place, aka a vehicle or a home. I didn't know a vehicle was part of that, to be honest. Yeah, if you own it, it's your possession technically.
So if you're in your car, you could technically shoot someone and... Well, they try to break into your car. Oh, okay, it is. That's what the statue is, yeah, sir.
So it is a vehicle or a home as a place in which a person has protections and immunity is permitting one in certain circumstances to use force up and including to deadly force to defend oneself against an intruder, free from legal prosecution, for the consequences of the force used. Now, a person may have a duty to retreat to avoid violence if one can reasonably do so. So you can't just go around shooting people because they walk into your home, regardless of the situation. That's just not exactly how it works.
If you were able to, like say you're seeing your friend or someone breaks in your back door, I don't know if that's a really good example, but basically if you were able to get away, that's step one. That's choice one. We want to choose to get the fuck away from the violence, right? We don't want to flee towards it.
We don't want to kill people nearly when they walk into our home unless it's causing an immediate danger to you. So they do say if you were able to retreat, because that will take away the castle law if they find that you were able to leave the situation and not have to use the deadly force to get out of it. The castle doctrine negates the duty to retreat when an individual is assaulted in a place where the individual has a right to be, such as within one's home. So, maybe my example wasn't correct.
Deadly force may be justified in a defense of justifiable homicide applicable in cases when the actor reasonably fears imminent peril of death or serious bodily harm to him or herself or another. Justifiable homicide inside one's home is distinct as a matter of law from Castle Doctrine. They're two different things. Because the mere occurrence of trespassing and occasionally a subject requirement of fear is sufficient to invoke the castle doctrine.
The burden of proof of fact is much less challenging than that of justifying a homicide. In regards to Byron Smith, Hamline University School of Law professors of Olson stated, I think the first shot is justified after the person is no longer a threat because they're seriously wounded and the application of self-defense is over, which is what we're talking about. Now, a number of aspects in this case were noted by police as being inconsistent with self-defense, which is why this turns into an issue. This whole case, thinking about it from outside and two kids coming into robbie, you should come dead because they're trespassing in your home and it pauses.
You don't know what threat they posed to you, you've had guns stolen from your house. In his scenario, not only did this apply to almost kitchen the balls with how many different statutes from this apply to his scenario. But then there's the flip side of it. So, there are the inconsistencies with it not being premeditated.
So, the evidence brings out some inconsistencies in the self-defense argument. Smith moved his truck earlier in the day and he claimed it was to clean his garage. However, prosecutors of course believe it was to mimic the look of him not being home, to kind of bait people who were going to burglar his house because it looks like he was not there. So, that's why prosecutors believe he did move his truck.
However, he believes or he doesn't believe. He said it was merely to clean his garage. Another issue that the prosecution had with the case was that Smith recorded at least six hours of audio on that digital recorder we were talking about in the basement of his residence. The reason that's most shocking is because in the recordings he is heard saying things that could be deemed as kind of preempting what was to come.
So, he was sitting in a chair at the bottom of his stairs with a loaded rifle, a tape recorded that captured not only the shootings, but a weird wild monologue that he had. And I'll try to find a little bit of clips of that. Chris, stop by tomorrow morning. No rush, but still inconvenient.
Can you do that? Yeah. 100 yards in the corner and walk in from the west. I realize I don't have an appointment, but I would like to see one of the lawyers here.
But prior to the break-in, he has heard on the recording saying, in your left eye, I'm mumbling to himself, I realize I don't have an appointment, but I'd like to see one of the lawyers here. So, the prosecution noted that he was reciting, that he needed to speak to a lawyer, hours and hours and hours before this shooting happened. So, their case was that, why would you need a lawyer if people are bringing into your home and you're not following the law? So, that's an interesting point that they made, is that the things that he was remembering to himself prior to the shootings were definitely negating parts of the self-defense claim, because why would you need a lawyer if- He's already preparing a defense, it seems like, in some ways.
He knows he's doing something questionable morally, and obviously one of the big tenets of our law is, do you have culpability? Do you understand your guilt and what you did was wrong? It seems like he did know that. He was preparing for that.
And another thing he said was, in your left eye, and it was found later, that Kiefer, Kiefer, was shot in the left eye by Smith, and alleged that the other statement was a rehearsal, like I said, of what he was going to say to an attorney indicating that he knew he was going to eventually need an attorney that day. Let's get into trying on the work, we'll wrap this up and talk about what we think happened here. So, Smith recorded statements, the evidence indicating he had planned the shootings alongside the excessive number of shots fired led to the charges brought up of second degree murder. Smith was initially charged with two counts of second degree murder, however, in April 2013, he was indicted on two counts of first degree murder, so they did change it from second degree to first degree.
They did, because they said it was not only planned, but that he lay in wait and- Yeah. So second degree murder, for those who don't know, is to my knowledge, you weren't planning it, but what you did ended up in someone dying, correct? Or was I like a spur of the moment killing, right? So I think that would be manslaughter, no.
So the murder too is, is it's not aggravated, there wasn't an intended designed killing, but you did kill somebody with the intent to kill them, and made sure that they died. Yeah. You know, it's not like you hit them with your car and drove away, like you had a killer manslaughter would be or something of that. But manslaughter means, you know, your actions caused a person to die.
Murder means- And it's bad to kill. No, murder means you intended for them to die. So second degree murder was you did intend for them to die, that it wasn't as elaborately planned out. And first degree murder means that you essentially set it up for someone to be killed.
You were the playbook. While also intending to commit a crime in the meantime to cover it up or to- I'm going to think about that part too, it's a covering and it was also a crime. Bill was set for Byron at $50,000, which he did post. Now on April 29, 2014, he was found guilty on two counts of first degree murder with premeditation and on two counts of second degree murder after three hours of dirty- Depilations, dre-de-la-ration.
So I always get so confused that there's no reason they bring up so many charges just in case one doesn't get a guilty verdict and the other does. You can ask for what's called lesser-known offenses. So if you charge someone to first degree murder, but they don't believe that the statute is met to apply a first degree murder charge, but they do feel that second degree murder conditions are met. That's why they bring up like 30 different charges to see what sticks kind of- In a sense, yes, but they also have to make a case for it.
It's a more mature and thought out way of throwing a bunch of shit at the wall and seeing what sticks. Exactly. So I'm going to read you guys exactly the difference between first and second degree murder here. And this is straight off the Google machine.
We always get an answer from Google, you know. We love our own Google machine. Alright, so I love old people, man. Anyway, the most common separates murder into two degrees.
Versed in secondary, entry is voluntary and involuntary manslaughter is separate crimes that do not constitute murder. Second degree murder is any intentional killing with malice of forethought, which means you had bad intentions before the crime was committed. Is a second degree murder? But here's the difference, but it is not premeditated or planned.
Oh, so like you had bad thoughts? So you went there with bad intentions? But you didn't necessarily go there with the mind set up. I'm going to kill this motherfucker tonight.
Maybe you brought a gun with you for protection, but you didn't set it up where I know where they stay. I know where they live. I'm going to show up there and boom. So there's your difference.
It's a distinct difference, but it's a very- And it's something that like maybe, I mean, I didn't know the specifics between the two, so it's definitely something I'm sure listeners will appreciate having that little bit there. And one day we're going to have to get my uncle on this because he's a criminal defense lawyer. So anyways, so my name is Smith was immediately sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. Now it was stated by the jurors that the audio recordings were named as the biggest influence on their decision.
Now I'm going to quote one jerk here and he said, his name's Wes Hadlstad. He was one of the 12 jurors on the case. And he quoted, that was the most damning piece of evidence in my mind. That audio recording of the actual killings and the audio recording of Mr.
Smith's interview immediately after Zorzaju will play pretty much convinced me that we were dealing with a deranged individual. It needs to be noted that Byron David Smith has tried to appeal his conviction and that has not gotten him anywhere. That's not worked for him very well. This is where the debate comes in.
Now there are kind of three parts of the debate. And we're going to get into it with each other and we're going to get into it with some people who have weighed in on the case themselves. Now the one side of the debate, I say there's three different parts because there's like a little middle area, right? So the one is, homeboy was self-defense.
He was, his house was broken into, he was acting in self-defense, they broke into his house with the intention to do who knows what. I'm assuming, Robert, who knows they spoke on from him before, he was protecting his property. He is a hero, is what people actually say. Second is, the man was fed up, scared, tired of being abused by these neighborhood kids.
Tired of the police not doing anything about it, because clearly it had happened many times before and nobody was arrested. The charges weren't going through fast enough or something was not being done. And then, in a time he took it into his own hands. So that's the second point.
And then the third is he committed a gold blood murder, he over-killed, he's a murderer, he's disgusting, he killed two teens. They weren't going to do any harm, they were stealing stuff which is like some bullshit thing. You know, it's not that huge of a deal, he's a monster, he should be locked away for life. So those are the three sides to the debate here.
Now, the Harman Law Professor, Joseph Daly, commented that the laws surrounding the case were dividing the little false community. Because he said in some states, someone breaks into your home and you were allowed to shoot them dead, period, a.k. Texas. Texas has that kind of law where he was.
Well, just standing around law, I mean the most recent, famous case was, obviously, Trayvon Martin, I was saying, you know, it's testing, the George Zimmerman, shot Trayvon Martin in Florida. That was between your... Yes, but he was in defense of his neighborhood. He was part of a neighborhood watch, whatever was.
I didn't know that was the count. Oh yeah, that was his defense, the trial wasn't a standard ground law. I mean, we're definitely going to talk about that consistently. But yeah, in Fox News host John Hannity, if anybody's not familiar with John Hannity, supported Smith's actions on his show, actually, inside the fact that they broke into his house.
These two kids were in his house in their robbery. They were stealing from him, and the police chief acknowledged that, that they were there to commit a crime, to possibly steal from him and possibly hurt him. We don't know. I mean, I got even took it a step further on, John Hannity's show, saying, the guy should get a medal of freedom for what he did.
Yeah, I mean, there's a Facebook page dedicated to Byron that calls him a hero, and it has almost 300 likes and followers. Which is, so, as you see here, there's very distinct sides of the fence, and there's that kind of like, I agree with this is why. So, speaking of Facebook page... There's a great middle ground there.
I mean, we don't know. Yeah. I wanted Matt and I to read a few of the comments on that Facebook page, because like Matt said, it's literally called, it's calling him a hero. And I want to show because on the Facebook page, of course, there's both sides of the fence, right?
There's people that believe he should burn in hell, and there's people that believe he should be given that medal of freedom. Yeah, but he did a good first of all, yeah. And I thought it was interesting to read some of these quotes from these people. Now, the about me on the Facebook page does read, I think that people who get caught breaking into other people's homes deserve to be murdered without hesitation, without mercy, by any means possible.
Home invasion is a growing threat, and places you and your family at risk. Standing your ground is a good thing. Byron David Smith is an absolute hero for standing his ground and eliminating a threat to his home and property. Now, that's the about me of the Byron David Smith as a hero Facebook page, and Matt and I are going to go back and forth and just read a few little comments here from people who have vastly different opinions back and forth about that.
So, Matt, do you want to kick it off with the first one? Certainly, well, Lisa. As far as I am concerned, those two teenagers were simply nothing more than terrorists. They were deliberately targeting elderly friends and neighbors who were under medical care for their medications and neighbors who had hunting rifle firearms.
My concerns may seem to be overly drawn, but I shudder to think about what those two and others involved with them may have actually been involved in. So, I'm saying a little stretched common terrorist, but I do see the points on both sides, don't you? And we'll discuss how we personally film a second, but don't you see these? They are making good arguments for both sides.
So, another comment says, for killing the time 18-year-old girl after his, oh, mind you, this is directly from Facebook, so any typos are literally from people's comments. So, she said, for killing time 18-year-old girl after his gun jammed makes Byron Smith a piece of shit murder. So, I'm guessing what that means is his gun jammed, she had the opportunity to realize what he did, and she was still living at that point, and said he went around and shot her anyways in the face under the chin up to the cranium. That makes him a murderer, it's pretty much about missing.
No, the next one. I just listened to the documentary. They claimed that he enticed them into his home. How?
By sitting in his home reading a book? They broke a window, and both of them came into his home uninvited. Actually, they were going to rob him again. That's a good point, because so many people are lying in the way, but how would you know someone is...
Obviously, he saw them in his house, but he didn't know on Thanksgiving on this day they were going to come back and try to rob me. How would he ever have known that? That's not something he'd find. That's what I mean.
I don't think he was sitting there. That's the thing. You almost want to think that he was sitting there waiting for that. He was probably sitting in his basement watching TV, or reading a book, or doing something, just hanging out by himself on Thanksgiving.
Wasn't he a widower or something? There was no mention of spouster kids. Someone was Thanksgiving. It was Thanksgiving.
You would assume that there is some reason he was chilling in his basement. I don't think he was just hanging out down there. But then the other guy moved his car. That's true.
We'll go over that. We'll go over that in a second. So, another one says Byron David Smith is a coward who baited and shot two unarmed teenagers. I'm not much of a death penalty guy, but if anyone deserves an assist piece of scum, what a danger he is in a form...
What danger was he in from an unarmed, terrified woman who was lying on the ground after already being shot and begging for her life? Anyone who thinks this guy is a hero needs to take a long look at the mirror and look at the evidence. He could have stopped after shooting each one of them once and called the police, and ambulance, and the kids would have lived. And he'd be a free man.
This guy was sick in the head and plans to commit the murder. I mean, his gun jammed after shooting the girl once and he pulled out another gun and executed her while she's her begging for her life. He's also on tape saying you die now and talking before and about shooting someone through the left eye, which is what he did. To an unarmed woman, coward.
You people must think Brock Turner is a hero too, huh? How does this page even exist? If he was a friend or family member of mine before this, I'd be ashamed and he'd be dead to me. So, that was one of the more passionate ones.
Wow, that one had a lot of uh... And then I would read the next one so I can read the last passionate one. So, we each get a passionate person in here. So, the next one says, this is a great transgression of justice.
He was in his own home after the break in previously. He did not go out after these two. He was a home owner in his home. I cannot leave Hugh Street at this time.
I don't like him or his victims. What he did was wrong, but I also believe Hayley and Nick had a lot of culpability for their own deaths. Perhaps that was down to drugs or not having a fully developed frontal lobe. Who knows for certain?
But what I do know is that the Kuiper and Brady families are never going to convince a majority of the public to see their kids as sweet angels who made minor mistakes. They were a pair of punks murdered by a guy who became paranoid in large part because of Nick and Hayley, and all helping him to make him that way. No amount of references to wholesome yearbook pictures and how the two cousins laughed and played a lot, etc. is going to change that.
So, wow, very, very heavy there. I sincerely hope there is never another program produced about this case. What? Sorry.
One just ended on ID and I changed it as soon as I realized it was about these murders. Maybe like asking for quoting you directly. Yeah, hopefully I'll listen to this and be like, oh shit, I'll say that. And then the next one says, and I think it's important to read these because it is like back and forth on the case and we're getting to the end of them and then we're going to discuss I for an eye.
But the skumbags targeted an older vulnerable man. He was white in middle class. If he had been black, he would not be in jail. Well, I wrote the question marks because what the fuck?
Yes, he would be. If he was black, he would have been in jail when he bled. What are you talking about? He would have been in jail if he was black.
Yeah. This person's a little backwards. This person's a little backwards. There's so much injustice towards our black brothers and sisters that it's literally, I don't know what that comment meant.
So, next one is on you, bro. Anyone who gets into your property breaking crystals is a thirad. Threat. Well, she meant to say thirad.
Threat. What she said. It might have been you. How are you supposed to know they're unarmed?
How? Especially in a country where everybody has a gun. Good point, girl. You just had one chance to know it and you'd better shoot first.
For much less, many people have been killed by police officers in the USA. Like a deaf man who just did not follow instructions. What a coward in criminal murder against humanity. Black gentleman who did not open the door and was executed by a police officer of a university.
Yeah, big threats. Do you mean to say thirads? I don't know. She means thirads.
She's just twice. Yeah, she did this twice. I don't know. Yeah, big threats.