Skip to content
Sportswashing Simblified episode artwork

Nov 1, 2021 50 min

Sportswashing Simblified

from Simblified Hosted by IVM Podcasts

The Simblified quartet get together to discuss the phenomenon of Sportswashing illustrated by the recent Saudi takeover of Newcastle United Football Club. We highlight how political soft power is gained and human rights violations are masked by simply owning a team of a few men running after a ball. Join us for an episode on a complex and controversial topic that even triggered an outburst from the typically serene Naren. Add one part news, one part bad jokes, one part Wikipedia research, one part cult references from spending too much time on the internet, one part Wodehouse quotes, and one part quality puns, and you get Simblified. A weekly podcast to help you appear smarter, to an audience that knows no less! Your four hosts - Chuck, Naren, Srikeit and Tony attempt to deconstruct topics with humour (conditions apply). Fans of the show have described it as "fun conversations with relatable folks", "irreverent humour", "the funniest thing to come out of Malad West" and "if I give you a good review will you please let me go". Started in 2016 as a creative outlet, Simblified now has over 200 episodes, including some live ones, and some with guests who are much smarter than the hosts. Welcome to the world of Simblified! You can contact the hosts on: Chuck: twitter.com/chuck_gopal / instagram.com/chuckofalltrades Naren: twitter.com/shenoyn / instagram.com/shenoynv Tony: twitter.com/notytony / instagram.com/notytony Srikeit: twitter.com/srikeit / instagram.com/srikeit

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

The Simblified quartet get together to discuss the phenomenon of Sportswashing illustrated by the recent Saudi takeover of Newcastle United Football Club.

Ready to play

Sportswashing Simblified

0:00 50:41
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

I, V, M. So anyway, we are reunited all four together after a brief hiatus from the last week's episode, which had a conspicuously absent Tony, who was skipping on his main job and doing a site business working in a big tech firm. But he is back. And yes, so let's begin with, so this topic is going to be around sports.

So let's start with a sporting link question to each of you, which is the your fondest sporting memory, the one sporting memory that you that you that you work the most emotion and your fondest voting memory. So, as a spectator or as a player, I'm glad I have a player. I swear that's a question on my head. Yeah, either one, whatever floats your foot here.

But ideally as a spectator, we fail to the topic more as a spectator. Okay. I'll go then because I have one. It was when my hostel in 2006 in Kerala, all of us were waiting for ball by ball updates from the one friend who had a TV for the for the greatest ODI, second greatest ODI of all time, the Australia South Africa 434, 438 game.

And we were jumping up and down to yours of joy. It was, yeah, that was my favorite sporting memory. Very, very international of you to have your greatest putting memory, not in all together. See, see, see, the thing was that those want a surprise, you know.

Oh, that's a lot of that. That should be a lot of the words. Actually, I learned so much finesse by freelancing now. Which also follow up for invoice also.

Anyway, please remember like early on I asked you, what is the international behavior that you gave one full rant about how countries don't matter. No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no. He's refined his approach. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

Yeah. Go ahead, Narin, your memory of the most important. It's been an 1980-free one. So once we had gone to, I was a little kid.

I was a little kid. I was a little kid. I was a little kid. Does it involve any venture of any sport at this point?

Yeah. Go ahead. So I watched my rent chair to a statement hunting. He was the guy who drew the paintings.

Sorry. So this was must have been before 1980. I don't remember the girl. We were gone.

I remember going to a porn stadium and watching Farruk engineer and Sunil Gavaskar face a West Indies bowling attack if memory serves right. So the first time we'd seen, I'd really seen people bowling really fast at that speed. I can't for the life of me recall with the bowlers. I guess it was holding in Robert's foot.

And so the memory is Gavaskar hitting what about his drives and things like that. And the sound it really carries on a cricket ground and he's back then at the end of the day. I don't know in the stadium, the racket is much bigger and whatever. But this was amazing.

When the ball hits the bat and then it rockets off to the boundary, it's beautiful. I'll make a compilation of all these sounds just being really amazing. That was a knock knock joke. That does it.

Yeah, I mean, I think we've just been blessed to be born in an era where there are so many very, very women's. We played it by 2007 when Sree Sun took the catch to in 2020 World Cup. It actually streamed it live in engineering auditorium. Oh, I was like, oh my god, it's all over me.

2011 World Cup finals I watched with my now wife, Dan Galfreid. And we'd actually like gone in the morning to one Bangalore supermarket and picked up like 10-15 breezes and stuff like that. And one night he was like, can I also join you? That sounds like a fun planet.

But I guess the latest ones are the freshest now. So Gaba was brilliant and then the win at Lord's. All of these are too many too many to come. I was there.

I was there. I was there. I was there. I was there.

I was very disappointed in Tony because I was hoping he would be the one to like break the cricketing memories and kind of give some tennis angles or something like that. Yeah, favorite sport related memories that we was actually taking my dad to. Rolangarov. Oh, you went right there.

That is truly one Tom God that you grew. You know what is this is my favorite sporting memory now, discussing our favorite sporting memories. So for me, of course, I have a long and for most part of it very unhealthy relationship with Liverpool football club. It has only recently reformed itself.

I used to support them through some of the worst and most wretched times the club went through. So when they actually won the UEFA Champions League, which was their first trophy after nearly a decade and a half. So it was, I mean, the more important trophy later was the Premier League. Champions League was the first thing that they won under Jürgen Klopp.

And even the situation in which I watched that because I was traveling in Malaysia with my wife and we were in a place where there was barely any internet connection near the human islands. And like over there, we were like in the Ramshackle part kind of place where I was treating them like a dodgy 3G connection and I saw like Jordan Anderson lifting the trophy and stuff. So I was like, do you work up with the ocean and then I had a beach to celebrate it on. So that was when he was like, wait, what did we watch that game together?

Wait, what would be in the world? You watched all the Liverpool losses. We mentioned that we went somewhere. We mentioned that UEFA Champions League final where the Liverpool lost.

So they lost that. You were in a particularly joyful, you were also between the Jürgen Klopp slip if you remember. Yeah, that's the Jürgen Klopp slip. But Chuck's best, worst, best sport memory will be all of us together watching the 2015 World Cup final.

Oh, yeah. And then we all went out and got drunk. That is true. We did watch that.

And we also recently talked about how this is going to be a do you remember event moment. Absolutely. And now is when we remember it. This is a long intro that we were having.

So I don't know if it would have time for the topic itself. I think it should not be a break. Oh my God, bro, bro. It's really, really intense.

So anyway, so moving quickly, the reason I got into the topic which we are talking about is primarily because, again, in the Premier League, one of the clubs which is called U-Caston United has recently been taken over by the consortium, but primarily the Saudi Investment Fund. So it's a Saudi owned the exact name being the Saudi owned public investment fund, the PIF, which is 80% of the owner of the Premier League of the U-Caston United Club. Now, this is where now this particular takeover is significant for many things because of the amount of money backing that is involved over here, the state in which the Newcastle United Club is and the reactions that have come from various quarters. So that's where this angle of sports washing has come through.

And let's discuss, let me give you the background briefly, the background of what's happening with the U-Caston United. So, New Zealand United has been a pretty large, pretty old Premier League club that's been there since the late 19th century. That's when Al-Mashira started paying for them. Potentially.

Before that, New Castle was famous for being old as people carried cold too. Yes. And so, yeah, exactly. And it is that very blue-collar town, which has, it is also one of those big cities in the UK, very rare big cities in the UK that only has one club.

And because not only all the large cities in UK, like Liverpool, Manchester, London, London, as well, London has like multiples. But so, most of them have like multiple clubs, but New Castle is very famously just has New Castle United FC. So, this club obviously has been going through, in the present time, has been going through pretty rough times. They've had, they've primarily struggled, they were struggling with their previous owner, Mike Ashley, who is the owner of Sports Direct, the sporting goods chain.

And he was notoriously tight-fisted and didn't really like the club very much, I didn't want to invest much in it. But he saw it as an asset and was trying to desperately try to hock it for ages. And why this, and this has been a protracted saga for Newcastle, where he's been trying to sell for almost a decade. And in the meantime, the club has like legitimately just stagnated.

Like they've just been doing the bare minimum, there's no excitement whatsoever for the club. So basically it's not just a protracted saga, but also protracted saga because it's turned 180 degrees. Oh, my word. This is why I need to do this.

Yeah, yeah. I generally thought you would do something with new castle, old castle. I would take it different. Yeah, yeah.

Anyway, yeah. So what happened was finally after the club was stagnated, the fans were really, really annoyed. Because again, as I mentioned, it's the only club in the city. So it's not like the fans have another club to support in the city or people can turn to anything else.

If you want to follow football in Newcastle, you follow Newcastle United. And that was really, really terrible for the fans. They've had a very, very bad decade of no-no-no-no-nothing. So in the city, there is the Saudi Investment Fund, which has come in, and the public investment fund, which has come in.

And they basically were attempting to purchase the purchase, because they had it for a while. There were a couple of blockages from the Premier League and a couple of other issues as well. A lot of issues that took place that prevented this issue, but that only recently went through. And here is why it's significant.

A lot of at least football fans would remember how Manchester City transformed from a club that was basically a relegation club and nothing club into something that has, into a dominating force. It's one of the best clubs in the world now, in terms of talent, in terms of prospects and stuff like that. And that was because of the Abu Dhabi Fund investment. Now, to give you a sense of scale, Abu Dhabi Fund is worth less than $20 billion.

And the Saudi Fund is worth more than $500 billion, which is what has taken over Newcastle United. To give you also a sense of scale, the purchase of Newcastle United from Mike Ashley for the public investment fund cost $300 million. And the MBS, or Mumad Bill, I forget his name, MBS. Mumad bin Salman, who is the Premier and the King of Saudi Arabia, who is the Chairman of the Public Investment Fund, owns a yacht worth $400 million.

So did you just say that they bought Newcastle United for $300 million? Yes, they were at the Rodeo costs. No, I was about to say that's what Bijjus does, acquires for the firm. Actually, in all probability, what first of all happened was, actually there's not an original thing, I read it from the run Twitter or something, that MBS actually said Bijjus is a new car.

And it's a new car. It's something like that. So, what did you do to him? I saw it somewhere.

Oh, lovely. I mean, come to think of it with the amount of funds that he has. This is effectively like a bad Amazon purchase. Yeah, it was even that all get me new arsenal.

Yeah, it's like he was trying to order an Alexa and Alexa and sort of order something else. So it's effectively that. But yeah, so basically that purchase has gone through. So that's the sense of scale.

And so the investment that is to come into Newcastle United will probably like, and this is worth what PSG, which is the Qataris who invested in PSG, who won it. And then there is the Abu Dhabi group, which is controlling the Man City. And Chelsea is a Roman agravage. There are a Russian.

So here is where now this particular club is poised to be. And it's currently 19th in the Premier League. Yeah, I was just checking. That was interesting.

And they're currently 19th in the Premier League, which is a relegation zone, which is where they can get relegated to the championship. So the investment will is not and the transfer into is closed currently, which will reopen in January. So it's quite likely that there's going to be a lot of fireworks and some really high profile players coming in and this club like transforming quite rapidly because they need to kind of secure its survival in the Premier League first before going on to dominate it eventually. So the next part about this particular aspect is that over the coming decade, look out for Newcastle United being among the top clubs in English football over.

You're going to have a lot of Newcastle United fans who are going to turn up a lot with the Catholic supporters. And even Newcastle, even Newcastle. So yeah, so that's where the topic that I wanted to discuss really was about this phenomenon. As we talked about the Qataris, Abu Dhabi, Man City and Chelsea being owned by Russian oligarchs and with the Russian zoning Chelsea.

There is this entire phenomenon that's really taken off now with the South East coming into Newcastle of sports washing. And so let's discuss what sports washing is, what its implications are and what its examples are and how this is going to kind of like transform the way sports is over the next decades to come. But let's do that on the other side of this break. So let's see you there.

You know that feeling when you finish a movie and you just need to talk about it, that desperate need to discuss why Kalhuna Ho hates different enter IBM's brand new podcast, Sennified. It's Shrimi and Karan just yapping over Hindi cinema every Friday. Romcom's directorial debut is career defining moments, whatever they're vibing with, they're breaking it down. Join the podcast on IBM Pub's YouTube or any audio streaming platform.

Caution, you want to rewatch everything after listening to us. Come join us on Sennified. And welcome back to Sennified where Shri Keith is going to tell us about the showers that players take right after the game, which is sports washing. That also could be the kitman.

That's what he does. He does sports washing. That's his profession. So that also could be sports washing in some way.

Unfortunately, it's much more boring to give it's full definition of what sports washing really is, is the practice of an individual group, corporation or nation state using a major prestigious international sport to improve its reputation through hosting a sporting event. The purchase or sponsorship of sporting teams, but by the participation in sport itself. Originally done by Zs. Yes.

So that's why actually, no, actually, I mean, you can actually see the reputation of there and all in person. That's true. And actually, if you look at it, it is part of it. So this is where it's quite interesting that you think that sports washing as a term was only coined like in 2015.

But as a phenomenon, it's quite old. And in fact, one of the most famous examples that you can think of is the 1936 Olympics by the Nazi Olympics. Right. So the Nazi Olympics, actually, that's where Hitler saw those 1936 games as an opportunity to promote his government and the ideals of racial supremacy and anti-Semitism.

Right. So he wanted to kind of bring to for that. Oh, no other race is as superior in athletics and the best possible human form can be a champion. Not a Jewish, a pure Aryan Nazi form.

Right. And so that ideology was something he was trying to promote, which in its very premier installment itself, fell on its face with Jesse Owens, the sprinter, yeah, the black, a black American sweeping and winning over looks long. Who is the German Aryan ideal that was there. So, yeah.

So that was one of the earlier examples of sports washing. Another one, another very famous example of sports washing, which the sports washing aspect isn't as apparent is the rumble in the jungle, the fight between George Foreman and Montvadalee. The sports in Zire. And that's where the Zire, the fact that it was in Zire was because it was Fred Weinman, who was an American advisor to the Zire's dictator.

Oh, my time. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. Wow. So he persuaded the dictator to have that high profile event that would help his regime kind of like wash over a lot of his atrocities and a lot of stuff like that. So I think it was washing over diatocities in Zire.

It took its sake to his reputation was in Zire States. Thanks. Yeah. Well, at least two.

By the way, because Zire, the Congo was the successor of Zire as a country. So, yeah. So, yeah. So, I mean, that was another famous example.

And finally, you have been seeing the biggest examples of the whole sports washing phenomenon has been witnessed since the turn of the century in the Premier League, where you'll see all of these teams coming in. You're also seeing and sports washing has become a method to very rapidly gain like global currency. As you can see with like the Katari, the great example of that. Like, Katar was firstly, I mean, it has a terrible human rights record, but it was pretty much unnoticed as a country in the Middle East.

Prior to its emergence as a sporting hub with first the purchase of ESG, then the proliferation of being sport, which was, which is a massive sporting channel for global audiences. And finally, culminating in them getting the bid for the World Cup, which is, which honestly is a great example of seeing how effective sports washing is that FIFA, which is obviously a fairly corrupt organization itself, has decided to move the Olympics, especially to the Winter, yeah, World Cup, sorry, the World Cup to the Winter, which has always been in the summer to accommodate for the hot weather in Katar, which cannot be held during the summer, and to accommodate for that. I was about to say, how do you make a very corrupt, very corrupt, losing self in battle? Oh, well done.

Anyway, so that kind of led to this kind of sports washing has kind of taken over, but what are the key reasons why this is happening? Because the one thing is that there are certain studies have shown that sport when utilized by nation states can be harnessed for nation building, breaking down anti-pathy and cultivating a sense of national identity and appearing deceptively inclusive in the global context. I love that you're a deceptively inclusive, you can see actually on a micro level where Katar is work famously, I mean, as most Middle Eastern states famously anti homosexuals being there, are actually have actually struck as part of the deal that they are doing in the world. They would not be, there will be no prosecution of homosexuals within the Olympic, within the World Cup areas and stuff like that.

And alcohol will be sold in those areas as well, which will be, which is also against the rules over there. So you're looking at what they've done is they've bent the rules a little bit for accommodating this particular thing so that when people experience that particular thing, they see, oh, these are just a normal country, which allows for everything, all the good stuff, but therefore washing their reputation in that way. And this was also, this is actually beautifully encapsulated in a court by a comedian, the comedian Mark Steele, who talks about how if ISIS had been smart, it's not blowing up stuff, they have a board of football club. Then most people in England would have praised them as heroes and saviors, right?

So it actually shows how like the soft bar aspect of these countries, which are, and South Korea has been a master of it, they have been using their soft bar by initially buying weapons from developed countries and kind of skirting the criticism around their terrible human rights record about all the stuff. But initially there, but now they're trying to enter into the sporting arena. And here's where geopolitics also plays a role because it's not just the sports, which is particularly apparent in the Premier League because of the UK's current predicament. Their foreign direct investment is completely dried up because of Brexit.

And so here is where they are in a place where, so in fact, during the entire tickle, in April this year, when the Deep Court was on the rocks and the Premier League was entering the Southeast from entering there, the MPS actually got in touch with Boris Johnson and told me kind of greased the views on this particular deal. And here we are a few months later where this particular thing has gone through. And by Amnesty International and all the other bodies are heavily protesting all of this, the UK government has made a statement saying that we are not going to make a comment about this because we don't want to unnecessarily antagonize the Saudis. They have literally openly said this.

So here is where you can see how entirely the money of these countries, which has gotten by, which has been gotten through a lot of oppression, is just being very, very clear laundered is these particular expressions. Because it's mostly fossil fuels. A question of yes Prime Minister episode in which our yes minister, I don't remember, in which they refer to this hypothetical state called Qumran, which is obviously modular. So the Master of Un And like in Britain, where they commit adultery when they get stones.

But you know, sports watching is like very, very toxic trade when there is actually a red lasso. So for anyone who's not watched it is the most wholesome show that you can watch during the pandemic or even otherwise. But there's actually like a football club is owned by a Nigerian oil company, which is sort of committing atrocities and they just let go of the spot. I was wondering why nobody was replying to their nails for funding.

And that's why it also comes down to like, there's a fantastic financial times article, which I was like reading and brilliantly cutting in response to this Saudi takeover of the puzzle where they mentioned for the UK specifically, where they said, where there's a line that's like welcoming dirty money is likely to remain national policy for Britain, especially after Brexit has dented for direct investment in an ancient low skill low productivity country. The main thing for us want to buy is heritage from country houses to football clubs. So it's a direct trade. UK has pretty much done the biggest one goal and kind of through their finances altogether.

And here is these countries, what you're saying, just bother your heritage and your old football clubs and the fan global fantasies that we can get for straight up money coming into the country. But what's really interesting about what makes sports watching that much more insidious and difficult to stamp out is 97% of Newcastle United's poor fan days supported the takeover. Because when you think about it, you think about it, the fan basis, the fans just think about the Newcastle fan. They've gone through more than two decades of terrible full of stagnancy and all that stuff.

And they have seen all these other clubs like massively take off because of all the funding that they've got in like other like Man City and stuff. And the one thing that's become apparent to them is that the system, the system favors are rich clubs. You've seen Man City's got to get to take over and winning all this glory. And these all these clubs are standing by and watching them win everything.

And he celebrated as amazing team. So Newcastle United fans are like, why not us? And this is actually led to some really, and of course the rank and file fans. This is led to some really, really incredible sites like when the takeover of confirm there were a whole bunch of Jordies like Newcastle United, you guys are United fans dancing around with Saudi Arabia.

Wow. And so you have like sites like that happening and that is exactly what they want to accomplish where Saudi Arabia becomes this patron of the sport. It will also be in no being major acts of very, very savvy PR and you know, the PR agencies who do this kind of thing on the ground. In France of India.

And nowadays it's not just the press that is, you know, as famously everyone knows Facebook and other social media things. And it is how things are presented that makes now. So there is again another Yes Prime Minister reference where, you know, Humphrey tells us five questions of Bernard Woody in two different ways. And the way he asked the questions makes him in all pro or against it.

So it's how you put the thing it's, it's tremendously complex. And that's where so if you actually examine it in terms of density being the perfect example. It's the investment isn't just on the club and the players that they will bring to the club. The investment is into the city into the infrastructure to the stadium into the staff that they will have the coaching that they put there into the training fields and the stores that they put up.

Actually, if you see it actually if you see it about 97% is players salaries. So all that is just a chestnut. It's not, you know, it's not around. 200 million pound salaries.

I mean, this is ridiculous amounts for people who are just basically wandering around kicking your ball. So what you should be doing, this is what Mr. Rice me. Okay, I'm a noob.

I'm a noob. Why do you need a genius from whatever import little South American country to go. Why can you not develop talent in your own little country right there. They're obviously very talented players.

Why do you not have a hundred of them. You do not you do not you just go and catch an MR or a messy or whoever and come to play over. That's exactly what people do. I've seen you in the right.

There's a great point to that. And there was a large discussion I was having with another football fan. So, man city when they started out they bought a bunch of players and stuff like that. But now it's been a decade plus since that he got it done.

And what they did was also they modernized and really invested in their training facilities and the coaching and all that stuff. And now you have this player called Phil Fordin who is one of the who's one of England's best young players who's come from the man city academy plays for the first team. He's a home grown man city player. But this is where it comes down to right.

He's a hard working extremely talented kid local boy who's come to the academy and risen there. But there would have not been a Phil Fordin if there had not been the group investing the money and all the atrocities that the group does in the Middle East has actually filled for them who was completely unknown. Need 27 billion pounds of the kid you could buy him but like I don't know you know half a bottle of whiskey every week and he'd be yours man. Why do you need why do you need a big a big whatever.

Whatever it is. Wow. I feel very combative today. This is the most animated and the wrongest I've seen.

Because I mean two things. One obviously you being a very fun supporter of capabilities and knows that the market demands were the market demands. So if he's worth that much it's probably because someone is willing to pay him that much. I have some commonest rules on that.

Exactly. We'll see. But the second point is that I mean whether someone comes from X country or Y country I actually feel that it's a good thing that they're coming from the small donations because they actually go back and improve the state of the world. The state of where they come from.

The white York for instance has built a full sort of white York stadium and everything back home. So in fact it actually serves the countries where they come from. Yeah. I'm very proud of it.

The white York is from Trinidad and Pigo. And Maya. Yeah. And Afrika.

Yeah. I'm guessing it's a huge point for any African country when they have somebody from Senegal or Egypt in this case. Yeah. Like we talk about neither Chopra winning a gold and how that's going to change young people to aspire for.

Imagine that on the scale of much lower developed countries and international talent and not just once or twice a year someone. And it's quite equivalent in some way to let's say the which is that JSW, JSW investing tremendously in academies and Olympic Olympians. Right. Like there are a lot of talented kids in India who can take on different sports but they need the facilities.

They need the training. They need the world class coaching to really get to that level and refine their sport to that level. So that's what the Abu Dhabi group has managed to do to some extent in Manchester. But what is happening here is it's the translation and it's the digot of the two dilemma of sports washing is that.

On one hand there is all this corrupt money that's floating and all that corrupt money has created something so talented, so tremendous, so pure in its own way. So that's why you ought to be on conflicted because this fear is amazing. But it's really came from is very dicey. So this is a lovely thing.

Yeah. Right after the break. Yeah. So let's come back and continue the discussion right after the stick.

Namaste. It's a Sir Kyle. Good morning. Evening afternoon.

My podcast is titled says, no guys, no topic and no filter say from Father Brochar. That's me Monday to Friday Sunday. I'm with the kids. We chat with celebs.

You'll never meet traffic jams on streets and people from all professions. Every one day I go live with the show, ask me anything, air me, beautiful questions, I know better than a Mumbai or even host a panel discussion called COCK and BUL where we dive into current affairs and wonder why anyone cares at all. And Friday releases all the surprise episodes for you all. So tune into CyberSayers on YouTube and all of your streaming platforms.

You know that feeling when you finish a movie and you just need to talk about it? That desperate need to discuss why Kalhu Nahu hits different. Enter IBM's brand new podcast, Sennified. It's streaming and current just yapping over Hindi cinema every Friday.

I'm calm, director of your debut, skidier defining moments, whatever they're vibing with, they're breaking it down. Join the podcast on IBM Pub's YouTube or any audio streaming platform. Caution, you want to rewatch everything after listening to us. Come join us on Sennified.

Alright, and here we are back. We're discussing. Yeah, we were discussing. Okay, let me put it.

We were discussing. I was going on about why we need billions from dodgy places to improve soccer in football. Okay, now you said soccer. Now I can do better.

So in the United Kingdom, and I was like, why not invest that money in homegrown talent rather than, you know, not than importing people from overseas, which is like the standard, you know, I take, I take, I stand corrected. So yes, it's not its capitalism money will flow for the maximum effect and people who are spending the money take the decision. Sometimes it will be, you know, a high price player like Missy or some, sometimes it will be someone from the Dominican Republic or it might be someone from Haiti or wherever. And the question is the whole thing is now it becomes a very difficult ethical issue.

So we have many of when you're talking, you know, ethics like sort of deconstructed is very simple, right? So can't there's the most famous is Emmanuel camps. What is it called the categorical imperative? So categorical imperative means something you do regardless of the consequence.

It is the right thing. You have to do the right thing. And here it is very difficult to unpackage and find out what the right thing really is. So I would say just from a sort of, you know, first principle, point of view that it's wrong to take money from Dajirajeens.

But on the other hand, had it not been for that money, an entire cities or nations sporting sort of enthusiasm would go. And we know that sporting enthusiasm is what mind and different kind of culture culture and cultural thing that mind country together. The country is just a notion. It's nothing but a notion.

So sports are really important part of it. And if other countries for whatever their individual reasons might be are willing to bump in their own money, what's wrong with it. So yeah, take this discussion from it. And that's where I feel, I mean, see, it's the construct of capitalism itself, right?

You have to kind of look at the investment of money sport is always a good thing. Like sport grows, people, the communities grow culture grows. And actually sports does grow. So I will just discussing the IPL, the level of physical ability and just cricketing ability in the IPL.

What is incredible? I mean, you have literally dozens of players who are absolutely world class and would otherwise never have developed. Absolutely. So that definitely happens.

What needs to happen is, yes, you can always look at it as, oh, this money is corrupt. And therefore everything that emerged from it is corrupt. But that's in my opinion again, it's a fallacious way of looking at it. Up to if there are people who are getting rich and countries and nations that are getting rich by dodgy means, they need to be prosecuted on that.

Right. Condending the fact that they are investing their own sport and condemning the sport itself is not a pleasure. I'm guessing then she gets you feel the same way about say the Saudi funding software which can turn funds over. So this is argument that every time you use Uber, you are actually a financial system.

Exactly. And so the thing is again, we are living in a DP capitalistic system. And this is where actually one of those lines of argument which I have, which I penned down because I was thinking this is very relevant. If you compare, you look at the Nazi regime and they are now considered to be the embodiment of evil because they're because they're singular act that they were very blatantly looking at killing people.

Right. They invested money in killing people. Right. What capitalism does is that it successfully disaggregates suffering.

Yeah. Right. So you have one level of suffering happening somewhere else that's counterbalanced with a very beautiful act of creation and growth. Another end.

And the suffering gets disaggregated into so many smaller pieces that it's no longer easy to point at a single thing like a concentration campaign. Versus where you're having kids who are playing with soccer balls and learning how to play well, but those soccer balls are being shown by China, by kids who are not worthy given some kind of people. So you have these kind of dilemmas that are created by this capitalist system as such and that makes sports washing incredibly effective and incredibly hard to root out. Yeah.

But that's, I mean, in some sense a simplistic argument. Right. I mean, you know Nazis are bad because you were born like 40 years after it happened. Right now we live in a country where every institution is actually following that same path and we can't speak out about it because we'll probably face a consequences or we don't want to speak about it or equally lots of families who are well off are in favor of the regime.

That's here. Yeah. Yeah. Including the sports washing to the level of the most powerful getting body in the country has a secretary who has to be tagged with every tweet by every critter that they put out.

So and Ganguly actually sort of saying that no, my daughter is wrong about protesting against this because she doesn't know anything when she goes. So I mean, it's sports washing happens in multiple levels, but also I think it's a little simplistic to say that if we were there in Nazi Germany and we were, you know, on the oppressors side, we'd have automated that. I only wanted to highlight that. Yeah.

I wanted to highlight the fact that it was a very clear act of it. It's very easy to brand the Nazis as evil. No, even even. Yeah, it only came out later.

But even then they were active. What came out later was the brutal things they were doing in concentration camp. But even before that, people had a very good idea was of what they were doing to choose. They were basically being carted away and never being seen again.

So the question is, yeah. Yes. The point that I was making was it's not about, I'm not trying to highlight whether in hindsight, obviously it's easier to see, but what I'm trying to highlight is it's much, much more easier to brand a concentration camp as an active evil. Yeah.

And tagging your general secretary who has political connections in every week. No, and also what people don't come down. For example, China, we all deal with China. We are dependent on Chinese goods.

China is also doing some questionable things to the Uyghur population, which we really don't know because no one knows what's going on in those camps. And yet the world continues to do business with China, even though the rhetoric has escalated and there is a lot of saber rattling going around. If Chinese goods do not come to your country, your country suffers. It really suffers.

And I personally believe that whatever Xi Jinping is doing now, you know, sort of cutting back on manufacturing, getting his house in order for whatever reasons they might be, is going to really hurt a lot of countries, a lot of Western countries, because the cheap goods are not coming. So that's what happens. The moment you don't get cheap goods, things start getting expensive. Politicians get voted out of power in democracies.

That's what happens. And so it's very common. So why would a politician have any incentive to take schedules against China? Yeah, so I'm seeing the real categorical imperative is for you to become good enough to play for Newcastle and then make them lose all the matches so that it loses all their money.

I was thinking, so this is what happened to Vijay Mani. Yeah, but let me bring it back to me. So in that, in this particular thing, the one aspect that Sava Lava is reading about, about Sava Shik, Green Washing is another phenomenon altogether. But we did have another episode.

We did have another episode. We did have another episode. This is like Joey dating all the women in New York, kind of scenario. Yeah, so coming back to the sports version, the one aspect that they did point out.

So one is the Katai influence is also tremendously high in F1. So Savai is good at the Katai group. He's wanted to get added to the Katai F1 calendar next year. And so here is where that article actually brought about it.

The next great conflict is between the fact that sports and sports versus sports entities are getting more and more woke by the day. We're getting very aware of whether you see whether the major league baseball is being gained from Atlanta, Georgia, because they passed restrictive voting rights act over there to the NFL kind of sacking, just sacking a head coach because he made racist slurs about something in the past. So different different sports are now actually taking a very active stand and the sporting body that is very active stands on like social issues and stuff like that, where Premier League clubs are still taking the knee right now for games and every. And it's also trying to move beyond the lip service aspect, you know, very, very deliberate manner and they're being called out for it.

So here is where a big conflict is coming where modern sport is getting both progressive political more socially involved. And with this funding coming in over the next decade, we're probably going to see a major conflict between these two forces. There is one end of a lot of money flowing in through to be a sources and the other end of like people taking like a stand for it. So will we actually, unlike you mentioned Ted Lasso Tony, the whole not giving up to any spoilers, but they did take a stand against that particular sports watching in the investor.

And I wonder if you are probably going to see a lot more of that from both players as well as fans and coaches fans coaches and the other people involved. So that is the next great conflict to happen. Yeah, that's something you think there are any other countries or clubs that might make likely marriage partners in the next few years, like most of the golf I think you've exhausted. Yeah, so I'd say, I mean China China actually China actually majorly doing that with the NBA.

So they don't have actually and I mean I won't claim to know much more than my basic college on this but they still don't have an active investment into the NBA as far as the club already is concerned. But what happened is you can actually see a lot of so one of the club owners made a derogatory comment about China in the NBA and the NBA really cracked down on that. So they shut his comments down and all that stuff because it's a massive market there. So the NBA was involved in censoring a lot of the stuff that was happening around that time, around the conversations around the Uyghurs and stuff like that.

So that China does not get offended that biggest market doesn't go offline there. So yeah, that is a major China is exerting its influence. India already is doing that with cricket as such if you see in that way, it's a tremendously linked that way. But yeah, it's mostly in the Asian countries that are going to now.

It's the coming decade is more Asia, Invest Asia and that's going to really take off in this particular regard. And yeah, so I think that's where a sports machine gets really interesting. So yeah, I mean if you've come to a natural end over, you're at a beautiful quote that actually concluded the article that I talked about. I'll link it in the description.

We can link that in the description because it's really a great read about the new cast of takeover and like how they concluded that. Where it said, new cousin is alluregally old, founded in 1892 40 years before Saudi Arabia was founded. Right. And comes equipped with its own requisite Latin motto that says 40 year defend it defend triumphals or triumphing by brave defense, given the club's traditionally leaky defense 16 balls considered in seven matches this season, it might want to change that that motto something more appropriate.

What about Pecunia non-hotet, which is money doesn't smell. Wow. Amazing. Yeah, so that was actually a really that is a really sharp article on the Newcastle United.

So it's actually absolutely worth the read. So yeah, that's that for sports washing. This was a surprisingly like emotional rollercoaster of an episode, right? This one's in the beginning to marine spray down right in the middle.

It's like absolute as absolute disparagement of football. Yeah, let's not do it. That's very good to another. Don't don't don't arab him the wrong way.

Okay, let's quickly get to the other of this episode. Oh, wow. So you want to take a look at that. Oh, man.

Yeah. So yeah, stay safe. Stay unwashed and stay simplified. Again, I really think you need to.

Okay. This is really it's really it's really it's really it's been washed. They unwashed everyone. As long as they have toilet.

Bye. See you next week.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Simblified?

This episode is 50 minutes long.

When was this Simblified episode published?

This episode was published on November 1, 2021.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Simblified episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.