The final frontier begins. This is about saving the future of humanity. This is a huge victory for the good guys. Welcome to another episode of Beam Me Up, a Star Trek podcast. I am Brent Allen, and I have seen every episode of Star Trek 47 times. And I'm Matt Sonnenberg, and this is my first time through the series. And this is the show where we are on a mission to introduce first-time watchers to the universe of Star Trek, multiverse, to every quadrant of the Star Trek universe by watching, in air-date order, the most important episodes that deal with the lore, the history, and the timeless message of Star Trek. But if you love what you're listening to here, I recommend that you also go check us out.
on YouTube where you can get more of Matt and Brent, all the behind the scenes, all the pre-show. I guess there's not really a post-show, but usually more of us, all the interesting things that we edit out later. You can catch them all on YouTube. You can find that easily by going to be me up pod.com and clicking on the little YouTube icon in the top menu. It's over there.
I promise. Today's episode is the 16th episode of Star Trek Deep Space Nine season five entitled Dr. Bashir, I presume, or as I like to call it, the mother of all retcons. In case you didn't watch this one first in this episode, the doctor, Louis Zimmerman, arrives at Deep Space Nine to turn Bashir into the new long term medical hologram. But his research exposes a Bashir family secret that Julian is genetically modified, which is a big no no in the Federation. And oh, yeah, Ram and Lita are in love. Now, Matt, we're going to get into everything having to do with this episode. I'm sure you've got questions. I need your reaction to everything else. But I want to know just overall, Julian, this whole time has been a genetically.
modified superhuman go. Huh? I mean, honestly, my first question for you was going to be, yeah, did they actually plan that long-term or is it something they just wrote into the show, which I think you answered for me, but we'll talk, we'll talk about it. We'll talk about exactly where it came from and when they figured it out and all that sort of stuff. Honestly, though, like I go back and like, look at.
at what I've seen from Julian and, and the way he plays parts. And, and I don't know, maybe it's just the way they explained it. It all kind of made sense. Yeah. And so I guess I didn't really question it too much. It was surprising, I guess that, huh? Did you figure it out before? Did you figure it? Did you figure out what the family secret was before they specifically said it or not at all? Not at all. All right. Were there hints? Not really. I don't think so. Yeah, no, I don't. But when you like, cause now that you know the secret, you go back and watch it again and you see what they're talking about. Uh, yeah, that's more, I think my question was a long time watcher going back. Like, did you figure it out beforehand? Like, I don't remember.
You know, because I can't I can't watch it now, not knowing. And I can't go back and watch from season one to this point without knowing who he is, because like there's that whole thing that he says early on. They haven't talked about it a ton where he was going to be the valedictorian of his class, except he missed. one question on the final exam. And now he's the number two. And you're like, and he did it on purpose to throw people off the track. You know what I mean? Like it's every dark thing he's been playing. Like it's all been whatever, you know, spoiler alert for the rest of the series or for the end of this episode when I get to why was this in the run? And we'll talk about this actually even a little bit more later too. But obviously this changes Julian Bashir going forward. Sure. And I could have just said, hey, Julian's genetically modified. And you'd have been like, whoa, what? I need more explanation. Yeah, exactly. 30 second explanation. Yeah, exactly. And you love origin stories. And this was Julian's origin story. Yeah. So there you go. I mean, Matt, the thing is, though, this.
This episode came right on the heels of in purgatory shadow and by Inferno's lights. This was the next episode. And it's such a tonal shift. And I said tonal, not total. It is a tonal shift from what we got last week. I was listening to the Seventh Rule podcast, which is a podcast where Siroc Lofton, who played Jake Sisko, and Aaron Eisenberg, who played Nog before he passed away, were going through the series, kind of rewatching it and talking about it. And Siroc has kept it going after Aaron passed away. Rest in peace, Aaron. But he was talking about it and he basically discussed this was sort of like a palate cleanser from the intensity of the ones before. You know, like they needed, like they kind of sort of felt in the arc of the season. They had this big, huge thing. And this had to, you know, come back to, it's a bottle episode, right? Like everything happens on the station. Their guest star, their big guest star was under contract from the studio right next door or the soundstage right next door.
You know, so it was a lot of that. But I mean, let's be honest. This episode is just one big retcon of the character. They haven't been building up to this. This wasn't a secret that the series was hiding and that they decided now is a good time to reveal it. Alexander Siddig says that he pretty much found out about this as he was reading the script. Sure. Similarly to how he found out in the last episode that he'd been a changeling for the previous bunch of episodes. Keep that in mind. The last two episodes revealed Julian as a changeling.
And this episode now shows us that he's this big, super human, like two things right in a row. In fact, Julian was like, like he went to the writers going, I actually don't know if you went to the writers, but like, he's like, that's a crappy way to find out. You'd think if they wrote that in that somebody would call the actor and be like, Hey, just a heads up. This is where we're going with your character. But no, no, they just kept them in the dark. And he's like, and that's how Star Trek works. Matt, we've got, we've got some stuff to get to, but I do have some character actor spotlights. I want to hit. And then I do want to talk about how the story came to be, because I do think that it is a relatively interesting. And then we'll get into talking about the episode. All right. So if you'll indulge me character actor spotlights first, let's talk about Mr. Bashir. Richard Bashir is played
before i i recognize him very much he's been in everything exactly and i had to go double check to make sure it was him especially after he started talking right because in this episode he like has a british accent he has like a cockney british accent yeah yeah and i am very much used to him having an indian accent like that's in most of the stuff he plays at least i've seen him in he has an indian accent and so to his name and he like by birth i think he's pakistani i could be wrong please don't don't you know grill me if i'm wrong but let's face it his first and last name is like the whitest white name you could ever get brian george But like, it's easy for me to remember. So, I mean, I, but yeah, I was kind of surprised to see him pop up in Star Trek and not what I would have expected. I just, I can't, to this day, I can't see him as anything except for Roger's dad from Big Bang Theory. Sure. Cause that was his, that's the other role that immediately comes to mind for me now. Okay. Yeah. So, yeah. So, so like my biggest question is what does his real voice sound like? I think he is a British actor. Okay. And you know, obviously he gets played in these, these ethnic roles more often than not.
So, yeah, but that's that's Brian George. So there's I got one more. And Matt, we're going to round out the cast that is on the cover of the DVD in this episode with these character actor spotlights. It's time to talk about none other than our own Dr. Julian Bashir, a.k.a. Sadiq El-Fatil, a.k.a. Alexander Sadiq, a.k.a. Nanaa Visitor's baby daddy, a.k.a. Sid. We'll just call him Sid because that's what everybody calls him. Now, Sid is Sudanese by birth. One of his uncles was twice the prime minister of Sudan, but Sid spent the majority of his formative years in London, attending the London Academy of Music and Dramatic Arts, which is otherwise known as Lambda. I just love that. Now, as you.
may remember through the first three seasons of deep space nine sid's name credit was sadig sadig elf adil which i know you know that because you never press skip intro when you're watching the show mad um and i am not going to attempt to pronounce his full name because it's huge like yeah really, really, really, really long. But this is his name. And Sid actually says that Sadig El-Fadil is my name. That is the name on his passport. It is an important name to him. It is his family name. He says it just wasn't suitable for the screen because he's like casting directors and producers are more incapable of remembering someone's name than the audience is. So he had to just go with something familiar. So for career purposes, he changed it. Sadig, of course, is his actual first name. Move that to his last name. And he says that Alexander was really just a name he pulled out of a hat because it didn't matter at that point. It's a screen credit. That's all it is. Now, that being said, after he graduated Lambda, he got a role on a made-for-TV movie that Rick Berman happened to see.
And he loved him. Said he just jumped off the screen at him. They brought him in to audition for the role of Benjamin Sisko. of all people. And they were still trying to find him. They hadn't found Avery Brooks yet. And they loved him. Their only problem was he was 25 years old. He was just too young, they said. Right. So they hadn't cast the doctor yet. And they're like, that actually could be a good role for him if he's just fresh out of out of medical school, fresh out of Starfleet. So they made him the doctor because they really like they really, really wanted him on the show. Right. He plays Dr. Dr. Bashir through the entire run of Deep Space Nine. Now, obviously, Sid is still best known for his role on Deep Space Nine, which he swears that he actually once got detained in an airport for three hours and had to wait on the FBI to get there just so they could get his autograph. Oh, boy. We'll be right back.
Snugins. Shall we play a game? It's over, Johnny. No! Oh, wow, man. Hey, if you recognize those sounds, then you're probably somebody who would like our show. We are called Did You Hear About This, and we talk about all kinds of news stories. It's like the 80s and 90s stuff that we grew up on. Yeah, this isn't stuff that's getting covered on the 10 o'clock news, I'll tell you that. You can check us out at didyouhearaboutthis.show. We're on every single podcast platform. Go find us.
Now, since Trek, he has continued to work in both film and television, both here in America and over in British films. He's been in shows here in America and shows like 24, Game of Thrones, Gotham. He's lent his voice to animated shows like Family Guy, the Disney Plus series Star Wars, The Bad Batch. And like I said, he's been in several BBC productions that honestly, neither you or I are very familiar with. And that is our guy, Alexander Siddig, or just Sid. He's a cool guy. He's super involved in the convention scene. You can catch him. He's got lots of great stories.
that he's done there. All right, let's talk about this episode and how it came to be. The story idea for this episode came from a guy named Jimmy Diggs. Now in his pitch, the Zimmerman Bashir, minus the big secret, was actually the B plot of the episode he was trying to pitch. The staff didn't really care for the A plot, but they...
thought that the Bashir Zimmerman thing was good enough to be its own a plot, but they felt the need to add more to it. So that's when the staff decided that Zimmerman should find out a big old secret about Bashir's past, which to this point, as you thought about it, Matt, they haven't really explored Bashir's past a whole lot through the course of the show so far. Like they were aware of that, like, oh, this is a good opportunity to figure that out. So they bounced a lot of ideas off the wall, but it was really in the 11th hour while they were producing the previous two parter that we just watched last week. That's when they came up with the idea of something else, of something else that has been largely unexplored in the Star Trek universe. And that was genetic engineering. Their thinking was, is that this like genetic engineering is all over real.
science of the day, right? Lots of other science fiction use it, but all Star Trek has ever done with it was just to say that it was illegal. And yeah, they had that episode with Khan Noonien Singh way back in the original series where they mentioned the eugenics wars. And that's really it. They haven't mentioned it since then. They didn't mention it in TNG. They haven't mentioned it in Voyager, which is going forward. They haven't mentioned it. It's just sort of languished out there. Even when they brought Khan back in Star Trek 2, they still didn't really talk about genetic engineering at all. That was just a revenge plot for Khan onto Kirk, right? So while they're making the previous episode and finding out that Bashir had been a changeling.
they also decided to make him genetically modified. Now, Ronald D. Moore, the guy who winds up writing the teleplay for this episode, had this to say of the sudden retcon of the character. It really explained a lot about the character to me. Yeah. He had some strange jigs and jags in his profile over the course of the first four seasons. We have this guy who's really arrogant, who almost became a tennis player at one point, has all these different tales of why and when he went to medical school and why he didn't become the valedictorian of his class and who has something about his past on Earth that he just doesn't want to talk about. And when Odo was going to Earth in the episode Homefront, which we watched, he asked Bashir, is there anybody you want me to look up? And Bashir says, I have nobody there I want to talk to. It occurred to us there was something in this guy's backstory that had to be interesting.
And suddenly it all made sense if this guy had been genetically engineered to be very, very smart, but he had to hide it all of his life. It's exactly what you picked up on, right, Matt? Exactly. That's what I say. Like, it made sense. So, you know, there's a lot of people who don't like the fact that they did this. Like, oh, they just they're looking for some. And the fact that even the writers are like, actually, this makes sense. You know, like it wasn't just something cool is this as they started thinking about it and digging into all these things they've learned about, but sure so far.
this is where it led them. So it's kind of cool. Now, the final version of the story that we get is actually relatively different from the original version that was written. Originally, Zimmerman was up to some like shenanigans with the LMH because he didn't want the EMH, which looked like him to be replaced. Right. And then what was going to happen was he was going to discover Jules a secret. And then as he's about to expose it, Miles discovers that he's doing these shenanigans. And basically he steps in and says, I know what you're up to. Don't tell anybody about Julian and I won't tell anybody about you. And the secret was contained between the three of them and us as an audience. But it was actually Alexander Siddig when he got that script and read and went, what? That he went back to the writers and said.
this is going to impact his performance of how he plays this character. If only he miles in the audience know the secret. So they talked about it and he convinced them to change it to where everyone was aware of the secret and let the whole cat out of the bag so that they, and they like that because you can now play with that in future episodes. You don't have to hold that secret. You can, you can, you don't have to have that as tension. You can leverage it otherwise, you know? So that's how this, yeah, I agree. I absolutely agree. If you're going to do it, let's not keep it a secret. Like let's not pretend like it doesn't happen. Like let's, let's see what happens. Repercussion. Now remember when deep space nine started, we were very much had to be an episodic television.
And Deep Space Nine has been pushing these character arcs and now even fundamental character changes. Because if you watch Dr. Bashir after this episode versus before this episode, it's two different Bashirs. And you're going to be like, wait a minute, what happened to him? So kind of got to watch the episode to know what happens. All right, Matt, all of that out of the way. Let's get into the story here. Yeah, let's let's dig in. We've got we've got an A plot, which obviously is everything having to do with Lewis Zimmerman and Bashir. We have the B plot, which is Rom and Lito, which we haven't even touched on them yet in our discussion. But let's go ahead and start with maybe some specific plot points, certain things that happened or certain character moments that you want to talk about outside of the A plot B plot discussion. OK, I will say the doctor walks on the screen and like I realize it's not at least I was pretty sure it wasn't.
the emh okay but he walks on and i'm like i i was just going with it going with it going with it nothing seemed out of place until they like come back from the commercial and it's it's talking to cisco and like are you aware of what the emh is i'm like wait what of course you know oh oh i'm in the wrong show right i'm in the wrong show i i i had to flip the switch and realign myself and say okay The doctor, the EMH are on Voyager. That's where I've seen them. Okay. We are now on DS9. This is a crossover. This is kind of cool. I kind of like this. There you go. But now I'm in the right head space. And oh, DS9 was maybe not aware of that. And we did also see the doctor, the EMH in First Contact, the movie, when he briefly appeared in sickbay. And Crusher was like, I swear I never used one of these things. Oh, my God. Yeah. She just used them to keep the Borg at bay for a few minutes. And then he went away. So yeah. But the EMH is supposed to be all over Starfleet for sure. But yeah. Yeah. Yeah. But I mean.
So it doesn't necessarily seem weird when he pops up other places. Although I like how Cisco reminded us like DS9 is Cardassian. Right. Like we don't have Federation tech over here. Right. So. Right. And that was, I mean, that conversation was, was plotline needed because at the time you have some people who are watching Deep Space Nine, but not watching Voyager. So they really wouldn't have known who this guy is.
That's very true. And even now when people are binging, if you're going through and you binge, if you do what most people do and binge the entire show before moving on to the next series, you're not going to know who the doctor is watching this episode. Now, Matt, you know how I often say watching an air day order, you start seeing things where the production's doing things that you never understood. It was in this season, although in Voyager at season three, where we first met Dr. Lewis Zimmerman.
the hologram over on Voyager. Remember, because they had to expand the doctor's program because things were breaking down. So that's why I understand who he is. Exactly. Exactly. So it's it's really and it's the first time we saw him and that they established on that show that he used himself as a likeness and and showed us this attitude about what Dr. Zimmerman could be. And now they bring him back later on the season. So it is this cool. They are still working together. They're not just completely independent of each other. And I like that. I like when we see a little bit of production crossover. Let me ask you this. So the first thing you hear is the voice, an offscreen voice, Dr. Bashir, I presume. And then Julian turns around and looks like, yeah. And all of a sudden you turn around and it's the doctor. Now you may not have.
noticed the yellow just yet or the uniform it's bob picardo like what was your first reaction to the doctor's here but it can't be the doctor but it's the doctor well exactly that's what i'm saying like i i was fairly certain it was zimmerman oh so you you thought zimmerman your mind immediately went to zimmerman not doctor okay i don't know if i could have given you his name i mean he gave his name pretty quick but um but yeah like like it's like the the hair and makeup that they give zimmerman is just a little bit off a little bit messier than than the doctor. Right. And, and so I think you could see that I did not notice the yellow right away. I noticed it later. I did notice that later. I'm like, yeah, he's not wearing the usual colors. Like, but I guess for what he's doing, it is kind of more engineering. Yeah. He's in engineering. I think he's in science. He's actually in engineering. Yeah. But you also, he didn't have any pips. He's not a commissioned officer or anything like that. Yeah. He has nothing here on the collar. He's just wearing the uniform. Like it's almost like he's a civilian contractor or something. I'm not really sure. Yeah. Yeah. So.
they didn't really explore it too much and i kind of wondered if it's going to be a multi-episode arc with him but he i think by the end of this they kind of closed it out um so like i don't expect to see him next episode but it very much felt like the doctor, Dr. Zimmerman was not apprehensive, but like, he didn't really want to be doing what he was doing. He kind of begrudgingly sent here. And I think you kind of mentioned it, like he's basically replacing himself, but like the feeling every time he spoke, especially to Julian, his replacement, it was very, not quite hostile. It was Kurt. It was very Kurt. Yeah. Yeah. And there's, and there's a little bit of, I think that's just who Dr. Zimmerman is, but I do think, um,
They will deal with this more later. Okay. And I'm not going to give you any more than that, but they will come back and deal with this. So I would say your assessment that he's mad about being replaced because that's him as the AMH that he's mad about that. Like that's an accurate assessment, I would say. Especially when he describes it to Julian as like, we're going to make you immortal. And I mean, he's got to be sitting there thinking it's like, this could have been me. This should have been me. This is my tech. Well, he says to Cisco, even a few minutes ago, it's almost begrudging. Like he's like, this is pointless because he's like, you know, the AMH, which is amazing, which is going to be in use for years and years and years and years to come. But the new LMH model, I mean, gosh, you're just going to go on.
You know, he's like, I'm not done with the MH yet, but yeah, we're, we're, we're working on 2.0, but one point I'll be around for a long time. Right. Right. Do we ever get any more on exactly why Bashir was chosen by Starfleet plot reasons? No. Okay. I mean, you know, he's a, he's the doctor who's out on the fringe and he's doing cool stuff out at, out in the frontier medicine of deep space nine and coming up with stuff. And I mean, I mean, I, I just.
because we do cover so often, like he is so young and like, why wouldn't they pick someone who's more experienced or with some level of merit that everybody knows, you know, there's gotta be that doctor out there that everybody knows. Sure. And there's certainly a lot. I mean, cause honestly, I would think if you're going to pick anybody, you're going to pick somebody like Crusher, who's the head doctor, the CMO of the flagship or something like that. But they don't, they go to pick Bashir. And I will say this, there have been several Dr. Bashir episodes that we have missed in the course of this run where Bashir has had to do some really cool medical stuff. Like he's had to, he's had to create new medical stuff. There was a, there was a question one time, like,
So like a new thing happens, which Starfleet doctor would you want? You know, of all the different doctors, like which one do you want treating you? And, and my answer, like I kind of went through it and I was like, well, Crusher wouldn't know the answer and we'd have to wait till we get to a star base. Um, you don't know Dr. Phlox, but Dr. Phlox would like, like muggle something together and, and do something. Uh, Dr. Bashir would learn it. He would research it. He would figure it out. Whatever it was, he would figure it out. Uh, whereas Dr. McCoy from the original series, he would just already know the answer.
But I like the doctor when we're like, he's going to figure it out. Like there's nothing that he puts his mind to that he can't figure out. Sure. So maybe if that answers your question, though, Matt, like he's had some some really significant wins that would get back to Starfleet Medical. So his would be a name that is that is circulated. He is five years out of out of medical school at this point, practicing on his own. So all of that, you know, he's not as young as before, maybe. But he's the doctor here, not on another station. So we need to have it happen here. Yep.
like i said for plot reasons plot reasons makes sense um there was one point when when his parents started talking and they talked about how julian had to be talked into going into medical school and they're like he actually wanted to be up and they cut him off but there's no chance we actually get to know that not at all no not at all sorry i wonder there'd be some deep deep star trek trivia in there somewhere jumping away from bashir for a moment i feel like maybe this has been mentioned once before in something i've watched but i didn't really remember it a five-year marriage contract Yeah. Is this, this is a Fringy thing. Yeah. We, they, they created it for this episode. We've never heard of this before, but it's a thing now. It's now it's a thing. Yeah. That's, that's interesting though. Rom wanted a kid. So he enters into a standard five-year marriage contract and then he fell in love and they took him for everything he was worth. What an idiot. Yeah. Falling in love. Gosh. Yeah.
But yeah, honestly though, like I feel bad for Ram and kind of relate to Ram, especially when I was in high school. I understand. Like I, I feel like I'm at a point now where I'm just sitting there like Ram, just blurt it out. Just blurt it out. Like I've learned my lesson the hard way. Just, just say what you're thinking. The worst thing that can happen is they say, no, just do it. I've been in your position many, many times. Right. Just do it.
They just had to build up, build up, build up for the big dramatic catcher at the airport scene. But man, Rom, buddy, I like you, but got to break out of that. You're old enough now. I think that's all I got. I've got a few that I want to talk here. Did we talk about the reveal of Bashir being a super genetically modified gene? I think that was the first thing we thought. Yeah, because your response was, oh, right.
It makes sense. I like I want to talk about the conversation between Quark and Lita at the bar. And I wrote it down. You know, Quark says Rom needs a woman with brains and beauty. And she goes, I have brains. And he goes, sure you do, honey. That's why I hired you. Now, why don't you finish eating and take those brains back to the double table where they can get a nice good look at them? Yeah. My respect for Quark kind of took a hit.
To be fair, I just want to point this out by all accounts. Everyone who talks about the scene, they're all quick to point out. Armin Shimmerman is the furthest from this as a human being. Oh, you know what I mean? Like I would have never put that on the actor. This is on the writers and the actors are doing their job. Yeah. Like it's, it's, it's entertainment. It is what it is. Like I get it, but yeah, so I, I'm not going to pin that on the actor at all. Right. I mean, it's good to know, but, um, because yes, I don't know the actors that well, but yeah. Wow.
Wow. Quark. Huh? Um, I mean, I love your, your, your ambition and your entrepreneurial spirit, but gotta know how to treat people. Yeah. Yeah. It's a thing. It's a thing for as much as Quark is coming around. He just hasn't come around quite yet. No, quite yet. Um, I want to talk about miles for just a minute. It's probably one of the best bits of the entire episode where he's doing the interview and you know, he's like, uh, this is going to get back to Julian. Overall. Yeah. It was fantastic. Oh, absolutely. And it was, it was an easy way for them to fit all of the main cast into that episode. Like you're mentioning, um,
for it like i think that was the only time we saw him was in the interview yeah and it was for like five seconds sure but yes you're saying sorry yeah so yeah i was like no this isn't gonna back to julian right like he's not gonna hear this he's not he's a really great guy i like him a lot he's amazing that was the best thing they could have done with that that's a true friend matt that's a true friend i would do that with you anybody comes up because you know it was it is you're not gonna hear us right all right matt's actually a pretty swell dude he's all right you're gonna like him All right. I got one more I want to talk about and then we'll move on. At the very end of the episode, when Rom comes running up, you know, and him and Lita go through their whole thing. And she's like, oh, doctor, I'm so sorry. Like she kisses him like right in front of him. And he's like, and then he turns around and he's like, excuse me, have you ever heard of my work in genetic engineering or whatever it is that he says? You know, you can tell he.
He wasn't really that in Delita. Like, it's like whatever. There is a fun behind the scenes story that they tell where Bob Picardo had actually gone to the writing staff and said, hey, am I allowed to play with this line? Remember, that's a big no, no. You're not allowed to do that in Star Trek. He had enough in with everybody that's like, OK, you can you can do it. So he tried apparently a couple of different lines. And one of the ones that he did, like they do the whole thing and he turns around and goes, excuse me, perhaps you've heard of my work on Star Trek Voyager. Oh, man. Yeah, yeah. I mean, I know they don't like him playing around with lines, but you have to imagine from time to time just to break things up.
they intentionally throw in something like that. Yeah. And remember, like they actually seek out Bob Bacardo's wit for the I'm a whatever, not I'm a doctor, not a whatever. Like they routinely seek him out for that. So he's kind of used to being able to play with some lines. So you can see where they give him a little bit of leeway because he's had that. So, well, Matt, why don't we move and talk about the plots? Let's go with the B plot first. Go ahead and get that one out of the way. Rahm trying to tell Lita how much he likes her and Lita's trying to let him, but Rahm just won't do it. When Dr. Zimmerman, who has also taken a liking to Lita, makes her an offer that she could run her own cafe back at the Jupiter station. And as we just said, as Lita's about to board the transport and leave, Rahm rushes to her side.
and finally confesses his love, which Lita accepts and decides to stay. Matt, what do you think about Ram and Lita? It's a weird pairing, but I guess it kind of makes sense because they're kind of both the, just from a meta standpoint, as far as the show goes, like they're both the same level of character. Right. Kind of like they show up once every 10 episodes. And so like that kind of makes sense. It's not going to be super weird where Cisco starts dating Lita and now she needs to be in every episode or something like that.
so from that standpoint i guess it makes sense but otherwise i don't know i not who i would have set ram up with not that i know who i'd set him up with but uh i don't think i would have gone towards lita but it's interesting as as they kind of bring up in this episode like it's sheer's ex and wasn't there one other oh no maybe i was just thinking like she goes on a date with zimmerman but i'm like yeah she's she's had at least brief relationships with with other many other people on cast right now. Now, something you don't know, Matt, is they've actually been setting this up for a while. You've just missed those episodes. Yeah, I haven't seen that. If you'll go back to our extra viewing episode that we did a couple of months ago called Bar Association for our patrons. If you guys want to hear that episode, go to patreon.com forward slash beat me a pod. But in Bar Association, remember where Rom stands up to Quark and forms the union of the bar workers? Like that was kind of Lita's like, oh, I like him. He does stand up for himself and he is this strong guy who stands up to Quark. Like there's that.
thing with her. So she's kind of like that. There's been a handful of episodes where it's her kind of talking about it. And this is sort of the payoff of that in the end. Now that wasn't enough for me to watch those episodes with you, but I mean, it has been there. Yeah.
How much more obvious can she be? Exactly. I mean, she, and she's trying to, and Rob, God love his soul. Bless his heart. I, he just does not pick up on anything. No, he does. He just doesn't have the confidence to act on it. He knew she likes him. It wasn't, it was like, you know, there was just that doubt. What is the hesitation? Like, like that, that, like I said, you know, I could kind of feel for mom because like that was me back in high school, but that was also me when I was unsure of the result. Right. Exactly. Yep. Yep. Except she can't make it much more obvious without actually saying, no, I do want to put it a little bit on her for kind of, I mean, obviously this is for comedy sake.
But the fact that she knew just as well that they were both interested in each other and she kind of sat there and was waiting and was forcing him to say it instead of just coming out and saying, Hey, I like you. You like me? Do you want to go out? Like, come on, it's the nineties, right? Right. Things were changing. Women could, could ask guys out on dates. It was, it was, there was still a lot of the traditional way of things should be though. I understand. I understand. But like, come on, it's Star Trek, right? We're 400 years in the future. Yeah. They're trying to push that for sure. Come on. Yeah. It just, it's Ram and Lita. You're going to love them. They're going to be together for a while.
It's, it's a fun relationship. I like that Rom is in an actual relationship. Like, like Rom's the guy. I don't want him to be like Quark, you know, like Rom is the family man. Like he's a good dude. Sure. You know what I mean? Like I like Rom. I want to see Rom happy. I want to see Rom moving forward. And you know, the idea, let's face it, Rom's kind of a little troll. You know, he's, he's not the smartest guy. He's not the most eloquent. He's not the best looking. He's not even the best looking for Rengi, you know, but he gets, he gets the babe. He gets the girl, you know, like he gets the girl who's out of his league. Like, Oh yeah. I mean, that's definitely how they're, they're writing it. So yes. But they, but they have a real relationship. Like, and you'll see that as they go forward. Like it's a
to say the least. Fair enough. So, and I don't mind telling you a while back, I think it was when we were doing our actor spotlight on Armin, or maybe it was on Aaron who plays Nog. I told you when they go to the conventions, they often get up there and do a, like they have like the first family of Ferengis or the Ferengi first family of Star Trek or something like that. And it's been, it's Quark, Nog, Moogie, the girl who plays Moogie, Aaron. And I said, and there's another person that I can't tell you yet. Well, Matt, I can now tell you that other person is Lita, who's in the first family of Ferengi, but not a Ferengi, which is kind of fair enough, which is pretty fun. So anyway, all right, Matt, you got anything else about Raman Lita? I think that should do it. All right, let's get to the main.
The main topic, the main thing of this particular episode, Dr. Lewis Zimmerman has arrived from Jupiter Station to use Bashir as the model for the new LMH. During the course of his research, which brings Julian's estranged parents to the station, it has discovered that Julian was genetically modified as a child. And as that's a big no-no in the Federation, because, you know, the whole con thing, this could mean the end of Julian's career in Starfleet. That is until his dad steps up to the plate and takes responsibility for it, and they work it out so that Julian can stay. Matt, go for it. I'm glad that you mentioned before that they haven't really mentioned the genetic stuff since, like, the original series. Yeah. Because...
them bringing up like, Oh, this is illegal. Like, okay, sure. If you say so, I like, this is felt like new information to me. Like they treated it. I felt like, you know, old hat, like everybody knows this, but I mean, why wouldn't they? I mean, everybody aboard that station should know that. Yes. Um, but still until the very end where they came out and said, you know, for every Julian Bashir we can create, there's going to be a con saying waiting in the wings. And like, okay, I get your point now. Cause like the whole episode I'm sitting there thinking like, why is this so bad? Like, okay, if it's illegal, it's illegal. Fine. But like,
I was very much like in camp with O'Brien where he's like, you know, there hasn't been a case of this in over a hundred years, you know, they don't understand things have changed. Like, and I was kind of on board with that and I didn't really want to go through a whole, you know, court scenario with, with this, but I was still sitting there saying like, why is this such a big deal? Right. It's like, Julian's not hurting anybody here. Like, and I think the way this played out was basically the perfect ending for me. Like it was Julian's parents that did it to him. Right. So they ended up getting the punishment actually. And they kind of still like acknowledge Julian for who he is, like who he currently is not, you know,
what he did in the past or what was done to him in the past and allow him to continue moving forward. And I think that just kind of, like I said, it was the perfect way it could have ended for me. But in the midst of that, Brian had one line that I think if I had to pick a Star Trek message out of this, it came from this. Genetic recoding can't give you ambition or personality, compassion, or any of the things that make a person truly human. And once again, I don't know if that's a point they were trying to drive home at all because they, I mean, they found a different way of resolving it, right? I feel that if they had gone into the court scene.
as he was trying to kind of push in towards that direction, like if they had gone that direction with the story, they would have brought this up again. They would have driven that home, you know, bonked us over the head with it, but they didn't. And so I never know if I'm reading too much into these things. Well, it's interesting you say that, Matt, because this is actually where I wanted the story to go. I've watched this episode an untold number of times. I've never thought about it from this perspective. A lot of the podcasts and other people that I've listened to leading up to this really seem to fixate on how wrong it was of Richard, specifically Richard, to do this to his son.
Because, you know, and they're just echoing what Julian's argument was, you know, like you didn't give him a chance to get to know who he is. And I got to tell you, as a parent, I look at it actually from their viewpoint, because let's be honest. Julian was six years old and he says he couldn't tell a house from a tree or a dog from a cat. Yep. That's not a little slow. Yep. That's bad. Like really, really, really, really bad. Now, who knows what he could have become? But at six, that's not. No, like.
That's not the case. So there's his situation, I think, was a lot worse than what even Julian realizes. But I have two thoughts, but I basically think it comes down to. Julian and his father are a lot more alike than Julian ever realized. And here's what I mean, because neither of them going into this episode realized where their value truly lied. And I think this is kind of where you're going. This is a little bit of what Miles was talking about. What makes you you, what makes you valuable is not your genetic recoding or your sequencing. It's not your smarts. It's not any of that. It's who you are on the inside, right? One of the Star Trek messages that we've had, the Gene Roddenberry vision of the future is we value life. We value life for life's sake. You are valuable. And I hope everybody out there listening hears me when I say this, because I'm now talking to us. You as a human being, Matt.
You as a human being are valuable because you are alive. because you are life. Intrinsically, your value is just because you're alive. It's not in what you do. It's not in what you have accomplished. It's not in all these other things. You are valuable. You are precious just because you are you. And this is something like we learn this from Picard so often. We have to value life. We learn this from studies with data, learn this from studies with a doctor. We value people because they're alive. Let's look at Julian. There's a key moment when he's talking with Miles where he tells us what his internal dialogue has been his entire life, right? And it's really kind of sad. He goes, it's unnatural. He's a freak. He's a monster. He's using these words to describe himself.
this is his own internal dialogue like that yeah yeah and and i'm sitting there thinking like dude you are being way too hard on yourself yes like when he when he used the word unnatural uh-huh like i got it okay you're modified you know as he said you know not from nature yeah fine i get it you know but as soon as he's like freak or monster would also be acceptable i'm like no right no exactly yeah and he needed to have that fixed in him and and you know and then he talks about the truth of his circumstances it's just the facts of his circumstances he was in the first grade he couldn't tell a dog from a cat or a tree from house like i said that's not a little behind that's not a little slow there's something else going on right now that being said he was sure at that time even as a six-year-old of all the things he didn't know that he was a great disappointment to his parents and that's what made him so angry it's not because his parents had him genetically modified it's because he didn't feel that his father in particular but also his mother really loved him As he was, he didn't feel like he was valued because of who he was only because of what he became. Right. That's that's where Julian is. When you look at Julian's anger, it's not in what his parents did to him.
It's because he didn't ever feel like they loved him for him to just be him. And you know how we know that that's true, that I'm 100% right with that? Because when he's in there and he's having this big argument with his dad, you're my architect, you're not my father. And Jules was dead and Julian was born and this and that. And how do you know? And his mother says, whoa. And it took his mom and his dad. His dad does probably what I would do. He turned his back on his kidney because he was seething because he couldn't say it. His son was just going off, going off, going off. And he was like, this is not like he didn't have the words, but his mom, God bless her. Oh, my wife is like this in my own life. She has a great way to temper the.
the anger. But she's like, that's not why we did it. We don't love you because of what you became. We did it because we loved you. And she tells him the truth, right? That we were scared that we had somehow screwed you up. We didn't want you having to live this life. So we did what we thought was best for you at the time, not for our sake, but for yours, because we loved you. And then Julian hugs her. And from there on out, he's soft towards his parents because what he needed to know above all else was that he was loved for who he is as his parents' son.
not for what he could do. And that even if he couldn't do all that, that they still loved him in spite of all that. And when that finally came into his, into his, into his, his being, because in the next scene, when, when his dad has gone and told the whole truth and like, yeah, we're going to send him to jail. And he's like, I'm not gonna let my dad go to jail. You know what I mean? Like he's still, he still cares for his parents, for his dad specifically. Like you're not putting my dad in jail. No, I'll just leave. And he's like, no, no, no, you can't do that in a completely different way. This is exactly who Richard Bashir is because Richard Bashir has spent his entire life living in utopia, right? Living in the Federation, not out on the fringes. He's in earth.
And in the center of utopia, but his whole life, he's always trying to measure up to other people because he also didn't understand that his value and his worth as a person lied in the fact that he was a person. That's why he's always trying to prop up and say, he's got all these, all these prospects and he's always scheming and he's always. You know, when I worked in trains, dad, you were a third class steward for two weeks before you got kicked off. Yeah. But when I was there, like, like he reminds me of a crazy inventor guy and he's just an amazing storyteller. Yeah. Right. Yeah. Yeah. But, but Richard Bashir had the same problem that Julian did where he felt like he had to prop up and make himself seem bigger and better than he ever was in order to be accepted into a society that in theory should already accept him just because he's alive. Now that one hit me when I started thinking about Dr. Bashir or not Dr. Bashir, I'm sorry, Mr. Bashir, because for people out there who don't know, I am a homeschooling dad, a homeschooling stay at home dad.
at that. That's what I do when I'm not doing this, right? We're fortunate enough that my wife's income provides enough money for the family and that I get to, I'm a teacher by education and by training and I've gotten to do a whole lot of other stuff. So I'm at home with my kids homeschooling my own kids. Matt, I got to tell you, I deal with the looks and the questions every day from a society that does not value as a whole dads who stay home or dads, even the homeschooling group community who does not value dads homeschooling their kids. They only value moms homeschooling their kids. I also deal with my own internal monologue all the time about my own worth and my value as a human.
and as a man in my family. I'm just being real, just getting real honest. I deal with that all the time. What I have come to learn is the truth is this very Star Trekian truth. My value doesn't lie in a paycheck. Like this is where I, Brent, have had to go. My value doesn't lie in a paycheck. My value lies in my existence as a person and because of my place in my family. My value lies as the father to my children, as the husband to my wife. I am part of this family. My contribution to both my family and society, while not money or career oriented, is still a valuable contribution. And even if I didn't do that, I would still be valued and cared for in this family. Now, I know that.
But I have to constantly fight to remember that. Sure. Just getting honest. So when I hear and I see Dr. or not Dr. Bashir, I'm sorry, Mr. Bashir. When I see Richard, I go, that's me because that's been me trying to make this thing. Oh, yeah. Oh, you run a podcast? Yeah, I run a podcast. Let me tell you all the cool things I get to do. I'm a media member of an NFL team. Sort of. You know what I mean? It's I do. I just it's and it makes me wonder about in this utopia. Where do we have? We still not figured that part out yet, you know, and I'm sorry. I've had this. I've been watching this episode a lot.
leading up to tonight's recording. And, and I've thought about this a lot in my, you know, to, to leader. So I'm sorry to just sort of unleash this little diatribe, but when I look at it, that's where I sit back and I see Julian and his father are the same person because they've, they've not understood the truth. And when they do begin to understand this truth, that their value lies in just being them and that they're loved as they are, they can become who they were actually meant to be. You know, his father can take responsibility for what's going on in his life. Julian can just be free to be.
known for who he is and he doesn't have to hide anymore. He spent his whole life hiding. He doesn't have to hide anymore. It can just be there with the truth just being out. And it's OK. And it's just OK. There you go. And I do think this, too. This is also a great example of what happens when kids don't take the time to understand their motivations of their parents and resolve conflict, because this is an unresolved conflict that's been going on for a very long time. And Julian's never stopped. I mean, I thought about that, too. Like, why didn't this happen when he was 16, 18, 20?
Yeah. I mean, I know how old he is supposed to be in the show right now, but. About 30 at this point. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And again, you know, this is Julian. And have you ever done that, Matt? Have you ever had the internal dialogue where you're having an entire conversation or entire argument with somebody in your head? And it blows up because it goes from here's the truth of what's actually going on. And it all of a sudden spins out to now I'm a freak and I'm a monster. And they took this away from me. And how could they possibly dare to do that? They're evil. They're like he's blown that up because he's kept it inside. He's never he's never actually had a chance to talk to his parents about it without it getting blown up. So anyway.
I leave that out there as what I discovered in watching this film or this episode. Your worth, people. Know your worth. Your worth is just because you're a person. Value humans. Value life. I don't know how much more basic Star Trek message you can get than life is valuable just because it's alive. I like it. Matt, do you got anything else about this episode? I think I can wrap it up. All right. A couple little production notes we didn't talk about. Sure. At the end, Admiral Bennett says that the eugenics wars happened 200 years ago, which would actually place it about 200 years off the established continuity of what was already established back in TOS, of which Ronald D. Moore, the teleplay writer for this episode, goes, oops.
He's bad. He just didn't. He should have said something different. He should have said 400 years, not 200. Just oops. All right. That's it. That's actually all that I had there. All right, Matt, I'll leave it to you. Did you like this episode? Would you want to watch it again? And do you know why it's part of our run?
Uh, yes, yes. And I mean, I guess we kind of said like it changes Julian. So yes. Yeah, I will. That's the main reason. I will tell you, they will not like just go on to next week and pretend like this episode never happened. Sure. Like it does change. Like they do new things with Julian because of this information. So, um, that's exactly why we had to watch it. Yeah. Well, Matt, in a little bit of a situation where we're setting stages for characters. So we're staying in deep space nine. We're going to be in deep space nine for a bit of a run. Just so you know, we are skipping a few episodes that we're going to the next episode called soldiers of the empire.
Brace yourself, Matt. It's going to be a lot of talk about honor because this is a Klingon episode. Oh boy. But it is one we must view. I debated this one and I've discussed it and we decided this is essential to understanding a couple other characters and what happens with them later on as well that I can't just say. I understand Worf. Come on. Yeah. Who else is it? Anyway, so with that, I'm not going to give you any extra viewings for Deep Space Nine today. And I guess with that, Matt, that's going to wrap us up on today's episode of Beam Me Up, a Star Trek podcast. Remember, guys, if you want to get in touch with us, you can do that by emailing us to beammeuppod at gmail.com. Hey, let us know. What did you guys see? Am I just way off base here?
Is Matt way off base? Is this a horrible episode? Did you like the retcon? Did you not? BeameUpPod at gmail.com. Head over for our giveaway at BeameUpGiveaway.com. Matt, where can the fine folks out there find you on the internet? You can find me personally both on Instagram and Twitter at As A Matter of Matt. And I'm at Brent Allen Live across all the social medias. I'd love to connect with you there as well, too. Until next time, folks, live long and prosper.