Skip to content
Star Trek: Deep Space Nine | Inquistion episode artwork

Mar 8, 2022 52 min

Star Trek: Deep Space Nine | Inquistion

from Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast Hosted by Brent Allen

Did You Hear About This? This humorous pop culture podcast discusses the latest retro stories and pop culture news. Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify Support the show

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Star Trek: Deep Space Nine | Inquistion

0:00 52:11

Chapters

  1. 18:56 [Ad] Did You Hear About This?
  2. 19:34 (Cont.) Star Trek: Deep Space Nine | Inquistion
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

The final frontier begins. This is about saving the future of humanity. This is a huge victory for the good guys. You've never seen Voyager. Commitment to this course of action is not emotional.

Welcome to another episode of Beam Me Up, a Star Trek podcast. I am Brent Allen, and I've seen every episode of Star Trek 47 times. And I'm Matt Sonnenberg, and this is my first time through the series. And this is the show where we are on a mission to introduce people to the Star Trek universe by watching, in air date order, the most important episodes that deal with the lore, the confusing history sometimes, and the timeless message of Star Trek. And even if this episode all takes place in a holodeck, or if it's a dream, or whatever other...

Curveball, we want to throw at you. You should still go check out the behind the scenes. Maybe we'll tell you if it was real or not. You can do that by going to BeMeUpPod.com. Click on the YouTube icon in the upper right hand corner. Make sure to follow us over there. You never know what you might find. Well, I will tell you, this is not a holodeck simulation or a test. This is the real thing. Or is that what you want me to think? Or is that what I want you to think that I want you to think?

I had some questions in this episode. My mind went some places. Well, let's definitely make sure that we get to that. Today's episode is the 18th episode of season six of Star Trek Deep Space Nine entitled Inquisition, or as I like to call it, the Bashir Identity. In case you guys didn't watch this one first in this episode, Dr. Bashir is interrogated by a member of Starfleet Internal Affairs that suspects that Julian may be a sleeper agent for the Dominion.

It turns out it's all an unwilling recruitment of Bashir into the Federation's secret black ops organization known as Section 31. Matt, we're going to get into everything about this. You said you have questions. This is a big episode. This changes some things for us. It's important in things overall. Give us your initial thoughts about what you just learned going on here in the Federation. I mean, the biggest thing for me is we already have so much going on, I feel. And knowing that we only have like a season and a half left, I'm like.

why are you introducing new things? Like, we still need to wrap up so many things. Let us get into this war and just deal with a war and make sure you resolve that. Like, I guess, okay, section 31 here is probably going to play a part in helping out with the war, ending the war, doing something. It's going to tie in, I'm sure. But is it really necessary? I think you have enough on your plate already.

Use the tools at your disposal. Don't create new ones. But Section 31. The Federation has a Black Ops division. The Romulans have the Tal Shiar. Well, or do they? The Romulans have the Tal Shiar. The Cardassians have the Obsidian Order. And the Federation has Section 31. This is the first introduction. Who named this thing? Iris Stephen Bear. I can answer that one. The Tal Shiar. The Obsidian Order. I mean, personally, I think the Obsidian Order has the best name. That's a pretty cool name. It really is.

Yeah, this is section 31. That's area 50, 51, area 50. Is that it? 56. I don't know. I forget the number one. It's area 51. Yeah. Um, you know, I don't know. Am I seven? We had a, we had a hanger. Uh, we have a small, uh, uh, airport, municipal airport where I grew up called Cratesfield. Um, and.

they have a building that's marked area 51. Oh, do they? Yeah. Nice. Nice. I think I've heard some of them not in Star Trek, but like in other places, it's just, it's the sixth floor. There is no sixth floor. It's up on the sixth floor. The building's only five floors tall, but it's on the sixth floor. Like it's, it's like in my high school, the rooftop rooftop pool. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Which I'm still convinced exists somewhere. I just never got to see it. Sure. Just not in Wisconsin. Do they have pools in Wisconsin?

Oh, yeah. Yeah. We have pools, but you have to shut them down for winter and you're not going to put one on the roof. Yeah. Well, there you go. Matt, this is a game changing episode. Adding in a new component. I mean, to your whole point, what are you doing at this part of the game? Now, to be fair, in a season where you have 26 episodes, even at episode 18, you still have something like 35 episodes left. That's a lot of episodes to fill in time. Like there's a whole episode in the seventh season where 100% going to skip called Take Me Out to the Hollow Suite, where the crew goes to the Hollow Suite and plays a game of baseball.

Against the Romulans or something like that. Like, I forget exactly. Maybe it's the Vulcans. I forget exactly who it is. Like, that's the whole episode. Yeah. You know, they insert those those little Bashir's Bashir's about to develop a new holodeck program that actually we'll talk about here in a couple episodes. But there's stuff that just happens in the holodeck. Like they will have those wasteful episodes, you know, as they get through. But you're right. Introducing this at this point. But adding a component like Section 31, though, honestly, it redefines pretty much everything that we know about the Federation or everything we think we know about the Federation. I mean, this is a perfect Ira Stephen Bear poking holes in the idea of.

of a utopian of the future of the United Federation of Planets. And this is his thing. This is his back. In fact, this is exactly why he did it. It all comes down to, I think, what Bashir said towards the end of this. When push comes to shove, are we willing to sacrifice our principles to survive? And I think that's the big question that comes in when they introduce something like this into the Federation. And I think it's good. And this is a big debate in the fandom, Matt. And we're going to talk about this. I do think that it is good for Star Trek to have something like this in the Federation because you have to ask that question. Like, yeah, everything's great and gravy when everything's cool. But when the chips are down, will you hold to your principles? Captain Kirk asked this way back in the original.

series, was it balance of terror or maybe the Corbamite maneuver when we're faced with adversity, will we still be who we say we are? And like, okay, so there's this black ops division that operates. Now, first of all, is the black ops division actually bad, even though they operate autonomously and in secret, are they, are they operating in really bad manner? Well, maybe just based on what we see here in, uh, uh, in this episode. And we'll explore that if you, if you believe the ends justifies the means or not. Right. Right. I have to tell you though, Matt, as a Trekkie, I find this a very questionable thing to insert into my beloved TV show, you know, a thing that I personally agree with. And I espouse this, these ideas and these, this vision of the future as a television fan, as a, as a viewing audience member, I think this is a dang near perfect episode of television. Sure. I mean, it, I, I probably watched this episode five times leading into tonight. And every time I watched this, it held me through the whole episode times. I just had to put my phone down and stop.

notes and just watch. Like it was amazing. Well, Matt, we're going to get into all of that, but I do have some actor character spotlights that I want to discuss before we get into all of that. The first one is our director for this episode. Did you happen to notice who it was? I believe it was Michael Dorn. You're absolutely right. It was Michael Dorn, AKA Worf, literally AKA Worf. That is his Twitter handle, Matt. I have to say, I think he did a great job with this episode. I really, normally I just say, Hey, that was the director and let's move on. But, but I want to talk about it. Not once in this episode, did he ever tip his hand as to what was really going on. But when you go back and you watch it again, you see the seams, like you can see where it goes from reality to the simulation and you can, and you can see how the simulation.

over time starts to sort of devolve to the point where Bashir figures it out. You know, like it starts here and it kind of starts sloping down as they start applying more and more and more pressure. I just realized, yeah, there are a few things early on that would make more sense now. And there's even one real subtle move, Matt, that I can only assume this was a, I don't know if this would have been in the script. This could have been a decision that Sid made, the guy who plays Bashir. It could have also been a director's choice. Because you know, like when he goes to sleep that night, he's getting up the next morning to go to this medical conference. That's when he gets beamed out and into this holodeck. And the whole rest of the episode's a simulation.

until the last two minutes, right? Well, when he wakes up after only an hour of sleep, he gets up and he's all whatever and he reaches his hand right behind his neck and he kind of feels right there. That's where the neural interface was. Yeah. He puts his hand right on it. Like I stopped and I saw it and I went, oh, I've never noticed that before. But it kind of looks like he's just like brushing something away from his head. He's like, well, if they inserted something like that could be like a, you know, it's little tales like that, that you'll see as you go back and you watch this episode again. So this is so reminiscent to me of the movie Sixth Sense, which has one of the greatest plot twists at the end of the film that everybody knows now. They should. And if you don't, then what rock are you living under?

If you don't, you need to watch the movie. If you don't, you probably just don't know that you do. That very well could be true too. Yeah. Like I'm not even going to say it. I'm sure everybody has heard the plot twist by this point in your life. You just might not know what movie it's from. There you go. And I'm not even going to say it because if you know what I'm talking about, then this makes 100%. If you don't know what I'm talking about, then you need to go get the movie and watch it because that's right. You probably know. But in that movie, when you find out what's really going on, if you go back and watch from scene one, it like they didn't pull a fast one on you at the end. It tracks. There are clues all throughout the whole thing. And it really is a very cohesive story. And I just, I love when, when.

storytellers do something like this. And I think it goes back to that. Why you and I like the third Harry Potter movie so much or the book so much, because even with the closed time loop, like it's completely thought out all the way through. It's not just a linear thing, you know, that you can go back and see it happening again as you, as you watch it the first time. I got to tell you though, for me personally, in my head, like my head cannon, the time when Bashir actually gets beamed out to the holodeck is not earlier in the episode when he's sleeping, but it's, it's later when he gets beamed out of, it's when he's beamed onto the, onto the.

Dominion ship and he sees way in. Okay. You know, so like, was it the trial or were they about to execute him or something? I don't remember exactly what it was, but they're, um, gosh, I've watched it's all washing to hit my head together right now. But that like, to me watching the episode up to that point. And then that's when he gets me like, Oh, they just beamed into a holodeck then. And they put them on way in ship. And then when they beamed him off way in ship, they're still on the holodeck. They kind of pulled one of those moves. And then all the characters, because once you get to the defiant, everybody's way different. Like, like they were pretty solid right up through then, but from the defined on, like they're just, they're pressing and presence. Like they've turned on a heel. Uh, but no, it really goes all the way back to the beginning. And you see that. I mean, it would have to

Right. Where they talk about like they lined it up with his conference and none of us would realize he was gone. And so, you know, the actual crew didn't have any knowledge that he was gone or had been snatched. They were expecting him to be gone. And so, yeah, like my thought, like he said, when like you're going to say they beat him off, it's like, yeah, when he got up in the morning and left for the conference, you know, teleported somewhere and they intercepted him or something. But that's how it would have went to my head.

So anyway, kudos to Michael Dorn for crafting really just a perfect episode of television. Not just the way it was written, by the way it was executed. Riveting, riveting, riveting TV, in my opinion. We have to talk about Director Sloan, though, Matt. Director Sloan is played by a guy named William Sadler. Matt, do you know this guy from anywhere? So the guy looked kind of familiar. I did catch the name as a special guest star in the credits. And the name sounds kind of familiar, but I could not tell you a single place without looking it up. And I still haven't looked it up. Well, let me help you out. William Sadler, as of this recording, has 178 credits to his name.

MDB. The man gets around. Sure. Here's a few notable ones. He was in Die Hard 2. He was in the Shawshank Redemption. He was in the Green Mile. He was on the show Roswell. He was actually on several other things. But to me, Matt, the place where I will always know him the best is not on Gargoyles.

But it was as the Grim Reaper from the Bill and Ted movies. Of course, there he's under makeup, but still the Grim Reaper. I've only seen the first one once or twice, and it hasn't been in like a decade. So he was only in the second one. He was only said you need to go watch it. It's so funny. They play like they have to challenge death, like to a series of games to see if they get to go back to the real life or not. And they play games like Battleship and Twister. Eventually, he joins the band and all different kinds. He was in the new movie that just came out a couple of years ago. So last year. Anyway, that is William Sadler. He plays our disturbing director, Sloan, director of Section 31.

One hour, Nick Fury here in the Star Trek world. That's the connection I had started making as you started talking about it right there. Honestly, I think it's just because he has the name director. That's, you know, it's you're a little bit of a secret organization, but it's you're just director. Now, let's talk about how this episode came to be. Originally, this episode was pitched as a comedy about Bashir just going to a planet for reason. And he essentially gets a parking ticket because he parks his runabout in the wrong spots. And he winds up having to deal with the bureaucracy of the planet he's on. And they don't like genetically modified people. And he's genetically modified. And so that becomes a big thing. And he's having to deal with all this red tape and this big investigation into who he is and all that kind of stuff. Well, Irish Stephen Bear.

almost immediately upon hearing that pitch, takes that idea and goes, instead of a comedy, let's make it a nightmare and let's make it about a covert organization within Starfleet that decides that Bashir is a Dominion spy and they begin to interrogate him using this elaborate holodeck simulation and they try to fake him out. Now, I don't know about you, Matt, but to me that basically sounds like Iris Stephen Bear wasn't actually listening to the pitch. He had his own idea in his head already and he was just waiting for the dude to shut up so he could say what he wanted to say. That's what it sounds like to me. But really, Matt, I mean, what makes this episode so remarkable and we've already mentioned it just a little bit is the addition of Section 31. I hope you realize by now that Section 31 and what it is is completely antithetical to Gene's vision of the film.

future. Yep. Like smacks it in the face. Gene would have been livid. I think if, if this would end, they probably been like, yeah, but you're not in control anymore. So we're going to do it anyway. Um, but I think Gene would have just been, been livid, but here's the thing though. Gene would have been livid. I think about a lot of stuff on deep space nine, which has set deep space nine apart because really since season two, Iris, even bear has been taking this look at this CD underbelly of the Federation poking holes in the idea of this utopian society that things aren't all right. You know, believing that in his words, paradise can really only be paradise. If there's somebody outside doing all the nasty work that nobody wants to talk about. Yeah. Right. Um, and we've been following this along and just, you, you've had, we've watched.

We've watched all of these episodes, Matt. You know, and it starts with the whole Maquis saga from season two, discovering that and culminating in the whole Michael Eddington situation. We saw it with the past tense episodes where they looked at the history of the Federation leading in and what caused that. And bringing that in, we looked at it with Homefront Paradise Lost, which is where the Changeling had come to Earth. And you had the Admiral who was basically willing to seize control of everything just to catch the Changeling. We watched it with Dr. Bashir, I presume, which is the one where we discovered Julian's backstory and what that looks like in the world of the Federation. I received embarrassment that he felt like everything was kind of leading to this, to this discovery of this covert organization within Starfleet that has been there since the beginning.

Nobody knew it's part of the original charter. They say, so as you can imagine, Matt, this is a really controversial idea in the fandom, particularly for those people who were fans of the original series. And even for TNG, you know, that's all Picard in such a light and holding him up to a high moral standard. This was, this was a huge thing for those of us who are coming out a little bit later. We're like, well, of course the Federation has something like that. You know, we might think, but this was a big deal. This was, this was a big, big deal. It still is a big deal. And I'm going to ask you when you get to the end, what do you think about the idea of a section 31 existing in something like what Starfleet is and like what the Federation is? And I'm going to tell you something that might blow your mind a little bit, uh, even more, but we're going to get that at the end of it.

episode right now, Matt, I'm going to turn everything else over to you and you're going to take us through this episode. There is zero B plot, none at all. So that plot is the plot is the plot. Matt, take us through it. What'd you see? What'd you experience? What questions do you have a long way? What things popped out to you? What are those moments that you were like, what? Go. As I've done so many times in recent weeks, I feel going back and reading my notes and thinking about the early parts of the episode after learning the plot twist makes me see everything in a different light. So bothering to ask, like, is it weird to relieve the entire crew of duty?

to, to take care of the situation. I mean, I guess it's a unique situation in the first place, but it was ultimately a holodeck simulation. So, okay. Yeah. I mean, we can definitely talk about that because I always find that a little weird. We're going to relieve the senior staff. We're looking for a leak, but we're going to relieve the senior staff. Why is it just the senior staff? Shouldn't you relieve the whole crew? Contact the Bajorans and have them send in like somebody to come in and manage everything else first. You know, like why just the senior staff?

their intelligence told them that it was someone within the senior staff who had a high enough security clearance or something to, to get the information that they had been passing along. Like, I mean, if you have, if you know like what information is being distributed theoretically, um, since this is all fake, um, that if it's something serious enough, there's only a certain amount of people who are going to know about it. We'll be right back. Oh, wow, man. Hey, if you recognize those sounds, then you're probably somebody who would like our show. We are called Did You Hear About This? And we talk about all kinds of news stories. It's like the 80s and 90s stuff that we grew up on. Yeah, this isn't stuff that's getting covered on the 10 o'clock news. I'll tell you that. You can check us out at didyouhearaboutthis.show. We're on every single podcast platform. Go find us.

See, I can hear that, except I'm going to turn and poke holes in that. And I'm going to say names like Michael Eddington, who is not a senior staff member, but has access to see that stuff. And I mean, he worked in security, didn't he? Right. But then there's also the dude on Voyager who was a kind of a lower decks engineer who was feeding information to Seska. And the name of the actor was Raphael Sabarge. And I don't remember the name of the character right off the top of my head. But I mean, they made that work for plot reasons because they didn't want to get rid of any actual crew. And they made this work for plot reasons because they only really wanted to talk to the seven. And really, they only wanted to talk to Julian. They didn't talk to anybody else. But it is one of those things I hear that. And I'm like.

just those guys. Okay, cool. I'm with you. Let's go with, let's just go on the ride. You want to take us on writers. But I think one thing that does stick from the beginning, I mean, no, they're doing a really good job of making me not like Sloan. Like I, at first I was going to make, make the note that, you know, I really don't like this guy, but then across my mind, it's like, well, that's how he's written. You're not supposed to like him. So I changed it to, they're doing a really good job of making me not like him. And I don't know. There are a lot of stereotypical tropes throughout this whole thing, just his, from his mannerisms to the.

devious nature of his antics and stuff. And looking back at it, like things we see in a lot of movies and TV with a character like this, you know, a special ops guy, like he's going to be kind of slimy. He's going to be a bit questionable. He's going to say controversial things. He's, he's going to essentially be the opposite of the characters that.

theoretically, you know, in love and you don't want to see them hurt at all. Like I like Julian. And so this guy's coming at him and it's like, you're bad, you're bad. You just don't know you're bad. And, and like he, he gets into the, I mean, it gets to that point eventually that I just cannot stand people. And you know, I don't know if I've said it before on air, but people are the worst. Um, Julian eventually gets to the point. He's like, whatever I say to him, either thinks I'm lying or repressing my memories. And so it's basically Sloan has an excuse for anything and everything Julian says, and he already has his mind made up. So it doesn't matter what Julian says, right? He uses circle logic on him. And I, I loved at one point that Cisco.

tried to call him out on it. And now looking back on that, I'm like, oh, that was Holodex Cisco. Oh, right. But to think that that was actually programmed into this program, to know that Cisco would call him out on it, on him using a circle logic. I'm like, that's good. They did do their research. So, I mean, I don't know who developed this program, if it was Sloan himself or when it was lackeys, but it was very well done, very well researched, very thorough. I mean, up until the end, like they did have their characters down. They did put them in the right scenarios and situations. And I think honestly, this episode.

probably just because I haven't seen enough of them, I think really kind of showcases the power of the holodeck and what holodeck programs can do, right? Because usually when I'm on a holodeck, it's with some character I've never met before. You know, maybe something is supposed to be someone from history or something like that. And so like you've heard of Isaac Newton or something like that or William Shakespeare, but it's not one of our crew members that we've been following along. So you don't really know their personality and how you expect them to act and that sort of thing. They can kind of do whatever they want. But now what we're seeing here with crew that we know we've been following for six years. And so we have a way we expect them to act and react to situations. And that's all being...

done within the holodeck someone programmed it well enough to be able to respond to julian with all the mannerisms of those characters sorry i'm just discovering all this in the middle of i i did not make these notes earlier it's just it's coming to me now um but from the time that bashir was first interviewed like they brought him out of his room the dude didn't really interrogate him at all just asked him some casual questions and then sent him back my first thought i mean julian started to notice a few things like his teddy bear was tipped over and there was something else he well the camera pointed out to us hopefully um but it's like okay They've definitely, in my mind right then, they've definitely searched this room and it may be bugged. Right. Like that, those are my first two thoughts. And now then, then like miles, well, all that miles, I guess, contacts him to have this conversation. And I'm like, dude, this is all a trap. It's all a trap. They want you to talk. They want like.

they bugged your room now. They're trying to get you to talk. And so they're going to kind of push you. And it's like, oh, okay. If we give him miles, like my first thought was like, is that really miles? Or is that a, a pre-planned video they made in an attempt to, to coerce you to talk? In no way, shape or form. Do I ever feel like that is actually miles talking to Bashir. Even in the moment, it feels fake. It feels forced. It really does. Yeah. Yeah. Even in the moment of what, like, cause he discovers how something's weird with my room. All of a sudden he chimes in and you're like, this is them being up to something, you know? And like, I'm sitting there thinking like, why isn't Bashir catching onto this? Well, I think.

he is i think he's starting to you know like because he started he starts seeing things are wrong in his room you know um and that's the only thing that gives me pause about the whole miles video thing is because bashir really seems to think that it's miles and you know let's face it sometimes sometimes star trek production isn't the greatest and you know like i feel bad saying that but it's true you know and i because obviously they would have in the real world the way they filmed that is they just take cole meanie and put him down sitting at a desk and have him look off into nowhere and he's just talking to a script reader out there you know um so it's just a bad job of putting that together but it just and maybe that's really what it was but it just it just feels off Um, did you, did you pick up though? He asked him about the breakfast, like what he wants for breakfast, you know, and obviously they're not gonna feed him breakfast because they're trying to high stress situation, make him hungry and all that. But later that's what Wei Yun pulls out is what he exactly had written down that he wanted. Oh yeah. I for sure caught that. Yeah. And so like, I mean, that was actually the first, first thing I noticed before, uh, miles chimed in with that, like, uh, that, that he got the wrong breakfast. Right. And my first thought was like, is this a test? Is this another way to kind of stress him out? Right. Like give him the wrong food. I'm like, cause at that point I'm still like, okay, this is a.

really going on, right? They have what he said, like seven crew members. They quarantine. Yeah. How hard is it to, how hard is it to get seven meals prepared and delivered to the right place? You had a little note card on the trade telling you which location to go to and who it was for. Sure. I can't mess that up. No. And I mean, frankly, at some point, look, if I, if I go through McDonald's and they put the wrong sauce in my bag, I pull back around and I go bang on that door and like, you forgot my sauce, man. If you bring me gah, I'm banging on the door being like, Hey, you brought the wrong food. This makes me want to throw up. Please at least take it away. And he's starving. He's famished. Like you don't just be like, okay, I guess I'm not eating. You go like, no, I want some food. Dang it.

i do yeah the whole mile speech felt like you know they're really suspecting you i i can't tell you anything but they're suspecting you right so so is there something you want to tell me is there something you want to divulge right like everything is a test like i i had that at that point right now now i realize yeah it actually kind of was a test to see how he handles this this situation right but that i wasn't thinking because they're trying to recruit him for an underground society Right. Like I didn't have any of that at all. Um, but I'm like, yeah, they're, they're messing with him. There are some things going on here. Right. Um, cause then when he goes back and gets interrogated the second time and actually kind of gets interrogated, we didn't see it right away because the camera was just on Sloan and Bashir. Right. But then halfway through, we get this opposite camera angle and we see his two lackeys, his guards standing by the door. Right. And I'm like in any other scenario that I have seen this high level interrogation, accusing this guy of being a traitor to everything, having dominion secrets or passing secrets to the dominion, like that interrogator would never allow them to be insane.

room. They're outside the door. Right. And so as soon as they flipped that camera and I saw them standing there, I'm like, that's weird. I didn't realize why necessarily, but I'm like, that's weird. Right. And once again, now I think that tracks a little more just with a poor holodeck program for as much credit as I want to give this holiday program. There's a lot of flaws with it too. And once again, I don't know if these are intentional or not little things that they left in there to kind of give us hints that, you know, something's off.

But in my mind, that's one of them. Like those guards should not be in the room. They should be posted right outside the door, but not inside. So once again, I'm sitting here thinking something is going on. Why is this off? Which is what you're supposed to be feeling. Like that's, that's the point, right? Like you're supposed to be like, what is going on? And I mean, even in that second interview that you're referencing there, like, like Adler Sadler, it's not his name. Sloan played by Sadler. Like Sloan first comes across. Like, I think you did this. I think you did this. And he flips. I'm here to help you. I'm here to try to help you figure this out. You know, I'm sure like it's like, I'm going to get you and I'm going to throw the book at you and you're going to rot and sell for the rest of your life. Like it's like.

dude, what is your deal? Like, are you here to actually help him? Or are you really here to, to, you know, is this, is this another episode of the drum head? You know, where you just want something, you want to find something on him. Like, well, and this is where it started to take a turn for me is like Sloan keeps accusing him with zero proof. Sure. He's like, I'm sure you did this. I don't have proof, but I'm going to make sure you go down for it. Right. And as soon as they keep pushing and pushing and pushing and Sloan's at it and his guards are at it and they're just like trying to get rid of Julian. And so then I started thinking like, are these not good guys? Like not with the Federation?

Because like, I know no one's supposed to like internal affairs. Right. Right. They're the bad guys who work for the good guys. Right. But they're the guys that hold you accountable for what you actually do. Yes.

But I mean, you know, the way they're painted on movies and television, like, yeah. But my thought is then, okay, are these guys not internal affairs? They somehow hoodwinked everybody. They're up to something more nefarious and they need Julian out of the way. Like, cause I mean, you've gotten, got me now, but Julian is a super smart guy, genetically modified to keep bringing that up. And it's like, okay, he can outsmart everybody. He's the only one who's going to be able to figure out our plan. So we need to get rid of him and then we can take over DS9 or whatever they're doing. Like, but we need the doctor out of here. Otherwise, like it's not going to work. Right. And so like, they're building up this case, building up this case. And you know, once again, like I said,

zero proof of anything but they have this uh i mean eventually he gets a starfleet special order he can neutralize security threats by whatever means necessary and i'm like you just made that well yeah so they're just going to kick him off and take him to this other star starbase 53 for further questioning right i'm like okay well at that time i'm just thinking like they want to get him away from cisco like cisco's going to interfere and prevent us from doing what we need to do right so we need to get him because cisco came in and basically once again this is so mind-blowing now that this was all simulation so cisco coming in and demanding that he gets charged. You know, this is my station. You're not removing me from duty. Like I'm still in charge here. Yeah. So get out and let me talk to my guy. I mean, play it as if it's not a simulation, just play it as if it was actually what it was because they give them credit. They did a very good job of simulating our characters right up until the defiance scene. Yes. And that scene with miles on the intercom, like that was horrible, but like, that's who Cisco is. This is, this is part of the Cisco we know. And when he sits there and he goes through that whole spiel, like, have you been, have you.

been authorized by Starfleet commander, relieve me of command of this station. No, then this is what we're going to do as long as I'm here. And I'm going to sit on this and make sure his rights are observed. And you're not going to do this. And I'm going to talk to him anytime that I sweet Bippy want, because I'm the man here. Like he laid the smack down on him. And Sloan just had to be like, okay, you get to do it. Well, yeah, he's like, okay, if you're, you're in charge of DS9, well then I'm going to take him off of DS9. Sure. So I wake him up in the middle of the night. Yeah. I'm taking you to Starbase 53 for further questioning. And I'm just thinking he wants to get away from Cisco, take him out of Cisco's jurisdiction. Yeah. He's taking him to another county, another state. But now think about it. Think about it from, from, from Sadler.

From Sloan's point of view, he created this guy, just earned Bashir's trust that much more. What is Bashir now going to tell this holographic simulation that Sloan is watching the whole time? You know what I mean? Like, and he's, he's monitoring his thoughts on the neural interface. Like, you know, it's, it's so brilliant on so many levels, but take it, just put it into, assume it's reality. That moment when Cisco does that, I mean, that is, that is Starfleet captaincy at its best. You're standing up for your guy and no matter what he's done, you're not going to let somebody come in and just railroad him. Like I said, they did their research. Whoever programmed this thing.

did their research to get those characters right. But then, yeah, Sloan gets as slimy as ever and just really starts pushing, right? I think that this is where I felt he really started applying pressure. Everything up to this point was a little bit more natural, a little bit, okay, we don't like him, but it may be legitimate. But then he basically just tries to coerce a confession out of Julian, right? And this is where I'm like, okay, I've had enough of this guy. Like, this sucks. Where's Cisco now when you need him? But yeah, tries to get him to sign a confession to avoid Maximus Carey prison for the remainder of the war, he says.

And that's when, as you mentioned earlier, he gets beamed out. And then I'll admit, for a little while, they had me convinced. That Bashir was what he was? You really are going to write him as a Dominion spy, as a sleeper agent. Yeah. As soon as he's beamed out by Wei Yun, I'm like, the biggest reason I believe Julian up to this point is because I like Julian and I don't want that to be true. Right. But this is Star Trek. This is TV. I could see it going either way. Ultimately, they can write it however they want. And this would be one of those moments that you would let me fall in love with Julian only to know that, yeah, he turns out to be a bad guy in the end.

he's a reason, you know, the Federation loses the war. I don't know how this, how the show actually ends, but. It was not looking good. And it was well played by Wayoon. Welcome home. Well, I mean, you talk about the research that they did on Cisco. Cisco is their own guy. Sure. This is the research they did on Wayoon to simulate Wayoon. The logic Wayoon uses throughout this entire scene here is magnificent. So much better than Sloan. Right. Like Sloan was just trying to force it. Right. And like I said, using circle logic, making connections where there weren't any connections, grasping at straws. Like, yeah, you're a bad guy. You're a bad guy. You're a bad guy. And I get to Wayoon. It's like, yeah, this is how it always goes. We've had these meetings before. Right. You never remember. It's kind of frustrating. But I.

got to deal with it. This is the price of dealing with sleeper agents. They never remember. It takes us a while. Yeah, focus on that food. Use your senses. It'll come back to you. And like you said, the perfect meal. You wonder, was that meal in the program already or was there a change to the matrix and they added it after he mentioned it the first time? I 100% believe that they added it after he mentioned it the first time. There's no doubt in my mind that that's what they did. It was too precise. Yeah, yeah. And they made such a thing, here's Sloan writing it down and oh, yeah, we'll send it right up. And then when they...

don't come through with it which is clearly on purpose it's they're clearly giving him the wrong food yes right um to then bring it back at this point like yeah that's that's all 100 uh a change to the matrix as you said but this scene with wayun had me flipping back and forth like three times at least because the way wayun explained it as i was saying like yeah this isn't the first time This is how it always happens. It'll come back to you and then you'll forget again. Right. Like everything, everything Sloan was telling you is actually true. Basically he figured it out, but we're here to save you. Don't worry. Right. Felt so real and so plausible at that point. And the way he explained, like you had to make a moral decision to save lives. Like that does kind of sound like Bashir. Shoot. He would have ran the numbers in his head. It's like, yeah, this is better long-term. Well, and it's literally, so they talked about the episode that we skipped where he was talking to the other genetically modified people. And a plot point of that was they felt that the best way to save Federation lives was to surrender to the Dominion. It would, it would minimize the number of lives.

lost. Like that, that was their thing that they suggested. Like they didn't just make that up for this episode. That was, that was that episode. So when he sits back and you go, yeah, absolutely. Bashir would run the numbers as a Vulcan logic. That's computer brain. This is, this is what it's going to take to, if we wage the war, here's what it's going to take. If we don't wage the war, the dominion is going to win anyway. Right. That's their, that's their probability. So surrender now and save the lives. That, that actually makes sense. Right. From, from that sort of a level, except will they really win? I don't know. Actually, I do know. You don't know. We'll have to find out. Then I drifted into a scenario that I'm not a hundred percent sure they were hinting at in the episode. It was just something that crossed my mind. Sure. Like Wei Yun is super tricky.

And at this point, he uses his head to win fights. He's not strong. And if his Jem'Handar aren't there with him, which they are most of the time, but not always, he needs to be able to talk his way out of a situation or talk his way into a situation. And he's a Vorta, that's what he does. And so I started thinking, what if Weiyun was monitoring this situation down on DS9? And none of what Sloane was telling him was actually true yet. But what if he could make it true? Because that would make this scene all the more devious. So Weiyun is just monitoring everything going on down on DS9. He's monitoring Sloane. He's monitoring.

Bashir. And he hears all of this somehow. And so at the precise moment where it would make Bashir look the guiltiest, he beams him out and then feeds Bashir this story. Yeah, this isn't the first time, even though it actually is. This isn't the first time we've done this. Don't you remember? It'll come back to you. I'm just trying to plant this memory in his head, right? So Weyoun is actually lying and trying to use this opportunity to his advantage. And this is actually where he's trying to turn Bashir into a dominion spy. He hasn't been doing it up to this point. Right, right. But this is where he tries to turn him and convince him because Bashir is super unsure right now. And why else would Weyoun save his butt? Like, why else would he do that?

If it wasn't true, if he hasn't done this before. And that just seemed like such a good twist to me. Like, ooh, Weyoun, dirty, dirty dog. Way to use this. But then Bashir starts to put pieces together, right? It's like, why would both of you be trying to convince me the same lie unless you were working together? I'm like, shoot. Once again, Sloan is not actually with the Federation. He is actually working with Weyoun. That's interesting. That would be a twist. How did that happen? So he is Dominion or he's hired by the Dominion? And then they start throwing all these other ideas at us. Like, oh, no, Sloan's the traitor. Okay, Cisco found the ship, getting attacked, all things going down.

It's like, wait, because then they beam him back, right? Right. They beam, yeah, beam a sheer back. And one of the just random things he blurts out on the Defiant, and so we're back to the Defiant, and like everybody's pressing him, like, what happened? Like, why is this going on? What are you doing? And he throws out Sloan was replaced by a changeling. Like, ooh, ooh, that's a thought too. Like, we've seen this before. Like, they already replaced Julian, but what if they replace someone else now? And this guy we've never seen before, it'd be perfect. Like, why should we believe him? Like, why did Cisco not do his research about this guy before he let him strip everybody of the powers and lock him away?

That should have been like, there should have been some, some message from Starfleet letting you know that this guy's coming. But then the idea of a changeling just got stuck in my head. And like you said, the scene on Define just broke down and broke down and broke down. Are they all changelings? Did you just teleport into a ship full of changelings? What are they going to do to you? And then they started focusing in just on Miles and it's like, oh, maybe it's just Miles is a changeling? No, they're all kind of acting weird. And I definitely caught the Miles shoulder thing at the exact same time Bashir did. Like they made that nice and obvious. So I appreciate that. But there were just so many moments in that sequence, which was probably only what, five minutes of the episode? Yeah.

I was just all over the place. Right. All over the place. It turns out it's a holodeck the whole time. Now, what I didn't understand until a little bit later, and correct me if I'm wrong, but this holodeck is not on DS9. No, DS9's holodeck are the holo suites, which are Cardassian in origin, but they also belong in Quark. In fact, that's a note I had, and this was very smart and very deliberate by them. The holodeck that they use is a Federation holodeck, not a Cardassian holodeck. The set that they used is actually Voyager's holodeck set when they filmed it because it's on a, because Sloan and Division 31 or Section 31.

our federation so it's on a federation ship with federation technology and federation stuff albeit covert um you assume even possibly with a cloaking device that the federation isn't supposed to have uh or something to be able to get in beam him out and well if they have transporter technology that apparently they can't detect as they talk about later like how do they get him out of there well either they didn't teleport him or they have technology we can't detect and like that i mean that gets in that's very much into area 51 territory right you know we have alien technology and we're trying to reverse engineer it. And, and the government is hiding all these secrets and they're trying to solve all these mystery tech things that they found. Like that, that to me, it kind of feels like what they're trying, what they're trying to point at here. Right. Right. Right. It's very much, we're two steps ahead of you and we're not going to give you our tech, even though we're theoretically on the same side. We can't release this to the general public yet. Yeah. Cause they're not supposed to have it. They're not supposed to exist yet. But that's how they stake over. There you go. They stay two steps ahead of everybody else. Well, the rest of the Federation doesn't need it. You know, let those guys handle the regular stuff. We're only.

dealing with the really, really bad stuff or the stuff that we're not really supposed to talk about that nobody wants to think about. You know, the, the, the stuff where it makes you go, you want me on that wall. You need me on that wall. Those kinds of guys, you know? Yeah. And it was all a holodeck simulation and there they are. And Bashir's being recruited into section 31, even if he didn't know it or wants to be, and they didn't give it, like he says no. And they're like, too bad, buddy. You're in it anyway. So yeah. I mean, the only question I have left then I think is as they're.

leaving the holodeck essentially like julian's like well what if i choose to expose you and sloan kind of laughs at him it's like i'm not worried about that right and then like they inject him with something knock him out so when they did that my initial thought is oh okay that's gonna make him forget everything that just happened here but then he gets back to ds9 he's discussing with the crew and he's discussing sloan he's discussing section 31 i'm like yeah wait what's the point like okay i guess they just knocked him out so they didn't know you know the location of their secret hideout but if he still remembers everything about it like Why is Sloan not worried about him being exposed? Like he still remembers everything. He's talking to people about it. I think I'd be worried, buddy. Well, I mean, I think it's also part of the he's not worried about it because Sloan doesn't exist. Yeah, sure. Go tell people. They'll never believe you that this is real. And they're not going to find me even if they think it's real. You know, Cisco, you had you just created a program based on this crew. You've done your research. Yeah. But think about it. But for what we even saw, like he asked Cisco and Cisco's like, nobody's ever heard of Sloan before. And I asked about Section 31 and they didn't acknowledge it, but they didn't deny it either. They just brushed me off. And Cisco could like that's as far as he could get. So. But is that going to stop him?

That's what we'll have to find out in next week's episode, Matt. Yeah, I don't think it will. But Cisco does order Bashir to join Section 31, which I found was interesting. An interesting order, which just tells me that we're not done with Section 31. Possible. I can neither confirm nor deny that. We'll have to look into it. Which means it's true. It's a cover up. It's a cover up. Matt, I got two more things I want to bring up for you. All right. First one is this. The role of Sloan was originally considered to be portrayed by Charlie Sheen. Not serious enough. The reason they didn't go to Charlie Sheen is basically, here's what they said. They wanted someone with enough power and strength to keep you guessing the whole time, which basically means he's not a good enough actor.

Yeah. Star power name for sure. Not a good enough actor for Star Trek. I'm going to, that's going to be the meme when this episode goes out. It's a face of Charlie Sheen, enough star power, but can't act for Star Trek. And I'm just going to say, Star Trek doesn't always have the best actors, at least not in this time period. They don't. Yeah. I love them all.

Well, there's been some rough ones. All right, here's the other one. I just want to point this out. Sloan says this to Bashir at some point. The last time he tried to attend a medical conference, you were taken prisoner by the Dominion. And he says, it's an experience I wouldn't care to repeat. The irony of that is, Matt, at the end of this episode, it's revealed that Bashir was again kidnapped while under the context of attending a medical conference. It's an experience you didn't want to repeat. He said while he was repeating the experience. Okay, I didn't think of that through. Yeah, he said it while it was actively happening. Right, right. Well, Matt, I don't have any Star Trek message out of this. I'm sure if I really thought hard, I could pull one out of it. There wasn't one. This is plot. This is introduced section 31.

Just a good episode, just a good hour of TV. At least in my opinion, a good hour of TV. Matt, I'll put it to you though. Did you think it was a good hour of TV? Did you like this episode? Is this one you want to watch again? And do you think you might have an inkling as at least why this was part of our run? I definitely know why. I mean, like I said, section 31, they're not just dropping it. Section 31's around for a while. We need that introduction. I mean, I enjoyed it for the most part. I mean, like I said, Sloan is super slimy and I really hate his guts, but that's exactly what I was supposed to feel. So in that light, it was a great episode. It did what it was supposed to do. And I definitely need to watch it again.

Once again, like I said, knowing the plot twist and as you were talking about early on, like being able to see all those things going into it, like, yeah, I need to watch it again. Yeah. Well, Matt, you know, before you watch this episode today, I texted you. I was like, hey, listen, they're going to be talking about these things that happened with Bashir, about meeting with other genetically modified people and some of these other things that Bashir did that you're going to have no idea what they're talking about. And I said, don't worry about it. Everything you need to know, they're going to explain inside of this episode. But yes, they did happen just in episodes that we skipped. Don't spend any time thinking about it. Just go with what they're telling you in the episode and carry on.

Well, Matt, if you'll grab your pen, I actually want to give you your extra viewing episodes for today because our episode for next week is actually the very next episode. I wouldn't normally have extra viewing episodes, but the ones I'm going to give you are the episodes that were referenced in this episode that we have since skipped. And there's two of them. One of them is an episode called Hippocratic Oath. I believe this was season four. This is where Bashir tries to cure the Jim Hadar of their addiction to catch or sell white. This is a good one in the development of the Bashir and Miles friendship romance. This is kind of before they really became really good friends, but it's a good one in the development of that relationship between the two. So probably more season three, actually, I would imagine. And then the second episode is an episode called.

statistical probabilities, which I think was just an episode or two ago in here in season six, maybe it was season five. Don't quote me on that. But this is the one where Bashir goes to work with other genetically modified individuals. As you might assume, those particularly genetically modified individuals having been institutionalized for their whole lives are a little crazy. And I say that in all the most loving, caring, sensitive words that I can. They're just out there, you know. So hilarity ensues in many cases. Sure. So I give those to you to go watch at your leisure. Let me know if you do. Maybe we'll do an extra viewing episode on those for our patrons. And if you guys are interested in finding out more about those extra viewing episodes, Matt does at least one a month, sometimes more. And those are made available to our patrons over.

patreon.com slash beam me up pod. Matt, the next episode we were watching here on beam me up pod for the main run. We're staying right here in DS9. I told you we're going to the very next episode. It's called in the pale moonlight and all of Trektum out there just went in the pale moonlight. And for us this week here on beam me up, a Star Trek podcast, that's going to do it for us this week. Remember folks, if you'd like to get in touch with us, we would love for you to do that. You can do that by emailing us at beam me up pod at gmail.com or head over to beam up pod.com for more ways to contact us, Matt, tell the folks where they can get in touch with you out there on the internet.

You can find me personally on both Instagram and Twitter at asamatterofnet. And if you guys want to get in touch with me, I'd love to connect with you there. I'm at Brent Allen Live across all the social medias. Hit me up. I'll talk to you there as well, too. Until next time, folks. Live long and prosper.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast?

This episode is 52 minutes long.

When was this Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on March 8, 2022.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.