Skip to content
Star Trek: Deep Space Nine | Trials and Tribble-ations episode artwork

Sep 14, 2021 55 min

Star Trek: Deep Space Nine | Trials and Tribble-ations

from Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast

The crew of DS9 find themselves back in time, on the original Enterprise, the 1701, right in the middle of the episode, "The Trouble with Tribbles." Hilarity ensues, but what does this episode do for a first time watcher? Is this episode as good as Trekkie's all claim that it is? Let's find out. If you're watching with us, the next episode will be from Star Trek: Voyager Season Three: Future's End Parts 1 and 2. If you want to contact the show: email: [email protected] Twitter: @beammeuppod Instagram: @beammeuppod Website: beammeuppod.com Matt doesn't know anything about Star Trek. Brent has been a Trekkie for over 20 years, having watched every episode and movie multiple times. Join Matt as he explores for the first time why is Trek the Cultural Phenomenon that it is today. Relive all those early moment when you first watched Trek. But since there are over 760+ hours of Star Trek, Brent's task will be to find the best 150 or so that best represent what Star Trek is, the story of Star Trek, and paint Gene Roddenberry's vision of the Future. Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/beammeuppod) Did You Hear About This? This humorous pop culture podcast discusses the latest retro stories and pop culture news. Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify Support the show

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

The crew of DS9 find themselves back in time, on the original Enterprise, the 1701, right in the middle of the episode, "The Trouble with Tribbles." Hilarity ensues, but what does this episode do for a first time watcher? Is this episode as good as Trekkie's all claim that it is? Let's find out. If you're watching with us, the next episode will be from Star Trek: Voyager Season Three: Future's End Parts 1 and 2. If you want to contact the show: email: [email protected]...

Ready to play

Star Trek: Deep Space Nine | Trials and Tribble-ations

0:00 55:08

Chapters

  1. 13:49 [Ad] Did You Hear About This?
  2. 14:27 (Cont.) Star Trek: Deep Space Nine | Trials and Tribble-ations
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

The final frontier begins. This is about saving the future of humanity. This is a huge victory for the good guys. You've never seen Voyager. Commitment to this course of action is not emotional. Johnny, beam us up. Welcome to another episode of Beam Me Up, a Star Trek podcast. I am Brent Allen, and I have seen every episode of Star Trek 47 times, but I may have seen this episode 147 times.

I was hoping for 48. Anyway, I am Matt Sonnenberg, and this is my first time through the series. And your first time watching this episode. Also true. And this is the show where we are on a mission to introduce people into the universe of Star Trek by watching, in air date order, the most important episodes that deal with the lore, the history, the timeless message, and the good old fun that is Star Trek. But as much as we love talking about Star Trek with each other, we would love to talk Star Trek with you as well. Now, we can't really do that directly, but you can send us your thoughts and opinions about these episodes to BeMeUpPod at gmail.com, and we'll be happy to read that stuff on the air and discuss whatever you have to discuss. So do that, and then go check out BeMeUp.

giveaway.com and see what we got going on there. Today's episode is the sixth episode of Star Trek Deep Space Nine season five entitled Trials and Tribulations. Mark the pronunciation there. Or as I like to call it, we do not discuss it with outsiders. In case you didn't watch this one first in this episode, the crew of DS9 gets transported back in time and inserted into the Tribble episode from the original series and hilarity ensues. Now, Matt, we're going to get to the recap of this episode. Lots and lots. That was a pretty good recap right there. That's it, right? Yeah. Yeah. They get inserted into the old episode and hilarity ensues. Like, yes, that's that's the episode. Here we go. Well, Matt, we'll get into a more detailed.

recap of the episode, but I'll give you a chance. I've sort of teased it a little bit. Tell me your initial response, overall response to this episode, trials and tribulations. So I'm going to go back to the initial text message that I sent you after I watched this episode. You asked me, how did it go? And my response was super fun episode, brilliantly executed.

That sums up very briefly how I feel about it. Like this is one of the best episodes I've seen of this kind. What do you mean of this kind? What are you talking about? Like I've seen episodes before where I don't know if it's always necessarily a time travel thing, but they like overlap with an old episode or something, some other content that we've seen before. And maybe it's sometimes even just within an old episode or a movie or something. I guess maybe it is usually time travel based, but just the way they went about it.

Even on today's screens, it didn't look super fake. Like, oh, yeah, they just green screened them in over there. And so, I mean, they made it fairly logical. And I was honestly impressed between like the dialogue and some of the interactions I have some questions about. But they just integrated the new DS9 crew into this episode very, very well. And honestly, I feel kind of fleshed out the Star Trek world. OK, what do you mean by that? I want to explore that. What do you mean it fleshed out the Star Trek world? So like you have always kind of tried to drill home for me that these ships contain.

hundreds of people, not just the crew on the bridge. And we just don't usually get to see all them. But in this episode, when we're kind of behind the scenes, just walking through hallways, there's a constant flow of people. And they hired so many extras for this episode just to walk around the halls and say, hey, yeah, there's other people on this ship that you can blend in with. And it's not just going to be the DS9 crew walking down the hallway and stop by the first person to see. It's like, what are you doing here? It's like, no, there's hundreds of other people. You're not going to recognize everybody you can blend in. And so I think that kind of helped drive that point home again. Yeah, there's so many more people here. And that's something they could do in the 90s with the budget they had as opposed to this.

60s with an basically unknown series. It's like, OK, you're working on a tight budget. You're not going to pay for. dozens of extras. So little things like that. Well, we're going to talk about all of that. We're going to talk about budgets. We're going to talk about casting. We're going to talk about special texts. I don't know how you can discuss this episode. You know, two friends sitting down having a drink, somebody who's just seen the episode for the first time. What about this? I don't know how you discuss this episode without talking about the technical side of how they did it. I don't know how you do it without talking about the references that they put into it, all the inside jokes that hopefully you picked up on most of them. And I'm going to add it kind of a section to our deal today, Matt, where it's just here are the references that they made like to themselves. Like we'll kind of separate that out from the actual plot discussion. That'd be good because I mean, I'll be honest.

Yeah, I don't have a lot of notes for this episode. Yeah, it's partly because I was very engrossed in it, but partly because like the story we've seen before, we've discussed before back on our TOS episode. It's like most of that was just a replay. Like there were some times when they just sat down and said, okay, now you're going to watch 30 seconds of the TOS episode. Like they did that multiple times. And I'm like, okay. And just to give everybody a fair warning, if it makes a difference, you had kind of suggested maybe you want to go back and watch the Trouble with Triples first. And I did because I had some extra time this week. And so I actually sat down and watched the Trouble with Triples and then I went and watched this one not knowing what I was getting into. And I was very, very glad that I watched the Trouble with Triples first because it made, I think it really makes this episode that much better because I would not have remembered that.

yeah, this is scene for scene, word for word. They're actually just using the old film. Okay. Yeah. Got it. Literally using the old film. Yeah. I got to tell you, I remember my first time watching this episode. Um, and if you guys remember my story, I did not watch TOS until like, that was like my last series that I watched of the, the TOS Berman era series. So when they're referencing Arn Darvin and this guy, Barry Waddle and this whole, this whole episode that happened, like I was aware, I was aware that what they were doing, but I didn't know who this guy was. I didn't know. When, when, when Kirk walks on the screen then. Yeah. How was that for you? Well, I mean, it's, it was, I got the, I think I was, cause I was like, I was with a girl at the time and she said, Oh yeah, they put them back.

of this old episode. So when I saw Kirk and Spock, like I knew from production. Yeah, but I mean, this episode in some ways kind of depends on you actually knowing what happened in the original episode. Sure. It doesn't because they explain enough of it, but if you're a first time watcher. But that's what I'm saying. I think this episode gets so much better if you go watch Trouble with Troubles first. Yeah, yeah. And that's what I've known as a rewatcher is if you don't need the Trouble with Troubles to be able to see and appreciate this episode. This episode is self-contained. They explain everything you really need to know and there's so much happening. You're probably not going to catch half of it anyway. This episode is so good on the rewatch. Go back. It really is. But when you have seen

the trouble with triples and not only just seen it, but when you've recently seen it going into this episode, there's so many connections that you begin to make that are, that you go, Oh, that's brilliant. Oh, that's amazing. Oh, they did such a good job with that. Um, and, and so I definitely noticed a few of those and, and there's one in particular just got me so good. Okay. Let's talk about it. What was it? Um, when, so I, I always kind of wondered in the TOS episode when Kirk opens the storage compartment and all the triples fall down and then he's standing there kind of monologuing and the occasional triple kind of trickles out. But I'm like, man, I wonder who was up there having fun, just chucking an occasional triple down on top of Kirk.

And then in this episode, they rewrite it. So it's like, oh, Cisco and Dax are out there and they're chucking Tribbles around and they occasionally fall down the hole. Right. That's actually one of the notes I had for later because they go back and do that. I love when you can take something that is a nothing and turn it into something and really do something with it. And in that specific scene, Matt, we actually talked about that scene back when we did our episode on Trouble with Tribbles that when Kirk just gets showered with this rain of Tribbles and every once in a while he gets this one and it hits him in the head and there's the shot of like he looks up like annoyed because on the other side is a guy who's just chucking Tribbles and he's like,

He's like hitting him in the head and Shatner was like, stop. It always felt like it wasn't just the Tribble casually rolling down the chute. It felt like it had a little more velocity to it. Yeah, exactly, exactly. But the guys couldn't see on the other side. They were just chuckling. They didn't know what was happening once they went over the floor. And that's why their explanation for it in this episode is so brilliant. Yeah, yeah. Well, we're going to talk about more of that kind of stuff. Matt, I mean, bottom line with this episode, there is not a single person on God's green earth that doesn't love this episode. They got everything right about this episode. They just did. And even the people who find criticism, because I've mentioned.

before I do listen to other podcasts and stuff. And I want to hear what other people have to say about an episode, get different takes. And there are some people out there who actually find criticisms of this episode. And to that, I just say they're big old dummy heads. Like seriously guys, this is a comedy. This is a self-referential art form that is not real life. So stop it. Don't pull out. You don't like this. There's a lot you can pull out criticisms for of a lot of Star Trek. This is not an episode that you criticize because they're not trying to be serious with it. You know what I mean? Like there's a lot of wink, wink, nudge, nudges, all that sort of stuff in it. And it's meant to be a laugh. You, you that like, as a, as a comedian myself, like the number of times you say, relax, it's just a joke. Like.

relax it's just a joke guys this is not the episode to find criticism this is the episode to laugh to smile and and to move forward and and frankly the effects where they're able to insert our ds9 crew into the old set episode 1996 which we sound like that's like so old and no but i mean this was like really cool cutting edge technology i highly highly recommend to everybody who has access to the dvds because there's no blu-rays of deep space nine unfortunately go watch the special features or look them up on youtube matt go for it it's fine um it's really groundbreaking what they were doing um as they go through so matt let's get into it let's let's dive into it we'll start where we always start with the character actor spotlight i have i have two Actually, I guess I want to highlight real quick. One is our Klingon in disguise, Barry Waddle, AKA Arn Darvin, who's played by a guy named Charlie Brill. I highlight him here, not because you know who he is, not because you've seen him in a bunch of other stuff, but simply because he is the exact same actor that played Arn Darvin in the original TOS episode. I kind of wonder because like his moves and mannerisms and like just the way he went about it, like all seem very familiar. And like, I honestly didn't play somebody. I'm like, he seems like that other guy that was selling the tribbles, but then they gave the name Barry Waddle and like, hmm, should I know that name? Like, okay. Yeah. And so like, I would.

I actually thought, yeah, he was Cyril Jones. But yeah, so then when they got into that, oh, Klingon, like, oh, that guy. Okay, sure. So this is DS9 continuing its streak of bringing back the original series era actors to have them reprise their roles, which we first saw them do in the episode Blood Oath, Matt, which you and I watched, which that's the one where they brought those three Klingons back, like the three main Klingons that had been used throughout the course of TOS. One of whom, by the way, was Koloth that we saw in Blood Oath, who was the Klingon from this episode, which we didn't see him in today's episode, but we did see him in The Trouble with Tribbles. He was referenced, though. Dax was like, oh, I want to go see Koloth. I want to go see Koloth. And Sisko's like, no, you can't.

We saw clips of him from the old episode. Did we? Pretty sure. I think so. I don't think so. Because he wasn't in the bar fight. That wasn't him. No, but didn't we see the episode or the clip where...

Kirk is holding the tribbles. Oh, maybe. Like right at the end. And that's when he figures out that Darwin is an imposter. Yeah, you might be right. You might be right. I think he's in there. You could be right about that. But anyway, but yeah, so they referenced that. So anyway, that's Koloff. That's the same guy that they have there. Now, I would also like to point out, actually I have quite a few others. Back with us, we have William Shatner as James D. Kirk. We have Leonard Nimoy as Spock. We have Nichelle Nichols as Lieutenant O'Hara. DeForest Kelly as Bones. And well, you get the idea, Matt. While these were not technically guest stars, the production did have to go to them and negotiate with each of them to be able to use their likeness and performance from the archival footage. So all of those TOS actors who appeared in this episode, they all got.

paid. We'll be right back. the usage of the archival footage. And I'm kind of surprised that that wasn't in their original contract that, Hey, we can use this footage in the future. However we want. Yeah. I was surprised too. That actually was a, was a shock to me because I would think that that would be standard practice. Like if I pay you, but yeah, if I pay you to create a piece of art, I own that piece of art and I can use it however I want. Um, and, and I don't need your, like, I don't know. That's just how I would want to do it. Um, but they, they did got to be, but now I, I want you to remember this fact though, Matt, that it actually is a thing that if a show uses its own archival footage later on, the actors who appear to have to at least sign off on their image being used. Okay. Okay. I just filed that in the back.

back of your head that that's actually a thing um now I don't know what each person got paid as their royalty or their fee for this episode but Walter Koenig who plays uh I know this I can picture him Koenig is, I can't think of the character name. Oh, no. Check off. He's check off. Yeah, he's check off. He commented like at a convention or something one time that he got paid eight times more for this episode than he did for his original performance. Inflation. Yeah, that's a lot of inflation. But I really wonder, like, I don't know that inflation went up that much. Maybe it did. No, I don't know. I think they just didn't get paid very much back then. That's definitely true. Yeah. Now, it was apparently such a thing that it took them like three months to get everybody to sign off and to negotiate with everybody. Like, it took a while. As you can imagine, we're talking about budgets. This contributed to the overly huge price tag for this particular episode. Yeah. Which let's talk about a lot of that. Let's talk about how this episode came to be because there's obviously.

some history going into this episode. Now, this episode came about because in this year, 1996, it was Star Trek's 30th anniversary. Now, you remember last week, maybe two weeks ago, I don't know, whenever we did our last Voyager episode, I really, these are all starting to run together for me, Matt. I gave you an extra viewing episode called Flashback, which is just sort of a one-off. I would have, I really wanted to do that episode, but this episode was just so good and both of them are just sort of their own little self-contained.

thing. They don't really fit in the larger aspect, but they're notable. But in flashback, that's the one where they took Janeway and Tuvok and they dropped them on the bridge of Captain Sulu's ship during the movie Star Trek 6. So you want to go watch that movie or that episode? It's a fine episode. It really is. Well, the production was asked by the studio to do something to honor the original series, kind of like what Voyager had done. Obviously, they were in production on these at the same time. So the production considered several ideas for how to bring TOS characters into DS9, or how do they take their DS9 people and put them back into like a setting from the original series? Or maybe like, can they put them into an original series episode but have them like take the place of the original actors like Sisko?

would be Kirk for some reason or, you know, some sort of sci-fi thing. Well, exactly, exactly. Now they considered several ideas, but it was actually a guy named Rene Echevarria, which is not a guy we've talked about a whole lot, Matt, but this guy, he's a writer, he's a producer. He's a guy, we'll talk about him at some point, I'm sure. He comes up with an idea to revisit a classic episode, just a classic episode and actually drop the characters into the episode. So that was, that was his idea. And you have to understand in order to do it, they were like, okay, well, how did they do it? Well, they said, we absolutely can do it because just a couple of years earlier in 1994, a little film that you might've heard of had come out, Matt, where they basically did the same thing. They took a modern actor and they dropped him into archival footage of the past and examples like they had this person meet for him.

presidents shake their hand and even run off to the bathroom because they had to pay, that film was, of course, Forrest Gump. So the technique was already available. That's just what they wanted to do now with the Trouble of Tribbles. And almost right away, they said, well, we're doing the Tribble episode. Like that wasn't really a discussion. It was just we're doing the Tribble, and everybody got super excited about doing it. Now, I guess sort of as the universe is conspiring to make this happen sort of a thing, one day when the staff went out to lunch, they went to a pizza shop on a street called Mulberry Street. As they were discussing it, Charlie Brill and his wife just happened to be sitting at the counter eating pizza. Charlie Brill, the guy who played Arne Darvin, right? They just, pure coincidence, just happened to be sitting there. So they went up to him, they talked.

to him for a few minutes. They pitched him the episode. He was 100% on board with coming back to redo the role. And apparently this was like a big no-no because that's not how you negotiate things in Hollywood at the time. But they did it anyway. And Bear would basically go on to say, I was Stephen Bear. He'd go on to say that this just proves that God is a DS9 fan. Now, obviously this wasn't going to be a cheap production for a television show. So they were a bit wary of what this would actually take to happen. So the team created a few test clips showing our DS9 characters in TOS episodes. One of them showed Cisco meeting Kirk in the Mirror Universe episode just as a test to say, hey, look, we can do it. We can put them in the original episode. Show that to the studio. The studio loved it. They greenlit the...

project now combine all the stuff that they're going to have to do for this along with that price tag for all the actors of the original series this results in at the time trials and tribulations would be the most expensive hour of television ever produced that's crazy i don't know that we can say that today but you know now 30 years later again uh not quite 25 years later um but it at the time it was its most expensive hour of television ever produced so with that matt i think that kind of sets the stage for us uh for me to stop talking a little bit and turn it over to you although i'm sure i've got plenty to say and plenty things to point out because there's a lot to do so matt i will I will ask you how you want to do this. I mentioned wanting to do the references and the head nods, but this is typically the spot where we do like the specific plot points. We should have, we should, we should do this before the broadcast. What do you want to do first? How do you want to tackle this episode? Cause you mentioned not having a ton of notes. Yeah, I don't have a ton of notes. And I mean, I, I really don't know if you, if you have a method to go about this, go for it. All right. Why don't we, why don't we take care of the references and head nods? Okay. And then we let's, let's call the B plot, the modern day Cisco meeting with the temporal agents. Let's call that the B plot. So to figure out what the B plot was, but that's what I said. Yeah. And then, and then we'll just talk about the A plot and that's, it's more of a, okay, you liked it.

You know, it works together. So let's talk about some of these references and head nods. Matt, did you have any you want to point out? Because I've got a whole list of them. Let me ask you this. What are the ones that jumped off to you? Like when you're watching, oh, they referenced that or oh, they did that or oh, this was here. Well, yeah, I mean, the one with the throwing the dribbles down the chute, like I said.

that worked really well for me. Um, when they transferred down or were on the enterprise and they got the new uniforms. Yeah. And okay. First of all, it was three guys who, you know, we always kind of say like we have that triad. Um, and so they all, they walked out there and I think it was, it was a Bashir that says, Hey, wait a minute, are you two wearing the wrong color? Right. And it's like, um, well.

And O'Brien goes, don't you know anything about this period of history? Exactly. Exactly. I'm like, okay. And then they follow that up right then and there with Bashir saying, I'm a doctor, not a historian. Right. Like so good. So good. Yeah. I often wonder, I've not found a single references. I'm sure it probably didn't, but you know, Bob Picardo comes up with these, I'm a doctor, not a whatever thing over on Voyager, which is something next door from where these guys are. Right. I often wonder if they made a guy, Hey Bob, what do you got for us on this one? Yeah. I doubt they did that, but I, in my head, I want them to have gone and maybe once in a while. Yeah.

I mean, I can see that happening. I like that they, I want to hope this isn't just my imagination, but I'm pretty sure they even went to the old transporter effect when they beamed onto the enterprise. Like maybe part of it was a sound effect that went with it that made me notice it more than anything else. But it's like, yeah, they obviously nowadays to recreate something they can do in the 60s wasn't too hard for them to do. But that was a nice touch there. I think those are about all that I maybe took notes on. I know there were more that I noticed, but I didn't.

make notes of them all. I mean, one of the other big things for me was, I just loved, you kind of mentioned before, Dax and Kolath, but, like, she has connections to everybody. She's been around for so long. I just loved, like, she could draw a connection to everybody. Like, we have six degrees Kevin Bacon. Like, it's one degree of Dax.

She just knows everybody. Right. Well, let me give you a few. Let me give you a few. Let's go all the way back up to the beginning. The names of the temporal agents. Matt, did you catch the names of the temporal agents? No. Dolmer and Luxley were their names. That doesn't seem to ring a bell right now. It may not, but that was their names. When they go back and like, oh yeah, they went back on such and such stardate and they go, oh, it was so long, so long, so long. And he goes, a Friday. Yeah. I did catch them say that. And I'm like, that seems odd, but okay. Because the original episode, the original COS episode aired on a Friday. Oh. Because that was the days that they aired back then. So Friday. Okay. That was theirs. Bye.

the way. Should I say it now? Yeah, I'm going to say it now. I was going to save this for the B-plot when we get to that discussion, but... the names of the agents, Dolmer and Luxley, Dolmer who wanted, or Luxley, I think, who wanted the truth and Dolmer who was skeptical of the truth or whatever it is. Those were anagrams of the name Mulder and Scully. Oh boy. Yeah. Little X-Files reference for you there. Yeah. That's great. That's great. We got a Gorn reference in this episode, Matt. There was. Cisco was like, I want to go back and talk about Cestus 3 and when he fights the Gorn. Yep. I caught that one. Yep. So I love that. And again, I told you, man, that Gorn thing just comes up when you least expect it. Oh, this is a deep cut, Matt. A deep cut. Barry Waddle slash Arndarvin. When they first meet him, they...

He claims that he deals in Kivas and Trillium. Okay. Now, this is a reference to the first TOS episode where we ever saw Klingons. The name of that episode was Errand of Mercy. You and I did that episode. Sure. It was the very first time we ever saw Klingons in Star Trek, period. And in that episode, Kirk and Spock dressed up like traders or salesmen or something like that to try to get in and talk to the Klingons. And Spock says that what they're dealing to the Klingons is Kivas and Trillium. Wow. That's a deep cut. Deep, deep cut. There's a moment, moving on from that, there's a moment when Sisko goes, storage compartments? Storage compartments! He says it in the exact same way that Kirk said it in the original episode. Like when they realized the Tribbles are in the storage compartments. Storage compartments? Storage compartments? Like he referenced that.

Like, it was weird when he said it. And I'm like, I don't know. That just didn't feel like Cisco. But okay, that totally explains it. Quark. Let's talk about Quark for just a second. So Quark makes an appearance in this show. And he only makes an appearance. He has no lines. This, by the way, is the only episode. This is the only episode that Quark appears where he doesn't have a single line of dialogue. He's right at the end. He's on screen for about six seconds. He's just sitting there with his hand on his thing. And he's covered with Tribbles. He's got the one he plucks off his head. That is an in-joke that, you know, and think about it. He had to go through all that makeup on all the time to get makeup off for that one little shot. Because in The Trouble with Tribbles, there's a shot of the bartender sitting there covered in Tribbles. It's true. And it's a reference.

So that's where that one came from. All right, now the big one I got to talk about, Matt. Let's talk about Worf talking about the Klingons. Oh boy. We're not talking about the Klingons. In that scene, Worf finally gives us an in-canon explanation for why the TOS Klingons look different or not. He just says, we don't discuss it with outsiders. He says, yes, they are Klingons. And basically he says, but I'm not going to take the time to explain it to you. Yeah, because we don't discuss it with outsiders. And Bashir and O'Brien are like, whoa, was it genetic engineering? Was it viral mutation? Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. One, I just have to say, I love the fact that they finally address it to where they say, yes, those are Klingons.

And no, we don't talk about it, which is ever since they updated the look of the Klingons back in the original Star Trek movie, because that's when they changed. Gene Roddenberry, he gave us, he's like, well, maybe it's a different sect, maybe there was all this other stuff happening, or maybe the show just finally had a budget where they could make them look the way they were originally supposed to look anyway. And everybody just kind of goes on. But people had been talking about why they looked different in TOS for so long, and there was the rule that they had in Star Trek, like, you don't discuss it. Like, yes, they're Klingons, and no, we don't discuss it. Yes, there's only one Mickey Mouse, and yes, he's a boy. That's the rule, you know? Kids, there's one Mickey Mouse, and yes, he's a boy. Just don't ever let anybody tell you different. That's the rule.

So to have, to have Worf say it to them, to go, yes, they're Klingons. We do not discuss it with outsiders. Now the Bashir and O'Brien. specifically talking about genetic engineering and viral mutation, those were the two biggest fan theories that have been floating around out there. I was going to say, that's the internet. Yeah, it is. Remember, internet's still kind of in its infancy. It's getting a little, you know, it's evolving a little bit. There were forums and message boards. Sure, absolutely. And there's still conventions. They talk about it at the conventions and stuff. So this was all Ronald D. Moore. We've talked about him several times. He was one of the episode writers. It was him and Renee. And they included the scene as a nod to the fans, as an acknowledgement of the difference. And this is one of those wink, wink, nudge, nudges that people love to over-criticize. Stop it. It's meant as a production. Yes, they're Klingons. No, we don't talk about it.

it. Fans have these theories, but we're just not going to, we're not going to approach it, but it's, it's the, it's the laugh of it. Right. Um, so I, I love that. I love that they put that in there. I love that they acknowledged it and I love that they went forward with it. So I love the scene. It might be my favorite scene of the whole, of the whole episode personally. And with that, Matt, that's all the references and head nods that I have outside of the set and the costumes and all of that. So why don't we talk about the B plot real quick? Well, let me ask you this before we do that. Did you have any other specific character moments that just sort of jumped off the screen that you want to talk about before we get into the plots? I think that was a bulk fit. There was just a lot of good humor in here. Absolutely. Yeah. So much humor. I mean, I started off with Jack, the Dax, uh,

making the joke about being always on time. And then everybody trying to pick on Worf and like O'Brien trying to get Dax to pick on Worf as well. Just tell me, you smell a hint of white hearts of lilacs. Okay, sure, sure. And then Dax goes, no, no, no, I've got my own way of dealing with Worf. Yeah, which makes you wonder. But I mentioned this to you as well, but Temporal Investigations, I just got done watching Loki, the new Disney Plus series. And that's the only thing I could think of during this whole thing. This is the TVA, like Star Trek did the TVA first. Got it, okay. There it is, yeah. So the B-plots, quick recap of that.

In the present time, Cisco is having to relay the events of a time travel incident to temporal agents, Dolmer and Luxley, with no sense of humor. Once the agents decide that no big deal, that there's been no big deal about this incident, it is revealed that they have actually brought back a load of dribbles to the station in the present, and they now have to deal with film. That's pretty much it. It's a bounce back and forth, you know. Yeah. They spend most of the time on A-plot, so. Sure, sure they do. But I do. I love the sort of dad jokes, the time jokes that they give them, that you know a lot of people, like they've heard these jokes a thousand times. Like they're not funny to them anymore, but they're hilarious to everybody else who says it, you know. I am curious though. They mentioned.

that Captain Kirk had 17 temporal violations. Yes. Have all of those been documented? Are all those like from episodes? Or are they just pulling a number out? So there are seven time travel episodes. But I did see out there where somebody came up with 17 incidences between the episodes. But I mean, don't forget the biggest one, Star Trek 4, the one with the whales, where they went all the way back in time. You talk about a temporal incursion. You know, I mean, they basically, they got a species that had been extinct and they brought them back and made them not extinct anymore. Which some people say, some people say this is actually what happened with the Tribbles. That the Tribbles, like when they exploded the Tribbles.

or did something with the triples, like they were wiped out. Well, yeah, back in the TOS. Yeah, Worf kind of gives that idea. Like he mentions, like we annihilated them. Like we got rid of them. They were a pest. Like we did everything we could to get rid of them. And that almost made it sound like when he heard triples, it's like, man, these things haven't been around for hundreds of years. How are we getting, why are they back? Like, go away. But Worf wouldn't have been around then though, you know? No, but he wouldn't have been around, but I could see that being, you know, something that was taught in the Klingon history books since they hate them so much. And Worf, so just he imbues all things Klingon, whether he personally doesn't, I agree with you on that.

I never had that impression. I got to be honest with you. So the idea that they've repopulated a species that was once extinct now across the universe, that's an issue that probably needs to be dealt with. But, you know, again, it's all jokes. The only thing I could say, this one bothers me every time I see it. And I heard, I think it was Norman over at the Mission Log podcast. He also pointed it out where one of the agents is sitting there fiddling with the baseball on Cisco's desk. Like while they're talking, I'm like, dude, you don't touch another man's baseball on his desk like that. I was thinking about that too. They kind of made a point of him setting it back down and you could see Cisco in that shot when he sends it down. I'm like, man, he's not happy right now. You don't, don't, don't, don't mess with another man's balls, man.

It's just the way it is. Leave him alone. But yeah, that's all I had as far as the B-plot goes. Yeah, yeah. Let's talk about the bulk of the episode, what actually makes the episode. The crew of DS9 has picked up a passenger stranded on Cardassia, along with the Orb of Time, which winds up sending the Defiant back in time to the events of the episode Trouble with Tribbles. As soon as they arrive, that passenger beams off the ship, and it seems he's actually a Klingon in disguise, Arn Darvin, who was foiled in the attempt in the original episode.

So now he wants to complete the mission and the crew must go into deep cover and betting themselves into the original episode to stop him before he can help his past self destroy the station. And again, hilarity ensues. Matt, what you got? I like how they kind of addressed what their version of time travel was going to be right off the bat. And they, in my opinion, at least they did this by, you know, the investigators asking Cisco. So do you think this was a predestination paradox time loop that you were meant to go back in the past? It's like, no, no, it was an accident. We weren't supposed to do that. So I thought that was kind of interesting because like I said.

they ended up playing it both ways. Like, I feel that there were some things that they made happen that didn't happen the first time, or at least we didn't know about. But there are some things that, like my favorite example of them throwing the tribbles out of the chute onto Kirk that would kind of infer... that it was a predestination paradox using their terms there, but that they were always meant to go back to the past because like they were always there because that part didn't change. And they gave us an explanation for how that happened. So I, you know what, you know why this is your favorite episode, Matt? Yeah. Because it follows the correct rules of time travel, which is why Prisoner of Azkaban is your favorite Harry Potter novel. Everybody drink a drink because it follows the rule at the time. And I've said this time and time again, if anybody's new out there, I have, I have often referenced, I think Matt's in agreement with me that if time travel is possible, and I think it might be in reality, I think it might be, you can't go back and change the past because what happens is what happens. Yeah. What happened already happened. I don't, it's not a paradox. You're not going to go to go back to the past.

and, you know, kill someone and make me disappear. Right. And you're not going back to the future. Right. But, right. And if you are your own grandpa Bashir, then either you will be or you won't be. It's not a, it's not always a weird one. That's a weird one. That's a, that's a weird mind. But do you think Tom Arnold, you know that name? I do. He was a comedian out of the late nineties, used to be married to Roseanne Barr at some point. Um, Tom Arnold, um, maybe a B level comedian, I guess. Uh, he had a song that he wrote called I'm My Own Grandpa. Go YouTube. It's, it's really funny. I don't think I'm familiar with that. It's actually fairly funny. And like, he talks about like the, how it happened and all that kind of stuff.

but in a different way than Bashir would have been his own grandpa here. But it, uh, yeah, that's, I don't believe in paradoxes. Now I can't, I can't, I can't hold that against sci-fi that uses time travel and they use the paradox and the changing history as a trope. So often I go, Oh, that's, I can't say that because that would just get annoying, but I will reference it here just to say they did it right here. Yeah. You know, so I'm all for it. Sure. So I was a little confused when, when they were on the enterprise and they all kind of changed their outfits, like Cisco and stuff, you know, they, they got their, their outfits and they, they fit in just fine. But then we had a few, a few outcasts like Odo and correct me if I'm wrong, but I, I'm pretty sure they just gave him.

Cyrano Jones's outfit. That's what it looks like, didn't it? Like, even down to the shirt. Like I said, I had just watched the other one. And like, he has this weird, like, I don't know, stripy shirt that for some reason I noticed. And I'm pretty sure Odo was wearing the same shirt and the same jacket. Like, Odo's not as big as Cyrano Jones was, or at least not as padded as they made him with his coat of many pockets. But I'm pretty sure it's like the same outfit. And that just seemed to confuse me. I'm like, is Odo going to try to sell triples? Or like, what is going on here? And it turns out he just randomly sits in the bar. Okay, cool.

But I don't know. It felt like a weird choice of outfit. I've never thought too much about it, to be honest with you. Like him or Worf, either one of them. It's just what they did to blend in. I did love, though, just speaking of Odo, I think the first time I really saw them incorporating the original footage.

with this crew because there's one thing to go like, okay, in this shot, it's the crew. And then they flash to the shot and this shot and this shot, but there's a shot where whoever comes into the bar and like, she's talking to the guys at the, at the bar and it's over her shoulder. You see Odo's like sitting there watching her and all of a sudden it's together. The first time I made the note that they, they did a really good job of incorporating Odo. Yeah. And then just kind of continued throughout the episode that, Oh, they did a good job incorporating everybody. Okay. But yeah, can we, can we go ahead and talk about that? Sure. Because I didn't, I purposely didn't put the technical side up there. I want to talk about, but this is, I think the place, because that's, that's really what this, this episode is about is how did they do this and how did they pull it off?

Um, at least I think it is. So these effects were used or were created using a combination of very few blue screen effects. Like they used a few blue screen effects, but mostly it was a painstaking recreation of the original series sets. Again, ballooning the cost because they weren't going to, uh, just have these actors on a blue screen interacting with a set and like pasting them in there. Like that, that wouldn't work. It wouldn't look right. It just didn't.

Now with that, while they filmed it, the director that they brought in, they actually use the old lenses and the type of film and the lighting techniques that they use in 1967. I was going to mention that too, because there was one scene in particular where I think it was Odo again in the bar and he was super, super red. And I'm like, okay, they really went, we're, we're pretending we're in the sixties shooting this. I mean, there's, there's no other explanation for that. Why it should look so, I mean, honestly bad by today's standards, especially like, I mean, okay, it was an artistic choice for this episode. I understand it. I'll allow it.

sense within this episode, right? Yeah, I'm glad that things have improved in, you know, lighting techniques and whatever, whatever caused that. Like, I don't know if that's in the film or if that's in the lighting or what causes that to happen then. But yeah, I noticed it. Yes, definitely noticed it. Now they had to, like I said, I had to recreate those sets, right? They had to recreate the hallways. They recreated the bridge. They recreated. And I mean, from the flashing lights to everything, the original blueprints, screen references, everything. And their stories of how like, like they had the blueprints, but then like when they were making the original set, something happened and it changed away from the blueprints. So when they came back to follow the blueprints, like somebody, it was like somebody.

original production who was like, oh, wait a minute. Wait a minute. That's wrong. That's not what wound up happening. And like they saved him because otherwise the scale would have been off. Even Walter Koenig, we referenced him earlier. He came and visited the set and he had to show Colmini and Alexander Siddig how to properly interact with the set and different things. There's only one spot where they actually really changed what happened. And it's that spot where Cisco's like, hey, Dax, you scan for Darwin and I'm going to pretend to mess around in this panel. Right. Yeah. That panel did not exist in the original series shots. Fair enough. But they added it. Yeah. That's like the only thing. Like everything else is exact. It was kind of off on a side hallway that I don't know that we saw in the first episode. So no.

Now, the other thing that they had to redo is the exterior shots of the Enterprise and the K-7 space station. Now, they actually had to create new models for this episode in order to shoot them. The Enterprise, the original model for the Enterprise was actually hanging from the ceiling in the Smithsonian Institute at the time. Actually, it's still there. If not, it's at the Sci-Fi Museum over in Seattle, which if you ever get a chance to go over there and go see it, absolutely go do that. I know they have Kirk's original chair over there. So they actually recreated a new, brand new Enterprise model. Had it all, you know, detailed all the way down. And the K-7 model, the space station model, had just been lost. Nobody knew where it was. You didn't know what happened to it. So they had to build a new one. Now, both of those models were only about half the size of their original. Like, the original Enterprise model was like,

11 feet long. This one was only like five, which is still huge. I didn't know they built in that big. I know, right? That's huge. I thought they just went, you know, super zoomed in. Right. Like little, you know, get one of my little starships behind me over here. Yeah. A few inches big and just really close up. Right. No, no, they, they had pretty good sized models that they used, but, but they did them in such perfect scale. I mean, everything was, was super duper exact. Now, the other thing as far as how did they incorporate them into the original, into the original film, like with, you know, they, how do they put them into the screen with, with each other? Well, that's where more of the blue screen stuff comes in, but they actually went back to the negatives of the TOS episode, the old film negatives and scanned them.

in digitally because we were starting to move to digital editing now, right? So rather than having to paste them in, so they scanned them in so that they could match it and just make it look awesome and color it the same and all that sort of stuff. So, you know, this is the first time in Star Trek history that we've ever seen the original series in the new digital era with DVD quality rendering. I can't say it's HD because HD is different than DVD, but that was HD back in the day was DVD. And this is perhaps where the idea came from to go back and do it with the entire series with the TOS series where they released them on DVD and eventually on Blu-ray. They re-scanned in all of the negatives and had to re-cut the film. They also did that with TNG, lost a lot of money on TNG, which is probably why they're never going to do it with Deep Space Nine or Voyager, which is unfair.

fortunate, um, for that. Now, one other, one other thing, um, oh, so, so they, they push them together. I want to show you something here, Matt, just, just so you can see it. Uh, I'm going to put up a picture here for you. I'm going to describe this for the listening audience out there. This is a picture of Kirk walking down. This is after the barroom fight and he's dressing down all the officers and we see Scotty and we see Chekov, but then you see O'Brien and you see Bashir and you see the whole other line and, and Kirk goes up and he talks to Bashir and he talks to, uh, O'Brien, you know, kind of giving them the dressing down. Well, would it interest you to see the side by side of the original shot of this map? Yes. I honestly, here you go.

This is a side-by-side shot of the original, and you can see the two guys that they digitally edited out. Yeah, I was going to go back and look at that after I saw that. I'm like, okay, so they had to replace him somehow. And just the way they shot it, because right after that, they all turn and walk out the door. And I think they may have cut it early from the other episode when they start walking. They didn't give us as much of that just to make it easier on the editing team. And actually, you can see they had to edit the guy right past Bashir, because that's a different person from the original episode. But everybody else down the line, those are all the originals. I want to give you one more, Matt. One more I want to give you. This is the scene where at the very...

And Cisco's like, I got to go do one more thing. And he goes to Kirk and have a hand. And they do this. Well, so you have Cisco who's in his gold. Was that in the first one? I was trying to remember if it was. You know, I think this was actually from a different episode. I really do. And I've always thought this was from a different episode, but I could be wrong. All right. I watched him back to back basically. And I didn't remember that being in there. I think this was from a different episode, but it is from an actual episode. Well, obviously it had to be because they had the footage of Kirk. Sure. They couldn't get a young Kirk again. Right. Unless they did it digitally. But right. You got Kirk in his ugly putrid green colored uniform. I hate that uniform. Me too. Me too. But yes, there you go.

so there's the original well I'll try to get these put up in show notes or somewhere I'm not sure how we do that uh for that but just just to show you like they literally inserted these guys into the footage to make it happen and again I mean go watch the special features folks uh just because the the technical side of how they put the show together is is just as interesting if not more than the actual story that they were telling because I mean that last one in particular I just want to point out again because that was the one I felt where like the lineup was one thing. Yeah. Yeah. They, they talked to each other in a sense, but that, that was just clever camera work, you know, flipping back and forth. Right. You know, okay. He says this line, so let's give him a line that sounds like Ryan's going to snap in in between there. Cool. Um, but this one here at the end was Cisco talking to Kirk. He actually hands him something. Right. And so that's the one that's more impressive to me is like, he, he hands him an object and I'm like, okay, so that had to have happened somewhere, but they, they made it look seamless. I mean, maybe if you're a, a audio video guy and a really technical person who, who you could point out some flaws, it's like, Oh, there's a pixel off here or something. I don't know.

But just just watching it for the first time, it seemed pretty flawless. Yeah. Now, for reference sake, Matt, just just so you know, a mere five years later, a movie would release called Lord of the Rings. OK, you've probably seen it. Yes. Just five years later. So I don't know how long it took them to produce this movie, but you're probably only talking about three years later in terms of actual like making the movie. Right. And in this movie, they used forced perspective to take two actors that were effectively the same size and make one look like a hobbit and make one look like a full grown wizard, having them handing and passing objects back and forth to each other seamlessly. Yeah. Watching behind the scenes on that stuff is crazy. It's crazy. Right. And you just you realize like this is where, you know,

know technologies for shows are really starting to take off in and about this time I have one more note for you oh two more I'm sorry two more notes for you Matt about making the film when Dax and Cisco first enter the set and are walking down that TOS corridor the original enterprise corridor that's actually the first time that Avery and Terry had been allowed to see the sets so all of those reactions are their genuine reactions to like like just oh my gosh looking at these sets that they had there which I was I thought that was neat I like that when I like that when productions do stuff like that sure you know or like they keep two enemies away they keep two enemies away like they don't let the actors interact so they can be all you know pissy with each other yeah you know they're sending notes back and forth that the crew was writing to each other, saying mean things about them. And then let's talk about the fight because that's the other, I think, big thing where they get inserted. That fight, I think they said it took them two weeks to film that fight because it was so intricate for how they had to set everything up. The stunt crew in that episode, or in that fight scene, had to learn an all-new fighting style to go with that 1960s brawl. Dude, I'm telling you. They had to learn it because they didn't know. Getting in Star Trek is so bad. Oh, it is. Especially the old 60s stuff. Yeah, and it was apparently, it was really a big challenge for the modern stunt workers to learn how to do it. They said it was a lot of fun, but they said it was really hard for them to learn how to do it.

to go in and make all that. So, uh, yeah, that's, that's pretty much, that's, that's pretty much how they did the show. Uh, they, they made it. I mean, it's, they went back in time and they inserted themselves and everything worked out. They saw, I mean, it's, it's, it's prisoner of Azkaban all over again, right? Like that's fun. It's fun to see that, that last, the last half hour of the movie, I guess again, um, it was just so funny, Matt. It's so funny. It was, it was like, I, I, I told you once again off air, I hate saying that, but, um, this watching this episode honestly felt like an extra viewing. Yeah. It, it felt like something that you wouldn't include in the normal run and.

just we picked for fun later on and like yeah it had that that vibe to it like this is a really fun episode I just want to watch it right it has that fun but it's it's and I'll tell you this is not going to affect anything going forward like under any other surprise if it did I think yeah if this episode if this episode wasn't as great as it was we would not have stopped to watch it but it's why it's frankly it's why we didn't watch episode and it's it's a technical Marvel masterpiece. I mean, it's why we missed Flashback over on Voyager. Sure. Because you put these two episodes up next to each other. I love Voyager, but it does not compare. If this episode didn't exist, do you think we would watch Flashback then?

I don't know because, you know, I'm, I'm really, I'm really picky with what episodes I let us watch, you know, cause I mean, we're just over the halfway point through this run and like, I'm looking ahead and I'm going, we've, you've got a good idea of what Star Trek is. Now I got to get you through the series. So if we're going to watch it, it can't like, there's not many of them that are just for fun. You know, the, the ones we're watching really have to, they have to do something to the character. They have to move the plot forward. They have to do something or have a big, huge, like Star Trek message behind them. But sometimes occasionally there will be an episode that is so monumental. So marquee the Gorn episode, this episode. Yeah. Yeah. Going back and thinking about that, that was so early on.

But like the Gordon episode, yeah, definitely didn't affect plot or anything along those lines. So. it definitely falls in this bucket, I think. Sure, sure. So with that, Matt, man, I think that's it. That's all I've got on this episode. Is there anything else you want to talk about? Any other references you want to make as far as we wrap up our discussion here on Trials and Tribulations? I think that'll do it. All right, Matt. Well, I feel silly asking this, but I do every episode. Did you like this episode? Do you want to watch it again? Yes. You understand why it's part of our run? Well, kind of. We just discussed it. Does this episode help get you beamed up into the fandom, Matt? That's the question at hand, really? I think so. This makes you a fan of the show. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah. Like you said, there's no one that doesn't like this episode. You can't. It's a law. It's actually...

It's a law of God himself that you can do. All right, Matt. Well, would you like to know what our next episode is? That would be I got to tell you, I feel bad for this episode because we're here with trials and tribulations. And then like, I don't know. I don't know. Do we get super serious? And no, I will tell you it's another time travel episode, though. OK, we are going over to Star Trek Voyager, which, by the way, several investigations, you get the idea that they're not a modern group. Like they're kind of over all the time. And they talk about how Kirk was like the most violent, you know, the biggest offender. I'll tell you what. James T. Kirk got nothing on Kate Mulgrew. He got nothing on Captain Janeway. OK, he know because she likes to play in the timeline. Just saying, just saying, throwing it out there. Anyway, the episode.

we're going over to Star Trek Voyager season three, Futures End. This is a two-parter, Matt, and it's Futures End part one and two. So we will be watching that episode for next week. You'll want to enjoy that episode. Yeah, I'll leave it there. Well, because we'll talk. Yeah, we'll do that. I do have a couple of extra viewings that I'd like to give you, Matt. Okay. And these are located here on Deep Space Nine. The first one is an episode called Things Past. Let me give you the description. After getting knocked out, Sisko, Odo, Dax, and Garrick awake in the past on Terok Noor, which is what DS9 was called when the Cardassians were involved. And they are about to be executed for an attempt on Dukat's life. Really good episode. Fan-freaking-tastic episode. Does not affect where we're going in the future. So we're skipping it. But a good episode.

I'd give it to you as a potential extra viewing for the month of September. I will also give you this one, The Ascent. The Ascent is one of those episodes, Matt, I feel like every sci-fi show does, where you take your odd couple of the show and you put them together and force them to be together for an entire episode and stuff happens. And this one, Odo and Quark walk up a hill. Okay. That's pretty much it. Odo and Quark walk up a hill, but it's Odo and Quark trapped together. For whatever reason, I tend to find these odd couple episodes, they're going up. Like here, they're walking up a hill. Voyager did one like this.

that had Tuvok and Neelix trapped in an elevator. Okay. It was like a spatial elevator. So it was going to outer space. It was an elevator nonetheless. But for whatever reason, I find they're always going up when we put the odd couple together. I don't know why, but I don't know why. So anyway, yeah, next week though, Future's End, part one and two. And for this week, Matt, that's going to do it for us in our discussion of trials and tribulations here on Beam Me Up, a Star Trek podcast. Remember folks, if you'd like to get in touch with us, email us to beammeuppod at gmail.com or head over to beammeuppod.com for more ways to contact us and beammeuppod, no, just beammeuppgiveaway.com. You guys check out the cool stuff we have going on over there. Matt, where can the folks find you out there on the internet?

You can find me personally on both Instagram and Twitter at asamatterofmat. And if you guys want to get in touch with me, you can find me at BrentAllenLive across all the social medias. I'd love to connect with you there as well, too. Until next time, folks, live long and prosper.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast?

This episode is 55 minutes long.

When was this Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on September 14, 2021.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.