Skip to content
Star Trek: Enterprise | Home episode artwork

Nov 1, 2022 47 min

Star Trek: Enterprise | Home

from Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast

The Enterprise has returned home, triumphant over the Xindi, preventing a much larger attack. While everyone is singing their praises, the crew is having trouble readjusting to their new status as celebrities while the mood on Earth has shifted to fear and retaliation against anyone who is not human. If you're watching with us, the next episode will be a three parter that we will call "The Augment Trilogy." This one will cover the episodes, "Borderland," "Cold Station 12," and "The Augments." These episodes are back to back Contact the show: email: [email protected] Twitter: @beammeuppod Instagram: @beammeuppod Website: beammeuppod.com Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/beammeuppod) Did You Hear About This? This humorous pop culture podcast discusses the latest retro stories and pop culture news. Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify Support the show

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

The Enterprise has returned home, triumphant over the Xindi, preventing a much larger attack. While everyone is singing their praises, the crew is having trouble readjusting to their new status as celebrities while the mood on Earth has shifted to fear and retaliation against anyone who is not human. If you're watching with us, the next episode will be a three parter that we will call "The Augment Trilogy." This one will cover the episodes, "Borderland," "Cold Station 12,"...

Ready to play

Star Trek: Enterprise | Home

0:00 47:59

Chapters

  1. 15:31 [Ad] Did You Hear About This?
  2. 16:09 (Cont.) Star Trek: Enterprise | Home
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

The final frontier begins. This is about saving the future of humanity. This is a huge victory for the good guys. You've never seen Voyager. This course of action is not emotional.

Welcome to another episode of Beam Me Up, a Star Trek podcast. I am Brent Allen, and I have seen every episode of Star Trek 47 times. And I'm Matt Sonnenberg, and this is my first time through the series. And this is the show where I am on a mission to introduce my good buddy, Matt, to the Star Trek universe by watching an air date order. Oh, it's been a while since I've said that. The most important episodes that are dealing with the lore, the history, and the timeless message that makes Star Trek, Star Trek. But whether you're spending time on Earth or taking a little jaunt over to Vulcan, I would encourage you to head over to beammeupod.com. Click on the YouTube icon.

in the upper right hand corner. And you can join us behind the scenes and see where this podcast started, how it starts every day, every week, every month, however often we put this show out, just like you can kind of figure out where T'Pol's coming from. It's a weird place over there on Vulcan, but we'll talk about that later. Today's episode is from season four of Star Trek Enterprise Entitled Home, or as I like to call it, Enterprise's version of the show Family. In case you guys didn't watch this one first, or it's been a while, in this episode, the crew returns home from the Expanse, having stopped the Zindi from deploying their weapon. Archer is dealing with some PTSD, Tripp and T'Pol take a visit to Vulcan, and Dr. Phlox has to deal with some lasting xenophobia on Earth. Now, Matt, we're going to get into the recap of the episode here in just a little bit.

But first of all, do you know what I mean when I say Enterprise's version of the show family? Nope. Do you remember the episodes Best of Both Worlds, part one and two from Next Generation? Yeah. That's the one where Picard became a Borg. I was going to say something with the Borg. Yeah. The one where Picard became Borg. When we were done with that, the next episode we watched was called Family. That's the one where Picard was dealing with the consequences of being Borgified. And he wound up going home to LeBarre, France. And we met his brother and his sister-in-law and his nephew, Rene. And him and his brother wound up fighting in the mud and the grape fields and stuff like that. Right. That's this episode for Enterprise. Like you're dealing with the fallout of this big thing and not just moving on. And honestly, that's why I really like it.

think because it's not just like they get done with it and then hey we're off on another adventure like they're actually sitting in it for a while i thought you were gonna like this episode because i'm like first like five minutes into this i'm like brent you just give me another courtroom drama episode But no, that wasn't where this episode went. For those of you who couldn't see it, Matt just rolled his eyes at me hardcore until he was like, yeah, but that's not where it went at all. So Matt, what did you think? Having just watched this episode for the very first time, to be fair, let's just remind everybody if you haven't been following along, Matt has skipped the entire Zindi story arc with the exception of the episode that kicked it off with The Expanse. We watched one episode in the middle that really had more to do with the Andorians and now he gets this episode. So he hasn't really seen it all, but you know, they won. Yeah, they made it back. I mean, that was pretty obvious. All except 27 of them, apparently. I'm guessing all unnamed crew members.

But yeah, it was good for the most part. There were parts of this episode, I think they had a hard time avoiding it, but it felt more like a 90s sitcom than Star Trek. Okay. But it still wasn't awful. I've seen worse. Okay. So it was okay. Let me ask you this. Did you find yourself confused because of having skipped the whole thing with the Zindi story arc throughout the course of the episode? Or did you have enough background information from either what I told you or what they told you within the episode itself to be able just to sort of catch up with where they are and move forward with the story?

I think as far as the Zendi were concerned, like I didn't feel confused about that. No, like we saw they had a weapon. They were trying to blow up her. A lot of people died. Like that was the gist of it. And they stopped them. I guess ultimately is the other thing. Like that's enough. That's enough to get what's going on. Like the biggest thing that I was confused about that I feel, I don't know if it played out in season three or if I was supposed to pick up on it before that. What was the whole trip into Paul thing? Like to me, that came out of nowhere. And it was kind of half of this episode. I did tell you about it. I don't know if you remember. I did. I told you like two episodes ago. I was like, hey, just so you know, trip into Paul become a thing.

during this season three. And it's basically, they both have some trauma and they're dealing with it together and they get emotional. I don't know that you told me, but it's one of those things that I'm not going to remember. Yeah. And it feels like a little detail. And then I hit this episode and it's like, oh, okay, maybe not a little detail. Yeah. It was, I mean, it was weird because it never really advanced to the point of a relationship. Like think of a Worf and Jadzia, a Tom and B'Elanna, where like when you saw them, they were in a relationship. That wasn't always Tripp and T'Pol every time we saw them on screen. Like generally they were acting in accordance with their duties, but occasionally there'd be a scene where they sort of steal away together. And it wasn't like a big fiery romance.

Like that's not at all what it was. Like it was just, they had a connection. Uh, they had some private time together. Things happened a couple of times and you know, it's a Paul's being very Vulcan and very, you know, stiff with the whole thing and you know, trips trip. So, uh, yeah, but you did get an understand enough that trip and to Paul are in a relationship and trip kind of figured out his actual feelings for to Paul in this, in the course of this relationship. Cause that's kind of not where they've been and who knows what's going on with the Paul because of how this episode ends, but we'll definitely get there. Matt.

Like I said, we're going to jump into all the details of this. I'll let you expand on that here in just a few minutes. But I do have a character actor spotlight I want to give us here for today. Since we really are not going to have a specific episode for this particular character. Unfortunately, he's kind of getting the shaft in this podcast, the way that we're running through this series. This is where we're going to do a spotlight. And I'm going to give him his moment to shine. He does have episodes that focus on him. So he is a developed character. We're just happening to miss them. So today I want to talk to you about our helmsman, Travis Mayweather. Travis is played by a guy named Anthony Montgomery. Anthony is from Indianapolis, Indiana, home of the best acapella music group. Straight No Chaser has absolutely nothing to do with the rest of this talk.

He didn't start acting until college, believe it or not. And it really wasn't even his idea. He was actually asked to audition for a role in a local children's play. He got the role. He went through the whole deal. He enjoyed it. And from that experience, he decided to pursue acting as a career. Now he changed colleges, eventually earned his BA in performance theater, after which he moved to Chicago. And instead of acting, he started singing with an R&B group. Don't ask me the name. I don't know. We've probably never heard of him before in our lives. He also incidentally tried his hand at standup comedy while he was out there in Chicago. Chicago is a tough place to try to start standup comedy, by the way. Just letting you know. Firstly, I've never heard of him in the standup comedy world either, which is a world I'm quite familiar with. But that doesn't mean anything.

anything. There's a ton of people out there. He did eventually make the big move to California where he started pursuing acting. He managed to get booked into a few small roles in late nineties television shows like beyond belief, which is hosted by Jonathan Frakes, William T record. Anyway, he was also, he did like some skit stuff for Jay Leno and the tonight show. He was on a, an episode of Stargate SG one, which is the podcast we're going to do when we're done with this one, Matt. He was on Frazier and he did a few others. He eventually auditioned. Oh, he did audition for a guest role on Voyager. Unfortunately, he was a little too late to audition for the main cast, but he did audition for a guest role. And while he didn't get that part, he did leave an impression on the casting director who would go on to cast enterprise. So when enterprise came up,

They brought him in. Obviously he got this role. Now he would go on to appear throughout the entire run of enterprise, which by the way, I don't know if I've told you this yet or not, Matt enterprise is the only live action star Trek series to not have a major casting change in the middle of the, of the show. The people who started the show are the people who end the show and they didn't change it throughout the middle because they got cut off. Yes. I don't know. TOS went shorter and they had major changes anyway.

Now, after Trek, Anthony took some time to go work with inner city children back in Indianapolis. He wound up making a documentary about his grandfather, who apparently was a really famous jazz musician named Wes Montgomery. And he also focused on theater. He returned to standup comedy and he focused on music. Only instead of R&B, this time he would focus more on rap and his demo album, which feature four tracks that were Star Trek related songs. He has since come back to acting on the screen, being in some films that I have never personally heard of. But he's also doing some TV gigs on shows like NCIS. He was on House, a few other things like that. Anthony can be seen quite regularly on the convention circuit today. That is our helmsman, Travis Mayweather. All right.

being said, Matt, I'm going to hand the show over to you. This is the time when we're going to go through the show. Uh, you talk to us about your plot points. I think it might be good, Matt, as you, if you want to think about it and structure it this way, uh, the show really followed three different stories. If you want to kind of maybe talk about those three stories as a group, like there's Archer and his whole deal with his PTSD trip into Paul and their trip to Vulcan. And then Dr. Phlox and him facing the xenophobia along with Reed and Mayweather and Hoshi and, and those guys. Um, I don't know if we want to kind of group those, however you want to do it. I'll turn it over to you. However you want to talk about it. Go for it, my friend. I thought about that afterwards. Like I should probably rearrange my notes at some point. Like I realized those were kind of the three sections there. And it's like,

Well, I didn't think about it until I started doing my notes now. Yeah. I didn't think about it until I started doing my notes here. And I was like, oh, I should have texted Matt to be like, hey, think about it in this term. I didn't think about it myself until late in the game. It's all good. A few notes. I really actually. Yeah. Yeah. I really like the stadium that they're in when they first come home when they're giving speech and everything. Like, I don't know what it is about it. Like, it just felt really cool and futuristic. Sure. But that CGI work was amazing. Yep. But Archer gives this speech. Right. And it's a little on the somber side.

Right. It's like, no, let's hear it for the 27 members of the crew who didn't make it back and kind of wraps it up. And then we go into our theme song that you love, by the way, our extra peppy theme song right after the somber speech. And I'm like. dude, do you know how perfectly the old, the old version would have fit into this episode? It would have nailed it. Not only, you know, this episode called home and like, it would have been perfect. And the tone of it would just been perfect just after that speech. And then the new version played, like I, the old version playing in my head going into it. And then the new version came on like, Oh no, you just found every way to make this as bad as possible.

Like who planned this? Does no one hear what I'm hearing? It was frustrating, man. I understand. It was. It was. We get a mention of Captain Jeffries. Yes, we do. And I don't know if this is pure coincidence or if it's actually there for a reason. But I've also noticed like around the ship, you know, things are always different. And sometimes they just go through the tunnels, the inner workings. And those tunnels are called? Jeffries tubes. The Jeffries tubes. Yes. Yes. Is this Captain Jeffries? Is there a connection actually? There absolutely is. And I'm so glad you picked that up because that was one of my notes that I had here.

Because what Archer says is he talks about Captain Jeffries who had a big hand in designing the starships. Yeah. Okay. In real life, the name of the guy who designed the Enterprise 1701 back in the 60s was named Matt Jeffries. All right. In the 90s, when they, there you go. In the 90s, when they started talking about these Jeffries tubes, that was a little hat tip to Matt Jeffries who actually designed the ship. And here it's another homage. It's another hat tip. And it blatantly calls out Jeffries is the guy that designed the ships. So yes, absolutely. Those are all connected and they are all references to the same person who actually did do the designing of the Enterprise. Awesome. I like it.

All right. So I texted you a quarter of the way through this thing, maybe a third of the way. And I was I was feeling really bad. Like, you know, I'm bad with names and remembering people. And especially if I only met him once or whatever. We get this chicks talking to Archer, this old friend. And it's like, oh, I heard about your promotion, Captain. And I'm like, OK, like the introduction to this character made it feel like, oh, we should know this person. Oh, maybe she was in the first episode of Enterprise and she got left back down on the planet or something. I'm like, Brent, help me. Who is this? Should I know who this is? Right. Right. And like, no, no, she's new. Huh? Because what makes it even worse? I don't think they name her in the episode.

at all i i was listening and listening and listening for a name and i'm pretty sure the only thing we ever got was captain well i know her as captain hernandez um like There's probably a name for her in the script somewhere. We don't have her first name as a character, but she is Captain Hernandez. What I don't know is, do I know that from another episode that she may or may not turn up in? Or do I know it from this episode? I'm really not sure. And I'm going to go with you on the idea that they didn't mention it in this episode because I can't refute it one way or the other. So it's entirely possible. Her name is Hernandez. Yeah. Okay. Yeah. And this is the first episode we've seen her in. You just have to accept that there's some history between her and Archer. Which is fine. Sure. I mean, ultimately, it's for plot reasons. They needed someone for Archer to talk to. And for someone to talk to Archer.

as well sure yeah can't go rock climbing alone but they turned it into a thing into a relationship basically if i understood it correctly old girlfriend right like they used to be a thing but then he was her commanding officer and so they broke it off and okay but like you said like there were there are other ways they could i think they could have played this out like we saw archer having the dream up there right they could have he could have gone off on a one-man retreat and either meditated or just yeah dreams whatever or they could have done it this way i mean they could have done it anyway but like they didn't need to introduce a new character to us right is what i'm saying we'll be right back I mean, yeah, but at the same time, like, do they need to? No. Does it make it more interesting? Because, like, I'm trying to think through, if he goes off and meditates.

And all of a sudden it's going to be really weird because like, cause if he's just out there not talking to anybody and just being in his head, that's really boring to watch. And even if he's like having these visions and these flashbacks, that's what I'm picturing those sorts of things. Well, then you have all those characters that he has to talk to, even if it's existing people from season three, but then you got to bring all those people back for him to come back. It's still just like crew members, bridge members. It could be that too. But then that's just, that just looks like, honestly, you're being cheap on the production side. But I mean, I don't know, to come back and have an old girlfriend slash an old classmate, someone who is your equal on not hit, not an admiral, not a, not a subordinate, but someone who is his equal. And I think that actually might.

have been one of the main reasons why because now she can talk to him like an equal yeah you know she doesn't have to give him respect she he doesn't have to give her respect like they're they're on equal footing and they have the history so she can just talk to him and be like yo you're being a big dum-dum head right now And what stays on the mountain, what happens to the mountain stays on the mountain. It probably does work better that way. But they kind of, I mean, to start things off, like I said, this began as like another trial. I mean, they called it debriefing, but it felt like Saval had Archer on trial. Yeah, I think that was the problem, right? Because that's not what this is supposed to be. This is supposed to be just, hey, tell us what happened. Let's go through the event so we make sure that everybody's on the same page. But Saval was grilling Archer. Yeah, he was like, why didn't you do this? So you're telling me you didn't try to save my people? Oh, you didn't download the contents of the computer? Yeah.

Why didn't you do that? You know, here's the thing. Archer starts going off on the ambassador. And while he may have gotten really heated and, you know, under the collar with this guy, I think he was fully justified. Yeah. And Admiral Forrest winds up yelling at Archer. And I kind of want to yell at Admiral Forrest because Admiral Forrest should have turned around and said something to Saval and said, dude, this is not what this is. And you need to back up off my guy. Like, I don't know exactly what the chain of command is there between like the Admiral and the ambassador and stuff like that. And so I don't know exactly how that should have played out in real time. Like it felt like Saval was kind of above them in a sense, or at least like.

just because he's Vulcan and you know, they're superior to us and they're, they're doing us a favor and helping us out. So I'm not going to like talk back to him. I think that's maybe where the Admiral is coming from. And so then it's like, yeah, I mean, Archer, you got, you got to show him some respect to you. Like you can't do that. You can't blow up at him. Yeah. I don't agree with that. Yeah.

I understand. And I mean, I kind of wondered about that too, because I was with you. I felt Archer was justified because like I said, that's not what this was supposed to be. Now Archer has to, he has to maintain better control, but given what he's just come, I mean, the man still has dirt on his face from whatever he's been going through. And, and, you know, actually I was really actually disappointed in Admiral Forrest because he turns around and he says, take some time. And Archer goes, I don't need a vacation. And I'm like, you're right. You don't need a vacation. You need a counselor. You need to go work on, you need to go talk about this with somebody because some stuff happened to you.

Like legit real and things that I know that you don't, that I'm not going to spoil for you, Matt. Things that were really, really tough on Archer that were not okay, you know, and he's got to go deal with this. Now they've got to get the information out of him, but I tell you what's not good for him to go deal with is just to go rock climbing out there by himself or even with the other captain. Like he needs to be on a couch somewhere. This man needs to be talking to somebody. And I say that in all seriousness, this man is dealing with PTSD. He needs professional help. And if you folks need professional help, get professional help. And if you don't know where to go, I'll tell you where to go. Start with your primary care physician, call them and say, this is what's going on. What's my next step. And they'll help you. I don't know what's going on in the.

future with these guys, but that's, that's, I mean, this, we might just amount make this to, you know, the year 2000 when we really didn't do much with mental health in this country at all. And we still don't do enough right now, but on previous star tracks, like they have counselors right on the bridge. Right. And I mean, that's what I feel like. this Hernandez, was it? Captain Hernandez. I get like you were saying it's good that she was his equal and whatnot, but it really felt like that would have been a perfect spot for like Troy. Yeah. Like that, like Troy needed to go rock climbing with him. Sure. Except Troy is not going to be born for another 200 years. I understand. It's not physically time travel, man. Come on. There you go. I like it. I like it. In the future, they study Archer in history class and Troy realizes, man, that guy needed a counselor. I'm going back in time. You remember when Troy showed up in Voyager all of a sudden? Wouldn't that be something if like Troy or Riker or somebody just showed up in Enterprise? Yup. Yup. Just saying it's possible. They can write whatever they want. They do time travel.

despite what the Vulcan high command says, the Vulcan science Academy time travel is a thing. Write that, write that in your head cannon, write that in your head cannon. I, Archer did when he blew up, gave me one of the best lines that, I mean, could be interesting going forward. Which was, I got more help from the Andorians than I ever got from the high command. Yeah. That I, the more I thought about it, I'm like that, that's really, really true and would not have expected that after like.

the first meeting I saw with the Andorians or even the second meeting with the Andorians. Right. Or even the third. You've seen three now. Yeah, but it's it's basically true. Like they were abandoned by the Vulcans while they were out there. Well, I mean, the Vulcans have actively tried to slow them down and not let them go. And he and he was right because his other line, the one that jumps out to me, this planet would be a pile of dust if we had listened to you. Yeah. And that is an accurate statement.

Do you have anything else about Archer? No, I just really wish that he didn't apologize to Saval at the end. And I really wish that it would have been Saval that apologized to Archer. I know he didn't apologize, but I was surprised that he did admit he was wrong about Archer. So, I mean, it's maybe not exactly what you're hoping for, but I think, I mean, it is kind of a step in the right direction just for him to admit he was wrong and to admit he was wrong, like to the person that it mattered. Like he didn't go to Admiral Forth and say, yeah.

I was wrong about Archer. Like he was the right guy for the job. Like he talked straight to Archer and said, I was wrong about you, man. That was good on him. The other thing that I just want to point out in the universe thing. So Captain Hernandez is going to be the captain of another in a, in X01 class or in X class enterprise. Okay. And that's something I figured out eventually kind of, but that was a question I had early on was like, is she taking over the enterprise? Cause like they try to be shoving everybody else off onto, you know, taking vacation or taking leave at least in like, so what, and when they just saw like it was under construction, like they talked about enterprise being refit. I'm like, I don't know what ship this is actually. Yeah. They actually talked to us that they were building these.

ships all the way back in the episode, I think it was the expanse. If you remember the enterprise comes home, they're being chased by the Klingons. The Klingons about have the enterprise dead to rights. And all of a sudden these other ships come out of nowhere. And it's like, Oh, we've been busy. We've built some stuff. And they told us they're building new NX class of new NX class ships. It's going to take them a couple of years to be ready. Well, it's been at least a year and change. Right. So, uh, and the ship's not quite ready yet, but it's getting there. It is. It's going to look exactly like the enterprise. And in fact, I will go ahead and tell you, I don't care. Cause it really doesn't matter. The name of that ship will be the Columbia and it will be, this is the NXO one. That one will be the NXO two. So I think we'll jump to Flaxen. Okay

I think it was a really good setup that they gave us with must've been read kind of warning flocks. Like, Hey man, are you, are you, have you taken the proper precautions? Like this isn't the earth that you, you left, like things have changed. Like all aliens are kind of looked down on right now. Like it doesn't matter that you looked here before. Like people are just scared of aliens right now. And the more I thought about it, like the more I felt I could kind of understand it because this is the type of thing that has been around for so long. Just people blaming other people groups, even when they have nothing to do with anything. Sure. We see that happening in our world today. Yep. Yep. And.

like the more Reed tried to warn him about it, the more I realized like, this is going to get ugly and they're going to show it in this episode. Like that's not a, for nothing warning. It's worth setting you up for the rest of this episode. And I, I honestly like how this, this kind of played out. Like it's, I'm curious to see if we get more of this as we move forward. And, and if it, if they go any deeper with it or if there is any kind of resolution to it, because I mean, kind of left it in limbo, I guess at the end of this, but yeah, it happened like this, this bar patron out of nowhere, just start challenging flocks. Cause he's an alien. I'm like, really dude, really? And I absolutely love that Reed and Mayweather.

stand up for him. Right. I was like, yeah, don't do this, buddy. Don't do this. And he just keeps pushing, pushing, pushing. And you know, it happened in such a way that was very reminiscent to me of what you would see of a movie set in the fifties or the sixties, when a black person would go sit at a counter in a restaurant that they weren't supposed to go sit at and somebody, you know, some racist.

You know, I can't even say the word that's coming to my mouth. It's coming to my mind right now because it's not nice. And this is a family friendly show, Matt. But some some racist comes up and, you know, at first they kind of like try to make like they're playing nice with them. But they're basically saying, get out of here because I don't want you here. Yep. And it escalates. And you're right. Good on on Trip. I'm sorry, not Trip. Good on Malcolm and Travis or really stand in the ground, you know. But if that whole thing didn't happen, we never would have got to learn that Phlox is a blowfish face. Yes. Weird. Like, OK, my wife absolutely loves puffer fish. OK. And so I saw this thing and I just started laughing.

And I paused it and rewound 10 seconds. I'm like, Becca, Becca, you have to look at this. You have to see this. Just watch. Watch this guy. When he comes back on screen, just watch him. Oh, man. It's like, I'm assuming, yeah, you say this is the first time we find out about it, right? Because like Malcolm and Travis seem to be very surprised, like what just happened. And do we ever see it again? Like my mind started racing. Like, is this normal? Is this a defense mechanism? Or was this like adrenaline pumping? Like, that's why Dr. Fox is always so calm. Like he can't, can't let us.

blood pressure get too high or this happens automatically. Like, was that a bad thing? Like in his culture, like letting your face puff up, like, is that a sign of weakness or is that a weird mating ritual? Or is it like, I mean, like, what does this mean to you? Like, cause Phlox seems super like not upset, not quite disappointed, but like. Almost embarrassed, honestly. Yeah, almost embarrassed. Yes, yes. That, that came out. It is, it is a defense mechanism of Denobulans. This is the first and only time that we will see it. Why did they write it in in this particular moment? Did they know about it in a character Bible before this moment? I don't know. I can't find anything on it. It's like they.

just sort of wrote it in. Yeah. Yeah. It's like, well, how do we get out of the scene? Well, what if, okay. Okay. Yeah. What if he had some defense mechanism that freaked everybody out and stopped it? Okay. Well, what could it be? Uh, then they have like a puffer fish in a tank next to him. Yeah. We did that. Like what? I mean, he does not necessarily gills, but he has, you know,

the ridges that kind of come down the sides of his face already yeah i mean it's it's not completely out like it it didn't feel like i i didn't question that he would have the ability to do that like that didn't seem like the weird part it's more like why haven't we seen you do this before like i mean if it were a human or honestly just about any other race i might question it more or for whatever reason like the way his face is built i didn't question it so much yeah i don't know I don't know why, but that's a thing Denobulans do. Good to know. Yeah. Good to know. You'll never see it again either. So, you know, don't get too used to it. But also, I guess it just means Phlox doesn't get into that sort of a situation anytime soon. So, you know, don't leave this section. I don't know if you're getting ready to transition, but don't leave the section without actually talking about the other conversation that Phlox wound up having with Hoshi later. Yes. And that's where I'm going next. Okay, great. Yeah. Because we got to wrap this up a little bit. Yeah. Kind of. Sort of.

But Phlox goes from his initial conversation with Reed. It's like, oh, don't worry. I'll be fine. Like I've lived here before. I'll be fine. I'll be fine. I'll be fine. He's actually like quite confident at that point. But then after this one encounter, it's like, all right, I'm going to stay on the Enterprise. I'm not going anywhere. I'm going to have my food delivered to me. I'm not going to cause any trouble. He just like shut down. Basically, it felt like. And like, here's another guy I think needs a counselor because I just very drastic change. And I mean, obviously different than Archer, but like something happened.

mentally for him. You know what it reminds me of, Matt? And this is relatively fresh in my brain right now. Some months ago, as people listen to this, the January 6th committee hearings, select committee hearings were occurring. In one of those hearings, I don't remember which one, there was the testimony of one of the poll workers that this young lady, her and her mother's name had been put out there and criticized and had a finger pointed at as, you're the bad guy, right? And what people started to do to this woman and her mother, simply because they thought she was the bad guy, where these people used to love what they did.

I, I'm sorry. I don't remember their names off the top of my head. I'd recommend everybody. If you haven't heard their story, you can probably YouTube it. Go look it up. It is, you should hear their story from their own lips. The story of her mother basically saying that they've lost their, like they're scared to have their name set out loud in public because it would attract the wrong kind of attention. The idea that they, like she said, she's been shut up and now she won't even go to the grocery store anymore. She's gained 60 pounds because of what people are doing to her because of some allegation that somebody with a super powerful social media following pointed a finger at this person unjustly. So yeah. And that's what it reminded me of. Like they were shut in their house. The FBI came and told her at one point, Hey,

don't go home. You probably want to find another place to stay for about the next two or three months until this blows over. That was what happened to flocks after that situation for his own safety, for the safety of people around him. Exactly. And it is, it is deplorable. It is not right. It is inexcusable. And frankly, those who perpetrate it and those who are responsible for pointing a finger at that should be held accountable to the fullest extent of the law, in my opinion. And this is an episode of Star Trek that was written and produced.

20 years ago, speaking exactly to stuff that is happening today. And I say again, Matt, the world needs Star Trek on TV. We are better when Trek is on TV and we need to all sit down and watch the show together. We would be in a better spot. And I'll say this just so you know, Matt, the theme of humans turning xenophobic after the whole Zindi incident with this is not a one off. All right. And it's not over. Remember, we are not the enlightened Federation just yet. This is how we get there. And humans are still going to human, you know, and I.

like you kind of gave me the heads up going into this into season four here saying like we got our new writer director or whatever it was and like this is what enterprise should have been all along and like i i don't know how far we depart from this because like you said this is kind of our transition episode but just some of the ideas that they bring up in here like this one right here, the things that we have to get past to make it to the Federation, right? Like these are not simple things. And these are things like you said, they're going on right now in our world today. Yeah. And it's, it's a lot to deal with. And it's a lot of what I feel we're going to start seeing those Star Trek messages hot and heavy again. I mean, Hoshi just spells it out for us here, right? Like this isn't the way to deal with prejudice. The best thing is to show your face and remind people that there are aliens who don't want to blow up the planet. That's so good. And that's hard. That takes a hero to go do that. And here's the thing, Dr. Fleck shouldn't have to go be a hero again. He's already been a hero. Yeah. There were literally just thousands and thousands of people in that stadium cheering him on.

Like, thank you for what you did. Yeah. And then there's this. And then this. Yeah. And those people are gross and disgusting. And that kind of bigotry needs to stay in your quarters. Stay at home. Don't bring it out into public. It's not OK. If somebody loses their name because of it, it's not OK. Matt, let's turn this around. Make this a little happier. Let's talk about a flying romance that is going to be so successful. I'm not sure how much happier it gets necessarily. Look who's coming to dinner, ma. Yeah. Yeah. Tripping to Paul. And so that's part of the reason I had trouble with it is not only like I haven't really seen in this played up in the episodes too much, but.

then like to Paul's kind of trying, kind of sort of trying to hide it, like not openly telling her mother about it at least. Nope. And so I kept questioning, like, is this actually a thing? Is this actually happening? Like, okay. Yeah, I guess it is. Okay.

But then, of course, it can't be that straightforward. No. There's another guy. Yes. There's a fiance. There's from an arranged marriage. Or I don't know if you, I mean, you know James Bond, of course, right? I know. I think I'm currently at 12 of the films. I'm working my bathroom. Yeah. But well enough. Yes, I know it well enough. You're familiar with, you know, Bond, James Bond. Yes. And then, of course, in my head, there's a cartoon growing up, James Bond Jr. I don't think I ever saw that. Okay. But so they took it one step farther and it always plays out in my head. Bond, James Bond, James Bond Jr. Okay. I get it. I get it. In any case, as soon as like the tone.

wasn't quite there but like just the way they followed each other like her mother's like fiance and to Paul immediately follows it with former fiance like fiance or more fiance like oh no that's not quite work here anyway sorry tangent you get the idea that yes like you said it's an arranged marriage this is something they do on Vulcan to Paul's not happy with it of course she's kind of the outlier already we know she's different we know she doesn't like to follow all of Vulcan customs and culture so it's not really a surprise that she doesn't want to follow this arranged marriage right But I was surprised how much more they play into how different the humans are. And we get this, especially when we get, does T'Pol's mother have a name? There's another character I don't think we actually got a name for, and I can't want to name him. It's like T'Less, I think is what it is. Okay, yeah, I don't think I heard that.

All my notes are just mother or to Paul's mother. Between the mother and Trip, we get these conversations and like Trip's just trying to be a nice guest, a gracious guest. And it's like, you know, thanks for letting me come and stay. It's like expressing gratitude to the earth custom. Like, hey, Paul says thank you all the time. It's like, yeah, I know. She's picked it up from you. Like, what's so bad about that? Like, come on. You know, OK, I lived in another country for quite a while. OK, OK. Living in another country, there are customs that I bring with me from my country that this is how I do things. When I'm in the other country, I do my best to kind of do it the way that.

they do it. But at the same time, there's always this natural conflict within of how much do I just be me? Because this is how I do it. Not that it's right, not that it's wrong, not that it's disrespectful, but at the same time to be respectful. And for that idea, I'm going to honor your ways and your custom. So when Trip comes in and he says, thank you, like that's just him being him. He's not being disrespectful or anything like that. And when T'Pol is saying thank you all the time, she's picked that up because she lives in that culture and has for the last several years. Like, yes, he's going to pick that up. Like it is illogical onto Les's part to be perturbed and put out with it. And you can say those are emotional.

Yes, they probably are. And she's definitely experiencing them. Like it just gets me because like, even as humans, we struggle so much to get people to be kind and say please and thank you. Like it's one of those things you always try to teach your kids, right? And it can be a huge struggle. And it feels like people might, some people learn it, but then lose it again as they become an adult. And it's just like, so to go into someone else's house and be that polite and use those words, it's like, man, you're really trying to be nice, trying to be gracious, trying to express your gratitude, right? And unless like saying thank you is like a derogatory term in their language.

or something. Like, I just don't see why that was such a problem. Like it feels off. It's because like you were saying, Vulcans are jerks, Matt. That's what it is. I don't think she should have been as put off as she was. No, no. This is clearly though, like this is the girl bringing somebody home who can't admit yet that that's her boyfriend, but he is. And, and, and trip trips doing his best. He's like, look, I'm going to, I'm going to respect you and let you say it. However you need to say it. Like, I'm just going to be, I'm just going to be me. Like he's, he's just got to be who he is. He's going to try to be respectful of everywhere that he is. Try to be helpful. He wants, like he wants to make mom.

impressed you know he wants to get on mom's good side because he likes her daughter like that's natural that's okay yeah uh it just i mean like the thing to do then would have been to suppress your emotions right that's what trip should have been trying to do right if he wants to impress mom yeah, but trips a human and he's a good old boy. And I think that that would play off really weird to the audience too. If he kind of tried to do that. Well, it would have to be, he'd have to go in and do it the way he did it here, completely fail and then have a conversation with somebody saying, well, maybe you should try this. And then he would go in and try it. And like, you have to alert the audience. Like that's what you're trying to do. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. But I did appreciate that. He's still an engineer and he's good at fixing gadgets. Right. Like I, I was surprised how like shocked mother was like, Oh, you fixed it. Oh, well maybe you can fix this one too. Right. Like.

She really must've had a low opinion of him coming in. Cause I mean, like he said, if he's worked on a war core, like little kitchen appliance shouldn't be a big problem. Well, I mean, honestly it was, it was her own racism. She didn't like him cause he was a human. Sure. Before she ever met him, she didn't like him just because he was a human. She didn't want him there. Her daughter was engaged to this other guy over here. She was thinking about herself, her own career and what had happened to her career and the possibility of what could happen with that guy over there. And this guy's in the way and I don't like him cause he's not Vulcan. Well, and I think she had all of that rolling in the back of her head, which we didn't know at the time. Right. Right. I mean, we kind of knew about the fiance. She was kind of upset about that. Like, yeah, I want you to marry this Vulcan.

set you up with but that it rolled into basically i don't know if it's you know just her superiors or the high command or who the security ministry or whoever this was that was taking it out on her because of to paul's actions sounds like an emotional response to me matt yep yep but don't worry the vulcans have purged all emotion so many so many times we can talk about it I think I got about eight more times than me, Matt. All right. But then we get this little back and forth. I mean, Klaus comes to visit. I'm not going to let you go. Yeah. Has this thing with T'Pol. It's like, I can help your mother. What? So she finds out about that. And it's just messy. Yeah. And honestly, I was very, very surprised that they had T'Pol give into that pressure. Like, I understand she wants to help out her mother and get her job back and stuff like that. But after all she's seen and all she's done with Starfleet to like, I feel this is where in another series, she would have gone back to Archer and said, hey, this is what's happening. What can we do? And like, I.

I guess maybe it doesn't work as well right now because of the way like relations are between humans and Vulcans. Like Archer wouldn't have had as much pull necessarily or any human wouldn't have had as much pull. Right. But maybe at least could have given her another option. Like maybe we could try this or maybe we can, you know, talk to this person instead of having to go through with a marriage potentially just to save your mother's job and do all this and restore the family name or whatever you want to put it. And then like I said, this is where I really feel it got into 90s sitcom territory. And it's like, man, you just got to tell her, well, I don't want to make things more complicated for her. So you're just going to let her go ahead and do it. Okay. So that, I mean, then we're all sitting there at the wedding and it's like,

to tell her? Is Tripp going to tell her? Oh, she gave him a kiss. She's thinking about it. Is DePaul going to cut it off? And we'll see you next season.

Yeah, that was a weird place to end. This would have been a season ender in a 90s sitcom. Wait till next season to see if they get married or not or who breaks up the wedding. And now it felt very not Star Trek. It felt weird. I don't know. And so now I'm really curious to see if they even address. I mean, I think they have to address it at some point because it involves Tripp and T'Pol and they're not going anywhere. And leaving it as a cliffhanger feels like they want to make a bigger deal out of it instead of just resolving it in this episode. So I was honestly very, very, very surprised that the episode ended there. I was not expecting that. Honestly, it surprised me too watching it this time around. It really did. Yeah, yeah. I was like, whoa.

That's where that one ends. Cause I know where the story goes, you know? And I was like, Oh, that's okay. I didn't think that's where this one would end, but cool. So yeah. And that's where we are. It's a Paul got married and a trip sitting there watching. And all of a sudden I'm here in Garth Brooks, friends in low places, blame it all on my roots, showed up in boots, ruined your black tie fire. And he's wearing his old clothes. There you go. Well, Matt, I'll give you one more production note just for sake of things we learned in this particular episode. Vulcan is 16 light years from earth.

which is relatively close. I thought that seemed like a small number. Yeah. There's a, there's a movie where they warp, they jump from earth to Vulcan and it happens stupid fast. Yeah. And you're like, Whoa, how close are these places? Uh, now that could be just because of the movie speeding things up, but it was, Oh my gosh. All right, Matt, well let's, let's boil it down. Let's ask you the questions. Did you like this episode? Would you want to watch it again? And do you understand why it was part of our run? It was okay. I have no real need or want to watch it again right now. I mean, like I said, it's not, it's not a bad episode, but I, yeah, it doesn't leave you with warm fuzzies. No. Yeah. Okay. Uh, but as I said before, I feel like this is kind of transition.

episode into wherever we're going. Like I said, we got done with this indie for now. We're bringing people home and moving on to something. And I don't really feel like I know what that something is yet, but maybe it's somewhat related. Maybe it's not. I don't know. We're currently on earth. We're not on the ship except for flocks. So what's happening? Well, let's go ahead and dive into it, Matt. Next week, we are going to begin kind of, this is sort of a final push for us here through enterprise, but we're going to begin.

We're going to have a lot of episodes, multi-arc episodes coming up. And these episodes aren't just, hey, they sort of loosely tie together. No, no, these are part one, part two, part three type episodes. Next week is a three-parter, Matt. And the three-part, I believe it's actually the very next episode. I'm almost positive it is. But the name of the three episodes, they're boom, boom, boom, right in a row. Borderland, Cold Station 12, and The Augments. I will remind you, Matt, we are in prequel territory. And I will say this, over the course of this podcast, over the last few years, I know you don't necessarily have great memory when it comes to all the details of everything you've seen, but you have seen everything you need.

to know for the remainder of the show, particularly what's coming in this next week. You have seen it, whether you remember it or not. Well, we'll find that out next week, right here on beam me up a star Trek podcast. Remember folks, if you'd like to get in touch with us, you can do that by emailing us at beam me up pod at gmail.com or head over to beam me up pod.com for more ways to contact us and talk to us about home. Talk to us about the Zendi. Talk to us about this next run. We're getting ready to go through. You guys know what it's coming up. Matt doesn't. We'll find out soon, Matt. Tell the folks where they can get in touch with you on the internet.

You can find me personally, both on Instagram and Twitter at as a matter of myth. And if you guys want to get in touch with me, I'm at Brent Allen live across all the social medias. I'd love to connect with you there as well, too. Till next time, folks. Live long and prosper.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast?

This episode is 47 minutes long.

When was this Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on November 1, 2022.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.