The final frontier begins. This is about saving the future of humanity. This is a huge victory for the good guys. Welcome to Beam Me Up, a Star Trek podcast. I am Brent Allen, and I've seen every episode of Star Trek 47 times. I'm Matt Sonnenberg, and this is my first time through the series. And this is the show where we are on a mission to introduce people to the universe of Star Trek by watching the most important episodes. Most important, 150-ish or so episodes that deal with the lore, the history, and the timeless message of Star Trek. And if you're a fan of new bromances...
whether they be in Star Trek or with Star Trek fans. Maybe you could have one with us. Come find us behind the scenes over on YouTube. Go to BeMeUpPod.com. Look for the YouTube icon on the upper right hand corner and follow us over there. Get a little extra touch of who we are and what we do and what we're all about and have some fun with us. Today's episode is from season three of Star Trek Enterprise titled Proving Ground, or as I like to call it, why are the Andorians here? In case you guys didn't watch this one first or it's been a while in this episode, the Andorians catch up to Archer and the crew in the Delphic Expanse under the pretense of trying to help them and to forge an alliance. But what they're really after is that Zendi weapon, forcing the two sides to collide over who gets the weapon ultimately resulting in.
the destruction of said weapon and sending the Endorians living home. But it could spell the end of this budding alliance between Earth and the Endorians. Or does it? Because just when it seems the two would go their separate ways forever, Tran leaves the Enterprise a little gift, the scans and the schematics of the weapon. Now, Matt, we're going to get into everything having to do with...
this particular episode. But before we do all of that, give us your initial reaction to this episode, dropping you right in the middle of a season long arc of which you have watched nothing except for really the, the kickoff episode of that, which was the season finale last week, but you're dropping right in the middle of this episode to kind of pick up this little bit of the story. And then you're going to be flying away right after it. So what'd you think of this episode proving ground? I mean, it was fun. And, but I am curious, just kind of even based on like the previously on and like knowing how they build previously ons, how they honestly put things out of order and just give you snippets that can sometimes give you a little bit different.
context than they were actually in but it's really you know what you need to know for this episode um i'm curious to see how that all played out and what other adventures they've had and obviously they've lasted here for a while they've learned some things they i do have some questions mostly about like some of the people we saw in here like i'm sure they're important for season three but maybe not past that so you don't really care to necessarily tell me but i'm gonna ask you anyway um but overall it was good it was fun and honestly the reason i mean i'll tell you right now the reason we watched it because of the andorians and the alliance possible what's going on behind the scenes getting closer to the federation that that was honestly a the best part of the episode. I mean, it wasn't the main part of the episode, I think more so even than the Zendie. Like that was always, that was really the B plot. Right. Oh yeah, yeah, absolutely. Yeah. The, the story long, the season long story arc really is the, the whole thing about the Zendie weapon is driving everything that is happening. But for 26 episodes, it's okay. This episode, we're going to go deal with this while we're driving towards the Zendie weapon. And this episode, we're going to go deal with this other thing while driving towards the Zendie weapon. Well, I mean, it's, it's the same as Voyager, right? We're headed home.
but we ran into this alien a long way. Right. Except for imagine if like every three minutes in Voyager, it's we're going home. We're heading home. We're heading home. We're heading like, like in season three, we got to get the weapon. We got to stop this. And you got to get to the weapon. Got to stop this. And we cut to the Zendi every, every three minutes. Right. Right. And, and we do, we keep getting those, those shots of the Zendi and their council chambers and the different species of Zendi that exist and different things like that. So yeah, we'll get into all that. And Matt, like I texted you before I said, you're going to get everything you need to know about what's happening with that part of the storyline in the previously on, but honestly, that's not why we're stopping to watch this episode for it's the other side, which is what I want to focus the majority of.
our discussion on. However, I will tell you, I am happy to answer any and all questions about the Zindi and that story arc that you just, that are just percolating in your head that you want to ask. Like I'm not going to hold anything back from you. So whatever you want to ask, I'm happy to do that. But, uh, really and truly this was about shran and archer more than anything those two particular individuals and i definitely tried to separate not only like those two kind of storylines but my other questions that i know don't have anything to do with why we're watching this episode but i still want to know sure and i'm happy to go down all that i guess the other one is is uh for reed and the name of the girl oh shoot what was her name talus yeah uh which was just like i think that was the writers giving us an example that's not shran and archer of seeing how the andorians and the humans can come together and actually start working together and form a mutual respect and all that sort of stuff which i mean you already kind of mentioned like transcend the plans I, at the end of the episode, honestly, left me wondering a little bit, like it could have been Tran or could have been Talos. I could have seen either, either one of them doing, you know, that's fair. It really could have been either one. That's absolutely fair. It could have been either one. Although I would, I would tend to say that Tran and Talos are more aligned and in lockstep. So exactly. That's, that's why I felt that way. But like, do you just want to dive into this right now or you want to hold off? Let's hold off on it. Let's, let's hold off on it. Because I do have a few things to get there before we, before we do, I gotta tell you for me personally, though, I always forget about this episode when I start thinking about season three of enterprise, because it really doesn't have a ton to do with this indie weapon at all. The real big thing is we catch up to the Kima site.
which was the previously on piece. And we see it's in testing phase and stuff's about to happen. Like, that's really all it is. This one really isn't about them tracking down the Zindi weapon. It's really about the Endorians. So I always forget about it. And when I was first plotting this out, thinking I was going to skip over the whole, the whole season. And then I came to this episode. Oh yeah, yeah. Okay. We got it. And that's why you watch them. That's why, that's why I want, yes. The amount of, the amount of homework I've had to do for the show is like, it's phenomenal. What I've, I mean, you, I'm patting myself on watching 800 episodes just to figure out which 150 we pull out. And the thing is, these are all episodes. I know, like, I'm just having, like, I'm having to go back and watch it with new eyes. And sometimes I have to watch episodes two or three.
times just to go okay is it really because it's kind of well it's the same thing it's it's like me if i was trying to do this with like harry potter or something for me i've read the whole story so many times i know the entire story but when someone's like okay which chapter did this happen in i can't tell you which chapter it happened i might be able to tell you which book it happened and sometimes that i get a little bit confused just because the whole story starts to blend together and so like i get where you're coming from. You know all these episodes. You've seen them all. You know the story. You know the contents of them, but trying to nail a specific event or specific happening to one episode and saying, well, yeah, we got to watch that.
what episode was that in? And sometimes it's a, okay, am I going to combine this with other episodes? Are we going to put them together or not? Let me watch them all together just to see if it flows or, or whatever. But you know, to the completely side to all of this that we're talking about here, the Harry Potter thing, you know, what happens to me so often these days is I confuse what happens in the book with what happens in the movie. And I'm not really like, and it's actually different in a lot of cases. And I'm not sure which one I'm talking about. Like they both exist in my head as being the single story. And sometimes I'm not sure. So I get it. Yeah. Unfortunately, I don't have that necessarily going on with me in Star Trek. I have not read all the novels 47 times. I'm not that deep into it. So anyway, all right, let's move on with this. I do have a couple.
character actor spotlights that I would like to point out as well. Obviously we have Jeffrey Combs back as Shran. So yay. Good to see him. Are you, how are you liking Jeffrey Combs? I know I've built him up to be the same, but what do you think of Jeffrey Combs?
I love him. Like as Weyoun, he was fun, but I think the character, he was a bit restricted by the character. I feel like there was like, he had to act a certain way around different people. Like his interactions when the founder wasn't around, like I felt he could loosen up a bit and we got more of the fun of Jeffrey Combs. And I feel he's able to let loose a little bit more and kind of be himself a little bit more as Shran. And so I think I like the character of Shran more than Weyoun actually. Not that he played Weyoun poorly, but yes, I enjoy Jeffrey Combs. I have zero qualms or problems with that, with what you just said there, but I'm glad.
glad you like jefford combs because as i said i just saw the other day um that said there is a new character in star trek who is being noted recently for this character's hair okay like like it's his hair is so perfect and it's like it's it's almost taking on it's it's it's uh it's a little place in the fandom like you're going to go to conventions i promise you and people are either going to have styled their hair in the form of this character or they're going to have like some sort of a plastic wig or something that's just this character's hair like the way it's so perfectly quaffed or the hair is going to be on t-shirts absolutely absolutely i'm sure it already is But the meme somebody had made was, here's this character. And then it went, it's starring so-and-so as this character and Jeffrey Combs as this character's hair. Like it was great, you know? Anyway. Okay. Anyway, I do have one more character spotlight I do want to point out. The Andorian General. This is the guy that we saw kind of in the blurry screen TV talking to strangers and do stuff that he didn't really want to do. That actor's name is called Granville Van Dusen. Granville Van Dusen. I love that name. Right? Right? Now, you're probably not going to recognize him. You're not going to know him from anywhere. In fact, he wasn't actually the person that was supposed to play that role. They actually had a whole other person who went in, played the role, shot his scenes for it. But then when they-
needed him to come back and do a couple of reshoots, which I don't know why they need him to reshoots because he had like 32 seconds of screen time, but whatever. They didn't come back and do some reshoots. He couldn't do it. So they went and got this guy and had him redo everything. Now, like I said, you probably really wouldn't know him from anywhere except Matt. Do you remember just two weeks ago we did an episode called Judgment? Sure. Well, Granville Van Dusen played the Klingon magistrate there in the courtroom. Okay. It's the same actor. That's the only reason I point him out because that's him. But with that, Matt, you wanted to get into this. So there's my few pieces. This episode was a good piece of writing. Rick and Brandon trying to make it through. Matt, I'll hand it over to you. Whatever you want to talk about as we go through.
this a plot b plots however you see it specific plot points along the way um i'm gonna let you go anywhere but i'm going to force you to talk about one thing specifically maybe here at the theme song the theme song how did you like the brand new theme song brand new well revamped um the revamped theme song they added tambourine it's not good i i listened to this thing like it started playing and i'm like wait this is oh brent told me they changed i have to listen to this it was not good honestly the original is better oh no i want them to switch it back that's how much i did like i i it like got further from being okay and working with it like but you were like it's so slow they need something a little more upbeat a little more up tempo that's what they gave you but not that no not that not that oh well the fandom as a whole then would say so say we all yeah so say we all i'm glad for that at least yes yes you are lockstep right there with everybody else matt yeah it was rough man it was really rough all right with that out of the way we'll be right back
Hey, if you recognize those sounds, then you're probably somebody who would like our show. We are called, did you hear about this? And we talk about all kinds of news stories. It's like the eighties and nineties stuff that we grew up on. Yeah. This isn't stuff that's getting covered on the 10 o'clock news. I'll tell you that you can check us out at, did you hear about this dot show? We're on every single podcast platform. Go find us.
I can end the show right there. Honestly, that's it. I'm done. I want to talk a little bit about to pull. Okay. Yeah, let's do it. Cause you kind of mentioned last time we saw her at the end of the season two, like leaving the high command, no longer restricted to that uniform and stuff. And they're going to play around with it. First time I see her here, I know this is going to be a huge generalization, but his short hair wearing tight red outfit. I just kept seeing Kira and I'm like, this is like a rip off Kira. Like some, you know, Chinese knockoff action figure.
And it just it threw me off every time she started talking because it wasn't your voice But what surprised me even more though, I think, is that she didn't stay in the red. Yeah. And I know the women in Star Trek in particular tend to change outfits fairly often, but it's not usually, with my recollection at least, it's not usually within the episode. They usually have like one uniform for this episode, one outfit, and then another episode, they might have a different outfit, another episode, another outfit. But at least by the time I started looking at her and noticing, she had at least three different outfits in this episode. Did she? I didn't even notice. I noticed the red one, but I didn't. She started with the red. Then the next time we saw her walking down the hall, she was wearing blue. Okay. And then by the end of it, she was in purple. Yeah.
And I'm like, I get like, this is over the course of many days, probably. But we're going from, and I think that's part of the reason why we don't usually see them change within an episode because it kind of always feels like it's one day and everybody else is wearing the same thing. So you're wearing the same thing too. But it just felt like it could have been the same day with all the stuff we were talking about. And it's like, did you just feel like changing your clothes in the middle of the day? Spill some coffee on you and have to change? I don't know. But it just definitely, it definitely stood out to me. And that's why I feel like this is not normal. Although maybe it will be normal for football. I don't know. I'll have to watch more of season three and find out if this is a regular thing or not. But it definitely felt weird. I couldn't tell you how many.
times she changes her outfit over the course of a particular episode but she has several outfits now the red and the blue i think are probably the more prominent ones but but she i mean we see her in her pajamas she has blue silky pajamas that she likes to wear sure we see her in um she has like some purple and pink like she's got some flair the other thing that's changed with her is her hair have you noticed that i i thought it was different it's a little down she's down a little bit yeah yeah it looks good a little longer and it's like yeah okay but it looks good like when i go back and i see early to paul i mean i think this is true of most characters when you see early whatever character it's rough you're like oh that got through your screen test like we've talked about that early Data, early Cisco, early, like, yeah. Yeah, I mean, even early, like, Janeway, early Odo, you know, all those folks. It's tough. It is tough. See, I mean, like I said, it's not unusual for, like, I feel it's the women in particular to have multiple outfits. It's just, I felt it was weird to see so many of them in one episode. I mean, like, Seven had, you know, she's not necessarily a uniformed officer, so she switches a lot, too. And, like, I've seen many different outfits on her, but, like, it doesn't feel like she switches mid-episode. Right. And that's the biggest difference for me. Now, you mentioned them briefly, Zindi. Yes. And this is the part that I feel like if I watch the rest of season three, I will be caught up on this.
But like when we're in those boardrooms and stuff, we got like the folks that look like what I was first introduced to the Zendias when I saw like four of them once. But now there's all sorts of like reptiles and bugs. And there was even some like... giant lizards floating in a tank and yeah i had them like a first person shot from them of them talking once and i'm like oh those aren't just like pets those are actual like sentient species okay like so are these all zendi they are so the the idea of the zendi is imagine a world where apes birds reptiles insects water creatures is it five i think it's five it's those imagine those five five shoots of life all evolve together at the same rate. Does that make sense? So your insects evolve and become fully operating sentient. They can build a bunch of stuff. So do the water creatures. So do the apes. So do the reptiles. So do the birds. So what you're telling me. That's the idea. So they're all Zindi. They're all from the same world. They've all evolved together, but they're obviously their own different races. Yes. Within the Zindi. Star Trek made the first.
disney live action film explain yourself i'm not following you but okay i like it so far i'm thinking like Disney's in this thing, you know, over the past decade where they want to make their classic movies into live action. Right. And then they try to do things like the jungle book where there's only one human in the entire movie. The rest of your characters are talking animals. Right. And so like, that's kind of what this feels like is like, okay, these are all based on animals. We're going to have them played by humans. But, or I mean, I even questioned like the bug one. I don't know if the bug one's played by humans. I think that's a CGI. I kind of thought so. And the water guys are CGI. Obviously the reptile and the arboreals, the, the, the, the AV.
Is it that the bird ones are extinct? Maybe I feel like one of them is extinct. That might be the bird guys are extinct and they're not wanting to go like the rest of them don't want to go that direction. So and the other thing about them is, is the only real example of Zindi people that we get are the people you meet in that boardroom. Like we don't meet the rest of the folks out there, but just judging by those people in the boardroom, like the insects and the reptiles are far more aggressive and warlike. The guys that are the water guys in the water tanks are like very much the wise ones. Like they're kind of looked as like the ones who break the ties and they people like they respect their opinions on things. And then, you know, the ones that descend from the apes. And I want to say.
it's the birds i don't think they're they're extinct yet um but like the ones that descend from that are kind of the the more the peace brokers and the ones who have a little bit more of a conscience you know uh so uh there's different qualities to that but they are together in a sort of a united world type situation because they are all zindy and like if you look um they all have certain characteristics that are the same like they have like these little like temple things that are the same for all of them like even the insects have like this little little bone so yeah but this group almost feels like um like a un or something like that yeah yeah very much like that very much like that but that's the you know and it's probably the best example of that or honestly almost like their own federation except they're all from one planet but like something of that sort where it's just all these different groups coming together and saying hey we're gonna work together now all right i think i'm gonna bring this up now just because i had such a good laugh with it okay you asked if i like jeffrey combs yeah i particularly liked him when he had the meeting with the zendy over the comms when he's yeah flying in and it's like we're looking for a rare element archerite
Yes. Yes. And like you see, like it's, it's pure comedy for us. Every time he like glances over at Archer and he's like, am I doing this right? Archer, right? Sure. Yep. And just the tone of his voice, that entire speech that he's giving essentially, it's just a little bit pebbier than he usually is. Not quite as serious of a tone. And it's just, it's so good. Yeah. I love that scene. And that's why, yes, the Andorian mining consortium runs from no one. I need an Andorian mining consortium t-shirts.
you know that yes that i mean that's such i mean other than it's saying and dorian like that that feels like just such a deep cut right especially if it never gets mentioned again but yes if i ever need an example of why i love jeffrey combs that scene right there is it But kind of diving into the main plot of this episode, like you said, Shran and the Andorians catch up with Enterprise. They're kind of came out of nowhere, I guess, just for this episode type of thing. I'm assuming we haven't been tracking the Andorians this whole time, like been searching for them. It's just that this is brand new for this episode. Yeah, this would have been a thing like the viewers at home, unless they had seen the commercials leading up to the show where they knew that Shran was going to be in it. When you see his hand come in and there's a blue hand and you start hearing the voice, you're like, oh, oh, oh. And then, you know, they're traveling around. They're looking, they're looking, looking. He's like, you know, we'll find these pink skins right before he gets into the.
it's been a long road getting from there to here like right before you get to that like that's oh they're trying to catch up to him what are they doing here like yeah that was a big piece like how are they here what's going on and like i i don't think that played quite as powerful powerfully for me just because i kind of assumed maybe they had been doing this the whole time this was like part of the previous they almost felt like part of the previously on i felt like there was a little gap in there i'm like is this part of the new episode or was this previously yet like is that how we left the last episode hanging was shran was looking right um and so like i i felt that there could have been more of a lead up to it as opposed to oh no this is brand new information But yeah, so very minor note, kind of off topic a little bit here, but there was a mention of they had to reconstruct the database, right? And this just made me think again of what we were talking about a couple weeks ago, I think, how things that are happening here in this prequel.
don't always seem to make sense with what we know happens in the future. Okay. What do you got? And so I like, I'm saying like, I kind of made this point when we were first talking about this, like maybe those records were lost. Maybe those records were destroyed. And that's why no one has a record of this thing happening previously. Or we, you know, future generations, 200 years later, don't know about this stuff. I mean, here they are saying, yeah, we lost our database. We've reconstructed 30% of it. I mean, I granted this is just on one ship. It's not like all of Starfleet or anything like that, but it goes to show that records and data can be destroyed. And so if.
exploration logs from their past, you know, 10 years that they've been working on get destroyed, people 200 years from now aren't going to know about whatever was destroyed. Let's pass down, you know, generation to generation via word of mouth. And even then it's just going to, you know, might be considered myth at that point. It's like, yeah, I heard this from my great, great grandfather. He claims there was this alien species, 8472. It's like, okay, sure. It's a ghost story. You tell your kids at night too.
Yeah. So it's just a minor detail, but I feel kind of further explains like we were talking about. If things don't seem to line up, I think there's a reason, a valid reason you could have used to explain that away. So we knew that Shran was coming to find the enterprise. They kind of hinted at that, but I absolutely loved once again.
the camera work in this episode. Yes, it's fantastic, wasn't it? When I put him up on screen and we get the shot from behind Archer's head that perfectly lines up a Shran's antenna with Archer's head so you can't see any of Shran's face and it looks like Archer has antenna on the top of his head now. It's like, oh, oh, too good, too good. We get a couple of references to this throughout the episode, but I'm a little bit impressed with how technologically superior the Andorians are to the humans. They don't seem like it, do they? Until they say, yeah, I haven't seen stuff like this since I was in elementary school or whatever. Like Talos in particular is like,
yeah it's very nostalgic for me like and but shran's just like you know yeah we can pass through these anomaly fields just fine because i mean we have better shields we have better sensors like we have ways of dealing with them and even just like trying to repair their ship it's like i thought this would take us two days we'll get it done in 12 hours because they're here helping us and they have ways of doing things or uh talus making the comment of man i can only get these up to 94 efficiency and reads like i or maybe it's like reader trip one of them i've never gotten past 93 like just all these little hints at like, yeah, the Andorians are superior, right? They absolutely are superior when it comes to the technology. So, uh, And even just talking speed of ships and stuff like that, too. It's they're well past what what the humans are at right now. And I think there's a piece of that that's meant to remind us of that, you know, because this is they should be further along than the humans are. Right. They've been at this longer. They've they've had the warp technology longer. So, yeah, they've improved it faster. I mean, they want to borrow the part and not borrow, like get a copy of that part for the warp engine. Right. And it's like, yeah, this valve will really help us out. And like, I'm sure it would. But thankfully, you know, the Andorians don't have that that prime directive not to interfere with people, I guess, and and give them technology.
they're not ready for um because he definitely agrees to that i was a little bit surprised with that and so that's that's also what had me bouncing back and forth this entire episode right they kept hinting at like well especially with to paul saying hey they're they're devious they're deceptive like you can't trust them but then they're like oh yeah we're gonna help you repair your ship faster we're gonna give you this new technology we're gonna you know play nice play nice play nice and i did have that feeling yet like as much as they were trying to misdirect and and and Talos always had an explanation for everything she was doing. It feels like Shran is playing nice as a diversion, which I think kind of played out to be true. Talos was doing the dirty work, Shran was the diversion, while at the same time keeping them on track to get the weapon.
But it's like, yeah, I'll do whatever I have to do to keep you involved here, help us get what we need, and then we're going to dump you. Because as soon as Shran's like, yeah, let us take the weapon onto our ship, I'm like, that's what I don't trust there. And I was very glad that Archer had the situation like, but I want to come along. Now, if I were Archer, I wouldn't necessarily have needed the, I'm going to be in command, I'm going to give your crew orders, but just come along on the ship. Now, where I feel that Archer falls behind and is not the same level of captain as, say, like Picard or something like that, other captains we've seen, is I kept waiting for him to have a backup plan. I kept waiting for him.
to be one step ahead of shran right and he never was he was maybe right alongside shran but he was never one step ahead right like i kept waiting he's like okay i'm gonna go join your ship got shran to agree to that cool and he should have been prepared for the double cross because and it was kind of another one of those moments where it's scott bacula had a hard time with acting and i don't think he should have been put in that place sure because i think it should have been written differently i think he he should have you know uh you know message to paul it's like you were right they're they're trying to pull out of the deal why don't you transport over here and we'll take care of it or you know you can come out from behind the asteroid now like they said yeah the enterprise went to warp and they're they're headed to the rendezvous point or whatever but like pull a ui and hide behind the asteroid it's like we don't trust rand fully yet so that that's the biggest piece i felt was missing and i get it's early on and and maybe archer becomes a cautionary tale for future starfleet captains and he's written about in all the books and it's like yeah this encounter with rand Make sure you have a backup plan whenever you're going into a deal with people now. Like, this is something they teach going forward now. I mean, to be fair to Archer, though, he wasn't really focused on the Endorians. He was really focused on the Zindi. And like, yeah, Shran could have been there for a distraction, but it wasn't a hard distraction. Like, you know, and I think you still have to acknowledge the idea that Shran didn't want to double cross Archer. He didn't. He really didn't want to do this. Like, so he was ordered to. Shran is a very interesting character in that respect. And I feel it was kind of subtle, but not subtle at the same time.
depending if you're paying attention to certain scenes, it was very much like, yeah, Shran was following orders, but he didn't want to. And he kept getting this, I don't like unpaid debts. The conversation between him and Archer, I don't like unpaid debts. We keep doing each other favors. Isn't that how alliances are born? Kind of hinting at that future again, right? And then we got the conversation between Shran and his superior, his general, the guy you mentioned before. And you can see it in his face, especially at the end of the...
the chat or after they hung up or whatever, like it's, he did not agree with the general, but at the same time, he was a good little soldier and doing what he was told. Yeah, he's a soldier. And I kept waiting for him to, you know, kind of put his foot down. And like I said, I guess that's kind of what was hinted at with them sending the plans right at the end of the episode. But I guess I'm surprised he went as far as he did, you know, taking the weapon, refusing to give it up, getting to the point where they actually did explode. Like he tried calling Archer's bluff and
At that point, you know, we're not really sure if Archer's bluffing or not. Right. I kind of thought Archer was bluffing and I wasn't sure exactly how they were going to pull that off. But yeah, Shran was in it to the bitter end to the point of damaging his own ship and having to limp home. And, you know, as proof at the end where he gets the little gift at the end, you know, say whoever it was, I think at least it met with Shran's approval if it wasn't Shran himself. That still goes to show like Shran's still kind of in it. Like he still holds a lot of respect. And that's kind of why I questioned who it was and thought it might actually be Talos. Because like you said, I do think the two of them are in lockstep.
And they kind of have the same beliefs and like, hey, I think we can't, because I think that's why we saw so much of the interactions between Talos and Reed. Because Reed was very much, I think they were kind of opposites, right? Reed was very standoffish. I don't want to trust them. Talos was very much, hey, I'm just here to help. I want to do our thing. Had a little bit of an ulterior motive, we find out. But still in the long run, I think, yeah, she sees that connection there and I think, hey, we can work together. Because there was that little hint of almost flirtation where it's like, I think Reed tells her, hey, if you've ever done with the Imperial Guard, you can come join Starfleet here. She's like, you do well in the Imperial stuff too. So kind of that back and forth there and it's like, okay, yeah.
A little bit of mutual respect going there. Whereas like with Archer and Tran, I feel it was always more Archer wanting to trust Tran and Tran being a little more standoffish. So it's interesting how they chose to portray all those. But like I said, I think Shran and Talos are both kind of on the same page there. And after I saw Shran as uncomfortable as he was following orders, he still followed orders from his general. I have a harder time believing that he would be the one to send that message. Sure. But I could see Talos doing that and maybe getting the okay from Shran, but, or maybe not, but like he finds out about it later and he's like, maybe reprimands her in public, but then calls her into the room later. It's like, good job. Thanks. You're my right hand. You know, I can't do that publicly, but I wanted to do that too. So thank you for taking care of that type of thing. But in the end, the sentiment is still there. Yes.
tried to screw you guys over. We just stole this thing. You guys had to stand up to us, which I loved the idea that that Archer is willing to stand up to the Andorians just like he stands up to the Vulcans. Yes. You know what I mean? Like he is clearly allied with the Vulcans, but he'll call them on their crap. And while they're not necessarily allied with the Andorians, there is definitely a relationship there. And he is also willing to call them on their crap, too. You know, we're seeing this idea, particularly with between the Vulcans and the Andorians, neither side of those of that argument of that conflict are innocent. Yeah. Right. And they've said that like Bud's blood has been spilt. It's neither side.
is innocent and to this day neither side is still innocent and archers he's very in the middle between the two of them you know i i mean it makes more sense as we get further into the episode and and seeing what shran is trying to do and build trust with archer and stuff but i found it interesting early on how he kind of threw the valkans under the bus when he he it's like well why are you here you know archer wanted to know like okay we understand how you found it but why are you here like well you're World is brutally attacked. Thought you would be grateful to have an ally. No one else came to help you. Where are the Vulcans? Like they couldn't even spare one officer. She had to give up her entire career just to be here. And like, he made some really good points. I'm like, yeah, why couldn't they spare one officer? Like they didn't want to be tied to this. Well, but not only that, but they also, they didn't want to go into the expanse because the expanse is a bad place. Like I'm not saying they've had a bad experience. Sure, sure. But you know, it's not just, hey, spare an officer. It's, it's, you don't want to go here. Well, if you're going to go, I'm not sending any of my people with you. And, and T'Pol had to, as you said,
resign her commission and destroy her career in order to do it in order to stay just because of her loyalty to Archer over her own people. Um, which, which I think from the Vulcan's point of view, I mean, I understand not wanting to send anybody there, but if you have someone who voluntarily wants to go, why don't you let them go and try to build that relationship and foster that relationship with the humans? Right. At that point, what you're bringing up, Matt is the logical decision. if she's going to go anyway yeah then why put her in a position to resign her commission if she's volunteering to go and she's going to go anyway if she's going to go anyway at least like keep her as part of the high command and say okay we need regular reports from you like wouldn't that be more beneficial logically yes yes yeah so yeah the Vulcans don't always act in logic do they matter no no they don't not at all no I don't know some of the most least logical people I've ever met in my life in my fictional life i do like the accusation that uh to paul makes sense too in this whole exchange when they're when they're the andorians are coming on board like she she straight up accuses shran of monitoring communications between starfleet and walking on command and he doesn't deny it like there are multiple times where he just has information right and it's like oh yeah i heard about this i heard about this like yeah no one told you about that you were listening
Right. So that, I mean, I just feel like that brings a whole nother dimension to everything that's going on. Let's talk real quick before we get out of here, though, just to clarify. And Doria slash Shran, but Andoria's motivations for obtaining this weapon, because what they did was they sent one of their main ships and one of their, their, their, I don't know if decorated officers would be it, but a battle hardened officer off to go get this weapon. That's what he's doing. He's not there to help the pink skins. Correct. He's there to get the weapon. That's why he's there. So like now I have to second guess everything that he said, right? Because everything he said was to gain Archer's trust. Except the trust was already there, though. Like, yes, he's there nefariously.
but he's also going maybe when he said okay when he said that he volunteered for this mission did he or was he assigned because he had archer's trust but it certainly sounds better to archer to say i volunteered sure yeah we don't know did he we don't know yeah that's what i'm saying like either way i'm second guessing just about everything he said now just because yes we learn of his actual motives for being here wanting the weapon for themselves just essentially to antagonize. This is brother-sister relationship stuff, right? He wants the weapon just to antagonize them. He doesn't really want to use it at all, but it's just like, I want to be bigger than you are, so you don't pick on me. He wants it for defensive purposes. We're not actually going to use it. We just want to make sure that they don't come after us. Exactly, exactly. Now, in real life, as well as other sci-fi shows and other movies, the thing is, is when somebody gets an overpowered piece of weaponry, that's what causes them to be attacked. They're getting it because they want to be able to defend themselves better. It's the ultimate defense. We're not going to use it.
We're going to defend ourselves. And as soon as somebody gets that, that's when you get attacked by the other thing. There's a very popular movie out in the movie theaters. As we record this, it'll probably be out of the theaters by the time people are listening to this. The whole premise of the film is it's a military training mission because the bad guys got some like nuclear powered uranium enrichment going. We got to go blow that thing up because they're not allowed to have it and we can't let them get it. So we're going to go launch this attack. And the movie is about training for that whole attack. Sure. That's what caught like this whole thing that he's going to go get this weapon in order to not be attacked is actually the thing that in real life causes people to be attacked or even in sci-fi like causes people to be attacked.
So it's a really bad plan. And I don't, there's a thing. I don't trust the Andorians. I might trust Shran, but I don't trust the Andorians to just keep it as a defensive weapon. You know, I just like, like at this point, I think Shran's that guy you feel bad for because he's sitting there. He honestly wants to believe that they only want it for defensive purposes. And like, he's, he's got that good guy in him, that conscience. And it's like, oh yeah, yeah. They just almost a little bit of a little naive in that respect. Right. Like, yeah, they just want it for defensive purposes. Okay. Yeah. So we leave this episode.
The Earthship, the Enterprise, has the technical schematics or the scans or whatever of this weapon because the weapon went kablooey. Yes. The Andorians also have that same schematic because, you know, they didn't just give them all of their files like it was. Oh, yeah. Right. Yeah. So the Andorians have this thing. But we also leave this place in a position where the Earthlings and the Andorians now have a little beef. You know, we haven't we haven't gotten closer to the Federation at this point. This is a monkey wrench in that. So, I mean, I feel like if this is intended to happen, what's in my head is actually intended to happen. It's not going to happen in the next season.
Maybe if they got a full like seven seasons, it could have played out. But in my head, after seeing this episode, my thought process was, okay, I know the humans and Andorians get together. The leadership that's in charge right now does not seem to be interested in Federation. Tran, on the other hand, certainly feels like he is headed in that direction. So where do we see this government overthrow and Tran goes in charge and joins Federation? Pardon me, Matt, I'm gonna look over here and take a drink.
That's the question, Matt. That's the question. And let me let me remind you that when they were writing this episode, they didn't have a big plan. They didn't have a big scheme for where this is all going to go. And I mean, obviously, they knew just like we do. The Federation eventually has to be born. Yep. But there's nothing saying it had to be born by the end of the series. No, it doesn't. This is just stuff that happened pre-Federation. That's what we're talking about. Exactly. Exactly. So, you know, they didn't write this particular episode as a linchpin or a key piece in an overall story. This was just the next Andorian story they did, as will the next ones be, because obviously we're not done with the Andorians yet. Matt, did you have anything?
us about this episode you want to talk about we found out and Dorian's bleed blue we did we did Vulcan's bleed green and Dorian's bleed blue yep but other than that I think I think we covered it so I have two notes for you production notes that I just found these fun the captain's chair on Shran's ship. Wow. Try saying that 10 times fast. Yeah. The captain's chair on Shran's ship. And that's something I didn't mention. I really like the Andorian ship. Oh yeah. It's the first time we've ever seen an Andorian ship like that. Interior and exterior. Yeah. We always seem like down on a planet. So I never actually like saw their ship. And I'm like, I like it though. I really do. The chair itself was Janeway's chair in Voyager. Okay. Off of Voyager. And that's not the only Voyager connection. The desk in Shran's ready room was also used as Chakotay's and Tuvok's desks in their offices the one or two times throughout Voyager that we ever got scenes in those two locations as well. Okay. So yay to the prop department and other people for going back and grabbing some stuff. Matt, I will ask.
you the official questions did you like this episode would you want to watch it again and do you get why this one may or may not have been part of our run Yes. Yes. And yes. I think that was pretty clear today. Very good. Very good. Well, Matt, would you like to know what our next episode is? That would be useful. All right. Well, for our next episode, we are skipping the rest of season three and we're headed straight to season four. Now, Matt, I've got to give you just a little background so you kind of understand where we're going. We'll dive more into this next week. But here's a short little version of this whole thing. So you already know that when they moved into season three, they had a big shakeup and the studio CBS demanded that they that they do something different. So they come up with the store, the season long story arc. They're getting more serialized television changing. They're going to do that. So when season three wraps up, the Zindi weapon story arc was was wrapped up. But the finale.
season three athlete actually cliffhangers a brand new story arc that was supposed to run for the entirety of season four. Okay. That particular story, just as a side note, involved the enterprise getting hurled back in time to the time of the Nazis on earth. Except we find out that the Nazis are actually being controlled by aliens. So think that Voyager episode that dealt with the Nazis, but it was a holodeck episode. Kind of that all over again. All right. It's kind of weird. That was going to be the, they were going to rewrite history a little bit, I guess. I don't know. And that was, that was the idea of going into the off season. Now in between seasons, there was a bit more of a dust up and Rick, things really came to a head with Rick Berman and the studio had less Moonves and less basically said,
to the effect of, I'm going to cancel your show unless you step aside. So he effectively forced Rick Berman and Brandon Braga out. Now they still get their names on the title cards of the show and stuff like that, but they... they were pretty much done with the series and they handed the series over to a guy who had been working around the show for a while named Manny Koto. If this is the name we're going to, we're going to talk a lot more about Manny. Manny was a Star Trek fan from the time he was knee high to a grasshopper. And now he's in charge of running the prequel of Star Trek. And he goes, you know what? I actually know what we should be doing with the show. They haven't been able to figure out, but I know where we need to go with the show. And so he goes in, he spends the first two episodes wrapping up what would have been the entire season because they, because they painted him into that corner. Like he couldn't just drop it. Right. So it was a Michael Pillar movie. Exactly. Absolutely. So, so he wraps that up and.
the show that we're going to is the, this is actually the third episode because not only does he have to wrap that up, he has to then bring them home, right? So the third episode is actually our next episode. And the title of that episode is home. This is the crew returning from the Zendie and the Delphic expanse and all that sort of stuff. And we're going to see, we're going to, it's going to kind of reset us of what is life now like for this crew? What, what has happened to them from their experience in the expanse? Obviously they stopped the Zendie from blowing up earth. That's not going to be a secret. Okay. And, and this is going to set off a different way of season four. And, and what I think you're going to agree with me is that season four.
is what Enterprise should have been from the very beginning. It's just where it should have gone. And it's really a shame that it doesn't go past season four because this is where the show, like most sci-fi shows, season three, season four, it finds its legs. It finds its feet. It finds its identity. You know, in ratings being what they are, station stuff where they are, couldn't save the show. But this is a fantastic season. I think you're going to like, we're going to watch a lot of it, Matt. We're going to watch a lot of it. So we're watching at home. That being said, I don't have any extra feelings for you except the rest of season three. We're going to watch that, the whole thing. Have at it. But that's going to do it for us this week.
on Beam Me Up, a Star Trek podcast. That's going to do it for us for season three. That's it. This is the shortest season we have ever watched, Matt. One episode. Yep. I take that back. I think we watched one episode out of season three of TOS. Whatever. That's it. Guys, email us. BeamMeUpPod at gmail.com. Matt, where can they find you out there? On the internet. You can find my first name on both of us, Jerry and Twitter at As A Matter of Net. If you guys want to get in touch with me, you can find me at Brent Allen Live across all the social medias. I'd love to connect with you there as well, too. Until next time, folks. Live long and prosper.
Matt, I'm entirely disappointed in you. Yeah. I thought for sure. For sure. During this segment, you were going to reference the Andonian mining consortium. I should have been doing something to that effect. I even made a note of it. Oh, man. And you're going with bromance. I'm like, okay, I'm with you on that one. Do what? Yeah, I butchered that one. Uh-huh. Uh-huh. Do you want to go back and redo it? Otherwise, I'll just move on. No, no. Okay. I was like, oh, all right.