Skip to content
Star Trek: Voyager | Critical Care episode artwork

Jul 19, 2022 46 min

Star Trek: Voyager | Critical Care

from Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast

You may think this is a weird episode for us to include, especially having skipped over Unimatrix Zero, but Brent will explain why early in this episode. As for this episode, the Doctor's program is stolen and sold to a planet who rations healthcare in a very unethical manner, and the Doctor just can't take it. What will Matt make of this episode and what it's trying to say? Let's dive in and find out. If you're watching with us, the next episode will be Lineage. Contact the show: email: [email protected] Twitter: @beammeuppod Instagram: @beammeuppod Website: beammeuppod.com Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/beammeuppod) Did You Hear About This? This humorous pop culture podcast discusses the latest retro stories and pop culture news. Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify Support the show

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

You may think this is a weird episode for us to include, especially having skipped over Unimatrix Zero, but Brent will explain why early in this episode. As for this episode, the Doctor's program is stolen and sold to a planet who rations healthcare in a very unethical manner, and the Doctor just can't take it. What will Matt make of this episode and what it's trying to say? Let's dive in and find out. If you're watching with us, the next episode will be Lineage. Con...

Ready to play

Star Trek: Voyager | Critical Care

0:00 46:12

Chapters

  1. 10:28 [Ad] Did You Hear About This?
  2. 11:06 (Cont.) Star Trek: Voyager | Critical Care
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

The final frontier begins. This is about saving the future of humanity. This is a huge victory for the good guys. Welcome to another episode of Beam Me Up, a Star Trek podcast. I am Brent Allen, and I've seen every episode of Star Trek 47 times. And I'm Matt Sonnenberg, and this is my first time through the series. And this is the show where we are on a mission to introduce people, like my good friend Matt over there, to the Star Trek universe by watching the most important episodes that deal with the lore, the history, and the timeless message that is Star Trek. Whether you're on level blue or waiting down on level red for a care that may never come, you should head over to another...

red button you can find on uh beatmeapod.com and look for that youtube icon in the upper right hand corner i actually don't think it's red it might be gray or white or something like that but you'll most often see it as red so we'll go with it but you can see all the behind the scenes stuff that we get from the show all the stuff that gets cut out of the show from the main recording it's a lot of fun we have fun with people over here matt as long as people don't wind up on level white hopefully we'll be fine yeah yeah well today's episode is from season seven of star trek voyager this is the first season seven episode we're doing matt but it is not the premiere it's like episode four or something yeah i think i have a list of episode five it might be five yeah sure sure i'll go with that uh but it's because i mean you start last week you gave me extra viewings and you're like Like, yeah. Okay. So here's, here's the season finale season opener. You can watch those extra viewing. And then we're going to give you this episode in season seven, this episode in season seven. I'm like, what are you doing? And here we are. Yeah. Okay. Okay. Yeah. Well, I mean, okay. This is probably a good place as I need to talk about it. Like this, this is where we are as a podcast. Like it's where we are in the life of the show. Like we've now seen 137 episodes of, of Star Trek. Like the mission of the show is not to give you an exhaustive look at what all is out there, but is to, to be very cherry picking, be very choosy about what we're using to introduce you to what Star Trek is really all about. And frankly, at this point, 137 episodes in, you kind of got it.

it like let's be honest you really got we've hit most of the messages exactly exactly and so like i mean other than the one today yeah which we'll get to but Otherwise, if it doesn't have to do with the main overarching story and or some big major character thing. Yeah. So where the characters end up or what happens to the characters like you're right there. There's not a lot of reason to slow down right now. Exactly. And that's and that's where I find myself. And this is a very different spot than when we were obviously for starting out the season, the series, this podcast where I would stop a lot more frequently, you know. So it's really just where we find ourselves. And Enterprise is going to be a wild ride as we go through that. We're going to go through that one quick, like really quick. But for today, we're not talking about Enterprise, Matt. We're talking about Critical Care Season 7 Star Trek Voyager, as I like to call it. Doctors Gone Bad. In case you guys didn't watch this one.

First in this episode, the doctor finds himself in a society where a computer dictates medical care based on a person's function in that society, meaning that some people get all the care they need, even if they don't really need it, while others suffer from not being able to receive the necessary care that they so desperately truly need. Can't get much more Star Trek than this episode, Matt. We're going to get into all of it. But before we do, give me your overall impressions watching Critical Care for the very first time. It was a fun little episode. And I mean, maybe fun is the wrong word because it was a little bit more serious. But if you hadn't warned me ahead of time that, hey, we're covering this one because it's like a topic we've never covered before or Star Trek has never covered before.

I would have maybe questioned why we were watching this. I'm like, it's doctor-centric, and I don't think these aliens are necessarily going to be around for long. We're not going to spend a lot of time with them. What is going on? Why are we here? I'm not seeing anything new, necessarily. But I did not like the episode.

One of my favorite parts about it was just getting to see things more from the alien perspective, I guess. And we maybe normally get to like we started off with this alien planet, with this alien city, with these alien ships flying around and like an alien space station. Then we dive into this like alien hospital. I'm like, oh, OK, cool. What are we doing here? And I think that that just being different was enough to keep my attention most of the time. Matt, this is this is an episode that I like. I can't really explain why I've always personally loved this episode. Like it's always an episode that I just find so intriguing. I find the concepts super intriguing, which, OK, you're not supposed to say the same word twice, but I just did. Like I just it's it's such a.

good show. And there is this very little bit with the doctor that's like, whoa, did the doctor just blow his own ethical subroutines? And what does that mean for him as he's discovering his own life and whatever that potentially means for him? But that's really secondary to the rest of the episode. And just this concept of how do we, how do we manage medical resources and distribute them among society? And what does that look like and what's right and what's wrong?

I was waiting for your AKA today to be Star Trek does healthcare reform. There you go. That'd be better than what I did. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, it's, it's, but, but Matt, this episode is so quintessentially a Star Trek episode. This could have been a TOS episode and been just fine. It could have been TNG. It could have been DS9. Honestly, it could be enterprise. Like this is the, a robot or a computer is controlling what happens to an entire society for the betterment of that society. But it takes out all the humanity of the whole situation. Like literally Star Trek, the original series did that episode probably a couple of times, you know, and one of them, I think what we watched one of them.

Didn't we where the where they they took out war? They weren't doing war anymore. And the computer. Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah. So all you guys are going to die and all you guys have like two million casualties. So just send them to the vaporizer over there. Yeah. And we just have to destroy each other's buildings. And there we go. It's a much more civilized way of doing it. Yeah. But war is not supposed to be civilized. Like you're not supposed to allocate stuff like that anyway. So that's why we stopped, Matt. And you nailed it. I'm glad that I'm glad that the warning helped you with that, because one of the last things I want for you as you're watching these episodes is for you to be bogged down in your mind with why is Brent having me watch this episode and have that take away from just being able to enjoy the episode or see what the episode.

about. So I'm glad that that worked for you. But this is this is the one where we're the timeless message of Star Trek type of episodes. Very much so. I mean, as soon as the doctor figured out what was going on, when he when he gets brought up to level blue, it's like, OK, I know now what what this episode's about and why we're watching it. Yeah. This might be the last one of these kind of episodes we do. Maybe I'm not entirely sure yet. But it really this, you know, as we said, we're barreling barreling towards the end of the show for sure. All right, Matt. Well, I have one character actor spotlight that I would like to actually have two character spotlights. I want to give you real quick. The first one is the guy who came up with the story for this episode. His name was James Kahn. The only reason why.

bring him up because I thought this was really interesting. This is the guy who did the novelization of the movie Star Wars Return of the Jedi. Okay. Just thought it was interesting. That's all. The guy I really want to bring up though is the guy who played our chief doctor on the blue level, Gregory Itzen, Dr. Dysak. I don't know if you recognized him at all, Matt. Out of everybody, he's the guy that's most notable to me personally. And there were a few faces that seemed familiar. There was only one I recognized and he had such a small bit part that I didn't figure you were going to mention him. Yeah. No, I'm going to talk about Gregory Itzen. Now, this is actually Itzen's third time on Star Trek, all of which have been relatively makeup free. I don't know if that's part of his contract.

We'll be back for more. We're going to see him really soon in Enterprise. The first time we saw him, though, Matt, you and I have actually already seen him. He was in the Deep Space Nine season one episode, Dax, that we did for extra viewing. Specifically, he was the guy who came to get Dax to accuse her of killing, well, accuse the symbiote of killing his father. So that's the same actor. We're going to see him again as a Vulcan actually coming up soon. So we'll point him out. Maybe why he looks familiar. It's possible. It's possible. Now, outside of Trek, he's had several other roles. I've noticed him bouncing around all other, but I will bring up his main one. He had a role on the show 24 for several seasons, actually, as the vice president and eventually the president, Charles Logan. Itson was nominated for an Emmy for that episode.

still a working guy. He's still getting stuff going on. So check him out. Gregory it's, and he's definitely a, he, he has one of those faces that he's not a, that guy. Like I know who he is when I see him, but he's so recognizable to me. Like when I see him, like he's very distinct, I think in his look, uh, but he just kind of comes off as he's just always there. Anyway, Matt, I don't really have, there's, I don't know what's going on with this final season of Voyager as far as production notes and all that. Cause remember last week I was like, they're spectacularly little about this episode. Yeah. That's again on this episode. I just don't know if there's not been that many interviews, if people haven't talked about what happened making this episode or really if just nothing happened. Um, or if that's what's going on at this time, like of the show, like, I don't know.

because I was even trying to look up other stuff in multiple different areas. There's not really a whole lot with this episode as far as production stuff goes. So I'll turn it over to you. There was a definite A plot, B plot to this one. There's the B plot of what happened on the ship looking for the doctor. And then there's the A plot of what happened on the alien hospital with the doctor. But Matt, I'll just kind of let you tackle it however you want to tackle it and take us through this episode of Critical Care. The most important thing just being the message that we found ourselves discussing through the course of this episode. We'll be right back. It's over, Johnny.

Oh, wow, man. Hey, if you recognize those sounds, then you're probably somebody who would like our show. We're called Did You Hear About This, and we talk about all kinds of news stories. It's like the 80s and 90s stuff that we grew up on. Yeah, this isn't stuff that's getting covered on the 10 o'clock news, I'll tell you that. You can check us out at didyouhearaboutthis.show. We're on every single podcast platform. Go find us.

Yeah. And so, I mean, we kind of know where that's going, I guess. I don't know how deep this is necessarily going to get. But like you said, the doctor is forced to work. Well, not even really forced. Like by the time he gets over there, as soon as he sees there's people in need, he's like, yeah, good thing I'm programmed with a Hippocratic Oath. I'm like, ah, good doctor. Yes. So, I mean, he's just going to do his thing while he's there. He's smart enough, though. And I appreciate this about him, too. Like this bit reminds me a bit of Seven, actually. I complimented her on this the other day where they're going about doing their task as whoever wants them to do.

But while they're doing that, they are also planning something on the side. So we had Seven the other day who was trying to undo the stuff with the warp core or something, I think. And while she was doing that, she put in some safety protocols. So if anyone tried to undo what she was doing, they would have something to go through. The doctor here, yeah, he's going to go and save lives. That's what they want him to do. He's going to do his job. But he's also still trying to contact Voyager. He's also still trying to help the folks down on level red. He's doing all these things on the side as well, things he wants to do. So I think that's part of the reason I love these characters too. They're smart.

It's a great set of characters, Matt. And the two you just named, and I know I've said this before, I'll say it again. The seven and the seven, seven and the doctor specifically are, well, I used to say top three most interesting characters in all of Star Trek for like for the journey that they go on, the path they go on. I just, I think they're, they're phenomenal. It's possible. I may have to promote them to top five at this point, given some of the new stuff that I'm seeing, maybe, maybe you're going to promote them and say they're top two. No, no, I don't. It's hard. It's hard to get outside of, of Spock and data and those two guys. And I'm not even really sure which one comes up over, over the other. So yeah, anyway, but I mean,

the seven and seven are, are, phenomenal characters. And quite frankly, Matt, if you go back and rewatch this, once seven comes on board, the show really shifts to it's Janeway, it's seven and it's the doctor. And occasionally the other characters get an episode. Sure. So, and it was good for the show. It was like the right thing for the show because they were by far the most interesting characters. So yeah, that's why we have to have random walks down the hallway with Tom and Harry in hockey uniforms. Right. Because that's all the shame time you get today. Right. You're going to prove that the real doctor is gone. Thanks. Bye. But as you mentioned, the machine, the computer, the allocator is running the show over here. Was it really though? That's what they claim. That's what they claim. But I mean, doesn't somebody have to input?

stuff into the computer? Well, somebody has to program it at some point. Right. So wasn't it really Administrator Schellick? Schellick? Yeah. He was the one who really was controlling. Well, I mean, we kind of got that at the end there, right? That's what I mean, right? Because by the end, when he's laying on the table, he's like, I give you orders around here. I'm like, I'm sure you do. You blame the allocator. You tell everybody else, no, that's what the allocator says.

But yeah, I, cause I mean, everything had to be approved by the allocator. Right. And so like you, you could give the computer a command and it may or may not be approved. We saw that multiple times throughout the episode, but yeah, you're right. It's like, is the easy computer ever going to deny what Shelly told it? Probably not. So at least Shelly can go in there and type some stuff in and make it approved. Yes. Yes. I, I, I mean, I just figured it'd be easy enough to anything with his voice imprint. Right. It will obey. So, um, but everything's based on this TC, the treatment coefficient, which, okay, it's their ranking system. Got it. Right. But as the doctor finds out, it's mostly based on their profession, their skills, their accomplishments.

or as he put it their importance to society and i'm like hmm Because the thing I hated most about this episode, well, maybe not even the most, one of the things that bothered me a lot was every time the doctor would bring up Tevis, like the sick kid who wanted to be a doctor, he would bring him up to like Shellac or whoever else, someone on level blue, maybe the chief of medicine or whatever. And they're always like, yeah, what's he going to do? What's he going to amount to? How's he going to help us? And I don't think one time does a doctor ever say, hey, did you know he wants to be a doctor? Did you know he's been helping me? I mean, maybe he didn't want to go that far and throw him under the bus and say, yeah, he's actually been administering medicine to patients.

But still, like he has ambitions to be a doctor. I've seen his schoolwork. He's smart enough to be a doctor. Like he knew this stuff already without me telling him. Like he was able to diagnose himself properly. And I don't think he ever mentioned that. And every time they brought him up, I'm like, oh, you're going to tell him now, right? Oh, you're going to say, hey, yeah, if you give this kid a chance, he could be your next doctor. He could be the next chief of medicine. Because like that, that felt like the point that they're getting at. It's like, oh yeah, he's never going to amount to anything. Do you think if he did tell them that, that they would listen to him? Like, would it really matter? Would they really actually give him any consideration? No, I didn't expect that necessarily.

But I think that's even more so why I'm surprised the doctor didn't bring it up. Right. Or the writers didn't have the doctor bring it up because, okay, yeah, he's not going to listen. But the doctor would try to put his best foot forward and make this kid look the... the best he possibly can. Right. And just say all he ended up doing, like we knew behind the scenes, like what the kid wanted to become and how smart he was and stuff like that. But the doctor's just like, just kind of let it ride. It's like, oh yeah, that kid's never, you know, he's bottom of the ladder. He's not going to mount anything. And he just kind of left it there. Like he didn't even try. He didn't even voice that opinion. So I think that's one of my biggest complaints about this episode, I think. But eventually we really just see the doctor take things into his own hands and work the system. And we hit a point where, especially when he's having to talk with the chief of medicine, like I felt like he was sitting there explaining a surplus to Michael Scott.

Right. And I'm like, it's like, if you don't use all your resources now, they won't give you as much next month and then you won't be able to your job and then you're gonna lose your job. Yeah. It's like, whoa. And, and the way that Dysick just turned on Chellick for that, he was like, look, I know what you do and you're, you're going to not give me what I need to be able to do my job next month. And, but you know, and Dysick's like, whatever. So he's like, I'm going to kill you because of that. Like, really?

I mean, that, that, that was definitely a bit rushed for, for, for plot sake, for time sake. Cause that's the part, like I always want Dicek to like come over to the good side. Like, cause I, okay, let me, let's jump to the end. The doctor gets all the way through this. Has anything changed in this, in this society after the doctor leaves? Theoretically. Has it? Like, well, the idea that I was left with at least was in order to keep these resources up and essentially help more people, you're going to promote more people to level blue because then we can actually give them the meds up there. And like that, that was kind of the, at least interim solution. Yeah. That's what I mean. Like, but you're still with the allocator. They're still there. Shelly's going to go back to being whoever.

he is now, you know, I mean, and, and Dysick's just out for Dysick. He's just looking out for himself so that he doesn't get demoted and he doesn't get, I mean, it's, yeah, I think the biggest thing is though that at least for this episode, because we weren't going to spend a lot of time here, the doctor did the best he could with the time he was given. That's fair. And, and I mean, that's a message in and of itself, Matt, you do the best you can. Hope you hope you make an impact and see what happens later on. At least theoretically save the people that were there in level red at the time. So they didn't hit level white. Yeah. And yeah, well, there's nothing he could do about that now. Right. It wasn't stabbed or wait, no, it should have been.

You just made me laugh at somebody's death, Matt. Yep, you're welcome. So you may be right in saying that in the long term, not a lot is probably going to change. I mean, what we needed to see was like Tevis become like... junior chief of medicine or something like that. So someone who could maybe move up the ranks and, and, and change things in time. And if it's not Tevis, who's the other guy, a bogey doctor that actually the young man who kind of looked like Tevis, but he kept getting shipped up to yellow blue. Yeah. Or, or Dysick actually came over to the doctor's side and like understood. And then we had, or they blow up the allocator. So sorry, I can't use allocator anymore. Now just be good people, be humans. Yeah. I mean, ultimately like it kind of makes you wonder, like I, that was an unanswered question I had. And I didn't expect us to get an answer. Cause once again, I didn't figure we were going that deep with this, but, uh, Chella kept saying like the people I work for, the people I work.

work for? And like, okay, who do you work for? I don't think you're just referencing the allocator. Like there's someone above you. So like, I mean, ultimately I think what we need is to get rid of Chellick. Right. But then if there are people above him, okay, I don't know. But because I mean, if you still have Chellick in charge, you're not going to get rid of the allocator. You're not going to.

get the big sweeping changes that you want to get, I don't think, because he has too much control right there. Right. And that's what I mean, Matt, is there has to be somebody who sees what the doctor is saying, what, frankly, we are all trying to say, and adopts that as their own philosophy. And at least that person can carry hope. Like, I don't know if you remember all the way back when we did the very first Mirror Universe episode with Kirk and Spock. Like, in the last 30 seconds of the show, Kirk, like, our cook looks at Mirror Universe Spock and is like, hey, you can be the change. And Kirk comes back and he's like, listen, I did what I could. I told him what I had to do, but I had to bounce. You know, kind of what you said of, you're doing the best with the time you're given. I had to bounce. But at least that Spock was over there.

He's like, maybe he can do something and make something better of this. And we do eventually know that things did change in that universe. Was it for the better? Well, we can talk about that later. But leaving this planet, did it again? I'm asked that question. Did anything really change it? Even if it didn't, I like your answer, Matt. Even if it doesn't change long term, it changed for those people. And frankly, it's more of a question for us than it is for them anyway. So, yeah, I mean, because we do have more time here in our current situation. And as you said, that's theoretically probably a situation that can be applied.

Globally, I would think just about. Well, I mean, these shows always bring up, I think, an interesting concept, like a very real world. Resources are limited. We do not have unlimited resources. You have to be able to manage them in a certain way. The need can often outweigh the resources. Now, we saw here the need was very different. We're going to give you this injection just because it helps your arteries not to age, but it could be lifesaving to those people down there. Yeah, they were using it.

as a preventative measure for the rich, essentially, or the, I mean. Or the upper class. Classism, social economicism, whatever ism this really is. It could be applied to many. Exactly, yeah. But yeah, they're using it as a preventative measure for those folks, whereas like you said, it's life or death for the folks down below. Right, and this is, I mean, obviously this is clearly an allegory. Like on the one hand, this is talking about medical supplies. It can definitely be applied to the medical world, but yes, it can.

be applied elsewhere as well, whether it's food. There you go. It's like, okay, this one class of people is going to take this steak and cook it very finely and put it on a fancy plate and eat two bites of it and throw the rest away. And then there's the people living on the street who would be happy for any scrap of food you gave them, whether it's cooked or not. And it's like, it's the same food, same resources. It can help both people.

But what are you doing? It really, I don't know, Matt. It's just, it's one of those great Star Trek pieces where I think it poses the question. It doesn't answer the question and leaves you to just sit back and go, where does that apply? So let's, let's take a minute. This one's all about the Star Trek. So let's get deep on it. It's all about the message, right? This has very little to do with the plot, the story or anything like that. So let's talk about the message. The, how do you allocate resources when resources are limited, you know, and the need outweighs the resources, but also how do you do it to where you're not a complete and total ass about it and giving people what they don't need versus giving people something that would literally could save their life. Like we see that in our own world, even today.

Right. I don't know what the answer is, Matt. I don't know how to, I don't know how to do that. Like, I mean, that's part of the problem too. Right. Right. No, no one has necessarily figured it out. And I mean, people are trying the best they can. Right. Going along the medical route again. Like that, that's one thing that I keep popping up in my Twitter feed recently. Um, like prescription drugs and stuff, how the cost of them is just skyrocketing, skyrocketing. Yeah. And it's like for a certain class of people, either one, they don't need them or two, it's covered by their insurance or something like that. Or they just have the resources to be able to buy it. Yep. But then there, there's another class of people who, if they don't get that medication.

They may die soon, but they can't afford it. And so then I get people like Mark Cuban stepping in. And I haven't looked into the program specifically, but I see people praising it all over the place that he's found some way to make these prescription drugs cheaper for everybody. I just saw one tonight said this medication that would normally cost us $1,200 only cost us $90 this time. And so like I said, that's definitely helping some people in the here and now. Is this a long-term solution? Maybe, I don't know. Did it actually solve the problem that we had?

I mean, I think that problem is still out there. So I would say it probably hasn't solved it completely. Right. But it's definitely helping in the here and now. And that's kind of what I think like the doctor did. Right. Right. He did the best he could with the time he had there. And so we have people doing that and just trying to figure out how can I help the most people right now. But that that overarching problem is always probably going to be there. Because I don't know if there is a solution. Right. Well, let's tackle one of the big debates that we have here in America, which is not a debate that is in most first world countries around this this earth and this globe. But it is one here. And it's should we move to a system where everyone gets.

healthcare because we value you as a human being. The fact that you suck air and you share a human soul means that you are worthy and we respect you and we value you enough to help you stay alive. Or do we keep everything privatized and keep the system? Because the one way actually means the government starts controlling things and the other way means... insurances and, you know, but somehow they tell you that it's really between you and your doctor and whatever. And, and it becomes that sort of diametric piece. Like, like who do we value the most? Where do we value people? Because I like what you said. And I love the point you brought up, Matt, that maybe this is less about resource allocation and saying, Hey, let's move to a socialized medicine system. Cause we could debate that all day long. We're not gonna solve that on this podcast, you know? Yeah. But the idea, look at Tevis, you guys assumed because he's down here and you gave him this TC level, he's never going to amount to anything. And you wrote him off when actually that kid right there has the potential. You used some sort of qualifier. You were.

removed his individuality and just made him a computational thing and decided what he was going to be or what they were basically looking at what he is now and what he is contributing now. Right. And like, how is anyone ever supposed to dig out of that? Exactly. Exactly. Because you, you stole their humanity. And, and, you know, I know I've said this at least once on the show, but I've seen some things recently that make me want to repeat.

this again, anytime you take away a person's individuality and you begin to lump them into a group of people based on external factors, white people, black people, uh, Asian people, uh, people with blonde hair, people with brown hair, uh, people who are of, uh, of a poverty class level, socioeconomically people who are, you know, their family makes 500 K or more a year, uh, people who are, uh, uh, gay or people who are straight people who are trans people who are cis. Anytime you remove the individuality of you as a person and just lump people together and use that to be their identifier, you lose value for the person. And I'm not saying anything bad about any of those groups of people because I'm saying it's not about the group. It's about the individual. And we value you as an individual. I think back to Geordi. Next Generation did this episode. We skipped it, Matt. But they did an episode where Geordi was talking to, I want to say it was a Romulan. He was trapped on a planet with a Romulan. Remember, they didn't even really talk to Romulans back then very much. And they were like, the Romulan was like, oh, my planet, somebody who's blind would have just, we would have killed you as a baby because what good could you do? And Geordi's sitting here like, why would you kill me? Like, I'm glad that I got to live. Look, I'm the chief engineer of the flagship of the Federation. Like, just because I had a disability, my disability actually made me better. Like, why would you take that away from me just because of something like that? And that

has done to tevis right yeah yeah because i think whenever the allocator was instituted that kind of forever split everybody like the people that were in charge that did have the the uh education and the what they say the profession the skills and the accomplishments at that time you know they rose to the top right and everybody else was down below and and the doctor said it at one point you're not just rationing health care here you're getting rid of the sick in the week yeah because we saw you know we saw Tevis, like he had a bright future as long as he could make it to the future. But he had this, this physical ailment that was eating away at him. And well, I mean, as we saw, he didn't make it. I still kind of question if he was helped along that path, but it was very questionable at that point. I'm like, he was almost completely healed. Oh, he's dead. Yeah. Wait, what? I believe that kids would call that sus these days.

But I mean, Matt, to your point, wasn't it Teddy Roosevelt, one of our, you know, one of our great presidents who, uh, was a very sickly child. He was very weak and sickly child. I can, I can answer the question. Yes, he was. And he would, and if he had grown up in this society, he would have been given a lower TC deal and not been able to do anything to do. But I mean, Teddy Roosevelt eventually became, uh, you know, I truly, truly an American hero, uh, here for, I mean, a worldwide hero. Like the guy was, he was just a super admirable guy. Um, I think of other people like Abraham Lincoln again. Okay. I'm on a president kick. You know, Abraham Lincoln was born to a sharecropping farmer who had moved around a bunch, didn't get, wasn't able to go to school, taught himself. And he eventually rose Alexander Hamilton. Okay.

He didn't become a president. We got a cool play out of him 200 years later. But Alexander Hamilton, you know, another guy. He grew up, you know, the son of the son of an unmarried woman. And, you know, some guy who just left him after a while. Like it was all just when you didn't when you don't value people or you only value people based on their contribution to society and not for who they are or maybe to what you're getting at for the potential of what they could contribute to society. When you miss what they could become, you miss them. Yeah. And that's something I've seen before, too, is that it's so hard to work your way out of those bottom ranks if you don't have your basic needs taken care of. And, you know, that's food and water.

But then also, you know, medical care can kind of get in that category too, depending. Sure. And once again, that's still kind of a gray area. It's like, okay, yeah. How do they, how do we provide them with all those things if they don't have them when they start out? Who provides that? And that's the question is to somehow bring everybody into a more level playing field. At least give them a chance to survive. I mean, I don't know that we necessarily need to give everybody everything. And I don't know that we need to pull resources away from one group of people in order to give it to others and force that upon people. But to say, hey, we can at least make sure you're not going to die from bait. I mean, these guys were suffering. They just needed a cytoglobin injection.

These guys just needed some insulin, man. I'm not sure what the great comparison would be. This guy needed some blood pressure medicine. That's all. This guy needed a $4 antibiotic. That's it. I'll never forget. I used to run a doctor's office. I'll never forget. I might've told you this story one day before. I'll never forget. I was outside. I was working on the sign for the business. And this guy comes walking by. He's coughing a little bit. And he, you know, he asked me, he's like, hey, you work for the doctor. I was like, yeah, I'm a manager. I run the office here. He goes, oh, how much is it for somebody to come in who doesn't have any insurance? And I kind of told him, he just kind of looks at me. He's like, yeah, I can't do that. And he walked away. And I went, hey, what's going on? He's like, man, I think I just got strep throat

But I can't get an antibiotic without a prescription from a doctor. And I'm sitting here going, you know what I have inside? I've got the strep test. I've got a doctor inside. And this man just can't, he has $4 to get the medicine. He just can't afford for somebody to go, that's all you need, you know, to write the prescription. And, you know, and I'm actually very proud to say, I said, come on, man, I'll take care of you. Let's go. I said, if that's all you really need, you know, and the doctor was able to see him, got him fixed up, gave him the test. Sure enough, he had strep. They gave him the antibiotic. We never saw him again after that. And it was fine. You know, he didn't come back and abuse it. That does happen sometimes. And that's a different conversation what you do. But just because some people abuse it, does that mean you shouldn't try to help as many people as

abuse the system. Again, a different way. I mean, like I said, you actually went through the process and prove that he had strep. So he needed the medicine. Right. It wasn't like he came back the next week and said, yeah, I have strep again. And you just wrote him another prescription or something. Right. Right. I mean, he was. Yeah. I mean, he wasn't coming asking for certain narcotics or different things like that, you know, in this particular case. And that's all here or there. I'm just talking basic life care, life saving stuff, you know. But you see, I think that goes to my at least temporary answer. Again, you did what you could for that person with the time you were given. There you go. Like I said, you never saw him again. But.

you did what you could in that time. Yeah. Matt, have you ever heard, have you ever heard the story of the kid picking up the starfish on the beach? Yes. You know what I'm talking about? For those out there who might not have heard it, I'll repeat it. But I think it goes nicely with what you're saying. A boy goes out and he sees a starfish or a beach just full of starfish, starfish as far as he could see. And, and he gets in, he picks up a starfish, you know, starfish are water animals. They got to stay in the water. So he picks them up and he just starts flinging them back into the ocean, flinging them back into the ocean. Somebody comes along and says, what are you doing? So I'm trying to save some of these starfish, get them back in the ocean. He's like, how are you? There's so many out here. You're never really going to make a difference. And he holds up one of the starfish, the

Yeah, that's it. We do what we can do for the people that are put in front of us. And you see, I think that's the best solution I can give you right now is if everybody got on board with that message, do what you can for the people around you and it would make the world a whole lot better. And this is why, Matt, the entire world needs to sit down and just watch Star Trek together. It's what the show's all about. It's why we stopped to watch this particular episode of Critical Care. All right, Matt, I just want to mention real quick the B-plot of this episode. Sure. The crew is searching for the missing doctor by visiting all the people that the thief has swindled. I feel like Nog could have been really helpful in this particular part of the show. I was thinking the exact same thing as they were backtracking through his weird traits.

scheme. I'm like, did he learn this from the Ferengi? He wasn't a Ferengi. I can tell you that much, but unless he was in disguise. But yeah, the way they had to trace this trail back and just sounded like Nog would have done that. Nog would have done that. Right. Yeah. Except Nog would have returned everything in the end too. Right. Well, Nog was a good Ferengi. Well, Nog was a bad Ferengi. He was a good Federation officer. There you go. There you go. All right, Matt. Well, did you have anything else? I'm sorry. I don't mean to push this along. You know, we always, we stay in the podcast for as long as we need to, and we don't stay longer than we want to. Two things I want to bring up about that popped up in the B plot. One, when they were tracking this back and they were trying to find Gar, like.

At one point they mentioned, I forget if it was Gar or someone else, but yeah, he left to go to this gambling tournament. And I just sat there like, wait, gambling tournament. I think they were just trying to go for as generic an event as they could. I'm like, wait, it's a tournament where you gamble. I mean, like if you go to a basketball tournament, okay, you're playing basketball. So a gambling tournament, you're just gambling. What are you gambling? Well, it's like the world series of poker or something like that. You know, I guess maybe, but I mean.

you don't call that a gambling tournament. It's a poker tournament. There you go. So what are you, what are you gambling on? I want to know. Um, but then there you go. Um, even though you didn't bring them up in, in your, uh, spotlight earlier, I do want to give a shout out. I guess I'm pretty sure you, you haven't watched parks and rec, right? I think we've talked about that. A handful of episodes. I keep trying to get into the show and I've, it's not grabbed me and I hear it's, you just give it in and it grabs you eventually. I just haven't gotten to talk to you about that. Yeah. You have to get past the first season. You need to watch the first season to, you know, get some things. Sure. That's Star Trek, Matt. There you go. There you go. Uh, but I want to give a shout out to

Jerry Grigich, he's, he's in this episode. Um, for you, Brent, he was the guy who played the husband when they were back. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. He plays a guy, a character named Jerry Grigich in Parks and Rec. Okay. And it's almost the same character. Oh really? Like kind of a, the bumbling husband, um, can never do anything quite right. And yeah. Um, so that, that was fun to see you. Like he was doing that before Parks and Rec. Okay. He's a character actor. Got it. Right. But that's all I got. Um, I, I did find it interesting though. Just.

the way they took the plot at the end with Gar. Speaking of, we're all worried about the doctor and his ethics. Then we get Tuvok here threatening Gar with a mind meld. Right. We get Neelix who actually poisons the guy. Right. Like, I mean, like, what is going on here? We don't address any of this. Right. I mean, they kind of do a little bit like Tuvok and Neelix have their little side sidebar. But yeah, it's just like everybody's a little bit off in this episode. Tuvok threatened. Neelix actually did it. But he's like, relax, commander. He's just going to, you know, have some gas for a while. He's just gassy. Don't worry. It'll be fine. It'll be good. You actually poison. Yeah, he's just got gas. I mean, I question those.

if Niles hadn't stepped in at that moment, would Tuvok have gone through with my belt? He's been known to do it before. He has a history. But Tuvok is, I don't think you've seen enough episodes to really, truly appreciate. And I'm sorry, parents, if you've got young kids, you might want to beat this next part out. How much of a mind meld whore Tuvok is. He mind melds with everybody. I mean, it's supposed to be such an intimate thing. To my point even more. Yeah. He would have done it. Oh yeah, absolutely. He would have done it. Absolutely. Tuvok, Tuvok had no compunction about mind melding with people. He was all about it. You can't tell me that. Yeah, he just threatened it. He only didn't do it because Nila stepped in. Yeah. Yeah, it's a thing. It's for sure a thing. Matt, I don't think we can get out of here though without,

you just brought it up. We do need to address the doctor and his ethics. And what does this mean for him as a character that he basically went against his own ethical subroutines? And he comes to seven at the end and goes, Hey, can you give me a checkup? Because I don't know what's going on because I just did this thing, which is not okay. Like it's not okay. Let's call it what it was. It was effective, but it wasn't okay. What do you make of the doctor and what he's becoming or become? Well, and that's the thing is there is a change because as seven says, it wasn't an error in his programming or a bug or anything like that. Like his programs run just fine.

didn't have any glitches in it didn't see anything happen in the past there which he was looking for something to blame it on right right he didn't want to believe like i actually did that right and that's an interesting thought in the first place and that like that's something that we as humans can't really do like oh yeah it's just a glitch in my programming yeah we don't have that to blame it on um so yeah i mean that that kind of puts the doctor one step more towards human you know sentient ai however you want to look at it like if you ever had any doubt that he was more than just a program right this is an instance I would definitely point to because he's making decisions for himself that kind of go against his programming, if I'm understanding this correctly. Yeah, it's a development. I don't know that there's much to talk about. I just point out, Doctor's changing. Doctor's definitely changing. He's becoming more human and more whatever. So with that, Matt, I'll ask you the official questions. Did you like the episode? Would you want to watch it again? And do you get why it was part of our run? I think yes, yes, and yes.

All right. Well, it's time for our next episode, Matt. You want to know? That would be useful. We're skipping the remainder of season seven going right to... No, we're not. On to Enterprise. All right. We got a few. We'll pick you up. All right, Matt. Our next episode, as we are moving towards this end, again, like I said, it's a little bit of kind of figuring out how people are going to end up. So in that vein, our next episode, the title is Lineage. And Matt, I also need to let you know about something that has happened in the interim. It's one of those really quick little bits that actually happened towards the very end of an episode. You know, our favorite couple on the ship, Tom and B'Elanna, they get married. So Tom and B'Elanna are officially married now. All right. So just so you know. So you might say finally, you might say...

Really? I suppose as they're wrapping up the season or the series. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, it feels like someone is going to get together and who else is going to be. Exactly. You know, it's nice to see a relationship work out, you know, so or does it work out, Matt? Because there is still the rest of the season to go. But Tom and Balada do eventually get married. Tom, Tom, growing up, man, look at look at this little guy we once found in a prison colony. And, you know, his dad's proud of him now. Yeah. Yeah. There we go. I got a couple of extra viewings for you. Not nearly as many as last time.

Matt just breathed a sigh of relief there. All right. The first one is called Inside Man. It's actually the episode right after this. This is another one of the episodes with Barclay in it and the whole communication back and forth to Earth. In this particular episode, Barclay tries to send a hologram version of himself to Voyager to help interact with them and things that are happening. But it gets intercepted by the Ferengi who go in and alter the hologram in an attempt to capture Borg nanoprobes by coming through some little micro thingy maneuver or whatever. The important thing of this episode is, hey, they're still in contact with Earth, which is pretty awesome. Barclay is still around. Troy is still around. Admiral Paris is still around.

still around. It's a good episode to watch, but in the end, it's really just, they're still in communication, like pretty regular. This regular communication is happening now. Um, not quite two way back and forth, but it's getting close. Uh, or they're working on it. They're, they're advancing the technique. All right. The next episode is a personal favorite, Matt. It is a super funny episode. And if you picked this one as your extra viewing this month, I would not be mad at you at all. Along with anything from season six as well. This episode is called body and soul. And this episode, the doctor has to hide out from, from some photonic life hunters. He's being hunted. And in doing so, he decides to hide inside of seven of nines body. Hilarity ensues.

Okay. Yeah. His program goes into seven and he, you know, can take over and do stuff. And so what you now have is Jerry Ryan acting like the doctor in seven's body. It's, it's a super, it's so funny. It's such a good episode. Anyway, I'll leave that with you, Matt.

but that's going to do it for us this week on beat me up a star trek podcast folks remember if you'd like to get in touch with us you want a pundit for one of your favorite episodes as we round out voyager so you got to make sure you include this episode then you can do that by emailing us to be me up pod at gmail.com or head over to be me up pod.com for more ways to contact us and how to find our youtube channel matt where can they find you out there on the internet you can find me personally on instagram and twitter at as a matter of met and if you guys want to get in touch with me i'm at brent allen live across all the social medias i'd love to connect with you there as well too until next time folks live long and prosper

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast?

This episode is 46 minutes long.

When was this Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on July 19, 2022.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.