The final frontier begins. This is about saving the future of humanity. This is a huge victory for the good guys. You've never seen Voyager. Commitment to this course of action is not emotional.
Welcome to another episode of Beam Me Up, a Star Trek podcast. I am Brent Allen, and I have seen every episode of Star Trek 47 times. And I'm Matt Sonnenberg, and this is my first time through the series. And this is the show where we're on a mission to introduce people to the entirety of Star Trek by not watching the entirety of Star Trek, but just getting a good overview of what Star Trek is putting out there. We're watching an air date order, those episodes that deal with the lore that Star Trek is trying to tell, the history of the series and why it's such the cultural phenomenon that it is, and then also the timeless message that Star Trek is trying to put out there. What is the tale, the moral tale that they're trying to talk to us and why?
it that Star Trek is something that the entire world just needs to sit down and watch together. Matt, Matt, did you did you forget what you're supposed to do here? You wanted me to do something? Well, yeah. I mean, we talked about this like an hour ago. This is where you're supposed to ask the people to go check out our YouTube channel so they get all the behind the scenes stuff. Don't you remember? We had that conversation like an hour ago.
No, I don't remember that at all. Well, that's weird. Well, Matt, let me if people did want to watch our YouTube channel, how would they find it? Well, I believe they would go to be me a pod dot com and click on the YouTube icon in the upper right hand corner. Unless you've changed that. No, no, no. No, that's correct. That's that's still the same. But we might need to run a diagnostic on your program over there, buddy. But yeah, that's how you'd find it. Sounds like a plan. Well, why don't we talk about today's episode, which is episode 11 of season five of Star Trek Voyager entitled Latent Image, or as I like to call it, the one where the doctor gets a soul. In case you guys didn't watch this one first in this episode, the doctor discovers that he has some memory files erased, much like Matt did. And later.
finds out that it's because he made a choice that resulted in a conflicting error in his subroutines, prompting the crew to rewrite his program. But this time, Seven challenges him to let it play out and see how he deals with it. Now, Matt, we're going to get into the recap of this episode. We'll talk about all the things that popped out to us. We'll talk about the messages and all that kind of stuff. But before we get into it, I've got a character actor spotlight for you today. We've got some other things, but give me your overall thoughts on this episode of Latent Image. It was kind of fun. And the first half of it was fairly predictable. It was predictable because of how the episode was directed, I think, and how they shot it.
but it was still enough to kind of keep my attention and make me wonder like, yeah, what did happen? So I needed to see the second half. This episode certainly has a very distinct, here's the first half, here's the second half feel to it, right? I gotta tell you, Matt, personally, I really liked this episode. And this was one of those episodes like I struggled with.
during the charting the course episode with, with letting it go. Cause Jeff, the guy who did it with me was, he, he was very much on the side of, no, you don't need this one. Um, but you know, I, this one just has so much to do with the doctor and his story and what's going on with him. And I just like it. I think it's got a great mystery to it. There's a ton of rewatchability now that you know what's going on. Uh, when you see all the little eye movements back and forth between the characters, or you see how like Harry or Janeway or Tuvok are like playing off, like they don't know anything or, you know, Oh, she's ordering him to go do this. But like, she knows that there's nothing there because of that. Like, you know, it's, it's a real interesting rewatch until you get to the middle part. And then, Oh boy, does it get heavy?
But as I said in the AKA, this is the one where the Doctor is finally really recognized by the crew as having a soul. This is his Measure of a Man episode. Is he a machine? Is he a program? Or is he alive? What is he? And I think this episode is very key to his growth and development as a character. I've often said that I think the Doctor is one of the top three most interesting characters in all of Star Trek, the whole franchise. And his story, I think, is one that is worth doing a deep dive into it. And I'm just sad that we've had to skip several episodes of his that are really, really fantastic episodes. But this one is one that I wanted to stop at. But with that, Matt, like I mentioned, I do have a character actor spotlight. Before I tell you who it is, would you care to guess who I'm talking about?
The only person I can think of is Naomi Wildman. Yes. Let's highlight our youngest crew member, Naomi Wildman, played by a lady named Scarlett. I hope I'm pronouncing it right. Palmer's or Pomers might be Pomers. This is actually her third appearance as Naomi. They've all been here in season five. This just happens to be the first one that we're seeing of her. She is going to return to play Naomi 16 times over the remainder of the show. So while she's never on the DVD cover, she is as good of a returning character as any of the ones that we have over on Deep Space Nine. So she gets her own spotlight. And since we have her today and I don't have anybody else, what better place to talk to her than talk about her than right here? Now, Scarlett began a little bit sad that we didn't get more of her in this episode.
some really fun Naomi Wildman episodes. There are some really like almost cringeworthy Naomi at Wildman episodes, not even cringeworthy. It just, because she's a kid, it's like, it's like Voyager did a kid episode. Yeah. Like I just feel like she, she plays well with the camera. And so like she, she acts well, I, but I think that.
How old is she supposed to be? We're going to talk about that. OK, we're going to talk about that in just a minute. So go ahead. That was my only complaint is I'm pretty sure she is probably like double the age she's supposed to be. Oh, more. And let's let's get into that. Yeah, because one of the things I really love about Naomi as a character is she does eventually become fairly well integrated into the crew. She and Seven of Nine are often paired up and they play so well off each other. But she also pairs up with Janeway a few times and she becomes the assistant to the captain or something like that or the captain's assistant. It just, you know, it's really fun. Now, she began her career in a music.
video called Heal the World by the one and only Michael Jackson. After that, she began appearing in various commercials, a couple of guest spots on TV. I think like Seventh Heaven was one of the was one of the shows and a few others. And then in 1992, I think it was 93, I think she was only five years old. She lands the role. She lands a role on the film The Babysitter's Club. Did you ever see it? I did not. I saw it. I have no shame. I was a teenager back then. I remember reading it if I had. I just know I haven't seen it. It was certainly not a not a movie that was developed for preteen boys, but I remember doing it. I just don't remember her in the film. She was also.
at seven years old, just a couple years later, in a film called Mighty Joe Young, which was a pretty big movie for the 90s. I also saw that movie. Did you happen to see that one? I saw that movie. She was in that movie. Don't remember her, but sure. Neither do I. And then she was cast as Naomi Wildman in Star Trek Voyager. Now, Naomi as a character is only two and a half. Okay. That's it.
maybe three, maybe getting close to three at this time. Naomi was 10 years old when she's playing this part, right? Like I was, I was going to guess maybe like eight or something like that. She was maybe supposed to be like four, but I can't remember when we saw that. Like I remember we saw the birth, but I didn't remember how long ago that was. Yeah. Now the difference explained in universe is remember Naomi is part Katarian, which is the things on her head. And that accounts for her rapid growth. There's actually an episode where they talk about she grew so many centimeters in like a week, which is like a lot. Right. And, and let's also not forget how fast a young Alexander Worf's child who Worf barely remembers. So I wouldn't be surprised if you do or don't. He grew very.
very fast as well. Anyway, while Naomi was playing this role, she did continue to appear in a few commercials and other films. Most notable being Julia Roberts, Aaron Brockovich, not a film I ever saw, but I know it was very popular back in the day. Now in her young career, she received five young artist awards. One of them, and the one she's most proud of was receiving the 1999 award for best supporting young actress for her role. Here's Naomi on Voyager. One of the things anecdotally she was always known for though, among the fans, especially was she always would write back. She loved receiving fan mail and she would always take the time to write back to anybody who wrote to her. She was, she was, I don't want to say famous for it. It's not like, Oh,
She'll write her because she'll write you back. But it was one of the things that she really liked to do. Now, post Trek, she landed the role of Kira Hart on the show Reba. I don't know if you ever saw Reba. It ran for seven seasons, I think it was, on CW. Yeah, I've seen a handful of episodes. My mom watched it. Yeah, she was the youngest daughter of Reba on the show. She was there for the duration of the show. She was in 102 of the 125 episodes. The episode she missed was the majority of season five. She was only in two episodes of season five, and that's because she took a brief stint off the show where she was checked into a rehab facility to deal with her eating disorder of anorexia. Typically, I wouldn't bring stuff like that out, except after she got out.
did return to the show and she became very public about her eating disorder and what it did in the healing that she's had to go through and had to take. They even joked about it a little bit in the show. Like when she came back, like they were like, where you been? She's like, oh, I just have to get a bite to eat. You know, like, like they brought it up in the show. So it's a thing. And she still talks about it a bit today. Um, very acknowledging, you know, she talks about how she's had it. She's really happy to have, she doesn't want to have had to go through it, but she's glad that if she did, she now gets to help people, both men and women. She always specifies because it affects men too. Um, but she gets to, you know, she gets to by telling her story, she can help other people with the, uh, with the disease as well. Now, since the end of Reba, she has pretty much just stopped acting
teen interview for Star Trek dot com or something like that. Are you done with acting? She's like, yeah, I'm pretty much done. She doesn't want to act anymore. Sure. When she finished, she turned her focus to music. She had a band and the name of the band was just Scarlet. They put out an EP in 2010, had about five songs on it, but then they didn't release anything more after that. She says even to this day, she's still involved with music, but she's only making it for herself. She's not really making it for commercial reasons because she doesn't think the money is very good in it. So it's really just for her. Her website, scarletpomers.com has gone unrenewed. So if anybody wants to go out there and buy up her name, go for it. It's out there and available. That's how like down she's come from all of that. You know, like she just she's done with that particular part of her life today. She's most.
out of the spotlight, as I mentioned, and she's really fine with that. She works as a photographer doing mostly fashion photography, but she also shoots like for bands doing their promotional album, their artwork, stuff like that. She says sometimes she'll do some concert photography, but she really doesn't like to. It's just not creative enough for her. At least when she's doing the other shoots, she has some creativity as a photographer that she finds satisfying for her. That pretty much is what her life is made up of today. As far as I can tell, there's not a ton about her out there. Photography and whatever personal things she does with music. She can very occasionally, Matt, and I mean very occasionally, be found on the convention scene. Like so occasionally, it's only been like twice in 10 years. All right. But she says she loves it. I don't know if she just doesn't get invited enough or she just doesn't go. I have no idea.
But anyway, that is Scarlet Pomers. She plays our young Naomi Wildman. We will see her several more times throughout the rest of the run of Voyager. I'm sure you're going to run into her a handful of times as well. Well, Matt, with that, this is where I'm going to turn the show over to you. You take us through. Talk to us about your plot points throughout this whole thing. It talks about your discovery along with the doctor of what was going on. How soon did you have it figured out? Did you pick up the clues that they were dropping along the way? You know, and yeah, you take it over from here, my friend. All right. Like I kind of said before, I feel like in the first half, I did pick up on a lot of the clues that they were dropping because like just the way that they put it, the way that they shot this episode and they hung around.
certain people afterwards and you kind of mentioned too like their eyes kind of going around looking at other people or avoiding other people and it just kind of very early on i made sure to make the note the captain knows more than she's letting on and whoever wrote this episode of course did a good job in making the bulk of the doctor's early interactions after like finding this with seven because she was the only other one really that didn't actually know anything about it. Now, thinking about this again, Harry claims not to remember it, but did he? Yes, he did. Because he also, if you go back and watch, he also had one of those lingering camera shots where he's like, he's just sort of looking like, are you buying this? But Harry, even if Harry was like knocked out and he doesn't necessarily remember the surgery, he 100% remembers Vincent Jital. She would have been a part of the crew. Sure. So they're not erasing his memory. They don't have men in black technology yet to erase their memory like that. Right. So yeah, they can erase the doctor's data, but.
They're not modifying other people's memories at this point. And I mean, for a second, until we got to that lingering shot on the captain, I think, I was questioning like, okay, did that alien... whatever he shot them with. Like, did that affect the memories? Yeah, that's I think there's a that's always something that I think of when I first see it. Like, you know, he shoots the two and then he shoots the doctor and the doctor just sort of phases a little bit, but he's still moving around. You're like, OK, that's what deleted his program. That's that's why he doesn't remember what just happened. And turns out it didn't do anything to him at all. It was Janeway and B'Elanna and all those guys. Yeah. What surprised me, though, because after seeing this entire episode, I think it was the truth that seven doesn't recognize the alien after the thousands and thousands of species they've come across. This was a new one to her.
not even the Borg have assimilated everybody. Yeah. So like that's, that's something that's, I'm sure we'll never run across these aliens again, but it makes me curious. But I think that was, I think her response to that was more for plot reasons. Like if she knew, knew about these aliens like that would have thrown a wrench in what they were trying to do. So it was more useful that everybody, including seven had no idea what was going on with these aliens theoretically. So I may be just nitpicking a little bit too much here, but when they, they show the scan of Harry and they're slowly building up like his skeletal structure and his innards. And then they put like some of the,
you know, the muscles and abnormalities and stuff on there too. It seemed weird to me that they would put this there without it being there for a reason. But it looks like he had kind of like a major crack on the front of his skull as well, like on his forehead almost. And at first I thought that's what we're going to be inspecting. It's like, dude, when'd you hit your head? But then he's like, oh no, at the base of the skull is by the spinal cord. I'm like, oh, okay, sure, you do your thing. And then, you know, they went around back there and like, okay, they can barely see anything. Yeah, magnify 500 times, magnify another 100. Yeah, it's a tiny little thing here. And I didn't know if that was just some random detail they threw in there or if that was supposed to be from a previous encounter as well that Harry hit his head somewhere. I don't know. Yeah, I see what you're talking about. It's kind of right in the middle of his head going straight up and down.
I mean, maybe it's where his two parts of his brain didn't fuse all the way when he was growing up. I don't know. Like, yeah, I mean, I don't know enough about anatomy and the insides of the body to know if there's supposed to be some sort of crack there or something. but it just, the way that it materialized as everything else was being processed, like it seemed to jump out to me. And like I said, the camera work in this episode all seemed very specific. Like we're going to hang around this one person to give you a hint that they might know something more. And so like when that detail jumped out at me, I'm like, I wonder what's going on there. The only thing that I was gonna say, the only thing that ever gets me is when they do go around behind the head and they start looking at something and they like magnify, magnify. I can never tell what they're looking at. And I don't think you're supposed to, like, I don't, I don't think you're actually supposed to be able to see it and tell it. They're just moving through it. And it is what it is. Yeah. Cause that's the thing too, is like, I don't think if the doctor had just gone and looked at it, he wouldn't know.
it. He first called it out because the computer ran a scan on the hollow image and said, oh, there's something weird here. Before this episode, had we ever met Ensign Jital? Nope. She's completely new. They just brought her into killer? Yep. Brought her into killer. And you know what else we've never seen before? Despite the doctor saying that he was quite the shutterbug 18 months ago, we've never seen this little imager before ever. I did wonder about that. I've been quite the shutterbug. I'm like, that sounds like a plot device.
oh yes that was like it's one of those every time i watch it even to this day i go really you were quite the shutterbug back then because i don't remember that at all yeah like the time frame they gave this like is a weird one can we talk about that sure because there's there's a fun little little notes um about that. So according to the star dates that everything happens and when they, when they back it up 18 months, this episode would have been, would have placed to Charles death chronologically between worst case scenario, which we did watch as a extra viewing episode, which was the next to last episode of season three between that one. And then Scorpion, which is the one where they meet the Borg and or species eight, four, seven, two, and go off on that. Like it would be, it would have been between those. That's when this event would have occurred. Okay. So a few things that, that whatever the doctor's memories though, show Janeway with her new shortcut hairstyle, which she did not have even in Scorpion.
Also back then, um, in fact, she didn't even get that. Yeah. She didn't even get that haircut till year of hell, which was like nine episodes later in the next season. Um, Paris's haircut was also different than it was new Paris versus in this season or whatever. Yeah. Like it was very short hair. Yeah. Yeah. Also Kes was not in any of these memories. And at the time, Kes was the doctor's assistant, not Tom Paris. However, when we get to sick bay and they're trying to treat everybody, it's Tom Paris. Who's there being the assistant instead of Kes whom it should have actually been. Yeah. So.
If you not inconsistency, I mean, all of that obviously is very explainable inconsistencies. Yes. Yes. Understandable. But still, you know, the eagle eyed people are like this point in the series and this point in Star Trek, they should know that they have fans that are going to pick this apart. Oh, if you're going to throw out a date like that.
you need to make things a little more consistent or at least try. I mean, at least instead of putting Tom in there, since we know, you know, he didn't become an assistant till later, like even if it's not Cass, give us some rando that we don't know or just find a way to make it work without an assistant or, or just say Cass is off the ship right now and can't come. Like you have to at least acknowledge something like that. Like I would think, you know, but also I know, you know, these guys back in the nineties, like just don't even mention it. Nobody will think about it. They're going to blow right through it. And I guess this is still the beginning of the internet era, but yes, definitely. And you remember in order to rewatch it, people had to like record this stuff on their VHS at home, you know, and fast forward through the car.
commercials like you didn't have streaming options where you could go back and check all this stuff out and things like that so it wasn't enhanced right yeah it wasn't quite in reruns just yet or anything like that so that's fair so as soon as we caught the the first glimpses of this mystery ensign and the unknown aliens and stuff i will admit i paused it i'm like shoot i bet you i'm supposed to know who all these people are and who's who these aliens are otherwise brent wouldn't include this episode right like these must be people that are recurring that we've seen before so i paused and i tried to go through my notes and find like who were the last aliens we met? Do you have any notes of any other ensigns? I'm like, I just couldn't find anything. I'm like, okay, fine, I'll do it.
they'll probably explain it for anybody who hasn't seen the previous episodes. Right. So I kept going and it's like, okay, maybe I wasn't supposed to know who these people were. Or maybe it just didn't matter. I will say that this run through has made me start to question things like that because I know I have a kind of poor memory when it comes to stuff like that. It'll take me, you know, half a dozen rewatches to really tie down who everybody is and how they're all related and where they appear and stuff like that. And I'm definitely not there yet. I still struggle with, oh, I've met this person before. Right. So yeah. Thankfully, like Naomi Wildman,
drilled into me enough times that obviously I didn't recognize the actress because that was the first time I've seen her but when they say Naomi Wildman or Naomi and why I think I think I don't think the doctor mentioned Wildman but in the captions that I had turned on it says Naomi Wildman there you go like I know who that is. There you go. I did want to applaud the doctor though. Okay. Or not just 100% sitting back and saying, oh, the captain will take care of this. Cause I mean, it did kind of feel like you might be writing them off a little bit. And so I was super impressed when he's, he got back to sick bay and he's like, okay, duplicate this. If someone tries to mess with them, you know, reload memories, activate me. And, and we're going to, then, you know, I'm going to put up a security camera here and take pictures of everybody. I'm like, okay, dude.
well done. Like you thought this through, you got your backup measures in there and I don't have any problem with that. I mean, especially like back in the nineties, I can imagine that that seemed excessive. And it's like, Oh, how has that been to work? But now with like today's technology, I'm like, okay, so yeah, he just set up his iPhone, you know, tethered it to his computer and said, Hey, yeah, if anybody messes with, you know, or, you know, he installed a ring doorbell, like, right. He gave his own like little version of the glitter bomb with the cameras and everything on the inside. Yeah. Yeah. It's just like, we see this stuff every day. So can I tell you my problem with that scene? What's that? I have a big problem with the scene. Um, so what he says is, and he,
does it in this order. The order is important. Okay. He says, computer duplicate my memory files for the last 48 hours. And the computer says done. And then after that, he goes and sets up the imager and says, record anybody who comes in and does this. Now those memories of setting up the imager were not duplicated. So later when he's reactivated and it reinstalls and the first thing he does is go to the imager that he may have had that planned in his head, but he like there was.
Like that was too quick. Like he didn't, that was not his memory. I will give you that. That could have been another quick fix in the script. Just set that up, set up a camera first and then duplicate memories. Because he should have said, now duplicate my memories for the last 48 hours. I'm going to go offline. And if anybody comes in and changes my deal or the next, he didn't even say that. He could have just said the next time I'm at, I'm, what's the word? Opened, called upon, activated. Thank you. The next time I'm activated, like I've seen the show before, just immediately reinstall my last 48 hours of memories. Maybe you'll copy over the exact same thing. Maybe you'll change something. Who knows? But he could have just said, but anyway, that one always.
Always gets me. Can we please back up, though, to because this is actually where I thought you were going when he first goes to see the captain and he's doing like the exam on her at the very beginning of the episode. And he's first telling her about the problem of what's going on. Right. And she says, OK, yeah, we'll look into it. And then he goes and talks to seven of nine about it as well. Like right. Yeah. But while he's talking to the doctor now, my wife is in the medical profession. I've been in the medical field for a while as well at various points in my life. I'm not there right now. But HIPAA is a really real thing. And you imagine that it's still a thing in the future. Personal privacy, personal stuff about your own deal, at least on some level. I do. I do. And when the captain goes.
I was the crew. My immediate thought is he can't tell you what's going on with the crew. That would be a violation of doctor patient confidentiality. And then he just starts talking and he's like, oh, well, the crew's fine. Generally speaking, there is this little bit of a virus out there, but I was able to nip it in the butt. I was like, oh, he's just speaking in general terms. Not a big deal. And then he goes.
But for seven of nine, here's what's going on with her. I was like, oh, dude, you just did it. You can't do that. And then he goes on and talks about Harry. And I was like, oh, no, you're not. Even though it's the captain, you're still not really allowed to do that. And I know it's like really tiny and stupid, but it bugs me every time I see it. It's like he shouldn't. Somebody needs to rewrite his ethical subroutines. It's not OK. Sorry. Fast forward back to where to where you were with the hollow imager and stuff, because I thought that's where you're going a minute ago. Yeah, that was definitely not on my mind.
But shortly before that is when I had made the note about Janeway. So if the security image came back with anybody but Janeway, I would have been surprised. Sure. But I was expecting Janeway. I'm like, it's gotta be. It's gotta be. Like the only thing that kind of confused me a little bit is that you heard the door open and like kind of the sound of someone coming over, but there wasn't really anybody and there was no reflection in the shot we got or anything like that. Like it seemed like.
it was almost an invisible being. And at that time I still had the thoughts of, I think they had even mentioned it at this point once that like there's an imposter or something and the aliens are the imposters. And I think they were trying to tie that to the tall maybe. And like, or do we have some kind of shape-shifting aliens and now they're posing as the captain? Like, is that where we're going with this? Right. But no, no, it's literally just the crew trying to hide this from the doctor. You know who I honestly think, usually think it is until the, like, if I haven't seen the episode in a long time, who my mind first goes to is I always think it's B'Elanna. Like, I know that, I know that it's the.
crew. Like, cause I remember the show. I know exactly what happens, but in my head, like when the door first opened, I'm like, Oh, that should be B'Elanna coming in to do that. But it's not, it's Janeway. She does. She has the scientific background. She absolutely does. We'll be right back.
Oh, wow, man. Hey, if you recognize those sounds, then you're probably somebody who would like our show. We are called Did You Hear About This? And we talk about all kinds of news stories. It's like the 80s and 90s stuff that we grew up on. Yeah, this isn't stuff that's getting covered on the 10 o'clock news. I'll tell you that. You can check us out at didyouhearaboutthis.show. We're on every single podcast platform. Go find us. Yeah, I have no problem with being here. And like, it kind of like she had to make the call the first time. And as the captain, I could see her not feeling.
that it would be right to ask anybody else to do that. Like, no, I need to do this myself. Well, she is the one that, don't forget, that made the whole thing happen with Tuvix and she killed Tuvix. So she's gonna have no problem deleting a few files out of the doctor's program. Janeway will do it. And believe me, that ran through my mind during this episode. We have had this talk before about Janeway making questionable decisions and it seems to be a theme for her. Like the writers have figured out her character and whether it's for better or worse.
This has become a thing with Janeway. It has. And I really love Kate Mulgrew's explanation of this. What is something that every other Starfleet captain has that she doesn't? The Admiralty. No, the Admiralty. That when she doesn't know what to do, that she can't call her boss. Call the Admiral and be like, okay, here's my situation. What do you, what advice do you have? Or call another captain. Call her. She doesn't, she doesn't have any kind of peer peerage. Like there's Chakotay, but, and honestly she should confide, she should talk this through with him a lot more. Like this is something to have that conversation with your, with your first officer, but she still has to be the one to make those, those calls. You know, she can make the final decision. But I mean, in all honesty, 18 months later, it comes back and then she talks.
with people with folks right well actually she talks out with seven who wasn't there the first time And the only reason she talks about what seven was because seven came to her and we have really the crux that like what I would say that maybe it's the first crux of the episode where they talk about the nature of individuality, the nature of the doctor and seven used herself as the example. Nobody else had that perspective, you know, and in many ways, this is what I love about seven and how they incorporated her. Not only was she the only individual who wouldn't know who Jital was, so she wouldn't have been privy to this information, which made her the perfect person to do this with. It's a literal side by side comparison of here you have the organic being of seven of nine and here you have a photonic computer based life form of the doctor or is it a life form? And Janeway makes sense. She's like, look, that doctor is more like a replicator than it is one of us.
Seven's like, is he though? Is he? You know, and she gives Janeway a great pause, great moment of pause. I love that conversation. I think it's super important. Not necessarily an hour day, but. Yeah, not quite there yet. But yeah, I it almost feels wrong to say, but I loved how seven kind of threw this all back in her face. Yeah. This is what you've been trying to teach me. This is what you've been saying all along. And now, why is it different? When they get into it, after they get into this first time and.
Janeway basically, I think she kind of leaves Seven to reverse it again and do some of the deletions and stuff. The camera once again focused on Seven for a while. And I honestly thought that she was going to follow Janeway's orders, but leave some kind of backdoor in the program and leave some way for the doctor to unlock the memories himself when he came back online. There'd have to be some trigger or something along the way, but that was my initial feeling is that, okay, I'll do what you say, but I don't quite agree with you. So I'm also going to do this other thing, but it turns out, yeah, that look was more so.
a questioning look and i'm gonna hunt you down and talk to you later but eventually we find out like it's not just janeway the entire crew is in on this everybody knows what happens except for the doctor in seven and now you got me wondering like what actually happened like that they they make one of the most uh curiosity inducing statements they made his program almost self-destructed and they just kind of let it go and i'm like no no come back here go back you gotta explain that and and so like i said eventually like the the last part of this episode is replaying that day and then letting the doc and then, you know, generally coming to the conclusion that we can't do it again. Let's let him deal with it and see what happens. Now, let me ask you, though, what is a more questionable decision on Janeway's part to be knowing now what you because you saw where the doctor got to in this episode again when he had to face it. And they all said it's happening again. It's happening again. Tom Harris said, yeah, I saw what happened and I agreed with the with the captain to do this to you. And it seems like everybody in the ship did as well. Seems like we don't know. We didn't talk to everybody, but it seems like we see him going through. So knowing what happened, what is more questionable on the part of the captain to change the computer files of a program or and not.
recognize the doctor's individuality or his aliveness. Okay. His sentience is his, his, his soul, so to speak, or I don't like that term, but we can get that. Well, sure. I I'm with you on that. I use it because they use it in the, in the show. Um, I think it's, it's, you know, again, we go back to the question of data. Was data alive? Is data alive? Like what, what makes, what makes a personal person? I think by any measure, the data was alive. The doctor's alive. I would agree with that, but like, I just really didn't like when Janeway jumped to, we gave him a soul. I'm like, yeah, that was a big leap. Sure. Sure. I get that. I get that. Um, but okay. So let me, let me finish my question. So what was a bigger, a bigger questionable call by Janeway to delete files and not recognize the,
doctor's uh alive life life form whatever whatever my word is there or to risk being out in the delta quadrant away from everybody at starfleet and away from any help and have your doctor's file self-corrupt did they have any sort of backup for the doctor at this point apparently they did because we went into the future with it remember that episode living witness they found the backup module so yeah maybe we did i guess that that should be a consideration i think for one they can you know reboot him reset him if they need to if something does happen but i mean Honestly, she didn't think this through enough the first time to come up with the solution. I honestly like how she handled the second time. Yeah. Yeah. Like kept him activated. Let him try to figure this out, but put him in a situation where he can't like delete himself or whatever he would, you know, he would have done. Like it kind of felt like they admitted him to like a psychiatric hospital or something. And the empty holodeck kind of looked like a padded room. Exactly. It really did. Like they put him in there. It's like, here, you have a chair where you're going to be, have someone watching you 24 seven. So if you try to pull something like, okay.
But like that's that's the feeling that I got. And I thought that was actually a good solution. It's like let him work through this and maybe even help him work through this if he needs it. But I think he kind of worked through it on his own for the most part. And that was the point, right? To let him come to terms with what happened and why he made the decision that he did and what he has to do to go forward. Because, you know, like I actually really I like what brought him out of it. And we'll talk about the ending here in just a second, a little bit more. But the idea that like the first time the doctor kind of seemed like himself since going into this state was when he walks over and he sees Janeway like, hey, you're not just tired. You're sick. You can't be here like that. Like he kind of started getting switched.
flipped and he flipped back into doctor mode. Yeah, yeah. And you know what I'm always reminded of when I see that scene? Is the movie Top Gun. Now, if anybody out there has not seen the movie Top Gun, the movie's 35, 40 years old. Spoiler alert, but you should go see it. But in the movie, the co-pilot Goose dies, right? Goose dies in the end. Well, no, he dies like in the middle of the movie, right? Because that's the whole second half of the movie is Maverick is dealing with the grief over the loss of his friend. And Tom Skerrick, the guy who plays the commander, what's he keep telling the guys to do with Maverick? Do you remember? Send him back up. Keep sending him back up. Send him back up. Get him flying again. Get him out there. Get him back in the seat. Get him where he... And it's...
it's not until that spot where he figures out he has to engage and get back to who he is before he can get over all that. Right. And, and like, it's so reminiscent of that to me that you've got to get back out there and move, you have to move on with that connection. But yeah, I can definitely see where you're coming from. You move on. I mean, that's just where my head goes. You know, I don't know if that's where the writers got it from or, or whatever, but send them, keep sending them back up. You got to get them back in the saddle. You got to keep them moving and remind them that life.
continues, you know? And I think, Matt, if I may, this is where I get into the Star Trek message of this episode. As we've talked about, season five is this really weird, I believe, unintentional examination of mental health. And this one goes into examining guilt and regret and how that can lead to self-doubt and doubting yourself, right? And, you know, so does the doctor actually gain something by working through it rather than just simply trying to forget? Yeah, I think he does. He gains a new sense of himself, right? He gains an experience. And I think it's something that a lot of us come up on time, from time to time in our lives where we do something, we've made a decision that you can't change anything. And it didn't turn out the way you wanted it to or it had a negative impact.
You couldn't save everybody or whatever it is. And you sit back and you just go, why would I have done that? That was really stupid of me. Right. Or, oh, go back to the episode Emissary with Cisco when we very first met him. And what did the prophet say to him? You exist here. You exist in this moment. Remember, because he existed in the moment where his wife died. Like, why do you stay here? You got to go forward. You got to you can't live here. We all have these moments from time to time throughout our life. But you have to learn from it and grow from it as a person. And I think that's a message is not that you just have to move on and forget, but you internalize. It becomes a part of you. It becomes a part of your growth as a human. Right. And I also think that.
there's that message of you got to be able to accept your choices and the consequences of those choices, even when they're not great consequences, but you can't be paralyzed by it. Like I'm not a mental health counselor, but I would think if you went to talk to a mental health counselor, that would be where they'd want to get you is internalize it, let it become a part of you, but you can't let it paralyze you. You've got to move on. You have to go back to life. Keep getting out there. Go back up. Yeah. And I kind of saw this coming from the doctor in three short statements that he made. It started out with, why did I decide to kill her?
I felt was a little bit of an overreaction, but it's, you know, that's all in perspective too. After he made the choice, okay, he made the choice to save Harry, but I guess could frame that as you chose to kill the other one, but okay. But then he moves on a little bit to, I can't live with the knowledge of what I've done. So still kind of in the same place, but I think he's gaining a little more perspective on like what's bothering him. And then right as he's about to let Janeway go, it's like, I'll still be here in the morning. I don't want to be responsible for any more suffering. Cause this all came out of, you know, when, when he, when they were on the shuttle and he teleported the alien off the shuttle.
to his own ship. And Harry, still conscious a little bit, says, you should have put him out in space so he couldn't come back and attack us. And the doctor says, I'm not in the business of killing people. And so I think that was kind of the launching point for all of this that went on later when he's like, why did I decide to kill her? Because he had made that statement. It's like, I'm not in the business killing people. I'm in the business of healing people, helping people. So then when he gets his mind in that loop of, I chose to kill this person. I can't deal with this. I don't understand what's going on. But then eventually comes around to, I don't want to be responsible for more suffering.
Therefore, I need to kind of let this go and I need to continue helping the people that are still here. And so that's kind of the path of growth that I saw throughout the doctor. And it all made a lot of sense to me. I think that's exactly where they were going with it, honestly. And I think you've gotten out of it what you need. I do want to talk about the poem real quick that Janeway's reading. She's reading Dante's La Vida Nuova. And the quote that the doctor reads is not actually a translation of what La Vida Nuova says. They've adjusted it to kind of make it fit a little bit better. So a lot of times people will quote this as being from Dante, but it's not actually from Dante. It's what the show writers messed with.
actually said, but here's what I like. What Bob Picardo, the guy who plays the doctor, what he says of it, he says the poem that the doctor reads says something like, and this is the very last phrase before the show ends here begins a new life. Yes. Which is a beautiful way to end that here begins a new life. We can move forward. Something's new here. I think he says, I think it worked on two levels. The poem was suggesting how having had this experience, the rest of the doctor's life would be changed. The other level is that you could say this is his first true hand, emotional discovery of art. That poem, which was written a thousand years ago, could reach across a millennium and touch his own experience deeply and perfectly. And the episode was not wrapped up in.
neat package by the end. I'm telling you, eventually Star Trek does catch on to this fade to black thing. Yeah, just let it go. Let it hang. Let the audience consider it. Let the audience wonder what happens next. And you don't have to resolve every last thread. Right, right. Because, I mean, but that line right there, right? Here begins a new life. That's the resolution. That's really all you need. Sure. Take it from where you want to go after that. Yeah. You know, so there it is, Matt. That's the episode. So one little production note that I want to know about the ending specifically, because I just I personally found this humorous. I don't know that anybody else out there will. The ending of the episode was actually originally different. Apparently, there's that speech that the doctor is giving when he looks up and sees Janeway is like falling asleep.
that speech was quite a bit longer in the original thing. And what he does, he looks up and he sees Janeway is asleep and he's just delivered this big speech that nobody's heard. And he walks over and that's when he picks up the book and he reads the end of the thing. Well, Brandon Broga didn't like it because he thought it was too long and drawn out and overly dramatic. And so Brandon goes in and tinkers with it and he gives us what we got, which is the shortened speech. There's Janeway having just fallen asleep, but now she's sick. So Janeway gets excused and he picks up the book that she sort of left behind, right? And so they rewrote that. Well, Joe Minoski, who's the guy who actually wrote the episode, he goes down to the set while they're filming and they're about to film this scene. This is the final scene that they have to film. And when he gets down there,
Everybody just starts telling them like, they're like, why did you change the ending? We love the original beginning, the original ending so much. They felt it was so much more poignant with Janeway still there, not having left that she had just fallen asleep. And the doctor like kind of comes over to take care of her and, you know, puts a blanket up on her or whatever, like just kind of returns to being human at that point. Right. And, you know, Joe was like, well, yeah, I liked that ending better too. Brandon's the one that changed it. And so they like everybody collectively, like the director, the actors, Joe, like they got on the phone and called Brandon. It was like, look, your ending sucks. Can we please go back to my ending? And they kind of went back and forth and Brandon eventually agreed. And he said, look, just shoot both endings.
do them both to shoot both endings and let's see which one works better when we, when we cut it in editing. Very, that's actually a thing that I probably would say at some point, just do them both and let's get to the end and let's see how we like them both. It's not a big deal. They were already set up to shoot Brandon's ending. So they wound up shooting that one first, right? Cause that's the one they were supposed to shoot. Well, then they got to the end of shooting that and it was like one or two o'clock in the morning and everybody was really tired and that was their final day of shooting. So they just said, yeah, forget it. Let's just keep this one and hope it works. And they all went home. They just didn't even, they went through this whole big rigmarole and then they didn't even follow through on it. So yeah, yeah, they were just tired. It's two o'clock in the morning. Let's go home. I'm done. I would
plan all along. If you had included like a detail, it's like, but shoot my ending first. Right, right. I know I'll take you too long. We'll be done. Right, right. It's one of those, like, I sit back and I think, like, what would Michael Piller have said? Where's Michael Piller when we need him? How would that have gone? Oh, do we miss Michael Piller yet, Matt? We liked him a lot. From time to time. Yeah. Yeah. All right, Matt. Well, I will ask you this question. Did you like this episode? Is it one you'd want to watch again? And what do you think? Was I right to make the audible and bring this episode into the main run? Or because the point here being the doctor is alive. This is when the doctor is recognized as being more than just a computer program by the crew. And it changes how they treat him going forward. Changes. It solidifies it a lot more. Or what do you think?
I'll leave it to you. You tell me, was I right to put this one in or not? Cause it's going in no matter what at this point. Well, I, I did enjoy it. Um, it gets a bit heavy at the end, so I would watch it again, but I think I'd wait a little while to watch it again. I don't know if back to back viewings is the way to go with this one. Um, as for why it's in here though, I, I think I need to reserve judgment to see how much this plays out in the future and how much things change and stuff like that. Cause I, I, right now I think I can see a definite argument for not having it in here in the run. Um, mostly because you telling me that.
they accept him as a living being now, or this was his measure of a man episode. Like that feels like it would be enough for me and I wouldn't have too many questions. So my instant reaction is to probably say you probably could have left this out. but that may change over time. All right. Fair enough. Fair enough. We'll see. We'll see if it changes. Maybe Jeff was right. But like I say, I had to make a call. You know, it was still a good episode. Still a good episode. There you go. All right, Matt, get your pen ready because here comes next week's episode. I promise you this is one that nobody is going to say we should leave out going through this. We're going to stay right here on Voyager. It's Sweeps Week in Voyager, which means it's time for a two-parter, a double episode that aired together as one single episode. It was a big episode. It was a big budget episode, Matt. The episode is called Dark Frontier 1 and 2. That is the title of the episode. And Matt, I have to tell you, I know how much you love a good origin story. So I really hope you like this episode. All right. And that said, I have two extra viewing episodes for you.
you today. The first one is called, have I given this one to you already? I can't remember, but if not, I'm going to give it to you again. Bride of Chaotica. I'm pretty sure you've talked about it, but I don't think it's on my list. Well, here it is. Bride of Chaotica. This is a holodeck program gone wrong episode. This is the episode that directly follows this episode where the doctor, a photonic now life form, is recognized. In the very next episode, photonic alien explorers, they are the Starfleet of the photonic life of the universe, interpret the Captain Proton program as reality. And it forces the crew to play out the scenario and Captain Janeway takes on the titular role of Bride of Chaotica.
This episode's a hoot, Matt. It's a lot of fun. It is important in the idea that right after this episode with the doctor, it actually introduces real photonic life that exists out there. Life that exists not as organic carbon-based life forms, but as photons. And I want to give you another one. I want to reiterate an extra viewing from a couple of seasons ago. So this is actually the second time I'm giving it to you, but I want to give it back to you one more time. It's from season three. It's an episode called Real Life. And in this particular episode, the doctor gets to experience all the highs and lows and all the hardships of having a family. This is not a feel good episode, Matt. I will warn you, but it is definitely one worth watching. And it is definitely one that if you're doing a deep dive into the doctor, this is a must watch episode. It is. It is. Yeah. Yeah. Like I said, it's not feel good episode at all, but it's a good one. It's worth it. Definitely. Definitely worth it. All right.
And with that, Matt, that's going to do it for us this week on Beam Me Up, a Star Trek podcast. Remember, folks, if you'd like to get in touch with us, you can do that by emailing us to beammeuppod at gmail.com or head over to beammeuppod.com for more ways to contact us. Matt, where can the folks out there find you on the Internet? You can find me personally on Instagram or Twitter as a matter of Matt. And if you guys want to get in touch with me, you can do that by finding me at Brent Allen Live across all the social medias. I'd love to connect with you there as well, too. That's going to do it for us this week, folks. Until next time, live long and prosper.
Well, let's talk about today's episode, episode 11 of season five of Star Trek Voyager entitled Latent Image, or is that... Okay. I'm sorry. I just got to ask, did you do that on purpose or did you just complete, like, did I just pick up on something or did you completely forget? I'm glad you picked up on it. Okay. Cause I was like, what are you doing? Okay. I'm just letting, did you forget? Like, no, no, I know I've forgotten in the past, but I totally went into that. I'm like, you guys should tell him, warn him ahead of time or, or, you know, Hey Brent, you know, do this or like, no, I just decided to wait and see how long it would take for you to pick up on it. All right. Well, what was that? About 45 seconds? Probably a clock later, but you got it. All right. See YouTube, this is all getting cut out. You guys get to see that.