Skip to content
Star Trek X : Nemesis episode artwork

Sep 27, 2022 58 min

Star Trek X : Nemesis

from Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast

It's our final adventure with our intrepid crew of the 1701-D...errr...1701-E. When an explosion blows up the Romulan Senate, the new leader of the Romulans requests an audience with Captain Picard. When Picard meets him, he is surprised to discover that this new leader, Shinzon, is actually a clone of Captain Picard himself, and the clone is bent on the destruction of the Federation. Meanwhile, Data finds a long lost brother of his, B-4. If you're watching with us, the next episode will be the Enterprise season 2 episode, "Cease Fire." Contact the show: email: [email protected] Twitter: @beammeuppod Instagram: @beammeuppod Website: beammeuppod.com Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/beammeuppod) Did You Hear About This? This humorous pop culture podcast discusses the latest retro stories and pop culture news. Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify Support the show

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

It's our final adventure with our intrepid crew of the 1701-D...errr...1701-E. When an explosion blows up the Romulan Senate, the new leader of the Romulans requests an audience with Captain Picard. When Picard meets him, he is surprised to discover that this new leader, Shinzon, is actually a clone of Captain Picard himself, and the clone is bent on the destruction of the Federation. Meanwhile, Data finds a long lost brother of his, B-4. If you're watching wit...

Ready to play

Star Trek X : Nemesis

0:00 58:52

Chapters

  1. 27:48 [Ad] Did You Hear About This?
  2. 28:26 (Cont.) Star Trek X : Nemesis
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

The final frontier begins. This is about saving the future of humanity. This is a huge victory for the good guys. You've never seen Voyager. This course of action is not emotional. Welcome to another episode of Beam Me Up, a Star Trek podcast. I am Brent Allen, and I have seen every movie of Star Trek 47 times. And I'm Matt Sonnenberg, and this is my first time.

watching this movie. And this is the show where we are on a mission to introduce people to the world universe galaxy of Star Trek, whether it's TV show or movie by watching them in air date order, but only doing the most important ones that deal with the lore, the history and the timeless message of Star Trek. And yes, Nemesis is one that is important to the lore, the history and the timeless message of Star Trek. But whether you're part of the Federation. or want to be a part of the Federation or you live in the neutral zone or wherever you happen to live, you should go to BeMeUpPod.com. Click on the YouTube icon in the upper right hand corner. Check us out on YouTube. Over on YouTube, you will find all the behind the scenes stuff that gets cut out of the show before, after, in between our neutral zone, if you will. Today's episode is not an episode. It is the final of our TNG next generation slash Berman era films. And that includes DS9 and Voyager and Enterprise. This is the final one. Those other ones don't get one. We'll talk about that later, I'm sure. This one's titled Star Trek Nemesis or Star Trek 10, or as I like to call it, it's the one where data died.

In case you guys didn't watch this one first or it's been a while in this film, Picard meets his clone who also somehow happens to be a Reman agent who's also somehow taken over the Romulan Senate. Long story short, the dying clone wants to take Picard's lifeblood so that he can live and go on to destroy the Federation because that's what the Romulans do. But in the end, Picard crashes the Enterprise into the Romulan ship because this is a movie and that's what we do to the Enterprise in movies. He goes mano a mano with his clone and wins and Data sacrifices himself in the end to save Picard. Matt, we're getting the recap of everything having to do with this film. You're going to walk us through it. We'll talk about the good stuff. We'll talk about the bad stuff. We'll talk about the Star Trek message, which was very replete throughout this movie.

liked that and never thought about it before I was watching it. But first, before we get into all the things having to do with this movie, just give us your overall kind of opening shots. You've just watched this movie for the very first time. What'd you think overall? I think I enjoyed it. It's we're getting into more modern times. I mean, we're past the year 2000, so not too long. I mean.

Granted, as of this recording, this movie is like 20 years old, which is weird to think. But still, we're getting into modern times. So modern graphics, we got the pacing down. We got a lot of action sequences. We got a lot of, I mean, they can do a lot more with computers now. And so things don't look so janky, but it was good overall. I think I can see maybe one or two spots that, you know, or maybe storylines or questionable things that really hardcore fans might have problems with. I guess maybe I don't know. I enjoyed it. Well, Matt, I got to tell you, a lot of hardcore fans had a lot of problems with this movie. But I'll say this for me personally.

about Brent. This was the first Star Trek movie I ever saw. This was also the first Star Trek movie that I ever saw in theaters. This was about the time, a little bit before this one, but this was around the time I became a Star Trek fan. I was on the other side of the world living in Korea and there was a girl and she really liked Star Trek. 20 years later, the girl is gone, but Star Trek is still very much a part of my life.

Anyway, I remember really liking it when it came out. I didn't have any of the history. I didn't really know these guys that well. I might have seen an episode or two here and there with them, but I remember really enjoying it. I liked it. It was better than I thought that it would be. But I have to tell you, though, Matt, for some reason that I honestly don't get. This movie is often panned in the fandom as one of the worst Trek movies of all time. And even the cast members, some of the cast members really railed against it. We'll talk about that a little bit later, too. I just don't get it. I really don't get it because I like this movie a lot. Even watching it for this particular episode, I was like, this movie is fine. I don't know what people's problem is with it. I mean, I haven't seen all the stars.

trek films but just as far as movies i've watched in general this is far from the bottom of the list so i i don't know exactly what people i mean my my biggest guess and maybe you know if this is a little more along lines or not but like although you said you didn't get why they don't like it necessarily um is if this messes with like what they believe to be canon up until this point or something there is some of that and we'll talk about that particularly as it deals with some of the cameos that came up and even warf and what's going on with him and all that we'll deal with all that i think honestly what it is apparently the the The guy that they brought in to direct this movie, Stuart Baird, I think was his name. The cast did not like working with him. They did not like what he did with this film. Apparently he was calling LaVar Laverne the whole time they were shooting, which is not good. Marina and LaVar both are like, this movie sucked. It didn't suck as bad as Insurrection, but it sucked. And, you know, but Brent Spiner, Brent Spiner was one of the guys that was part of the story writing team. Remember when Leonard Nimoy used to do that back with the original series movies? Like he was part of the team coming up with it. That's Brent Spiner now. And like, this was kind of one of his babies that he brought in. They did not intend for this to be their final film. By the way, they actually very much intended for a fifth film to become their final film.

And they had fleshed it out during the filming of this movie. And the cast was really excited. Like, wow, that actually sounds like a great idea. It's a good send off for the next generation crew. And that'll make way for a DS9 or Voyager Enterprise film or whatever comes next. And it just it didn't come to fruition. In fact, we'll go ahead and talk about it since we're in this vein. This movie didn't do well at the box office either. It actually is the second lowest grossing movie of the films. The first one was Star Trek V, The Final Frontier, which is often considered the worst of the Star Trek movies. This is actually considered the second worst of all of the Star Trek movies. I mean, I just kind of wonder, too, just where we are with Star Trek. You've kind of talked about this a few times. There it is. Yeah.

with you know the fatigue right yep people are just reaching the end of everything and just like yeah another star trek another star trek another star trek and i i mean i think that's got to play a big part in it because i mean i don't know where like the new like 2009 onward star trek films fall in the grand scheme of things but i have to imagine i mean even that is only like seven years away from this bill so yeah yeah i mean it's not that far away but still i mean there is a gap in there at least and like that's you get a break even after enterprise and stuff so i don't know i i there always seems to be a contingent of fans in any franchise that's not going to be, you know, be on board with any particular film or whatever. It's never everybody likes it. But yeah, I guess it surprises me that. And that contingent of fans, especially with the advent of the internet, keep in mind, this is 2002, so the internet is really picking up speed at this point and going. And that contingent of fans tends to be the loudest. Yeah. And I think you're exactly right. You know, this guy, Stuart Baird, apparently he never even watched an episode of TNG before directing this film. Like he thought Geordi was an alien. So not only was he calling the actor Laverne, he thought the character was an alien, which is just weird to me. Yeah, I mean, I get it from the actors.

point of view like it's not like that would not be fun right to to work on that set it would not be fun to work with that director and that type of thing But as far as the finished product, I think it turned out well. I agree. I 100% agree. I think this is far from the worst. I don't even know that it's middle. I think it'd be upper of the middle of the road. Yeah, I think, you know, for me personally, I think First Contact is up there. I think Star Trek 4 is actually up there. You know, I think I really like Star Trek 6. A lot of people put Star Trek 2, Wrath of Khan up there like is the best, the pinnacle. I don't think that it's up there. I think it's kind of right there in the middle. I think this one's right around there. Generations, I thought, was actually fine. A lot of people pay in that movie as well. I did not like Insurrection, personally, the one that came before this. But Matt, I think you hit the nail on the head.

was going on in the Star Trek fandom at this time was not good. And not just because people were chirping, but just the franchise fatigue, you know, enterprise was struggling to find and maintain an audience. It had been four years since the last Star Trek movie. I think people just weren't interested. Also, there were other films out at the box office, like the very next week, one little film you might've heard of called Lord of the Rings, the two towers that contributed to like an 86% drop-off from week one to week two.

Didn't want to blame it on that, but I was wondering what else was in theaters at the time. And yeah, that would totally. Absolutely. Absolutely. So, you know, and then I think what, I think what you get is you get this vocal minority. I think you get a franchise fatigue. People just didn't care to go see the film at this point. Yeah. I mean, next generation has been off the air for almost a decade. It's been four years since we've seen the last film. Like, do I really care about the next generation at this point? And then all these other movies are happening and stuff like that. I think people, it was just, it was not a good time for this film to come out, but I agree with you. I think the final product as a film is much better, but you compound that with the cast being vocal about not liking it. And then you turn into this thing. We've explored this in the show.

a bit the sort of group think that star trek fans do like you hold this episode up like city on the edge of forever is the best episode ever made man no it's not you're like yeah duets the best episode of ds9 ever and and well yes i would actually fully agree with that that is an episode that needs i think some seasoning and i think if you were to go back and watch that episode specifically now having the knowledge that you have of deep space nine and you watch that episode a couple more times and you see the depths to which nanon visitor and harvey something or other i think was his name the other guy playing the the other senator the romulan dude or i'm sorry the card scene, dude. Like it's a fantastic episode. Is it the best? No, it's really close though. I think it's top 10 for sure. But, uh, that one I think requires a bit more seasoning. This might be a film that maybe even required a little bit more seasoning and people just.

group thunk it. They said it was bad, so now it's bad. That's my guess. I could be wrong. Maybe I'm just weird, and you and I are weird together. That's why we're friends. So that's where this episode, or not this episode, that's where this movie really is. Matt, before we go on, I don't want to get too much further into this. I've got some character actor spotlights to do. It's been a while since we've had to do one of these for TNG, but let's go into it. The entire Next Generation cast is back, and that includes people like Worf, who's supposed to be an ambassador to Kronos, dealing with General Martok. We'll talk about that in a few minutes. Sure. We have cameos by people like Will Wheaton as Wesley the Traveler, or is he Wesley the Traveler? Let's talk about that in just a few moments. Did you notice, Wesley? Please tell me you noticed, Wesley. Was he just sitting at the

Yeah. During the one meeting. During the early part of the, during the wedding, he was there at the wedding. Yeah. That was Wesley. Yeah. Like, I don't think he even has a speaking part. He did it. He did. And they filmed it, but it got cut from the film. It's in the deleted scenes, Matt. But yeah, I mean, like, how do you bring him back and then just like drop him? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So, I mean, shut up, Wesley, I guess. I don't know. Like.

We'll talk about that. He told data to shut up. Yeah, yeah. Well, actually, you want to find out why we just talk about it while we're talking about Wil Wheaton. So Wil Wheaton, like I said, did have some lines in the script and they were eventually cut from the final movie on. It can actually be seen on the deleted scenes of the two desk special collector's edition DVD, something like that. But in that, when he got invited to come back and he was like, yes, I will go back. Absolutely. Because Wil Wheaton loves his next generation cast. He asked the writer, his guy's name is John Logan. He said, so why am I here? What's going on with Wesley? Is he still a traveler? Did he quit traveling and rejoin Starfleet? Is he because like he's in dress uniforms? He's in Starfleet dress uniform.

right yeah he's like what like why why is Wesley here and uh John basically is like I didn't really have time to figure it out uh for the movie and it honestly doesn't matter because of the rest of the film so we'll just leave it up to the audience to decide Now, that being said, in one of those deleted scenes, I mentioned that they did film. Apparently, there was a piece of script that was written that actually acknowledged that Wes had returned to Starfleet and he was going to serve aboard the Titan with Riker. And that's what he was doing there. And that would explain why he was in a Starfleet dress uniform. Now, as that scene was cut from the film, that means that that's not necessarily what happened, canonically speaking, which leaves open. He could still be a traveler or he could have returned to Starfleet, whichever may or may not come to pass. We may ever find out about it or not. I'm not going to tell you. You'll just have to wonder as you continue. I'm going to leave that as a tantalizing thing. Like, I'm gonna let you go watch it all and see if you can't find him. But the cool thing about him being a traveler that I really like this with all the news.

Star Trek that's out there, he could show up at any one of them, whether they're prequel, post-school, set in the future, set in the past, set in this era. Wesley could show up at any time. I'm not telling you if he does or not. Anyway, I will say this, though. I thought this was really funny. A novel, which is not canon, but still, a novel actually had a different explanation for why Wesley was there and in Starfleet dress unis. In this novel, Wesley had appeared as a traveler, but he appeared naked because he thought that this was the Betazoid ceremony. And so Picard had beamed down some clothes from the Enterprise form, and that's why he was in the Starfleet dress uniform.

So anyway, that's Wil Wheaton. Wil Wheaton was definitely there. The return of your favorite character in all of Starfleet, Star Trek. Star Trek, let's say that. Joining Will was Whoopi Goldberg as Guinan. Now, she did get a few lines in the film. We also saw Kate Mulgrew as the now Admiral Janeway. Yeah. Which, I mean, Matt, if you spend seven years, if you spend seven years as a captain in the Delta Quadrant, you got your crew home, guess what? You're getting a promotion. So, I mean, I get that, but it just feels weird to me that she went out and did her thing in the Delta Quadrant, came back, gets promoted to Admiral, and then we have Picard, who, correct me if I'm wrong, but was doing his thing before Janeway. Oh, sure. Is still out on the Enterprise doing his thing. Oh, sure. There's a reason for that, though. But, Matt, there's an in-universe reason for that. You remember the movie Generation?

when Picard met Captain Kirk. What did Captain, and I don't know if you remember this from the movies, the TOS movies, they promoted Kirk to Admiral and he hated it. Yeah. And he did whatever he could to get back in the chair. And he told Picard, don't ever let them take you out of that chair. Okay. Stay, don't get out of that chair. Stay in this chair. Like you don't have to take the promotion, but you don't have to keep going on missions either. Well, you know, but that's Picard though. Picard's gonna go do that kind of stuff. So, you know, but I mean, it makes for a better show. I've had a, you know, I have a harder time believing that Will Riker was the first officer for 15 years.

You know, and I get it. His idea, the idea was he was supposed to be holding out for Picard to go away so he could take over the Enterprise. But and eventually he just gave up the ghost on that one and went into the Titan, which, by the way, Riker going to be the captain of the Titan is a canonization of something that happened in the novels. That was that was this is an example of the filmmakers or the showmakers reading the book saying, that's cool. Let's make that canon because a lot of love on the on the butch call.

Now it makes a lot more sense to me in Lower Decks. It's like right around the Titan. That's right. That's right. You've been watching Lower Decks. That's right. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. You told me I could. So I did. Absolutely. Absolutely. It's like, oh, so this is where they get it from or where he gets promoted. Right. And that's why. And, you know, again, this is why Deanna is with him because they're now married, you know, and there you go. Now, interesting note, they did ask Jerry Ryan to come do a cameo of seven of nine to be at the wedding, but she refused. She's like seven. Didn't know these folks. Why would she be at their wedding?

No. Also, she apparently like she had like this was separated from Voyager by like just a year or two. And she just wanted more separation from Star Trek at that particular point in her life. So she declined. They also proposed in the wedding that they could have had a Gorn ambassador, but they couldn't do that because of the cost and trying to design what a Gorn would actually look like on film in 2002 as opposed to 1967 on TV. They also wanted to have a Tholian ambassador as a guest to the wedding. Now, do you remember the Tholians?

Do you really think I remember them? No, you don't. They were the they looked like the bounty hunters from Star Wars that Princess Leia dressed up at the end of Deep Space Nine. Those guys. They wanted one of those guys in the wedding, but they didn't have that either. Anyway, so those are some cameos. One more cameo I want to talk to you about. A guest tactical officer on the Enterprise was none other than one Bryan Singer. Now, Matt, who is Bryan Singer? I know the name. I cannot tell you why. And his connection. He was the director of the X-Men films of which Patrick Stewart played Professor X. So obviously there's this connection. He came in. And so Bryan Singer is a guest tactical officer for a scene. Let's get to our big guys, though, the guys we really need.

talk about. Where do we go first? Let's go with the Viceroy. Shinzon's Viceroy, who was in full heavy makeup. You wouldn't have known it was him unless you recognized the voice. And you probably didn't even recognize the voice. But the Viceroy was played by Ron Perlman. Now, Ron Perlman is a name that I really shouldn't have to mention. That explains the really deep voice. I kept seeing him and hearing him. And it's like, I almost wondered, is someone doing a voiceover for that guy? Right. But no, Ron Perlman, sure. Yep, that's it. Yep, Ron Perlman is there. Now, for those of you, if you don't know who he is, he played the role of the Beast, Vincent the Beast, in the 1980s live action TV show, Beauty and the Beast. He was also Clay from Sons of Anarchy, and he was Hellboy.

in both of the Hellboy films. We also saw Matt as a bartending American house elf in the Fantastic Beasts franchise. And he's been a voiceover artist for tons and tons and tons of animated shows, many of which we have probably seen. So that's Ron Perlman. All right, let's get to the biggest name here, the biggest guest star of this film, although he was not a big guest star back then. The Picard clone Shinzon is played by Tom Hardy. Matt, did you recognize him? I did not. That is Tom Hardy. This is early, early, early Tom Hardy. In fact, this is only his third role in a feature film. Now, I'm not going to explain too much about Tom Hardy because his reputation precedes him during this podcast. But let's talk about how he came to the role because I actually find the story a little interesting.

especially because it was so early in his career and nobody really knew who he was back then. Remember, this movie released in 2002, which means it was filmed through, you know, 2001 into early parts of 2002. In the year 2000, he left his drama school and accepted a role in the HBO miniseries Band of Brothers. Great miniseries. If you guys haven't watched it, go watch it. It's absolutely very good. Still holds up today. After that, he was in another military style film called Black Hawk Down. Now, have you ever seen Black Hawk Down? Honestly, I don't.

think I've actually seen the whole thing. Like I was a little too young when it first came out and I don't think I ever made my way back to it. So side note, as far as I know, and I don't have confirmation of this, but as far as I know, my stepbrother was actually a part of the events in real life. of what happened in Black Hawk Down. Okay. Now, the only the only reason why I really believe that is because I know for a fact that my stepbrother was in that area when those events took place. I also know that he refuses to watch the movie and he just says he can't not because he like thinks it's bad or whatever. Like he can't. He cannot bring himself to talk about it. Also, he won't tell me what happened. Like he just can't talk about it. Like and I.

get the feeling that that's partly because certain things are classified, but other just because of whatever he experienced while he was there. So again, I'm fully, I'm just sort of saying, I think this is what happened. I don't know. In my head canon of my own family's life, my brother was perhaps even depicted in that film or somehow in the middle of all that. I don't know. Anyway.

While they were filming Black Hawk Down, they were casting for Star Trek Nemesis and Tom Hardy got wind of it and he created an audition tape because remember, he's off filming this thing at the time. He created an audition tape and he sent it in. And this audition tape, according to the casting directors, was very quote unquote bizarre. And it also somehow included some home video of him dancing around in his underwear. OK, but whatever. It caught the eye of the casting directors enough and it included and it caught the eye of Rick Berman that they were interested. They brought him in. They did several screen tests. You know, it wasn't just a hey, offer him the role like they they kept coming back to him and he eventually won the role and he won the role over other people like James Marsters of Buffy and Angel fame. He would have been good in that role. I think Marina Sirtis actually said he was the guy she wanted to have in that role. She thought he would have been far better. Yeah. You know, yeah, I I'm actually kind of a fan of James Marsters. Yeah. And then a guy that I'm personally a fan of Michael Shanks of Stargate SG one fame, which will be the podcast we do when this one's over.

Anyway, that is Tom Hardy, who is playing our guy Shinzon with a shaved head as a young Captain Picard clone. One other thing I want to talk about as we're talking about this and we're talking about character development stuff, Worf. I want to talk about Worf just for a second. If you remember, Matt, we last left Worf as going to be an ambassador for Kronos, for the Federation to Kronos, dealing with Martok. Remember that at the end of Deep Space Nine, just as we record this several weeks ago, several months ago, actually. But, you know, in real world time, been a couple of years. Did it occur to you at all? Like, what's Worf doing here? Because shouldn't he be doing that? Like, I'm just curious. Did you did that thought cross your mind at all? Didn't question anything. I just assume we're.

in a different timeline or not even a different timeline, but just somewhere else in the timeline. Like, even though this movie came out where we're watching it, I didn't necessarily assume that like this movie takes place in line with what we were just watching. Yeah. Well, this movie makes sense. Yeah. This movie is post Dominion war. It is post. Well, I mean, I got that after I watched it. I mean, they referenced the Dominion war. Janeway was there as an admiral. I'm like, so has to be after Voyager, obviously. Like I put some of those pieces together as I watched it, but I'm not going to question that at the get go. And frankly, for the longest time, this was the thing that was furthest in the timeline that we'd ever gotten for almost 20 years. Like this was it. We're like, what?

happens after nemesis yeah yeah we got one little one little blurb of something that happened after nemesis in in something else and we'll talk about that when we get there but really this was it and and for me personally as a fan when we start talking about new trek and the stuff here i'm far less interested in prequels and things that came before as i am i want to know what happens next you know and thankfully that's being explored in some of the new trek series anyway what's going on with warf this was something that people asked this is something that caught my attention i went not when i first watched it because i didn't know but as a person later uh so just just to throw it out there again they did write a backstory because this was a conversation they had like with berman and the writers and stuff like okay well how does warf actually wind up back on the enterprise and while it was never put into the screen or why it was never filmed, they did have it written. And it actually was kind of twofold. And here's the deal. The idea was that from, well, first of all, there was a line in the script that got cut out where it was a conversation between Worf and Beverly, where Beverly says, I'm glad you made it. I didn't think you're going to make it. So the idea is Worf just barely got there. Right. And his response to her was diplomatic life was not something he was cut out for. Which I could totally understand. Totally understand. But this is still a few years later. Now, a novel further explains that there is a custom.

for ambassadors to resign every time a new president is inaugurated. It's almost a courtesy of allowing the president to put in their own ambassadors to various times. So where Worf was serving under a former president at the request of the Klingon government, he didn't like it, but he maintained that role. And when he had an opportunity to get out, he took it and he went back to Starfleet, which is what he does. And like Wesley, he was actually supposed to be joining Will and Deanna over on the Titan. However, the novel also goes on to further explain that after Data dies, Picard actually asks him to remain on board the Enterprise and Worf remains on board the Enterprise. Fast forward several years later to another novel where Picard leaves the Enterprise to go do something.

else that is further explored in a whole different series. And Worf is the one who's left in command of the Enterprise so many years later. Okay. Now that's all novels, so it could be something else altogether. Who knows? We'll see. But anyway, that's kind of a lot of the backstory on what's going on and where people are and questions you apparently didn't even think to ask. So with that, Matt, I will turn the rest of this over to you. You watch this episode for the first time, take us through an episode. No, it's a movie. What are the things that stood out to you? What'd you like? What didn't you like? What questions you have? What Star Trek messages do you think you pulled out of this? And what are going to be some of the ramifications you think of this film?

So random question that probably has no actual reason for me to be wondering about it. But, um, there was one line in there that I caught. I think they were explaining how, uh, Picard always gets the best quote unquote assignments. And like, they're like, yeah, the, so now the board and the Romulans. Yeah. I don't recognize that first one. We'll be right back. It's over, Jenny.

Oh, wow, man. Hey, if you recognize those sounds, then you're probably somebody who would like our show. We are called Did You Hear About This? And we talk about all kinds of news stories. It's like the 80s and 90s stuff that we grew up on. Yeah, this isn't stuff that's getting covered on the 10 o'clock news. I'll tell you that. You can check us out at didyouhearaboutthis.show. We're on every single podcast platform. Go find us.

The Sonar were the bad guys of the last movie. The four that they, and they also said Dr. Sorin. He also said Dr. Sorin, which those four people are the villains of the four TNG films. Okay. Dr. Sorin from Generations, the board from First Contact, the Sonar from Insurrection, and now the Romulans from Nemesis. So it is something I haven't seen and it was a very specific reference. Exactly. Yes. Okay. I feel better about that one then. I'm doing that thing where I read through my notes after watching the whole thing and I have like a dozen questions written down for you. Right. And 99% of them were answered later in the film. So I no longer have those questions for you. Fair enough. But I will.

ask you this one because i i want to say i've heard this exchange before but i've never asked asked about it imzadi yep is that a name is that a term of endearment is that what is that because yeah i mean like it didn't feel out of place when you know reicher was saying it to deanna right is it always those two and What is it or what does it mean? This was actually something that we saw all the way back in the pilot episode of Next Generation. Okay. And it is a term of endearment. It's a Beta Zed term of endearment. Okay. Imzadi. And it is something that Will always called Deanna. Yeah. It didn't sound foreign. It's like I had heard it before, but like I said, I just never actually questioned it. Yeah. Yeah. Imzadi. It is something you have heard. Like I wanted to make sure, like, because the first time it was used, just Will to Deanna, I wasn't going to question it. But then when like Shinzen or the Viceroy, I was never quite sure who was actually doing this, but got in her head. Yeah. And like said.

it again and i'm like well okay maybe that's just will saying it again and she's hearing it with a different face on like that scene in general was very confusing to tell exactly what was going on and like if they're gonna cut anything honestly i think they could have cut that and like i know they kind of used it towards the end of the film to remittle the film to figure out like where the ship was like she used that connection again and i'm like they could have written around that like i i don't know that you know what that's where they should have brought will back and and like he he would have been able to find that ship that's what should have happened So for whatever it is worth, just a quick search, because I was just kind of curious, a quick search. It appears that the word was used in 10 different episodes of Next Generation. It could be more. That's just my search that immediately pops that number up. So it's something that we heard quite often. For reference, we only saw Q in nine episodes of Next Generation and think how big Q felt as a presence throughout Next Generation. We heard this 10 times throughout the course of the series. So it certainly is a well ingrained word. Yeah. What is it with sci-fi and having like desert raiders?

whether they're sand people right yeah or jawas or whatever these guys were here in this film yeah like like yeah we're gonna go down on this planet and oh these things are a little too quiet and then they come over the sand dunes and then you get back to your ship and they're all trying to pick apart your ship i'm like i mean talk about stereotypes yeah and that they had the weird filter on it that made it look all weird there and all that sort of stuff yeah it was fun it's one of those things that i sat back and i went they had the budget to do this and brought out the dune buggy and all that kind of stuff exactly like it was that in picard's uh, contract. He like, I'll do this, but I want to drive fast or I want to like, I just don't know. Like once again, I feel like didn't actually need that. Right. And that, that, that was early enough that I kind of forgot about it by the end of the film and didn't even think about, yeah, you didn't need that scene. Just going back to my notes now. I'm like, he made such a big deal out of, I want to try out the Argo. Okay, sure. Now, just to be clear, the Argo was not the dune buggy. The dune buggy was a shuttle. It was the shuttle. Yeah. And it was like, I saw that printed on the sign.

But like, I think when, when like Riker mentioned or whatever, like you want to try out the Argo, like that had to be what he was referencing. What was the dune buggy? Oh yeah, absolutely. I think that that was, that's, I always assumed that it was the dune buggy until I realized that it wasn't, it was actually the shuttle craft. When he said, but there was nothing special about the shuttle craft itself. As far as we, as well, as far as we talked about, like maybe like the remote control. I don't know. Yeah. It has some cool new design pieces to it. The nacelles moved and folded and different things like that. But yeah, but, but the dune buggy was a part of it. So I just, I, I capture the whole thing as, as one deal. But I'll tell you, if you're interested, Matt, you can actually purchase your very own.

little miniature Argo from... I'm not surprised. They are part of the Ship of the Lion. You know what? I, the one I actually wondered about is, is there a model of the enterprise sunk halfway into the scimitar? Like that needs to be a model. No, but it should be now. Like, yeah, that's what I'm saying. So I get these ads all the time, usually around Christmas time for, uh, Oh, what is it? The Hoth, the Bradbury collection or the Bradshaw collection. I don't know. One of these like collections and it's usually Harry Potter stuff and it's like Harry and Voldemort fighting. And it's like a sculpture from the film, you know, and it looks very well done. I would never put this up in my house. Like, you know, but it looks very cool. Um, they're, they also made like the Christmas.

villages and stuff. That would be, that would be a situation I would see that in, but those usually are very expensive. I'm sure it would be. It would need to be pretty big to get both ships in there. Right. And with any amount of detail. Right. But like, I think I've seen them just for Star Trek purposes, because it's a Star Trek show. I think I've seen them, the scene where Spock is dying at the end of Wrath of Khan and him and Kirk are like talking through the glass and they're, you know, they both got their hands up. I think I've seen that one as a statue several times, but yeah, the two ships buried into each other. That'd be kind of neat. But to finish off with movie, Matt, right? So who wants to finish off with the dune buggy piece though? Like.

Just the fact that it existed was a bit gratuitous. But when they remote control the shuttle to catch it. Right. And I saw it coming from a mile away. I'm like, they're going to jump the thing. Why? There's zero reason they should have had to jump that. Park that shuttle at the edge of the cliff and drive in. There was zero reason they need to actually jump. But it looks cool. Yeah. Is this Dukes of Hazzard? Come on. We got a budget. It looks cool. Yeah. Go give me more space battles. I don't need.

dune buggy jumping so from here i'm just kind of jumping around a little bit but i like how the mental battle played out between the card and shinson like i i always comment when there's a good bad guy and it always feels like they're one step ahead and the cards one step ahead or our captain of whoever it is whatever show we're watching but like they're always like one step ahead and you think oh no no they're one step ahead not their one step ahead and you never know i mean you can usually figure out the good guys are gonna win in the end but sure um it's interesting to see how they they play against each other and i didn't realize it early on but they were doing this the whole film. I mean, right from the beginning when they collected B4, right? Because that was the first step. That was the trap that they set for Picard, right? Because they needed him to pick up the Android. They needed it to be on board Enterprise. I think, theoretically, we're planning on, which I still think was the dumbest idea, hooking him up to data and giving him his abilities. I mean, ultimately kind of made a backup for him because now he dies and now we have a backup data. Do we? I mean, not entirely yet.

they gave us hope for it but um the point being like as soon as they they showed data hooked up to the to before i'm like this is not going to turn out well but that's me playing into their hands again and saying like oh now it looks like the bad guys are gonna be ahead but it turns out the card and jordy figure the thing out and they deactivate before and data stands in and gets taken aboard and that type of thing so i'm a little curious though why did they beam data over to their ship Why does who beamed it over? Well, yeah. Who did? Wasn't it Shenzhen technically? Right. Which part of the movie are you talking about right now? When they, he like appears on their bridge and they download the data. Right. Right. That is data. Not that they think it's before, but that's data. Yes. Right. They think it's before, but as technologically advanced as they are, they can't tell the difference. Like as soon as I found out, like it took a long time, honestly, for it to click with me that.

that was originally data back there already for a while. I thought both of them were on board the ship. Like after he saves the card and stuff and like, wait, so there's, they're both over here. How'd you get over? Like, yeah, I, I, I was a little confused, but then it's like, oh no, it was always data. Got it. Yeah. But now I'm questioning why did they, they had to know it was data. I mean, I mean, I'm sure that's one of those things that could easily be fixed with a single line of dialogue of your mask, your neural pathway. You're, you're, because he says it later, right. They're identical except for data's neural pathways are more advanced than before. Like, so you mask your neural pathways or Jory, you know, Jory gave him the extra port and, you know, gave off of,

set up a false b4 signature to exude from data like it's something like that they could explain it away yeah i'll give you that sure and i guess the other thing is if they're not looking for it like they wouldn't see it you know like if they really scanned the android they'd be like wait this isn't before well yeah i mean but if they weren't looking for it if they thought they had theoretically they were planning that there were two androids on that ship and so if they do their quick scan it's like oh there's an android wouldn't they be like Where's the other one? Or how do we tell them apart? Well, I mean, that's where I would assume that they had some sort of tracking device inside of B4 that, again, off screen, Geordian data had to have found when they discovered what B4 really was. And they just put all that over into data. Jumping topics. I like when sci-fi gives us random things that at least don't make sense in my brain because that's not how things work here. But it's interesting to think about what would happen if this did exist somewhere. In this case, I'm talking about Remus, the planet, right?

that circles around the sun, but does not rotate itself. And therefore one side is always facing the sun. Like that's an interesting. thought like now now i'm wondering like are there actually planets out there that do that that they know about i mean i don't think in our solar system i'm pretty sure all the planets rotate right as far as we know um i'm i'm not familiar enough with astrology or astronomy i guess actually would be to know what rotates and what doesn't out there but you would assume i would assume the rotate a revolutionary movement around the sun produces a rotational spin on an axis i was gonna say i thought i'm pretty sure it's something to do with physics and you know gravity and stuff and the spinning it just all kind of goes together and so like now part of me wonders like what explanation could you give as to why like i i was all for it but like if someone had to give me an explanation as to why that planet does not rotate but still like i said i enjoy them giving us kind of oddball what ifs like i know this the moon doesn't rotate when you look up to see the moon you are always seeing the exact same side of the moon it does not rotate as it spins around our earth we like you and i have never seen the other side of the moon ever so the dark side of the moon is always the dark side of the moon right what you're saying interesting

Now, part of me kind of wants to know why that is. Right. So maybe it's not that far fetched. Yeah. And I mean, so Remus was supposed to be a Romulan moon, right? Or just a smaller planet in the Romulan system. I forget which it was, but regardless. I don't recall, but yeah. Yeah. But their point was, yeah, half of it always faces the sun and half is always in the dark. And that's why they explained to us, like, the Remus don't like the light. They're in the dark. They're in the mines. Yeah. Remus is the inhabited third planet of the Romulan star system. So when Picard and the away team, which I'm sorry, but that away team was huge. Yeah. I was really confused. Like, he's like, all right, let's go. And like that pre-planned. So like.

It felt like the entire bridge crew left. I'm like, wait, who's in charge of the ship now? Like, I think everybody, every named character I knew left the bridge. Like, I guess maybe like Jordy was still on board or something, but I don't know. Could he take control? I don't know. But in any case, they went down.

And they get their first look at Shinsen. And Picard the entire time, like at least after he steps into the kind of light, like he just stares at him real funny. And I mean, it kind of makes sense now because it felt like he knew him. He had seen him before. And I was waiting for something like, oh, this was in a movie I haven't seen or an episode I haven't seen before. It's like, he's back. But no, it's like, oh, you look familiar. And they get into this syndrome that he has. Is this new information or has this been discussed before? Like when they drop the name of that syndrome, would the audience have known, you know?

Captain Picard has been revealed to have so many various syndromes in his life. Okay. Frankly, I have trouble remembering what he has and what he doesn't and when's the first time we hear about something and when not. You know, because if you remember, there was the episode Tapestry where he has a fake heart and we kind of see how he got the fake heart. There's another episode earlier where Picard has a particular syndrome and it was cured when he was a kid. That might have been this one. I don't remember. There's another syndrome that he's revealed to have later in the series, Picard, that I don't recall we've ever heard of. It's like, oh, yeah, okay. He has another syndrome. Very good. It's really just a thing that they do. I think it's just a thing they do.

character moment was this particular one one that he had i maybe i don't know but because that that to me felt like the first thing other than picard looking at him funny that felt like the first thing that they dropped like oh hardcore fans are going to realize what's going on here now i'm like okay i'm not quite there yet but i i mean when he gets into like we are one and like that's still kind of weird man like even for a clone to say right like that's kind of weird right uh again a quick google search as you're talking this is the first mention of shalaf syndrome yeah yeah plot point that's it Yeah. But to what you're saying there about him saying, we are one, we are one. I think what you're starting to get into though, Matt, is this scene combined with a couple of other scenes throughout the film that really pulls us into the Star Trek message of the film. Like outside of the action that happens of Picard and there's a clone and the clone wants his blood and the clone is.

going to go destroy the Federation because he's still pissed and he's not really human. He's a Riemann, he says. And blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. All of this stuff, Data sacrifices himself. Like, this is the Star Trek. This is the core of Star Trek. Is this part right here? We are one, he says. And Picard's dealing with that later, you know? And he says, if you were in my shoes, this is what you would have done. And how do we know? Because I am you. And that kind of rattles Picard, you know? That rattles him. And he's very much lamenting over it. And he kind of believes it. Like, he takes it at face value that, man, maybe I'm not as awesome as I thought because I would be doing this. And you kind of got to feel for him because he's been in a bad situation. And let's make no mistakes. Shinzon has been in a bad situation. He didn't ask for any of the stuff

Um, you know, but it was, it was when all of a sudden Picard's talking to Dumbledore, I'm sorry. I mean, data and data argues that it's not the genetic makeup that determines who you are as a person, but it's your experiences and your choices. I mean, this is the age old nature versus nurture, right? Yeah, exactly. And I mean, we, we, I've seen the, I mean, not necessarily the experiments done, but just like twins separated at birth and it's like, well, how'd they turn out? I mean, yeah, they can definitely be very different, even though they're genetically identical. And I mean, that's kind of what it is here. And so, I mean, I, I really liked when we got to it at the end.

And Shinsen's like, it's too late. Picard's like, never, never. You still have a choice. Make the right one now. And to me, like that was a huge message to me. It was like, it's never too late to make that change. Now I will admit in today's age, like sometimes that's really tough because society and the people around you aren't always willing to let you make that change. Like they just have it ingrained in their mind. You did this bad thing. You're always a bad person now.

But in reality, like Picard's saying here, you still have a choice to make the right one now. It's never too late to change. You were in a bad position. You could be in a better one now. Let's make this right. Start down a different path. To even that point there, Data uses himself and B4 as an example. He says they're physically identical, but it's their experiences that make them completely unique individuals. And he goes on to say that the fundamental difference between Picard and Shinzon, and even between himself and B4, is the desire to become better. Neither B4 or Shinzon have a desire to be better. Picard has a desire to be better, to become more than who he is. And Picard...

later says that he's trying to reason with shins on who just won't hear it says that you have the potential to make yourself more than you are that's what it means to be human when we as people have the potential to be better than we are that's what makes us that's what makes humanity great for all the crap of humanity we have the ability to be better the possibility of being better you just have to pick it you got to seek after you got to desire it you got to move with it in the midst of all the pew pew pew matt that's what i pulled from this particular film yes every so often we get into a battle scene and i see something that i've never really seen before i'm like why don't they do that more often i know most recently i can remember like they transported a bomb directly into the other ship by the war corps or whatever and blew it up. You should do that more often. This time, they blew out the front window on the bridge. I mean, they were pretty quick to react and get a force field up there. But it did two things. One, they did lose some people at the front. It caused a lot of chaos and a lot of injuries. But it also...

blew up their screen, their view screen. Right. And I mean, every ship might not be like that, but if I'm a bad guy and I know that how Federation ships are built, like I'm aiming for that a whole lot more often. Like blow, blow, blow up that. Who cares about the, the, the engines and the warp core and the weapons, like just.

blow a hole into the bridge and i mean if you want then then fire another shot in there kill the entire bridge they're all mostly shown with what appears to be a glass dome on top yeah that you can you know you can presumably look out and see the stars right above you which i'm sure is real pretty as you're working on the bridge but you know and that that the view screen is actually kind of supposed to be like a window i guess if you turn it off or something like that i don't know um yeah yeah yeah i saw that i'm like that was kind of cool i mean i'm glad nobody we knew died there but um Forget all the people we don't know. I'm just glad the people we knew. I know that sounded bad, but I couldn't say nobody died because somebody got sucked out the window. Let's just assume that Chief O'Brien was back in the transporter room and he caught him and transported him back. There you go. Let's just assume that. There you go. Because if Worf can be back, dang it, so can Chief O'Brien. Just hopefully he left Keiko at home. It's harsh. A little bit. So then the other kind of gratuitous thing, I thought, although it was quick thinking on Data's part, and part of me wondered if this is why they put the jump in the beginning of the film with the dune buggy was at the end of the film.

when Data decides to jump from ship to ship. It's like you lined them up. I was like, here we go. That's the only reason I could think it was just kind of bookending with the jumps there. I like that as a storytelling device. Sure. Set us up for it. Pay it off in the end. Once again, of course, Data's the only one that can do that, right? Then it felt like the emergency transporter, the mobile, the little device that Data had, was that a new piece of tech? The way they introduced it, it felt like it.

It might have been. I know that I've I have seen and heard of personal transporters before in Star Trek, and I just don't remember where all I've heard about them. Sure. So I don't want to I don't want to confuse things that happen later for something that would have happened earlier. Oh, no, we've seen that before. I don't know. You know, would you agree, though, in this like at the beginning of the film? It's like, hey, here's Data's arm. I have this emergency thing that Geordi gave me. I think he said it.

Then it's like, okay, we're not going to use it now. It comes back. It was almost like a cue moment from James Bond, right? It's like, all right, here's your new tech for the movie. You're going to use all of it once throughout the film. So we get to the end of the film. We haven't used something yet.

We know how you're going to get out of this jam. I'm just saying, why is Data the only one who has one? It didn't look like that big of a piece of technology. Like that's something that easily could be sewn into any piece of clothing or into a combat. That's what makes me think, though, that it's kind of like brand new. It's like this is almost a prototype, I guess. Like they only have one at this point. Yeah, I guess. Because, yeah, otherwise, why wouldn't he have to one for himself and one for whoever he's saving? Or why wouldn't everybody in Starfleet just have one? Oh, yeah. Eventually, everyone should have one. Absolutely. Yeah. I don't know what else you really want to talk about, but I think we hit the major point. We did. I think.

the major thing is data dies. Yeah. At the end, like for, for everything that happened, the thing that's going to have repercussions going forward, I guess you will Indiana leave and get married and go off somewhere else, but also data, data not only dies, he sacrifices himself for Picard and the crew was really broken up over it. Like in rightly so, like, you know, for as much as we've talked about ever since really season one is data, a person is what is data? Like they're going to miss him. And he was, he was their friend. They considered him fully an individual. Oh yeah. I mean, I think as much as like Picard was broken up about it, I think it really,

hit home the most when Riker comes back after having his battle on the ship and he didn't see the explosion. He didn't see data leave or anything. He comes back on. It's like, Hey guys, how's it going? And Deanna just walks up to him and is like, it's data. But like, that's all she has to say. And like, like you just feel it in that moment. Yeah. Yeah. It is a, uh, a sure thing. Now behind the scenes, Brent Spiner, remember he had a hand in creating this particular story and he also had a hand in creating the next story as well. Um, he wanted data to die at the end of this film because remember data is an Android. He's not supposed to age. And Brent Spiner felt he was getting too old to continue to play data. And, and, you know, obviously he doesn't want to recast it or anything like that. And he,

he wanted data to die. And, you know, sure. Yeah. And I, you know, I mean, I can imagine like as an actor, like, do you want your character, if you know that you need to finish playing the character, the character would be served. You want him to go out, you know, we're just going to write you out of the show and send you somewhere else. Or do you want to die? Do you want like a good death? Like this was a good, you know? Yes, Worf.

Today is a good day to die. That would have been great. That's what I felt was missing. Once Data got over to the other ship, he didn't say anything. I felt we needed some kind of farewell from him. Some kind of last words. And even if no one was there to hear it, giving us a very monotone...

Data-esque, today is a good day to die. Just because, you know, mimicking things he heard from his friends. Sure. Like, that would have been fantastic. And I mean, and you set that up earlier in the film with Data and Worf having a conversation and somehow that gets said. You know what I mean? Like, you just, because Data and Worf are also friends. Yeah. We got a weird line from Worf halfway through. It's like, at least the Romulan spot with honor when they're fighting the Remans. It's like.

Yeah. It's yeah. Data dies. Data dies. Data dies. Also, I just want to point out the song he sings at the beginning of the episode. He sings blue skies. Yeah. Nothing but blue skies. Do you remember me telling you that Brent Spiner actually released an album like a crew album called Old Yellow Eyes? Kind of a nod to all of that. All right, Matt, that's really it. So let's boil it down. Let me ask you a question. I didn't have anything else really.

Oh, oh, just a couple of things. Do you remember Riker saying at the end, he was like, you know, the first time I met Data, I remember he was trying to sing a tune and he just couldn't get it right. Yep. We saw that in Encounter at Farpoint. Do you remember what that song was? Nope. Pop Goes the Weasel. It wasn't anything. He was doing Blue Skies in this one. Couldn't get the tune right for Pop Goes the Weasel all those years ago. The other one, just to point this out, now that you have been watching Enterprise just a little bit, did you happen to notice that in the Battlefleet group, one of the other ships was named the USS Archer? Yeah, I saw a few of those pop up on screen from time to time and I can never read them all. Yeah, USS Archer. Little nod there to that.

whole thing. All right. That's all that I had for this one, Matt. Let's boil it down. Did you like the movie? Would you want to watch it again? And do you understand why it's part of our run? Yes. I think I'd watch it again. And I mean.

Data dies. Can you really miss that? Can I explain it in 30 seconds? Yeah. Should I? I suppose you could. No. You know, but I mean, it's this is the end of the next generation cast. Yeah. I know that you know that there is an upcoming series called Picard. Picard is not the next generation part two. Like, in fact, when they announced it, Picard took the cast out to dinner and he told them this is not the next generation part two. You guys are not going to be in this show. Please don't be mad. Yeah. You know, he told them that. And so so this is really the end of the TNG era and where we leave it. And there is that nice little bit of hope, as you say, where we see before trying to sing blue skies at the end. And maybe.

those neural pathways will latch on and will overwrite something inside of B4. you know, physically those neural pathways are very, very different. So, you know, will we ever come back and revisit that? I'm not going to tell you. But anyway, with that, Matt, I'm actually really glad you like this movie. And just understand that when you go to the fan conventions and people go, oh, nemesis, just smile and nod and tell them you liked it. Fair enough. Would you like to know what we're watching next week, Matt? That would be useful. Well, we're back to Enterprise and we're going to be skipping quite a bit now. I've said to you, we're really following the storyline of the founding of the Federation and those sorts of things. So we're going all the way to the middle of season two, Matt. Middle of season two, we're watching an episode called Ceasefire. And I gave you all the extra viewings last week. So I don't have any extra viewings for you for this week.

But for this week, that will do it for us right here on Beam Me Up, a Star Trek podcast. Hey, folks, do you secretly like Nemesis? Do you agree with Matt and I that it's a good movie? Or do you think we're absolutely totally off base and you're just like, I can't believe you like that movie. Write it and let us know. We'd love to see it. We'd love to read about it. We might even send an email back. We might even read it on a future episode here at Beam Me Up. You can do that by emailing us to beammeuppod at gmail.com or go to beammeuppod.com for more ways to contact us. Matt, how can the people contact you? You can find me on both Instagram and Twitter at As A Matter Of Matt. Until next time, folks, live long and prosper.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast?

This episode is 58 minutes long.

When was this Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on September 27, 2022.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.