Skip to content
Stink Bomb: A $46 Million Decision episode artwork

Aug 25, 2026 8 min

Stink Bomb: A $46 Million Decision

from Stinkin Truth Podcast

Mark Schlereth and Mike Evans react to the Browns naming Deshaun Watson as their starting QB for Week 1 and why Shedeur Sanders should still stay ready.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Stink Bomb: A $46 Million Decision

0:00 8:58
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

This is the stinking truth. Although this announcement wasn't really a shocker, it was somewhat anticipated. Still has created a lot of reaction, a lot of friction, a lot of debate, a lot of controversy. And that is Cleveland and Todd Munkin decided to go with Deshaun Watson as the Browns starting quarterback to start the season over Shador Sanders. Now you called this a while ago. You said it was going to be Deshaun Watson. Now that it's official, what do you think went into the decision? Well, I mean...

One, I'm not there every day, right? So I'm not watching practice. I'm not seeing what that camp battle is like. None of that stuff. I thought that Shadour in week two played better than Watson. But I also thought he was protected better. I mean, he had all day in the pocket. The throw at the touchdown pass was exceptional. He probably had five or six seconds in the pocket to let that thing develop. He had a deep over route that he was good on with the same type of protection in the pocket. So I thought that he was much better protected when Deshaun Watson came into that game. He was under duress with different offensive linemen in the whole nine yards. So that part...

It's not necessarily an apples-to-apples comparison. But I will say this. I didn't think either of these guys went out and performed exceptionally well in either of the preseason games. I thought... Watson was probably a little bit better than Shadour in the first one. I thought Shadour was better than Watson in the second one. But if you're taking away or trying to win the starting quarterback job from an incumbent that you've paid a lot of money to, there's got to be no doubt. You have got to step up and you've got to earn it. You've got to take it from Deshaun Watson. And I did not think Shadour did that. The first interception on a dagger concept in week one of the preseason, it's just an awful throw. You know, and I told you people made excuses. Well, the ball was wet. I don't give a rip if the ball was wet. It's not how it works. You've got to be able to execute.

I will say this, though. I think it's easier to transition from Watson to Shadour after five or six weeks if it's not going well than it is going from Shadour to Watson. And the other thing that concerns me about Watson, if he does get usurped, which I don't doubt that he will during the course of the season, what do you do with him? I mean, to watch his press conference and to see a guy who, for me, is not in touch with reality. Upset because you got booed. Upset because they cheered when you tore your Achilles. Upset with the fan base. Dude, the fan base wants a winner. The fan base wants production for a guy who made, what, $230 million total guaranteed? The fan base deserves, in Cleveland, decent football. The fan base wants you. And you're my quarterback, and you're going to boo who at the podium about the fact that it was disrespectful that the fan base booed you?

The fan base has the right. They pay the tickets. They have the right to want a championship caliber football team. They have the right to want and forget about championship caliber. They want the they have the right to want good football as opposed to the factory of sadness that, you know, has been the Cleveland Browns. And you haven't provided that from the time you signed that contract. You know, you can sit there and boohoo about, well, I do charity work. Nobody cares. Nobody wants to hear it. You know, they want to see production on a football field.

and you have not given them any production. So my question is, Mike, if that's the kind of stuff that you're worried about, if that's the kind of stuff that you can't overcome, if you don't have the competitive nature to say, oh yeah, I really want to boo me, I'm going to shove it up your cans. I'm going to play great. then are you really ever going to amount to anything at the quarterback position at this point in your career when you're 30 and you really haven't played very much over the last few years? What would be your message to Shador Sanders fans? Because we know that there's a lot of them out there that really believe in this guy. Let's face it, he's a lightning rod figure. I guarantee you ESPN and the other national football outlets out there aren't pumped with this decision because Shador would have been the better story for them moving forward. So what would be your message to all the Shador Sanders fans who are upset with this decision?

Well, he's going to come riding in at some point like a knight in shining armor, right? And you're going to get your opportunity. He's going to get his opportunity to play this year. Because I can't imagine, as currently constructed in the way that Deshaun Watson has played throughout the preseason, I can't imagine him retaining that job for 17 weeks. Whether it's lack of performance, whether it's mentally not being able to handle the pressure of being booed. I mean, he came out and said, man, it'd be better if we just played 17 weeks on the road. Dude, are you that soft? Are you that soft?

I mean, you better shut down any social media you have. Maybe you already have. Don't turn on the phone or the TV like just living under a rock in fantasy land. You're that freaking soft that you can't handle the criticism. You understand this is professional sports. Get good or get gone. That's how it works. And so that part concerns me. But I would imagine for Shadour fans, he's going to play. He's going to get his opportunity at some point in the season. And then you're going to get to figure out if he's the guy going forward or if you're right back into the draft trying to get Arch Manning.

or whoever else rises like cream to the top. So that would be, bide your time, eventually you're going to see Shador play. Don't you think that's 100% guaranteed? 100%. And for any upset Shador Sanders fan out there, just understand, there's 46 million reasons why this decision was made the way it was. The Cleveland Browns owe Deshaun Watson 46 million guaranteed this year. That's why he's starting to start the season. And if it was...

If it was any way close, even if Sanders probably only had a slight advantage over Watson, he wasn't going to win the job. Because if you're paying a guy $46 million, you're going to try to get some return on that investment. I understand that this, but this, I don't think this sets up Todd Munkin in a, in a very favorable position right off the bat. Cause you know, he gets up in front of that team and he talks about the idea that we're building something. We're going to build a culture. Part of that culture is built on the idea that the best player plays doesn't matter. Your draft status doesn't matter how long you've been in the league. Doesn't matter what you get paid. And yet at the most important position, it's easy for plenty of us to sit back and say the, the, the contract was what won Watson this job. Yeah. I think there's like the thing I always loved about professional sports is it doesn't matter where you come from. It's meritocracy. If you're the better player.

You're going to play. But I will say this. If they're paying somebody a lot of money, then you've got to go out and make it a no-brainer. You've got to play so well, Mike, that everybody in that locker room says, that dude, without question, is the better player. What are we doing? And I don't know. And again, I wasn't there for every practice. I don't know that anybody in that locker room can sit there and say, head and shoulders, Sanders was better than Watson. Maybe they can. Maybe I'm wrong on that. But again, do I believe Watson's going to start 17 games this year?

It's either going to be from, you know, mental fatigue, not being able to handle the criticism. It's going to be from physical fatigue and injury, or it's just going to be from flat out not playing very well.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Stinkin Truth Podcast?

This episode is 8 minutes long.

When was this Stinkin Truth Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on August 25, 2026.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Stinkin Truth Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.