Skip to content
Stink Bomb: A Questionable QB Situation episode artwork

Sep 1, 2026 11 min

Stink Bomb: A Questionable QB Situation

from Stinkin Truth Podcast

Mark Schlereth and Mike Evans continue to evaluate the cuts and roster moves teams made as the final 53-man rosters were submitted in the NFL. Do Cleveland and Minnesota know what they're doing?

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Stink Bomb: A Questionable QB Situation

0:00 11:22
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

This is the Staking Truth. More takeaways from Cutdown Day. How about Odell Beckham Jr. making the Giants 53-man roster? This is somebody who has not been OBJ since 2019, you know, but give him a lot of credit. You know, he's bounced around, he's had injuries.

But he stuck with it, you know, and clearly football matters to him that, you know, he's continued to fight through a lot of roadblocks to the point where, at least for now, he's on the Giants 53-man. It's an incredible story because you look at how he came into the league with the Giants and, you know, the three-finger catch and all the different things that went down and quickly became the best receiver in the National Football League. And then as you mentioned with the injuries and, you know, $100 million contracts and then going broke and, you know, playing for the Rams and tearing up his knee there and all those things. This is, to me, just a great... a potential redemption story on your career. And you don't have to be a superstar anymore, but can you have an impact? Can you be viable? Can you teach the young guys how to play? Can you become a mentor? Can you become one of those guys that's a third down target? Maybe it's 35, 40 catches, but it's big time catches. Maybe it's the underneath stuff. Maybe it's for the love of the game routes, all those things. But how cool, I mean, to me, it's really cool. Now, I don't know that it's just really cool and that he, oh man, he's just show everybody what, or if it's a...

you know, if it's a statement on the receiving core in general and part of the rebuilding aspect of the Giants that John Harbaugh has taken over. Like, so I'm not 100% sure which one that is, but, you know, I love the story. Malik Nabors coming off the ACL and everything else. You know, the LSU connection. I just think all that stuff is kind of cool. It'll be a great storyline to follow. Yeah, sometimes these teams send us very clear messages about how they feel about their team or about a specific position group like the Browns. I know there are plenty of Shador Sanders fans out there who are upset that their guy didn't get named the starting quarterback, that it was Deshaun Watson, but...

Maybe the Browns are telling you, don't count on Deshaun Watson being the guy for too long. They carried three quarterbacks plus a fourth with Dylan Gabriel, who they put on IR. So you're carrying four quarterbacks, basically. It tells you a lot about how they view the guy that's up currently number one, Deshaun Watson. I forget what the rookie's name is. Is it Taylor Green? Yeah, he made some plays. He's athletic. He, you know, in the preseason, did some things. Dylan Gabriel goes on IR, as you mentioned. You know, I think you look at the Browns right now.

I don't think they feel like they have the long-term answer at quarterback. I know they don't feel like Watson's the long-term answer. I feel like they don't think that Shadour's the long-term answer. I don't believe they think Gabriel's the long-term answer. I think the green kid is a kid that intrigues them, but I don't know that they think he's going to be a franchise quarterback. I think they look at it like, our franchise quarterback is playing in college right now.

And that's the direction we're going to go. I mean, isn't that the message you send? You're carrying four quarterbacks. Come on. You are definitely couching your bets on who you've got. I think they were on the roster right now. There were four teams that after initial cut down day, they kept four quarterbacks. And remember, you go back years ago when Bledsoe was the starting quarterback for the New England Patriots. They kept the fourth quarterback. And that fourth quarterback that showed potential and was intriguing to Bill Belichick and the ownership. There was something about him. That dude's name was Tom Brady.

And so, you know, there is, I think more than anything else, when you keep four, Mike, it's a belief system or it's an indicator that you really don't think you have a legitimate starting quarterback. on your roster. I think that's what it comes down to. And you might as well stockpile as many as you can with the hopes that maybe one of them shakes out. In the meantime, you're going to continue to look for more. While we're on the subject of quarterbacks, the Vikings are carrying a lot of quarterbacks, including J.J. McCarthy. And kind of a bizarre story that some people are saying this doesn't pass the smell test. So he was ruled out of the final preseason game against the Broncos here in Denver on Friday. He had a minor ankle sprain on Monday and Tuesday, didn't practice on Wednesday, and didn't feel comfortable enough to go play in the preseason game. The Vikings insist it's

no big deal. It doesn't change our view of him. Come on, Mark. You know why it doesn't change their view of him? Because they've already decided he can't play. They've already decided. The guy can't play. But does it go deeper than that? Because I've been trying to figure out why in a time where teams draft young quarterbacks and they are so uber patient with those quarterbacks, even to the point where we can all see he can't play, but the teams keep giving that guy because they drafted him a chance. The fact that they're moving on from J.J. McCarthy, tell me if I'm wrong. To me, they have gotten the impression that this guy just doesn't love football.

And that they're willing to move on because of that. Well, read the tea leaves, right? If you look at J.J. McCarthy and you read the tea leaves, it would tell you that the Minnesota Vikings don't feel like he can play. They don't feel like he loves it. They don't feel like that's in his blood. And I'm just reading the tea leaves, man. I don't know. I haven't met him. I don't know him. I haven't been around them as a football team. But think about this. His rookie year, he tears his meniscus. And they say, hey, man, this is going to be a two- to four-week injury. And the next thing you know, he opts out of the season to have a meniscus repair. So he's going to be out for the entirety of the season, which is going to push back his development. And obviously, that was a decision that he made. And I understand you're trying to think about your future.

know arthritis and all that other kind of stuff but so it went from reported a four week he's gonna be out for four weeks to oh he's out for the year okay and then this scenario where you bring in Kyler Murray to compete with him for the starting quarterback job and all of a sudden I'm looking at the third preseason game and oh by the way you also brought in Carson Wentz who's your second team quarterback and now J.J. McCarthy falls down the depth chart and When you're competing, if you're a competitor, you know what competitors do? They compete. I say this all the time. I don't care if we're washing dishes. I want to whip your ass at washing dishes. And usually, when it comes to whether you're going to play or not, it's not your decision. As a player, football players play. You're chomping at the bit to play. You're lying to the organization. I'm fine. I feel great. Everything is good. And what do they do before the game, Mike? They work you out. And then the team puts a statement out.

Hey, we decided that based on his movement, he's not ready to play. We sat him down for the third preseason game. He says in your report, yeah, I don't feel like I can play right now. That feels to me like an agent saying, don't play, right? Opt out, and we're going to try to get you traded. And at this point, based upon what has happened to J.J. McCarthy, the best thing that could happen to him, I believe, is get traded, move on, get one of them quarterback rehab years with a great organization. And I'm not saying Minnesota isn't. I think Kevin O'Connell is a really good coach.

He needs a change of scenery and he needs some mama cat. You know what mama cat is? You know, that one coach, you know, there's always that just going to love you up a little bit and, you know, and take care of you and tell you how good you are and pat you on the little hiney, you know, and just nurture you along. He needs a good old fashioned mama cat. Well, I haven't got these kind of vibes about a young quarterback since the days of Josh Rosen. And how quickly did Arizona pivot from Josh Rosen? And then.

What became clear as it played out was that Josh Rosen just wasn't really one of those eat, sleep, breathe football types. And he had other interests. And he's gone on to explore those other interests. But football just wasn't it for him. And I'm kind of getting those same kind of vibes with J.J. McCarthy. Man, football's a hard game. And, you know, it's just like baseball or any other professional sport, man. You have to deal with failure.

And you have to deal well with failure. Like when you're winning and when everything is going in your direction in any walk of life, doesn't matter if you're a sports person or like that's easy. Those times are easy. It's when you deal with failure, when you deal with setback, when you deal with disappointment, man, do you let it crush you or do you let it build you? You know, for me, the bottom line, the bottom line is when it comes to disappointment, it can't crush you without your permission.

You can't give it permission. And when you give it permission, well, then that's when there is no hope. And so, like I said, disappointment can either crush you or build you. It can break you or it can build you. But it can't do either without your permission. And so he feels to me, and again, I'm not around that team, but he feels to me to be a broken player. And when that happens to you, the best thing that can happen for you is to move on. And I hope Minnesota realizes it, too. Don't let your pride get in the way.

We picked him and we're going to develop it and we still believe in him and whatever. At some point, for the best interest of the organization and the best interest of the player, sometimes it's time to move on.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Stinkin Truth Podcast?

This episode is 11 minutes long.

When was this Stinkin Truth Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on September 1, 2026.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Stinkin Truth Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.