Skip to content
Stink Bomb: Is Caleb Williams Not A Good QB? episode artwork

Jun 30, 2026 11 min

Stink Bomb: Is Caleb Williams Not A Good QB?

from Stinkin Truth Podcast

Mark Schlereth and Mike Evans debate whether Stink thinks Caleb Williams is actually a good Quarterback or not.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Stink Bomb: Is Caleb Williams Not A Good QB?

0:00 11:35
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

This is the stinking truth. I gotta bring up something for this podcast that you brought up on our radio show. Yeah. And it was kind of a innocent, kind of throwaway, at least the way you delivered it. Kind of struck me as kind of like a matter-of-fact type comment. We were talking about quarterbacks, we were talking about Bo Nix, we were talking about his class. And you just flat out, and I'm gonna quote you, you said, Caleb Williams isn't a good quarterback. Right. And I went, excuse me? So, why don't you... Yeah, well, Caleb Williams... How do you defend saying Caleb Williams is not a good quarterback? Caleb Williams is not a good quarterback.

He's a dynamic athlete. He makes big-time plays. But is he a good quarterback? No, he's not a good quarterback because he doesn't play on schedule. Like, I mean, my evaluation is watch how many times they get into a late in the third quarter or fourth quarter and they're down 21-7, right? And then he holds the ball, he scrambles around, he makes three big throws, and all of a sudden they win a game 21-24. Like, that's not playing quarterback at an efficient level. That's being a dynamic playmaker.

So at this particular point in time, Caleb Williams isn't a good quarterback. If you were ranking that class, you'd put Jaden Daniels ahead of him. You'd put Drake May ahead of him. I'd put Bo Nix ahead of him. You have this generational talent who's supposed to be a great quarterback. He's not a great quarterback. He's a great playmaker. And when it comes to off-schedule football, the guy is probably about as good as it gets. He is Kyler Murray with more height. That's who he is at this. Now, that doesn't mean he can't get better.

And I know that that's what they have worked on, him being better. But this is, I mean, let me ask you this. How much better do you think he's going to get? Do you think he wasn't coached that way at USC under Lincoln Riley? Do you think Lincoln Riley wasn't trying to get him to play on schedule more? You don't think that that's ever been coached? What did he complete last year? 58% of his passes? 59% of his passes? In a league where everything is constructed to having a great percentage, a completion percentage? I mean, it's the same offense that Jared Goff was playing in. Was Jared Goff completing 58% of his passes?

Or more like 68% of his passes. So I'm just telling you that he is not a good quarterback. He's an exceptional playmaker. But do you win championships? playing off schedule and my answer to you is no you don't win him playing off schedule you will never win him playing off schedule that's not how you win championships yeah i'm a little surprised you're making such a big deal about his his completion percentage and you're right two years in the league it's been below um it actually went from 62 percent his rookie year down to 58 percent his second year but one of the reasons why you kind of uh minimize what quarterbacks do you're like oh well you know they throw a bunch of passes behind the line of scrimmage before you know what they're 12 for 12 whoop-de-doo bezel right right well Okay, so why are you putting that much stock into his completion percentage when I see a guy that from year one to year two went from 3,500 to 3,900 yards passing from 20 touchdowns to 27 touchdowns and kept his interceptions the same six to seven? Doesn't that kind of progress in year two in those key numbers tell you that this is a guy that's only going to continue to get better and better as he learns more about playing quarterback? Because you're always also saying that the college game is so different than the pro game.

So if it's so different, doesn't it just figure that the quarterbacks, some of them may figure it out earlier, but a lot of them are going to need some time to figure it out. Sure, they're going to need time to figure it out. It doesn't mean he can't figure it out. It just means that I don't think he's very good right now. And ultimately, I think this comes down to how you play the game or how you want to be perceived and how you want to grow. I'm not saying that he doesn't want to grow. And I know Ben Johnson is grinding on him to be a more efficient quarterback. I'm just saying that when guys want to lean on their playmaking ability.

When guys want to turn down a completion because it's a five-yard completion, and they want to turn that away, even though it's the first or second hitch in there, or the first rhythm throw in the progression, the first hitch in the progression, the second throw in the progression, they want to turn that down because there's something bigger out there or they feel like there could be something bigger. You're going to win some games, man, and you're going to make a bunch of highlight plays, and there's going to be some really cool moments. But you know what you're not going to do? I don't think you're going to win consistently, and you're not going to win come playoff time playing that style of football. I just don't think that style of football ends up. I think that you will make a bunch of SportsCenter highlights, and I've said this about Kyler Murray. In the end, you'll lose a lot of games. Now, they won last year, and good for them. They did a great job. I'm just saying that I think that that dude needs to be so much better of doing the boring well and taking what a defense gives him and being on time and being in rhythm.

When you rely on big plays and when you rely on broken plays or second chance plays, it's great to have a quarterback that has that ability. And he has that ability as well, if not better than anybody in the National Football League right now. That's what makes him so exciting. but when you rely on that ability on a consistent basis, what ends up happening is you'll win some games, but you'll make some mistakes, and you'll take a sack, or a turnover will be created where you're just not going to win come playoff time. I'm not saying that he can't be great. I'm just saying that he's not great right now. I want to get your reaction to a player that you have been critical of, maybe lukewarm at best when it comes to who he is as a player, Kyle Pitts. Five years with Atlanta, got paid over the weekend. Three-year contract, $54 million, $36 million of it guaranteed for a guy who is coming off a career year in catches with 88.

for really only 928 yards and five touchdowns. So not the career year from a yardage standpoint. He had 1,000 yards as a rookie. But Kyle Pitts, is this a good signing, re-signing by the Falcons? Well, you know, they put him on the franchise deal, and then they re-signed him to this big deal. So I just think he's kind of a one-dimensional player. He's like a tell. And so...

You know how I feel about the tight end position. A lot of people like you will say, well, who cares if he can't block? It doesn't matter. Well, it does matter. You know, we went through this exercise on our last podcast. The teams that play under center the most in the league, of the top 10 teams that played under center the most, which means we're going to run the ball and we're going to do some things that are a little bit more like old school football, eight of the top 10 wins the playoffs. Of the bottom 10 teams that play under center, the teams that play the most gun,

only one of the bottom 10 teams went to the playoffs. So like I look at him, if you use him, if you know what he is and you use him correctly as a movement tight end, not a wide tight end, you move him outside the numbers, you make him play X receiver, you do a lot of things with him. Then I think he could be a valuable asset, but you got to understand what he is. And there was a couple of years there where he was playing in Atlanta and you look at, oh shoot, who was the coach that was coaching him? You know, multiple tight ends, the Pittsburgh Steelers offense coordinator now.

I lost the name. Arthur Smith. Oh, yeah, Arthur Smith. Thank you. Thank you very much. That's why you're here. So, it's bringing in Arthur Smith. There he is, my guy. So, you know, he wants to play in multiple tight end formations, heavy formations, use multiple backs, run the ball. Like, that's not what Kyle Pitts can do. And so, it was Stefanski there who wants to run the ball and all that stuff. You know, you've got to understand where Kyle Pitts is best, what his best value is. And really, he's more, to me, he's more an X receiver than he is a tight end. And so, I think you've got to really use him in that. But I just think he's a one-dimensional tight end. So, that's why I'm not the biggest fan.

of him as an overall football player, but I understand as a receiver, he could be a valuable tool. So when you say, excuse me, a tell, so is it, and pardon me for oversimplifying things, but it's as simple as if he's out there, it's a pass. If he's not out there, it's a run. Well, it could be that, but if you're in two tight end situations, right, you're going to look at two tight end situations. If you're in solo, meaning a tight end on each side, you're probably running away from him. He's more of a cutoff player, or there's a play action off of run action where he's going to pin flat, you know, or pin corner or whatever, you know, whatever he's asked to do, or he's going to slide across the formation and be that.

low crosser so yeah there's there is those aspects of hey man what are they doing in this you know or hey if they're gonna run the ball they're gonna motion outside the formation and try to bring you know a linebacker try to bring somebody out there to cover him so that they get a better number in the box to run the ball so yeah there's there's a bit of a tell there in what they're doing and and because you're not gonna line them up in you know you're not gonna line them up in a too tight set like a west set right there and say let's go play smash mouth with with pits it's probably not gonna happen so those are the things that i think you have to look at you've got to be understanding of what a player can and can't do i'm just not Hey, listen, he's great. I'm not the biggest fan. Yeah. All right. Well, I can't wait until we do this again in a couple of days. NFL Network Top 100 list. A few more names. We'll turn off the board. Probably a couple more quarterbacks. Oh, can't wait for quarterbacks. Yeah, it's been great. Quarterbacks, quarterbacks, quarterbacks, quarterbacks.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Stinkin Truth Podcast?

This episode is 11 minutes long.

When was this Stinkin Truth Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on June 30, 2026.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Stinkin Truth Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.