Skip to content
Stocks at 52-Week Lows: Values or Traps? episode artwork

Jul 12, 2024 32 min

Stocks at 52-Week Lows: Values or Traps?

from Zacks Market Edge Hosted by Zacks Investment Research

Many investors like to look for deals among stocks hitting new lows but are there any? (0:30) - Can You Find Value In Beaten Down Stock Hitting New Lows? (5:30) - Tracey’s Top Stock Picks For Your Watchlist (29:00) - Episode Roundup: NKE, DE, PAYC, ETSY, LVS [email protected]

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Stocks at 52-Week Lows: Values or Traps?

0:00 32:24
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

This is the Value Investor podcast with Tracy Rinek, all things value all the time. Welcome back value investors. So there's good news and bad news here in 2024 with stocks. The good news is we're hitting new highs nearly daily on at least the S&P 500 and the NASDAQ.

So there's a lot of companies and a lot of the stocks hitting new highs at least 52 week highs and a lot of them are hitting all time highs. So that's the good news. But the bad news is there's still some stocks hitting 52 week lows. And some of those have been pretty prominent in the news recently because they're popular stocks that many of us may own.

And so they keep getting talked about and I thought I'd take a look this week at is there any deals in the stocks that are trading at 52 week lows? Are they values here or are they traps? Because as I always say, there is a reason a stock is at a 52 week low. Now it may be that the street is just panicking over something that's really not going to be that relevant long term.

It could be that there's just something going on in the industry that is somewhat cyclical and that will change in the next six to 12 months. And so the story will change so you could find a deal in there. Or it could mean there is something going on behind the scenes at some of these companies. Either they're in an out of favor industry or a changing industry, kind of like a blockbuster video type scenario or a borders bookstore, that kind of thing where it does actually result in the demise of the company because of changes in technology or changes just in that industry in general.

Or it could mean somehow management had a breakdown. Either management is changed or they just don't have the right management in there. And sometimes that can turn around. Sometimes it does not that it's almost basically too late sometimes to turn around some of those companies.

So I got to do a screen on sex.com for stocks trading at their 52 week lows. Originally, I looked for stocks within 5% of the 52 week lows, but I literally got over 1,800 stocks. So it's more than you think trading at the 52 week lows apparently. So then I said, why not just go for it?

I'm going to go for the screen where they actually are at the 52 week lows. And surprisingly, I still got 450 stocks on the screen. That's not seems like a lot more than I would have thought given that the stock market is hitting these new highs nearly daily. So that's a lot of stocks.

I did not put a tax rank in because for this screen, I really didn't care if it's, you know, has a bad sex rank, if it's a four, which is the cells or strong, or strong cell, which is the fives. You know, something is probably not good at these companies if it's trading near the 52 week lows or at it. And so these even worse, you know, two year lows, five year lows, because as my work colleague Dave Bartos, I always says momentum begets or momentum, but that can work both ways to the upside. It can definitely work as we're seeing right now with Nvidia and some of the other AI stacks.

But it can also work to the downside. Once you get that downward spiral going, it's very difficult to stop it until basically all the weak hands are flushed out. So you could, you know, you're going to get the lower sex rank usually on the stocks trading your 52 week lows and analysts are cutting those estimates. That usually is a bad thing for a stock and then it's continues to spiral down.

So we're going to take a look at five stocks off of this list of 450 stacks. Now that's a much longer list than I normally would ever want to screen for. But I was able to just scroll through it and pick out prominent names. So I didn't go for any obscure unknown small cap that is at the 52 week low.

I went for big, well known names and there were quite a bit, I would say I picked out 10 originally and then I narrowed it down to the five. And I tried to keep it in different industries and not cover some of the same stocks we've talked about on the podcast over the last one to two years. So I tried to get some new names in there and there are some new ones. So let's just dive right in and see what is going on with these stocks.

They're at the 52 week lows. Are they values here? Is there some kind of value even with the bad sex rank or is it a trap? And remember, let's define what the trap means again.

So a stock can be cheap. It could be trading at 52 week lows. It can have the low PE, maybe a low price to sales ratio. All of that could signal value could be under 15 on the PE and under one on the price to sales even.

But when you go over to look at the earnings, what is going on there? Is it declining? Is it going to be lower year over year? Are they cutting the estimates?

But that's probably going to be a given with a lot of these that the estimates are being cut. Although I don't know because I didn't screen for this extra. So we'll have to see when we get in there. But the true value stock has the low PE, probably low price to sales.

It has the low value fundamentals, but it also has something decent or good even going on with those earnings estimates. At least maybe earnings are expected to rise year over year and the analysts getting a little more bullish there. So we have some earnings growth because that's really what I want in a company. I don't want to end up with the company where it's dark times.

Basically, there's too many companies out there you can own. And remember, as a value investor, you're looking for a long term ownership. And you want to own the best. You want to own the companies that aren't struggling.

You want to own those that are crushing it, even cheaply, cheaply crushing it. So don't settle and don't think, I found a deal here just because it's trading at 52 week lows. Definitely dive in and see what's going on behind the curtain there, which is what we're about to do. Okay, so let's start off.

The first one is one, it's in the news nearly every day right now. A lot of you are talking about it. It's Nike, ticker NKE. And this is a surprising one.

It actually is, I believe near the five year lows now, multi year lows. It's guided lower in the last earnings report. So basically the stock just spiraled down. It's collapsed, let's just call it.

Here to date, stock is now down 32%. Over the last five years, it's now down 15.4%. And this is a dramatic spiraling down. Because during the pandemic, the stock was trading at new heights.

So this is just big change. And just goes to show that a lot of people think, oh, these big cap, well known names like a Nike that have been around for a long time, that we're hitting new highs, that we're crushing it in the pandemic. I can own this forever. I don't really have to pay that much attention to it.

It's fine. And then maybe not, maybe not. So what's going on behind the scenes with this one? Nike, it is his acts number five strong sell.

Not surprising because it did just report to guide lower analysts have had a cut now. So the rank is going to fall down. But remember that is a short term recommendation of one to three months. So that's that's panning out right here.

Nike is a PE of 23. So that's not that cheap, really. I took a look at the peg ratios and all of these as well. Peg is at 1.9.

So it's not in the value peg land. So those things are not signaling to me like I must dive in right now. But what are the earnings doing? They are on the fiscal year.

So this fiscal year earnings expected to be down 19.8%. Not surprising given what they just reported. Last year they made 395, expected to make 317. Next year though, let's look forward because they're already halfway through the fiscal year.

Next year expected to rebound up 13.7% to $3.60. So 317 up to 360. But when you scroll down, you can see why it has a number five on the agreement estimate revisions part where we see what the analysts are actually doing, whether or not they're cutting or raising on the detailed estimates page. You can see that 13 estimates were cut for this year in the last 30 days after that earnings report and eight were actually cut for next year.

So even though we're getting 13% earnings growth for next year expected, analysts are not liking what they're saying and they're pessimistic. And so eight have cut in the last 30 days off of the last earnings report. One estimate has actually been lowered even in the last week now. That's after the earnings.

So I'm not sure what that analyst is seeing. It just could be that maybe I don't know some of their internal data or you know, store shopping data that some of these analysts do are showing further negative things going on. So none of the estimates are higher. So that's pretty bearish to me.

But earnings growth is supposed to return for next year. So it's not as trappy as you might think. But I'm not totally convinced that that $3.60 level is going to hold the next couple quarters into next fiscal year. This has a little bit of trappiness.

It's also not that cheap at 23 times. And it's still hitting those five year lows, might not be done, might not have bottomed. We do get a dividend, but it's yielding only 2%. That's not that great for my patients.

So I'm not really liking Nike here because I'm not sure it's bottomed yet. People aren't desperate enough yet, even though it's at five year lows. So I'm saying on the sidelines with this one, but it's not real trappy, but it's not also a value. It's not really that cheap, even at the five year lows.

So this is why you got to take a look at the numbers, right? And check in on those conference calls and see what the analysts are saying as well, what their guidance is. But Nike, it still may have some more downsides. So I'm staying on the sidelines with that one.

Ticker is N as an NCK E. Okay, then another very prominent name, trading at 52-week lows is Deere, Deere and Company, the big farm equipment and construction equipment manufacturer. So Deere, year to date, it's down 12.7%. Over the last five years, it's still up 111%.

So this is not one year, the five year lows, not even close. But the last couple of years, it's kind of been trading in this narrow trading range. And over the two years stack, it's up, but up only 14.6%. So it's just kind of trading up down, up down, waiting for some kind of catalyst to either break down further or to bust out.

So is this one cheap? Deere trading with the PE of 13.9. So that's pretty cheap. A peg of 1.4, and they too also paid a dividend yielding 1.7%.

So you're not getting a lot for your patients if you're just kind of holding it and you've been writing in this narrow trading range for the last two years. What do the earnings estimates look like? So earnings expected to fall 26% here. This fiscal, I guess this is 2024.

It's at 25.56. That is down from 34.63 last year. And then in the next year, it also is showing another decline of 4.9% down to 24.30. Now what are the analysts doing on this one?

So it is a number three, that's just the hold, but it's reported a while ago and it's reporting again on August 16th or there about in mid-August. So most of the analyst revisions are in from the last earnings report. But for this fiscal year, 13 after that last earnings report, none were raised and 11 were cut for next year. And just in the last seven days, another estimate has been cut for next year.

But nothing has been raised in the last 30 days for this year or next year on Deere. So the analysts are pretty much in agreement that the earnings are going to decline here. And these types of companies in the farm and agriculture industry can be highly cyclical. And we've got high interest rates globally, really.

And so it's expensive for farmers to buy any kind of equipment right now. So they're likely going to hold on to as much of the equipment as they can without upgrading until money gets cheaper or they're desperate. So not so desperate yet. And so those earnings are on the decline.

But like I said, still pretty cheap under 14 times, but has a bit of the trappiness going on because earnings expect to be down this year and then again next year. So while it may look cheap on the surface, it's really not that cheap. But investors still hanging out in there for the most part, even though it's down 12.7% year to date that they're in that narrow trading range. What will cause it to fall or rise?

That is the question with Deere, ticker DE on Deere. So it does have the trappiness going on right now. So I'm on the sidelines on that one a bit. Okay, then we're going to switch over to software with Paycom.

Paycom software, ticker P as in Paul, A as in Andrew, Y, and then C as in cat. K-A-Y-C is this one. I wanted to get some kind of techie type of name in here. Year to date, it's down 32.2%, five years, it's down 42.5%.

And it's trading near it's 50 or it's 50 year lows. It's near it's five year lows. That's pretty painful. But I'm just looking at it on sex.com.

It's a number one rank. So we do have a number one rank. I don't want it to be sitting a 52 week low. That's unusual as I pointed out at the beginning of the podcast.

So kind of surprised by this. But what does this value fundamentals kind of look like? PE of 18.2. So not super expensive, but not super cheap.

Heg of 1.8. That's a little pricier. Dividend, they do actually pay 1.1% is a dividend on this one. But let's take a look at those earnings.

Because something has to be going on, right? Like how did it get this number one rank? The analysts have to be more bullish right here. So 2024, expected to decline just 0.5%.

So they made 775 last year, expected to make 771 this year. On 10% sales growth, actually. Next year, expected to make 860, which is 11.4% gain. So finally, turning around, seeing some more earnings growth next year, on 11% sales growth.

So these are all good numbers. Analysts over the last 60 days, two are higher for this year. One over the last 30 days is higher. But for 2025, two are down in the last 60 days, none are higher.

So that could just be the analysts after the last earnings report, thinking ahead, looking at 2025, realizing they got maybe a little too bullish about 2025. So they're correcting that a little bit lower. But a lot. For 2025, 60 days ago, it was at 863.

And now it's at 868. So 3% change. It's not a big deal. But also, similarly, on 2024, 771 versus 769, 30 days ago.

So 2% change there. We do have, like I said, a couple of analysts are on this one. We have nine estimates on the earnings. So it's not like there's only one or two analysts on this company.

So what is going on here? Why is it looking so dire on the chart? I would have to dive in further to see. But it's giving me the vibes of block, where the earnings actually look pretty good.

We're getting some earnings growth. It's not a value trap, but it still is selling off. And it's still out of favor on the street. And that is where Paycom is looking here as well.

But it is now at those five-year lows. How low will it go? But we don't know. That's why everyone's saying away from this one, right?

Because due to date, it's down 32%. It's spiraling. When will it stop? Then perhaps some will get in.

You've got to be brave to get in this right here. But it's got this X number one range. So this is an interesting one. And I'm going to keep an eye on it.

It's not a value trap here. It's not dirt cheap, but it does have some attractive things going for it. And so yeah, I'm keeping this one on my list as a value stock here. So that's Paycom software, P-A-Y-C.

Then we're going to switch over to another big winner from the pandemic at C. This one, I was kind of surprised. I haven't really been following it in recent months. And so I was surprised to see it on the 52-week low screen.

But year to date, it's down 30.5% for Etsy, which is particular Etsy, ETSY. Five years, it's down 12.8%. And that is a dramatic drop because Etsy, again, one of the big winners during the pandemic, it was up several hundred percent at one point during the pandemic. Everybody was buying their homemade masks off the site, remember, and we're just stuck at home.

We're buying all this stuff from Etsy stores. And then that kind of went away. As the economy reopened, we could go shopping in the stores again, less shopping online. We just were buying the hospital masks at that point, and not the homemade masks anymore.

So all of that went away. And now here we are. These shares are not yet at five-year lows, which were when COVID hit. That's when it went to the five-year lows.

But still five years down 12.8%, five years for the S&P 500 up 86%. So quite the dramatic difference with Etsy. So what does it look like here? PE 22.2.

So that's not that cheap. Peg ratio is at 4.5, which is really not cheap. So this is a little bit of an expensive stock here, even as it declines. And that's probably because the earnings have come down quite a bit.

So a year ago earnings $2.42. This year expecting $2.49. So that is up 2.9%. But that's not much growth.

That's why we got the high peg there, because it's not much growth. 2025 expecting 15% earnings growth, however, to 286. On the estimates changes, one is down for this year over the last 30 days. And one was raised, but that was in the last 60 days.

And similar story for 2025. So probably the same analysts just adjusting both years. So the estimates haven't really done too much. In the last even 60 days, they're just kind of hanging out there.

So we're going to have to wait for the next earnings report, which is coming in early August of 2024. But this stock just out of favor now, not really cheap enough to qualify for value, not enough growth to qualify for the growth. So it's in no man's land, and it's just kind of spiraling down as investors get out of it. So this does have momentum to the downside.

And so this is one that you probably want to stay on the sidelines with, if you're a value investor waiting to see, if you can actually get it as a value. Now, is it a trap? It's not a trap. We do have earnings worth expected for next year, and a little bit for this year.

But it's simply not cheap enough to be on the value category. So keep this one on your watch list. I will too. I don't think Etsy is still adjusting to this normalization of retail and consumer spending and everything, now that the pandemic has receded.

But this is one I definitely want to keep on my watch list. So that's Etsy ticker ETSY. And then we're going to switch over to travel with Las Vegas Sands ticker, Elison Larry, V as in Victor, S as in Sam. Wait a minute.

I did want to say what the Etsy, Etsy, ZX rank is a three hold. So it's not showing anything bullish. It's not showing anything bearish. So that I'm not surprised at given where those earnings estimates are and what's happening with any possible cuts.

But okay, so Las Vegas Sands, LVS is a ticker here. This one is also a number three hold. And here today, it's down 15.3%. Five years though, it's down 21.6%.

But it's not at the lows. Five year lows were in 2022. But that might not give you much comfort if you've been in it even since 2022. So Las Vegas Sands, the big casino operator in the US and Asia and PE 15.4.

So that's pretty cheap. Peg ratio is a value, peg ratio, 0.7. So that means it has both value and growth. It's under one.

And I like that. So we have a true value stock here on the fundamentals on those ratios, but let's look at the earnings. So this year, I'm expected to make $2.69. They made $1.89 last year.

So that's earnings growth of 42%. Wow, next year further earnings growth up to $3.04. Again, from $2.69, that's $12.8% earnings growth. Looking at the changes in the earnings, one estimate is higher in the last 30 days for both this year and next year.

For next year, one estimate has been lowered in the last week, however, none for this year in the last week. So one analyst getting a little bearish on next year, but not even that much. It's not showing up much in the actual consensus estimate trends. So for 2025, I said they were going to make $3.04.

That's the consensus. But that is actually up a penny in the last 30 days from $3.03. So analysts consolidating around these numbers here before this next earnings report. And when are we expecting that soon?

In July, we're going to get that. So we have around July 17, but give or take, but sometime that week, we are going to get it. So let's make a sense. What's going on here?

Why is everybody selling it off? I'm not that familiar with what their business is doing. So something must be going on for it to be pretty weak at the 52-week lows, pretty much a value stock. It does pay a dividend dealing 1.9%.

So you're getting something at least to hold on. But those earnings expected to be up, sales expected to be up, double digits this year, 13.7% and then another 7.8%. For next year, I don't know if this is on Asia business, on the US business, on fears of a slowdown coming from the consumer. I don't know.

But there is value in this one. There is not a trap with Las Vegas Sands ticker LVS. So some interesting stocks out of these five that I picked out. And interesting to see what is happening with these companies trading at the 52-week lows, or in some cases, five-year lows.

Some values, some trappiness, some are not their values or traps. And that's going to happen. It's going to happen because I did not screen for a value component. But that's another reason why you have to do the research.

Don't just do a screen and pick some stuff of it. Don't just watch some videos and think, oh, I know everything going on at these companies now. Listen in on the conference calls. We're heading into earnings season.

You're going to get a lot of information out of that. Or with Nike, they did just report earnings not that long ago because they're on the fiscal year. So listen in on that. You can always go back and listen in on the conference calls.

They have them on their website. Check out what the analysts are saying. If you have access anyway to that, go on sex.com. Check out the detailed estimates to see who is cutting, who is raising on the earnings.

Check out the price of consensus chart to get an idea over the last five years on what has been going on with those consensus estimates and the changes to them. Remember, you want up and to the right. You want to grow those earnings if at all possible. Yes, even value investors want earnings growth.

The trapean is comes when you're getting a lot of those earnings declining. That's what we don't want. We want our companies to be growing. So keep that in mind as well.

So let me recap the stocks we talked about again on this interesting episode. Nike was the lead off ticker NKE. We had deer and company ticker D as in David E, just two letters DE. We had pay comm software.

That's the X number one rank strong buy out of this list. ticker P-A-Y-C. P-A-Y-C. Then we had Etsy ticker E-T-S-Y.

And finally, we wrapped it up with Las Vegas Sands. Looks like a value and not a trap. Ticker, Elasin Larry, Visa and Victor, S and Sam, L-V-S. And as always, I'm aiming to find interesting value stocks and talk about everything that's going on in the value stock arena this year.

There are value stocks out there as even this screen showed, and we didn't even search for value. So you want to subscribe? Be sure to get us on YouTube. Go put in Zax Podcasts to subscribe there.

It's a different channel than our normal YouTube channel, but you can get some of our podcasts on the normal YouTube channel too, which is just zax.com slash YouTube or Zax investment research. But be sure to get us somewhere on YouTube and also on Apple and Spotify, Amazon Music. We're on almost all the podcasting platforms, but be sure to get us every week there. And I'll be back next week with some more value stocks.

No recommendation or advice is being given as to whether any investment or strategy is suitable for a particular investor. It should not be assumed that any investment since securities, companies, sectors, and markets identified, described were or will be profitable. All information is current as of the date here in and is subject to change without notice. Any user opinions expressed may not reflect those of as X investment research as a whole.

The Investor's Podcast (We Study Billionaires) - The Investor’s Podcast Network The Investor's Podcast Network Hosted by Stig Brodersen, William Green, Shawn O'Malley, Daniel Mahncke, and Kyle Grieve, The Investor’s Podcast has proudly reached nearly 200 million downloads, as the world's largest stock-investing focused podcast. On the show, we study a range of businesses and their investment prospects, from Spotify to Amazon, serial acquirers like Constellation Software, deep value plays, and more, using lessons from some of the world's most famous investors, like Warren Buffett, Charlie Munger, and Howard Marks. Leverage the lessons we learned from studying, and talking to, the wo Capital Ideas podcast Capital Group Want to learn how professional investors do it? The Capital Ideas podcast brings you the latest investment thinking from Capital Group, one of the world's largest investment management organizations. Each week we'll get inside the minds of portfolio managers, analysts and economists to break down market trends, macroeconomic forces, investing approaches and lessons learned from personal experience. Take 30 minutes and tap into the intellectual capital of Capital Group. Capital Client Group, Inc.All Capital Group trademarks mentioned are owned by The Capital Group Companies, Inc., an affiliated company or fund. All other company and product names mentioned are the property of their respective companies.For full disclosures go to capitalgroup.com/global-disclosures. Growth Triggers: Content Marketing & AI Luis Diaz Discover how to use your podcast to generate leads, sales, and influence in any market. On this show Luis shares his best tested and proven secrets, tips, and strategies from launching over 300 podcasts in over a dozen different niches and generating over 59 Million Downloads for his clients. Learn how to increase your podcast listenership, create multiple new revenue streams with your podcast, sell more of your core offer and build a show that gives you leverage and authority in your space. From picking the right monetization strategy for your podcast to learning how to position your podcast in a crowded market on Apple and Spotify; this is show is the ultimate marketing and sales resource for online business owners who want to know what works with podcasting. Get in touch over on Instagram <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow" class="link" href="https://www.instagram.com/luisr

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Zacks Market Edge?

This episode is 32 minutes long.

When was this Zacks Market Edge episode published?

This episode was published on July 12, 2024.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Zacks Market Edge episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.