Skip to content
Stocks: Overvalued or Cheap Heading Into 2021? episode artwork

Dec 9, 2020 33 min

Stocks: Overvalued or Cheap Heading Into 2021?

from Zacks Market Edge Hosted by Zacks Investment Research

S&P 500 earnings are expected to rise 21% in 2021 and that may be too conservative as the coronavirus vaccine rolls out. (1:00) - Understanding The Current Valuation Of The Stock Market (7:45) - What Should We Expect From Earnings Going Into 2021? (14:20) - How Are The Large Cap Companies Performing? (19:00) - Small Cap Stocks Rebound: What Is Driving This Performance? (27:45) - Episode Roundup: IJR, SLY, IWM, AAPL, INTC, SE, DOCU, TDOC [email protected]

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Stocks: Overvalued or Cheap Heading Into 2021?

0:00 33:54
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

stocks, bonds, ETFs straight out of downtown Chicago. This is Zach's Market Edge. Welcome to Zach's Market Edge, the podcast about investing in your life. I'm your host, Tracy Reinek.

And this week I'm joined by Sharaas Nien, Zach's Director of Research, to talk about the earnings outlook for 2021. What does it look like after this crazy year with the pandemic? We know some companies are doing really well, some areas of the economy are doing really well. Can they keep that momentum into 2021?

And how expensive is the stock market? Both the large caps and the small caps. A lot of people talking about how it's overvalued, Jiraz, here going into 2021. But is it?

I don't know what we're going to discuss it, because that seems to be the biggest fear that's out there. I feel about the overall market, at least. Is that it's too high? It's run too much.

And it's way overvalued. I get these emails and tweets from the Bears saying that it's worse than the valuations then in 1999. And we know how that ended. Should I be concerned about these things?

What do earnings look like going into 2021? So let me just address the valuation question first. And then we can go into the earnings. The valuation question always, since there is a high degree of subjectivity involved in valuation, it's always a heated debate.

And your references to 99. And there's this talk of these bubbles and the specs and all of that. So if you look at the multiples on an absolute basis, and you say, for the S&P 500, it's 22 and 1 half, as you look for the small caps, the Russ and others, those are multi-decad highs as well. And that's the only measure for you that you use to determine value, then yes, we are totally in uncharted territory.

And if that's how the markets behaved, then perhaps the outlook is a lot more scary. But I never bought into the valuation multiples as the only framework for determining value. Interest rates are as big a determinant of stock prices as earnings are. And the interest rates that we have now, we have never had that in history either.

And a sub one person interest rate in that environment, a 20, 22, 23 times earnings multiple is a lot lower in reality, relative to what we had in the 9, 2000, 2001. When interest rates were, the 10 year yield was north of 5%. So you can't look at these things in isolation. You have to look at the complete picture.

And I think when you do that, I don't think stocks are overvalued or there's a bubble or we are anywhere near the craziness that we went through in the 2009 and the new folks, that's probably what they read about in books and stuff. We actually went through that period. That was different. Yeah.

Yeah. It felt a lot different than what it feels like out there right now. Sure. Sure.

I've never seen an interview with Warren Buffett. Maybe, I don't know, it was before 2020. So maybe in 2019, what are the ones when he was on CNBC? And it was where you could send in your question, Rebecca Quick and she would ask him.

And they were asking him even in 2019 about the stock market being a bubble and being overvalued. And he gave the response you just gave, not with the interest rates this low. And that was before they went even lower. Absolutely.

So he was also looking at the same thing you were. And he said with the rates at those levels of 2019, even that he was a buyer of stock all the time at those levels. Absolutely. Yeah.

In 2019, we were in this one and a half to two percent range. Yes. Which if you look back the preceding 20, 30, 40 years was extremely low. And what we have now is totally unprecedented.

And on top of that, we have the Federal Reserve effectively guaranteeing and into the extent that a government entity or regulatory entity could guarantee anything. They are saying we will not raise interest rates for a very long time. And people define the very long time anywhere from three to five years. And so you have a sub one percent interest rate and an outlook in which interest rates are expected to remain low for a very long time.

So you couple that with outlook for the economy, outlook for major parts of the economy, there have some real momentum behind them. I find it hard to get bearish on stocks in that environment. Does the possibility of having a yelling at the treasury along with Powell at the Fed also boost your view of stocks in 2021? Yes, yes it does.

But to step back from their tracing, the tight fiscal policy narrative, the narrative of deficits being something to worry about that has been destroyed and killed in the political elites over the last so many years. So it's possible that these things come back. You never know what politicians will take up a point to kind of raise their own profiles on. But spending without regard to whether it's borrowed money or raised money for revenues has been the norm in the US and out over the world for a very long time.

And I think that will remain so now the fact that someone as credible as yelling will be in the treasury who has a certain reputation on this issue. And then Powell obviously is someone that the market has seen and known totally gives credence to this growth outlook. OK, well that sounds bullish. It is.

It is. So let's take a look at the earnings then because they are expected to rebound into next year. Should anyone be surprised by that because they're they declined this year. Yes.

So we had about a 16, 17% decline this year. And we will have a 21, 21 and a half percent growth in 2021. And the overall level of earnings in 2021 will effectively reach where we were in 2019. OK.

Now this is what I'm describing is the is the bottom up aggregate consensus estimates. So all the hundreds and thousands of analysts around their covering their individual companies we aggregate that to the sector and then the aggregate index level. If I have any worry or doubt about these estimates, it is that they are under counting the potential growth in 2021. And the reason for that is that the traditional framework that all the analysts use for making estimates is based on this model of how companies and households and industries behave as the economy comes out of recession.

And for history, they use the last 20, 30, 40 years of behavior as they know and has been documented in the economy. The thing that's different this time and that's always a worrying thing when somebody says it's different this time. That the recession was different. This was caused by a health care issue.

So the output impact and the production impact and the impact on growth was very severe and very fast. But once the health care issue is on its way being addressed, it is reasonable to expect. This is not my base case outlook and obviously this is not anyone's base case outlook. But there is a reasonable chance that the growth next year will be a lot faster than what consensus numbers currently project.

What do you see as the year over year issues that we're going to have? So for instance, maybe not so much in the first quarter, but the second quarter that was severely impacted by the first wave of the shutdowns and the economy year over year, companies should be able to easily beat whatever they did last year. But then by the third quarter, as things reopened this year, things got better. But can they still exceed that in 2021?

Can they beat the quick comeback that they had this year in the next year? Yes, I strongly believe they can. And yes, to your point that the Q2 2020 estimates, if you look at today's estimates for Q2 2021, they do represent a huge year over year again. In fact, for the S&P 500, the earnings growth is expected to be 40.4%.

And the reason for that, as you alluded to, is that the 32.3% decline we had in Q2 2020. And then things normalize beyond Q2 2021. So we have a 12% growth in Q3. The estimates will evolve as we go through the new year.

As we get these Q4 results in January and analysts digest the commentary from management teams, we will have estimates for Q1 and Q2 adjust. That's the norm. That's been the norm, Adirang. The last few quarters, the last two quarters to be precise, estimates have been going up.

As we start seeing earnings results come in, in the past, it was the reverse. Estimates would go down. My sense is that as we go through the coming reporting cycles, estimates will keep going up and perhaps go up at a pace that's higher than what we have been seeing over the last two quarters. Okay.

Now let's talk about one of the big sectors that everybody cares about. And that's really driving this market and that's technology. I saw that it's 31.8% of the S&P 500 now. By far the largest sector in the S&P 500.

Number two is at finance at 12.8 now. So what's happening in tech? I saw in the third quarter that Amazon, they're killing it and they drove a lot of, well, this is on retail. Sorry, we have Amazon in the retail sector.

But on Amazon, on the retail side, they drove a lot of what was happening there and on tech because Apple and Intel are so large now too. On the tech sector, they drove a lot of what happened in the third quarter there. What is going on with these huge massive companies? How are they impacting what's happening now with even just like the sector, you know, outlooks and things like that?

That's right. Yeah. So these major companies, you mentioned Apple and Amazon, and you have Microsoft and Google and Facebook. All of these are not only big in terms of stock market capitalization, but they're also huge earnings producers.

And despite their enormous sizes, they also have impressive growth numbers still. So these are companies that still produce double digit top line growth and in multiples of that on the bottom line. So very strong growth in the technology sector. In fact, of the many areas that effectively took the pandemic in the stride and didn't show any major slowdown or impact on profitability technology has to stand out in there.

And it's actually the we all use technology even before the pandemic, but the fact that technology enabled us to continue operating and continue working and not have to have to commute to work and not have to have the regular interactions that we had always associated with normal living is just enormous. So that trend continues. And technology is a major group producer in 2021 and beyond as well. Yeah.

So I think people are always surprised to hear because I've tweeted this little stat that you included in your earnings articles about how Apple earnings actually declined 3.9% in the third quarter and Intel's were down 22%. So between those two, they actually pulled down the entire sector from it would have been 20.4. And then if you strip those two guys out, well, no, it was 12.6. If you strip them out, you got 20.4% earnings growth just by removing those two companies.

That's right. Yeah. So Apple and Intel were drags on the overall technology sector growth into three. And the picture is actually a lot better once you take those companies out.

And that's actually not unusual for the sector. All these other companies in the sector, the Googles, the Microsofts, the Facebooks and many others have been doing extremely well. But when you look at consensus estimates for Q4, for Q1, 21, for fully or 21 and beyond, that shows continued momentum from the technology sector. And that's one of the reasons why just getting back to the earlier discussion we had about valuation that unlike 99 and 2000s where there was a lot of hot air and a lot of hopes and dreams about these stocks, the big winners of the stock market in the recent past have been companies that are enormously profitable and generate a ton of revenues.

Right. They're actually executing on like 1999. That's right. One of them to execute in 1999.

We hoped in the coming years they would be executing and now that now they are. That's right. Basically. Okay.

What about the S&P 600, the small caps? Because they're suddenly hot. We've talked about them before when we've done this podcast on the earnings, but I don't think many people are really paying that much attention because all they do care about it was for the hot caps. But now after the hottest month ever for the small caps in November here, suddenly I'm kind of interested.

So do we see a similar bullish outlook for their earnings in 2021 as well? Yes, but for different reasons. So the one difference that we have to keep in mind when we are thinking of the small caps versus the large caps is the composition of how the indexes are designed. So the S&P 600 or the rest of the 2000, which are kind of like the proxies for the small cap, technology is not as big of a deal as it is for the large caps.

And the chances, energy is medical is. And the outlook for those, while not as strong as it is for the large caps, is a lot better than what we have seen over the last many years. So, if we just look at the pure growth numbers, the S&P 600, 2020 earnings are on track to be done. We still don't have the Q4 numbers yet.

We have the first three quarters and estimates for Q4. So the 2020 earnings are on track to be down 29.4%, but 2021 earnings are expected to be up 35.9%. And then there is a 20, 21% growth expected in 2022 as well. So a very strong growth spurt is expected for the small caps.

And one other small comment, this was related to the comment I made earlier about how the risk is to the estimates being revised higher. If that thesis plays out, that will have an even more pronounced impact on the small caps than it would have on the large caps, because the small caps are a more domestic centric businesses than they are for the large caps. Okay. And how does it play in that there's not as much analyst coverage of the small caps?

Does that mean they're going to be not cautious, but is that going to skew what we see going forward even more so than the large caps? Will, are they underestating what the small caps are going to do just because there isn't quite as much people looking into it? It makes life difficult for folks like us who are in the business of keeping track of these companies. And this is the reality that there is a lot less coverage for the small caps.

Let's hope that the sunshine that the group has started getting in recent days is not just a fleeting phenomenon and it's something enduring. It will continue in 2021. The reality is that for regular investors, the opportunity of finding real gems and making real money is in the small caps. Yeah.

These are the companies that are that have still to be found. Everybody knows about Apple. Everybody knows about Google and all the other amazing companies that are there. And 80 of those large caps are covered by 20, 30, 40 analysts.

So the opportunity to make gains that are above anybody's expectation is a lot less over there than it is in these small caps. So hopefully if there is a lot more interest in these companies, if these stocks are going up, if they gain more weightage in the market, there will be enough demand in the marketplace to force these brokerage firms to devote more attention to these stocks. Yeah. Okay.

So on that note, let me ask you this. One, Zack's top 10 stock portfolio that comes out in early January every year and it's your top 10 stocks of the year that you pick. I never know. Nobody knows what you're doing with it.

But given your analysis that you just gave, are you looking more at some of the smaller cap type companies for the list going into 2021 versus the large caps? Yes. That's always been my desire and interest in picking stocks that are not household names to begin with. If you look at the top 10 portfolios for the last many years, the bulk of the stocks would be in that category.

And while you brought it up, Tracy, we had some amazing performance in 2020. The top performing stock in the portfolio is up 400%. What? Wow.

What? Tell me what it is. It's a company called C Limited SE. This is the equivalent of an Amazon in Southeast Asia.

And then we have another stock that's up 200%. That's Dokusign. Oh, yeah. Okay.

So just to be clear, you bought that in January 2020, Dokusign. That's right. So around this time, around this time last year, I'm currently in the process of putting together the list for 2021. So around this time last year, I shortlisted this portfolio.

And there were a couple of other names on my short list that I didn't pick. So Teladak was one of them. And so it's, it's, it's, it's, so yes, getting back to your question, small caps, provide the best opportunity for outperformance for all of us, for those of us who are in the business of doing this, like, like you and I, but for regular investors, saving for their retirement, it is the small caps that a lot of the people are not talking about. And if you do see your research on the opportunity of picking stocks that will grow for years and years to come, is it not higher there than with an apple or in video?

Yeah, I've always said as well as, you know, the fame names or fame men or whatever you want to call them, the big cap guys are doing. And it's been phenomenal what they've been able to, the growth rates that they're still doing. But eventually, alphabet won't be able to grow those revenues 20% here anymore. I'm shocked they're still doing it 20 years on, but eventually that will slow.

It just will. So yeah, to find that kind of growth, you have to go to these small, small caps. I've got a couple small caps in my value investor portfolio that I'm surprised at how well they're doing, but the small caps in general now have exploded. So it's being caught up in some of that momentum, but it only has one estimate on it on sex.com.

So and you know, very few people follow it on stock, but it's no one knows what it is, you know, but it's those types of companies. If we're going to see a boom come out of this pandemic that are really going to see big growth. Yes. And this morning, there was a no from Goldman Sachs, which made me feel good about this thesis.

I've been having for a while that the likelihood of the recovery in 2021 could potentially be stronger than all of us are projecting Goldman 2021 GDP growth estimate is 5.3%. The consensus number is 3.8%. So the a lot of the reasons they give for being so out of the range for consensus are along the lines of I will be discussed earlier that this is a different type of recovery. The nature of the pullback was different.

The forces holding the economy down were different. And as we come out of it with the help of vaccines and therapeutics, the impact that will have on us as consumers and households and companies would be different than what we are used to seeing coming out of the sessions. Yeah, for sure. Okay.

Well, I'm excited about your new top 10 now. I always get excited, but now that you're you're talking about the process and all that, I'm interested to see what's going to be on that list. So anyone out there, if you're interested, it launches at the beginning of January. So go on to x.com, you'll see ads on their way.

You can sign up so you can get the new top 10. And then they'll still see what happens to the old top 10. Is that still on there or does that go away immediately? So it'll it remains through the end of the year.

So the one that we were discussing earlier, that is that is on the site currently and it should be there. Okay. And I think if they if they do like one of the trials or something like that, they could see they could see this and other portfolios. Okay.

Well, that's good to know because does sound like things are looking like they could be very bullish in 2021. Yes. Yes, I agree. Yeah, I just listened in on the conference call for toll brothers and it was so bullish in this last quarter for them that they were intentionally slowing their business.

They were like restricting how many homes that certain sales centers could sell because they don't want to get too many orders because then their backlog is like, you know, it puts a strain on the rest of the business because they don't necessarily have enough construction workers and the land and you need the electricians and the plumber guys and all that. And so they were intentionally trying to restrain some of it. I haven't heard anybody talk about that. That's right.

Yeah, we'll see. They see these trends going on in 2021 and that's what also I feel makes it very different from a normal type of recession because you don't see housing doing that during a recession. So we already have certain areas of the economy, you know, doing really well as we get those vaccines and all of that. Okay.

So if you're interested in buying the small caps and you don't want to necessarily buy individual stocks to, I always recommend the ETFs. There are a couple of small cap ETFs out there. There's the iShares small cap ETF. It's IJR and then there's the S&P small cap 600 ETF, which would track what we were just talking about the S&P 600.

That's SLY and then there's the Russell 2000, which is obviously 2000 stocks instead of 600 and that's IWM. And then we also mentioned a couple other stocks here today, Apple, AAPL, Intel, INTC. And then at the end here, a couple that are in the ZACS top 10 right now, SE is C limited, so that's right. It's the DocuSign DOCU Teladoc is at TDOC Teladoc.

And so yeah, be sure to check out that top 10 because that's always a fun portfolio and it had a great year this year. And even the year before that, I just always check out because it's always interesting to see what names make that list. And as always, you need to subscribe so you can get all of our podcasts here at ZACS and Market Edge because we're going to be covering everything that we see, maybe coming down the Pike here in 2021 over the next couple of weeks. So you can get us on SoundCOD, of course, and many of you are on there, but we are on Spotify and we're on Apple Podcasts.

But get us somewhere and I'll see you again next week with some more stocks. This material is being provided for informational purposes only and nothing herein constitutes investment, legal, accounting or tax advice or a recommendation to buy, sell or hold a security. Do not act or rely upon the information and advice given in this podcast without seeking the services of competent and professional legal tax or accounting counsel. Publication and distribution of this podcast is not intended to create any information contained herein does not constitute an attorney-client relationship.

No recommendation or advice is being given as to whether any investment or strategy is suitable for a particular investor. It will not be assumed that any investment in securities, companies, sectors and markets identified as described were or will be profitable. All information is current as of the date herein and is subject to change without notice. Any views or opinions expressed may not reflect those of ZACS and doesn't research as a whole.

The Investor's Podcast (We Study Billionaires) - The Investor’s Podcast Network The Investor's Podcast Network Hosted by Stig Brodersen, William Green, Shawn O'Malley, Daniel Mahncke, and Kyle Grieve, The Investor’s Podcast has proudly reached nearly 200 million downloads, as the world's largest stock-investing focused podcast. On the show, we study a range of businesses and their investment prospects, from Spotify to Amazon, serial acquirers like Constellation Software, deep value plays, and more, using lessons from some of the world's most famous investors, like Warren Buffett, Charlie Munger, and Howard Marks. Leverage the lessons we learned from studying, and talking to, the wo Capital Ideas podcast Capital Group Want to learn how professional investors do it? The Capital Ideas podcast brings you the latest investment thinking from Capital Group, one of the world's largest investment management organizations. Each week we'll get inside the minds of portfolio managers, analysts and economists to break down market trends, macroeconomic forces, investing approaches and lessons learned from personal experience. Take 30 minutes and tap into the intellectual capital of Capital Group. Capital Client Group, Inc.All Capital Group trademarks mentioned are owned by The Capital Group Companies, Inc., an affiliated company or fund. All other company and product names mentioned are the property of their respective companies.For full disclosures go to capitalgroup.com/global-disclosures. Growth Triggers: Content Marketing & AI Luis Diaz Discover how to use your podcast to generate leads, sales, and influence in any market. On this show Luis shares his best tested and proven secrets, tips, and strategies from launching over 300 podcasts in over a dozen different niches and generating over 59 Million Downloads for his clients. Learn how to increase your podcast listenership, create multiple new revenue streams with your podcast, sell more of your core offer and build a show that gives you leverage and authority in your space. From picking the right monetization strategy for your podcast to learning how to position your podcast in a crowded market on Apple and Spotify; this is show is the ultimate marketing and sales resource for online business owners who want to know what works with podcasting. Get in touch over on Instagram <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow" class="link" href="https://www.instagram.com/luisr

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Zacks Market Edge?

This episode is 33 minutes long.

When was this Zacks Market Edge episode published?

This episode was published on December 9, 2020.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Zacks Market Edge episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.