I'm Brian Myers. I'm Mike Ritalik. I'm Becky Hiread. And this is Al pellets, a podcast featuring tips for ad teachers.
We are your agricultural education resource across the web, sharing research based tips and tackling the tough questions facing agriculture teachers every day. Hey, Al pellets. This is Brian with Becky and Mike and we are here by the Al pellet once again having outstanding conversations with colleagues from around the country we have with us today from the Commonwealth of Kentucky, Dr. Stacy Vincent.
Stacy, thanks for being with us today here on Al pellets. Whoo. I love you here. That's what people need to do.
Sometimes we get kind of hesitant kind of thing. Jump right in there. I love it. I mean, you said we're by the pal pellet.
So what's where you walk? We just started here. Stacy, why don't you go ahead and tell her about yourself and maybe you're a co-author for this paper. Yeah.
Stacy Vincent, professor over here at the University of Kentucky in agricultural education taught high school for seven years. I'm actually from Kentucky. You know, it's always rare when you're at a university and you actually have somebody that's from the state there and taught high school seven years in bourbon country. So in the outside of town, little town called Bardstown and my wife and I and our kids, we we farm.
Our farm is about two hours away back. Actually, I have taken over the, the grandparents place and a farm I bought in 2002 and that that overlooks my grandparents place. So we farm and coach soccer and everything else in between my wife was canning jelly yesterday. And so we were, we're, we're, we're at Jack of all trades and a master of none.
So what do you do to keep busy Stacy? I'm trying to pick up a few hobbies. That's great. Thanks, Stacy.
So as we get started, why don't you give us a quick overview of the topic for today and then we'll jump right in. 20 of the most progressive countries in the, in the world right now are really saying that there is a phenomenon that they're worried about and it is the, and it is the, the rate of males and their, their performance in schools right now. And so it's not just an ag thing. It's not just a US thing.
It's not just a rural thing. It's actually a global occurrence. And to me, if, if Ag can't have success with males, then I don't know who really can in, in public schools. And so Brett Wozden, the co-author of this, he came, came to us and it interests, his interest was, he just really wanted to see what, what was going on with boys and what could we do to help.
And he was really interested more in FFA. Why, why boys weren't becoming officers and, and it's so much of a deeper issue than just, just leadership roles and so forth. And, and so I had this, I had this idea for a quasi experimental design and it really spun from when I taught high school. When I taught high school, the PE teacher quit allowing female students and male students to take PE together.
And his, his thought was that, well, girls wouldn't participate in PE because they didn't want to get hot and sweaty in front of the boys. And then the boys didn't want to really get too competitive in, in case they got embarrassed in front of the girls. They literally created all the PE was separated. All the female students took PE and all the male students took PE.
And I really thought that was, it was really phenomenal how the students performed differently in his PE class. So I'd always been chewing on this. So here I had a, a eager grad student saying, Hey, this is not interested in. So he and I sit down and he, he re he enrolled in a quasi experimental design class with an N of one taught by me.
So I just, I literally bought him at he and I the book and we, I should have enrolled myself and we taught each other. I went through the entire book. We called a couple of folks out there in the profession that had done some quasi experimental design. Whenever there was a question, we were like, okay, what do you think of this?
And then we met with, we contacted every school in the aesthetic in Commonwealth. I appreciate you noticing that Brian and Commonwealth that had a male and a female I have teacher. And we, I think it ended up around 40 schools. And we asked them if they would be willing to participate.
And of those, there's a little under 20 that had permission from their school to come to a listening session. So we met it the FFA camp. We talked with them. And there were a few that dropped out then.
And then several that were like, yeah, we want to, we want to see what this happened. And one of the mutual things was everyone in the room was concerned about what we were interested in. Not, and it wasn't just, I don't want to say our entire concern was about boys. Our concern was about the difference of maturity at the, at the freshman level.
And, and so we ended up, we started off, I think with maybe 12 or 14 teachers agreed. And we literally grew straws and the ones with the short straw ended up being our control group. And they just continued to teach intro to AG the way they always had students. They didn't know any different except that we were tracking all of their stuff that the school put into Infinite Campus, which was their attendance rate to the behavioral issues, concerns, tardiness, and academic performance.
And then the other, the other teachers, they separated male and female. The female students took the female teacher, all the male students took the male teacher. They, most of them just taught it at the exact same time. And then they just went to one room and to the other.
We, the school offered a third option for intro to AG ed in case a parent wanted to opt out or if a kid was really questioning their, their identity. And but that, that never happened. We didn't have a single parent drop out. I mean, this tells you how many parents were actually really interested in this.
And we never had a kid say, you know, hey, this doesn't fit me. And, and I would also tell you that it was really interesting. Of course, summer happens. And then a teacher becomes a principal or another teacher ends up taking another school.
So we ended up having a few schools drop out and we end up with, I think, total of 10 classrooms. So the, we started tracking, we started following it. And we also had the teachers predict what they thought would happen. We asked them, okay, you're teaching a classroom full of all males.
You're teaching a classroom full of all females. You're teaching a classroom of the way it's always been. Do you anticipate you'll have a higher attendance rate than everyone else? Do you anticipate your students will have a higher grades than everyone else?
Do you think that your students will have more discipline referrals than everyone else? And it was really interesting because students continue to perform the way the teacher predicted. So, you know, we know that, you know, if you, when you're parenting, you come in with a bad attitude, it's probably going to end up with a bad day at the house. And so these, the teachers who came in said, you know, my students are going to have higher behavioral issues.
I'm going to have a higher behavioral issues. The students performed poorly in that class. And what was very interesting to us was over the course of time, the boys actually, girls just continue to do everything. And this is the next article that's about to be published in the journal.
The boys were, they performed academically better when we pulled them away. Their attendance rate went up. Their tardiness went down. And what the next article is going to have is they began to actually consider a career in ag and ag education.
Girls that never changed. I mean, they still stayed positive. They still stayed. What it was is, Bicki already knew this.
My wife says this. Look, we're fine whether you're in this house or not. Like they're okay. They're moving on.
And, but the boys actually, when you remove that element, they improved. And that was the big phenomenon. The other one was the qualitative piece that Brett and I kick ourselves for never collecting, which was every time we walked into these classrooms, total opposite. The girls, it was like walking into step bird wives.
It was really robotic. They were all sitting in the learning position. It was dead silent. You told them the directions, they grabbed their pencil, they went to work.
They were done 20 minutes early. We almost had a female ag teacher drop out of the study because she felt so uncomfortable the first two weeks because they never talked. However, once they did start talking, we noticed that the girls talked about stuff that ag teachers had never experienced before. Female ag teachers started telling us that the girls in class would say, Miss Myers, that's one of the ag teachers.
Miss Myers, how do you know when you're dating a good guy? Or what should a person they actually look like? These were really questions about their sexuality that they really respected this female ag teacher. They saw how she was treated.
She was a mom and they wanted true advice from her on things that she's never talked to them about. That was really special. The boys was the exact opposite. We go into the room.
We never, never went into a room where we didn't give the directions at least three times. Someone always passed gas. The ag teacher themselves were part of the problem, the male ag teacher. They were joking.
They always cut up a joke. They were make fun of about three or four of them in the room. We always went 20 minutes over on time. It was just a complete opposite.
How we didn't collect this data and set up a recorder just to show you all through video expression, it was night and day. I probably went way over what you were asking there, Dr. Myers. It was a fascinating study.
Now we're looking to do another round with the state of North Carolina in Kentucky and looking at it from a variety of lenses. For example, single teachers. I think we spend a lot of time in our research. This was a male dominant profession and men taught boys.
Then slowly girls started to take the classes and men did not do a good job teaching those girls. They typically said, why don't you grade my papers. This is a shop class, whatever. But then as more and more girls started doing that, men started to adjust and then women started teaching and the women that really started into this profession did a really good job.
We have never really sit down and helped our teachers understand that there are true differences between the masculinity and femininity. The things that we do to even attract and recruit students really favor a feminine dynamic. A masculine male really doesn't see themselves in that right now. There's a lot of things, a lot of things, social and so forth.
We're seeing that at universities too. Universities are having a really hard time, especially public universities with this. That oversight and overview is really helpful, Stacy. So what?
I'm talking to ag teachers and we have ag teachers listening to this. So what can we do to help? What did you tease out that we might be able to use in our local programs to make a difference? Yeah.
So there are two big things I was telling some teachers in a professional development the other day where I said we are way too impatient with males. And that has sort of society as well. Some countries are actually beginning kindergarten at different age groups now. So girls are starting at the regular five and six while boys are coming in at six and seven to help with that in the United States.
And this is scary. The American Psychological Association and I'm sorry, Dr. Talk. I will answer your question, but I need you to understand this part first.
We're having to battle this. The American Psychological Association is removing because of toxic masculinity, which was a thing in the 60s and 70s. They are removing when they counsel young men competitiveness, aggression and stoic. They're not removing that from girls, by the way.
And this is really, really disappointing for me. Alabama football coach was very vocal about why are we removing competitiveness from young men and the military has been very, very vocal about why are we removing aggression from the counseling of young men. And there's a lot of women movements who have said, why are we removing stoic from men, young men? Because these are the things that athletes, FFA, you love a kid that's competitive.
The military, we want someone who's willing to take that heal in battle and females, the number one thing they're attracted to men according to psychology is their confidence in themselves. So when you remove that, we also, when you throw in that we're impatient with students in our classroom, we give them this, we put them in as a freshman, then we put all of our eggs in the kid who gets active very quickly. And if we're not patient with that kid, then they're already like, why would I try? And so we move on and we don't give them time to bloom when it comes around about the time they're 17, 16 or 17 years old.
The other thing is that, and Becky, I'll give you a little secret here. And this is for all the females that are actually out there that are not married. It would give you a little tip of advice. Boys, don't say we love you on our first day.
Okay. And if we did, we're lying. All right. So we don't do it.
We don't want to commit to anything because of the number one thing, the fear of rejection. There's such a fear of rejection. And so therefore, anything that hints that we could be rejected, we're not going to do it. And so what can we do in the classroom?
The worst thing is when we do the FFA creed and that girl says volunteers, she's been studying it all weekend. Becky, she walks in to say the first paragraph creed, what does she actually do? She says all five paragraphs. Well, you know, every boy in there is struggling to still get the last part of the first paragraph now.
She says all five paragraphs. And the fact to receipt and that a teacher innocently says, if you keep that up, you're going to be our chapter president one day. You just laid the groundwork for rejection. So if I fear there's an opportunity for rejection, I'm just not going to try.
I'm just not even going to try. I'm just going to get involved. I'll do my little thing, but I'm never going to tell you. I love you.
And so we have to be patient with our young men. That is the biggest thing, Dr. Ratalek. I think that also goes back a little bit when he talks to about, you know, students perform the way that teacher predicted.
I think there's some pieces that kind of tied together there and kind of back to some of the things you mentioned about parenting where if we want expect kids to behave the way kids behave, there's an opportunity for us to take a step and be like, well, they're just, they're kids. Like this is just a normal thing kids do. And I think there's something for the teacher to not take that personally. And also then an opportunity for greater patients to say, this isn't, you know, this isn't some crazy random thing that's only happening in my classroom.
This is something that that kids do. And at the same time, then being able to say, and here's the expectation, here's what I want you to be to really kind of think about how do we ask students, how do we ask students to show up and then how do we show up in a way that lets them meet that expectation? You know who's president when we pass the title line? Why are you asking me all the hard questions, Stacy?
I don't know anything. It was actually Richard Nixon. That's how long ago it's been since we passed the title line. And so to make your point, what you just said is look at what happened when our focus and attention really put higher expectation on girls' performance.
They did it. They met our expectation. And we put no interest. We just assumed boys would not change.
But when we put our attention away from them, and I definitely don't want us to just push girls back to where they were, I just want us to have every kid performing. We need to close an academic achievement gap where girls are outperforming males in every content area, including math and science now. And because we have said, and I've heard this now for the last 20 years, not everybody was made for college. We're only saying that to one population of kids.
That's boys. And guess what? They're listening. They're meeting that expectation.
And so universities, four-year universities have seen a massive drop in male enrollment. One place that hasn't, trade schools. They've never seen a drop. So they are meeting our expectations.
Last year's graduating class, we had 21 students. Every girl in that class was dating, engaged, or married to a boy back home. Every single one of them that didn't go to college. Every single girl.
And I think we got to realize that it's starting really early. It's just not us and thinking about adolescence. It's starting at Pre-K kindergarten, first grade. I'm your first grader who's already like, I don't want to, like he's got other things he wants to do.
There's less play, there's less social activity, there's earlier expectations for reading and math, and all those kind of things. And if you're not developmentally ready, and other people are, and you're seeing people blow by, you're going to give up pretty quickly. And so it's ingrained at an early stage. But I like there's a, I hadn't put that way before, but having patience with the boys.
I think that's an interesting way to put it, and I appreciate you sharing that with us. And really appreciate the work you and your folks are doing here. And as you alluded, there's more to come. I think this is an important conversation that the profession needs to be having, because we've been talking about this in the hallways, in the teacher lounges, in the ag-teacher conferences, behind the scenes of time to really have this conversation.
I'm thinking as we continue to expand little school programs, and now we're talking about elementary ag programs, what does that look from the psychological and development of youth, and boys. So I appreciate you being with us today here, Stacy, on Outbellent. We hope you've enjoyed this episode of Outbellets. Check out our website for more information on this topic, and to learn more about our guests.
Follow us on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram to stay connected, and be sure to subscribe to our podcast so you'll never miss an episode. For Mike and Becky, this is Brian here by The Outbellets, saying thank you, and we look forward to seeing you again on another episode of Outbellets, Tips for Ag Teachers.