Hey there, listeners. It's Tablet Director of Production Josh Cross. The team behind Unorthodox wanted to bring you something special today called Tablet Radio Hour. In this edition, we're featuring Tablet's Minion. Straight out of the pages of Tablet Magazine, the Minion series highlights the specific opinions of 10 Jews gathered together to discuss a singular topic. Today, you'll hear about a Minion gathered to talk about why they're voting for Kamala Harris. And then another Minion of Jews who have decided to cast their votes this election for Donald Trump. You can read what both of these Minions, or Minionim, had to say on TabletMag.com, but the link will be in the show notes.
But for now, stick around here to hear a behind-the-scenes conversation from Tablet Magazine executive editor Wayne Hoffman, editorial assistant Jamie Bitesh-Carter, and journalist and author Abigail Pogrebin about what goes into making the Minion. These Minions are always full of surprises, and this special election-themed series was no exception. Here's Wayne. This is Wayne Hoffman. We began The Minion about two years ago as a series of roundtables with quote-unquote everyday people talking about particular demographic groups and how they do or don't feel welcome in the American Jewish community at large. Over the past two years, we've talked to a wide range of people. LGBTQ Jews, Black Jews, converts, non-Jewish spouses of Jews, disabled Jews. The list goes on.
But this fall, we decided to do something different. Instead of talking about demographic groups with relatively fixed issues to discuss, we decided to look at people voting and how they're voting and why in this very important presidential election coming up in November. There was no way to do one. We had to do two. So we reached out to do one minion with Jewish voters who are planning to vote for Kamala Harris and another with Jewish voters planning to vote for Donald Trump.
The first trick was finding the people to talk to. We don't just reach out to 10 people to form a minion and go from there. The process actually takes quite a while. Sometimes it's very challenging to find 10 people. Other times we have an abundance to choose from. Our editorial assistant, Jamie Pitesh Carter, is the person behind all of this. The woman behind the scenes making all of this work, finding people, analyzing who should be in the group, who shouldn't be in the group, what issues need to be addressed, et cetera. So Jamie, I wanted to bring you on board to talk about how we found people for these two minions in particular.
We launched a short survey and we distributed it just through our social media platforms. And in a matter of five days, we received over 200 responses. And that was right before the presidential debate on September 10th. So everyone who responded, responded before then. And what we found was really, really fascinating. We asked people, you know, who they were, where they live, you know, a little bit about their Jewish background. And we really did get quite a mix from people who identify as traditional Orthodox to just Jewish with really no affiliation other than a really big variety of ages as well. You know, people as young as 19 voting for the first time.
to people well into their 80s. Okay, so what did we hear? We had, very interestingly, about 50% more responses voting for Harris than Trump. So I separated the two groups and started looking into what was going on there. We did not have clearly defined two groups of people who are Republicans voting for the Republican candidate and people who are Democrats voting for the Democratic candidate. What did we have? We looked at the Harris voters. We did have a little bit more of a clear cut group. About 77% of those who responded that they plan to vote for Harris are registered Democrats. 13% were registered independent, 3% were registered Republican, and 7% were no party.
But when we looked at their voting history, right, we asked who they voted for in the last two elections. Ninety eight percent voted for Biden in 2020 and 94 percent voted for Clinton in 2016. So we had a little bit of a variety there, but we had more or less, you know, a pretty Democratic group and people who historically vote for the Democratic candidates. And did that line up in a parallel on the other side at all? No, it didn't at all. And this was where it got really interesting.
Only 45% of those who plan to vote for Trump are registered Republicans. 24% are registered Democrats, 20% independents, and 9% no party. And even more interesting, when we look back at their voting history, 65% who voted in the last election voted for Trump, and 60% who voted in 2016 voted for Trump. So this was really quite different. We were talking to two different groups of people with two different types of voting history. And I think as Abby starts telling about the discussion, I might pop back in to discuss why that is, why we have so many different voters. I'll just say one last thing before going to Abby. In comparison, we had a lot of people who previously voted for the Democratic candidate in the Trump group. We had one person out of the 120 people planning to vote for Harris that previously voted for Trump. And I'll pass it on to Abby. Yeah, so Abigail Pogrebin is the moderator of all of our minions, which is quite a Herculean task.
If you've ever tried to interview one person or talk to two people, you'll appreciate how challenging it is to talk to 10 or 12 at once and to do so succinctly and get people talking without contradicting each other or turning into just a melee. And Abby is really a pro at this. So Abby, after we got all of these people filling out forms and applying to be considered for the minions, we narrowed it down to two groups, one for the Trump voters, one for the Harris voters, roughly a dozen people or so in each group. I think we ended up with 12 and one and 11 and the other who we selected who could make it to the discussion. they're broadly representative of the larger trends that Jamie just described. They may not be representative of larger trends in the American voting public or even the Jewish American voting public, but they did represent what we found in our groups. So Abby, once you had a chance to sit down and talk to these two groups, what did you notice about the two groups and how they were alike and how they were different? Well, I would say, first of all, this was such an education and to do these back-to-back in one day was revelatory in a certain way. I would say just the main headline kind of in neon is October 7th. October 7th.
really orients each group kind of a little bit differently, but particularly for the Trump voters, is what many of them described as a day they woke up, October 7th and afterwards. That language of a wake-up call, of I woke up, was recurring in the Trump group in particular of, I'm a Jew, is this person going to care about Jews? That was just really stark to me. Maybe I should have expected it, but more, I think, than anticipated. So I would just start with the Trump group and say it was marked that 10 out of 12 said their main driver was Israel and the Middle East in terms of their votes. 10 out of 12. And all but one.
thought that Trump was going to be good for Israel. The highest voters, only two thought that Trump was for sure going to be good for Israel and the others were on the fence or the answer was no. So that was just something I would just start with and maybe just pause there as a main difference. Was that surprising to you to see how stark the difference was? I think it was just surprising how either animating or galvanizing this issue and this fear is. I would say that the other thing that was, I'll just read one quote that kind of encapsulates many of them. And this came from someone named Alana.
She said, I'm supporting Trump because I think he's better for Israel. And I feel like if somebody can't be good for Israel, how can they be good on anything else? If they're not good for the Jews, if they're not good for Israel, that touches on everything else. That was really kind of encapsulation of it being kind of an organizing principle through which they saw every other issue. What I would say, just in terms of...
the surprise of the Trump voters is they don't really like their candidate very much. There was, when we asked for adjectives to describe the person they were voting for, they were almost uniformly negative. And that contrasted with the Kamala, with the Harris voters, where they had plenty that was positive to say about her. And just to give an example of what the adjectives were, just again, on one foot, we said, you know, one or two words we asked them to describe, for the Trump voters to describe their candidate, and it was mercurial, God help us, obnoxious, competent and annoying, my last resort. In fairness, someone named Brent said, competent and decisive.
Isaac said, the lesser of two evils. That was really kind of consistent. I will just say about the Trump voter, the other thing that was stark for me was how negative they were about Harris. And really with the same two criticisms. One, really insubstantial, unsubstantial, whatever is the correct word, ill-equipped, devoid of her own ideas, spineless, easily influenced, empty, hollow. These are their words. That really was quite consistent in the Trump supporters and even in the Harris supporters.
I think just that her, I guess, either her lack of opportunity or inability to really say where she is strongly on the Middle East and Israel rattled them a bit, but it was not decisive in the end. Now, I know we asked each group mostly the same questions, but occasionally we asked them sort of mirrored questions. And one of the mirrored questions we asked each group was how their decision would or wouldn't be different if there were a different candidate running in the other party. So we asked the Harris voters how it would be different if the candidate weren't Trump that they're facing, but perhaps Nikki Haley or DeSantis or someone else. And we asked the Trump voters how it would be different if they weren't facing Kamala Harris.
Joe Biden. What did you learn from those questions? I think for the Harris voters, they would have actually possibly been swayed by a Nikki Haley, for instance. They at least wanted, they wish they'd had the opportunity, quite a few of them, to consider a Nikki Haley or an alternative. And they were very conscious of the fact that they never had that opportunity. They didn't say, and therefore I would have voted for Haley. They said more like, I never had a spectrum. I never had an alternative. For the Trump voter, it was absolutely the case that even though they conceded that Biden's cognitive skills had declined, they said he was unquestionably
much more stalwart on the Middle East, on foreign policy, on Israel. They could trust him more as being a champion for Jewish causes. Jamie, I know that some people did bring up the issue of Kamala Harris being a woman running for president. How did that come through in people's responses? So we did see some excitement about that. And, you know, I think we have to think in context. She, you know, has run a very abbreviated campaign, right? This is not a traditional way of being voted into being the candidate. But we did have some people really be excited that they're having another chance to vote for a woman as president. And they do see her as someone who could change history.
You know, she's, you know, a child of immigrants herself. She's, as they said, not a rambling old man, nor a crazed leftist that the MAGA complex can target. You know, they do sort of see her as the candidate of change. And again, these are the people who are planning to vote for her. And so I just want to make sure we highlight that even though that people aren't completely enthusiastic about voting for her, they do find some hope in what she's been able to show people over the last two months, if it's been that long. Well, I'm 53. I've lived through several elections. Others have lived through more, others fewer.
But there's been a recurring statement that I've heard every four years that this is the year the Jewish vote is going to trend Republican. It's going to happen. It's going to happen this year. This year, it's really, really going to happen. There are two ways to look at this question right now. Again, we're looking based on polls.
But on the one hand, it seems that it's true that Jewish voters have trended more Republican in the past few elections, and that Donald Trump, in particular, picked up about 24% of the Jewish vote in 2016, about 30% in 2020, and looks, according to polls, to pick up slightly more in this election. So on the one hand, it does appear that the Jewish vote has trended more Republican than it has in the past few decades. But at the same time, it is always a distinct minority of the Jewish vote, and that seems to be likely to be the case. Again, that Jews vote Democratic by more than a two-to-one margin, sometimes a three-to-one margin. Do you, based on what you heard, and what you read either from the people who participated or, Jamie, even from the people who just filled out forms, do you see a sense of movement, not just people voting the way that they always vote, but people changing their votes? I know, Jamie, you had alluded before that we saw more people who were voting for Trump this time who had not voted Republican in the past two elections. What kind of movement did you see or did you hear about, Abby, from people's responses? I mean, I would say there's definitely movement from those who would have voted Democrat before and now suddenly feel like there's something existential that is at stake in terms of the Jewish future. And I don't just mean Israel. I should have...
I should have mentioned that they're talking about the campus protests. They're talking about DEI, a general sense that kind of the liberals have abandoned us and we need to kind of stand with our own. So I think there will be movement there. I noticed one of the Trump voters had said about Trump, and I'm quoting, I don't think he's a great model, but I don't need a model for president. That's not where I look for righteous people. It's a great quote. I think the other thing, Wayne, that I should have mentioned is that for the Harris voters, there was this sense of their Jewish values being applied to Trump and him failing them. And that meant...
characteristics around decency, compassion, kindness that kept coming up and that for them and their perspective, Trump betrayed those values and he was never going to exemplify the kind of human being that they want their children and that they stand for in America to be. Yeah, I'll jump in and say when I was sort of dissecting the responses to the survey, seeing Harris as a more ethical person simply was the reason why some of the respondents said that they're voting for her instead of Trump. I'll just read another response because the alternative is completely untenable to me. So that was their response to why they're voting for Harris, simply. But they didn't have to justify anything else. Whereas when we when we looked at the Trump responses, you know, you asked about movement, Wayne, you know, that's literally what we saw in the numbers. Less than half of the people planning to vote for Trump are registered Republicans. So they're voting outside their party. They're moving, you know, pretty far from where they've been before. And, you know, when we looked at the Trump responses, you know, I saw a lot of people.
grappling with us. Like in their two to three sentences that we asked them to write, they felt they needed to say, I'm really struggling, but this is what I'm doing. Sort of defending their behavior. And, you know, I think they understand why other people can understand why. But even though people said, we had one person say, I voted for Trump in 2016. I immediately regretted that decision. I was planning to actually vote Democratic. And I think Biden dropping out of the race at this point changed that for a lot of people, but they're actually voting for Trump again. And so this grappling, this struggle, you know, I just want to highlight it. We didn't have two different groups of like gung ho Trump, gung ho Harris. We have.
two groups of people where a lot of them are grappling and struggling with this decision. And many don't know the right answer and don't feel that they, you know, strongly believe in what will happen or what they can do to make it happen. We haven't mentioned the economy, which is obviously a huge driver. There's just one quote I want to mention because it gave us a laugh from Stephen. A Trump voter said, my friend says Biden has made him stronger because it doesn't take him as much effort to lift $100 worth of groceries anymore. That there really is a sense that the economy is, you know, is problematic under the Biden administration. And also.
On the Harris side, reproductive rights felt like a Jewish value and immigration felt like a Jewish value. Now, there were also people, one of the questions we asked both groups was how many of you dislike both candidates? How did people respond in both those groups, Abby? I don't have the numbers in front of me, but I will say that one consistent, I would say one consistent takeaway is that neither group is jumping up and down about the candidate that they'll be voting for. So I want to wrap this up since it's almost time to vote. In fact, in a lot of places you can already vote. I've already voted. Me too. We closed out this.
this minion for each group with a sort of hypothetical thought question, which is, if you had to explain this election to your real or imagined future grandchildren, how would you describe it? What did people have to say to that question, Abby? And did you see any difference between how people interpreted this as an election to explain to generations to come? Yeah. I mean, first of all, I think that there did feel like this was a turning point. I know people say this is the most important election ever all the time, but there felt like there was a gravity to this in all of their answers. I will say that just Ariel, who was one of our Harris voters, said...
Donald Trump is a bad person. I would not want him to be your boyfriend. This is her talking to her hypothetical grandchild. I would not want him to be your boyfriend, your husband, your boss, your business partner, your neighbor. I think the American people have forgotten that choosing politicians who are decent people is important. That really was a through line, I would say, for the Harris voter. And, you know, for the Trump voter, it was very much like I made this decision for...
the Jewish people for our Jewish future. That was a huge takeaway in what many of their responses were to their grandchildren. I'm worried. I'm worried for you. I want to thank both of you, first of all, for being here today, but also for all of your work on this and all the minions. It was your idea. Wayne, you have to give yourself credit. I'll take some credit. This was my idea at the beginning. It has turned out marvelously. I encourage all listeners to have a read, not of one, but of both, please, one at a time, side by side, the Harris and the Trump. One of the advantages to doing these two separately, as I told all of our participants at the beginning of each minion, is this is not a debate. Everyone else on this call.
agrees with you. They're all voting for the same person. So we don't need to have people debating. And I think what that does is it lets people simply relax and explain who they're voting for and why. So if you're looking for people simply explaining their reasoning for their vote, even if it's not the vote that you would make, if you just want to understand why, without people screaming at each other or demonizing each other or calling each other names, these two minions would be a great place to start. I hope you will have a chance to read both of them. And then maybe after election day, if you want to take your mind off it and think about something else, please go back to our archives and read all the other minions that Jamie and Abby have helped us with over the past two years. Thanks so much for joining us.
To find the entire archives of the Minion, including the two most recent, please visit tabletmag.com slash minion.