Tape #004: Secret Mixtape Vol. 1 – I Still Know the "Liquid Dreams" Dance

Welcome back to I Killed My Tamagotchi!Tommy James and Alex "A-Town" Ryan kick off the first-ever Secret Mixtape, each bringing ten guilty pleasure songs to the table but with only ten spots available, every pick has to earn its place. Along the way, they debate what truly qualifies as a guilty pleasure, defend some questionable favorites, and try to build the ultimate nostalgic playlist.Plus, "Where Were We When?" rewinds to June 28, 1997, another Heartthrob email delivers a brand-new clue, and the nostalgia keeps rolling.Press play... because every mixtape tells a story.