Skip to content
Thanks, But No Thanks episode artwork

Oct 12, 2026 58 min

Thanks, But No Thanks

from Practical(ly) Pastoring Hosted by Practically Pastoring

What do you do when somebody hands you the keys to a church for the first time? And what do you do when you are interviewing with a church and realize you absolutely do not want the keys? This week Andrew, Tim, and Jeff tackle two questions from opposite ends of the pastoral hiring process. First, a bivocational pastor in his 40s has just been appointed lead pastor of a church of around 200 people after the previous pastor left burned out. He has a decade of college ministry experience but has never led an entire church before. The guys talk about why his first 90 days should be more about listening than changing, clarifying authority with the elders, learning the church’s history and unspoken traditions, reviewing budgets and bylaws, protecting sermon-prep and pastoral-care capacity, and building sustainable rhythms before he inherits the same expectations that burned out the last pastor. They also discuss tactical versus strategic changes, low-hanging wins, using existing sermons, building trust with volunteers, and why the healthiest first act of leadership may simply be refusing to become another burned-out pastor. Then the conversation shifts to a pastor who has been job hunting for six months and has already withdrawn from four church searches. How honest should you be when a church asks, “But why?” The guys talk about when a simple “this is not the right fit” is enough, when feedback might actually help a search committee, how to describe red flags without attacking people, why compensation is absolutely a legitimate reason to walk away, and why search firms or denominational leaders may be the safest place to give more candid feedback. Tim shares the hiring side of the process, Jeff tells the story of flying to Montana only to discover the compensation would not work, and Andrew shares a memorable story about a candidate backing out after one very confusing lunch. The takeaway: clarity is kindness, but kindness does not mean you owe everyone every thought you had during the interview. Join more than 1,500 pastors and ministry leaders in the Practically Pastoring Facebook Community for real questions about church leadership, hiring, preaching, conflict, and the things seminary somehow forgot to cover. Don’t do ministry alone. SPONSOR Thanks to our friends at Church Merch for supporting Practically Pastoring. For volunteer shirts, mugs, banners, tumblers, event gear, welcome materials, and more, visit promotionsguy.com/churchmerch. Church Merch, merch for your church.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Thanks, But No Thanks

0:00 58:59

No transcript yet.

Requests help us decide what to transcribe next.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Practical(ly) Pastoring?

This episode is 58 minutes long.

When was this Practical(ly) Pastoring episode published?

This episode was published on October 12, 2026.

Can I download this Practical(ly) Pastoring episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.