Skip to content
That Which Agitates episode artwork

May 10, 2024 10 min

That Which Agitates

from The Daily Vedantic Hosted by James Beshara

James explores the ancient philosophy of Advaita Vedanta, exploring the concept of sin and agitation. Drawing from the wisdom found in the Vedas, the host contrasts Eastern philosophy with Western notions of sin and punishment. Rather than a cosmic judge tallying sins, Advaita Vedanta defines sin as that which agitates the inner peace. Through thought-provoking examples and reflections, listeners are invited to consider the repercussions of their actions and the profound satisfaction of aligning with what one ought to do. Ultimately, the episode emphasizes the intrinsic reward of inner peace and alignment with oneself and the universe, leaving listeners with a timeless mantra: "Nothing feels as good as doing what we ought to do." The Daily Vedantic is a daily podcast and YouTube channel dedicated to the timeless wisdom of the Upanishads (⁠https://www.thedailyvedantic.co⁠). Dating back to over 5,000 years ago, the source of nearly all Eastern Philosophy, and loved by Western giants from Emerson to Thoreau to Carl Jung and Alan Watts, studied daily by Joseph Campbell to Aldous Huxley to Arthur Schopenhauer and countless others, The Daily Vedantic aims to make this ancient philosophy as modern and accessible as it is simple, practical — and profound. James Beshara (⁠https://www.twitter.com/jamesbeshara⁠) is a renowned startup founder of multiple companies, a prolific startup investor in 200+ others including some of the biggest startup names on the planet, a husband and father of three little girls, and philosophy student and teacher in Los Angeles. James also co-hosts Yoga For Your Intellect (⁠https://www.YFYI.co⁠), a biweekly long-form conversational podcast with his teacher Joseph Emmett ( ⁠https://www.instagram.com/yogaforyourintellect⁠ ). James is a student of Swami Parthasarathy, the acclaimed author of Vedanta Treatise (⁠Vedanta Treatise – The Eternities⁠) and teacher at Vedanta Academy in Malavli, India. As James says often, when you’re ready for the real thing, Swami’s daily lectures are where the true wisdom and systematic discovery of the world’s oldest continually studied philosophy resides: ⁠https://www.vedantaworld.org⁠

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

That Which Agitates

0:00 10:11
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

But we are not punished for the sin, we're punished by the sin. And what happens when we do what we ought to do? As is said often, within this philosophy, nothing feels as good as doing what we ought to do. We are back with another reflection on the daily pedantic.

Today's reflection is on that which agitates. The ancient philosophy of Invite Devadonta, which comes from these four textbooks, the Vedas, that sit at the source of nearly all Eastern philosophies several, several thousand years ago. A lineage of philosophy that has continued to this day with sages and saints instead of the Western philosophy, it's all about discovering new concepts. It's really just unraveling the same concepts, perhaps for a new audience, but rediscovering them over and over again, trying to understand what the sages, saints, the masters have already said.

That is the pursuit. And within this philosophy, there's no real concept of sin that we are used to in the West, where there are rules, cosmic rules, and a cosmic judge that says, hey, you broke that rule. Now I'm going to punish you. The closest that this philosophy gets to sin is the definition of that which agitates.

In other words, you're not punished for the sin, you're punished by the sin. You put your hand in a fire. You're not punished from some cosmic judge. You're punished by the burns on your hand.

The agitation that we feel when we wrong another, when we lie and realize, oh, shit, that was expensive because they might find out and this is going to destroy or at least set back our relationship quite a bit. And I just took out a hefty expense, potential expense, if they figure it out. I hope they don't figure it out. Oh, no.

Did I even say it right? Is there, oh, are they going to talk to so and so? Oh, they might find out and it weighs on you and agitates you. It has nothing to do with the act.

And something we've said recently in episode is it's not what you do. It's what you do at four. Eating meat might be completely fine for someone. For someone else, they feel something that agitates them.

Someone might be a complete piece eating ribs, eating steak, someone else. Might have a different orientation and feel agitation when they order the exact same entree. And this philosophy says, that's not a sin if it doesn't agitate. And you can easily take it to the extreme, which people always do.

They say, well, what if you kill someone else? Well, if it agitates you, then it was a sin. If it doesn't agitate you, it's not a sin. If you're a surgeon trying to save someone's life and emergency surgery and your knife cuts the wrong thing and that person dies and you have a professional perspective of, okay, I actually know that the odds in the surgery like that, with how fast we have to move the chance for mistakes, the odds are low and that happened.

That mistake happened. But that is the work that I've signed up for every day, 10 times a day finding myself right at death store with a patient. And it is the work that I'm used to that I know that I'm good at and I need to now go into the next operating room with another life-threatening surgery and I need to be clear headed. That physician, that surgeon, without agitation, having killed someone or the typical example of you're protecting your family, protecting someone around you and you have a justified reason to protect them and the person you're protecting them against, loses their life and you don't feel any agitation from it.

That is not a sin. And if you can find one person that in cold blood could murder another person and feel no agitation, then I would tell you yes, that is not a sin. But that's one as one hell of an if. It's hard for me, even an imagination to create something, someone like that, much less.

Try to find that person in real life. But yes, that is what the philosophy says. Take it or leave it. It might make sense to you.

It might not make sense to you. The philosophy is like a buffet. You can leave things on the shelf. But that actually makes far more sense to me than a cosmic judge.

That's watching every move and keeping a tally and then it's going to rack up the scores at the end and give you a punishment. That sounds far more far-fetched than anything articulated at the top of this episode. And what's really interesting here is that the philosophy is saying that you're not punished for the sin, you're punished by the sin. Sit lazily while those around you are cleaning up the house and you know you could help and you choose not to.

That's going to be agitation that you've signed up for. Why cheat or steal? That's agitation that we sign up for. You can feel it.

Feel it in your gut anytime that you partake in. What you know you shouldn't do and it agitates. That agitation is interrupted desire. So how does this philosophy define sin?

It is that which agitates. And furthermore, what do we incur when we incur sin? We are not punished for the sin. We're punished by the sin.

The agitation itself is the price we pay. What hangs on the other side of doing what we ought to do. Contextually what we know we ought to do. Not some list of 10 commandments but knowing that okay when I do what I ought to do.

In any and every aspect of life through reflection, through contemplation, through study, through awareness, start listening, become more and more aware of what you ought to do in each scenario in life. And what happens when we do what we ought to do? As is said often within this philosophy, nothing feels as good as doing what we ought to do. So I'm going to say this in lectures and it's just such a beautiful articulation.

I'm mentioning our house in front of our little kids, six-year-old, three-year-old, one-year-old, all the time. Nothing feels as good as doing what we ought to do. Because that's what hangs in the balance. That's the upside.

Not just no agitation but that inner bliss of knowing, Ah, today I did what I ought to do. That gym workout, that hard conversation at work, that five-hour task you've been putting off for two weeks, nothing feels as good as doing what we ought to do. That's an alignment with, the universe with, our community with our families with, our coworkers and with ourselves that cannot be touched by the indulgence of any sin. On a whole, another, it's a difference in kind, not a difference in degree from some sensual enjoyment.

Nothing feels as good as doing what we ought to do. That is a daily reflection. And we could all think about over and over again. I said nothing feels as good as doing what we ought to do.

It's not just the absence of agitation. It is the beauty, the beauty of being in alignment with ourselves and those around us. And that's today's reflection on the daily jontic. We'll see you next time.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of The Daily Vedantic?

This episode is 10 minutes long.

When was this The Daily Vedantic episode published?

This episode was published on May 10, 2024.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this The Daily Vedantic episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.