EPISODE · Jun 7, 2026 · 9 MIN
The Bobby Dunbar Case
from Quiet Files · host Meschelle
On the twenty-third of August, 1912, a four-year-old boy vanished during a family fishing trip at a remote cypress lake in southern Louisiana. His name was Bobby Dunbar. After eight months of searching, a boy matching his description was found in Mississippi with a traveling handyman. The Dunbar family identified him as their son.A poor young mother from North Carolina arrived and insisted the boy was hers — that her name was Julia Anderson, that the boy's real name was Charles Bruce, and that the handyman had been a family friend in temporary custody.A Louisiana court awarded the boy to the Dunbars. Julia Anderson went home empty-handed. The boy lived as Bobby Dunbar for fifty-four years.In 2004, his granddaughter — a journalist named Margaret Dunbar Cutright — asked her family to take a DNA test.The boy raised as Bobby Dunbar was not biologically related to the Dunbars. He was almost certainly Charles Bruce Anderson. Julia Anderson had been telling the truth for nine decades.This is the story of two boys — the one who came home, and the one who never did. The real Bobby Dunbar is presumed to have drowned in Swayze Lake on the day he disappeared. His body has never been found.Episode Eleven of The Quiet Files.Sources: State of Louisiana v. William C. Walters, trial transcript, 1913; A Case for Solomon: Bobby Dunbar and the Kidnapping That Haunted a Nation (Tal McThenia and Margaret Dunbar Cutright, 2012); 2004 paternity DNA analysis (commissioned by Margaret Dunbar Cutright).
What this episode covers
On the twenty-third of August, 1912, a four-year-old boy vanished during a family fishing trip at a remote cypress lake in southern Louisiana. His name was Bobby Dunbar. After eight months of searching, a boy matching his description was found in Mississippi with a traveling handyman. The Dunbar family identified him as their son.A poor young mother from North Carolina arrived and insisted the boy was hers — that her name was Julia Anderson, that the boy's real name was Charles Bruce, and that the handyman had been a family friend in temporary custody.A Louisiana court awarded the boy to the Dunbars. Julia Anderson went home empty-handed. The boy lived as Bobby Dunbar for fifty-four years.In 2004, his granddaughter — a journalist named Margaret Dunbar Cutright — asked her family to take a DNA test.The boy raised as Bobby Dunbar was not biologically related to the Dunbars. He was almost certainly Charles Bruce Anderson. Julia Anderson had been telling the truth for nine decades.This is the story of two boys — the one who came home, and the one who never did. The real Bobby Dunbar is presumed to have drowned in Swayze Lake on the day he disappeared. His body has never been found.Episode Eleven of The Quiet Files.Sources: State of Louisiana v. William C. Walters, trial transcript, 1913; A Case for Solomon: Bobby Dunbar and the Kidnapping That Haunted a Nation (Tal McThenia and Margaret Dunbar Cutright, 2012); 2004 paternity DNA analysis (commissioned by Margaret Dunbar Cutright).
NOW PLAYING
The Bobby Dunbar Case
No transcript for this episode yet
Similar Episodes
Oct 19, 2023 ·12m
Oct 19, 2023 ·12m
Oct 19, 2023 ·13m
Oct 19, 2023 ·13m
Oct 19, 2023 ·13m
Oct 19, 2023 ·13m