Skip to content
The Boredom Index: Pricing Your Downtime episode artwork

Mar 2, 2021 28 min

The Boredom Index: Pricing Your Downtime

from MSP [] MATTSPLAINED [] MSPx Hosted by KULTURPOP

What price boredom? A new economic indicator, the Boredom Index, could quantify and commoditise our downtime. And decide that we’re more valuable the less engaged we are. Hosts: Matt Armitage & Richard Bradbury Produced: Richard Bradbury for BFM89.9 Episode Sources: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/02/20/business/gamestop-investing-economy.html Follow us: www.kulturpop.com https://www.instagram.com/kulturpop/ https://twitter.com/kulturmatt

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

The Boredom Index: Pricing Your Downtime

0:00 28:08
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Right and heart of K-LIser Hidden Gem, a sanctuary according to affordable luxury and incomparable conveniences. Chambers, Quality, and Pore, Freehold, service apartments with an option for leasing service. From studios to two bedroom options, all units are semi-finished, with fully fitted kitchens, watching machines and more. Best of all, it's just a short walk to the LRT, Sunway, Putramoor and PwTC.

Visit ChambersResidence.com.my. Chambers, Quality and Pore by Matrix Concepts, nudging environments in reaching lives. This is a download from the FM 89.9, the Business Station. The FM 89.9, the Business Station.

My name is Rich Bradbury and welcome to Matt Sling. What's your boredom worth? It's a question that retailers and marketers have become increasingly interested in during the pandemic as they jockey for access to captive audiences. One person who has never had a thought he didn't think was valuable is Mr Matt Sling, Matt Armitage.

Another boring episode of Head Matt? The most boring I hope and you're very, very on point with that, I've never had a thought that wasn't valuable. If you've got one of my thoughts in a Christmas cracker, that would be the best gift of your life. But we are all bored.

I had a lot of trouble writing and researching the notes for this episode, largely because I was bored. I spent a lot of the time that I should have been researching, talking about music streaming quality with my friend Yi before we started concocting conspiracy theories about Facebook, which of course we did on Facebook because we're self-aware souls, we understand the irony. Sometimes it's the only thing that we have because 12 months into the pandemic, we're fresh out of inspiration, we're fresh out of energy, we resent the platforms and the companies that we rely on to entertain us. Some people have disappeared down those holes marked queue and descended into other conspiracies.

I'm lucky, I'm obsessed with trashy reality TV, so YouTube still has about three lifetimes worth of content to serve me before I have to go down those rabbit holes to stay watching. You might still be pushing it though with a show about boredom to an audience that's bored. I don't want to get all meta about it. Back in 2015, before this show was Matt's Blain, but when I was very much still Matt's Blain, we did a series of shows about the benefits of boredom.

We talked about some of the ways that a digital detox and regaining the ability to do nothing can actually be beneficial to us both physically and mentally. So things like taking a walk without your phone, simple things, sitting, staring at a lake or the sea or as nice of you as you have access to, because it allows us to switch off and reduce that mental load to turn away from that tide of digital information. And you didn't expect it to turn into a lifestyle? Although some experts predicted that there would be a pandemic or pandemics on this kind of scale during our lifetimes.

I think very few of us could have imagined how much of our life would be curtailed and in the ways that it would be curtailed for a lot of us rather than detox. We've gone the other way. We invented doom scrolling, hence the spread of these awful conspiracies. But going back to your comment about boredom, yes, we're bored.

We're tired. And sometimes these are separate things. Sometimes they're related. Sometimes we're tired because we're bored.

And the other times we're bored because we're tired. See, isn't that nice? We're finishing each other's sentences like a proper couple. Where we have this convergence of the two, we have this potential for what some health experts are turning pandemic burnout.

So more of that later. But first, we have this slightly bizarre idea. And this is the idea that we can commodify and quantify boredom. And it's the notion that companies have started to measure and put financial values on that boredom.

And eventually, we may see a tracker and actual boredom index emerge as an economic indicator and tool. Would that be a distinct phenomenon? Isn't it just another form of instant gratification? Well, it is to an extent.

But it's an extension and a refinement of the model. In the old pre pandemic days, there may have been a few touch points during the day when we were more susceptible to that hovering one click to buy finger where we just needed that little bit of a push. The pandemic has introduced a lot more potential touch points into our days. For example, the kind of enforced downtime that many of us traditionally had, like that time we spent commuting, look at the ways that advertising developed to target us during those journeys.

It was spot ads on ways, geo targeting for online ads, so that if you were on the train, you'd get specific ads in specific parts of town, as well as the more traditional out of home digital and print billboards that you see along the sides of the roads. And of course, things like radio ads. So even the signage and products marketed by stores in high traffic locations on the way to and from those public transport hubs would geared around the commuting. So it was a real mixture of marketing wisdom, a mixture of the old and the very new.

And those have disappeared? Well, to an extent, commuting was great for marketers because it was predictable. It happened within certain time periods that related to the working week. Now we're at home a lot more.

Our movements are less predictable. But that doesn't mean that we're less predictable. Our actions are still predictable because of the nature and purpose of boredom itself. As a distraction?

Well, yes, as we said, being bored has benefits. It can help to boost productivity, for example, taking a break, distracting yourself can help to clear your head, clear your mind. It allows you to come back to that challenging or mind-numbing task with a clear ahead and perhaps a touch less pessimism. The kind of boredom we're experiencing now, though, is very different.

If you think back to the old days and the things you used to do when you were bored, as I said on our movie themed episode, for me, cinema was my escape. I'm lucky. I live very close to a number of movie theaters. But those activities are mostly closed off to us at the moment, you know, the same with visiting museums and galleries, gathering restaurants and other public places.

A lot of these things are restricted or outright banned. So we're going back to the same sources of entertainment and information all the time, the streaming services, the news feeds, and we're endlessly scrolling for something new and something to divert us. And this is where brands are jumping in? Yeah, because often those feeds aren't giving us anything new.

I mean, I don't know how often you've clicked refresh on the front page of your YouTube, just in the hope that it'll give you something interesting to do for the next five minutes. But brands can at least activate those reward receptors. So it might be a fun product video. It could even just be an engaging slogan online.

Where we are now is very much in the realm of personalized ads. You know, we're talking about services that learn on digital habits. I'm old school, these shopping apps know to target me with notifications at bedtime. Because that's when my defenses tend to be lowest and my susceptibility is highest.

So that's the highest conversion time or conversion rate period for me. I probably shouldn't be telling back to an audience of marketers on radio, but I guess it doesn't matter because I'm already broken. So how does that gel with the kind of experience that many retailers and service providers have had over the last 12 months? Well, obviously, this is not an even playing field.

It's not a global success story. You know, we all know that the last 12 months have been financially devastating for hundreds of millions of people for millions of businesses. But it has been very good for others. We've talked about some of those growth sectors here on the show, the booming delivery based on logistics companies, distraction apps like Clubhouse, Cloud computing services, meat substitute products, furniture and interiors, streaming services and of course games.

A New York Times article that put me onto some parts of this subject called the Boredom Economy by Sydney Ember also lists some other maybe less expected boom sectors, certainly in the US at least. There were shortages of yeast due to a sudden spike in home breadmaking. And the gardening industry has seen such an explosion in demand that Scott's miracle grow ran its first ever Super Bowl commercial this year. So a few companies, often very large ones, have had a very good 12 months indeed.

For those organizations, Boredom is great for business. Is there an argument that Boredom is a pandemic luxury? Well, that's part of the discussion that we'll get to after the break in relation to that idea of pandemic burnout. But yes, to be bored, you have to have time to be bored in.

So yes, you can be bored at work. But by and large, the people who still have to go to physical workplaces, retail assistants, factory workers, warehouse workers, F&B staff, all kinds of frontline workers. If you're lucky, you get to be bored standing around in a store that doesn't have very many customers when you're not trying to sanitize everything that the last customer just touched. But most likely, you're rushing every working out to make ends meet, to care for those in need, or worse, to meet the demands of implacable bosses and ceaseless consumer demand.

Watch the meatpacking episode of John Oliver's last week tonight, if you want to get a taste of what that might feel like. So yes, in some senses, you might be lucky if you get to be bored. So in other words, boredom comes in many flavours. Yeah, if you've got the kind of boredom that can be cured by playing monopoly with a housemate, partner or family member, then that's one thing.

But there's also the boredom that comes from isolation, especially for people locked up in tiny rooms or apartments, you know, there's that social isolation aspect. So we're also seeing this boredom manifest and fuel self-destructive behaviour, which of course also has economic impacts and consequences. It might be something as simple as ordering in Thai cakes where once you ordered a slice and of course eating them in the same amount or in yeah, exactly, or impulse buying, touch gears to make yourself feel better, even if it's just for that instant. Certainly there's been an effort by many online retailers to speed up their delivery services, because the shorter the time between checkout and receiving the goods in your hand, the more likely you are to play by.

If it says it's going to deliver today or next day, you're going to play by. If it says you're not going to get it for four weeks, then maybe you'll think twice, especially when it's an impulse buy rather than a considered purchase or something you actually need. All right, when we come back, when boredom distorts markets, you're tuning to Matt's flame tier on BFM 89.9, the business station. Brave finance managers, BFM 89.9.

Welcome back, ladies and gentlemen. This is BFM 89.9. Of course, it's Matt's flame and I'm Richard Brembree. And before the break, we were talking about the boredom index and looking at the way our inactivity is shaping consumer behaviour, Matt.

Well, boredom doesn't have to be all about inactivity. You know, things like bike sales have sought. One of the accusations that has been levelled at a lot with COVID related SOPs around the world is that they inadvertently benefit big super stores and disproportionately way against specialist chains and independence. For example, bike shops and closed stores are closed in many countries, yet big box supermarkets allowed to open because they retail fresh food often sell everything from electrical goods to sports wearing bikes to fashion and heartbreak.

So there's been an argument that some countries are effectively creating new monopolies for the retail of a lot of consumer goods. And where there are gaps, we've seen all sorts of ingenious gray markets spring up. I think I mentioned last year that I ended up buying hair clippers from a locally based company that somehow imports them from Canada. Yes, you did.

And they all seem to be Amazon or other e-commerce site returns or repacks for the most part, because it was impossible to buy hair clippers at local retailers through most of last year. It might still be, I don't know, I haven't checked for them recently, but yes, to your point, boredom is reshaping a lot of our behaviour. And as I mentioned before, the break, that self-destructive element and that appetite for risk is also becoming a lot more evident. Hang on a minute.

Are you going to tie the GameStop and the whole Wall Street Best thing to the boredom index? I'm going to give it my best shot. I wasn't invested. So this is something again I picked up on in the New York Times piece that I mentioned before the break.

So the piece argues that in some ways, the boredom index would be an adjunct to an already established and well used gauge, which is the consumer confidence index, which is a bell weather that helps the gauge optimism about the future. The boredom index would give a more nuanced or maybe even warped vision of current consumer sentiment. I imagine they include you as a negative variable, right? I've always seen myself more as an error term.

At least that's what my family always told me growing up. But certainly there seems to be an element of boredom of piling on for the fun of it, with some of the Wall Street Bets posts and predictions. And again, that's come about as a result of this unique confluence of conditions. A sizeable number of people who lost their jobs have turned to the risk-filled world of day trading to make money to make a living, which itself has been made possible or made easier by a new generation of trading apps that offer transactions with low or no fees like Robinhood.

So you have this brand new consumer class of investor and they're not following investing norms. They're picking up tips on what stocks to trade well away from those established and mainstream sources of financial information. You might even argue that they're conspiring to distort markets. Well, choosing my words carefully here, the big trading houses have always used their size and a market share to gain every advantage they can.

That could be something as straightforward as locating their own servers as close as possible to the exchange's servers in order to gain advantages of microseconds in making trades. Now, obviously, that's not something a small investor with a few hundred or thousand dollars to invest can independently benefit from. So there's this fine line between what constitutes a conspiracy and a bunch of people on a publicly visible sub forum deciding they're all going to jump on a stock and drive its price up. So GameStop was the most evident that we've seen so far.

But there have been other stocks that have seen less meteoric rises as a result of these similar herd activities. And we've seen similar fluctuations in the demand for crypto assets, although we won't mention a certain tech billionaire who has also been lending his name to some of those activities. Now, I'm not a market expert. I'm not a lawyer.

To me, it looks like the little guy's behaving like the big guys and the big guys really hating it. But I'll have to let somebody else decide which group is acting more ethically or legally. Right. So how does this link to the boredom and the self-destructive behavior?

Well, partially because of the motivations that you see on these forums. So taking the GameStop example, some of the investors from their posts at least seem to enjoy the fact they were upsetting the short sellers as much as they enjoyed their own financial gains. But other people are literally betting their shirts. There was an episode of Planet Money on GameStop a few weeks ago that interviewed a guy who had poured everything he had into buying shares, his house deposit, some of his pension fund, everything went into GameStop shares.

Now, he put I think over two hundred thousand dollars in and of course, he won big. So your concern that boredom is pushing people to take risks that they don't really understand? Well, yeah, that guy I mentioned, he works within the financial industry. So he has a lot more knowledge.

But those new small traders, they're more likely to come in at the wrong end of the curve because they're just following the herd. They'll be buying near the peak and they can potentially lose everything they put into it. And as I said before, there's a growing number of people who lost their jobs and are trying to use day trading to feed their families. So they're not risking money they can afford to lose.

So certainly, I'm not criticizing these new apps. They're doing a fantastic thing in principle because they're making it easier to invest and they're making it easier to invest at lower cost. But making trading as easy as impulse buying on Amazon does come with consequences. And one of those consequences is the suicide last year of a 20-year-old investor and student Alex Kurtz, who mistakenly believed he'd incurred hundreds of thousands of losses on one of these apps.

He hadn't, but that comes down to not understanding the complexities and implications of the trades that he was making. And I imagine a lot of other people are in a similar situation. Okay, so far we've mostly looked at the negative effects of boredom. But you started the episode saying that boredom is a useful and necessary to all that.

Well, yes. So the point I hope that we've made is that our current situation, the confinement has created this different kind of boredom. And I think towards the end of last year, we did a show on work from home and productivity. And the crux of that show was that some people have found that in lockdown, they can actually get their jobs done faster.

So some employers are progressive and they're taking the attitude that it doesn't really matter how long the work takes as long as you get it done and you do it well. Which reminds me actually that we still haven't done the episode on the four day working week. So I have to come back to that. But other employers, if they know you're done for the day, they're just going to give you more work.

So can your employees haven't been letting on that they can get their work done with an hour or two to spare every day? And then when you add to that the saving, that couple of hours that you save that you would have spent getting out of bed showering, finding clean clothes and commuting to work, suddenly you have an extra half day available? Well, in some cases, the extra time will help to feed the boredom index. But for others, it's been an opportunity to revive other projects that have been on the back burner, whether it's a side hustle, developing a startup or simply a hobby or other activity you haven't had time for.

Last night, this is going back to refreshing that YouTube. Last night, I watched a disturbing video about people who make super realistic dolls that look like newborn babies. So that's a combination of side hustle and creative art project. It's also truly awful.

But they even paint the veins onto the baby skin and white really freaky. But you can see this new entrepreneurial creator class all over apps like Clip House. And as I said on the work from home show last year, we should start to see whether those ideas become anything sometime around the middle of the year as those ideas start to emerge into the summer sunshine. All right, great.

But I've got to bring you back to the topic, the pandemic burner, because we're running a little bit short of time. Well, in a way, the burnout is a bit like the flip side of this creative first. You know, those are the lucky people, they can get their work done, and they get to have some free time. Not everyone is so lucky.

They're juggling a lot more. They're homeschooling their kids while they're working. They're trying to keep a measure of domestic order in homes that they're spending pretty much 24 hours a day in. They may have bosses who think work from home means work all the time and make demands of them at all times of the day and night, expecting instant responses, whether you're queuing at the supermarket, cooking alphabets, spaghetti, or trying to remember what quadratic equations are useful for, and why your kids have to be able to use something that you never understood, because that's what calculators and computers are for.

So a new scientist piece on pandemic burnout quoted Mark Omerod, a former royal marine who lost both legs and an arm in an explosion while he was serving in Afghanistan. Now, Omerod told the BBC that homeschooling his two children while also juggling his day job ranked amongst his most dramatic memories. I mean, can you imagine that? I think we sometimes underestimate the pressures that the last year has subjected many people to.

Wow. Okay. So what are the signs of pandemic burnout? What should people be looking out for?

Well, the new scientist quotes Christina Maslak. She's a psychologist at the University of California, Barclay. She's the co-developer of a widely accepted burnout tool that's been in use for the past few decades. Now, burnout occurs when three factors coincide.

You get this overwhelming feeling of emotional exhaustion, feelings of cynicism and detachment, and a feeling of a lack of accomplishment a bit like listening to this show. You might feel exhausted even after plenty of sleep. You might find yourself emotionally distant from loved ones or no longer caring about jobs that need doing. And we don't know the scale of the problem yet because we don't have comparative studies because this is the first time we've gone through it in 100 years.

And of course, because we're still in the middle of it, we're still experiencing it with no clear exit inside. And is there a suggestion that burnout is increasing? Certainly in the new scientists, they suggest that we are trending in that direction. So while populations overall have whether the pandemic quite well, that data does hide subgroups that aren't coping as well.

Many women, for example, still experience the additional and imbalanced burden of family and domestic duties, probably while their partners are chatting on clubhouse about their new suboutio themed startup. We're not even close to understanding the long term impacts that the pandemic has and will continue to have on kids. And worryingly, there's also been an uptick in youth homelessness in some US cities with kids running away to escape being locked down in abusive and these situations. And at the same time, they've been removed from the infrastructural assistance that they might have received from their peers or from oversight by teachers or social services staff.

All right, I'm going to ask you, without letting you get too dark, how can we spot and potentially reverse some of these burnout indicators? Just join my online seminar for only $999. Now, I'm just kidding. This week, it's actually half priced if you use the promo code, Bradbury.

This is why a burnout in the bottom index intersect so closely, especially that self destructive side. If you are locked down on your own or with very little contact outside of that significant other, you know, you should be using those digital connection tools to stay in touch with people and do what you can to safely meet other people, socially distance walks or cycles are a great start. You know, any little thing that can help to take the lid off that pressure cooker. And do what you can to manage other people's expectations?

Yeah, I think that's key. You know, let bosses and colleagues know that your work messages are not going to be checked after a certain cut off time. Let family members know that you're going to carve out some time for yourself, even if it's only to watch Taskmaster, like I do. But also don't put enormous expectations on yourself.

You know, be reasonable about what you can achieve. If you can manage to be a mediocre member of staff and adequate parent and a lackluster gardener all at the same time, you're probably well ahead of the game. You know, we find ourselves in this weird situation where one group of people is so bored that they feel isolated and desperate. And another group is so busy that they feel isolated and desperate.

And yet they're both flip sides of the same conditions of boredom and burnout. So, you know, be kind to yourself. And it's not often you'll hear someone as disagreeable as me saying that. Who are you?

What have you done with Matt Armitage? Don't worry, the evil one will be back next week. Great. You've been truly into Matt's playing here on BFM 89.9.

Of course, you can find Matt on Instagram and Twitter at culture. Matt, you can also head over to culturebot.com the transcripts of these shows and information about Culturebot and its consulting services. If you did miss any part of the show, remember you can have a listen back on the BFM app to the podcast or head over to bfm.my or even on Spotify. You've been listening to Matt's Explained here on BFM 89.9, the Business Station.

Thank you for listening to this podcast. To find more great interviews go to bfm.my or find us on iTunes, bfm 89.9, the Business Station.

The MSP Show The Digital Nomad Podcast Where can you turn to speak with the movers and shakers in the IT industry? The MSP Marketing Show is your source for up-to-date business info. MSP Unplugged Paco Lebron MSP Unplugged is the weekly podcast for growing MSP owners running shops under $1M with 10 or fewer techs. Each week, our hosts sit down with MSP owners, operators, and the vendors who serve them for real, unfiltered conversations about what's actually working: growing revenue and landing better clients, cybersecurity, AI and automation, sales and marketing, and leading a team without burning out. Watch on YouTube or listen wherever you get podcasts. Business of Tech: Daily MSP News & IT Services Analysis MSP Radio, Dave Sobel, Managed Service Provider (MSP) Industry Analyst Vendors are rewriting the rules on MSPs faster than anyone can track — pricing, partner programs, liability, and now AI. Business of Tech is the daily MSP news briefing that tells you what changed and what it means for your business.Every weekday, channel veteran Dave Sobel picks the MSP and IT services news that actually moves your margins, contracts, and risk, and answers the one question that matters: Why do we care? No vendor cheerleading and no press-release rewrites — independent analysis for managed service providers, IT services leaders, and the vendors who sell to them.Short daily episodes keep you current in about 15 minutes. Longer interviews go deep with MSP owners, investors, analysts, and channel executives on where the managed services market is heading.What this MSP podcast covers:• AI for MSPs — AI pricing and consumption billing, AI liability and governance, and AI agents in the service desk• MSP pricing and profitability — per-user vs. usage-based pricing, margi SMB Community Podcast: Business Advice for Small MSP Owners Dave Sobel, Amy Babinchak, Small Biz Thoughts, James Kernan Running a small MSP means being the CEO, the sales team, the HR department, and the escalation tech — usually in the same afternoon. The SMB Community Podcast is where MSP owners get straight answers on the business side of running an MSP.Every week, Amy Babinchak, and James Kernan — MSP owners and advisors from the Small Biz Thoughts community — take on the questions small MSP owners actually ask: How should I price? When do I hire? Should I give a proposal at the first meeting? What is my MSP worth? No vendor pitches and no theory — practical advice from people who have run, grown, and sold IT businesses.What this MSP podcast covers:• MSP sales and client growth — the MSP sales process, proposals, price objections, referrals, local marketing, and choosing a CRM• MSP pricing and agreements — MSP pricing models, single plan vs. tiers, price increases, managed service contracts, margins, and cash flow• Leading an MSP team — MSP hiring, tech compensation and commissions, accountabil

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of MSP [] MATTSPLAINED [] MSPx?

This episode is 28 minutes long.

When was this MSP [] MATTSPLAINED [] MSPx episode published?

This episode was published on March 2, 2021.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this MSP [] MATTSPLAINED [] MSPx episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.